Skip to content

Acid–Base Concepts: Arrhenius to Usanovich

CSIR NET chemistry: Arrhenius, Brønsted–Lowry, Lewis, Lux–Flood, solvent-system and Usanovich definitions, conjugate pairs, K from pKa and levelling.

  • 16 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 17 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: One Reaction, Four Labels
  3. The Big Picture
  4. Arrhenius Definition
  5. Brønsted–Lowry Definition
  6. Lewis Definition
  7. Lux–Flood Definition
  8. Solvent-System Definition
  9. Usanovich Definition
  10. Choosing the Right Definition
  11. Memory Tricks
  12. Don’t Confuse
  13. Common Mistakes
  14. Practice
  15. Quick Revision Table
  16. Key Takeaways
  17. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: One Reaction, Four Labels

The Big Picture

Each definition is a generalisation of the one before it. The diagram shows what each one counts as the “acid particle”.

graph LR
    A[Arrhenius: H+ in water] --> B[Brønsted–Lowry: proton donor, any solvent]
    B --> C[Solvent system: raises solvent cation]
    B --> D[Lewis: electron-pair acceptor]
    D --> E[Usanovich: gives cations, accepts anions or electrons]
    F[Lux–Flood: oxide-ion acceptor] --> E
DefinitionAcidBaseWhere it is useful
Arrheniusgives H⁺ (as H₃O⁺) in watergives OH⁻ in wateraqueous chemistry only
Brønsted–Lowryproton donorproton acceptorany protic system, including gas phase
Solvent systemraises the concentration of the solvent’s characteristic cationraises the characteristic anionself-ionising non-aqueous solvents
Lewiselectron-pair acceptorelectron-pair donorcoordination chemistry, catalysis, adducts
Lux–Floodoxide-ion (O²⁻) acceptoroxide-ion donoroxide melts, slags, glass, ceramics
Usanovichgives cations, or accepts anions or electronsthe reversebroadest; includes redox

Arrhenius Definition

An Arrhenius acid produces hydrogen ions in water and an Arrhenius base produces hydroxide ions; neutralisation is

$$\text{H}^+(aq) + \text{OH}^-(aq) \rightarrow \text{H}_2\text{O}(l)$$

The bare proton does not exist free in water: it is hydrated, written H₃O⁺ (and in reality larger clusters such as H₉O₄⁺). Keep this definition only for what it does well, aqueous solutions. Its three limitations are the reasons the later definitions exist:

  1. It is tied to water; it says nothing about HCl reacting with NH₃ in the gas phase or in benzene.
  2. It cannot call NH₃ or Na₂CO₃ a base by mechanism, because neither contains OH⁻ (they make OH⁻ only by reacting with water).
  3. It has no place for BF₃, AlCl₃, SO₃ or metal ions acting as acids.

Brønsted–Lowry Definition

Brønsted and Lowry (independently, in 1923) defined an acid as a proton donor and a base as a proton acceptor. An acid–base reaction is a proton transfer between two conjugate pairs:

$$\underset{\text{acid}_1}{\text{HA}} + \underset{\text{base}_2}{\text{B}} \rightleftharpoons \underset{\text{base}_1}{\text{A}^-} + \underset{\text{acid}_2}{\text{HB}^+}$$

HA and A⁻ differ by one proton and form a conjugate pair; so do HB⁺ and B.

Conjugate pairs

AcidConjugate baseComment
H₃O⁺H₂Ostrongest acid that can exist in water
H₂OOH⁻water acts as an acid towards NH₃
HSO₄⁻SO₄²⁻HSO₄⁻ is itself the conjugate base of H₂SO₄
NH₄⁺NH₃
NH₃NH₂⁻NH₃ acts as an acid only towards very strong bases
[Al(H₂O)₆]³⁺[Al(H₂O)₅(OH)]²⁺a hydrated metal ion is a Brønsted acid

Species that can both donate and accept a proton (H₂O, HSO₄⁻, HCO₃⁻, H₂PO₄⁻, NH₃) are amphiprotic.

Strength and the conjugate relation

In water the strength of an acid is measured by its acidity constant

$$K_a = \frac{[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]}, \qquad \text{p}K_a = -\log K_a$$

For a conjugate pair in water, \( K_a(\text{HA}) \times K_b(\text{A}^-) = K_w = 1.0 \times 10^{-14} \) at 25 °C, so \( \text{p}K_a + \text{p}K_b = 14.00 \). The stronger the acid, the weaker its conjugate base. Basicity is usually quoted as the pKa of the conjugate acid (often written pKaH): a larger pKaH means a stronger base.

Which way does a proton transfer go?

A proton transfer favours the side with the weaker acid and weaker base. Quantitatively, for

$$\text{HA} + \text{B}^- \rightleftharpoons \text{A}^- + \text{HB}$$$$\boxed{K = \frac{K_a(\text{HA})}{K_a(\text{HB})} = 10^{\,\text{p}K_a(\text{HB}) - \text{p}K_a(\text{HA})}}$$

The levelling effect in one paragraph

In water, HCl, HBr, HI, HNO₃, H₂SO₄ (first proton) and HClO₄ all react completely to give H₃O⁺. Their solutions behave identically: water has levelled them to the strength of H₃O⁺. Likewise, NH₂⁻, H⁻ and O²⁻ are levelled to OH⁻. To tell strong acids apart you need a less basic solvent (glacial acetic acid is the standard choice); this is developed fully in Non-aqueous Solvents.

Limitations of the Brønsted view

It still needs a proton. BF₃, SO₃, Ag⁺ and CO₂ react with bases without donating any proton, and the theory cannot rank their acidity.

Lewis Definition

G. N. Lewis (also 1923) defined an acid as an electron-pair acceptor and a base as an electron-pair donor. Neutralisation is the formation of a coordinate (dative) bond, giving an adduct or complex:

$$\text{BF}_3 + :\!\text{NH}_3 \rightarrow \text{F}_3\text{B}\!\leftarrow\!\text{NH}_3$$

In orbital language the base supplies an occupied orbital (usually its HOMO), and the acid supplies a vacant one (usually its LUMO). Every Brønsted base is a Lewis base, because accepting a proton means donating a pair to it. The proton itself is a Lewis acid, so every Brønsted acid–base reaction is a special case of Lewis neutralisation (one Lewis acid, H⁺, transferred from one base to another).

Types of Lewis acid

TypeExamplesWhere the vacant orbital is
Incomplete octetBF₃, BCl₃, AlCl₃, BH₃ (as B₂H₆), GaCl₃empty p orbital on the central atom
CationsH⁺, Ag⁺, Cu²⁺, Fe³⁺, Al³⁺, all metal ionsempty s, p or d orbitals
Expandable valence (period 3 and below)SiF₄, SnCl₄, PF₅, SbF₅σ* orbitals of the M–X bonds (often described as “vacant d”, see the note below)
π-acceptors (multiple bonds)CO₂, SO₂, SO₃π* orbital: CO₂ + OH⁻ → HCO₃⁻
Molecules with a low-lying σ*I₂, Br₂σ* of X–X: I₂ + I⁻ → I₃⁻

Types of Lewis base

TypeExamples
Lone pair on N, O, P, S, halogenNH₃, amines, H₂O, ethers, R₃P, R₂S, F⁻, Cl⁻
Anions in generalOH⁻, CN⁻, SCN⁻, H⁻
σ-donor with π-acceptor abilityCO, PF₃, phosphites
π-electron donorsalkenes, arenes (to Ag⁺, Pt(II))

Lewis acid–base reaction types

  1. Adduct formation: BF₃ + OEt₂ → F₃B–OEt₂; Ag⁺ + 2NH₃ → [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺.
  2. Displacement of a base: F₃B–OEt₂ + NH₃ → F₃B–NH₃ + OEt₂. Ligand substitution such as [Cu(H₂O)₄]²⁺ + 4NH₃ → [Cu(NH₃)₄]²⁺ + 4H₂O is the same type (NH₃ displaces H₂O from the acid Cu²⁺), and so is HCl + NH₃ → NH₄Cl (NH₃ displaces Cl⁻ from the acid H⁺).
  3. Displacement of an acid: a stronger acid takes the base away from a weaker one, for example [Cu(NH₃)₄]²⁺ + 4H⁺ → Cu²⁺(aq) + 4NH₄⁺ (H⁺ displaces Cu²⁺ from NH₃).
  4. Metathesis (double displacement): exchange of partners, as in many reactions in non-aqueous solvents.

Friedel–Crafts catalysis is a Lewis acid–base sequence: AlCl₃ takes Cl⁻ from RCOCl to form the acylium ion RCO⁺ and [AlCl₄]⁻.

Limitations of the Lewis view

It has no single strength scale. Order of acid strength depends on the reference base: BF₃ binds NH₃ more strongly than PH₃, while Ag⁺ prefers PH₃-type donors. That observation is what the HSAB concept organises. The Lewis definition also excludes electron-transfer (redox) reactions, which only the Usanovich definition counts as acid–base.

Lux–Flood Definition

For oxide systems at high temperature, where neither protons nor convenient lone pairs dominate:

  • Lux–Flood acid: oxide-ion acceptor.
  • Lux–Flood base: oxide-ion donor.
$$\underset{\text{base}}{\text{CaO}} + \underset{\text{acid}}{\text{SiO}_2} \rightarrow \text{CaSiO}_3 \qquad (\text{O}^{2-} \text{ moves from CaO to SiO}_2)$$$$\underset{\text{base}}{\text{Na}_2\text{O}} + \underset{\text{acid}}{\text{CO}_2} \rightarrow \text{Na}_2\text{CO}_3 \qquad \underset{\text{base}}{\text{PbO}} + \underset{\text{acid}}{\text{SO}_3} \rightarrow \text{PbSO}_4$$

So the anhydride of an oxoacid (SiO₂, CO₂, SO₃, P₄O₁₀) is a Lux–Flood acid, and basic metal oxides (Na₂O, CaO, MgO, BaO) are Lux–Flood bases. Metallurgical slag formation uses this: SiO₂ (acid flux) removes basic impurities like FeO and CaO; CaO or MgO (basic flux, from limestone or dolomite) removes acidic SiO₂ and P₄O₁₀.

The Lux–Flood picture agrees with ordinary acid–base behaviour: an oxide that accepts O²⁻ forms an oxoanion, which is the conjugate base of an oxoacid. An amphoteric oxide can act both ways, for example Al₂O₃ is an acid towards Na₂O (forming aluminate) and a base towards SO₃ or P₄O₁₀.

Acid–base character of oxides

TrendExample
Across a period, more acidicNa₂O, MgO basic; Al₂O₃ amphoteric; SiO₂, P₄O₁₀, SO₃, Cl₂O₇ acidic
Down a group, more basicB₂O₃ acidic, Al₂O₃ amphoteric, Tl₂O basic
Higher oxidation state, more acidicCrO basic, Cr₂O₃ amphoteric, CrO₃ acidic; MnO basic, Mn₂O₇ acidic
Typical amphoteric oxidesBeO, Al₂O₃, ZnO, Ga₂O₃, SnO, SnO₂, PbO

Solvent-System Definition

For a solvent that self-ionises (autoionises), the solvent-system definition (Cady and Elsey) says:

  • An acid is a solute that increases the concentration of the cation characteristic of the solvent.
  • A base is a solute that increases the concentration of the anion characteristic of the solvent.
  • Neutralisation produces the salt and the solvent.
SolventSelf-ionisationCharacteristic cation (acid)Characteristic anion (base)
H₂O2H₂O ⇌ H₃O⁺ + OH⁻H₃O⁺OH⁻
NH₃ (l)2NH₃ ⇌ NH₄⁺ + NH₂⁻NH₄⁺NH₂⁻
BrF₃2BrF₃ ⇌ BrF₂⁺ + BrF₄⁻BrF₂⁺BrF₄⁻
N₂O₄N₂O₄ ⇌ NO⁺ + NO₃⁻NO⁺NO₃⁻

So in liquid NH₃, NH₄Cl is an acid and KNH₂ a base; in BrF₃, SbF₅ is an acid (it gives BrF₂⁺) and KF is a base (it gives BrF₄⁻). The definition does not need protons at all, and that is its strength. Its weakness is that it is tied to a particular solvent and assumes self-ionisation that is sometimes only postulated (liquid SO₂ is the classic doubtful case). Details are in Non-aqueous Solvents.

Usanovich Definition

The broadest definition:

  • Acid: any species that reacts with a base, gives up cations, or accepts anions or electrons.
  • Base: any species that gives up anions or electrons, or combines with cations.

Because accepting electrons counts as acid behaviour, every redox reaction becomes an acid–base reaction: in 2Na + Cl₂ → 2NaCl, Cl₂ (electron acceptor) is the acid and Na the base. Usanovich also covers SO₃ + Na₂O → Na₂SO₄ (SO₃ accepts O²⁻) and Fe(CN)₂ + 4KCN → K₄[Fe(CN)₆] (Fe(CN)₂ accepts CN⁻).

The usual criticism is that a definition covering nearly every reaction stops being useful for classification. In the exam, use Usanovich when the question names it, or when a reaction is acid–base only under it (a redox reaction such as Na with Cl₂).

Choosing the Right Definition

graph TD
    Q[Reaction given] --> P{Proton transferred?}
    P -->|Yes| BL[Brønsted–Lowry, also Lewis]
    P -->|No| O{Oxide ion transferred?}
    O -->|Yes| LF[Lux–Flood, also Usanovich]
    O -->|No| L{Lone pair donated to a vacant orbital?}
    L -->|Yes| LW[Lewis]
    L -->|No| U{Electron transfer?}
    U -->|Yes| US[Usanovich only]

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Conjugate base of H₂SO₄: HSO₄⁻conjugate base of HSO₄⁻: SO₄²⁻
Amphiprotic (H₂O, HCO₃⁻): donates and accepts H⁺amphoteric (Al₂O₃, ZnO): reacts with both acids and bases, any mechanism
Lewis acid BF₃: accepts a pair, not a Brønsted acidBrønsted acid HCl: donates H⁺; the Lewis acid is H⁺ itself
Lux–Flood acid: O²⁻ acceptor (SiO₂)Lux–Flood base: O²⁻ donor (CaO)
Solvent-system acid in NH₃: NH₄ClArrhenius acid: only in water
Levelled (several acids all appear as H₃O⁺)differentiated (strengths distinguished in a less basic solvent)

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Give the conjugate base of HSO₄⁻ and the conjugate acid of NH₂⁻.
  2. In BF₃ + NH₃ → F₃B–NH₃, which species is the Lewis acid?
  3. In liquid NH₃, is NH₄Cl an acid or a base on the solvent-system definition?
Answers
  1. SO₄²⁻; NH₃.
  2. BF₃, the electron-pair acceptor (empty boron p orbital).
  3. Acid: it raises [NH₄⁺], the solvent’s characteristic cation.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. Which of the following is a Lewis acid but not a Brønsted acid?

(a) HCl (b) NH₄⁺ (c) AlCl₃ (d) H₂O

Answer: (c) AlCl₃

AlCl₃ has a vacant orbital on Al and accepts pairs (it forms [AlCl₄]⁻ and the Al₂Cl₆ dimer) but has no proton. HCl, NH₄⁺ and H₂O can all donate a proton.

Practice Q2. In the reaction Na₂O + SO₃ → Na₂SO₄, the Lux–Flood acid is:

(a) Na₂O (b) SO₃ (c) Na₂SO₄ (d) none, because no proton is transferred

Answer: (b) SO₃

SO₃ accepts O²⁻ from Na₂O to form SO₄²⁻. The oxide acceptor is the acid. Option (d) applies the Brønsted criterion to a Lux–Flood question.

Practice Q3. In the reaction HNO₃ + H₂SO₄ ⇌ H₂NO₃⁺ + HSO₄⁻, HNO₃ acts as:

(a) a Brønsted acid (b) a Brønsted base (c) a Lux–Flood acid (d) an oxidising agent only

Answer: (b) a Brønsted base

HNO₃ accepts a proton from the stronger acid H₂SO₄. The protonated nitric acid then loses water to form NO₂⁺, the nitrating agent.

Practice Q4. The reaction 2Na + Cl₂ → 2NaCl is an acid–base reaction under which definition?

(a) Brønsted–Lowry (b) Lewis (c) Lux–Flood (d) Usanovich

Answer: (d) Usanovich

No proton, no electron pair shared from a donor lone pair and no oxide transfer. Only Usanovich counts electron acceptance (Cl₂) as acid behaviour.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. Given pKa values in water at 25 °C: HF 3.2, CH₃COOH 4.76, NH₄⁺ 9.25. Consider the reactions:

  1. HF + CH₃COO⁻ ⇌ F⁻ + CH₃COOH
  2. NH₄⁺ + CH₃COO⁻ ⇌ NH₃ + CH₃COOH
  3. CH₃COOH + NH₃ ⇌ CH₃COO⁻ + NH₄⁺

Which have K > 1?

(a) 1 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3

Answer: (b) 1 and 3 only

Use \( K = 10^{\text{p}K_a(\text{product acid}) - \text{p}K_a(\text{reactant acid})} \).

  1. \( 10^{4.76 - 3.2} = 10^{1.56} \approx 36 \): K > 1.
  2. \( 10^{4.76 - 9.25} = 10^{-4.49} \approx 3.2 \times 10^{-5} \): K < 1.
  3. The reverse of 2: \( 10^{9.25 - 4.76} = 10^{4.49} \approx 3.1 \times 10^{4} \): K > 1.

Each time the favoured side holds the weaker acid.

Practice Q6. Consider the statements:

  1. Every Brønsted base is also a Lewis base.
  2. In liquid BrF₃, KF is a base on the solvent-system definition because it forms BrF₄⁻.
  3. The Lewis definition gives a single, solvent-independent order of acid strength.
  4. Al₂O₃ can act as a Lux–Flood acid towards Na₂O.

Which are correct?

(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
  1. Correct. To accept a proton the base must donate a pair to it.
  2. Correct. KF + BrF₃ → K⁺ + BrF₄⁻ raises the solvent’s anion.
  3. Wrong. Lewis acidity order depends on the reference base (BF₃ prefers N donors, Ag⁺ prefers P and S donors). This failure is what HSAB addresses.
  4. Correct. Al₂O₃ + Na₂O → 2NaAlO₂: Al₂O₃ accepts O²⁻.

Practice Q7. A student classifies each reaction under the narrowest definition that still makes it acid–base. Which classification is wrong?

(a) SiO₂ + CaO → CaSiO₃: Lux–Flood (b) Ag⁺ + 2NH₃ → [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺: Lewis (c) HCl(g) + NH₃(g) → NH₄Cl(s): Arrhenius (d) NOCl + AgNO₃ → AgCl + N₂O₄ (in liquid N₂O₄): solvent system

Answer: (c)

The gas-phase reaction of HCl with NH₃ involves no water, so it cannot be Arrhenius. The narrowest definition that covers it is Brønsted–Lowry (proton transfer). In (d), NOCl supplies NO⁺ (the solvent’s cation, an acid) and AgNO₃ supplies NO₃⁻ (a base); they neutralise to the salt AgCl and the solvent N₂O₄.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
ArrheniusH⁺ / OH⁻ in water only
Brønsted–Lowry (1923)proton donor / acceptor; conjugate pairs differ by one H⁺
Conjugate relationpKa + pKb = 14.00 at 25 °C (water)
Proton transfer K\( 10^{\text{p}K_a(\text{HB}) - \text{p}K_a(\text{HA})} \); weaker acid side favoured
Lewis (1923)pair acceptor / donor; adduct; HOMO → LUMO
Lewis acidsBF₃, AlCl₃, metal ions, SiF₄, SbF₅, CO₂, SO₃, I₂
Lux–FloodO²⁻ acceptor = acid (SiO₂, SO₃, CO₂); O²⁻ donor = base (CaO, Na₂O)
Solvent systemacid raises solvent cation; base raises solvent anion
Usanovichincludes redox: electron acceptor = acid
Oxide trendsacidic across period, with oxidation state; basic down group
Levellingin water every acid stronger than H₃O⁺ appears as H₃O⁺

Key Takeaways

What’s Next