Porphyrins and Oxygen Transport
CSIR NET chemistry: porphyrin structure and spectra, heme types, chlorins and corrins, myoglobin, haemoglobin cooperativity, hemerythrin and hemocyanin.
- 17 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Crystal Field, Ligand Field and MO Theory: high-spin and low-spin Fe(II), ionic radii and spin state.
- Magnetic Properties of Complexes: antiferromagnetic coupling, which explains why oxyhemerythrin and oxyhemocyanin behave as they do.
- Electronic Spectra of Complexes: charge-transfer bands, which give oxy carriers their colours.
- The physiology side (oxygen dissociation curve, Bohr effect, 2,3-BPG) is in Respiratory and Renal Physiology.
The Hook: Why Does Free Heme Rust?
Porphyrins: The Ligand
Structure
Porphine (the parent porphyrin) is a macrocycle of four pyrrole rings joined by four methine (=CH–) bridges, the meso positions. The eight outer pyrrole carbons are the β positions, where natural porphyrins carry their substituents.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Donor set | four pyrrole N atoms, square planar N₄ |
| Charge | free base H₂P loses two N–H protons to give the dianion P²⁻ |
| Aromaticity | an 18 π-electron delocalisation pathway (4n + 2, n = 4); the ring is planar and rigid |
| Cavity | sized for first-row M²⁺ ions; larger or high-spin ions sit above the plane |
| Axial sites | two, above and below the plane: these decide the chemistry |
The porphyrin dianion is a tetradentate, dianionic, strong-field macrocycle. Because it fixes four equatorial donors, a metalloporphyrin’s reactivity is set almost entirely by the two axial positions: what the protein puts there (histidine, methionine, cysteinate, tyrosinate) and what the substrate occupies.
Natural porphyrins and hemes
Protoporphyrin IX carries four methyl, two vinyl and two propionate groups on the β positions. Its iron complex is heme (heme b).
| Heme | Difference from heme b | Found in |
|---|---|---|
| Heme b | Fe–protoporphyrin IX, non-covalently bound | myoglobin, haemoglobin, cytochrome P450, catalase, peroxidases, cytochrome b |
| Heme c | the two vinyl groups form thioether links to two cysteines (CXXCH motif) | cytochrome c |
| Heme a | a formyl group and a long isoprenoid (hydroxyethylfarnesyl) chain | cytochrome c oxidase (hemes a and a₃) |
Reduced and modified macrocycles
| Macrocycle | Change from porphyrin | Metal / example |
|---|---|---|
| Chlorin | one pyrrole β,β double bond reduced | Mg: chlorophyll a and b |
| Bacteriochlorin | two opposite pyrrole rings reduced | Mg: bacteriochlorophyll |
| Corrin | one meso carbon missing (two pyrroles joined directly); more saturated; monoanionic | Co: vitamin B₁₂ |
| Corphin (F430) | highly reduced porphyrinoid | Ni: methyl-coenzyme M reductase in methanogens |
Reducing the ring lowers the symmetry and moves intensity into the red: chlorophylls absorb strongly near 660–680 nm, which is why leaves use the red end of sunlight (see Photosystems).
Biosynthesis in one paragraph
In animals, glycine and succinyl-CoA condense to δ-aminolevulinic acid (ALA); plants make ALA from glutamate. Two ALA give the pyrrole porphobilinogen (ALA dehydratase, a zinc enzyme), four of which build the linear tetrapyrrole and then uroporphyrinogen III. Side-chain edits and oxidation give protoporphyrin IX, and ferrochelatase inserts Fe²⁺. Lead inhibits both ALA dehydratase and ferrochelatase, which is why lead poisoning raises ALA and zinc protoporphyrin (see Metal Complexes in Medicine).
Electronic spectra: Soret and Q bands
Porphyrin colour comes from π → π* transitions of the ring, not d–d bands. In Gouterman’s four-orbital model, two nearly degenerate HOMOs (\( a_{1u}, a_{2u} \)) and a degenerate pair of LUMOs (\( e_g \)) give two excited states that mix:
| Band | Position | Intensity | Origin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soret (B) | near 400 nm | very intense, ε of order 10⁵ M⁻¹ cm⁻¹ | transition dipoles add |
| Q bands | 500–650 nm | weaker, ε of order 10⁴ M⁻¹ cm⁻¹ | transition dipoles nearly cancel |
The free base (\( D_{2h} \), two N–H) shows four Q bands. Metallation raises the symmetry to \( D_{4h} \), the Q region collapses to two bands (α and β). Counting Q bands is a quick test of whether metal insertion has occurred.
Myoglobin and Haemoglobin
The active site
Both proteins hold a heme b in a hydrophobic pocket. Iron is bonded to the four porphyrin N atoms and to the proximal histidine (His F8). The sixth site, on the distal side, faces a second histidine (His E7) that does not bind iron but sits close to the bound O₂.
| Deoxy | Oxy | |
|---|---|---|
| Coordination | five-coordinate (4 N + His) | six-coordinate (4 N + His + O₂) |
| Formal Fe state | Fe(II), \( d^6 \) | Fe(II)–O₂ or Fe(III)–O₂⁻ (see below) |
| Spin | high spin, S = 2, 4 unpaired | diamagnetic overall |
| Fe position | out of the porphyrin plane, towards His F8 | moves into the plane |
| Colour | dark purple-red | bright red |
Why the iron moves. High-spin Fe(II) has two electrons in the antibonding \( e_g \) set (\( t_{2g}^4 e_g^2 \)); the \( d_{x^2-y^2} \) electron makes the ion too large for the porphyrin hole, so it sits a few tenths of an ångström above the plane. Binding O₂ makes the iron low spin (\( t_{2g}^6 \), or \( t_{2g}^5 \) for the Fe(III) formulation), the \( e_g \) electrons are gone, the ion shrinks and drops into the plane. This movement is the trigger for cooperativity.
How O₂ binds: bent end-on
O₂ binds end-on and bent (Fe–O–O angle near 120°), the geometry Pauling predicted. Two limiting electronic descriptions:
- Pauling: low-spin Fe(II) bound to singlet O₂.
- Weiss: low-spin Fe(III) bound to superoxide, O₂⁻, with the two unpaired spins strongly antiferromagnetically coupled.
The O–O stretching frequency of oxyhaemoglobin (about 1105 cm⁻¹) is close to that of superoxide salts and far from free O₂, so the Weiss picture (substantial charge transfer to O₂) describes the bond better. Diamagnetism alone cannot decide between the two, because a strongly coupled Fe(III)–superoxide pair is also diamagnetic.
| Dioxygen species | Bond order | Approx. ν(O–O), cm⁻¹ | Typical in |
|---|---|---|---|
| O₂ | 2 | 1555 | free gas |
| O₂⁻ (superoxide) | 1.5 | about 1100–1150 | oxyhaemoglobin, oxymyoglobin |
| O₂²⁻ (peroxide) | 1 | about 750–850 | oxyhemerythrin, oxyhemocyanin |
What the protein does
- Prevents μ-oxo dimer formation. Free Fe(II) porphyrins react with O₂ by a bimolecular path: Fe–O–O–Fe (μ-peroxo) → two Fe(IV)=O → Fe(III)–O–Fe(III). The globin buries the heme so two hemes cannot meet. Collman’s picket-fence porphyrin, with bulky groups protecting one face and an imidazole on the other, reproduced reversible O₂ binding in a small molecule for the same reason.
- Keeps water out. A hydrophobic pocket slows autoxidation to met-haemoglobin (Fe(III), which cannot bind O₂). Red cells reduce what forms with met-haemoglobin reductase.
- Discriminates against CO. CO binds free heme far more strongly than O₂ (by a factor of order 10⁴); in myoglobin and haemoglobin the preference falls to roughly a few hundred. The classic explanation was that the distal His forces CO off its preferred linear Fe–C–O geometry. The modern view puts more weight on the hydrogen bond from His E7 to bound O₂, which stabilises the polar Fe–O₂ unit but does little for CO.
Cooperativity in haemoglobin
Myoglobin (a monomer, one heme) gives a hyperbolic O₂ binding curve. Haemoglobin (an \( \alpha_2\beta_2 \) tetramer, four hemes) gives a sigmoidal one: binding one O₂ raises the affinity of the remaining sites.
The Perutz mechanism. In deoxy-Hb the tetramer is in the T (tense) state, low affinity, held by salt bridges between subunits. When O₂ binds, Fe moves into the porphyrin plane and pulls His F8 and the whole F helix with it. The movement is transmitted to the \( \alpha_1\beta_2 \) interface, salt bridges break, and the tetramer switches to the R (relaxed), high-affinity state. The concerted (MWC) model treats the tetramer as all-T or all-R; the sequential (KNF) model lets subunits change one at a time.
The Hill equation. For fractional saturation Y at O₂ partial pressure p:
$$\boxed{Y = \frac{p^{\,n}}{P_{50}^{\,n} + p^{\,n}}} \qquad \log\frac{Y}{1-Y} = n\log p - n\log P_{50}$$| n (Hill coefficient) | \( P_{50} \) | |
|---|---|---|
| Myoglobin | 1 (no cooperativity) | about 1–3 mmHg |
| Haemoglobin (adult) | about 2.8–3 | about 26 mmHg |
n is never larger than the number of binding sites (4 for Hb); n > 1 means positive cooperativity. A Hill plot (log[Y/(1−Y)] against log p) gives n as the slope in the middle region and \( P_{50} \) where the line crosses zero.
Allosteric effectors stabilise T and shift the curve right (higher \( P_{50} \)): H⁺ and CO₂ (the Bohr effect), and 2,3-bisphosphoglycerate, which binds in the central cavity between the β chains. Fetal haemoglobin binds 2,3-BPG less, so it has higher affinity and takes O₂ from maternal blood.
Non-Heme Carriers: Hemerythrin and Hemocyanin
Hemerythrin (Hr)
Found in some marine invertebrates (sipunculid worms, brachiopods). Despite the name it contains no heme.
- Site: two iron atoms bridged by a hydroxide (deoxy) or oxide (oxy) and two carboxylates (Asp, Glu). One Fe has three His, the other two His and an open site where O₂ binds. One O₂ per two Fe.
- Deoxy: Fe(II)Fe(II), μ-hydroxo, colourless.
- Oxy: Fe(III)Fe(III). O₂ is reduced by two electrons (one from each Fe) and picks up the proton of the μ-OH: it binds end-on to one iron as hydroperoxide (HOO⁻), and the bridge becomes μ-oxo. The hydroperoxide hydrogen-bonds back to the μ-oxo.
- Colour and spectra: violet-pink, from peroxide → Fe(III) charge transfer. ν(O–O) is in the peroxide range (about 845 cm⁻¹). The two Fe(III) are strongly antiferromagnetically coupled through the oxo bridge.
Hemocyanin (Hc)
The O₂ carrier of many arthropods and molluscs, dissolved in the haemolymph.
- Site: a type 3 dicopper centre: two Cu, each bound by three His. One O₂ per two Cu.
- Deoxy: Cu(I)Cu(I), \( d^{10} \), colourless.
- Oxy: Cu(II)Cu(II) with peroxide bound side-on bridging, μ-η²:η², between the two coppers. Intense blue colour from peroxide → Cu(II) charge transfer (a strong band near 345 nm and a weaker one near 580 nm). ν(O–O) is very low (about 750 cm⁻¹) because the side-on peroxide also accepts Cu electron density into its σ* orbital.
- Magnetism: two \( d^9 \) Cu(II) ions, but EPR-silent and diamagnetic: the peroxide bridge couples them strongly antiferromagnetically. Kitajima’s dicopper peroxo model complex, with a hydrotris(pyrazolyl)borate ligand, showed the side-on mode before the protein crystal structure confirmed it.
Comparison table
| Haemoglobin / myoglobin | Hemerythrin | Hemocyanin | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Metal | Fe, heme | Fe, non-heme, dinuclear | Cu, dinuclear (type 3) |
| Protein ligands | 1 His (proximal) | 5 His, 2 carboxylates (bridging) | 6 His (3 per Cu) |
| O₂ per metal | 1 O₂ : 1 Fe | 1 O₂ : 2 Fe | 1 O₂ : 2 Cu |
| Deoxy state | Fe(II) HS | Fe(II)Fe(II) | Cu(I)Cu(I) |
| Oxy state | Fe(III)–O₂⁻ (Weiss) | Fe(III)Fe(III), HOO⁻ | Cu(II)Cu(II), O₂²⁻ |
| O₂ binding mode | end-on, bent, one metal | end-on to one Fe, as hydroperoxide | side-on, bridging μ-η²:η² |
| ν(O–O) range | superoxide | peroxide | peroxide (lowest) |
| Colour deoxy → oxy | purple-red → red | colourless → violet-pink | colourless → blue |
| Found in | vertebrates (and many others) | some marine invertebrates | arthropods, molluscs |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Proximal His F8: bonded to Fe | distal His E7: not bonded; H-bonds to O₂ | |
| Hemerythrin: Fe, no heme | haemoglobin: Fe heme | |
| Hemocyanin: Cu, side-on peroxide | hemerythrin: Fe, end-on hydroperoxide | |
| Met-haemoglobin: Fe(III), no O₂ binding | oxyhaemoglobin: Fe(III)–O₂⁻ formally, but reversible | |
| Chlorin (one ring reduced, chlorophyll) | corrin (one meso carbon missing, B₁₂) | |
| Hill n (cooperativity) | number of binding sites (n can never exceed it) | |
| Soret band (≈ 400 nm, ε ≈ 10⁵) | Q bands (500–650 nm, ε ≈ 10⁴) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many unpaired electrons does the iron in deoxymyoglobin have?
- Which O₂ carrier binds dioxygen side-on between two metal ions?
- How many Q bands does a typical metalloporphyrin show?
Answers
- Four. High-spin Fe(II), \( t_{2g}^4 e_g^2 \), S = 2 (spin-only moment \( \sqrt{24} \approx 4.90 \) BM).
- Hemocyanin (μ-η²:η² peroxide between two Cu(II)).
- Two (α and β); the free base shows four.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. In oxyhemerythrin, the oxidation states of iron and the form of bound dioxygen are:
(a) Fe(II)Fe(II), O₂ (b) Fe(III)Fe(III), hydroperoxide (c) Fe(II)Fe(III), superoxide (d) Fe(III)Fe(III), superoxide
Answer: (b)
Each iron gives one electron, so O₂ is reduced by two electrons to peroxide; it takes the proton of the μ-hydroxo bridge and binds end-on to one Fe as HOO⁻. Both irons are Fe(III), and the bridge becomes μ-oxo.
Practice Q2. For haemoglobin with Hill coefficient n = 2.8 and \( P_{50} \) = 26 mmHg, and myoglobin with n = 1 and \( P_{50} \) = 2.0 mmHg (practice values), the fractional saturations at p(O₂) = 40 mmHg are closest to:
(a) Hb 0.60, Mb 0.85 (b) Hb 0.77, Mb 0.95 (c) Hb 0.95, Mb 0.77 (d) Hb 0.50, Mb 0.50
Answer: (b)
Hb: \( (40/26)^{2.8} = 1.538^{2.8} \approx 3.34 \), so Y = 3.34/4.34 ≈ 0.77.
Mb: Y = 40/(2.0 + 40) ≈ 0.95.
Myoglobin is nearly saturated where haemoglobin is still releasing O₂, which is why O₂ passes from blood to muscle.
Practice Q3. The ν(O–O) values of three dioxygen adducts are 1105, 845 and 750 cm⁻¹. The correct match is:
(a) oxyhaemoglobin 750, oxyhemerythrin 845, oxyhemocyanin 1105 (b) oxyhaemoglobin 1105, oxyhemerythrin 845, oxyhemocyanin 750 (c) oxyhaemoglobin 845, oxyhemerythrin 1105, oxyhemocyanin 750 (d) oxyhaemoglobin 1105, oxyhemerythrin 750, oxyhemocyanin 845
Answer: (b)
Superoxide (bond order 1.5) has the highest frequency: oxy-Hb. Both non-heme carriers hold peroxide; side-on bridging peroxide in hemocyanin is weakened further by back-donation into σ*, so it is lowest.
Practice Q4. On metallation of a free-base porphyrin, the number of Q bands changes because:
(a) the Soret band disappears (b) the symmetry rises from \( D_{2h} \) to \( D_{4h} \), making the LUMOs degenerate (c) d–d bands are added (d) the ring loses aromaticity
Answer: (b)
With two N–H protons on opposite pyrroles, the x and y directions differ (\( D_{2h} \)), so each Q transition splits into two, each with a vibronic partner: four bands. Metallation makes x and y equivalent: two bands.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Practice binding data for a tetrameric O₂ carrier give fractional saturation Y = 0.20 at 16 mmHg and Y = 0.80 at 40 mmHg. Assuming the Hill equation holds over this range, find n and \( P_{50} \), and comment.
Answer
\( \log[Y/(1-Y)] \) = log 0.25 = −0.602 at log 16 = 1.204; log 4 = +0.602 at log 40 = 1.602.
\( n = \dfrac{0.602 - (-0.602)}{1.602 - 1.204} = \dfrac{1.204}{0.398} \approx \) 3.0.
At Y = 0.5 the left side is zero; by symmetry of the two points, \( \log P_{50} = (1.204 + 1.602)/2 \), so \( P_{50} = \sqrt{16 \times 40} \approx \) 25 mmHg.
n ≈ 3 for a tetramer: strong positive cooperativity, close to adult haemoglobin. It does not mean three sites.
Practice Q6. Lungs are at p(O₂) = 100 mmHg and active tissue at 20 mmHg. Compare the fraction of sites that unload O₂ between lungs and tissue for (i) a cooperative carrier with n = 2.8, \( P_{50} \) = 26 mmHg and (ii) a hypothetical non-cooperative carrier (n = 1) with the same \( P_{50} \).
Answer
(i) \( Y_{100} = 100^{2.8}/(26^{2.8} + 100^{2.8}) \approx 0.978 \); \( Y_{20} \approx 0.324 \). Unloaded ≈ 0.65 of sites.
(ii) \( Y_{100} = 100/126 \approx 0.794 \); \( Y_{20} = 20/46 \approx 0.435 \). Unloaded ≈ 0.36.
The sigmoidal curve delivers nearly twice as much O₂ over the same pressure drop. That is the functional point of cooperativity: load fully in the lungs, release a lot in the tissues.
Practice Q7. Consider the statements:
- In deoxyhaemoglobin, Fe(II) is high spin and displaced from the porphyrin plane towards the proximal histidine.
- Oxyhemocyanin is diamagnetic even though both copper ions are Cu(II).
- In hemerythrin, O₂ binds side-on bridging between the two iron atoms.
- 2,3-Bisphosphoglycerate binds preferentially to the R state of haemoglobin and lowers \( P_{50} \).
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a)
- Correct. HS \( d^6 \) with \( e_g \) electrons is too large for the hole.
- Correct. Strong antiferromagnetic coupling through the μ-η²:η² peroxide.
- Wrong. O₂ binds end-on to one Fe as hydroperoxide; side-on bridging is hemocyanin.
- Wrong. 2,3-BPG binds the T state and raises \( P_{50} \) (lower affinity).
Practice Q8. A solution of an iron(II) porphyrin with 1-methylimidazole as axial base turns from red to brown on exposure to air at room temperature, and the product is EPR-silent with a strong IR band in the 850–900 cm⁻¹ region (assigned to the asymmetric Fe–O–Fe stretch). The same compound with bulky groups over one face of the porphyrin binds O₂ reversibly. Explain both observations.
Answer
The unprotected heme undergoes bimolecular autoxidation: Fe(II) + O₂ → Fe(III)–O₂⁻, which attacks a second Fe(II) to give Fe(III)–O–O–Fe(III) (μ-peroxo), whose O–O bond cleaves to two Fe(IV)=O; each oxidises another Fe(II), ending as the μ-oxo dimer Fe(III)–O–Fe(III). The two Fe(III) are antiferromagnetically coupled through the oxo bridge, hence EPR-silent, and the asymmetric Fe–O–Fe stretch appears in the IR.
The bulky groups (as in a picket-fence porphyrin) make a pocket on the O₂ side that stops two irons approaching each other, so the bimolecular path is blocked and only reversible 1:1 binding remains. The globin does the same job in myoglobin.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Porphyrin | 4 pyrroles + 4 meso CH; 18 π pathway; P²⁻ tetradentate N₄ |
| Heme b / c / a | protoporphyrin IX / thioether-linked to 2 Cys / formyl + farnesyl tail |
| Chlorin / bacteriochlorin / corrin / F430 | Mg chlorophyll / Mg BChl / Co B₁₂ / Ni methanogens |
| Spectra | Soret ≈ 400 nm (ε ≈ 10⁵); Q 500–650 nm; free base 4 Q, metal 2 Q |
| Deoxy-Hb | Fe(II) HS S = 2, 5-coordinate, out of plane |
| Oxy-Hb | 6-coordinate, diamagnetic, bent end-on, Fe(III)–O₂⁻ character, ν(O–O) ≈ 1105 |
| Distal His | H-bonds O₂; lowers CO preference relative to free heme |
| Cooperativity | T → R on Fe moving into plane; Hb n ≈ 2.8–3, \( P_{50} \) ≈ 26 mmHg; Mb n = 1 |
| Right shift | H⁺, CO₂ (Bohr), 2,3-BPG (binds T) |
| Hemerythrin | Fe₂, 5 His + 2 carboxylates; oxy Fe(III)₂ μ-oxo, end-on HOO⁻; violet-pink |
| Hemocyanin | Cu₂, 6 His; oxy Cu(II)₂ μ-η²:η² O₂²⁻; blue, EPR-silent, ν(O–O) ≈ 750 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Biological Electron Transfer: the same hemes in cytochromes, plus iron–sulfur and blue copper proteins.
- Metalloenzymes: heme enzymes that activate O₂ instead of carrying it (cytochrome P450, catalase, peroxidase).
- Back to the chapter overview or the Chemical Sciences syllabus.