Skip to content

Metal Carbonyl Clusters and Electron Counting

CSIR NET chemistry: carbonyl cluster structures, 18-electron and Wade–Mingos counting, cluster valence electrons, capping and fusion rules, isolobal analogy.

  • 18 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 14 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: When the 18-Electron Rule Runs Out
  3. What Counts as a Metal Cluster
  4. Binary Carbonyl Clusters
  5. Counting Method 1: The 18-Electron Rule per Metal
  6. Counting Method 2: Wade–Mingos Rules (PSEPT)
  7. The Isolobal Analogy
  8. Memory Tricks
  9. Don’t Confuse
  10. Common Mistakes
  11. Practice
  12. Quick Revision Table
  13. Key Takeaways
  14. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: When the 18-Electron Rule Runs Out

What Counts as a Metal Cluster

A metal cluster is a compound containing a group of two or more metal atoms held together, at least in part, by direct metal–metal bonds (the definition introduced by F. A. Cotton). Two broad families exist:

Low-valent clustersHigh-valent clusters
Metalsmid and late transition metals (Fe, Ru, Os, Co, Rh, Ir, Ni)early and mid transition metals (Nb, Ta, Mo, W, Re)
Oxidation statelow (often 0 or negative)moderate (+2 to +3)
Ligandsπ-acceptors: CO, PR₃, Cp, Hπ-donors: halides, chalcogenides, carboxylates
Counting18-electron rule, Wade–Mingos rulesd-electron count per metal–metal bond
ExampleOs₃(CO)₁₂, Rh₆(CO)₁₆[Re₂Cl₈]²⁻, [Mo₆Cl₈]⁴⁺, [Nb₆Cl₁₂]²⁺

This page treats the low-valent (carbonyl) family; the high-valent family is on the next page.

Binary Carbonyl Clusters

ClusterMetal frameworkCO arrangement
Mn₂(CO)₁₀Mn–Mn (unbridged)10 terminal, staggered
Fe₂(CO)₉Fe–Fe6 terminal + 3 μ₂-CO
Co₂(CO)₈Co–Cosolid: 6 terminal + 2 μ₂-CO; solution: bridged and unbridged isomers
Fe₃(CO)₁₂triangle10 terminal + 2 μ₂-CO on one edge
Ru₃(CO)₁₂, Os₃(CO)₁₂triangle12 terminal (\( D_{3h} \))
Co₄(CO)₁₂, Rh₄(CO)₁₂tetrahedron9 terminal + 3 μ₂-CO round one face
Ir₄(CO)₁₂tetrahedron12 terminal (\( T_d \))
Rh₆(CO)₁₆octahedron12 terminal + 4 μ₃-CO on alternate faces
Os₅(CO)₁₆trigonal bipyramidterminal
Os₆(CO)₁₈bicapped tetrahedronterminal

How carbonyl clusters are made

  • Thermal or photochemical loss of CO from smaller carbonyls: Fe(CO)₅ photolysis gives Fe₂(CO)₉; warming Co₂(CO)₈ gives Co₄(CO)₁₂; pyrolysis of Os₃(CO)₁₂ gives a family of higher clusters (Os₅, Os₆, Os₇, Os₈ species); heating Ru₃(CO)₁₂ can give the carbido cluster Ru₆C(CO)₁₇, the carbon coming from CO.
  • Redox condensation: a carbonyl anion attacks a neutral carbonyl or cluster, CO is lost, and nuclearity grows. This route gives many of the large anionic Rh, Pt and Ni clusters.

Identifying CO bonding modes by IR

ModeApproximate ν(CO), cm⁻¹ (neutral clusters)
terminal2125–1850
μ₂ (edge-bridging)1850–1750
μ₃ (face-capping)1730–1620

More metals sharing a CO means more back-donation into CO π*, a weaker C–O bond and a lower stretching frequency. Negative charge on the cluster lowers all the frequencies further, so compare like with like.

Counting Method 1: The 18-Electron Rule per Metal

Add up all valence electrons of the cluster, the cluster valence electron count (CVE), using the neutral-atom convention:

ContributorElectrons
metal atomits group number (Fe 8, Co 9, Ni 10, Os 8, Rh 9)
CO (terminal, μ₂ or μ₃)2
PR₃2
H (terminal or bridging)1
η⁵-C₅H₅5
Cl, Br, I: terminal / μ₂ / μ₃1 / 3 / 5
NO (linear)3
μ₃-CR (alkylidyne)3
μ₃-S4
μ₃-PR4
interstitial C / N4 / 5 (all valence electrons)
negative charge+1 each

If every metal obeys the 18-electron rule and each M–M bond is a 2c–2e bond,

$$\boxed{\text{number of M–M bonds} = \frac{18n - \text{CVE}}{2}}$$

The rule works for triangles, tetrahedra, butterflies, squares, trigonal bipyramids and square pyramids, because these polyhedra have three-connected or nearly so vertices where localised bonds suffice. It gives the expected electron count for any polyhedron as

$$\text{CVE}_{\text{localised}} = 18n - 2E$$

with E the number of edges. For the octahedron it predicts 108 − 24 = 84, but octahedral clusters have 86. For deltahedra with more than five vertices, delocalised bonding takes over.

Counting Method 2: Wade–Mingos Rules (PSEPT)

Mingos extended Wade’s rules to transition-metal clusters. Each metal uses 9 valence orbitals; 6 of them hold 12 electrons for metal–ligand bonding and non-bonding d electrons; 3 are left for the skeleton. So

$$\boxed{\text{skeletal electrons} = \text{CVE} - 12n}$$

which is the same as adding v + x − 12 for each vertex fragment. Then use the familiar table:

SEPTypeCVE
n − 1bicapped closo14n − 2
ncapped closo14n
n + 1closo14n + 2
n + 2nido14n + 4
n + 3arachno14n + 6

(CVE = 12n + 2 × SEP.)

The master table of cluster valence electrons

nPolyhedronEdges18n − 2EWade (14n + k)Observed CVEExample
3triangle34814n + 6 = 48 (arachno)48Os₃(CO)₁₂
4tetrahedron66014n + 4 = 60 (nido)60Co₄(CO)₁₂, Ir₄(CO)₁₂
4butterfly56214n + 6 = 62 (arachno)62Fe₄C(CO)₁₃
4square464—64(planar M₄)
5trigonal bipyramid97214n + 2 = 72 (closo)72Os₅(CO)₁₆
5square pyramid87414n + 4 = 74 (nido)74Fe₅C(CO)₁₅
6octahedron128414n + 2 = 86 (closo)86Rh₆(CO)₁₆, Ru₆C(CO)₁₇
6trigonal prism990—90[Rh₆C(CO)₁₅]²⁻
6capped trigonal bipyramid (bicapped tetrahedron)128414n = 84 (capped)84Os₆(CO)₁₈
8cube12120—120(cubic M₈)

Two rules of thumb follow:

  • Small or 3-connected polyhedra (triangle, tetrahedron, butterfly, square, trigonal prism, cube): 18n − 2E works; the bonding is effectively localised.
  • Deltahedra of six or more vertices: use 14n + 2 (closo), 14n + 4 (nido) and so on.

For the trigonal bipyramid and square pyramid the two methods agree.

Worked examples with interstitial atoms

An interstitial (encapsulated) main-group atom donates all its valence electrons to the cluster and occupies no vertex.

The capping principle

Adding a metal fragment over a triangular face of a closo cluster adds one vertex but no skeletal bonding orbital: the capping fragment’s three orbitals match the three-fold face orbitals that are already used. In CVE terms

$$\boxed{\text{each face cap adds 12 CVE}}$$

(The cap’s 12 electrons fill its own metal–ligand and non-bonding orbitals; it adds nothing to the skeleton.)

ClusterCVEReading
Os₆(CO)₁₈48 + 36 = 8484 = 72 + 12: capped trigonal bipyramid (SEP = 6 = n)
[Os₆(CO)₁₈]²⁻86closo octahedron (adding 2 electrons closes the cage)
Os₇(CO)₂₁56 + 42 = 9898 = 86 + 12: capped octahedron (SEP = 7 = n)
[Os₈(CO)₂₂]²⁻64 + 44 + 2 = 110110 = 86 + 24: bicapped octahedron (SEP = 7 = n − 1)

The pair Os₆(CO)₁₈ / [Os₆(CO)₁₈]²⁻ is the cluster version of the borane hook: two electrons change the shape, here from capped trigonal bipyramid to octahedron.

Condensed polyhedra: the fusion rule

For clusters built from smaller polyhedra that share a vertex, an edge or a face (Mingos’ fusion or condensation rule):

$$\boxed{\text{CVE}(\text{condensed}) = \text{CVE}(A) + \text{CVE}(B) - \text{CVE}(\text{shared unit})}$$

with the shared unit counted as a mononuclear (18), dinuclear (34) or trinuclear triangular (48) fragment.

Condensed clusterCalculationResult
two triangles sharing a vertex (“bow-tie”)48 + 48 − 1878, as in Os₅(CO)₁₉
two tetrahedra sharing a face60 + 60 − 4872 = trigonal bipyramid
trigonal bipyramid + tetrahedron sharing a face72 + 60 − 4884 = bicapped tetrahedron, as in Os₆(CO)₁₈
two triangles sharing an edge48 + 48 − 3462 = butterfly

The last line shows the rules are consistent: a butterfly is two triangles hinged along a common edge.

The Isolobal Analogy

Hoffmann’s isolobal analogy connects organic and inorganic fragments. Two fragments are isolobal if the number, symmetry properties, approximate energy and shape of their frontier orbitals, and the number of electrons in them, are similar. The symbol is a double-headed arrow with a half orbital below it, written here as ↔.

Building the table

Start from an octahedral ML₆ and remove ligands. Each removed ligand leaves a hybrid orbital pointing to the vacant site. Compare with CH₄ losing H atoms. The matching condition is “as many electrons short of 18 as the organic fragment is short of 8”:

Organic fragmentShort of octetMetal fragmentd countShort of 18
CH₃ (1 orbital, 1 e)1Mn(CO)₅, Re(CO)₅, CpFe(CO)₂d⁷ ML₅1
CH₂ (2 orbitals, 2 e)2Fe(CO)₄, Os(CO)₄, CpCo(CO)d⁸ ML₄2
CH (3 orbitals, 3 e)3Co(CO)₃, Ir(CO)₃, CpNid⁹ ML₃3

Check CpFe(CO)₂: 5 + 8 + 4 = 17, one short of 18, like CH₃ (7 electrons). CpNi: 5 + 10 = 15, three short, like CH.

Related fragments: Fe(CO)₃ (14 electrons) and CpCo (14 electrons) have three frontier orbitals holding two electrons, so in cluster chemistry they are isolobal with BH and with CH⁺. That is the Wade link: BH, Fe(CO)₃ and CpCo all contribute 2 skeletal electrons.

Using it

Organic or main-group moleculeIsolobal metal analogue
ethane, H₃C–CH₃Mn₂(CO)₁₀, (CO)₅Mn–CH₃
cyclopropane, (CH₂)₃Os₃(CO)₁₂ = [Os(CO)₄]₃; Fe(CO)₄(η²-C₂H₄) as a metallacyclopropane
tetrahedrane, (CR)₄Co₃(CO)₉(μ₃-CR); Co₂(CO)₆(μ-RC≡CR); Co₄(CO)₁₂
B₅H₉ (nido, square pyramid)Fe(CO)₃B₄H₈-type cage (a BH vertex replaced by Fe(CO)₃; count only)
ferrocene, Cp₂Fe[Fe(C₂B₉H₁₁)₂]²⁻ (dicarbollide ↔ Cp⁻)

The analogy predicts structure and bonding patterns, not identical chemistry: Mn₂(CO)₁₀ and ethane are isolobal but react very differently.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
CVE (all valence electrons)skeletal electrons (CVE − 12n)
18n − 2E: localised bonding14n + 2: closo deltahedra with n ≥ 6
Octahedron 86trigonal prism 90; capped trigonal bipyramid 84
Os₆(CO)₁₈ (84, capped TBP)[Os₆(CO)₁₈]²⁻ (86, octahedron)
Interstitial C: donates 4, no vertexμ₃-CR: a vertex-capping ligand donating 3
Bridging H: 1 electronbridging Cl: 3 electrons
Fe(CO)₄ ↔ CH₂Fe(CO)₃ ↔ BH (cluster vertex)
Isolobal: frontier orbitals alikeisoelectronic: same total electrons

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. What is the CVE of Ir₄(CO)₁₂?
  2. Which organic fragment is isolobal with Mn(CO)₅?
  3. How many electrons does a face cap add to the CVE?
Answers
  1. 4 × 9 + 12 × 2 = 60 (tetrahedron).
  2. CH₃ (both one electron short of a closed shell, one frontier orbital).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. Os₅(CO)₁₆ is expected to have the metal framework of a:

(a) square pyramid (b) trigonal bipyramid (c) bow-tie (d) planar pentagon

Answer: (b)

CVE = 5 × 8 + 16 × 2 = 72 = 14n + 2 (n = 5): closo trigonal bipyramid. A square pyramid needs 74, a bow-tie 78.

Practice Q2. The number of metal–metal bonds predicted by the 18-electron rule for Fe₃(CO)₁₂ is:

(a) 2 (b) 3 (c) 4 (d) 6

Answer: (b)

CVE = 24 + 24 = 48; (54 − 48)/2 = 3: a triangle. The two bridging carbonyls do not change the count (a μ₂-CO still gives 2 electrons).

Practice Q3. The cluster anion [Rh₆C(CO)₁₅]²⁻ has a CVE and geometry of:

(a) 86, octahedron (b) 88, capped square pyramid (c) 90, trigonal prism (d) 84, bicapped tetrahedron

Answer: (c)

54 + 4 (carbide) + 30 + 2 (charge) = 90 = 18 × 6 − 2 × 9: a trigonal prism (9 edges), with C at the centre.

Practice Q4. Which fragment is isolobal with CH₂?

(a) Co(CO)₃ (b) Mn(CO)₅ (c) CpCo(CO) (d) CpNi

Answer: (c)

CpCo(CO): 5 + 9 + 2 = 16, two short of 18, like CH₂ (6 electrons, two short of 8), with two frontier orbitals. Co(CO)₃ and CpNi are CH-like (15 electrons); Mn(CO)₅ is CH₃-like.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. Two clusters of formula M₃(CO)₁₂, one with M = Fe and one with M = Ru, give the following IR spectra in hexane (ν(CO), cm⁻¹):

  • Sample X: strong bands between 2060 and 2010 only.
  • Sample Y: strong bands between 2050 and 2000 plus a weaker band near 1830.

Which statements are correct?

  1. Y contains bridging carbonyl ligands; X does not.
  2. Y is the iron compound and X the ruthenium compound.
  3. Both have a CVE of 48 and three M–M bonds.
  4. The band near 1830 cm⁻¹ indicates a μ₃-CO.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only

A band near 1830 cm⁻¹ falls in the μ₂ (edge-bridging) range, so Y has bridging CO (1 correct, 4 wrong: μ₃-CO absorbs lower, roughly 1730–1620 cm⁻¹). Fe₃(CO)₁₂ has two bridging CO; Ru₃(CO)₁₂ has only terminal CO (2 correct). For both, CVE = 3 × 8 + 24 = 48 and (54 − 48)/2 = 3 bonds (3 correct).

Practice Q6. Consider Os₆(CO)₁₈ and its dianion [Os₆(CO)₁₈]²⁻. Which statements are correct?

  1. Os₆(CO)₁₈ has 84 cluster valence electrons and 6 skeletal electron pairs.
  2. [Os₆(CO)₁₈]²⁻ is a closo octahedron.
  3. Os₆(CO)₁₈ can be described as a trigonal bipyramid with one face capped.
  4. Both obey 18n − 2E with E = 12.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. 48 + 36 = 84; 84 − 72 = 12 skeletal electrons = 6 pairs = n: capped. Correct.
  2. 86; 14 skeletal electrons = 7 pairs = n + 1: closo octahedron. Correct.
  3. Capped closo (n − 1 = 5): a capped trigonal bipyramid (the same shape as a bicapped tetrahedron). Correct.
  4. 18 × 6 − 2 × 12 = 84 fits the neutral cluster (12 edges in a bicapped tetrahedron) but not the octahedral dianion (86). Wrong.

Practice Q7. A planar raft cluster M₅ consists of three triangles, each sharing an edge with the next (M = Os, all ligands CO). Using the fusion rule, the predicted CVE and the number of CO ligands for a neutral Os₅(CO)ₓ with this framework are:

(a) 76 and 18 (b) 78 and 19 (c) 72 and 16 (d) 74 and 17

Answer: (a) 76 and 18

Three triangles (48 each) sharing two edges (34 each): 3 × 48 − 2 × 34 = 144 − 68 = 76. With five Os (40 electrons), CO must supply 36, so x = 18. (78 is the bow-tie: two triangles sharing a vertex.) This is a prediction from the rule, used here as a counting exercise.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
Cluster≥ 2 metals with direct M–M bonds; low-valent (CO) vs high-valent (halide)
Binary clustersFe₃(CO)₁₂ 2 μ-CO; Ru₃, Os₃(CO)₁₂ none; Co₄, Rh₄(CO)₁₂ 3 μ-CO; Ir₄(CO)₁₂ none; Rh₆(CO)₁₆ 4 μ₃-CO
IR ν(CO)terminal 2125–1850; μ₂ 1850–1750; μ₃ 1730–1620 cm⁻¹ (approx.)
Neutral countingmetal = group number; CO 2; H 1; Cp 5; μ₂-Cl 3; μ₃-CR 3; interstitial C 4, N 5
18-electron ruleM–M bonds = (18n − CVE)/2; CVE = 18n − 2E for localised polyhedra
Wade–Mingosskeletal electrons = CVE − 12n; closo 14n + 2, nido 14n + 4, arachno 14n + 6, capped 14n
CVE table48 triangle, 60 tetrahedron, 62 butterfly, 64 square, 72 TBP, 74 square pyramid, 84 capped TBP, 86 octahedron, 90 trigonal prism, 98 capped octahedron, 120 cube
ExamplesOs₅(CO)₁₆ 72; Fe₅C(CO)₁₅ 74; Ru₆C(CO)₁₇ 86; [Rh₆C(CO)₁₅]²⁻ 90; Os₆(CO)₁₈ 84; Os₇(CO)₂₁ 98; [Os₈(CO)₂₂]²⁻ 110
UnsaturatedH₂Os₃(CO)₁₀, 46 electrons
Capping+12 CVE per cap, 0 SEP
Fusionsubtract 18 (vertex), 34 (edge), 48 (face); bow-tie 78
IsolobalCH₃ ↔ Mn(CO)₅, CpFe(CO)₂; CH₂ ↔ Fe(CO)₄, CpCo(CO); CH ↔ Co(CO)₃, CpNi; BH ↔ Fe(CO)₃, CpCo
AnaloguesMn₂(CO)₁₀ ↔ ethane; Os₃(CO)₁₂ ↔ cyclopropane; Co₂(CO)₆(alkyne), Co₃(CO)₉CR ↔ tetrahedrane

Key Takeaways

What’s Next