Enantiomeric and Diastereomeric Excess
CSIR NET asymmetric synthesis: ee, er, de, dr, optical purity, specific rotation, ΔΔG‡ and temperature, mixing samples, Horeau duplication.
- 18 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Stereogenicity, Chirality and Configurational Isomerism: enantiomers, diastereomers, R/S and specific rotation.
- Stereospecific and Stereoselective Reactions: the vocabulary of enantio- and diastereoselectivity, which this page turns into numbers.
- Rate Laws and Temperature Dependence and Collision and Transition-State Theory: the Eyring equation behind \( \Delta\Delta G^\ddagger \).
The Hook: “92% ee” on a Bottle Label
Four Ways to State Stereochemical Purity
For a mixture of two enantiomers present as mole fractions \( x_R \) and \( x_S \) (with \( x_R + x_S = 1 \)):
$$\text{ee} = \frac{|x_R - x_S|}{x_R + x_S} \times 100\%, \qquad \text{er} = \frac{x_{\text{major}}}{x_{\text{minor}}}$$For two diastereomers A and B, the same formulas define the diastereomeric excess (de) and the diastereomeric ratio (dr).
The conversions between the two forms follow directly. Write the major fraction as \( x \):
$$\text{ee} = 2x - 1, \qquad x = \frac{1+\text{ee}}{2}, \qquad \text{er} = \frac{1+\text{ee}}{1-\text{ee}}, \qquad \text{ee} = \frac{\text{er}-1}{\text{er}+1}$$| Major : minor | er | ee (or de) | What the sample contains |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50 : 50 | 1 | 0% | racemate (or 1:1 diastereomers) |
| 75 : 25 | 3 | 50% | half the sample is “excess” enantiomer, the rest is racemate |
| 90 : 10 | 9 | 80% | 80% pure enantiomer + 20% racemate |
| 95 : 5 | 19 | 90% | the most common “good” result in method papers |
| 98 : 2 | 49 | 96% | |
| 99 : 1 | 99 | 98% | |
| 99.5 : 0.5 | 199 | 99% |
Which number to use
- ee and de are traditional and appear in most exam questions.
- er and dr are increasingly preferred in research papers because they are directly proportional to rate ratios (and so to \( e^{\Delta\Delta G^\ddagger/RT} \)) and they add no confusion near 100%. 99% ee and 99.9% ee look similar; 199:1 and 1999:1 do not.
- de is defined only for a pair of diastereomers. When a reaction can give more than two diastereomers, papers report a ratio such as 85:10:5 rather than a single de.
Diastereomeric and enantiomeric excess in the same reaction
A reaction that forms two new stereocentres can give up to four stereoisomers: two diastereomers (for example syn and anti), each as a pair of enantiomers. The selectivity then needs two numbers: the dr (syn : anti) and the ee of each diastereomer.
Optical Purity and Specific Rotation
Specific rotation
$$[\alpha]_\lambda^{T} = \frac{\alpha_{\text{obs}}}{l \cdot c}$$with \( \alpha_{\text{obs}} \) in degrees, path length \( l \) in decimetres and concentration \( c \) in g mL⁻¹ (for a neat liquid, c is the density). The wavelength (usually the sodium D line, 589 nm), the temperature, the solvent and the concentration must all be quoted, because \( [\alpha] \) can change with each, and can even change sign with solvent.
Optical purity
$$\text{optical purity (op)} = \frac{[\alpha]_{\text{sample}}}{[\alpha]_{\text{pure enantiomer}}} \times 100\%$$For most compounds the rotation is a linear function of composition, and op = ee. That is why the two terms are often used as synonyms. They are not identical by definition:
- op is a measured quantity, reliable only if \( [\alpha]_{\max} \) is known accurately for the same solvent, temperature, wavelength and concentration.
- ee is a composition. It is now measured directly (chiral HPLC or GC, NMR with chiral additives), which needs no reference rotation.
- Deviations from linearity are known (the Horeau effect): when the enantiomers associate in solution (for example through hydrogen-bonded dimers), the homochiral and heterochiral aggregates rotate light differently, and op is no longer equal to ee. Small chiral impurities with large rotations also distort op.
Composition from rotation
Methods that measure ee directly
| Method | Principle | What you read |
|---|---|---|
| Chiral HPLC / GC / SFC | the enantiomers form diastereomeric complexes with a chiral stationary phase and elute at different times | ratio of peak areas |
| NMR with a chiral solvating agent or lanthanide shift reagent | fast-exchanging diastereomeric complexes give separate signals | ratio of integrals |
| NMR after derivatisation with an enantiopure agent (Mosher’s acid) | covalent diastereomers with different chemical shifts | ratio of integrals = dr of the derivatives |
| Polarimetry | rotation proportional to ee (if linear) | op |
| Circular dichroism | differential absorption of left and right circularly polarised light | intensity relative to a pure standard |
The physical basis of each method is the subject of the next page, Enantio-discrimination.
From Selectivity to Energy
When two stereoisomeric products are formed through competing transition states under kinetic control (irreversible, no interconversion of products), the product ratio equals the ratio of rate constants, and transition-state theory gives
$$\text{er (or dr)} = \frac{k_{\text{major}}}{k_{\text{minor}}} = \exp\left(\frac{\Delta\Delta G^\ddagger}{RT}\right), \qquad \Delta\Delta G^\ddagger = RT\ln(\text{er})$$With R = 8.314 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹:
| ee | er | ΔΔG‡ at 298 K (kJ mol⁻¹) | ΔΔG‡ at 195 K, −78 °C (kJ mol⁻¹) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50% | 3 | 2.7 | 1.8 |
| 80% | 9 | 5.4 | 3.6 |
| 90% | 19 | 7.3 | 4.8 |
| 95% | 39 | 9.1 | 5.9 |
| 98% | 99 | 11.4 | 7.5 |
| 99% | 199 | 13.1 | 8.6 |
- At 298 K, \( RT\ln 10 = 5.7 \) kJ mol⁻¹: every 5.7 kJ mol⁻¹ multiplies er by 10.
- At 195 K, \( RT\ln 10 = 3.7 \) kJ mol⁻¹: the same ΔΔG‡ buys a much larger er when cold.
- The ee depends on \( \Delta\Delta G^\ddagger \) only, not on the absolute barrier; a fast reaction can be very selective.
Temperature
Write \( \Delta\Delta G^\ddagger = \Delta\Delta H^\ddagger - T\Delta\Delta S^\ddagger \). Then
$$\ln(\text{er}) = \frac{\Delta\Delta H^\ddagger}{RT} - \frac{\Delta\Delta S^\ddagger}{R}$$- If the selectivity is enthalpy-controlled (\( \Delta\Delta S^\ddagger \approx 0 \)), ln(er) is proportional to 1/T and cooling raises er. This is the usual case and the reason so many asymmetric reactions are run at −78 °C.
- If \( \Delta\Delta H^\ddagger \) and \( T\Delta\Delta S^\ddagger \) oppose each other, a plot of ln(er) against 1/T can pass through zero: at that temperature (sometimes called the isoinversion or isoenantioselective temperature) the selectivity vanishes and on the other side the opposite isomer is favoured. Measuring er at several temperatures (an Eyring plot of ln er against 1/T) separates the two terms: slope \( \Delta\Delta H^\ddagger/R \), intercept \( -\Delta\Delta S^\ddagger/R \).
Kinetic versus thermodynamic control
- Enantiomers have identical free energies in an achiral environment, so thermodynamic equilibration always gives ee = 0. An ee can come only from kinetic control or from an equilibrium in a chiral environment (for example a chiral host or a crystallisation that removes one enantiomer).
- Diastereomers differ in free energy, so an equilibrium mixture has a non-zero de: \( \text{dr} = e^{-\Delta G^\circ/RT} \). Epimerisation at an enolisable stereocentre is often used deliberately to convert a kinetic dr into the thermodynamic one.
Manipulating ee: Mixing, Coupling and Upgrading
Mixing samples
ee is a weighted average by amount of substance, not a simple average of the numbers.
$$\text{ee}_{\text{mix}} = \frac{\sum_i n_i\,\text{ee}_i}{\sum_i n_i}$$with ee taken as positive for one enantiomer and negative for the other.
- 1.0 g of 90% ee (R) + 0.5 g of racemate: ee = (0.90 × 1.0 + 0 × 0.5)/1.5 = 60% (R).
- 1.0 mmol of 80% ee (R) + 1.0 mmol of 60% ee (S): ee = (0.80 − 0.60)/2 = 10% (R).
Two sequential selective steps
If a sample of ee \( e_1 \) is converted with complete stereospecificity, the ee is unchanged. If an enantiopure reagent of ee \( e_2 \) is used to make a derivative, the observed de of the derivative is \( e_1 e_2 \), not \( e_1 \) (the four diastereomers pair up as enantiomers, which are indistinguishable by NMR). This trap is worked through on the Enantio-discrimination page.
The duplication (Horeau) principle
When a sample of modest ee is coupled with itself to form a dimer with two identical stereocentres (or when two equivalents of a chiral unit are joined), statistics alone raise the ee of the chiral dimer, because most of the minor enantiomer ends up in the achiral meso (R,S) form.
Let the monomer have ee \( e \), so fractions \( p = (1+e)/2 \) (R) and \( q = (1-e)/2 \) (S). With no stereochemical preference in the coupling:
| Dimer | Fraction | Chirality |
|---|---|---|
| R,R | \( p^2 \) | chiral |
| S,S | \( q^2 \) | chiral (enantiomer of R,R) |
| R,S | \( 2pq \) | meso, achiral |
For e = 80%, the chiral dimer has ee = 1.6/1.64 = 97.6%, at the cost of losing \( 2pq = 18\% \) of the material as the meso diastereomer, which is separable. The same statistics apply whenever two units of a non-racemic chiral building block (for example two terpene-derived ligands on one boron atom) end up in one molecule: the homochiral combination is enriched relative to the monomer, provided the heterochiral (meso-type) combination is removed.
Upgrading by crystallisation
- A sample that is not enantiopure can often be enriched by crystallisation, but the outcome depends on the solid-state behaviour of the racemate (see Optical and Kinetic Resolution). For a racemic compound (the usual case), the racemate crystallises preferentially from a sample whose composition lies on the racemic side of the eutectic, and the pure enantiomer crystallises only from a sample richer than the eutectic composition.
- Diastereomers are distinct compounds, so a de is upgraded by ordinary chromatography or crystallisation. This is the main practical advantage of the chiral auxiliary approach.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | Is not this |
|---|---|
| ee: excess of one enantiomer as a fraction of the total | er: ratio of the two enantiomers |
| Optical purity: measured rotation / rotation of the pure enantiomer | ee: actual composition (equal to op only if rotation is linear) |
| de: two diastereomers | a ratio of three or more stereoisomers (needs a full ratio) |
| Specific rotation \( [\alpha] \): property of the compound under stated conditions | Observed rotation \( \alpha \): depends on path length and concentration |
| (+)/(−): sign of rotation | R/S: configuration from CIP rules |
| Kinetic control: ratio set by ΔΔG‡ | Thermodynamic control: ratio set by ΔG° (zero for enantiomers) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not taken from any CSIR NET paper. Use R = 8.314 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.
Level 1: Foundation
- A mixture contains 0.40 g of the (R)-enantiomer and 0.10 g of the (S)-enantiomer. What is the ee?
- Convert 96% ee into an enantiomeric ratio.
- In \( [\alpha] = \alpha/(l\cdot c) \), what are the units of l and c?
Answers
- ee = (0.40 − 0.10)/0.50 = 60% (R).
- Major fraction = (1 + 0.96)/2 = 0.98, so er = 98:2 = 49:1.
- l in decimetres, c in g mL⁻¹.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A sample of a chiral alcohol has \( [\alpha]_D = -9.0 \) under conditions where the pure (S)-enantiomer has \( [\alpha]_D = -36.0 \). Assuming a linear dependence of rotation on composition, the sample contains
(a) 25% (S) and 75% (R) (b) 62.5% (S) and 37.5% (R) (c) 75% (S) and 25% (R) (d) 87.5% (S) and 12.5% (R)
Answer: (b)
Optical purity = 9.0/36.0 = 25%, so ee = 25% in favour of (S). Fraction (S) = (1 + 0.25)/2 = 0.625. Option (c) treats op as the major fraction.
Practice Q2. An enantioselective reaction at 298 K gives 98% ee. The difference in free energy between the two diastereomeric transition states is closest to
(a) 2.4 kJ mol⁻¹ (b) 5.7 kJ mol⁻¹ (c) 11.4 kJ mol⁻¹ (d) 22.8 kJ mol⁻¹
Answer: (c)
er = 99:1. \( \Delta\Delta G^\ddagger = RT\ln 99 = 8.314 \times 298 \times 4.595 = 11.4 \) kJ mol⁻¹. Option (b) is the energy for a factor of 10 only.
Practice Q3. Equal masses of two samples of the same compound are mixed: one has 70% ee (R), the other 30% ee (S). The ee of the mixture is
(a) 20% (R) (b) 40% (R) (c) 50% (R) (d) 0%
Answer: (a)
Weighted average with signs: (0.70 − 0.30)/2 = 0.20, i.e. 20% (R).
Practice Q4. Which statement is correct?
(a) Equilibrating a 90:10 mixture of enantiomers in an achiral solvent through a reversible achiral reaction gives a 90:10 mixture at equilibrium. (b) A 90:10 mixture of diastereomers can be separated by flash chromatography on silica, but a 90:10 mixture of enantiomers cannot. (c) Optical purity and enantiomeric excess are equal by definition for every compound. (d) A compound with \( [\alpha]_D > 0 \) has the R configuration.
Answer: (b)
(a) Equilibration of enantiomers gives the racemate. (c) They are equal only when rotation is linear in composition (the Horeau effect is an exception). (d) The sign of rotation is unrelated to R/S.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A catalytic asymmetric reduction gives 95% ee at −78 °C. The same reaction at 25 °C is to be predicted, assuming \( \Delta\Delta S^\ddagger = 0 \).
Which statements are correct?
- At −78 °C, \( \Delta\Delta G^\ddagger \approx 5.9 \) kJ mol⁻¹.
- At 25 °C the er is predicted to be about 11:1.
- At 25 °C the ee is predicted to be about 83%.
- If the measured ee at 25 °C were 95%, the selectivity would be entirely enthalpy-controlled.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. er = 39; \( 8.314 \times 195.15 \times \ln 39 = 5.94 \) kJ mol⁻¹.
- Correct. exp(5944/(8.314 × 298.15)) = 11.0.
- Correct. (11.0 − 1)/(11.0 + 1) = 0.833.
- Wrong. A temperature-independent ee means ln(er) does not change with 1/T, i.e. \( \Delta\Delta H^\ddagger \approx 0 \) and the selectivity is entropy-controlled, the opposite of statement 4.
Practice Q6. A chiral secondary alcohol of 80% ee is oxidatively coupled to a C₂-symmetric dimer with two identical stereocentres. Assume the coupling has no stereochemical preference and the meso dimer is removed completely by chromatography.
Which statements are correct?
- The fraction of the crude dimer that is meso is 18%.
- The isolated chiral dimer has an ee of about 97.6%.
- Starting from a monomer of 60% ee, the chiral dimer would have an ee of about 88%.
- The ee of the chiral dimer is always equal to the ee of the monomer, because no chiral reagent is used.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 4 only (c) 1 and 2 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
Fractions: p = 0.9, q = 0.1.
- Correct. Meso = 2pq = 2 × 0.9 × 0.1 = 0.18.
- Correct. (p² − q²)/(p² + q²) = (0.81 − 0.01)/0.82 = 0.976, or 2e/(1 + e²) = 1.6/1.64.
- Correct. 2 × 0.6/(1 + 0.36) = 0.882.
- Wrong. Statistical enrichment occurs because most of the minor enantiomer is diverted into the achiral meso form (the Horeau duplication principle).
Practice Q7. An aldol reaction gives a 90:10 ratio of syn : anti diastereomers. The syn diastereomer has 96% ee and the anti diastereomer is racemic. Which statements are correct?
- The most abundant stereoisomer makes up 88.2% of the mixture.
- The de of the crude product is 80%.
- After chromatographic removal of the anti diastereomer, the syn product has 96% ee.
- Recrystallisation from an achiral solvent can never change the ee of the syn product.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. 0.90 × 0.98 = 0.882.
- Correct. (90 − 10)/100 = 80%.
- Correct. Achiral chromatography removes the diastereomer but leaves the enantiomeric ratio of the syn fraction (98:2) unchanged.
- Wrong. Crystallisation of a non-racemic sample can raise (or lower) the ee of the crystals and the mother liquor, depending on the eutectic composition. The solvent need not be chiral, because the sample itself is non-racemic.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| ee | \( (x_R - x_S)/(x_R + x_S) \); = 2x − 1 |
| er | (1 + ee)/(1 − ee); 90% ee = 19:1; 99% ee = 199:1 |
| de, dr | same formulas for two diastereomers |
| Specific rotation | \( [\alpha] = \alpha/(l\,c) \), l in dm, c in g mL⁻¹; quote λ, T, solvent, c |
| Optical purity | \( [\alpha]_{\text{obs}}/[\alpha]_{\max} \); = ee only if linear (Horeau effect) |
| ΔΔG‡ | \( RT\ln(\text{er}) \); 5.7 kJ mol⁻¹ per factor 10 at 298 K, 3.7 at 195 K |
| Temperature | enthalpic selectivity rises on cooling; isoinversion if ΔΔH‡ and TΔΔS‡ cancel |
| Thermodynamic control | ee = 0 always; dr = \( e^{-\Delta G^\circ/RT} \) for diastereomers |
| Mixing | amount-weighted, signed average |
| Horeau duplication | dimer ee = 2e/(1 + e²); meso fraction 2pq |
| Purification | chromatography upgrades de, not ee; crystallisation can upgrade either |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Enantio-discrimination: how chiral environments tell enantiomers apart, and how that is used to measure ee.
- Substrate-, Reagent- and Catalyst-Controlled Induction: where the ΔΔG‡ comes from.
- Separation Methods: the chromatography behind chiral HPLC and GC.