Electronegativity Scales and Periodic Anomalies
CSIR NET chemistry: Pauling, Mulliken and Allred-Rochow electronegativity, first-row anomaly, diagonal relationship, inert pair effect, secondary periodicity.
- 17 min
On this page · 15 sections
Prerequisites
- Electronic Configuration, Shielding and Effective Nuclear Charge for \( Z_{\text{eff}} \).
- Atomic and Ionic Radii for covalent radii and the contractions.
- Ionisation Energy and Electron Affinity: Mulliken’s scale is built from these two quantities.
The Hook: A Bond Stronger Than Its Parents
Electronegativity: The Definition
Two things follow from the definition. Electronegativity is a property of a bonded atom, not of an isolated one (so it is not the same as electron affinity), and it is not directly measurable: each scale defines it through a different measurable quantity, and the scales are then adjusted to give similar numbers.
The Pauling Scale
Pauling compared the dissociation energy of a bond A–B with the mean of the A–A and B–B bond energies. The excess \( \Delta \) is attributed to ionic–covalent resonance:
$$\Delta = D(\text{A–B}) - \sqrt{D(\text{A–A})\,D(\text{B–B})}$$$$\boxed{\lvert \chi_A - \chi_B \rvert = 0.102\,\sqrt{\Delta}} \qquad (\Delta \text{ in kJ mol}^{-1})$$The factor 0.102 is \( 1/\sqrt{96.485} \): with \( \Delta \) in eV the relation is simply \( \lvert\Delta\chi\rvert = \sqrt{\Delta/\text{eV}} \). Pauling’s original version used the arithmetic mean; the geometric mean works better when the two bond energies are very different. The scale is anchored by fixing one value; on the current (Allred, 1961) revision \( \chi_\text{F} = 3.98 \) and \( \chi_\text{H} = 2.20 \).
Pauling values to know
| H 2.20 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Li 0.98 | Be 1.57 | B 2.04 | C 2.55 | N 3.04 | O 3.44 | F 3.98 |
| Na 0.93 | Mg 1.31 | Al 1.61 | Si 1.90 | P 2.19 | S 2.58 | Cl 3.16 |
| K 0.82 | Ca 1.00 | Ga 1.81 | Ge 2.01 | As 2.18 | Se 2.55 | Br 2.96 |
| Cs 0.79 | I 2.66 |
Useful coincidences: C and Se are both 2.55, C and S are close (2.55 and 2.58), and N (3.04) is a little below Cl (3.16). The order F > O > Cl > N > Br is the one most often tested.
The Mulliken Scale
Mulliken defined electronegativity as the average of the ionisation energy and the electron affinity, both in eV:
$$\boxed{\chi_M = \frac{I + E_{\text{ea}}}{2}}$$The idea is direct: an atom that holds its own electrons tightly (high \( I \)) and welcomes an extra one (high \( E_{\text{ea}} \)) will attract electrons in a bond. With ground-state values:
- Cl: \( I = 12.97 \) eV, \( E_{\text{ea}} = 3.61 \) eV, so \( \chi_M = 8.29 \) eV.
- F: \( I = 17.42 \) eV, \( E_{\text{ea}} = 3.40 \) eV, so \( \chi_M = 10.41 \) eV.
Mulliken values are roughly proportional to Pauling values, and empirical conversions exist. Strictly, Mulliken’s definition uses valence-state ionisation energies and electron affinities (for the hybridised atom in the molecule), not ground-state atomic values. This is the scale’s great strength: it shows that electronegativity depends on the orbital involved. An sp-hybridised carbon (50% s character) is more electronegative than an sp³ carbon (25% s), which is why ethyne is far more acidic than ethane.
The Allred–Rochow Scale
Allred and Rochow took electronegativity to be the electrostatic force exerted by the nucleus, screened by \( Z_{\text{eff}} \), on a valence electron at the covalent radius \( r \):
$$\boxed{\chi_{AR} = 0.359\,\frac{Z_{\text{eff}}}{r^2} + 0.744} \qquad (r \text{ in Å})$$The constants are chosen to bring the numbers onto the Pauling range. \( Z_{\text{eff}} \) is taken from Slater’s rules.
The Allred–Rochow scale makes the periodic trend transparent: \( Z_{\text{eff}} \) rises and \( r \) falls across a period, so \( \chi \) rises sharply; down a group \( r \) grows while \( Z_{\text{eff}} \) barely changes, so \( \chi \) falls.
Other scales, briefly
| Scale | Basis |
|---|---|
| Sanderson | ratio of the atom’s average electron density to that of a hypothetical isoelectronic inert atom; introduced electronegativity equalisation on bond formation |
| Allen | average one-electron energy of the valence-shell electrons, from atomic spectroscopy |
| Hinze and Jaffé (extending Mulliken) | orbital electronegativity, varying with hybridisation and charge |
What Changes Electronegativity
- Position in the table: rises across a period, falls down a group, with the anomalies below.
- Oxidation state: a higher oxidation state is more electronegative. On the revised Pauling scale Tl(I) is 1.62 and Tl(III) 2.04; Sn(II) 1.80 and Sn(IV) 1.96; Pb(II) 1.87 and Pb(IV) 2.33.
- Hybridisation: more s character, higher electronegativity: \( \text{C}_{sp} > \text{C}_{sp^2} > \text{C}_{sp^3} \).
- Substituents (group electronegativity): CF₃ behaves as a strongly electronegative group, CH₃ as a weakly electron-releasing one.
Electronegativity difference predicts bond polarity (see Bonding in Heteronuclear Molecules for dipole moments and percentage ionic character) and the acid–base nature of oxides: across period 3, Na₂O and MgO are basic, Al₂O₃ amphoteric, and SiO₂, P₄O₁₀, SO₃ and Cl₂O₇ increasingly acidic.
Periodic Anomalies
The simple trends describe most of the table. Five groups of exceptions come up again and again.
graph TD
A[Periodic anomalies] --> B[First-row anomaly]
A --> C[Diagonal relationship]
A --> D[Inert pair effect]
A --> E[Secondary periodicity in period 4]
A --> F[Relativistic effects in period 6]
B --> B1[Small size, high EN, no low-lying d, max covalency 4]
C --> C1[Similar charge to radius ratio: Li-Mg, Be-Al, B-Si]
D --> D1[Tl+, Pb2+, Bi3+ favoured over group oxidation state]
E --> E1[Poor 3d shielding: Ga, As, Se, Br reluctant to reach highest states]
F --> F1[6s contraction: Au, Hg, inert pair]1. The first-row anomaly
The first member of each main group (Li, Be, B, C, N, O, F) differs sharply from the rest of its group. Reasons: very small size, high electronegativity and ionisation energy, and no low-lying d orbitals, so the valence shell holds at most four electron pairs.
| Feature | First-row element | Heavier congeners |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum covalency | 4 (NCl₃ exists, NCl₅ does not; OF₂ but no OF₄) | PCl₅, SF₆, IF₇ |
| Multiple bonding | strong pπ–pπ bonds: N₂, O₂, CO₂ are small molecules | P₄, S₈ and polymeric SiO₂ (single bonds preferred) |
| Single bond to itself | weak N–N, O–O, F–F (lone-pair repulsion at short distance) | stronger P–P, S–S, Cl–Cl (F–F about 158, Cl–Cl about 242 kJ mol⁻¹) |
| Catenation | C outstanding | Si, Ge much weaker |
| Hydrogen bonding | N, O, F hydrides strongly H-bonded (high boiling points of NH₃, H₂O, HF) | weak in PH₃, H₂S, HCl |
2. The diagonal relationship
The first element of groups 1, 2 and 13 resembles the second element of the next group, diagonally below and to the right. Moving right raises charge and shrinks size; moving down enlarges size. The two changes roughly cancel, giving similar charge-to-radius ratio (polarising power) and similar electronegativity.
| Pair | Shared properties |
|---|---|
| Li–Mg | form normal oxides (Li₂O, MgO) rather than peroxides on burning; react directly with N₂ to give nitrides (Li₃N, Mg₃N₂); carbonates decompose on heating to the oxide; fluorides, carbonates and phosphates sparingly soluble; chlorides deliquescent and soluble in ethanol; covalent organometallics |
| Be–Al | amphoteric oxides and hydroxides; rendered passive by concentrated HNO₃; chlorides are covalent, Lewis acidic, bridged (BeCl₂ chains, Al₂Cl₆ dimers) and fume in moist air; carbides Be₂C and Al₄C₃ give methane with water |
| B–Si | non-metallic, semiconducting; acidic oxides that form glasses (B₂O₃, SiO₂); volatile, flammable hydrides; halides hydrolyse readily to boric and silicic acids |
3. The inert pair effect
In groups 13–16 the heavier elements increasingly prefer an oxidation state two below the group value, keeping the ns² pair:
| Group | Light elements prefer | Heaviest element prefers | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | +3 (B, Al) | Tl(I) | Tl(III) compounds are oxidising |
| 14 | +4 (C, Si) | Pb(II) | PbO₂ is a strong oxidising agent |
| 15 | +5 (P) | Bi(III) | sodium bismuthate oxidises Mn²⁺ to MnO₄⁻ |
The ns electrons of the heaviest elements are held tightly (high \( I \) for Tl, Pb, Bi; see Ionisation Energy and Electron Affinity), partly because of poor shielding by 4f and 5d electrons and partly because of relativistic stabilisation of 6s. Equally important, bonds formed by these large atoms are weak, so the energy released in forming two extra bonds does not repay the cost of using the ns² pair.
4. Secondary periodicity (the period 4 “alternation”)
The period 4 p-block elements Ga, Ge, As, Se and Br follow the 3d series. Their ns electrons are held more tightly than the group trend predicts (the d-block contraction), so these elements are reluctant to reach their highest oxidation state:
- AsCl₅ is known only at low temperature, whereas PCl₅ and SbCl₅ are stable.
- Perbromate was not prepared until 1968, although perchlorate and periodate had long been known; BrO₄⁻ is a stronger oxidant than ClO₄⁻ or IO₄⁻ under comparable conditions.
- Selenic acid is a stronger oxidising agent than sulfuric acid.
Group trends in these properties therefore zig-zag (period 3 → 4 → 5) instead of running smoothly.
5. Relativistic effects in period 6
For heavy atoms the inner electrons move at a significant fraction of the speed of light. The main chemical result is that s (and to a lesser extent p) orbitals contract and are stabilised, while d and f orbitals expand. In period 6 this gives:
- the high ionisation energy and electron affinity of gold, and the existence of the auride ion in CsAu;
- the yellow colour of gold (a 5d → 6s transition shifted into the visible);
- the low melting point of mercury (tightly held \( 6s^2 \) electrons contribute little to metallic bonding);
- a contribution to the inert pair effect in Tl, Pb and Bi.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Electronegativity: atom in a molecule, no units on Pauling scale | electron affinity: isolated gaseous atom, kJ mol⁻¹ | |
| Highest electronegativity: F | highest electron affinity: Cl | |
| Pauling: from bond energies | Mulliken: from \( I \) and \( E_{\text{ea}} \); Allred–Rochow: from \( Z_{\text{eff}}/r^2 \) | |
| Diagonal relationship: Be resembles Al | group relationship: Be with Mg (often less similar) | |
| Inert pair effect: heavy elements of groups 13–16 | lanthanide contraction: size of 5d elements | |
| Secondary periodicity: period 4 (As, Se, Br) | relativistic effects: period 6 (Au, Hg, Tl, Pb, Bi) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which is more electronegative on the Pauling scale, N or Cl?
- Name the diagonal partner of beryllium.
- Which oxidation state of thallium is more stable, +1 or +3?
Answers
- Cl (3.16 against 3.04).
- Aluminium.
- +1, by the inert pair effect; Tl(III) compounds are oxidising.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Given bond energies (kJ mol⁻¹) H–H 436, Br–Br 193 and H–Br 366, the Pauling electronegativity difference between H and Br (geometric-mean method) is closest to:
(a) 0.45 (b) 0.89 (c) 1.25 (d) 8.7
Answer: (b) 0.89
\( \sqrt{436 \times 193} = \sqrt{84\,148} \approx 290.1 \) kJ mol⁻¹. \( \Delta = 366 - 290.1 = 75.9 \) kJ mol⁻¹.
\( \lvert\Delta\chi\rvert = 0.102 \times \sqrt{75.9} = 0.102 \times 8.71 \approx 0.89 \).
Option (d) forgets the factor 0.102 (it is just \( \sqrt{75.9} \approx 8.7 \), with \( \Delta \) in kJ mol⁻¹). The tabulated difference is \( 2.96 - 2.20 = 0.76 \); the method is approximate.
Practice Q2. Which of the following properties is not shared by lithium and magnesium?
(a) Direct combination with N₂ to form a nitride (b) Carbonate decomposes on heating to the oxide (c) Formation of a stable superoxide on burning in air (d) Formation of covalent organometallic compounds
Answer: (c)
Both Li and Mg burn in air to the normal oxide (Li₂O, MgO). Superoxides (MO₂) are formed by the heavier alkali metals K, Rb and Cs. The other three are standard features of the Li–Mg diagonal relationship.
Practice Q3. Using the Allred–Rochow relation, with Slater \( Z_{\text{eff}} = 7.60 \) for a 4p electron of bromine and covalent radius 1.14 Å, the electronegativity of Br is closest to:
(a) 2.10 (b) 2.84 (c) 3.30 (d) 6.67
Answer: (b) 2.84
\( \chi = 0.359 \times \frac{7.60}{1.14^2} + 0.744 = 0.359 \times \frac{7.60}{1.2996} + 0.744 = 0.359 \times 5.848 + 0.744 = 2.099 + 0.744 \approx 2.84 \).
Option (a) drops the additive constant 0.744. Check the Slater value: Br (Z = 35) 4p electron: 6 others in (4s, 4p) at 0.35 = 2.10; 18 in shell 3 at 0.85 = 15.30; 10 in shells 1–2 = 10.00; \( S = 27.40 \), \( Z_{\text{eff}} = 7.60 \).
Practice Q4. Which compound is a strong oxidising agent because of the inert pair effect?
(a) PbO₂ (b) SnCl₂ (c) TlCl (d) SiO₂
Answer: (a) PbO₂
Lead prefers +2, so Pb(IV) in PbO₂ readily gains two electrons: it is a strong oxidant. SnCl₂ is a reducing agent (Sn(II) → Sn(IV) is favourable for tin), TlCl contains the stable +1 state, and SiO₂ contains the stable +4 state of silicon.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Consider the statements:
- On the Mulliken scale, the electronegativity of a carbon atom increases with the s character of the hybrid orbital it uses.
- AsCl₅ is much less stable than PCl₅ and SbCl₅ because of poor shielding by the 3d electrons in arsenic.
- Fluorine has both the highest electronegativity and the highest electron affinity of all elements.
- Tl(III) is more electronegative than Tl(I).
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. Valence-state \( I \) and \( E_{\text{ea}} \) rise with s character: \( \text{C}_{sp} > \text{C}_{sp^2} > \text{C}_{sp^3} \).
- Correct. Secondary periodicity: the 4s electrons of As are held more tightly than the group trend suggests.
- Wrong. F has the highest electronegativity, but Cl has the highest electron affinity.
- Correct. 2.04 against 1.62 on the revised Pauling scale; higher oxidation state, higher electronegativity.
Practice Q6. Using \( I = 17.42 \) eV and \( E_{\text{ea}} = 3.40 \) eV for F, and \( I = 12.97 \) eV and \( E_{\text{ea}} = 3.61 \) eV for Cl, calculate the Mulliken ratio \( \chi_M(\text{F})/\chi_M(\text{Cl}) \) and compare it with the Pauling ratio \( \chi(\text{F})/\chi(\text{Cl}) \) (Pauling values 3.98 and 3.16). Which pair of ratios is correct?
(a) Mulliken 1.26, Pauling 1.26 (b) Mulliken 1.26, Pauling 1.13 (c) Mulliken 1.13, Pauling 1.26 (d) Mulliken 1.48, Pauling 1.26
Answer: (a)
Mulliken: F \( = (17.42 + 3.40)/2 = 10.41 \) eV; Cl \( = (12.97 + 3.61)/2 = 8.29 \) eV. Ratio \( 10.41/8.29 = 1.256 \approx 1.26 \).
Pauling: \( 3.98/3.16 = 1.259 \approx 1.26 \).
The agreement is closer than one should expect in general (the scales are only roughly proportional), but it shows why the Mulliken scale can be mapped onto Pauling’s.
Practice Q7. Which statements about period 2 elements are correct?
- Nitrogen forms NCl₃ but not NCl₅ because its valence shell cannot hold more than four electron pairs.
- The F–F bond is weaker than the Cl–Cl bond.
- Elemental nitrogen is diatomic because N forms strong pπ–pπ bonds, while phosphorus forms P₄ with single bonds.
- BeCl₂ and AlCl₃ are both ionic solids with no Lewis acidity.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 4 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
Statements 1–3 are standard features of the first-row anomaly (F–F about 158 against Cl–Cl about 242 kJ mol⁻¹). Statement 4 is wrong: both chlorides are covalent, bridged, Lewis-acidic compounds, which is part of the Be–Al diagonal relationship.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Definition | power of an atom in a molecule to attract electrons |
| Pauling | \( \lvert\Delta\chi\rvert = 0.102\sqrt{\Delta} \), \( \Delta = D_{AB} - \sqrt{D_{AA}D_{BB}} \) (kJ mol⁻¹) |
| Anchors | F 3.98, O 3.44, Cl 3.16, N 3.04, Br 2.96, C 2.55, H 2.20 |
| Mulliken | \( \chi_M = (I + E_{\text{ea}})/2 \), valence-state values |
| Allred–Rochow | \( 0.359\,Z_{\text{eff}}/r^2 + 0.744 \), r in Å |
| Raises \( \chi \) | higher oxidation state, more s character |
| First-row anomaly | max covalency 4; strong π bonds; weak N–N, O–O, F–F; H-bonding |
| Diagonal pairs | Li–Mg, Be–Al, B–Si |
| Inert pair | Tl(I), Pb(II), Bi(III) favoured; PbO₂, NaBiO₃ oxidants |
| Secondary periodicity | AsCl₅ unstable; perbromate late (1968); selenic acid strong oxidant |
| Relativistic | Au (colour, Au⁻), Hg liquid, part of inert pair |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Chemical Periodicity: Quick Revision: the whole chapter on one page.
- Next chapter: Structure and Bonding in Molecules (VSEPR), which starts with VSEPR Theory and Molecular Shapes.
- Electronegativity drives Bent’s rule: Bond Angles, Bent’s Rule and the Limits of VSEPR.
- The full subject overview: Chemical Sciences.