Optical and Kinetic Resolution
CSIR NET asymmetric synthesis: conglomerates, diastereomeric salts, resolving agents, chiral chromatography, kinetic resolution s-factor, DKR, desymmetrisation.
- 16 min
On this page · 15 sections
Prerequisites
- Enantiomeric and Diastereomeric Excess: ee, er and ΔΔG‡.
- Enantio-discrimination: thermodynamic and kinetic discrimination by a chiral partner.
- Phase Equilibria and the Phase Rule: binary melting-point diagrams and eutectics.
- Rate Laws and Temperature Dependence: integrated first-order rate laws, used to derive the selectivity factor.
The Hook: Pasteur’s Tweezers
Optical Resolution: Overview
graph TD
R["Racemate"] --> M["Mechanical / spontaneous
conglomerates only
(Pasteur; preferential
crystallisation)"]
R --> D["Via diastereomers
salts or covalent
derivatives, then
crystallisation or
chromatography"]
R --> C["Chiral chromatography
HPLC, SFC, SMB"]
R --> K["Kinetic resolution
chemical or enzymatic
(max 50% each)"]
K --> DKR["Dynamic kinetic resolution
substrate racemises
(up to 100%)"]Two quantities describe any resolution: the yield of each enantiomer (at most 50% of the racemate for each, unless the unwanted one is racemised and recycled) and its ee.
Crystal Forms of Racemates
How a racemate crystallises decides which resolution methods are possible.
| Type | Solid state | Melting-point (binary phase) diagram | Consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conglomerate | a mechanical mixture of R crystals and S crystals | simple eutectic at the racemic composition; racemate melts below the pure enantiomers | spontaneous resolution and preferential crystallisation possible |
| Racemic compound (true racemate) | R and S in a 1:1 ratio in every unit cell | a maximum (or minimum) at 50:50 flanked by two eutectics | the most common case; needs a resolving agent or chiral chromatography |
| Pseudoracemate (solid solution) | R and S randomly mixed in one lattice | a smooth curve, little change in mp with composition | crystallisation cannot change the ee |
- Conglomerates are a minority of racemates; most crystallise as racemic compounds.
- Wallach’s rule (an empirical observation): racemic crystals tend to be denser than the corresponding enantiopure crystals, consistent with racemic compounds being the more common outcome.
- For a racemic compound, a non-racemic sample whose composition lies between the eutectic and the pure enantiomer can be upgraded by crystallisation; a sample on the racemic side of the eutectic deposits the racemic compound instead.
Spontaneous resolution and preferential crystallisation
- Spontaneous resolution: a conglomerate gives separate R and S crystals; if they are visibly different (hemihedral faces, as in Pasteur’s salt) they can be picked by hand. Impractical except as a demonstration.
- Preferential crystallisation (resolution by entrainment): a supersaturated solution of a conglomerate racemate is seeded with crystals of one enantiomer; that enantiomer crystallises first. Before the other one starts to crystallise, the crystals are filtered off. The mother liquor, now enriched in the other enantiomer, is topped up with racemate and seeded with the other enantiomer. Alternating cycles give both enantiomers. It is used industrially for some conglomerate-forming compounds because it needs no resolving agent.
- Attrition-enhanced deracemisation (Viedma ripening): for a conglomerate whose enantiomers interconvert in solution, grinding a slurry of crystals can convert the whole solid to one enantiomer.
Resolution via Diastereomers
The most widely used classical method. A racemate is combined with a single enantiomer of a resolving agent, giving two diastereomers with different solubilities, melting points and chromatographic behaviour.
$$(\pm)\text{-A} + (+)\text{-B} \longrightarrow (+)\text{-A}\cdot(+)\text{-B} \;+\; (-)\text{-A}\cdot(+)\text{-B}$$Diastereomeric salt formation
- React a racemic acid with an enantiopure base (or a racemic base with an enantiopure acid).
- Crystallise. The less soluble diastereomeric salt crystallises preferentially.
- Recrystallise to constant rotation (or constant ee by chiral HPLC).
- Liberate the resolved compound by acidification (for an acid) or basification (for a base), and recover the resolving agent.
| To resolve | Use an enantiopure | Common resolving agents |
|---|---|---|
| Racemic acids | base | brucine, strychnine, quinine, quinidine, cinchonine, cinchonidine, ephedrine, (R)- or (S)-1-phenylethylamine |
| Racemic bases (amines) | acid | (+)-tartaric acid, dibenzoyl- and di-p-toluoyltartaric acids, (+)-camphor-10-sulfonic acid, (R)- or (S)-mandelic acid, malic acid |
| Neutral compounds (alcohols, ketones) | covalent or derivatised partner | convert alcohols to half-esters (with phthalic or succinic anhydride) to create an acid handle; ketones via diastereomeric hydrazones, ketals or aminals made with an enantiopure partner |
- The choice of resolving agent and solvent is empirical; screening is standard.
- The yield of each enantiomer is at most 50% of the racemate. The mother liquor is enriched in the other enantiomer, which can be recovered (often with the opposite enantiomer of the resolving agent).
- Resolution–racemisation–recycle (RRR): if the unwanted enantiomer can be racemised (for example through an enolisable stereocentre), it is racemised and fed back. Ideally each cycle harvests half of what remains: after three ideal cycles 50 + 25 + 12.5 = 87.5% of the original material is converted to the desired enantiomer.
Covalent diastereomers
Racemic alcohols are esterified with an enantiopure acid (for example a menthyloxyacetic acid or camphanic acid), and racemic acids with an enantiopure alcohol or amine. The covalent diastereomers are separated by chromatography or crystallisation, then hydrolysed. More steps than salt formation, but applicable to neutral compounds. Racemic ketones can be resolved through diastereomeric derivatives with chiral diols, hydrazines or amines.
Resolution via inclusion and complexes
- Chiral hosts (for example tartaric-acid-derived TADDOLs, cyclodextrins, chiral crown ethers) form diastereomeric inclusion compounds with one enantiomer more strongly.
- Chiral metal complexes and ligands can be resolved as salts with chiral counter-ions (for example the resolution of [Co(en)₃]³⁺ with tartrate). This shows that resolution is not limited to carbon stereocentres; see Transition Elements and Coordination Compounds.
Chromatographic Resolution
- Analytical chiral HPLC, GC and SFC measure ee (see Enantio-discrimination).
- Preparative chiral HPLC, SFC and simulated moving bed (SMB) chromatography separate enantiomers on gram to large scale; both enantiomers are obtained.
- Covalent diastereomers can be separated on ordinary silica, as above.
Kinetic Resolution
A process in which the two enantiomers of a racemate react at different rates with a chiral reagent or catalyst, so that the reaction mixture becomes enriched in the product from the fast enantiomer and in the unreacted slow enantiomer. The selectivity factor is
$$s = \frac{k_{\text{fast}}}{k_{\text{slow}}} = e^{\Delta\Delta G^\ddagger/RT}$$Deriving the Kagan equations
Assume both enantiomers react by first-order (or pseudo-first-order) kinetics with the same catalyst:
$$\frac{[R]}{[R]_0} = e^{-k_R t}, \qquad \frac{[S]}{[S]_0} = e^{-k_S t} \;\Rightarrow\; s = \frac{k_R}{k_S} = \frac{\ln([R]/[R]_0)}{\ln([S]/[S]_0)}$$With fractional conversion \( c \) and ee of the recovered starting material \( \text{ee}_{\text{SM}} \), the fractions remaining are \( (1-c)(1-\text{ee}_{\text{SM}}) \) for the fast enantiomer and \( (1-c)(1+\text{ee}_{\text{SM}}) \) for the slow one (each relative to its initial amount). Hence:
$$s = \frac{\ln[(1-c)(1-\text{ee}_{\text{SM}})]}{\ln[(1-c)(1+\text{ee}_{\text{SM}})]} = \frac{\ln[1-c(1+\text{ee}_{P})]}{\ln[1-c(1-\text{ee}_{P})]}$$and the mass balance links the two:
$$c \cdot \text{ee}_P = (1-c)\cdot \text{ee}_{\text{SM}}$$How ee changes with conversion
For s = 20 (computed from the equations above):
| Conversion c | ee of recovered SM | ee of product | Recovered SM (% of racemate) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20% | about 22% | about 88% | 80% |
| 40% | about 56% | about 84% | 60% |
| 50% | about 79% | about 79% | 50% |
| 60% | about 98% | about 65% | 40% |
And the conversion needed for 99% ee of recovered starting material:
| s | c needed | Recovered SM |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | 87% | 13% |
| 10 | 72% | 28% |
| 20 | 62% | 38% |
| 50 | 55% | 45% |
- ee(SM) rises continuously with conversion and approaches 100% for any s > 1, at the cost of yield.
- ee(P) is highest at low conversion, approaching \( (s-1)/(s+1) \) as c → 0, and falls as c increases.
- At c = 50%, ee(SM) = ee(P).
- Maximum yield of either enantiomer is 50%.
- To obtain the product with high ee, s must be large (s ≳ 50 for > 90% ee at useful conversion); to obtain the recovered starting material with high ee, a modest s suffices if you run past 50% conversion.
Important kinetic resolutions
| Method | Substrate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Lipase-catalysed acylation (vinyl acetate as acyl donor) or ester hydrolysis | secondary alcohols, their esters, amines | the most common laboratory KR; vinyl acetate releases acetaldehyde (from the enol), which makes acylation irreversible. Empirical rules (Kazlauskas) predict the fast enantiomer from the relative sizes of the two carbinol substituents |
| Sharpless epoxidation (Ti(OiPr)₄, DET, TBHP) | racemic secondary allylic alcohols | one enantiomer epoxidises much faster; the slow one is recovered with high ee |
| Jacobsen hydrolytic kinetic resolution (HKR) | terminal epoxides | chiral (salen)Co(III) catalyst and water; gives both the recovered epoxide and the 1,2-diol with high ee |
| Enantioselective acylation with chiral nucleophilic catalysts | secondary alcohols, amines | chiral DMAP analogues and related catalysts |
| Enzymatic oxidation, amidase or acylase hydrolysis | amino acids (N-acyl derivatives) | acylase I hydrolyses N-acetyl-L-amino acids, leaving the D-enantiomer acylated (the classical industrial resolution of amino acids) |
Parallel kinetic resolution
Both enantiomers are converted at similar rates but into different, separable products (for example two regioisomers, or by two complementary reagents). Because the slow enantiomer is not left to accumulate, the ee of each product stays high throughout the reaction.
Beyond 50%: DKR and Desymmetrisation
Dynamic kinetic resolution (DKR)
If the substrate enantiomers interconvert faster than the slow enantiomer reacts (\( k_{\text{rac}} \gg k_{\text{slow}} \)), the substrate pool is continually re-racemised, and all of it can be funnelled through the fast-reacting enantiomer.
- Maximum yield: 100%.
- Product ee (ideal, fast racemisation): \( \text{ee}_P = (s-1)/(s+1) \), constant throughout the reaction, unlike ordinary KR.
- Examples:
- Noyori Ru–BINAP hydrogenation of α-substituted β-keto esters: the α-stereocentre epimerises through the enol; the catalyst reduces one enantiomer selectively, setting two stereocentres in one step.
- Chemoenzymatic DKR of secondary alcohols: a lipase acylates one enantiomer while a ruthenium complex racemises the alcohol (by reversible dehydrogenation–hydrogenation through the ketone); Bäckvall’s combination is the textbook example.
- Enzymatic DKR of α-substituted esters and amino-acid derivatives (azlactones, hydantoins) that racemise under the reaction conditions.
Desymmetrisation
The substrate is achiral (meso or prochiral) and has two enantiotopic groups or faces. A chiral reagent or catalyst converts one of them selectively, creating a chiral product in up to 100% yield.
- Enzymatic hydrolysis of one ester group of a meso diester (pig liver esterase) or acylation of one OH of a meso diol (lipases).
- Enantioselective deprotonation of a 4-substituted cyclohexanone with a chiral lithium amide.
- Ring opening of meso epoxides with a chiral catalyst.
- Biological precedent: the enzymatic differentiation of the enantiotopic arms of citrate and glycerol (see Enantio-discrimination).
Desymmetrisation is often followed by a kinetic resolution of the minor enantiomer: if the monoester reacts further to the achiral diacid, and the minor monoester enantiomer does so faster, the ee of the remaining monoester rises with time.
| Strategy | Substrate | Max yield of one enantiomer | ee during reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classical resolution (salts) | racemic | 50% (100% with RRR) | upgraded by recrystallisation |
| Kinetic resolution | racemic | 50% | ee(SM) rises; ee(P) falls |
| Dynamic kinetic resolution | racemic, racemising | 100% | constant, (s − 1)/(s + 1) |
| Desymmetrisation | meso or prochiral | 100% | set by enantiotopic selectivity |
| Asymmetric synthesis | prochiral | 100% | set by catalyst or reagent |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | Is not this |
|---|---|
| Conglomerate: separate R and S crystals | Racemic compound: both in one lattice |
| Resolution: separates existing enantiomers | Asymmetric synthesis: creates one enantiomer from a prochiral substrate |
| Kinetic resolution: racemic, max 50% | DKR: racemising substrate, max 100% |
| DKR: product is a new compound | Deracemisation: same compound, one enantiomer |
| Desymmetrisation: meso/prochiral substrate | Kinetic resolution: racemic substrate |
| Selectivity factor s = k_fast/k_slow | ee: composition at a given conversion |
| Preferential crystallisation: seeding a conglomerate | Diastereomeric salt crystallisation: needs a resolving agent |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not taken from any CSIR NET paper. Numbers were computed from the Kagan equations above.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name one enantiopure base used to resolve racemic carboxylic acids.
- What is the maximum yield of one enantiomer in a classical kinetic resolution?
- What type of substrate undergoes desymmetrisation?
Answers
- Any of brucine, strychnine, quinine, cinchonidine, (R)- or (S)-1-phenylethylamine.
- 50% of the racemate.
- An achiral meso or prochiral compound with enantiotopic groups or faces.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Racemic 1-phenylethylamine is best resolved by crystallisation with
(a) acetic acid (b) (+)-tartaric acid (c) hydrochloric acid (d) (±)-mandelic acid
Answer: (b)
An enantiopure acid forms diastereomeric salts. Acetic and hydrochloric acids are achiral; racemic mandelic acid gives two pairs of enantiomeric salts and no net resolution.
Practice Q2. A racemate whose two enantiomers crystallise in separate crystals, so that the racemic solid is a mechanical mixture, is called
(a) a racemic compound (b) a pseudoracemate (c) a conglomerate (d) a meso form
Answer: (c)
Conglomerates allow spontaneous resolution and preferential crystallisation.
Practice Q3. A lipase acylates a racemic secondary alcohol with s = 20. At 50% conversion, the ee of both the ester and the unreacted alcohol is closest to
(a) 50% (b) 67% (c) 79% (d) 95%
Answer: (c)
At c = 0.5, ee(SM) = ee(P). Solving \( 20 = \ln[0.5(1-e)]/\ln[0.5(1+e)] \) gives e ≈ 0.79. Option (d) is near (s − 1)/(s + 1) = 0.90, the product ee reached only in the limit c → 0 or under ideal DKR.
Practice Q4. Which process can convert a racemic α-substituted β-keto ester into a single stereoisomer of the β-hydroxy ester in more than 50% yield?
(a) Lipase-catalysed kinetic resolution of the keto ester (b) Noyori Ru–BINAP hydrogenation under conditions where the α-stereocentre epimerises (c) Crystallisation of the racemic keto ester (d) Reduction with NaBH₄
Answer: (b)
Dynamic kinetic resolution: fast enolisation racemises the substrate, and the catalyst reduces one enantiomer selectively.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A racemic secondary alcohol is acylated with a lipase. At 55% conversion, the recovered alcohol has 95% ee.
Which statements are correct?
- The selectivity factor s is about 29.
- The ester has an ee of about 78%.
- The recovered alcohol represents 45% of the original racemate.
- Stopping at 30% conversion would give ester of higher ee than at 55%.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1, 3 and 4 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 2 and 4 only
Answer: (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- Correct. s = ln[(0.45)(0.05)]/ln[(0.45)(1.95)] = ln(0.0225)/ln(0.8775) = (−3.794)/(−0.1307) ≈ 29.0.
- Correct. ee(P) = (1 − c) ee(SM)/c = 0.45 × 0.95/0.55 = 0.777.
- Correct. 1 − c = 0.45.
- Correct. ee(P) is highest at low conversion; with s ≈ 29 it is about 90% at 30% conversion.
Practice Q6. For a kinetic resolution with s = 10, which statements are correct?
- To recover starting material of 99% ee, the reaction must be taken to about 72% conversion.
- At that point, 28% of the original racemate remains as the slow enantiomer.
- At 50% conversion, the ee of both product and recovered starting material is about 67%.
- Under ideal dynamic kinetic resolution with the same s, the product ee would be about 82% at any conversion.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1 and 3 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- Correct. From \( \ln(1-c) = [\ln(1-\text{ee}) - s\ln(1+\text{ee})]/(s-1) \) with ee = 0.99: c = 0.721.
- Correct. 1 − c = 0.279 (essentially all of it the slow enantiomer).
- Correct. Solving the Kagan equation at c = 0.5 gives 0.670.
- Correct. (s − 1)/(s + 1) = 9/11 = 0.818.
Practice Q7. Consider the following statements.
- Pig liver esterase hydrolysis of one ester group of a meso diester can give a single enantiomer of the monoester in up to 100% yield.
- In preferential crystallisation, a supersaturated solution of a racemic compound (true racemate) is seeded with one enantiomer.
- Racemising the unwanted enantiomer from a diastereomeric salt resolution and recycling it can, in principle, convert 87.5% of the starting racemate into the desired enantiomer after three ideal cycles.
- A parallel kinetic resolution converts both enantiomers, at similar rates, into different separable products.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
- Correct. Desymmetrisation is not limited to 50%.
- Wrong. Preferential crystallisation requires a conglomerate; a racemic compound crystallises as the racemate.
- Correct. 50% + 25% + 12.5% = 87.5% (ideal yields).
- Correct. This is the definition of parallel kinetic resolution.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Resolution | separation of a racemate; needs a chiral partner or conglomerate behaviour |
| Conglomerate / racemic compound / pseudoracemate | separate crystals / 1:1 lattice / solid solution |
| Pasteur | sodium ammonium tartrate (a conglomerate under his conditions), separated by hand |
| Preferential crystallisation | seed a supersaturated conglomerate solution; alternate enantiomers |
| Resolving agents | acids: brucine, strychnine, quinine, cinchonidine, 1-phenylethylamine; bases: tartaric, DBTA, CSA, mandelic acid |
| RRR | racemise and recycle the unwanted enantiomer; 87.5% after three ideal cycles |
| KR selectivity | \( s = k_f/k_s = \ln[(1-c)(1-\text{ee}_{SM})]/\ln[(1-c)(1+\text{ee}_{SM})] \) |
| Mass balance | \( c\,\text{ee}_P = (1-c)\,\text{ee}_{SM} \) |
| s = 20 | c = 50%: 79%/79%; c = 60%: 98% SM, 65% P |
| KR tools | lipases (vinyl acetate), SAE, Jacobsen HKR, acylase for amino acids |
| DKR | fast racemisation; up to 100%; ee = (s − 1)/(s + 1); Noyori, lipase + Ru |
| Desymmetrisation | meso/prochiral; up to 100%; PLE, lipases, chiral lithium amides |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Asymmetric Synthesis: Quick Revision: the whole unit on one page.
- Enzymes: Catalysis, Kinetics and Regulation: why enzymes are such selective resolving catalysts.
- Asymmetric Induction: the stereochemistry unit’s view of the same strategies.