Retrosynthesis and the Disconnection Approach
CSIR NET organic synthesis: retrosynthesis, transforms and retrons, FGI, one- and two-group C–X and C–C cuts, ring cuts and aromatic order of events.
- 19 min
On this page · 18 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Solving the Maze from the Exit
- The Vocabulary
- The Method
- Guidelines for Choosing a Disconnection
- C–X Disconnections
- C–C Disconnections
- Rings
- Aromatic Targets: Order of Events
- Worked Example: Two Routes to 4-Phenylbutan-2-one
- Worked Example: A Robinson Annulation Read Backwards
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Nucleophilic Substitution: every C–X disconnection is an SN2 or acyl substitution read backwards.
- Carbonyl Condensations and Enolate Named Reactions: aldol, Claisen, Michael and Robinson are the workhorse C–C transforms.
- Addition Reactions: conjugate addition and additions to C=O.
- Aromatic Substitution: directing effects decide the order of events on a benzene ring.
The Hook: Solving the Maze from the Exit
The Vocabulary
- Target molecule (TM): the compound to be made.
- Retrosynthetic arrow (⇒): “can be made from”. It points from the target to its precursors and is never used for a real reaction.
- Disconnection: an imaginary bond cleavage, the reverse of a bond-forming reaction, written with ⇒ and a wavy line through the bond.
- Transform: the reverse of a synthetic reaction (the aldol transform, the Diels–Alder transform).
- Retron: the minimal structural unit that signals a transform can be applied (β-hydroxy carbonyl for the aldol; cyclohexene for the Diels–Alder).
- Synthon: an idealised fragment, usually an ion, produced by a disconnection. It need not exist.
- Synthetic equivalent (reagent): the real compound that does the job of the synthon.
- FGI (functional group interconversion): a retrosynthetic change of one functional group into another, with no change in the carbon skeleton (amine ⇒ amide; alkane ⇒ alkene).
- FGA (functional group addition): adding a group on paper to make a disconnection possible, removed later in the forward direction (ketone ⇒ enone, then hydrogenate).
- Reconnection: joining two atoms on paper (two carbonyls ⇒ a C=C) because the forward reaction cleaves a bond (ozonolysis).
- Strategic bond: a bond whose disconnection simplifies the target most.
Synthons and their equivalents have a page of their own (Synthons and Synthetic Equivalents). On this page, a disconnection is always followed by the question “what reagents correspond to these two pieces?”.
The Method
graph TD
A["1. Recognise functional groups
and their relationships
(1,2? 1,3? 1,5?)"] --> B["2. Disconnect a bond by
a known, reliable reaction
(often next to a heteroatom
or functional group)"]
B --> C["3. Name the synthons
(charges must be sensible)"]
C --> D["4. Choose synthetic
equivalents (reagents)"]
D --> E{"Are the precursors
simple or commercial?"}
E -->|"no"| A
E -->|"yes"| F["5. Write the forward synthesis;
check chemoselectivity,
add protection if needed"]The last box matters as much as the first four. A disconnection that is correct on paper fails if the forward reaction attacks a second functional group, needs an impossible carbocation, or gives the wrong regioisomer.
Guidelines for Choosing a Disconnection
- Disconnect at a known reaction. Every disconnection must correspond to a reliable forward reaction. “C–C bond, two carbanions” is not a reaction.
- Disconnect C–X bonds first. Bonds from carbon to O, N, S or halogen are made by substitution or acyl substitution and are usually made late in the forward direction. Esters, amides, ethers and sulfides are the obvious first cuts.
- Use two-group disconnections where possible. A bond lying between two functional groups (1,3-diO, 1,5-diO) gives a more specific and reliable reaction than a one-group disconnection.
- Aim for the greatest simplification. Prefer disconnections near the middle of the molecule, at branch points, and into two pieces of similar size. This is the root of the convergent strategy on Linear and Convergent Synthesis.
- Use symmetry. If the target has a symmetry element, disconnect so that two identical pieces come from one reagent (hexane-2,5-dione, dibenzylideneacetone).
- Disconnect rings at the ring-forming reaction. Five- and six-membered rings come from intramolecular aldol, Dieckmann, Diels–Alder or Robinson reactions.
- Watch chemoselectivity. If the forward step would also attack another group, either change the order of events or plan a protecting group.
C–X Disconnections
One-group C–X disconnections
The heteroatom becomes the nucleophile and carbon the electrophile, because that is the polarity the heteroatom gives naturally.
| Target | Disconnection | Synthons | Reagents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ester R–CO–OR′ | C(acyl)–O | RCO⁺ + ⁻OR′ | RCOCl or (RCO)₂O + R′OH, pyridine |
| Amide R–CO–NR′₂ | C(acyl)–N | RCO⁺ + ⁻NR′₂ | RCOCl + HNR′₂ (two equivalents, or with Et₃N) |
| Ether R–O–R′ | C–O on the side that gives SN2 | R′⁺ + ⁻OR | R′–Br or R′–OTs (primary, methyl, allyl, benzyl) + RO⁻Na⁺ (Williamson) |
| Sulfide R–S–R′ | C–S | R′⁺ + ⁻SR | R′–Br + RS⁻ |
| Alkyl halide | C–X | R⁺ + X⁻ | ROH + PBr₃, SOCl₂, HBr |
Amines: disconnect after an FGI
Direct alkylation of an amine with an alkyl halide over-alkylates (the product amine is usually more nucleophilic than the starting amine). So amines are disconnected after an FGI to a less nucleophilic nitrogen:
| Amine type | FGI to | Forward reaction |
|---|---|---|
| R–CH₂–NHR′ | amide R–CO–NHR′ | acylation, then LiAlH₄ reduction |
| R₂CH–NHR′ | imine R₂C=NR′ | reductive amination: R₂C=O + R′NH₂, NaBH₃CN or NaBH(OAc)₃ |
| R–CH₂–NH₂ | nitrile R–C≡N | R–Br + CN⁻, then LiAlH₄ or H₂/catalyst (adds one carbon) |
| Primary R–NH₂ | azide R–N₃ or phthalimide | SN2 with N₃⁻ then reduction; or Gabriel synthesis |
| Ar–NH₂ | Ar–NO₂ | nitration, then Sn/HCl, Fe/HCl or H₂/Pd |
Two-group C–X disconnections
When a heteroatom sits 1,1, 1,2 or 1,3 to another functional group, a two-group disconnection is more specific:
| Relationship | Target | Disconnection leads to |
|---|---|---|
| 1,1-diX | acetals, aminals, hemiacetals | carbonyl compound + two equivalents of alcohol, amine or thiol |
| 1,2-diX | β-amino alcohol, β-hydroxy ether, β-hydroxy sulfide | epoxide + nucleophile (attack at the less hindered carbon under basic conditions) |
| 1,3-diX | β-amino ketone, β-alkoxy ketone, β-thio ester | α,β-unsaturated carbonyl + heteroatom nucleophile (conjugate addition); β-amino ketones also by the Mannich reaction |
The 1,2 case shows why the epoxide is so useful: it is a 2-hydroxyalkyl cation equivalent, a ready-made electrophile one carbon away from an oxygen.
C–C Disconnections
One-group C–C disconnections
| Target | Disconnection | Reagents |
|---|---|---|
| Alcohol R¹R²C(OH)R³ | any C–C(OH) bond | Grignard or organolithium + ketone (or aldehyde, or ester for two identical groups) |
| Primary alcohol RCH₂CH₂OH | C1–C2 bond | RMgBr + ethylene oxide |
| Primary alcohol RCH₂OH | R–CH₂OH | RMgBr + HCHO |
| Carboxylic acid R–COOH | R–COOH | RMgBr + CO₂; or R–Br + CN⁻ then hydrolysis |
| Ketone R–CO–R′ | R–CO | R′MgBr or R′Li + Weinreb amide R–CO–N(OMe)Me; R′₂CuLi + RCOCl; or FGI to alcohol and oxidise |
| Alkene R₂C=CR′₂ | C=C | Wittig or HWE (carbonyl + ylide or phosphonate anion) |
| Alkyne R–C≡C–R′ | C(sp)–R′ | R–C≡C⁻ + R′–Br (primary) |
Two-group C–C disconnections: the consonant patterns
Number the carbons from one functional-group carbon (C1) to the other. Patterns where the natural polarity of the two groups matches (alternating acceptor and donor sites, see Synthons) disconnect into ordinary reactions:
| Pattern in the target | Retron | Transform (forward reaction) | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| β-hydroxy carbonyl (1,3-diO) | HO–C–C–C=O | aldol | diacetone alcohol ⇒ 2 acetone |
| α,β-unsaturated carbonyl | C=C–C=O | aldol condensation (aldol + dehydration); Knoevenagel | benzalacetone (4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one) ⇒ PhCHO + acetone |
| 1,3-dicarbonyl | O=C–C–C=O | Claisen (or Dieckmann if cyclic) | ethyl acetoacetate ⇒ 2 ethyl acetate |
| 1,5-dicarbonyl | O=C–C–C–C–C=O | Michael addition | 2-(3-oxobutyl)cyclohexanone ⇒ cyclohexanone + methyl vinyl ketone |
| Cyclohexenone fused to a ring | enone in a new six-membered ring | Robinson annulation (Michael + intramolecular aldol) | octalone ⇒ cyclohexanone + MVK |
| Cyclohexene | C=C inside a six-membered ring | Diels–Alder | 4-acetylcyclohexene ⇒ buta-1,3-diene + methyl vinyl ketone |
The dissonant patterns: 1,2, 1,4 and 1,6
If you try the same trick on a 1,2-, 1,4- or 1,6-dioxygenated target, one of the two synthons always has unnatural polarity: a nucleophilic carbonyl carbon (acyl anion) or an electrophilic α-carbon. These targets need one of three tactics:
| Pattern | Tactic | Example |
|---|---|---|
| 1,2-diO | umpolung (acyl anion equivalent; benzoin; dithiane), radical coupling (pinacol, acyloin), or alkene → diol (OsO₄) | benzoin ⇒ 2 PhCHO (cyanide catalysis) |
| 1,4-diO | an unnatural electrophile (α-haloketone, epoxide) with a natural enolate, or an acyl anion equivalent in conjugate addition (Stetter) | hexane-2,5-dione ⇒ acetoacetate enolate + chloroacetone (then decarboxylate) |
| 1,6-diO | reconnection to a cyclohexene, then oxidative cleavage | hexanedial ⇒ cyclohexene (O₃, then Me₂S) |
All three tactics are developed on Umpolung and Acyl Anion Equivalents.
Rings
graph TD
R{"What ring?"} --> S6["Six-membered,
contains C=C"]
R --> S6O["Six-membered
cyclohexenone"]
R --> S5["Five- or six-membered
β-keto ester"]
R --> S3["Cyclopropane"]
S6 --> DA["Diels-Alder:
diene + dienophile"]
S6O --> RA["Robinson annulation or
intramolecular aldol of
a 1,5-diketone"]
S5 --> DK["Dieckmann condensation
of a 1,6- or 1,7-diester"]
S3 --> CP["Carbene or Simmons-Smith
addition to an alkene"]Points the exam uses:
- Intramolecular aldol of a 1,5-diketone gives a cyclohexenone; of a 1,4-diketone, a cyclopentenone. Five- and six-membered rings form preferentially over three-, four- or seven-membered alternatives.
- Dieckmann: a 1,6-diester (diethyl adipate) gives a five-membered β-keto ester; a 1,7-diester (diethyl pimelate) gives a six-membered one.
- Diels–Alder retron: find the C=C in the six-membered ring; the diene carbons are that C=C plus the two allylic ring carbons, and the dienophile is the remaining two carbons. The stereochemistry of the dienophile is kept (suprafacial, stereospecific).
Aromatic Targets: Order of Events
On a benzene ring, the disconnection itself is easy (each substituent comes from an electrophilic substitution, a diazonium replacement, or an FGI). The skill is the order, set by directing effects:
| Target | Correct order | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1-chloro-4-nitrobenzene | chlorinate, then nitrate | Cl is an o,p-director; separate the para isomer |
| 1-chloro-3-nitrobenzene | nitrate, then chlorinate | NO₂ is a meta-director |
| 3-bromoaniline | nitrate, brominate (meta to NO₂), then reduce NO₂ to NH₂ | NH₂ itself would direct o,p and over-brominate |
| 1,3,5-tribromobenzene | aniline + Br₂(aq) → 2,4,6-tribromoaniline; then diazotise and reduce (H₃PO₂) | uses NH₂ as a removable activating, o,p-directing group |
| 4-nitroaniline | protect aniline as acetanilide, nitrate (para), hydrolyse | direct nitration of aniline oxidises it and gives much meta product via the anilinium ion |
| Alkylbenzene with n-propyl | Friedel–Crafts acylation then Clemmensen or Wolff–Kishner reduction (FGI) | direct n-propylation rearranges to isopropyl |
Two reusable tactics appear here: FGI (C=O → CH₂; NO₂ → NH₂ → anything via the diazonium salt) and temporary groups (NH₂ added for its directing power, then removed).
Worked Example: Two Routes to 4-Phenylbutan-2-one
Worked Example: A Robinson Annulation Read Backwards
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | Is not this |
|---|---|
| Retrosynthetic arrow ⇒ (“made from”) | Reaction arrow → (a real step) |
| Synthon: an idealised, often non-existent fragment | Synthetic equivalent: the real reagent (CH₃⁻ synthon, CH₃MgI reagent) |
| Transform: the reverse of a reaction | Retron: the structural feature that triggers it |
| FGI: same skeleton, different group | FGA: a group added on paper (removed forward) |
| One-group disconnection (one functional group guides it) | Two-group disconnection (bond between two related groups; more specific) |
| 1,3- and 1,5-diO (consonant, natural) | 1,2-, 1,4-, 1,6-diO (dissonant, need special methods) |
| Disconnection (break a bond on paper) | Reconnection (make a bond on paper because the forward step breaks it) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not taken from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the retron for the Diels–Alder transform?
- Which forward reaction corresponds to disconnecting a 1,5-dicarbonyl compound between C2 and C3 (numbering from one carbonyl carbon)?
- Give the FGI used to disconnect a secondary amine R₂CH–NHR′ without over-alkylation problems.
Answers
- A cyclohexene (a C=C inside a six-membered ring).
- A Michael (conjugate) addition: enolate (d²) + α,β-unsaturated carbonyl (a³). Counting from one carbonyl, the bond between the enolate α-carbon and the β-carbon of the acceptor is the one formed.
- Amine ⇒ imine (forward: reductive amination of R₂C=O with R′NH₂ and NaBH₃CN or NaBH(OAc)₃).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The best pair of starting materials for ethyl tert-butyl ether, (CH₃)₃C–O–CH₂CH₃, is
(a) (CH₃)₃CBr + NaOCH₂CH₃ (b) (CH₃)₃CONa + CH₃CH₂Br (c) (CH₃)₃COH + CH₃CH₂OH, conc. H₂SO₄, 140 °C (d) (CH₃)₂C=CH₂ + CH₃CH₂Br
Answer: (b)
Williamson synthesis needs SN2 at the alkyl halide carbon, so the halide must be primary (ethyl bromide) and the hindered group must be the alkoxide. (a) gives isobutylene by E2. (c) gives a mixture of ethers and alkene. (d) has no nucleophile.
Practice Q2. Which combination does not give 2-phenylbutan-2-ol after aqueous work-up?
(a) PhMgBr + butan-2-one (b) CH₃MgI + propiophenone (c) EtMgBr + acetophenone (d) PhMgBr + butanal
Answer: (d)
An aldehyde gives a secondary alcohol: PhMgBr + CH₃CH₂CH₂CHO → 1-phenylbutan-1-ol. The other three each supply one of the three groups on the tertiary carbinol carbon.
Practice Q3. The retrosynthesis CH₃COCH₂CH₂COCH₃ ⇒ ⁻CH₂COCH₃ + ⁺CH₂COCH₃ is correct on paper. The best real equivalents for the two synthons are
(a) acetone + NaOH, and acetone (b) ethyl acetoacetate with NaOEt, and chloroacetone (c) acetone + LDA, and propanal (d) acetoacetic ester, and methyl vinyl ketone
Answer: (b)
Hexane-2,5-dione is a 1,4-dicarbonyl. The anionic synthon is a natural enolate (d²), conveniently supplied by acetoacetic ester; the cationic synthon has an electrophilic α-carbon (a², unnatural), supplied by an α-haloketone. Hydrolysis and decarboxylation remove the ester. (a) gives the aldol product of acetone; (d) gives a 1,5-diketone after Michael addition.
Practice Q4. To make 3-bromoaniline from benzene, the correct order of steps is
(a) nitration, reduction, bromination (b) bromination, nitration, reduction (c) nitration, bromination, reduction (d) reduction is not needed: bromination then amination with NaNH₂
Answer: (c)
NO₂ directs meta, so brominate while the nitro group is present, then reduce NO₂ to NH₂. (a) puts Br ortho/para to NH₂ (and over-brominates). (b) puts NO₂ ortho/para to Br. (d) goes via benzyne and gives a mixture.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A student proposes the following retrosynthesis of 4-acetylcyclohexene (1-(cyclohex-3-en-1-yl)ethan-1-one).
TM ⇒ buta-1,3-diene + but-3-en-2-one (methyl vinyl ketone)
Which statements are correct?
- The disconnection is a Diels–Alder transform triggered by the cyclohexene retron.
- In the forward reaction, the C=C of the product comes from C2–C3 of the diene.
- The acetyl group activates the dienophile by lowering its LUMO.
- Replacing MVK by (E)-pent-3-en-2-one would give a product with the methyl and acetyl groups cis on the ring.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. A C=C inside a six-membered ring is the Diels–Alder retron.
- Correct. C1 and C4 of the diene form the new σ bonds; the new π bond is between the former C2 and C3.
- Correct. An electron-withdrawing group on the dienophile lowers its LUMO and speeds a normal-demand Diels–Alder.
- Wrong. The Diels–Alder reaction is suprafacial on the dienophile, so the trans (E) relationship of methyl and acetyl is kept: the product has them trans.
Practice Q6. Consider two proposed routes to 4-phenylbutan-2-one, PhCH₂CH₂COCH₃.
Route A: PhCHO + acetone, NaOH; then H₂, Pd/C (1 equivalent, room temperature). Route B: ethyl acetoacetate, NaOEt; then PhCH₂Br; then aqueous NaOH, then H₃O⁺ and heat.
Which statements are correct?
- Route A uses an FGA (adding a C=C on paper) followed by an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl disconnection.
- In route A, the crossed aldol is clean because benzaldehyde cannot form an enolate.
- In route B, the acetoacetate enolate is a synthetic equivalent of the acetone enolate (d² synthon).
- Route B releases CO₂ in the last step.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2, 3 and 4 only (c) 1 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- Correct. PhCH₂CH₂COCH₃ ⇒ PhCH=CHCOCH₃ is an FGA; the enone then disconnects by the aldol-condensation transform.
- Correct. Benzaldehyde has no α-hydrogen; only acetone enolises, so there is one nucleophile and the more electrophilic aldehyde is the acceptor.
- Correct. The ester makes the CH₂ far more acidic and is removed later; the net change is “acetone enolate + benzyl cation”.
- Correct. Saponification gives the β-keto acid, which decarboxylates on heating through a cyclic six-membered transition state.
Practice Q7. For hexanedioic acid (adipic acid), HO₂C(CH₂)₄CO₂H, consider these analyses.
- It is a 1,6-dicarbonyl compound, so a direct two-group disconnection into two natural synthons is not available.
- Reconnection of C1 and C6 gives cyclohexene, which can be cleaved oxidatively in the forward direction.
- Cyclohexanone can also serve as a precursor, through Baeyer–Villiger oxidation and further oxidation, or through direct oxidative ring cleavage.
- Disconnecting C3–C4 gives two identical a³ synthons, which can be joined by a Michael reaction.
Which statements are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. Carbonyl carbons at C1 and C6 are a dissonant (even) relationship.
- Correct. Reconnection to a ring alkene is the standard tactic; forward, KMnO₄ (hot) or ozonolysis with oxidative work-up gives the diacid.
- Correct. Baeyer–Villiger oxidation gives ε-caprolactone (a 1,6-relationship between C=O and O), and nitric acid oxidation of cyclohexanone/cyclohexanol cleaves the ring to adipic acid.
- Wrong. Two acceptor synthons cannot be joined to each other; a bond needs one donor and one acceptor. (This is the logic behind radical or reductive coupling, which is a different method.)
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| ⇒ | “can be made from”; planning only |
| Transform / retron | reverse reaction / structural trigger |
| FGI, FGA, reconnection | change group; add group; join atoms (forward cleavage) |
| First cut | C–X next to a heteroatom (esters, amides, ethers) |
| Ethers | halide on the methyl/primary side (Williamson) |
| Amines | FGI to amide, imine, nitrile, azide or nitro |
| 1,1 / 1,2 / 1,3-diX | carbonyl + 2 HX / epoxide + Nu / enone + Nu |
| Alcohols | Grignard + HCHO, aldehyde, ketone, ester, epoxide |
| β-Hydroxy carbonyl | aldol; cut C(α)–C(OH) |
| 1,3-Dicarbonyl | Claisen / Dieckmann |
| 1,5-Dicarbonyl | Michael; + aldol = Robinson |
| Cyclohexene | Diels–Alder |
| 1,2 / 1,4 / 1,6-diO | umpolung / unnatural electrophile / reconnection |
| Aromatic order | directing effects; NO₂ meta, halogen o,p; temporary NH₂ |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Synthons and Synthetic Equivalents: the donor/acceptor (dⁿ/aⁿ) classification behind every disconnection on this page.
- Umpolung and Acyl Anion Equivalents: how the dissonant 1,2-, 1,4- and 1,6-patterns are actually made.
- Carbanions: enolates, kinetic versus thermodynamic control and ylides, the donors used throughout.
- Back to the chapter overview.