Acid–Base Concepts: Arrhenius to Usanovich
CSIR NET chemistry: Arrhenius, Brønsted–Lowry, Lewis, Lux–Flood, solvent-system and Usanovich definitions, conjugate pairs, K from pKa and levelling.
- 16 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: One Reaction, Four Labels
- The Big Picture
- Arrhenius Definition
- Brønsted–Lowry Definition
- Lewis Definition
- Lux–Flood Definition
- Solvent-System Definition
- Usanovich Definition
- Choosing the Right Definition
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Electronegativity Scales and Periodic Anomalies: the electronegativity of the atom carrying the proton or the lone pair decides most strength trends.
- VSEPR Theory and the Shapes of Molecules: a Lewis acid–base adduct changes the shape at the acceptor (planar BF₃ becomes tetrahedral in F₃B–NH₃).
- Bonding in Heteronuclear Molecules: HOMO and LUMO language, used here to describe donors and acceptors.
The Hook: One Reaction, Four Labels
The Big Picture
Each definition is a generalisation of the one before it. The diagram shows what each one counts as the “acid particle”.
graph LR
A[Arrhenius: H+ in water] --> B[Brønsted–Lowry: proton donor, any solvent]
B --> C[Solvent system: raises solvent cation]
B --> D[Lewis: electron-pair acceptor]
D --> E[Usanovich: gives cations, accepts anions or electrons]
F[Lux–Flood: oxide-ion acceptor] --> E| Definition | Acid | Base | Where it is useful |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arrhenius | gives H⁺ (as H₃O⁺) in water | gives OH⁻ in water | aqueous chemistry only |
| Brønsted–Lowry | proton donor | proton acceptor | any protic system, including gas phase |
| Solvent system | raises the concentration of the solvent’s characteristic cation | raises the characteristic anion | self-ionising non-aqueous solvents |
| Lewis | electron-pair acceptor | electron-pair donor | coordination chemistry, catalysis, adducts |
| Lux–Flood | oxide-ion (O²⁻) acceptor | oxide-ion donor | oxide melts, slags, glass, ceramics |
| Usanovich | gives cations, or accepts anions or electrons | the reverse | broadest; includes redox |
Arrhenius Definition
An Arrhenius acid produces hydrogen ions in water and an Arrhenius base produces hydroxide ions; neutralisation is
$$\text{H}^+(aq) + \text{OH}^-(aq) \rightarrow \text{H}_2\text{O}(l)$$The bare proton does not exist free in water: it is hydrated, written H₃O⁺ (and in reality larger clusters such as H₉O₄⁺). Keep this definition only for what it does well, aqueous solutions. Its three limitations are the reasons the later definitions exist:
- It is tied to water; it says nothing about HCl reacting with NH₃ in the gas phase or in benzene.
- It cannot call NH₃ or Na₂CO₃ a base by mechanism, because neither contains OH⁻ (they make OH⁻ only by reacting with water).
- It has no place for BF₃, AlCl₃, SO₃ or metal ions acting as acids.
Brønsted–Lowry Definition
Brønsted and Lowry (independently, in 1923) defined an acid as a proton donor and a base as a proton acceptor. An acid–base reaction is a proton transfer between two conjugate pairs:
$$\underset{\text{acid}_1}{\text{HA}} + \underset{\text{base}_2}{\text{B}} \rightleftharpoons \underset{\text{base}_1}{\text{A}^-} + \underset{\text{acid}_2}{\text{HB}^+}$$HA and A⁻ differ by one proton and form a conjugate pair; so do HB⁺ and B.
Conjugate pairs
| Acid | Conjugate base | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| H₃O⁺ | H₂O | strongest acid that can exist in water |
| H₂O | OH⁻ | water acts as an acid towards NH₃ |
| HSO₄⁻ | SO₄²⁻ | HSO₄⁻ is itself the conjugate base of H₂SO₄ |
| NH₄⁺ | NH₃ | |
| NH₃ | NH₂⁻ | NH₃ acts as an acid only towards very strong bases |
| [Al(H₂O)₆]³⁺ | [Al(H₂O)₅(OH)]²⁺ | a hydrated metal ion is a Brønsted acid |
Species that can both donate and accept a proton (H₂O, HSO₄⁻, HCO₃⁻, H₂PO₄⁻, NH₃) are amphiprotic.
Strength and the conjugate relation
In water the strength of an acid is measured by its acidity constant
$$K_a = \frac{[\text{H}_3\text{O}^+][\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]}, \qquad \text{p}K_a = -\log K_a$$For a conjugate pair in water, \( K_a(\text{HA}) \times K_b(\text{A}^-) = K_w = 1.0 \times 10^{-14} \) at 25 °C, so \( \text{p}K_a + \text{p}K_b = 14.00 \). The stronger the acid, the weaker its conjugate base. Basicity is usually quoted as the pKa of the conjugate acid (often written pKaH): a larger pKaH means a stronger base.
Which way does a proton transfer go?
A proton transfer favours the side with the weaker acid and weaker base. Quantitatively, for
$$\text{HA} + \text{B}^- \rightleftharpoons \text{A}^- + \text{HB}$$$$\boxed{K = \frac{K_a(\text{HA})}{K_a(\text{HB})} = 10^{\,\text{p}K_a(\text{HB}) - \text{p}K_a(\text{HA})}}$$The levelling effect in one paragraph
In water, HCl, HBr, HI, HNO₃, H₂SO₄ (first proton) and HClO₄ all react completely to give H₃O⁺. Their solutions behave identically: water has levelled them to the strength of H₃O⁺. Likewise, NH₂⁻, H⁻ and O²⁻ are levelled to OH⁻. To tell strong acids apart you need a less basic solvent (glacial acetic acid is the standard choice); this is developed fully in Non-aqueous Solvents.
Limitations of the Brønsted view
It still needs a proton. BF₃, SO₃, Ag⁺ and CO₂ react with bases without donating any proton, and the theory cannot rank their acidity.
Lewis Definition
G. N. Lewis (also 1923) defined an acid as an electron-pair acceptor and a base as an electron-pair donor. Neutralisation is the formation of a coordinate (dative) bond, giving an adduct or complex:
$$\text{BF}_3 + :\!\text{NH}_3 \rightarrow \text{F}_3\text{B}\!\leftarrow\!\text{NH}_3$$In orbital language the base supplies an occupied orbital (usually its HOMO), and the acid supplies a vacant one (usually its LUMO). Every Brønsted base is a Lewis base, because accepting a proton means donating a pair to it. The proton itself is a Lewis acid, so every Brønsted acid–base reaction is a special case of Lewis neutralisation (one Lewis acid, H⁺, transferred from one base to another).
Types of Lewis acid
| Type | Examples | Where the vacant orbital is |
|---|---|---|
| Incomplete octet | BF₃, BCl₃, AlCl₃, BH₃ (as B₂H₆), GaCl₃ | empty p orbital on the central atom |
| Cations | H⁺, Ag⁺, Cu²⁺, Fe³⁺, Al³⁺, all metal ions | empty s, p or d orbitals |
| Expandable valence (period 3 and below) | SiF₄, SnCl₄, PF₅, SbF₅ | σ* orbitals of the M–X bonds (often described as “vacant d”, see the note below) |
| π-acceptors (multiple bonds) | CO₂, SO₂, SO₃ | π* orbital: CO₂ + OH⁻ → HCO₃⁻ |
| Molecules with a low-lying σ* | I₂, Br₂ | σ* of X–X: I₂ + I⁻ → I₃⁻ |
Types of Lewis base
| Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Lone pair on N, O, P, S, halogen | NH₃, amines, H₂O, ethers, R₃P, R₂S, F⁻, Cl⁻ |
| Anions in general | OH⁻, CN⁻, SCN⁻, H⁻ |
| σ-donor with π-acceptor ability | CO, PF₃, phosphites |
| π-electron donors | alkenes, arenes (to Ag⁺, Pt(II)) |
Lewis acid–base reaction types
- Adduct formation: BF₃ + OEt₂ → F₃B–OEt₂; Ag⁺ + 2NH₃ → [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺.
- Displacement of a base: F₃B–OEt₂ + NH₃ → F₃B–NH₃ + OEt₂. Ligand substitution such as [Cu(H₂O)₄]²⁺ + 4NH₃ → [Cu(NH₃)₄]²⁺ + 4H₂O is the same type (NH₃ displaces H₂O from the acid Cu²⁺), and so is HCl + NH₃ → NH₄Cl (NH₃ displaces Cl⁻ from the acid H⁺).
- Displacement of an acid: a stronger acid takes the base away from a weaker one, for example [Cu(NH₃)₄]²⁺ + 4H⁺ → Cu²⁺(aq) + 4NH₄⁺ (H⁺ displaces Cu²⁺ from NH₃).
- Metathesis (double displacement): exchange of partners, as in many reactions in non-aqueous solvents.
Friedel–Crafts catalysis is a Lewis acid–base sequence: AlCl₃ takes Cl⁻ from RCOCl to form the acylium ion RCO⁺ and [AlCl₄]⁻.
Limitations of the Lewis view
It has no single strength scale. Order of acid strength depends on the reference base: BF₃ binds NH₃ more strongly than PH₃, while Ag⁺ prefers PH₃-type donors. That observation is what the HSAB concept organises. The Lewis definition also excludes electron-transfer (redox) reactions, which only the Usanovich definition counts as acid–base.
Lux–Flood Definition
For oxide systems at high temperature, where neither protons nor convenient lone pairs dominate:
- Lux–Flood acid: oxide-ion acceptor.
- Lux–Flood base: oxide-ion donor.
So the anhydride of an oxoacid (SiO₂, CO₂, SO₃, P₄O₁₀) is a Lux–Flood acid, and basic metal oxides (Na₂O, CaO, MgO, BaO) are Lux–Flood bases. Metallurgical slag formation uses this: SiO₂ (acid flux) removes basic impurities like FeO and CaO; CaO or MgO (basic flux, from limestone or dolomite) removes acidic SiO₂ and P₄O₁₀.
The Lux–Flood picture agrees with ordinary acid–base behaviour: an oxide that accepts O²⁻ forms an oxoanion, which is the conjugate base of an oxoacid. An amphoteric oxide can act both ways, for example Al₂O₃ is an acid towards Na₂O (forming aluminate) and a base towards SO₃ or P₄O₁₀.
Acid–base character of oxides
| Trend | Example |
|---|---|
| Across a period, more acidic | Na₂O, MgO basic; Al₂O₃ amphoteric; SiO₂, P₄O₁₀, SO₃, Cl₂O₇ acidic |
| Down a group, more basic | B₂O₃ acidic, Al₂O₃ amphoteric, Tl₂O basic |
| Higher oxidation state, more acidic | CrO basic, Cr₂O₃ amphoteric, CrO₃ acidic; MnO basic, Mn₂O₇ acidic |
| Typical amphoteric oxides | BeO, Al₂O₃, ZnO, Ga₂O₃, SnO, SnO₂, PbO |
Solvent-System Definition
For a solvent that self-ionises (autoionises), the solvent-system definition (Cady and Elsey) says:
- An acid is a solute that increases the concentration of the cation characteristic of the solvent.
- A base is a solute that increases the concentration of the anion characteristic of the solvent.
- Neutralisation produces the salt and the solvent.
| Solvent | Self-ionisation | Characteristic cation (acid) | Characteristic anion (base) |
|---|---|---|---|
| H₂O | 2H₂O ⇌ H₃O⁺ + OH⁻ | H₃O⁺ | OH⁻ |
| NH₃ (l) | 2NH₃ ⇌ NH₄⁺ + NH₂⁻ | NH₄⁺ | NH₂⁻ |
| BrF₃ | 2BrF₃ ⇌ BrF₂⁺ + BrF₄⁻ | BrF₂⁺ | BrF₄⁻ |
| N₂O₄ | N₂O₄ ⇌ NO⁺ + NO₃⁻ | NO⁺ | NO₃⁻ |
So in liquid NH₃, NH₄Cl is an acid and KNH₂ a base; in BrF₃, SbF₅ is an acid (it gives BrF₂⁺) and KF is a base (it gives BrF₄⁻). The definition does not need protons at all, and that is its strength. Its weakness is that it is tied to a particular solvent and assumes self-ionisation that is sometimes only postulated (liquid SO₂ is the classic doubtful case). Details are in Non-aqueous Solvents.
Usanovich Definition
The broadest definition:
- Acid: any species that reacts with a base, gives up cations, or accepts anions or electrons.
- Base: any species that gives up anions or electrons, or combines with cations.
Because accepting electrons counts as acid behaviour, every redox reaction becomes an acid–base reaction: in 2Na + Cl₂ → 2NaCl, Cl₂ (electron acceptor) is the acid and Na the base. Usanovich also covers SO₃ + Na₂O → Na₂SO₄ (SO₃ accepts O²⁻) and Fe(CN)₂ + 4KCN → K₄[Fe(CN)₆] (Fe(CN)₂ accepts CN⁻).
The usual criticism is that a definition covering nearly every reaction stops being useful for classification. In the exam, use Usanovich when the question names it, or when a reaction is acid–base only under it (a redox reaction such as Na with Cl₂).
Choosing the Right Definition
graph TD
Q[Reaction given] --> P{Proton transferred?}
P -->|Yes| BL[Brønsted–Lowry, also Lewis]
P -->|No| O{Oxide ion transferred?}
O -->|Yes| LF[Lux–Flood, also Usanovich]
O -->|No| L{Lone pair donated to a vacant orbital?}
L -->|Yes| LW[Lewis]
L -->|No| U{Electron transfer?}
U -->|Yes| US[Usanovich only]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Conjugate base of H₂SO₄: HSO₄⁻ | conjugate base of HSO₄⁻: SO₄²⁻ | |
| Amphiprotic (H₂O, HCO₃⁻): donates and accepts H⁺ | amphoteric (Al₂O₃, ZnO): reacts with both acids and bases, any mechanism | |
| Lewis acid BF₃: accepts a pair, not a Brønsted acid | Brønsted acid HCl: donates H⁺; the Lewis acid is H⁺ itself | |
| Lux–Flood acid: O²⁻ acceptor (SiO₂) | Lux–Flood base: O²⁻ donor (CaO) | |
| Solvent-system acid in NH₃: NH₄Cl | Arrhenius acid: only in water | |
| Levelled (several acids all appear as H₃O⁺) | differentiated (strengths distinguished in a less basic solvent) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Give the conjugate base of HSO₄⁻ and the conjugate acid of NH₂⁻.
- In BF₃ + NH₃ → F₃B–NH₃, which species is the Lewis acid?
- In liquid NH₃, is NH₄Cl an acid or a base on the solvent-system definition?
Answers
- SO₄²⁻; NH₃.
- BF₃, the electron-pair acceptor (empty boron p orbital).
- Acid: it raises [NH₄⁺], the solvent’s characteristic cation.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which of the following is a Lewis acid but not a Brønsted acid?
(a) HCl (b) NH₄⁺ (c) AlCl₃ (d) H₂O
Answer: (c) AlCl₃
AlCl₃ has a vacant orbital on Al and accepts pairs (it forms [AlCl₄]⁻ and the Al₂Cl₆ dimer) but has no proton. HCl, NH₄⁺ and H₂O can all donate a proton.
Practice Q2. In the reaction Na₂O + SO₃ → Na₂SO₄, the Lux–Flood acid is:
(a) Na₂O (b) SO₃ (c) Na₂SO₄ (d) none, because no proton is transferred
Answer: (b) SO₃
SO₃ accepts O²⁻ from Na₂O to form SO₄²⁻. The oxide acceptor is the acid. Option (d) applies the Brønsted criterion to a Lux–Flood question.
Practice Q3. In the reaction HNO₃ + H₂SO₄ ⇌ H₂NO₃⁺ + HSO₄⁻, HNO₃ acts as:
(a) a Brønsted acid (b) a Brønsted base (c) a Lux–Flood acid (d) an oxidising agent only
Answer: (b) a Brønsted base
HNO₃ accepts a proton from the stronger acid H₂SO₄. The protonated nitric acid then loses water to form NO₂⁺, the nitrating agent.
Practice Q4. The reaction 2Na + Cl₂ → 2NaCl is an acid–base reaction under which definition?
(a) Brønsted–Lowry (b) Lewis (c) Lux–Flood (d) Usanovich
Answer: (d) Usanovich
No proton, no electron pair shared from a donor lone pair and no oxide transfer. Only Usanovich counts electron acceptance (Cl₂) as acid behaviour.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Given pKa values in water at 25 °C: HF 3.2, CH₃COOH 4.76, NH₄⁺ 9.25. Consider the reactions:
- HF + CH₃COO⁻ ⇌ F⁻ + CH₃COOH
- NH₄⁺ + CH₃COO⁻ ⇌ NH₃ + CH₃COOH
- CH₃COOH + NH₃ ⇌ CH₃COO⁻ + NH₄⁺
Which have K > 1?
(a) 1 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer: (b) 1 and 3 only
Use \( K = 10^{\text{p}K_a(\text{product acid}) - \text{p}K_a(\text{reactant acid})} \).
- \( 10^{4.76 - 3.2} = 10^{1.56} \approx 36 \): K > 1.
- \( 10^{4.76 - 9.25} = 10^{-4.49} \approx 3.2 \times 10^{-5} \): K < 1.
- The reverse of 2: \( 10^{9.25 - 4.76} = 10^{4.49} \approx 3.1 \times 10^{4} \): K > 1.
Each time the favoured side holds the weaker acid.
Practice Q6. Consider the statements:
- Every Brønsted base is also a Lewis base.
- In liquid BrF₃, KF is a base on the solvent-system definition because it forms BrF₄⁻.
- The Lewis definition gives a single, solvent-independent order of acid strength.
- Al₂O₃ can act as a Lux–Flood acid towards Na₂O.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. To accept a proton the base must donate a pair to it.
- Correct. KF + BrF₃ → K⁺ + BrF₄⁻ raises the solvent’s anion.
- Wrong. Lewis acidity order depends on the reference base (BF₃ prefers N donors, Ag⁺ prefers P and S donors). This failure is what HSAB addresses.
- Correct. Al₂O₃ + Na₂O → 2NaAlO₂: Al₂O₃ accepts O²⁻.
Practice Q7. A student classifies each reaction under the narrowest definition that still makes it acid–base. Which classification is wrong?
(a) SiO₂ + CaO → CaSiO₃: Lux–Flood (b) Ag⁺ + 2NH₃ → [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺: Lewis (c) HCl(g) + NH₃(g) → NH₄Cl(s): Arrhenius (d) NOCl + AgNO₃ → AgCl + N₂O₄ (in liquid N₂O₄): solvent system
Answer: (c)
The gas-phase reaction of HCl with NH₃ involves no water, so it cannot be Arrhenius. The narrowest definition that covers it is Brønsted–Lowry (proton transfer). In (d), NOCl supplies NO⁺ (the solvent’s cation, an acid) and AgNO₃ supplies NO₃⁻ (a base); they neutralise to the salt AgCl and the solvent N₂O₄.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Arrhenius | H⁺ / OH⁻ in water only |
| Brønsted–Lowry (1923) | proton donor / acceptor; conjugate pairs differ by one H⁺ |
| Conjugate relation | pKa + pKb = 14.00 at 25 °C (water) |
| Proton transfer K | \( 10^{\text{p}K_a(\text{HB}) - \text{p}K_a(\text{HA})} \); weaker acid side favoured |
| Lewis (1923) | pair acceptor / donor; adduct; HOMO → LUMO |
| Lewis acids | BF₃, AlCl₃, metal ions, SiF₄, SbF₅, CO₂, SO₃, I₂ |
| Lux–Flood | O²⁻ acceptor = acid (SiO₂, SO₃, CO₂); O²⁻ donor = base (CaO, Na₂O) |
| Solvent system | acid raises solvent cation; base raises solvent anion |
| Usanovich | includes redox: electron acceptor = acid |
| Oxide trends | acidic across period, with oxidation state; basic down group |
| Levelling | in water every acid stronger than H₃O⁺ appears as H₃O⁺ |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Strength of Acids and Bases: why HI is stronger than HF, Pauling’s rules for oxoacids, aqua acids, and Lewis acid strength of the boron halides.
- The Hard–Soft Acid–Base (HSAB) Concept: why Lewis acid strength depends on the base.
- Non-aqueous Solvents: levelling, liquid ammonia, HF, H₂SO₄, BrF₃ and N₂O₄.
- The chapter overview: Acids, Bases and Non-aqueous Solvents.