Strength of Acids and Bases: Hydrides, Oxoacids, Aqua Ions and Lewis Acids
CSIR NET chemistry: hydride acidity trends, Pauling's rules for oxoacids, aqua-ion hydrolysis, BX3 Lewis acidity, steric strain and amine basicity.
- 18 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Why Is H₃PO₃ Only Diprotic?
- Three Families of Brønsted Acid
- Binary Hydrides
- Oxoacids: Pauling’s Rules
- Aqua Acids: Hydrolysis of Metal Ions
- Lewis Acid Strength
- Base Strength: Amines and Steric Strain
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Acid–Base Concepts: Arrhenius to Usanovich: conjugate pairs, pKa and the Lewis definition.
- Electronegativity Scales and Periodic Anomalies: electronegativity and the first-row anomaly drive the hydride and oxoacid trends.
- Atomic and Ionic Radii: charge density (z²/r) sets the acidity of hydrated metal ions.
The Hook: Why Is H₃PO₃ Only Diprotic?
Three Families of Brønsted Acid
Brønsted acids in inorganic chemistry fall into three groups according to what the acidic proton is attached to:
| Family | Proton on | Example | Main factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Binary hydride (hydracid) | the central element E | HF, H₂S, NH₄⁺ | E–H bond strength; electronegativity of E |
| Oxoacid | an oxygen bound to E | H₂SO₄, HClO₄, H₃PO₄ | number of terminal (=O) oxygens |
| Aqua acid | a water ligand on a metal ion | [Fe(H₂O)₆]³⁺ | charge and size of the metal ion |
These are steps on one ladder: as the oxidation state of the central atom rises, an aqua acid loses protons to become a hydroxo acid and then an oxoacid (see “From aqua to oxo” below).
Binary Hydrides
Across a period: electronegativity wins
$$\text{CH}_4 < \text{NH}_3 < \text{H}_2\text{O} < \text{HF} \qquad (\text{acidity in water})$$The E–H bonds are of similar length along a period, so the dominant factor is the electronegativity of E: the more electronegative E, the more stable the negative charge on the conjugate base E⁻ and the more polar the E–H bond. CH₄ and NH₃ are essentially not acids in water (NH₃ acts as an acid only towards very strong bases such as the hydride ion or alkyl-lithium reagents).
Down a group: bond strength wins
$$\text{HF} \ll \text{HCl} < \text{HBr} < \text{HI} \qquad \text{H}_2\text{O} < \text{H}_2\text{S} < \text{H}_2\text{Se} < \text{H}_2\text{Te}$$Down a group electronegativity falls, which on its own would make the acids weaker. The opposite is observed, because the E–H bond becomes longer and much weaker (about 570, 432, 366 and 298 kJ mol⁻¹ for HF, HCl, HBr, HI), and the large conjugate base spreads its charge over a bigger volume.
Basicity of hydrides
The trends reverse for the conjugate bases and for neutral hydrides acting as bases:
$$\text{NH}_3 > \text{PH}_3 > \text{AsH}_3 > \text{SbH}_3 \qquad (\text{basicity})$$The nitrogen lone pair sits in an orbital of substantial s–p hybrid character on a small atom; the lone pair of PH₃ and heavier hydrides is in a diffuse, largely s-type orbital (bond angles near 90°, see Bond Angles and Bent’s Rule), which is a poorer proton acceptor. PH₄⁺ salts exist (PH₄I) but are hydrolysed by water.
Oxoacids: Pauling’s Rules
Write an oxoacid as \( \text{EO}_p(\text{OH})_q \): p oxygens are terminal (not protonated), q are OH groups. Pauling’s two empirical rules:
$$\boxed{\text{Rule 1:}\quad \text{p}K_{a1} \approx 8 - 5p}$$$$\boxed{\text{Rule 2:}\quad \text{successive } \text{p}K_a \text{ values increase by about 5}}$$| p | Predicted pKa₁ | Class |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | about 8 | very weak |
| 1 | about 3 | weak |
| 2 | about −2 | strong |
| 3 | about −7 | very strong |
Why the terminal oxygens matter: each E=O (more exactly, E⁺–O⁻) group withdraws electron density from the O–H bonds by induction, and spreads the negative charge of the anion over more oxygens by resonance. Each extra terminal oxygen stabilises the conjugate base by a roughly constant amount.
Why successive pKa values rise by 5: each proton must leave an anion that already carries more negative charge.
Predicted versus observed
| Acid | Formula as \( \text{EO}_p(\text{OH})_q \) | p | Predicted pKa₁ | Observed pKa₁ (approx.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HOCl | Cl(OH) | 0 | 8 | 7.5 |
| H₃AsO₃ | As(OH)₃ | 0 | 8 | 9.2 |
| HNO₂ | NO(OH) | 1 | 3 | 3.3 |
| HClO₂ | ClO(OH) | 1 | 3 | 2.0 |
| H₃PO₄ | PO(OH)₃ | 1 | 3 | 2.1 |
| H₃AsO₄ | AsO(OH)₃ | 1 | 3 | 2.2 |
| H₂SO₃ | SO(OH)₂ | 1 | 3 | 1.9 |
| H₅IO₆ | IO(OH)₅ | 1 | 3 | 3.3 |
| HNO₃ | NO₂(OH) | 2 | −2 | −1.4 |
| H₂SO₄ | SO₂(OH)₂ | 2 | −2 | about −3 |
| HClO₃ | ClO₂(OH) | 2 | −2 | about −1 |
| HClO₄ | ClO₃(OH) | 3 | −7 | about −10 |
For H₃PO₄ the rules predict 3, 8, 13; the observed values are about 2.1, 7.2 and 12.4. The agreement (within about one unit) is why the rule is worth learning.
Using the rule backwards: structures from pKa
| Acid | Observed pKa₁ | p implied | Structure | Ionisable H |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H₃PO₃ (phosphorous) | between 1 and 2 | 1 | HPO(OH)₂, one P–H | 2 (diprotic) |
| H₃PO₂ (hypophosphorous) | between 1 and 2 | 1 | H₂PO(OH), two P–H | 1 (monoprotic) |
| H₃AsO₃ (arsenous) | 9.2 | 0 | As(OH)₃ | weak, all on O |
If H₃PO₃ were P(OH)₃ (p = 0), its pKa₁ would be near 8; the observed value fits HPO(OH)₂. Hydrogens bonded directly to P are not acidic, so H₃PO₃ is dibasic and H₃PO₂ monobasic. Both are good reducing agents because of their P–H bonds.
The two classic exceptions
Other trends in oxoacids
- Same structure, different central atom: for E(OH), acidity rises with the electronegativity of E:
- Same element, more oxygens: HOCl < HClO₂ < HClO₃ < HClO₄. This is Pauling’s rule 1 again (p = 0, 1, 2, 3).
- Higher oxidation state of the central atom: H₂SO₃ < H₂SO₄; HNO₂ < HNO₃.
Aqua Acids: Hydrolysis of Metal Ions
A metal ion in water is a Lewis acid that binds water molecules. The coordinated water is polarised by the cation, and one of its protons can be lost:
$$[\text{M(H}_2\text{O)}_6]^{z+} + \text{H}_2\text{O} \rightleftharpoons [\text{M(H}_2\text{O)}_5(\text{OH})]^{(z-1)+} + \text{H}_3\text{O}^+$$This is hydrolysis of the metal ion, and it is why solutions of FeCl₃, AlCl₃ and Cr³⁺ salts are acidic.
What controls the acidity
The acidity increases with the charge density of the cation, measured roughly by \( z^2/r \) (or \( z/r \)):
| Aqua ion | z | Typical pKa (approx.) | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| [Na(H₂O)ₙ]⁺ | +1 | about 14 | essentially neutral |
| [Mg(H₂O)₆]²⁺ | +2 | about 11.4 | very weak acid |
| [Fe(H₂O)₆]²⁺ | +2 | about 9.5 | weak |
| [Al(H₂O)₆]³⁺ | +3 | about 5 | as acidic as acetic acid |
| [Fe(H₂O)₆]³⁺ | +3 | about 2.2 | comparable to the first step of H₃PO₄ |
Three working rules:
- Higher charge, more acidic: Fe³⁺ ≫ Fe²⁺; Al³⁺ ≫ Mg²⁺ ≫ Na⁺.
- Smaller ion of the same charge, more acidic: Be²⁺ is more acidic than Mg²⁺, which is more acidic than Ba²⁺.
- Covalent (soft, polarising) cations are more acidic than \( z^2/r \) predicts: Hg²⁺ and Sn²⁺ hydrolyse more than their size and charge suggest, because their M–O bonds have more covalent character. This links to Fajans’ rules.
Successive deprotonation, especially for M³⁺ and M⁴⁺, leads to OH-bridged polycations and eventually to the precipitation of the hydroxide or hydrous oxide (Fe(OH)₃, Al(OH)₃) as the pH rises.
From aqua to oxo
As the oxidation state of the central atom rises, the stable form in water loses more protons:
| Oxidation state | Typical form | Example |
|---|---|---|
| low (+1, +2, +3) | aqua ion | [Fe(H₂O)₆]³⁺, [Cr(H₂O)₆]³⁺ |
| intermediate (+4) | hydroxo or oxo-aqua species | [VO(H₂O)₅]²⁺ (vanadyl, V(IV)) |
| high (+5 to +8) | oxoanion or oxoacid | VO₄³⁻, CrO₄²⁻, MnO₄⁻, OsO₄ |
The same element can therefore give a basic oxide in a low oxidation state and an acidic oxide in a high one (CrO, Cr₂O₃, CrO₃ in the Lux–Flood table).
Lewis Acid Strength
The boron trihalides
Towards a reference base such as NH₃ or pyridine, the Lewis acidity order is
$$\text{BF}_3 < \text{BCl}_3 < \text{BBr}_3 < \text{BI}_3$$This is the reverse of what electronegativity alone predicts: fluorine should make boron the most electron-poor. Two effects explain it:
- π back-donation: filled p orbitals on the halogen donate into the empty boron 2p orbital. The B 2p–F 2p overlap is the best (similar size and energy), so BF₃ has the most π stabilisation in its planar form.
- Reorganisation energy: to accept a base, BX₃ must pyramidalise from trigonal planar to tetrahedral, which destroys the π bonding. BF₃ loses the most, so it pays the highest price and forms the weakest adducts.
Supporting evidence: the B–F bonds in BF₃ are shorter than expected for a single bond, and they lengthen on adduct formation.
Other factors in Lewis acidity
| Factor | Effect | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Positive charge and small size | stronger acid | Al³⁺ > Mg²⁺ > Na⁺ |
| Electronegative substituents (σ-only) | stronger acid | B(C₆F₅)₃ stronger than B(C₆H₅)₃ |
| π back-donation from substituents | weaker acid | BF₃ weakest of BX₃; B(OR)₃ and B(NR₂)₃ very weak |
| Steric bulk round the acceptor | weaker acid (adduct strained) | B(mesityl)₃ forms few adducts |
| Expanded coordination possible | acid even with full octet | SiF₄, SnCl₄, PF₅, SbF₅ |
Base Strength: Amines and Steric Strain
Methylamines in water and in the gas phase
The inductive (+I) effect of methyl groups pushes electron density onto nitrogen, so basicity should rise steadily with substitution. In the gas phase, with no solvent, it does:
$$\text{Gas phase:}\quad \text{Me}_3\text{N} > \text{Me}_2\text{NH} > \text{MeNH}_2 > \text{NH}_3$$In water the order is irregular:
$$\text{Water:}\quad \text{Me}_2\text{NH}\ (10.73) > \text{MeNH}_2\ (10.64) > \text{Me}_3\text{N}\ (9.80) > \text{NH}_3\ (9.25) \qquad (\text{p}K_a \text{ of conjugate acids})$$The protonated amines R₃NH⁺ are stabilised by hydrogen bonding to water through their N–H protons. NH₄⁺ has four such protons and Me₃NH⁺ only one, so solvation favours the less substituted ions. The balance of inductive effect (favouring Me₃N) and solvation (favouring NH₃) puts Me₂NH on top and Me₃N below MeNH₂.
Steric strain (H. C. Brown)
Towards the proton, which is tiny, steric effects hardly matter. Towards a bulky Lewis acid such as B(CH₃)₃, they do:
- F-strain (front strain): clash between groups on the base and groups on the acid at the new bond. 2,6-dimethylpyridine (2,6-lutidine) is a stronger base than pyridine towards H⁺ (inductive effect of two methyls), but forms a much weaker adduct with B(CH₃)₃, because the 2- and 6-methyl groups collide with the boron methyls.
- B-strain (back strain): strain among the groups on the base itself. Bulky groups on nitrogen spread out to relieve crowding; forming an adduct pushes the nitrogen towards tetrahedral and squeezes them together again, which weakens the base.
- Tied-back alkyl groups: quinuclidine, in which the three “ethyl” arms are tied back into a cage, binds B(CH₃)₃ much more strongly than Et₃N does, because the flexible ethyl groups of Et₃N get in the way of the acid. Textbooks file this example under different strain labels; learn the comparison itself.
So base-strength orders also depend on the reference acid, just as acid-strength orders depend on the reference base.
Other basicity factors
| Base | pKa of conjugate acid (approx.) | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| NH₃ | 9.25 | sp³ lone pair |
| Pyridine | 5.2 | sp² lone pair (more s character, held more tightly) |
| Aniline | 4.6 | lone pair delocalised into the ring |
| Me₂NH | 10.73 | inductive effect, good solvation |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| HF < HCl < HBr < HI (acidity, bond strength rules) | F > Cl > Br > I (electronegativity) | |
| HOCl > HOBr > HOI (acidity, electronegativity rules) | HCl < HBr < HI (hydracid acidity) | |
| H₃PO₃: dibasic, HPO(OH)₂ | H₃PO₂: monobasic, H₂PO(OH) | |
| B(OH)₃: Lewis acid, pKa about 9.2 | Si(OH)₄: weak Brønsted acid | |
| Gas phase: Me₃N strongest | water: Me₂NH strongest | |
| 2,6-lutidine: stronger base to H⁺ than pyridine | weaker base to B(CH₃)₃ (F-strain) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Using Pauling’s rule, estimate pKa₁ of HClO₃.
- How many ionisable protons does H₃PO₂ have?
- Which is the stronger Lewis acid towards NH₃: BF₃ or BBr₃?
Answers
- ClO₂(OH): p = 2, so pKa₁ ≈ 8 − 10 = −2 (a strong acid; observed about −1).
- One. H₂PO(OH): two H on P, one OH.
- BBr₃. BF₃ is weakened by strong B–F π back-donation that is lost on pyramidalisation.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The correct order of acid strength is:
(a) HOI > HOBr > HOCl (b) HOCl > HOBr > HOI (c) HOBr > HOCl > HOI (d) all three are equal, since p = 0 for each
Answer: (b)
All three are E(OH) with p = 0, so Pauling’s rule gives the same first estimate (about 8), but within one structural class the electronegativity of the halogen decides: Cl pulls most electron density from O–H. Observed pKa about 7.5, 8.6, 10.6.
Practice Q2. Arrange the aqua ions in order of increasing acidity: [Na(H₂O)ₙ]⁺, [Mg(H₂O)₆]²⁺, [Al(H₂O)₆]³⁺, [Fe(H₂O)₆]³⁺.
(a) Na⁺ < Mg²⁺ < Al³⁺ < Fe³⁺ (b) Fe³⁺ < Al³⁺ < Mg²⁺ < Na⁺ (c) Na⁺ < Mg²⁺ < Fe³⁺ < Al³⁺ (d) Mg²⁺ < Na⁺ < Al³⁺ < Fe³⁺
Answer: (a)
Charge density increases from Na⁺ to Mg²⁺ to the M³⁺ ions. Between the two M³⁺ ions, Fe³⁺ (pKa about 2.2) is more acidic than Al³⁺ (about 5): Fe³⁺ is larger, so \( z^2/r \) alone does not explain it; the more covalent Fe–O interaction does. Option (c) is the pure-size trap.
Practice Q3. Which oxoacid is predicted by Pauling’s rules to be the weakest?
(a) H₂SO₄ (b) H₅IO₆ (c) H₆TeO₆ (d) HNO₃
Answer: (c) H₆TeO₆
H₆TeO₆ = Te(OH)₆, p = 0, pKa₁ ≈ 8. H₅IO₆ = IO(OH)₅, p = 1, ≈ 3. H₂SO₄ and HNO₃ have p = 2, ≈ −2.
Practice Q4. In aqueous solution, the order of basicity of the methylamines is:
(a) Me₃N > Me₂NH > MeNH₂ > NH₃ (b) Me₂NH > MeNH₂ > Me₃N > NH₃ (c) NH₃ > MeNH₂ > Me₂NH > Me₃N (d) MeNH₂ > Me₂NH > NH₃ > Me₃N
Answer: (b)
pKa of conjugate acids: Me₂NH₂⁺ 10.73, MeNH₃⁺ 10.64, Me₃NH⁺ 9.80, NH₄⁺ 9.25. Option (a) is the gas-phase order.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Three oxoacids of an element X have the molecular formulas H₃XO₄, H₃XO₃ and H₃XO₂. Their measured pKa₁ values are all between 1 and 2.3. Titration shows that H₃XO₄ is tribasic, H₃XO₃ dibasic and H₃XO₂ monobasic. Which statements are correct?
- All three acids have exactly one terminal (P=O-type) oxygen.
- H₃XO₃ contains one X–H bond.
- H₃XO₂ is expected to be a reducing agent.
- If H₃XO₃ had the structure X(OH)₃, Pauling’s rule would predict pKa₁ near 8.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
pKa₁ near 2 fits p = 1 for all three (Pauling: 3; the observed values run 1–2 units lower for these acids). With one terminal O each:
- H₃XO₄ = XO(OH)₃: three OH, tribasic.
- H₃XO₃ = HXO(OH)₂: two OH and one X–H, dibasic.
- H₃XO₂ = H₂XO(OH): one OH and two X–H, monobasic.
X–H bonds make the lower acids reducing (the behaviour of phosphorous and hypophosphorous acids). A structure X(OH)₃ would have p = 0 and pKa₁ ≈ 8, which contradicts the data. X is phosphorus.
Practice Q6. Use Pauling’s rules to predict all three pKa values of H₃AsO₄, and compare with observed values of about 2.2, 7.0 and 11.5. Which statement is correct?
(a) Predicted 3, 8, 13; the rules overestimate each value by roughly 1–1.5 units (b) Predicted 8, 13, 18; the rules fail completely for arsenic acid (c) Predicted −2, 3, 8; the rules underestimate each value (d) Predicted 3, 3, 3; successive pKa values do not change
Answer: (a)
H₃AsO₄ = AsO(OH)₃: p = 1, pKa₁ ≈ 8 − 5 = 3; Rule 2 adds 5 each time: 3, 8, 13. Observed minus predicted: −0.8, −1.0, −1.5. The rule is a one-unit estimate; it is good enough to classify and to deduce structure, not to give a second decimal.
Practice Q7. Consider the statements:
- 2,6-Dimethylpyridine is a stronger base than pyridine towards H⁺ but a weaker base towards B(CH₃)₃.
- The order of Lewis acidity towards pyridine is BF₃ > BCl₃ > BBr₃.
- In the gas phase, trimethylamine has a higher proton affinity than ammonia.
- Boric acid is a monobasic Lewis acid whose apparent strength in water increases on adding mannitol.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
- Correct. Inductive effect to H⁺; F-strain with B(CH₃)₃.
- Wrong. The order is the reverse, BF₃ < BCl₃ < BBr₃ (π back-donation, reorganisation energy).
- Correct. Without solvation the inductive effect gives Me₃N > Me₂NH > MeNH₂ > NH₃.
- Correct. B(OH)₃ accepts OH⁻; mannitol forms a chelate borate ester, which pulls the equilibrium over.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Hydride acidity, across period | CH₄ < NH₃ < H₂O < HF (electronegativity) |
| Hydride acidity, down group | HF ≪ HCl < HBr < HI (bond strength) |
| HF weak | strong bond (about 570 kJ mol⁻¹); unfavourable entropy of F⁻ hydration; pKa about 3.2 |
| Hydride basicity | NH₃ > PH₃ > AsH₃ > SbH₃ |
| Pauling rule 1 | pKa₁ ≈ 8 − 5p (p = terminal O) |
| Pauling rule 2 | successive pKa rise by about 5 |
| Basicity of P acids | H₃PO₄ 3, H₃PO₃ 2, H₃PO₂ 1 |
| Exceptions | H₂CO₃ (unhydrated CO₂), B(OH)₃ (Lewis acid) |
| Hypohalous | HOCl > HOBr > HOI |
| Aqua acids | acidity rises with \( z^2/r \) and covalency: Fe³⁺ (≈ 2.2) > Al³⁺ (≈ 5) > Fe²⁺ > Mg²⁺ > Na⁺ |
| BX₃ to NH₃ | BF₃ < BCl₃ < BBr₃ < BI₃ |
| Amines in water | Me₂NH > MeNH₂ > Me₃N > NH₃ |
| Amines in gas | Me₃N > Me₂NH > MeNH₂ > NH₃ |
| F-strain | 2,6-lutidine weak towards BMe₃ |
| Tied-back amine | quinuclidine binds BMe₃ better than Et₃N |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- The Hard–Soft Acid–Base (HSAB) Concept: a framework for when the partner decides the strength.
- Non-aqueous Solvents: how the solvent sets the range of acid strengths you can observe, and superacids.
- Back to Acid–Base Concepts for the definitions.
- The chapter on one page: Acids, Bases and Non-aqueous Solvents: Quick Revision.