Ideal and Non-ideal Solutions
CSIR NET chemistry: Raoult's and Henry's laws, ideal mixing, deviations, azeotropes, activity coefficients, regular solutions and colligative properties.
- 18 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Azeotrope That Stops Distillation
- Partial Molar Quantities
- Raoult’s Law and the Ideal Solution
- Henry’s Law and the Ideal-Dilute Solution
- Real Solutions: Deviations from Raoult’s Law
- Activity and Activity Coefficients
- Colligative Properties
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Thermodynamic Potentials, Maxwell’s Relations and Spontaneity: chemical potential, partial molar quantities and the Gibbs–Duhem equation.
- Phase Transitions, Phase Equilibria and the Phase Rule: tie lines, the lever rule and binary diagrams.
- Ideal and Real Gases: fugacity, the gas-phase twin of activity.
The Hook: The Azeotrope That Stops Distillation
Partial Molar Quantities
For any extensive property \( X \) of a mixture, the partial molar quantity of component \( i \) is
$$\bar{X}_i = \left(\frac{\partial X}{\partial n_i}\right)_{T,P,n_{j\neq i}}, \qquad X = \sum_i n_i\bar{X}_i$$The partial molar Gibbs energy is the chemical potential. Partial molar volumes can be negative (MgSO₄ in water at infinite dilution: the ions collapse the open water structure around them), and they depend on composition: mixing 50 cm³ of ethanol with 50 cm³ of water gives less than 100 cm³. The Gibbs–Duhem equation applies to every partial molar quantity: \( \sum_i n_i\,d\bar{X}_i = 0 \) at constant \( T \) and \( P \).
Raoult’s Law and the Ideal Solution
An ideal solution obeys Raoult’s law for every component at every composition. Its components have identical A–A, B–B and A–B interactions in effect (benzene–toluene, chlorobenzene–bromobenzene, n-hexane–n-heptane are close). Then
$$\mu_A(\text{l}) = \mu_A^*(\text{l}) + RT\ln x_A$$and the mixing functions are those of ideal gases:
| Function | Ideal solution |
|---|---|
| \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G \) | \( nRT(x_A\ln x_A + x_B\ln x_B) < 0 \) |
| \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}S \) | \( -nR(x_A\ln x_A + x_B\ln x_B) > 0 \) |
| \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \) | 0 |
| \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V \) | 0 |
For an equimolar mixture of 2 mol in total at 300 K: \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G = 2RT\ln 0.5 = -3.46 \) kJ and \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}S = +11.5 \) J K⁻¹. Ideal mixing is driven entirely by entropy.
Vapour composition
$$p = p_B^* + (p_A^* - p_B^*)\,x_A, \qquad y_A = \frac{x_A p_A^*}{p}$$The total pressure is linear in liquid composition (the bubble-point line). The vapour is always richer in the more volatile component than the liquid: if \( p_A^* > p_B^* \), then \( y_A > x_A \). Plotted against vapour composition, the total pressure gives the curved dew-point line; between the two lines liquid and vapour coexist and the lever rule gives their amounts.
On a temperature–composition (boiling-point) diagram at fixed pressure, the liquid line is now the lower curve. Repeated vaporisation and condensation (each step a “theoretical plate”) walks the composition towards the more volatile pure component: that is fractional distillation.
Henry’s Law and the Ideal-Dilute Solution
In a dilute solution the solvent obeys Raoult’s law and the solute obeys Henry’s law; such a solution is ideal-dilute. The Gibbs–Duhem equation guarantees this pairing: if \( \mu_B \) varies as \( RT\ln x_B \) (Henry), then \( \mu_A \) must vary as \( RT\ln x_A \) (Raoult) over the same range. Henry’s law governs gas solubility (carbonated drinks, oxygen in blood, decompression sickness); the solubility of a gas falls as temperature rises when dissolution is exothermic, as it usually is.
Real Solutions: Deviations from Raoult’s Law
| Positive deviation | Negative deviation | |
|---|---|---|
| A–B interactions | weaker than A–A and B–B | stronger than A–A and B–B |
| Vapour pressure | above the Raoult line | below the Raoult line |
| \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \) (typical) | > 0 (endothermic) | < 0 (exothermic) |
| \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V \) (typical) | > 0 (expansion) | < 0 (contraction) |
| Activity coefficient \( \gamma \) | > 1 | < 1 |
| Azeotrope, if deviation large | minimum-boiling (maximum in \( p \)) | maximum-boiling (minimum in \( p \)) |
| Examples | ethanol–cyclohexane, acetone–CS₂, ethanol–water | acetone–chloroform (C–H···O hydrogen bond), HNO₃–water, HCl–water |
Azeotropes
At an azeotrope, liquid and vapour have the same composition, and the mixture boils at constant temperature like a pure substance. Distillation separates a mixture only into one pure component and the azeotrope:
- Minimum-boiling azeotrope (positive deviation): the azeotrope comes over as the distillate; the residue tends to the pure component in excess.
- Maximum-boiling azeotrope (negative deviation): a pure component distils first; the azeotrope remains in the flask. Constant-boiling hydrochloric acid (about 20 % HCl by mass, boiling near 109 °C at 1 atm) is the standard example.
The azeotropic composition shifts with pressure, which is the basis of pressure-swing distillation. An azeotrope is therefore a mixture, not a compound.
Immiscible liquids and steam distillation
If A and B are completely immiscible, each exerts its full vapour pressure: \( p = p_A^* + p_B^* \). The mixture boils when this sum reaches the external pressure, below the boiling point of either liquid. The mass ratio in the distillate is
$$\frac{m_A}{m_B} = \frac{p_A^* M_A}{p_B^* M_B}$$so a high-boiling, high-molar-mass organic compound (essential oils, aniline) distils with water well below 100 °C.
Activity and Activity Coefficients
Keep the ideal form of \( \mu \) and absorb the non-ideality into the activity \( a \):
$$\mu_A = \mu_A^\circ + RT\ln a_A, \qquad a_A = \gamma_A x_A$$| Convention | Reference | Activity from vapour pressure | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raoult (solvent, or both components of a liquid mixture) | pure liquid A | \( a_A = p_A/p_A^* \) | \( \gamma_A \to 1 \) as \( x_A \to 1 \) |
| Henry (solute) | hypothetical pure B behaving as at infinite dilution | \( a_B = p_B/K_B \) | \( \gamma_B \to 1 \) as \( x_B \to 0 \) |
For electrolyte solutions, the molality-based mean activity coefficient \( \gamma_\pm \) and the Debye–Hückel limiting law belong to the electrochemistry unit.
Excess functions and the regular solution
Excess functions measure departure from ideality: \( X^E = \Delta_{\text{mix}}X(\text{real}) - \Delta_{\text{mix}}X(\text{ideal}) \). In particular
$$G^E = RT\sum_i n_i\ln\gamma_i$$A regular solution has ideal entropy of mixing (\( S^E = 0 \)) but non-zero enthalpy: \( H^E = G^E = n\xi RT x_A x_B \), where \( \xi \) is a dimensionless interaction parameter (\( \xi RT \) is proportional to \( 2\varepsilon_{AB} - \varepsilon_{AA} - \varepsilon_{BB} \)). It follows that
$$\boxed{\ln\gamma_A = \xi x_B^2, \qquad \ln\gamma_B = \xi x_A^2}$$(the two-suffix Margules equations). \( \xi > 0 \) gives positive deviation; \( \xi < 0 \) negative deviation. If \( \xi > 2 \), \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G \) develops two minima and the liquids separate into two phases; the upper critical solution temperature is where \( \xi \) falls to 2 on heating. This is the thermodynamic basis of the partially miscible liquid pairs on the phase-rule page.
Colligative Properties
Colligative properties depend on the number of solute particles, not their identity, for a non-volatile solute in a dilute solution. All four come from one fact: the solute lowers the chemical potential of the solvent, \( \mu_A = \mu_A^* + RT\ln x_A \), while a pure solid solvent or the pure solvent vapour is unaffected.
| Property | Formula (dilute) | Constant |
|---|---|---|
| Relative lowering of vapour pressure | \( \dfrac{p_A^* - p_A}{p_A^*} = x_B \) | none |
| Boiling-point elevation | \( \Delta T_b = K_b\,m_B \) | \( K_b = \dfrac{RT_b^{*2}M_A}{\Delta_{\text{vap}}H} \) |
| Freezing-point depression | \( \Delta T_f = K_f\,m_B \) | \( K_f = \dfrac{RT_f^{*2}M_A}{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H} \) |
| Osmotic pressure (van ’t Hoff) | \( \Pi = c_B RT \) | none |
Here \( m_B \) is molality (mol kg⁻¹), \( M_A \) is the molar mass of the solvent in kg mol⁻¹, and \( c_B \) is molar concentration in mol m⁻³ if \( \Pi \) is in Pa.
Derivation sketch for \( K_f \). At the freezing point, \( \mu_A^*(\text{s}) = \mu_A^*(\text{l}) + RT\ln x_A \). Then \( \ln x_A = -\dfrac{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H}{R}\left(\dfrac{1}{T} - \dfrac{1}{T_f^*}\right) \). For a dilute solution \( \ln x_A \approx -x_B \approx -M_A m_B \) and \( 1/T - 1/T_f^* \approx \Delta T/T_f^{*2} \), which gives the formula above. For water, \( K_f = \dfrac{8.314 \times 273.15^2 \times 0.018015}{6010} = 1.86 \) K kg mol⁻¹ and similarly \( K_b \approx 0.51 \) K kg mol⁻¹.
The same equation, read the other way, is the ideal solubility of a solid in a liquid: \( \ln x_B = -\dfrac{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H_B}{R}\left(\dfrac{1}{T} - \dfrac{1}{T_{f,B}^*}\right) \). It predicts that solubility depends only on the solute’s melting properties, not on the solvent; a solid with \( \Delta_{\text{fus}}H = 19.0 \) kJ mol⁻¹ melting at 353 K has an ideal mole-fraction solubility at 298 K of \( \exp[-(19\,000/8.314)(1/298 - 1/353)] = 0.30 \).
Osmotic pressure
Solvent flows through a semipermeable membrane from pure solvent into solution until the extra pressure \( \Pi \) on the solution raises \( \mu_A \) back to \( \mu_A^* \): \( \Pi V_A = -RT\ln a_A \). For a dilute solution this becomes \( \Pi = c_B RT \), formally the ideal-gas law. Applying a pressure greater than \( \Pi \) drives solvent the other way: reverse osmosis.
Abnormal molar masses: the van ’t Hoff factor
$$i = \frac{\text{observed colligative effect}}{\text{effect expected for no dissociation or association}}, \qquad \Delta T_f = iK_f m$$| Process | \( i \) | Degree \( \alpha \) |
|---|---|---|
| Dissociation into \( \nu \) ions | \( 1 + (\nu - 1)\alpha \) | \( \alpha = \dfrac{i - 1}{\nu - 1} \) |
| Association into \( n \)-mers | \( 1 - \alpha\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{n}\right) \) | dimer: \( \alpha = 2(1 - i) \) |
NaCl in water has \( i \) somewhat below 2 at moderate concentration because of ion pairing and non-ideality; carboxylic acids in benzene have \( i \) near 0.5 because they dimerise through hydrogen bonds.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Raoult: \( p_A = x_A p_A^* \), pure-liquid constant | Henry: \( p_B = x_B K_B \), empirical constant \( K_B \neq p_B^* \) | |
| Ideal solution: \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H = 0 \), \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V = 0 \) | Ideal-dilute: solvent Raoult, solute Henry; \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \) need not be 0 | |
| Minimum-boiling azeotrope: positive deviation | Maximum-boiling azeotrope: negative deviation | |
| \( \gamma \) (activity coefficient, solutions) | \( \phi \) (fugacity coefficient, gases) | |
| Molality (mol per kg solvent): \( \Delta T_f \), \( \Delta T_b \) | Molarity (mol per volume): \( \Pi = cRT \) | |
| Osmotic pressure: number-average \( M \) | Light scattering: weight-average \( M \) (polymer chapter) | |
| Steam distillation: immiscible, \( p = p_A^* + p_B^* \) | Fractional distillation: miscible, Raoult |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Take \( R = 8.314 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H \) for an ideal solution?
- Which colligative property is best suited to finding the molar mass of a protein?
- A mixture showing large negative deviation from Raoult’s law forms which type of azeotrope?
Answers
- Zero (also \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}V = 0 \)).
- Osmotic pressure; the other effects are too small at the low molar concentrations involved.
- A maximum-boiling azeotrope (minimum in the vapour-pressure curve).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Liquids A (\( p_A^* = 80 \) kPa) and B (\( p_B^* = 30 \) kPa) form an ideal solution. For a liquid with \( x_A = 0.40 \), the total vapour pressure and the mole fraction of A in the vapour are:
(a) 50 kPa and 0.40 (b) 50 kPa and 0.64 (c) 55 kPa and 0.64 (d) 44 kPa and 0.73
Answer: (b)
\( p = 0.40 \times 80 + 0.60 \times 30 = 32 + 18 = 50 \) kPa. \( y_A = 32/50 = 0.64 \). The vapour is enriched in the more volatile A. (a) uses the liquid composition for the vapour; (c) averages the pure vapour pressures.
Practice Q2. Water has \( \Delta_{\text{fus}}H = 6.01 \) kJ mol⁻¹ at 273.15 K and \( M = 18.015 \) g mol⁻¹. Its cryoscopic constant is closest to:
(a) 0.51 K kg mol⁻¹ (b) 1.86 K kg mol⁻¹ (c) 1860 K kg mol⁻¹ (d) 5.12 K kg mol⁻¹
Answer: (b)
\( K_f = \dfrac{RT_f^{*2}M_A}{\Delta_{\text{fus}}H} = \dfrac{8.314 \times 273.15^2 \times 0.018015}{6010} = 1.86 \) K kg mol⁻¹. (c) uses \( M \) in g mol⁻¹; (a) is the ebullioscopic constant of water; (d) is the cryoscopic constant of benzene.
Practice Q3. 2.0 g of a non-electrolyte dissolved in 100 g of water lowers the freezing point by 0.372 K (\( K_f = 1.86 \) K kg mol⁻¹). The molar mass of the solute is:
(a) 50 g mol⁻¹ (b) 100 g mol⁻¹ (c) 200 g mol⁻¹ (d) 1000 g mol⁻¹
Answer: (b)
\( m = \Delta T_f/K_f = 0.372/1.86 = 0.200 \) mol kg⁻¹. In 0.100 kg water: 0.0200 mol. \( M = 2.0/0.0200 = 100 \) g mol⁻¹. (c) and (a) come from wrongly applying a van ’t Hoff factor of 2 or 1/2 to a non-electrolyte; (d) is a factor-of-ten slip in the mass of solvent.
Practice Q4. Acetone–chloroform mixtures show:
(a) positive deviation, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H > 0 \), minimum-boiling azeotrope (b) negative deviation, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H < 0 \), maximum-boiling azeotrope (c) ideal behaviour, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H = 0 \) (d) negative deviation, \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H > 0 \), minimum-boiling azeotrope
Answer: (b)
The C–H of chloroform (activated by three chlorines) hydrogen-bonds to the carbonyl oxygen of acetone, an interaction absent in either pure liquid. A–B attraction exceeds A–A and B–B: mixing is exothermic, the vapour pressure falls below Raoult’s line, and the mixture shows a vapour-pressure minimum, i.e. a maximum-boiling azeotrope.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. In a binary liquid mixture at 300 K with \( x_A = 0.50 \), the partial vapour pressure of A is 30.0 kPa; pure A has \( p_A^* = 50.0 \) kPa. Treat the mixture as a regular solution. Which statements are correct?
- \( a_A = 0.60 \) and \( \gamma_A = 1.20 \) (Raoult convention).
- The system shows positive deviation from Raoult’s law.
- The interaction parameter \( \xi \approx 0.73 \), so the liquids are miscible in all proportions.
- \( \gamma_B \) at \( x_A = 0.50 \) is less than 1.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- \( a_A = p_A/p_A^* = 30.0/50.0 = 0.60 \); \( \gamma_A = a_A/x_A = 1.20 \). Correct.
- \( \gamma_A > 1 \): the vapour pressure exceeds the Raoult value of 25 kPa. Correct.
- \( \ln\gamma_A = \xi x_B^2 \Rightarrow \xi = \ln 1.20/0.25 = 0.729 \). Phase separation needs \( \xi > 2 \). Correct.
- For a regular solution \( \ln\gamma_B = \xi x_A^2 = 0.729 \times 0.25 \), so \( \gamma_B = 1.20 \) at the equimolar point, greater than 1. Wrong.
Practice Q6. 1.0 g of a synthetic polymer is dissolved in water to give 100 cm³ of solution. At 300 K the osmotic pressure is 249 Pa. Which statements are correct?
- The molar concentration of polymer is about 0.10 mol m⁻³.
- The number-average molar mass is about \( 1.0 \times 10^5 \) g mol⁻¹.
- The freezing-point depression of this solution would be about \( 2 \times 10^{-4} \) K.
- The molar mass obtained is the weight-average molar mass.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- \( c = \Pi/RT = 249/(8.314 \times 300) = 0.0998 \) mol m⁻³ \( \approx 0.10 \). Correct.
- Amount in \( 1.0 \times 10^{-4} \) m³: \( 1.0 \times 10^{-5} \) mol. \( M = 1.0/1.0 \times 10^{-5} = 1.0 \times 10^5 \) g mol⁻¹. Correct.
- Molality ≈ \( 1.0 \times 10^{-5}/0.1 = 1.0 \times 10^{-4} \) mol kg⁻¹ (dilute, density ≈ 1); \( \Delta T_f = 1.86 \times 10^{-4} \) K, unmeasurably small. Correct.
- Colligative properties count molecules: they give the number-average. Wrong.
Practice Q7. 1.20 g of acetic acid (\( M = 60.0 \) g mol⁻¹) in 100 g of benzene (\( K_f = 5.12 \) K kg mol⁻¹) lowers the freezing point by 0.614 K. The van ’t Hoff factor and the degree of dimerisation are:
(a) 0.60 and 0.80 (b) 0.60 and 0.40 (c) 1.67 and 0.67 (d) 0.50 and 1.00
Answer: (a)
Expected (no association): \( m = (1.20/60.0)/0.100 = 0.200 \) mol kg⁻¹, \( \Delta T_f = 5.12 \times 0.200 = 1.024 \) K. \( i = 0.614/1.024 = 0.600 \). For dimerisation, \( i = 1 - \alpha/2 \Rightarrow \alpha = 2(1 - 0.600) = 0.80 \). (b) uses \( i = 1 - \alpha \); (c) inverts the ratio; (d) is complete dimerisation.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Partial molar | \( \bar{X}_i = (\partial X/\partial n_i)_{T,P,n_j} \); \( X = \sum n_i\bar{X}_i \) |
| Raoult | \( p_A = x_A p_A^* \) |
| Henry | \( p_B = x_B K_B \) (dilute solute) |
| Ideal mixing | \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}G = nRT\sum x\ln x \); \( \Delta_{\text{mix}}H = \Delta_{\text{mix}}V = 0 \) |
| Vapour | \( y_A = x_A p_A^*/p \); richer in the volatile component |
| Positive deviation | weak A–B, \( \gamma > 1 \), minimum-boiling azeotrope |
| Negative deviation | strong A–B, \( \gamma < 1 \), maximum-boiling azeotrope |
| Activity | \( a_A = \gamma_A x_A = p_A/p_A^* \) (Raoult convention) |
| Regular solution | \( \ln\gamma_A = \xi x_B^2 \); two phases if \( \xi > 2 \) |
| Steam distillation | \( m_A/m_B = p_A^* M_A/(p_B^* M_B) \) |
| Colligative | \( \Delta p/p^* = x_B \); \( \Delta T = Km \); \( \Pi = cRT \) |
| Constants (water) | \( K_f = 1.86 \), \( K_b = 0.51 \) K kg mol⁻¹ |
| \( K_f \) formula | \( RT_f^{*2}M_A/\Delta_{\text{fus}}H \) |
| van ’t Hoff factor | dissociation \( 1 + (\nu - 1)\alpha \); dimerisation \( 1 - \alpha/2 \) |
| Ideal solubility | \( \ln x_B = -(\Delta_{\text{fus}}H/R)(1/T - 1/T_f^*) \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Chemical Thermodynamics: Quick Revision: every formula of the chapter on one page.
- Back to the start of the chapter: Laws of Thermodynamics, State and Path Functions.
- Osmosis, water potential and colligative properties in cells: Chemical Bonds and Biophysical Chemistry.
- The full Chemical Sciences syllabus and the other physical chemistry units: Chemical Sciences.