Skip to content

Aromaticity Formula Sheet and Short Notes

One-page CSIR NET revision: aromaticity criteria, π counting, benzenoid arenes, aromatic ions, annulenes, azulene and fulvenes, with generation and reactions.

  • 5 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 5 sections
  1. Criteria and counting
  2. Benzenoid compounds
  3. Non-benzenoid aromatic ions
  4. Annulenes, azulene, fulvenes
  5. Where to next

Every rule, number and trap from Aromaticity Criteria, Benzenoid Aromatic Compounds, Non-benzenoid Aromatic Ions and Annulenes, Azulene and Fulvenes, on one page.

Criteria and counting

  • Aromatic: cyclic, planar, fully conjugated, \( 4n + 2 \) π electrons (2, 6, 10, 14, 18).
  • Antiaromatic: cyclic, planar, conjugated, \( 4n \) (4, 8, 12, 16): destabilised, paratropic, bond-alternating.
  • Non-aromatic: non-planar (COT tub, [10]annulene) or interrupted by sp³ carbon (cyclopentadiene).
  • Origin: Frost circle has one low MO, then degenerate pairs → closed shells at \( 4n + 2 \).
Atom typeπ electrons
ring C=C carbon1
carbanion C / carbocation C / radical C2 / 0 / 1
pyrrole N, furan O, thiophene S2 (one lone pair only)
pyridine N1 (lone pair in plane)
C bearing exocyclic C=O (tropone, cyclopropenone)0 (C⁺–O⁻)
CriterionAromatic signature
EnergeticRE = \( 3(-119.7) - (-208.4) \approx 151 \) kJ mol⁻¹ (36 kcal mol⁻¹); benzene → 1,3-diene +23.4 kJ mol⁻¹
Structuralequal bonds (benzene 1.39–1.40 Å); HOMA near 1
Magneticdiatropic: outer H downfield, inner H upfield; NICS negative; susceptibility exaltation
Reactivitysubstitution rather than addition (least reliable)
  • Homoaromatic: homotropylium C₈H₉⁺ (COT + H₂SO₄), CH₂ protons δ about 5.1 and −0.7.
  • Möbius: one phase inversion → \( 4n \) aromatic. Baird: T₁ state → \( 4n \) aromatic, \( 4n + 2 \) antiaromatic. Hirsch: spherical \( 2(N+1)^2 \).
  • \( 4n + 2 \) is for monocycles: pyrene (16 π) is aromatic.

Benzenoid compounds

AreneKekuléClar sextetsKey bond (fraction double)Classical RE (kcal mol⁻¹)
Benzene211/2about 36
Naphthalene31C1–C2 2/3about 61
Anthracene41C1–C2 3/4; C9–C9a 1/2about 84
Phenanthrene52C9–C10 4/5about 92
Pyrene / triphenylene6 / 92 / 3
  • Hückel DE: benzene \( 2\beta \), naphthalene \( 3.683\beta \), anthracene \( 5.314\beta \), phenanthrene \( 5.448\beta \).
  • Benzene MOs (D₆h): \( a_{2u} < e_{1g} \) (HOMO) \( < e_{2u} \) (LUMO) \( < b_{2g} \). Valence isomers: Dewar benzene, benzvalene, prismane.
  • o-Xylene ozonolysis: glyoxal : methylglyoxal : biacetyl = 3 : 2 : 1. Mesitylene gives only methylglyoxal.
  • Generation: alkyne cyclotrimerisation (Ni, CpCo); dehydrogenation (Pd/C, S, Se, DDQ); Haworth (succinic anhydride, Clemmensen, cyclise, Clemmensen, dehydrogenate); phthalic anhydride → anthraquinone → anthracene; Elbs; Pschorr; Bardhan–Sengupta; Mallory photocyclisation.
  • Benzene: SEAr via arenium ion; Birch → 1,4-diene (donor on C=C, acceptor on CH); side-chain oxidation needs benzylic H.
  • Naphthalene: C1 kinetic; sulfonation about 80 °C → 1-, about 160 °C → 2-; acylation CS₂ → 1-, nitrobenzene → 2-; 2-naphthol couples at C1; deactivated → other ring (5, 8); V₂O₅/air → phthalic anhydride; CrO₃ → 1,4-naphthoquinone.
  • Anthracene: C9/C10: Diels–Alder, Br₂ addition, anthraquinone, [4 + 4] photodimer, benzyne → triptycene.
  • Phenanthrene: C9–C10: Br₂ addition, 9,10-phenanthrenequinone, ozonolysis → diphenic acid derivatives.

Non-benzenoid aromatic ions

RingAromaticAntiaromatic
C₃C₃H₃⁺ (2π)C₃H₃⁻ (4π)
C₄C₄H₄²⁺ (2π)C₄H₄ (4π)
C₅C₅H₅⁻ (6π)C₅H₅⁺ (4π, triplet)
C₇C₇H₇⁺ (6π)C₇H₇⁻ (8π)
C₈C₈H₈²⁻ (10π)planar C₈H₈ (8π)

Hückel DE: C₃H₃⁺ \( 2\beta \); C₅H₅⁻ \( 2.472\beta \); C₇H₇⁺ \( 2.988\beta \); COT²⁻ \( 1.657\beta \); cyclobutadiene 0.

SpeciesGenerationReactions
TriphenylcyclopropeniumBreslow: phenyldiazoacetonitrile + diphenylacetylene, then BF₃/H₂O; or 3-X-cyclopropene + Lewis acidNu⁻ adds → 3-substituted cyclopropene
Diphenylcyclopropenoneα,α′-dibromodibenzyl ketone + Et₃N−CO (hν) → diphenylacetylene; O-protonation
Cyclobutadiene(C₄H₄)Fe(CO)₃ from 3,4-dichlorocyclobutene + Fe₂(CO)₉, then Ce(IV) (Pettit); photo-α-pyrone in Ar at about 8 KDiels–Alder trapping (alkyne → Dewar benzene), dimerisation
C₅H₅⁻crack dicyclopentadiene; NaH, BuLialkylation; Thiele fulvenes; FeCl₂ → ferrocene
Ferroceneacylation (1,1′-diacetyl), Vilsmeier, Mannich, lithiation; no direct nitration/halogenation
C₇H₇⁺Br₂ then heat (Doering–Knox); Ph₃C⁺ BF₄⁻ (Dauben)Nu⁻ adds → 7-substituted cycloheptatriene; hydride acceptor
Tropolonedichloroketene + cyclopentadiene, then solvolysispKa about 7, chelates Fe(III)/Cu(II), phenol-like SEAr
COT²⁻COT + 2 KUCl₄ → uranocene
C₈H₉⁺COT + H₂SO₄ / FSO₃Hhomoaromatic NMR
  • pKa (approximate, aqueous scale): cyclopentadiene about 16; cycloheptatriene about 36–39; cyclopentane about 50. DMSO: CpH 18.0 > indene 20.1 > fluorene 22.6.
  • \( \Delta pK_a = 20 \) → \( \Delta\Delta G^\circ = 2.303RT \times 20 \approx 114 \) kJ mol⁻¹ at 298 K.
  • Tropylium: δ about 9.2 (7H singlet); \( pK_{R^+} \approx 4.7 \); \( \log([\text{R}^+]/[\text{ROH}]) = pK_{R^+} - \text{pH} \).
  • Tropone: basic (hydroxytropylium in acid), polar, [6 + 4] with cyclopentadiene.

Annulenes, azulene, fulvenes

AnnuleneVerdictEvidence
[8]non-aromatictub
[10]non-aromaticangle strain or inner-H clash
1,6-methano[10]aromaticring H δ about 7, CH₂ about −0.5
[14]; dimethyldihydropyrenearomaticCH₃ about δ −4.2 in the dihydropyrene
[16]antiaromaticinner H downfield; dianion (18π) diatropic
[18]aromaticouter about 9.3, inner about −3.0 (low T); shifts converge on warming
  • Sondheimer: 1,5-hexadiyne → Cu(OAc)₂/pyridine (cyclic trimer) → KOtBu → partial H₂ → [18]annulene.
  • Vogel: naphthalene → Birch (isotetralin) → :CCl₂ → Na/NH₃ → Br₂, base → 1,6-methano[10]annulene.
  • Azulene: blue, about 1 D (five-ring negative), DE \( 3.364\beta \) (naphthalene \( 3.683\beta \)), S₂ fluorescence (anti-Kasha), non-alternant. E⁺ at C1/C3; H⁺ at C1 (azulenium); Nu⁻ at C4/C6/C8; heat → naphthalene. Syntheses: Ziegler–Hafner, Pfau–Plattner, sesquiterpene dehydrogenation.
  • Fulvenes: Thiele (CpH + R₂C=O + base). Pentafulvene ring⁻/C6⁺: RLi adds at C6 → substituted Cp⁻. Triafulvene and heptafulvene: ring⁺; 8,8-dicyanoheptafulvene stable.
  • Fulvalenes: calicene (3⁺/5⁻) and sesquifulvalene (7⁺/5⁻) strongly polar.
  • Pentalene 8π antiaromatic; dianion 10π aromatic. Heptalene 12π non-planar polyene.

Where to next

Back to the chapter overview, the orbital background in Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems, or the metal side of Cp and COT ligands in Alkyl, Carbene and π Complexes.

Advertisement
Advertisement