Skip to content

Main-Group Cages: Zintl Ions, Electron-Precise and Oxide Cages

CSIR NET chemistry: electron-precise cages (P₄, P₄S₃, cubane), Zintl ions and phases, fullerenes, zeolite and hydrate cages, polyoxometalate cages.

  • 20 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 15 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Lead That Dissolves as a Cluster
  3. Two Kinds of Cage
  4. Phosphorus, Arsenic and Sulfur Cages
  5. Zintl Phases and the Zintl–Klemm Concept
  6. Carbon Cages: Fullerenes
  7. Oxide and Water Cages
  8. Polyoxometalate Cages
  9. Memory Tricks
  10. Don’t Confuse
  11. Common Mistakes
  12. Practice
  13. Quick Revision Table
  14. Key Takeaways
  15. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Lead That Dissolves as a Cluster

Two Kinds of Cage

Electron-precise cageElectron-deficient (Wade) cage
Bondingone 2c–2e bond along every edgedelocalised multicentre bonding
Electron pairs vs edgesskeletal pairs = number of edgesskeletal pairs < number of edges
Typical vertex connectivity3 (each atom forms three cage bonds)4 or 5 (deltahedra)
Facesany polygonstriangles (deltahedra)
ExamplesP₄, P₄S₃, P₄O₁₀, cubane, [P₇]³⁻[B₁₂H₁₂]²⁻, [Sn₉]⁴⁻, [Bi₅]³⁺
Counting tooloctet rule (8 − N)Wade’s rules

The 8 − N rule and 3-connected cages

A main-group atom with N valence electrons that obeys the octet rule forms 8 − N two-centre bonds (counting each bond to any atom). Group 15 atoms form three bonds; a group 14 anion E⁻ such as Si⁻ or Ge⁻ (five valence electrons) behaves the same way.

For a polyhedral cage in which every vertex is 3-connected and also carries either an exo bond or a lone pair, every vertex has a full octet when the total valence electron count is

$$\boxed{\text{total valence electrons} = 5n}$$

(three cage bonds shared, plus one exo pair: 3 + 2 = 5 electrons per vertex on average).

CageShapeCount5n
P₄tetrahedron4 × 5 = 2020
[Si₄]⁴⁻, [Ge₄]⁴⁻tetrahedron4 × 4 + 4 = 2020
C₄R₄ (tetrahedrane)tetrahedron4 × 4 + 4 = 2020
C₆H₆ (prismane)trigonal prism6 × 4 + 6 = 3030
C₈H₈ (cubane)cube8 × 4 + 8 = 4040
C₂₀H₂₀ (dodecahedrane)pentagonal dodecahedron20 × 4 + 20 = 100100

Benzene and prismane are isomers (C₆H₆); in prismane every carbon is 3-connected within the cage. The hydrocarbon cages are strained, especially tetrahedrane and prismane, but they are electron-precise.

Phosphorus, Arsenic and Sulfur Cages

Inserting atoms into the P₄ edges

Start from the P₄ tetrahedron (6 P–P edges). Inserting a bridging atom into edges gives a family of cages:

CageEdges bridgedOther featuresShape
P₄O₆all 6 by OP(III), each P keeps a lone pairadamantane-like, \( T_d \)
P₄O₁₀all 6 by Oplus a terminal P=O on each P; P(V)adamantane-like, \( T_d \)
P₄S₁₀all 6 by Splus a terminal P=S on each Psame cage as P₄O₁₀
P₄S₃the 3 edges to one Pthe other three P keep a P₃ triangle\( C_{3v} \)
As₄O₆, Sb₄O₆all 6 by Othe molecular oxides (arsenolite, senarmontite)like P₄O₆

P₄S₃ (used in strike-anywhere match heads): a basal triangle of three P atoms, each bonded to one S; the three S atoms all bond to the single apical P. Bonds: 3 (P₃ triangle) + 3 + 3 (P–S) = 9 two-centre bonds. Electron check: valence electrons 4 × 5 + 3 × 6 = 38 = 9 bonds × 2 (18) + lone pairs (one on each P, 8; two on each S, 12). Every atom obeys the octet: electron-precise. Other phosphorus sulfides (P₄S₅, P₄S₇, P₄S₉) also exist; they are not needed in detail.

The adamantane cage

Adamantane C₁₀H₁₆ has four 3-connected CH bridgeheads and six 2-connected CH₂ bridges arranged like a piece of the diamond lattice. The same topology (4 bridgeheads, 6 bridges, four fused six-membered rings) appears across the periodic table:

CompoundBridgeheadsBridges
adamantane C₁₀H₁₆4 CH6 CH₂
hexamethylenetetramine (CH₂)₆N₄4 N6 CH₂
P₄O₆ / As₄O₆4 P / 4 As6 O
P₄O₁₀, P₄S₁₀4 P (each with a terminal O or S)6 O or S

Zintl Phases and the Zintl–Klemm Concept

The idea

In a compound of a very electropositive metal (alkali, alkaline earth) with a heavier p-block element, treat the electropositive metal as fully ionised and give its electrons to the p-block element. The anion then builds a structure that a neutral element with the same number of valence electrons would build.

Zintl phaseAnionIsoelectronic withAnion structure
NaTlTl⁻ (4 valence e⁻)C, Sidiamond-type Tl network
CaSi₂Si⁻ (5 valence e⁻)P, Aspuckered layers like grey arsenic
NaSi, KGe[Si₄]⁴⁻, [Ge₄]⁴⁻P₄isolated tetrahedra
CaC₂[C₂]²⁻N₂dumbbell

This is the Zintl–Klemm concept: the anionic partial structure follows the 8 − N rule of its isoelectronic element. It explains why NaTl is not a close-packed alloy, and why NaSi contains Si₄ tetrahedra.

Discrete Zintl ions

Solutions of Zintl phases in liquid ammonia or ethylenediamine contain discrete polyatomic anions. Crystals are obtained by adding a cryptand (2,2,2-crypt), which wraps each Na⁺ or K⁺ so that the cation cannot take its electron back and the solid does not revert to the alloy.

For the deltahedral ions use Wade’s rules with bare-atom vertices: group 14 atom 2, group 15 atom 3, group 16 atom 4 skeletal electrons (valence electrons minus 2 for the exo lone pair).

IonCountSEPWade typeShape
[Sn₅]²⁻, [Pb₅]²⁻5 × 2 + 2 = 126 = n + 1closotrigonal bipyramid
[Ge₉]²⁻9 × 2 + 2 = 2010 = n + 1closotricapped trigonal prism
[Ge₉]⁴⁻, [Sn₉]⁴⁻, [Pb₉]⁴⁻9 × 2 + 4 = 2211 = n + 2nidomonocapped square antiprism
[Bi₄]²⁻4 × 3 + 2 = 147 = n + 3arachnosquare (octahedron minus two opposite vertices)

Two electrons more on a nine-atom cluster change it from closo (tricapped trigonal prism) to nido (monocapped square antiprism). The two shapes are geometrically close, so real nine-atom ions are often intermediate.

Electron-precise Zintl anions

Not every polyanion is deltahedral. Group 15 polyanions often obey the 8 − N rule instead:

[P₇]³⁻ (also [As₇]³⁻, [Sb₇]³⁻): total valence electrons 7 × 5 + 3 = 38. Three atoms carry the negative charges; each P⁻ (six electrons) is 2-connected. The other four P atoms are 3-connected. Cage bonds = (3 × 2 + 4 × 3)/2 = 9, which matches the nortricyclane skeleton (a P₃ triangle base, three 2-connected bridges, one apical P). Check: 9 bonds × 2 = 18 electrons; lone pairs 4 × 1 + 3 × 2 = 10 pairs = 20 electrons; 18 + 20 = 38.

Polycations

The heavy p-block elements also form cationic clusters when oxidised in very weakly basic media (molten AlCl₃ salts, SO₂ or superacid solvents with AsF₅ or SbF₅), for example

$$\text{S}_8 + 3\text{AsF}_5 \xrightarrow{\text{SO}_2} [\text{S}_8][\text{AsF}_6]_2 + \text{AsF}_3$$
CationCountSEPTypeShape
[Bi₅]³⁺5 × 3 − 3 = 126 = n + 1closotrigonal bipyramid
[Bi₈]²⁺8 × 3 − 2 = 2211 = n + 3arachnosquare antiprism (10-vertex parent minus both caps)
[Te₄]²⁺, [Se₄]²⁺4 × 4 − 2 = 147 = n + 3arachnosquare planar

The square [Se₄]²⁺ and [Te₄]²⁺ ions can also be described as 6π aromatic rings: 4 × 6 − 2 = 22 valence electrons, with σ bonds and lone pairs accounting for 16 and the remaining 6 in a delocalised π system. [Bi₄]²⁻ is the isoelectronic group 15 analogue (4 × 5 + 2 = 22).

Carbon Cages: Fullerenes

C₆₀ (buckminsterfullerene) is a truncated icosahedron: 60 carbon atoms, all equivalent, each 3-connected, arranged in 12 pentagons and 20 hexagons, point group \( I_h \).

PropertyC₆₀
Vertices V60
Edges E90 (from 3V = 2E)
Faces F32 = 12 pentagons + 20 hexagons
Euler check60 − 90 + 32 = 2
Bond types6:6 ring fusions (shorter, double-bond-like) and 6:5 fusions (longer)

Points that the exam uses:

  • Isolated pentagon rule: the stable fullerenes have no two pentagons sharing an edge. C₆₀ is the smallest fullerene that satisfies it.
  • C₆₀ reacts like an electron-poor alkene at its 6:6 bonds: it adds nucleophiles and binds to low-valent metals in an η² fashion, as in (Ph₃P)₂Pt(η²-C₆₀).
  • It is readily reduced; alkali metal fullerides such as K₃C₆₀ (with C₆₀³⁻) are superconductors at low temperature.
  • Endohedral fullerenes trap an atom inside the cage, written M@C₈₂ (for example La@C₈₂).

Oxide and Water Cages

Silsesquioxanes

Hydrolysis of RSiCl₃ can give the cubic cage (RSiO₁.₅)₈: eight Si at the corners of a cube, twelve O bridging the twelve edges. Each Si is tetrahedral (three bridging O and one R). These “polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxanes” are the molecular analogue of a double four-ring in a zeolite.

Zeolites

Zeolites are aluminosilicate frameworks of corner-sharing TO₄ tetrahedra (T = Si, Al). Each Al in place of Si adds one negative charge to the framework, balanced by exchangeable cations:

$$\text{M}_{x/n}\,[(\text{AlO}_2)_x(\text{SiO}_2)_y] \cdot z\text{H}_2\text{O}$$

where n is the cation charge. Loewenstein’s rule: Al–O–Al linkages are avoided, so Si/Al ≥ 1.

The building block of several zeolites is the sodalite (β) cage, a truncated octahedron:

FeatureSodalite cage
T atoms (vertices)24
T–O–T links (edges)36
Faces14 = 6 four-rings + 8 six-rings
ZeoliteHow sodalite cages are linkedLarge cavity and window
Sodalitesharing faces directly (the truncated octahedra pack to fill space)none beyond the β cage
Zeolite A (LTA)through double four-rings (cubes)α cage with eight-ring windows
Faujasite (zeolites X and Y)through double six-rings (hexagonal prisms)supercage with twelve-ring windows

Ring size (number of T atoms in the window) controls which molecules can enter: this is the basis of molecular sieving and of shape-selective catalysis.

Clathrate hydrates

Water can build hydrogen-bonded cages around small non-polar guest molecules (CH₄, CO₂, Xe). In the common structure I hydrate the unit cell contains 46 water molecules forming 2 small pentagonal-dodecahedral cages (5¹², 20 water each, notation: twelve pentagonal faces) and 6 larger 5¹²6² cages (24 water, twelve pentagons and two hexagons). With every cage filled by methane, the ideal formula is

$$\text{CH}_4 \cdot \frac{46}{8}\text{H}_2\text{O} = \text{CH}_4 \cdot 5.75\,\text{H}_2\text{O}$$

Natural methane hydrates are rarely fully occupied, so real compositions carry more water per CH₄.

Cage ligands

Cages are also built around metal ions on purpose. The cryptand 2,2,2-crypt encloses K⁺ or Na⁺ in a three-dimensional cavity (which is why it is used to crystallise Zintl ions), and cobalt(III) “sepulchrate” complexes are made by capping [Co(en)₃]³⁺ with formaldehyde and ammonia so that the metal ends up sealed inside a macrobicyclic cage. The metal acts as a template for the cage synthesis.

Polyoxometalate Cages

Early transition metals in their highest oxidation states (V(V), Nb(V), Mo(VI), W(VI)) condense in acid into discrete metal–oxygen cages built from MO₆ octahedra sharing corners and edges.

TypeExampleStructure
Isopolyanion[Mo₆O₁₉]²⁻, [W₆O₁₉]²⁻ (Lindqvist)6 octahedra round one central O
Isopolyanion[Mo₇O₂₄]⁶⁻ (heptamolybdate), [V₁₀O₂₈]⁶⁻ (decavanadate)edge-shared octahedra
Heteropolyanion[PW₁₂O₄₀]³⁻, [SiW₁₂O₄₀]⁴⁻, [PMo₁₂O₄₀]³⁻ (Keggin)central XO₄ tetrahedron inside 12 MO₆
Heteropolyanion[P₂W₁₈O₆₂]⁶⁻ (Wells–Dawson)two Keggin-derived halves
Heteropolyanion[TeMo₆O₂₄]⁶⁻ (Anderson)planar ring of 6 octahedra round a central octahedron

The Keggin anion

In α-[XM₁₂O₄₀]ⁿ⁻ the twelve MO₆ octahedra form four M₃O₁₃ groups (each three edge-sharing octahedra), which share corners with one another and surround the central XO₄ tetrahedron. Ideal symmetry \( T_d \).

Oxygen typeNumber
central, bonded to X and three M4
terminal M=O12
bridging M–O–M (corner-sharing, between M₃O₁₃ groups)12
bridging M–O–M (edge-sharing, within M₃O₁₃ groups)12
total40

Charge from oxidation states: [PW₁₂O₄₀]: \( +5 + 12(+6) + 40(-2) = -3 \). For X = Si(IV) the charge is −4. Removing one {WO} unit gives the lacunary anion [PW₁₁O₃₉]⁷⁻ (\( 5 + 66 - 78 = -7 \)), whose vacant site can bind another metal ion.

Heteropoly blues: the Keggin molybdophosphate and tungstophosphate anions accept electrons without changing structure. Reduced forms are intensely blue mixed-valence (M(V)/M(VI)) species. The “molybdenum blue” colour developed from phosphate and molybdate is a standard analytical test for phosphate.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
P₄O₆: no terminal O, P(III)P₄O₁₀: 4 terminal O, P(V); same cage
P₄S₃: 3 S bridge edges to one apical PP₄S₁₀: all 6 edges bridged, 4 terminal S
[Sn₉]⁴⁻ (22 e⁻, nido)[Ge₉]²⁻ (20 e⁻, closo)
[P₇]³⁻: electron-precise, nortricyclane[Sn₉]⁴⁻: Wade deltahedral cage
As₄S₄: As–As cross-cage bonds, localisedS₄N₄: S···S cross-cage, delocalised S–N
Zeolite A: double 4-rings, 8-ring windowsFaujasite: double 6-rings, 12-ring windows
Isopolyanion: one kind of metal + Oheteropolyanion: central heteroatom X (P, Si) as well
Endohedral M@C₈₂: inside the cagefulleride K₃C₆₀: cations outside, between cages

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. How many skeletal electrons does a bare Pb atom contribute to a Wade cluster?
  2. How many hexagonal faces does the fullerene C₈₀ have?
  3. What is the charge on the Keggin anion [SiW₁₂O₄₀]?
Answers
  1. 4 − 2 = 2.
  2. Pentagons = 12 always; hexagons = (V − 20)/2 = (80 − 20)/2 = 30. (From 5p + 6h = 2E = 3V: 60 + 6h = 240, h = 30.)
  3. 4 + 72 − 80 = −4: [SiW₁₂O₄₀]⁴⁻.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. According to Wade’s rules, the Zintl ion [Pb₅]²⁻ is:

(a) nido, square pyramid (b) closo, trigonal bipyramid (c) arachno, butterfly (d) electron-precise, planar pentagon

Answer: (b)

5 × 2 + 2 = 12 electrons, 6 pairs = n + 1: closo, a five-vertex deltahedron, the trigonal bipyramid.

Practice Q2. In the molecule P₄S₃, the numbers of P–P and P–S bonds are respectively:

(a) 6 and 0 (b) 3 and 6 (c) 0 and 6 (d) 3 and 3

Answer: (b)

The three basal P atoms form a triangle (3 P–P bonds). Each basal P bonds to one S (3 P–S) and each S bonds to the apical P (3 more P–S): 6 P–S bonds. Total 9 bonds, consistent with 38 valence electrons and octets on all atoms.

Practice Q3. The Zintl phase NaSi contains:

(a) a diamond-type Si network (b) isolated [Si₄]⁴⁻ tetrahedra (c) Si₂ dumbbells (d) planar Si₆ rings

Answer: (b)

Si⁻ has 5 valence electrons, like P. With 4 Si⁻ units the anion copies P₄: a tetrahedron with three bonds per atom (20 valence electrons = 5n). A diamond network (a) would need 4 valence electrons per atom, as Tl⁻ has in NaTl.

Practice Q4. The number of oxygen atoms bridging two metal atoms (μ₂-O) in an α-Keggin anion [XM₁₂O₄₀]ⁿ⁻ is:

(a) 12 (b) 24 (c) 36 (d) 4

Answer: (b)

12 corner-sharing plus 12 edge-sharing μ₂-O = 24. The other 16 are 12 terminal and 4 central (bonded to X).

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. Consider the following species and statements:

  1. [Ge₉]²⁻ and [Ge₉]⁴⁻ differ by one skeletal electron pair; the dianion is closo and the tetraanion nido.
  2. [Bi₈]²⁺ is an arachno cluster whose shape is a square antiprism.
  3. [Te₄]²⁺ is a closo tetrahedron.
  4. [P₇]³⁻ has nine P–P bonds and three two-connected P atoms.

Which are correct?

(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
  1. [Ge₉]²⁻: 18 + 2 = 20 → 10 pairs = n + 1, closo. [Ge₉]⁴⁻: 22 → 11 = n + 2, nido. Correct.
  2. [Bi₈]²⁺: 24 − 2 = 22 → 11 = n + 3, arachno; the 10-vertex bicapped square antiprism minus its two caps is a square antiprism. Correct.
  3. [Te₄]²⁺: 16 − 2 = 14 → 7 = n + 3, arachno: square planar, not tetrahedral. Wrong.
  4. 38 valence electrons; three P⁻ are 2-connected, four P are 3-connected; bonds = (6 + 12)/2 = 9. Correct.

Practice Q6. A structure I methane hydrate has 46 H₂O per unit cell with 2 small and 6 large cages. A natural sample analyses as CH₄·6.0H₂O. Assuming the water framework is intact, what fraction of the cages is occupied by methane?

(a) 0.92 (b) 0.96 (c) 1.00 (d) 0.85

Answer: (b) 0.96

Methane per unit cell = 46/6.0 = 7.67. Cages per unit cell = 8. Fraction = 7.67/8 = 0.958 ≈ 0.96. A fully occupied cell would give CH₄·5.75H₂O.

Practice Q7. Which statements about cages are correct?

  1. Every closed cage of 3-connected atoms with only five- and six-membered faces contains exactly 12 five-membered faces.
  2. In zeolites, Loewenstein’s rule allows Si/Al ratios below 1.
  3. The sodalite cage has 24 tetrahedral atoms and 14 faces.
  4. P₄O₁₀ and hexamethylenetetramine have the same cage topology.

(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only

Statement 1 is the Euler result (p = 12). Statement 2 is wrong: forbidding Al–O–Al means at least as many Si as Al, Si/Al ≥ 1. Statement 3: truncated octahedron, 24 vertices, 6 squares + 8 hexagons = 14 faces. Statement 4: both are adamantane-type cages (4 bridgeheads, 6 bridges).

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
Electron-precisepairs = edges; 3-connected cage needs 5n valence electrons
5n examplesP₄ 20, [Si₄]⁴⁻ 20, prismane 30, cubane 40, dodecahedrane 100
P₄ insertionsP₄O₆ (6 bridging O), P₄O₁₀ (+4 terminal), P₄S₃ (3 bridging S, C₃ᵥ), P₄S₁₀
Adamantane familyC₁₀H₁₆, (CH₂)₆N₄, P₄O₆, As₄O₆, P₄O₁₀, P₄S₁₀
Zintl–KlemmNaTl diamond (Tl⁻ ≈ C), CaSi₂ layers (Si⁻ ≈ As), NaSi/KGe E₄⁴⁻ tetrahedra
Wade Zintl anions[Sn₅]²⁻ TBP closo; [Ge₉]²⁻ closo TTP; [Sn₉]⁴⁻ nido capped square antiprism; [Bi₄]²⁻ square
Electron-precise anion[P₇]³⁻ nortricyclane, 9 bonds
Polycations[Bi₅]³⁺ TBP; [Bi₈]²⁺ square antiprism; [Te₄]²⁺, [Se₄]²⁺ square (6π); [Bi₉]⁵⁺ is an exception
Isolationcryptand for anions; superacid / molten salt for cations
Fullerenes12 pentagons always; C₆₀: 60 V, 90 E, 32 F, Iₕ; IPR; K₃C₆₀ superconducting
ZeolitesM(x/n)[(AlO₂)ₓ(SiO₂)ᵧ]; Si/Al ≥ 1; sodalite cage 24 T, 14 faces; A: D4R, 8-ring; faujasite: D6R, 12-ring
Hydrate sI46 H₂O, 2 + 6 cages; CH₄·5.75H₂O ideal
Keggin[XM₁₂O₄₀]ⁿ⁻, Td; O: 4 + 12 + 12 + 12; [PW₁₂O₄₀]³⁻, [SiW₁₂O₄₀]⁴⁻; lacunary [PW₁₁O₃₉]⁷⁻
Lindqvist[M₆O₁₉]: 1 μ₆ + 12 μ₂ + 6 terminal; Mo, W → 2−; Nb → 8−

Key Takeaways

What’s Next