Separation Methods: Extraction, Chromatography and Ion Exchange
CSIR NET chemistry: solvent extraction and D vs pH, plate theory, van Deemter, resolution, GC, HPLC, ion exchange, size exclusion and electrophoresis.
- 24 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Why Three Small Washes Beat One Big One
- 1. Solvent Extraction
- 2. Chromatography: Common Language
- 3. Planar Chromatography: Paper and TLC
- 4. Gas Chromatography (GC)
- 5. Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)
- 6. Ion Exchange
- 7. Electrophoresis in Brief
- 8. Other Separations Worth Knowing
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Acid–Base Concepts: pKa and the fraction of a weak acid that is un-ionised, which controls how much of it extracts.
- The HSAB Concept: why soft metal ions extract as sulfur-donor chelates and why chloro-complexes of some metals bind anion exchangers.
- Isolation and Separation of Macromolecules: the Life Sciences view of the same column methods (gel filtration, ion exchange, affinity), useful if you studied biochemistry first.
- Logarithms and the equation of a straight line, for log D versus pH plots (Graphs of Functions and Scientific Plots).
The Hook: Why Three Small Washes Beat One Big One
1. Solvent Extraction
Partition coefficient and distribution ratio
When a solute S distributes between an aqueous phase and an immiscible organic phase, the partition (distribution) coefficient refers to one chemical species:
$$K_D = \frac{[\text{S}]_{\text{org}}}{[\text{S}]_{\text{aq}}}$$The distribution ratio D refers to the total analytical concentration, whatever form the solute is in:
$$D = \frac{C_{\text{org}}}{C_{\text{aq}}} = \frac{\text{all forms of S in the organic phase}}{\text{all forms of S in the aqueous phase}}$$\( K_D \) is a constant at fixed temperature (Nernst distribution law). D changes with pH, with complexing agents and with ionic strength, because those change how much of the solute is in the extractable form. Experiments measure D.
Fraction remaining after repeated extraction
For an aqueous volume \( V_{\text{aq}} \) extracted n times with fresh portions of organic solvent of volume \( V_{\text{org}} \) each, the fraction q left in water is
$$\boxed{q_n = \left(\frac{V_{\text{aq}}}{V_{\text{aq}} + D\,V_{\text{org}}}\right)^n}$$and the percentage extracted after a single extraction is
$$\%E = \frac{100\,D}{D + V_{\text{aq}}/V_{\text{org}}}$$With equal volumes, \( \%E = 100D/(D+1) \): D = 1 gives 50%, D = 10 gives 90.9%, D = 100 gives 99.0%.
Extracting a weak acid: D depends on pH
Only neutral HA enters a non-polar solvent; A⁻ stays in water. With \( K_D \) for HA and acid constant \( K_a \):
$$\boxed{D = \frac{K_D\,[\text{H}^+]}{[\text{H}^+] + K_a}}$$- At pH well below pKa, \( D \to K_D \) (all HA, all extractable).
- At pH = pKa, \( D = K_D/2 \).
- At pH well above pKa, \( D \approx K_D[\text{H}^+]/K_a \): it falls tenfold per pH unit.
For \( K_D = 20 \) and \( K_a = 1.0 \times 10^{-5} \): D = 19.8 at pH 3, 10.0 at pH 5, 0.198 at pH 7. This is how a carboxylic acid is pulled out of an organic layer into aqueous NaHCO₃ and then back after acidifying. A weak base B behaves the other way round: it extracts at high pH, where it is unprotonated.
Metal chelate extraction
A metal ion is charged and hydrated, so it does not enter an organic solvent until it is converted into a neutral, hydrophobic species. The two standard routes are:
| Route | Extracted species | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Chelate formation | neutral ML_n with a weak-acid chelating ligand HL | 8-hydroxyquinoline (oxine), dithizone, acetylacetone, cupferron, dimethylglyoxime (Ni) |
| Ion association | neutral ion pair or solvated salt | Fe(III) from concentrated HCl into ether as H⁺(solvated)·FeCl₄⁻; large cations such as tetraphenylarsonium with large anions |
For \( \text{M}^{n+}(\text{aq}) + n\text{HL(org)} \rightleftharpoons \text{ML}_n(\text{org}) + n\text{H}^+(\text{aq}) \), with extraction constant \( K_{\text{ex}} \) and the chelating agent in excess:
$$\boxed{D = K_{\text{ex}}\,\frac{[\text{HL}]_{\text{org}}^{\,n}}{[\text{H}^+]^{n}}} \qquad \log D = \log K_{\text{ex}} + n\log[\text{HL}]_{\text{org}} + n\,\text{pH}$$Three consequences that Part C tests:
- A plot of log D against pH is a straight line of slope n, the charge of the metal ion. Slope 2 means M²⁺, slope 3 means M³⁺.
- The pH₁/₂, where D = 1 (50% extracted with equal volumes), is \( \text{pH}_{1/2} = -\frac{1}{n}\log K_{\text{ex}} - \log[\text{HL}]_{\text{org}} \). A tenfold increase in reagent concentration lowers pH₁/₂ by one unit.
- Two metals with different \( K_{\text{ex}} \) have different pH₁/₂, so they can be separated by buffering between them. Masking agents (EDTA, cyanide, tartrate) form water-soluble complexes and keep an interfering metal in the aqueous phase.
2. Chromatography: Common Language
All chromatography distributes solutes between a stationary phase and a mobile phase that moves past it. A solute that spends more time in the stationary phase moves more slowly.
graph TD
A[Chromatography] --> B[Mobile phase: gas]
A --> C[Mobile phase: liquid]
A --> X[Mobile phase: supercritical fluid]
B --> B1[GC: gas-liquid partition
gas-solid adsorption]
C --> C1[Planar: paper, TLC]
C --> C2[Column: HPLC]
C2 --> D1[Adsorption / normal phase]
C2 --> D2[Partition / reversed phase]
C2 --> D3[Ion exchange]
C2 --> D4[Size exclusion]
C2 --> D5[Affinity]Retention parameters
| Quantity | Definition | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Retention time \( t_R \) | time from injection to peak maximum | identity, under fixed conditions |
| Dead time \( t_M \) | time for an unretained species | time spent in the mobile phase |
| Adjusted retention time \( t_R' \) | \( t_R - t_M \) | time spent in the stationary phase |
| Retention (capacity) factor | \( k = \dfrac{t_R - t_M}{t_M} \) | moles in stationary / moles in mobile phase; ideally 1 to 10 |
| Selectivity factor | \( \alpha = \dfrac{k_B}{k_A} = \dfrac{t'_{R,B}}{t'_{R,A}} \) (B the later peak, so α ≥ 1) | how differently the phases treat A and B |
| Retardation factor (planar) | \( R_f = \dfrac{\text{distance moved by spot}}{\text{distance moved by solvent front}} \) | always between 0 and 1 |
The retention factor is related to the distribution constant: \( k = K\,V_S/V_M \), where \( V_S \) and \( V_M \) are the volumes of stationary and mobile phase.
Efficiency: plate number and plate height
Plate theory treats the column as N imaginary equilibrium stages. N is measured from the peak:
$$\boxed{N = 16\left(\frac{t_R}{W}\right)^2 = 5.54\left(\frac{t_R}{W_{1/2}}\right)^2} \qquad \boxed{H = \frac{L}{N}}$$W is the baseline width (from tangents to the inflection points, equal to 4σ for a Gaussian peak), \( W_{1/2} \) the width at half height, L the column length and H the height equivalent to a theoretical plate (HETP). Small H means an efficient column. t_R and W must be in the same unit.
Why peaks broaden: the van Deemter equation
Rate theory explains band broadening as the sum of three contributions, each depending differently on the linear flow velocity u of the mobile phase:
$$\boxed{H = A + \frac{B}{u} + C\,u}$$| Term | Name | Physical cause | How to reduce it |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | eddy (multipath) diffusion | molecules take paths of different length through the packing; independent of u | small, uniform particles; open tubular (capillary) columns have no A term |
| B/u | longitudinal diffusion | solute diffuses along the column axis while waiting; worse at low flow | faster flow; less important in liquids, where diffusion coefficients are about 10⁴ times smaller than in gases |
| Cu | resistance to mass transfer | equilibration between phases is not instantaneous; worse at high flow | thin stationary film, small particles, low viscosity, higher temperature |
Setting \( dH/du = 0 \) gives the optimum velocity and the minimum plate height:
$$\boxed{u_{\text{opt}} = \sqrt{B/C}} \qquad \boxed{H_{\min} = A + 2\sqrt{BC}}$$The curve of H against u is a hyperbola-like plot with a minimum. To the left (slow flow) the B term dominates; to the right (fast flow) the C term dominates, and the curve rises almost linearly with slope C.
Resolution
Resolution measures how well two adjacent peaks are separated:
$$\boxed{R_s = \frac{2\,(t_{R,B} - t_{R,A})}{W_A + W_B}}$$\( R_s = 1.5 \) is taken as baseline resolution; at \( R_s = 1.0 \) the peaks still overlap slightly. The Purnell equation splits resolution into the three things you can control:
$$\boxed{R_s = \frac{\sqrt{N}}{4}\left(\frac{\alpha - 1}{\alpha}\right)\left(\frac{k_B}{1 + k_B}\right)}$$| Factor | How to change it | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Efficiency \( \sqrt{N} \) | longer column, smaller particles, optimum flow | \( R_s \propto \sqrt{L} \): doubling resolution needs four times the length (and about four times the time) |
| Selectivity α | change stationary phase, mobile-phase composition, pH, temperature | most powerful: small change in α gives a big change in R_s |
| Retention \( k_B \) | solvent strength (HPLC) or temperature (GC) | helps up to k of about 5 to 10, then little further gain and much longer runs |
The general elution problem
A sample with components spanning a wide range of k gives early peaks crowded together and late peaks broad and flat. The fix is to change conditions during the run:
- GC: temperature programming (raise column temperature during the run).
- HPLC: gradient elution (increase the strength of the mobile phase during the run).
3. Planar Chromatography: Paper and TLC
- Paper chromatography is partition chromatography: the stationary phase is water held by cellulose, the mobile phase an organic solvent mixture.
- Thin-layer chromatography (TLC) on silica gel or alumina is mainly adsorption chromatography. Polar compounds adsorb strongly on silica and have low R_f; a more polar eluent raises all R_f values.
- Two-dimensional development (second solvent at right angles) resolves mixtures such as amino acids that one solvent cannot.
- Colourless spots are located with UV (fluorescent indicator in the layer), iodine vapour or a spray reagent (ninhydrin for amino acids).
R_f depends on the layer, the solvent, temperature and chamber saturation, so identification needs a standard run on the same plate.
4. Gas Chromatography (GC)
Mobile phase: an inert carrier gas (He, N₂, H₂). Stationary phase: a high-boiling liquid (for example a polysiloxane) coated on the inner wall of a fused-silica capillary or on a packed support. The sample must be volatile and thermally stable, or made so by derivatisation (silylation, methylation).
Detectors
| Detector | Principle | Responds to | Does not respond (or responds weakly) to |
|---|---|---|---|
| TCD (thermal conductivity) | analyte changes thermal conductivity of carrier gas | universal; non-destructive | low sensitivity |
| FID (flame ionisation) | organic carbon burnt in H₂/air flame gives ions; current measured | organic compounds with C–H bonds; very sensitive, wide linear range | H₂O, CO₂, CO, N₂, O₂, noble gases; carbonyl and halogenated carbons respond less |
| ECD (electron capture) | β-source (⁶³Ni) ionises carrier; electronegative analyte captures electrons, current drops | halogenated compounds, nitro compounds, conjugated carbonyls (pesticides, PCBs) | hydrocarbons, alcohols |
| NPD / thermionic | alkali-salt bead | N- and P-containing compounds | hydrocarbons |
| FPD (flame photometric) | emission from S and P species in a flame | S and P compounds | most others |
| MS | mass spectrometer | universal with structural identity | — |
Retention index
Retention times change between instruments, so GC identities are reported as Kovats retention indices, which place a compound on a scale defined by n-alkanes (each n-alkane has I = 100 × carbon number). Under isothermal conditions, for a compound eluting between alkanes with n and n + 1 carbons:
$$I = 100\left[n + \frac{\log t'_{R,x} - \log t'_{R,n}}{\log t'_{R,n+1} - \log t'_{R,n}}\right]$$Example: adjusted retention times n-octane 4.00 min, n-nonane 8.00 min, unknown 5.66 min. \( I = 100[8 + \log(5.66/4.00)/\log 2] = 100(8 + 0.500) = 850 \).
5. Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)
| Mode | Stationary phase | Mobile phase | Elution order | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal phase | polar (silica, alumina, bonded –CN, –NH₂) | non-polar (hexane with a little polar modifier) | least polar first | isomers, lipids |
| Reversed phase | non-polar (C18 or C8 bonded silica) | polar (water with methanol or acetonitrile) | most polar first | most organic and pharmaceutical analysis |
| Ion exchange | charged resin | aqueous buffer | weakly bound ions first | inorganic ions, amino acids |
| Size exclusion (gel permeation / gel filtration) | porous gel | any solvent that dissolves the sample | largest first | polymer molar mass distribution, proteins |
| Affinity | immobilised specific ligand | buffer, then eluting agent | non-binders first | enzymes, antibodies |
In reversed phase, adding more organic solvent makes the mobile phase stronger: retention of every component falls. In normal phase, adding a more polar modifier does the same. The order of eluting strength on silica (the eluotropic series) runs roughly pentane < CCl₄ < toluene < CH₂Cl₂ < diethyl ether < ethyl acetate ≈ acetone ≈ acetonitrile < methanol < water.
Size exclusion is the only mode where retention does not depend on chemical interaction. Molecules larger than the largest pores are fully excluded and elute together at the void volume; molecules small enough to enter every pore elute together at the total permeation volume; in between, elution volume falls roughly linearly with log(molar mass), which is how a column is calibrated with standards.
HPLC detectors: UV–visible (most common, needs a chromophore), fluorescence (very sensitive, selective), refractive index (universal but insensitive and unusable with gradients), conductivity (ions), electrochemical, and mass spectrometric.
6. Ion Exchange
Resins
| Type | Functional group | Exchanges | Works over |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strong-acid cation | –SO₃⁻H⁺ | cations | almost all pH |
| Weak-acid cation | –COO⁻H⁺ | cations | only where –COOH is ionised (higher pH) |
| Strong-base anion | –CH₂N(CH₃)₃⁺OH⁻ (quaternary ammonium) | anions | almost all pH |
| Weak-base anion | –NH₂, –NHR (protonated) | anions | only where the amine is protonated (lower pH) |
Most are cross-linked polystyrene–divinylbenzene. Capacity is quoted in milliequivalents per gram of dry resin.
$$\text{R–SO}_3^-\text{H}^+ + \text{Na}^+ \rightleftharpoons \text{R–SO}_3^-\text{Na}^+ + \text{H}^+$$Selectivity rules
- Higher charge binds more strongly: \( \text{Th}^{4+} > \text{La}^{3+} > \text{Ca}^{2+} > \text{Na}^+ \).
- Same charge: the ion with the smaller hydrated radius binds more strongly. For the alkali metals the bare-ion order is reversed by hydration: \( \text{Cs}^+ > \text{Rb}^+ > \text{K}^+ > \text{Na}^+ > \text{Li}^+ \). Likewise \( \text{Ba}^{2+} > \text{Sr}^{2+} > \text{Ca}^{2+} > \text{Mg}^{2+} \).
- For anions on a strong-base resin, large polarisable, weakly hydrated anions bind more strongly: \( \text{I}^- > \text{Br}^- > \text{Cl}^- > \text{F}^- \).
- Dilute solutions favour the more highly charged ion (electroselectivity); concentrated solutions reduce this preference, which is why concentrated acid or brine regenerates a resin.
Classic separations
- Lanthanides on a cation exchanger eluted with a complexing agent (citrate, EDTA, α-hydroxyisobutyrate): the ions differ little in their affinity for the resin, but complex strength with the eluent increases from La to Lu as the ionic radius contracts. The heaviest lanthanide forms the strongest complex and leaves the resin first: Lu elutes first, La last. (See the lanthanide contraction in your inner-transition chemistry.)
- Transition metals on an anion exchanger from concentrated HCl: metals that form anionic chloro-complexes (CoCl₄²⁻, FeCl₄⁻, ZnCl₄²⁻) are held; Ni²⁺, which does not form a stable anionic chloro-complex, passes straight through. Lowering the HCl concentration step by step then releases Co, then Fe, with Zn held longest.
- Deionisation: water through H⁺-form cation and OH⁻-form anion resins (or a mixed bed) loses all ions as H⁺ + OH⁻ → H₂O.
- Ion chromatography: anions separated on a low-capacity anion column with a carbonate or hydroxide eluent, followed by a suppressor that converts the eluent to weakly conducting H₂CO₃ or water, so that the analyte ions can be detected by conductivity.
7. Electrophoresis in Brief
Charged species migrate in an electric field with velocity \( v = \mu E \), where μ is the electrophoretic mobility (roughly charge divided by size). In capillary zone electrophoresis a fused-silica capillary has ionised silanol groups; the cation layer at the wall drags the bulk solution towards the cathode (electro-osmotic flow, EOF), usually faster than any ion’s own migration. All species therefore reach a detector at the cathode end, in the order:
cations (fastest first, small and highly charged) → neutrals (all together, at the EOF velocity) → anions (largest mobility last).
Neutral molecules are not separated in plain CZE; adding a surfactant above its CMC (micellar electrokinetic chromatography) separates them by partition into the micelles.
8. Other Separations Worth Knowing
| Method | Basis | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Precipitation with organic reagents | selective insoluble chelates | dimethylglyoxime gives red Ni(dmg)₂ in ammoniacal solution; oxine precipitates Al³⁺ and Mg²⁺ at different pH |
| Masking | keeps an ion in solution as a soluble complex | cyanide masks Cu, Zn, Ni in EDTA titrations; fluoride masks Fe³⁺ and Al³⁺ |
| Distillation / volatilisation | volatile species | NH₃ in Kjeldahl analysis; As as AsCl₃; Os and Ru as tetroxides |
| Solid-phase extraction | small sorbent cartridges | pre-concentration of trace organics from water |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Partition coefficient \( K_D \): one species, constant | distribution ratio D: all forms, changes with pH and ligands | |
| Retention factor \( k = (t_R - t_M)/t_M \) | retardation factor \( R_f \) (planar, distance ratio, 0 to 1) | |
| Selectivity α (ratio of k values) | resolution R_s (includes peak widths) | |
| N from baseline width: factor 16 | N from half-height width: factor 5.54 | |
| Normal phase: polar stationary, polar elutes last | reversed phase: non-polar stationary, polar elutes first | |
| FID: blind to water and CO₂ | TCD: universal, less sensitive | |
| ECD: halogenated, nitro compounds | FPD: sulfur and phosphorus | |
| Cation exchanger: smaller hydrated ion binds more (Cs⁺ > Li⁺) | gas-phase intuition that the smaller bare ion should bind more | |
| Size exclusion: no chemical interaction, largest first | adsorption: retention by surface binding |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- State the difference between the partition coefficient and the distribution ratio.
- In size-exclusion chromatography, which elutes first: a protein of 150 kDa or one of 15 kDa?
- Write the van Deemter equation and say which term is absent in an open tubular column.
Answers
- \( K_D \) is the concentration ratio of a single species between the phases; D is the ratio of total analytical concentrations, summed over all forms (ionised, complexed), and changes with pH and ligand concentration.
- The 150 kDa protein. Larger molecules enter fewer pores and travel the shorter path.
- \( H = A + B/u + Cu \). The A (eddy diffusion, multiple path) term is absent because there is no packing.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A solute has D = 5 between ether and water. 100 mL of its aqueous solution is extracted three times with 20 mL portions of ether. The percentage extracted is:
(a) 75.0 (b) 83.3 (c) 87.5 (d) 96.3
Answer: (c) 87.5
\( q_3 = [100/(100 + 5 \times 20)]^3 = (0.5)^3 = 0.125 \), so 87.5% is extracted. Option (a) is the result of a single 60 mL extraction: \( 100/(100 + 300) = 0.25 \) remaining. Option (b) is a single extraction with 100 mL of ether, \( 100D/(D+1) = 83.3\% \).
Practice Q2. A peak has a retention time of 5.0 min and a baseline width of 0.25 min on a 25 cm column. The plate height is closest to:
(a) 3.9 μm (b) 39 μm (c) 0.39 mm (d) 64 μm
Answer: (b) 39 μm
\( N = 16(5.0/0.25)^2 = 6400 \). \( H = L/N = 25\ \text{cm}/6400 = 3.9 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{cm} = 39\ \mu\text{m} \). Options (a) and (c) are unit slips by a factor of ten.
Practice Q3. A mixture of La³⁺, Eu³⁺ and Lu³⁺ is loaded on a strong-acid cation-exchange column and eluted with ammonium α-hydroxyisobutyrate. The order of elution is:
(a) La, Eu, Lu (b) Lu, Eu, La (c) Eu, La, Lu (d) all three together, since they have the same charge
Answer: (b) Lu, Eu, La
Complex stability with the eluent rises across the series as the ionic radius falls (lanthanide contraction). The most strongly complexed ion, Lu³⁺, spends the most time in the mobile phase and elutes first; La³⁺ elutes last. Option (d) ignores the role of the complexing eluent.
Practice Q4. The most suitable GC detector for trace chlorinated pesticides in a hydrocarbon-rich soil extract is:
(a) thermal conductivity (b) flame ionisation (c) electron capture (d) refractive index
Answer: (c) electron capture
The ECD is highly sensitive to electronegative, halogen-containing compounds and almost blind to hydrocarbons, so the matrix does not swamp the signal. FID would respond strongly to the hydrocarbons; TCD is too insensitive; RI is an HPLC detector.
Practice Q5. On a C18 reversed-phase column with methanol–water mobile phase, which change shortens the retention time of a neutral aromatic analyte?
(a) increasing the water content (b) increasing the methanol content (c) changing to a silica column with the same mobile phase (d) lowering the flow rate
Answer: (b)
More organic solvent makes the mobile phase more like the non-polar stationary phase, so the analyte partitions more into the mobile phase and k falls. (a) does the opposite; (d) lengthens all retention times without changing k.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q6. A metal ion Mⁿ⁺ is extracted into chloroform by a chelating agent HL held at 0.010 M in the organic phase (equal phase volumes). The measured distribution ratios are log D = −1.0 at pH 2.0 and log D = +1.0 at pH 3.0. Which statements are correct?
- The metal ion is divalent.
- log K_ex = −1.0.
- pH₁/₂ is 2.5 at this reagent concentration.
- Raising [HL]_org to 0.10 M moves pH₁/₂ to 3.5.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
\( \log D = \log K_{ex} + n\log[\text{HL}]_{org} + n\,\text{pH} \).
- Slope: \( (1.0 - (-1.0))/(3.0 - 2.0) = 2 \), so n = 2: statement 1 true.
- At pH 2.0: \( -1.0 = \log K_{ex} + 2(-2) + 2(2.0) \), so \( \log K_{ex} = -1.0 \): statement 2 true.
- pH₁/₂ (log D = 0): \( 0 = -1.0 - 4 + 2\,\text{pH} \), pH = 2.5: statement 3 true.
- With [HL] = 0.10 M, log[HL] = −1: \( 0 = -1.0 - 2 + 2\,\text{pH} \), pH₁/₂ = 1.5. More reagent lowers pH₁/₂ by one unit: statement 4 false.
Practice Q7. For a packed GC column the van Deemter constants are A = 0.08 mm, B = 0.60 mm cm s⁻¹ and C = 0.15 mm s cm⁻¹. Which pair gives the optimum linear velocity and the minimum plate height?
(a) 2.0 cm s⁻¹, 0.68 mm (b) 4.0 cm s⁻¹, 0.38 mm (c) 2.0 cm s⁻¹, 0.38 mm (d) 0.5 cm s⁻¹, 0.68 mm
Answer: (a)
\( u_{opt} = \sqrt{B/C} = \sqrt{0.60/0.15} = \sqrt{4} = 2.0 \) cm s⁻¹.
\( H_{min} = A + 2\sqrt{BC} = 0.08 + 2\sqrt{0.09} = 0.08 + 0.60 = 0.68 \) mm.
Check by substitution: \( H(2.0) = 0.08 + 0.60/2.0 + 0.15 \times 2.0 = 0.08 + 0.30 + 0.30 = 0.68 \) mm. At the optimum the B and C terms are equal. Option (b) takes u = B/C, forgetting the square root (at 4.0 cm s⁻¹ the true H would be 0.83 mm); option (c) has the right velocity but drops one of the two equal terms (0.08 + 0.30); option (d) inverts the ratio, \( \sqrt{C/B} = 0.5 \).
Practice Q8. Two compounds give R_s = 1.0 on a 15 cm HPLC column. Assume H, α and k do not change when the column is lengthened. Which statements are correct?
- A 30 cm column gives R_s = 2.0.
- About 34 cm of column is needed for R_s = 1.5.
- On the longer column the analysis takes proportionally longer.
- Changing the mobile phase to raise α from 1.05 to 1.10 nearly doubles R_s at constant N and k.
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 2, 3 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 2, 3 and 4 only
- \( R_s \propto \sqrt{N} \propto \sqrt{L} \). Doubling L gives \( \sqrt{2} \times 1.0 = 1.41 \), not 2.0: statement 1 false.
- For R_s = 1.5: \( L = 15 \times (1.5/1.0)^2 = 15 \times 2.25 = 33.75 \) cm, about 34 cm: statement 2 true.
- Retention time scales with L at the same flow velocity: statement 3 true.
- The selectivity term \( (\alpha - 1)/\alpha \) goes from 0.05/1.05 = 0.0476 to 0.10/1.10 = 0.0909, a factor of 1.91: statement 4 true. This is why selectivity is the cheapest lever.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Formula or fact |
|---|---|
| Distribution ratio | D = C_org/C_aq (all forms); K_D for one species |
| Repeated extraction | \( q_n = [V_{aq}/(V_{aq} + DV_{org})]^n \); %E = 100D/(D + V_aq/V_org) |
| Weak acid | D = K_D[H⁺]/([H⁺] + K_a) |
| Metal chelate | log D = log K_ex + n log[HL] + n pH; slope n; pH₁/₂ falls 1 unit per tenfold HL |
| Retention | k = (t_R − t_M)/t_M; α = k_B/k_A; R_f = spot/front |
| Efficiency | N = 16(t_R/W)² = 5.54(t_R/W₁/₂)²; H = L/N |
| van Deemter | H = A + B/u + Cu; u_opt = √(B/C); H_min = A + 2√(BC) |
| Resolution | R_s = 2Δt_R/(W_A + W_B); 1.5 = baseline; R_s ∝ √N, (α − 1)/α, k/(1 + k) |
| GC detectors | TCD universal; FID organics, blind to H₂O/CO₂; ECD halogens; FPD S, P; NPD N, P |
| Kovats index | n-alkane = 100 × C number; log interpolation of adjusted t_R |
| HPLC modes | normal: polar last; reversed: polar first; SEC: largest first |
| Ion exchange | higher charge binds more; same charge: Cs⁺ > K⁺ > Na⁺ > Li⁺; I⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > F⁻ |
| Lanthanides | complexing eluent on cation exchanger: Lu first, La last |
| CZE | EOF to cathode; cations, then neutrals, then anions |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Spectroscopic Methods of Analysis: Beer–Lambert, AAS, emission and fluorescence, which supply most chromatographic detectors.
- Electroanalytical Methods: potentiometry, conductometry, coulometry and voltammetry.
- Liquid NH₃, HF and acetic acid as media: Non-aqueous Solvents.
- Chapter overview: Analytical Chemistry.