Organometallic Reactions: Substitution to β-Elimination
CSIR NET chemistry: substitution, oxidative addition, reductive elimination, migratory insertion, β-hydride elimination, σ-bond metathesis and ligand attack.
- 17 min
On this page · 17 sections
Prerequisites
- Electron Counting, Metal Carbonyls and Acceptor Ligands: every reaction on this page is classified by how it changes the electron count.
- Hydrocarbon Ligands: Alkyls, Carbenes and π-Complexes: the alkyl, alkene, allyl and Cp ligands that react here.
- The HSAB Concept: soft, electron-rich metals undergo oxidative addition most readily.
- Steady-state kinetics and activation parameters (ΔS‡) from physical chemistry.
The Hook: A Complex That Breathes
The Master Table
Learn this table and you can label any step in a catalytic cycle.
| Reaction | Δ oxidation state | Δ coordination number | Δ electron count | Typical requirement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ligand dissociation | 0 | −1 | −2 | 18-e complex, bulky ligands |
| Ligand association | 0 | +1 | +2 | ≤ 16-e complex |
| Oxidative addition (OA) | +2 | +2 | +2 | ≤ 16 e⁻, two vacant sites, OS +2 accessible |
| Reductive elimination (RE) | −2 | −2 | −2 | the two groups cis |
| Migratory insertion (1,1 or 1,2) | 0 | −1 | −2 | the two groups cis |
| β-Hydride elimination | 0 | +1 | +2 | β-H, vacant cis site, syn-coplanar M–C–C–H |
| α-Hydride elimination | 0 (carbene as neutral L; +2 if written as CR₂²⁻) | +1 | +2 (neutral method) | α-H, early metal |
| Oxidative coupling of two alkenes | +2 | 0 | −2 | gives a metallacyclopentane |
| σ-Bond metathesis | 0 | 0 | 0 | d⁰ metal (no electrons for OA) |
graph TD
A["What changed at the metal?"] --> B{"Oxidation state +2?"}
B -->|yes| C["Oxidative addition
(or alpha-elimination)"]
B -->|no| D{"Oxidation state -2?"}
D -->|yes| E["Reductive elimination"]
D -->|no| F{"Electron count -2,
new bond within ligands?"}
F -->|yes| G["Migratory insertion"]
F -->|no| H{"Electron count +2,
alkene + M-H formed?"}
H -->|yes| I["Beta-hydride elimination"]
H -->|no| J["Substitution, sigma-bond metathesis
or attack on a ligand"]Each pair is a microscopic reverse: OA ↔ RE, insertion ↔ elimination, association ↔ dissociation. Because each step changes the count by 0 or 2, catalytic intermediates shuttle between 16 and 18 electrons, which is Tolman’s 16/18-electron rule for catalysis, developed on the catalysis page.
Ligand Substitution
18-electron complexes: dissociative (D)
An 18-electron complex cannot accept a seventh ligand without putting electrons into an antibonding orbital, so substitution starts with loss of a ligand:
$$\text{M(CO)}_6 \xrightarrow{k_1,\ \text{slow}} \text{M(CO)}_5 + \text{CO}; \qquad \text{M(CO)}_5 + \text{L} \xrightarrow{\text{fast}} \text{M(CO)}_5\text{L}$$Signs of a dissociative mechanism:
- rate = \( k_1[\text{M(CO)}_6] \): first order in complex, zero order in incoming ligand L;
- rate nearly independent of the nature of L;
- positive ΔS‡ (two particles from one in the transition state);
- rate increases with ligand bulk (steric relief) and for metals and ligands that bind CO less strongly.
17- and 16-electron complexes: associative (A)
A complex with fewer than 18 electrons has a vacant low-lying orbital and can bind L first.
- 16-electron square-planar d⁸ complexes (Pt(II), Pd(II), Rh(I), Ir(I)) substitute associatively through a five-coordinate intermediate, as in classical Pt(II) chemistry.
- 17-electron radicals substitute associatively and very fast: V(CO)₆ exchanges CO far faster than the 18-electron Cr(CO)₆, and the 17-electron Mn(CO)₅ radical is far more labile than Mn₂(CO)₁₀. One-electron oxidation or reduction of an 18-electron complex can therefore catalyse substitution (electron-transfer chain catalysis).
- Signs: rate = \( k_2[\text{M}][\text{L}] \); rate depends on the nucleophilicity of L; negative ΔS‡.
Many 18-electron carbonyls show a two-term rate law, rate = \( (k_1 + k_2[\text{L}])[\text{M}] \): a dissociative path plus an associative path with good nucleophiles.
How an 18-electron complex can react associatively
A ligand can rearrange to free up two electrons’ worth of space without leaving:
| Rearrangement | Electron change | Example |
|---|---|---|
| η⁵ → η³ ring slip | Cp: 5 → 3 e⁻ | (η⁵-indenyl)Rh(CO)₂ substitutes associatively, very much faster than CpRh(CO)₂: the indenyl effect, because slipping to η³ restores the aromaticity of the fused benzene ring |
| Linear → bent NO | 3 → 1 e⁻ | Co(CO)₃(NO) substitutes by an associative path |
| η³ → η¹ allyl | 3 → 1 e⁻ | allyl complexes |
| η⁶ → η⁴ arene | 6 → 4 e⁻ | arene exchange in (arene)Cr(CO)₃ |
Photochemical and chemical CO removal
UV light labilises CO (Cr(CO)₆ + hν in THF → Cr(CO)₅(THF), then L replaces THF). Trimethylamine N-oxide removes CO under mild conditions: Me₃NO attacks a carbonyl carbon, CO₂ and NMe₃ leave, and a vacant site remains.
Oxidative Addition
$$\text{L}_n\text{M}^{(x)} + \text{A–B} \longrightarrow \text{L}_n\text{M}^{(x+2)}(\text{A})(\text{B})$$The metal gives two electrons to break A–B and forms two new M–A and M–B bonds.
What favours oxidative addition
- Electron-rich metal: low oxidation state, donor ligands (PMe₃ better than PPh₃, which is better than CO).
- Heavier metal in a group for the same reaction, especially in group 9: Ir(I) adds small molecules more readily and more irreversibly than Rh(I). Third-row metals form stronger M–L bonds and stable higher oxidation states. (Do not over-apply this: for aryl halides, Ni(0) is often more reactive than Pd(0).)
- Coordinative unsaturation: 16-electron (or lower) complexes; an 18-electron complex must first lose a ligand.
- A weak A–B bond and strong new M–A, M–B bonds.
Mechanisms
| Mechanism | Typical substrates | Stereochemistry and evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Concerted (three-centre transition state) | H₂, C–H, Si–H, aryl halides on Pd(0) | cis addition; retention at carbon; often via a σ-complex (η²-H₂) |
| S_N2 (metal as nucleophile) | CH₃I, benzyl and allyl halides, acyl halides | second order; accelerated in polar solvents; large negative ΔS‡; inversion at carbon; reactivity CH₃ > 1° > 2° and I > Br > Cl; often trans addition overall |
| Radical (chain or non-chain) | some secondary and tertiary alkyl halides | racemisation at carbon; inhibited by radical traps |
| Ionic (stepwise) | HCl, HBr in polar media | protonation of metal, then halide binding |
Vaska’s complex summarises all of this:
$$\textit{trans}\text{-Ir}^{\text{I}}\text{Cl(CO)(PPh}_3)_2 + \text{H}_2 \longrightarrow \textit{cis}\text{-Ir}^{\text{III}}(\text{H})_2\text{Cl(CO)(PPh}_3)_2$$16 → 18 electrons, Ir(I) d⁸ → Ir(III) d⁶, CN 4 → 6. With O₂ it gives a reversible η²-O₂ (peroxo) adduct. In every case ν(CO) increases after addition, because the oxidised metal back-donates less.
Binuclear oxidative addition
Two metals can each be oxidised by one unit:
$$2\,[\text{Co(CN)}_5]^{3-} + \text{H}_2 \longrightarrow 2\,[\text{HCo(CN)}_5]^{3-}$$Each cobalt goes from Co(II), 17 electrons, to Co(III), 18 electrons.
Reductive Elimination
The reverse of oxidative addition, and the product-forming step of most catalytic cycles: two cis X-type ligands couple and leave.
$$\text{L}_n\text{M}^{(x+2)}(\text{A})(\text{B}) \longrightarrow \text{L}_n\text{M}^{(x)} + \text{A–B}$$What favours reductive elimination:
- the two groups cis (trans groups must first isomerise);
- high oxidation state, electron-poor metal (π-acceptor co-ligands, positive charge);
- bulky ligands and chelating phosphines with large bite angles that push the two groups together;
- first-row and second-row metals more than third-row (Pd more than Pt);
- easiest for H–H and C–H, harder for C–C (the directional sp³ orbitals of two alkyl groups overlap poorly in the transition state);
- stereochemistry at carbon is retained.
Sometimes a ligand must dissociate first (to a three-coordinate or five-coordinate intermediate), or the metal is oxidised to make elimination faster.
Migratory Insertion
An unsaturated ligand inserts into a cis M–X bond (X = H, alkyl, aryl). Two kinds:
| Type | Ligand | Product | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,1-insertion | CO, isocyanide, SO₂ | the X group and the metal end up on the same atom | M–CH₃ + CO → M–C(O)CH₃ (acyl) |
| 1,2-insertion | alkene, alkyne | M and X end up on adjacent atoms | M–H + CH₂=CH₂ → M–CH₂CH₃ |
CO insertion: the CH₃Mn(CO)₅ experiments
$$\text{CH}_3\text{Mn(CO)}_5 + \text{L} \longrightarrow \textit{cis}\text{-CH}_3\text{C(O)Mn(CO)}_4\text{L}$$Three classic results:
- With ¹³CO as L, the product contains the label in a terminal CO cis to the acyl, never in the acyl group. The CO that becomes the acyl is one already on the metal.
- The reverse reaction, decarbonylation of cis-CH₃C(O)Mn(CO)₄(¹³CO), gives CH₃Mn(CO)₅ with the label distributed cis : trans : none = 2 : 1 : 1 relative to methyl. That distribution is expected only if the methyl group migrates (in the reverse, methyl moves to a vacant cis site); if the CO moved instead, no trans-labelled product could form.
- Kinetics follow a pre-equilibrium:
At low [L] the rate is first order in L; at high [L] it saturates at \( k_{\text{obs}} = k_1 \). A plot of \( 1/k_{\text{obs}} \) against \( 1/[\text{L}] \) is linear with intercept \( 1/k_1 \) and slope \( k_{-1}/(k_1k_2) \).
Other features of 1,1-insertion:
- the migrating alkyl keeps its configuration (retention);
- Lewis acids (AlCl₃, BF₃) bound to the acyl oxygen, coordinating solvents, bulky ligands and one-electron oxidation all accelerate it;
- CO insertion is close to thermoneutral and reversible; double CO insertion to give M–C(O)C(O)R is rare, so CO alone does not polymerise this way.
Alkene insertion
1,2-insertion of an alkene into M–H or M–C is the reverse of β-hydride elimination:
- syn addition: M and H (or R) add to the same face of the alkene, through a four-centre planar transition state;
- for a terminal alkene the metal usually ends up on the terminal carbon (linear alkyl), for steric reasons;
- insertion into M–H is usually exothermic and fast; repeated insertion into M–C is chain growth in Ziegler–Natta polymerisation.
Elimination Reactions
β-Hydride elimination
$$\text{L}_n\text{M–CH}_2\text{CH}_2\text{R} \longrightarrow \text{L}_n\text{M(H)}(\eta^2\text{-CH}_2{=}\text{CHR})$$Requirements (recap from the hydrocarbon-ligand page): a β-hydrogen, a vacant site cis to the alkyl, and a syn-coplanar M–C–C–H arrangement. Repeated β-H elimination and reinsertion with the opposite regiochemistry moves a metal along a chain (alkene isomerisation, “chain walking”).
α-Elimination and α-abstraction
High-valent early-metal alkyls without β-hydrogens lose an α-hydrogen. α-Abstraction (one alkyl removes the α-H of another, leaving as alkane) gives Schrock alkylidenes, as in the neopentyl tantalum example. α-Elimination is also invoked in the Green–Rooney view of polymerisation.
σ-Bond Metathesis
d⁰ metals (Sc(III), Y(III), lanthanides(III), Ti(IV), Zr(IV)) have no d electrons for oxidative addition. They still activate H–H and C–H bonds, through a concerted four-centre (“kite”) transition state with no change in oxidation state:
$$\text{L}_n\text{M–R} + \text{R}'\text{–H} \longrightarrow [\text{four-centre TS}] \longrightarrow \text{L}_n\text{M–R}' + \text{R–H}$$Classic examples: Cp₂Lu–CH₃ exchanges its methyl with ¹³CH₄ in solution (Watson); Cp₂Sc–CH₃ + H₂ → Cp*₂Sc–H + CH₄ (hydrogenolysis, the chain-transfer step for d⁰ polymerisation catalysts).
Attack on Coordinated Ligands
Nucleophilic attack
Coordination to a cationic or electron-poor metal makes a ligand electrophilic.
| Ligand | Nucleophile | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| CO | OH⁻ | M–COOH → M–H + CO₂ (the water–gas shift step) |
| CO | RLi | acyl anion → Fischer carbene after O-alkylation |
| CO | Me₃NO | CO₂ + NMe₃ lost; vacant site created |
| Alkene on Pd(II) | H₂O, ROH, amines | hydroxy- or alkoxypalladation (Wacker chemistry) |
| η³-Allyl on Pd(II) | soft carbanions (malonate), amines | allylic substitution (Tsuji–Trost); soft nucleophiles attack the allyl face anti to Pd |
| η⁶-Arene on Cr(CO)₃ | carbanions | cyclohexadienyl anion, then substituted arene |
| Fischer carbene | amines, alkoxides | substitution at the carbene carbon |
Davies–Green–Mingos rules predict where a nucleophile attacks an 18-electron cation carrying several π-hydrocarbon ligands (under kinetic control):
- Even polyenes (η², η⁴, η⁶) are attacked before odd polyenyls (η³, η⁵).
- Open (acyclic) ligands are attacked before closed (cyclic) ones.
- For an even open polyene, attack is at a terminal carbon.
Electrophilic attack
- At the metal: protonation of electron-rich complexes gives hydrides (Cp₂WH₂ + H⁺ → [Cp₂WH₃]⁺).
- At the M–C bond: protonolysis (M–R + HX → M–X + RH) and halogenolysis (M–R + X₂ → M–X + RX); stereochemistry at carbon can be retention or inversion depending on mechanism.
- At a ligand: Friedel–Crafts acylation of ferrocene; alkylation of the oxygen of an acyl anion.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Oxidative addition: OS +2, two new M–X bonds | Ligand association: OS unchanged, one new M–L bond | |
| Concerted OA of H₂: cis product, retention | S_N2 OA of CH₃I: trans product often, inversion at C | |
| Migratory insertion: OS unchanged, count −2 | Reductive elimination: OS −2, count −2 | |
| β-H elimination: needs β-H and cis vacancy | α-abstraction: needs α-H, early high-valent metal | |
| σ-bond metathesis (d⁰, no OS change) | OA followed by RE (OS +2 then −2) | |
| Indenyl effect (η⁵ → η³, associative) | Dissociative CO loss from 18-e carbonyls |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Give the changes in oxidation state and electron count when Vaska’s complex adds H₂.
- Which step is the microscopic reverse of 1,2-insertion of ethylene into an M–H bond?
- Why can Cp*₂Lu–CH₃ not activate CH₄ by oxidative addition?
Answers
- Ir(I) → Ir(III), +2; 16 → 18 electrons, +2.
- β-Hydride elimination from the ethyl complex.
- Lu(III) is d⁰; there are no metal d electrons to give, and Lu(V) is not accessible. It reacts by σ-bond metathesis instead.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The reaction CH₃Mn(CO)₅ + PPh₃ → CH₃C(O)Mn(CO)₄(PPh₃) is an example of:
(a) oxidative addition (b) migratory insertion followed by ligand association (c) reductive elimination (d) σ-bond metathesis
Answer: (b)
Methyl migrates to a cis CO (16-electron acyl intermediate, OS unchanged at Mn(I)), then PPh₃ fills the vacancy (18 electrons). No change in oxidation state, so not OA or RE.
Practice Q2. The substitution of CO in Ni(CO)₄ by PPh₃ in hydrocarbon solvent has a rate independent of [PPh₃] and a positive ΔS‡. The mechanism is:
(a) associative (b) dissociative (c) interchange with S_N2 character (d) electron-transfer catalysed
Answer: (b)
Zero order in incoming ligand and positive ΔS‡ both point to rate-determining loss of CO from the 18-electron complex.
Practice Q3. A single enantiomer of the chiral alkyl bromide CH₃CHDBr adds to an electron-rich metal centre by the S_N2 pathway. The configuration at carbon in the alkyl complex is:
(a) retained (b) inverted (c) racemised (d) unchanged because the C–Br bond is not broken
Answer: (b) inverted
In the S_N2 pathway the metal attacks carbon from the back side and bromide leaves, as in an organic S_N2 reaction: inversion at carbon. A radical pathway would racemise; a concerted three-centre addition would retain.
Practice Q4. Which complex will most readily undergo associative CO substitution?
(a) CpRh(CO)₂ (b) (η⁵-C₉H₇)Rh(CO)₂ (indenyl) (c) Cr(CO)₆ (d) Fe(CO)₅
Answer: (b)
All four are 18-electron. Indenyl slips easily from η⁵ to η³ (the benzo ring regains full aromaticity), freeing a site for the incoming ligand: the indenyl effect. Cp slips far less readily; Cr(CO)₆ and Fe(CO)₅ substitute dissociatively.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. For the reaction CH₃Mn(CO)₅ + L → CH₃C(O)Mn(CO)₄L, the observed pseudo-first-order rate constants (illustrative data) are \( k_{\text{obs}} = 2.0 \times 10^{-4} \) s⁻¹ at [L] = 0.010 M and \( 5.0 \times 10^{-4} \) s⁻¹ at [L] = 0.100 M. Assuming the pre-equilibrium mechanism above, \( k_1 \) and \( k_{-1}/k_2 \) are:
(a) \( 6.0 \times 10^{-4} \) s⁻¹ and 0.020 M (b) \( 5.0 \times 10^{-4} \) s⁻¹ and 0.010 M (c) \( 6.0 \times 10^{-4} \) s⁻¹ and 0.050 M (d) \( 2.0 \times 10^{-2} \) s⁻¹ and 0.020 M
Answer: (a)
Linearise: \( \dfrac{1}{k_{\text{obs}}} = \dfrac{1}{k_1} + \dfrac{k_{-1}}{k_1k_2}\cdot\dfrac{1}{[\text{L}]} \).
Data points \( (1/[\text{L}],\ 1/k_{\text{obs}}) \): (100 M⁻¹, 5000 s) and (10 M⁻¹, 2000 s).
Slope \( = (5000 - 2000)/(100 - 10) = 33.3 \) M s. Intercept \( = 2000 - 33.3 \times 10 = 1667 \) s, so \( k_1 = 6.0 \times 10^{-4} \) s⁻¹.
\( k_{-1}/k_2 = \text{slope} \times k_1 = 33.3 \times 6.0 \times 10^{-4} = 0.020 \) M.
Check: \( 6.0 \times 10^{-4} \times 0.010/(0.020 + 0.010) = 2.0 \times 10^{-4} \) s⁻¹, as observed. Note that 5.0 × 10⁻⁴ s⁻¹ is not yet the saturation value.
Practice Q6. cis-CH₃C(O)Mn(CO)₄(¹³CO) is decarbonylated. Assume a cis CO (any of the four, labelled or not) dissociates with equal probability and the methyl group then migrates to the vacant site. Which statements are correct?
- 25% of the product carries no ¹³C label.
- 25% of the product has ¹³CO trans to the methyl group.
- If CO migrated instead of methyl, the trans-labelled product would be absent.
- The observation of the trans-labelled product supports alkyl migration.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 2 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Put the acyl on +z and ¹³CO at +x; the four cis sites are ±x, ±y.
- Vacancy at +x (the labelled CO lost): product unlabelled, probability 1/4.
- Vacancy at −x: methyl moves to −x, label at +x is trans to methyl, probability 1/4.
- Vacancy at ±y: methyl at ±y, label at +x cis, probability 2/4.
Distribution cis : trans : none = 2 : 1 : 1. If instead the acyl CO moved and methyl stayed at +z, the label (at +x) could only be cis to methyl or lost: no trans product. Observing trans product supports methyl migration.
Practice Q7. Vaska’s complex reacts with CH₃I in a polar solvent. Rate = k[Ir][CH₃I], ΔS‡ is large and negative, and the reaction is faster in more polar solvents. A chiral secondary alkyl halide reacts with inversion at carbon. Which conclusions are correct?
- The mechanism is S_N2 oxidative addition with the metal as nucleophile.
- The first intermediate is likely a cationic five-coordinate Ir(III) species with iodide as the counter-ion.
- ν(CO) of the product is lower than that of Vaska’s complex.
- Replacing PPh₃ by the more basic PMe₃ should speed up the reaction.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. Second-order kinetics, polar transition state, inversion: S_N2.
- Correct. Ir attacks CH₃, iodide leaves to give [IrCl(CH₃)(CO)(PPh₃)₂]⁺ I⁻, which then binds iodide.
- Wrong. Ir(III) back-donates less than Ir(I); ν(CO) rises after oxidative addition.
- Correct. A more electron-rich metal is a better nucleophile.
Quick Revision Table
| Step | ΔOS / ΔCN / Δe⁻ | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| Dissociation | 0 / −1 / −2 | 18-e; rate zero order in L; ΔS‡ > 0 |
| Association | 0 / +1 / +2 | 16-, 17-e; ΔS‡ < 0; ring slip, bent NO |
| Oxidative addition | +2 / +2 / +2 | electron-rich, heavy metal; concerted (cis), S_N2 (inversion), radical |
| Reductive elimination | −2 / −2 / −2 | cis groups; high OS, bulky ligands; retention |
| 1,1-insertion (CO) | 0 / −1 / −2 | alkyl migrates; retention; 2 : 1 : 1 label result |
| 1,2-insertion (alkene) | 0 / −1 / −2 | syn; M to terminal C |
| β-H elimination | 0 / +1 / +2 | β-H, cis vacancy, syn-coplanar |
| α-Elimination | 0* / +1 / +2 | early metals; alkylidenes (*+2 if carbene counted as CR₂²⁻) |
| σ-Bond metathesis | 0 / 0 / 0 | d⁰; four-centre TS |
| Nucleophilic attack | — | even before odd, open before closed |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Homogeneous Catalysis by Organometallic Complexes: these steps chained into industrial cycles.
- Revise ligands in Hydrocarbon Ligands.
- Organometallics: Quick Revision.
- Back to the chapter overview.