Orbital Symmetry and Electrocyclic Reactions
CSIR NET organic chemistry: pericyclic classes, FMO and correlation diagrams, Woodward–Hoffmann rules, conrotatory vs disrotatory, ions, torquoselectivity.
- 18 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Two Cyclobutenes, Two Dienes
- What Makes a Reaction Pericyclic
- The π Orbitals You Need
- Three Ways to Get the Same Answer
- The Electrocyclic Selection Rules
- Working Out the Stereochemistry
- Ionic Electrocyclic Reactions
- Torquoselectivity
- Photochemical Electrocyclic Reactions
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems: the π MOs of allyl, butadiene and hexatriene, their energies and coefficients.
- Aromaticity Criteria: Hückel’s Rule, Antiaromaticity and Beyond: \( 4n + 2 \) versus \( 4n \), and the Möbius idea used for transition states.
- Symmetry Elements and Operations: mirror planes and C₂ axes, which are all the group theory a correlation diagram needs.
- Stereospecific and Stereoselective Reactions: the language for “one isomer in, one isomer out”.
The Hook: Two Cyclobutenes, Two Dienes
What Makes a Reaction Pericyclic
The families
| Family | What happens | Change in σ bonds | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electrocyclic | a conjugated polyene closes to a ring (or the reverse) | one σ bond formed or broken, at the ends of one π system | hexatriene ⇌ cyclohexa-1,3-diene |
| Cycloaddition | two π systems join at both ends to form a ring | two σ bonds formed | Diels–Alder |
| Sigmatropic | a σ bond migrates along a π system | one σ bond broken, one formed | Cope, Claisen, [1,5]-H shift |
| Cheletropic | two σ bonds made or broken at the same atom | two σ bonds at one atom | SO₂ + butadiene → sulfolene |
| Group transfer | atoms (often two H) move from one molecule to another | diimide reduction | |
| Ene | an allylic H moves to an enophile while a C–C bond forms | propene + maleic anhydride |
This page covers the theory and electrocyclic reactions. Cycloaddition reactions, sigmatropic rearrangements and the ene, cheletropic and group-transfer family follow.
Evidence that a reaction is pericyclic
| Observation | What it suggests |
|---|---|
| Strict stereospecificity (one isomer in, one isomer out) | concerted, single TS |
| Large negative entropy of activation | highly ordered cyclic TS |
| Small solvent effect on rate | little charge separation in the TS |
| No effect of radical initiators or inhibitors; no CIDNP | no radical chain |
| Thermal and photochemical routes give different stereoisomers | orbital-symmetry control |
The π Orbitals You Need
The ends of the polyene are where the new σ bond forms, so only the terminal coefficients of the relevant orbital matter. Hückel coefficients (computed for a linear chain, \( E = \alpha + x\beta \)):
| System (π electrons) | Orbital | \( x \) | Coefficients, C1 to Cn | Termini |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ethylene (2) | ψ₁ (HOMO) | 1 | 0.707, 0.707 | same sign |
| Allyl (2, 3 or 4) | ψ₂ (nonbonding) | 0 | 0.707, 0, −0.707 | opposite |
| Butadiene (4) | ψ₂ (HOMO) | 0.618 | 0.602, 0.372, −0.372, −0.602 | opposite |
| Butadiene, excited | ψ₃ (LUMO) | −0.618 | 0.602, −0.372, −0.372, 0.602 | same sign |
| Pentadienyl (4, 5 or 6) | ψ₃ (nonbonding) | 0 | 0.577, 0, −0.577, 0, 0.577 | same sign |
| Hexatriene (6) | ψ₃ (HOMO) | 0.445 | 0.521, 0.232, −0.418, −0.418, 0.232, 0.521 | same sign |
| Hexatriene, excited | ψ₄ (LUMO) | −0.445 | 0.521, −0.232, −0.418, 0.418, 0.232, −0.521 | opposite |
Two rules let you write these without a calculator:
- ψₖ has \( k - 1 \) nodes, spread symmetrically.
- The terminal lobes alternate: ψ₁ termini in phase, ψ₂ out of phase, ψ₃ in phase, and so on.
So the HOMO of a \( 4n \) π-electron polyene (ψ₂ of butadiene, ψ₄ of octatetraene) has termini out of phase; the HOMO of a \( 4n + 2 \) polyene (ψ₃ of hexatriene) has termini in phase.
Three Ways to Get the Same Answer
1. Frontier molecular orbital (FMO) method
Look at the HOMO of the open-chain polyene (Fukui’s frontier-orbital idea). To form the new σ bond, the two terminal p lobes that end up overlapping must have the same sign.
graph TD
A["Count pi electrons
of the open polyene"] --> B{"Thermal or
photochemical?"}
B -->|"thermal"| C["HOMO = ground-state HOMO"]
B -->|"hv"| D["HOMO = old LUMO
(one electron promoted)"]
C --> E{"Terminal lobes of
that HOMO"}
D --> E
E -->|"same sign on same face"| F["DISROTATORY
(one clockwise, one anticlockwise)"]
E -->|"same sign on opposite faces"| G["CONROTATORY
(both rotate the same way)"]- Butadiene, thermal: HOMO ψ₂, termini out of phase. The positive lobe at C1 is on the top face and the positive lobe at C4 is on the bottom. Both ends must turn the same way (conrotatory) to bring like lobes together.
- Butadiene, hν: HOMO is now ψ₃, termini in phase → disrotatory.
- Hexatriene, thermal: HOMO ψ₃, termini in phase → disrotatory; hν: ψ₄ → conrotatory.
2. Correlation diagrams (Woodward–Hoffmann)
In 1965 Woodward and Hoffmann classified every orbital that changes in the reaction by a symmetry element kept throughout the motion:
- Conrotation keeps a C₂ axis (in the molecular plane, bisecting the C2–C3 bond of butadiene).
- Disrotation keeps a mirror plane (perpendicular to the molecular plane, bisecting the same bond).
For butadiene → cyclobutene, the orbitals are labelled S (symmetric) or A (antisymmetric):
| Butadiene orbital | Under mirror (dis) | Under C₂ (con) | Cyclobutene orbital | Under mirror | Under C₂ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ψ₁ (occupied) | S | A | σ (occupied) | S | S |
| ψ₂ (occupied) | A | S | π (occupied) | S | A |
| ψ₃ | S | A | π* | A | S |
| ψ₄ | A | S | σ* | A | A |
Orbitals of the same symmetry correlate, lowest with lowest, and lines of the same symmetry never cross.
- Conrotatory (C₂): ψ₁ (A) → π (A); ψ₂ (S) → σ (S). Both occupied reactant orbitals become occupied product orbitals: the ground state correlates with the ground state. Thermally allowed.
- Disrotatory (mirror): ψ₁ (S) → σ (S), but ψ₂ (A) → π* (A). The ground state of butadiene correlates with a doubly excited state of cyclobutene: a large symmetry-imposed barrier. Thermally forbidden. The first excited state (ψ₁²ψ₂¹ψ₃¹) correlates with the first excited state of the product, so the disrotatory path is photochemically allowed.
“Forbidden” means a high symmetry-imposed barrier, not impossible. A forbidden reaction can still happen by a stepwise (diradical or ionic) route if the conditions are harsh enough, and then it loses its stereospecificity.
3. Aromatic transition-state (Dewar–Zimmerman) method
Draw the cyclic array of basis orbitals in the transition state and count phase inversions (sign changes between neighbouring lobes that overlap):
| Phase inversions | TS topology | Aromatic (allowed thermally) with | Antiaromatic with |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 or even | Hückel | \( 4n + 2 \) electrons | \( 4n \) |
| odd | Möbius | \( 4n \) electrons | \( 4n + 2 \) |
A disrotatory TS for butadiene has no inversion (Hückel, 4 electrons, antiaromatic → forbidden); the conrotatory TS has one inversion (Möbius, 4 electrons, aromatic → allowed). Photochemical reactions take the antiaromatic TS. This method is the fastest in the exam hall and works for every pericyclic class.
The Electrocyclic Selection Rules
| π electrons in the open polyene | Thermal (Δ) | Photochemical (hν) | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| \( 4n \) (4, 8 …) | conrotatory | disrotatory | butadiene ⇌ cyclobutene; octatetraene ⇌ cyclooctatriene |
| \( 4n + 2 \) (2, 6, 10 …) | disrotatory | conrotatory | hexatriene ⇌ cyclohexadiene; allyl cation → cyclopropyl cation (reverse) |
The rule refers to the electrons of the open-chain partner, and it holds in both directions (microscopic reversibility): if ring closure is conrotatory, ring opening by the same mode is too.
Charged and odd-membered systems
Count electrons, not atoms.
| Open species | Atoms | π electrons | Thermal mode | Ring |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allyl cation | 3 | 2 | disrotatory | cyclopropyl cation |
| Allyl anion | 3 | 4 | conrotatory | cyclopropyl anion |
| Pentadienyl cation | 5 | 4 | conrotatory | cyclopentenyl cation (Nazarov) |
| Pentadienyl anion | 5 | 6 | disrotatory | cyclopentenyl anion |
| Heptatrienyl cation | 7 | 6 | disrotatory | |
| Heptatrienyl anion | 7 | 8 | conrotatory |
Heteroatom analogues follow the same count: aziridines open to azomethine ylides (4π, thermal conrotatory), and oxiranes with strongly stabilising groups open to carbonyl ylides.
Working Out the Stereochemistry
A reliable routine: draw the open polyene in the s-cis, s-cis (U-shaped) conformation needed to close, mark each terminal substituent as outside (pointing away from the chain) or inside (pointing into the U), then rotate.
- Conrotatory turns one “outside” group up and the other “outside” group down → the two outside groups end up trans in the ring.
- Disrotatory turns both outside groups the same way (both up) → they end up cis.
An E terminus with the chain drawn U-shaped has its substituent outside; a Z terminus has it inside.
The 4π examples
| Diene | Termini | Thermal (con) | hν (dis) |
|---|---|---|---|
| (2E,4E)-hexa-2,4-diene | out, out | trans-3,4-dimethylcyclobutene | cis |
| (2E,4Z)-hexa-2,4-diene | out, in | cis-3,4-dimethylcyclobutene | trans |
In practice the cyclobutene → diene direction is the one seen thermally, because ring strain makes the diene more stable. The hook used exactly this: cis-cyclobutene → (E,Z)-diene; trans-cyclobutene → (E,E)-diene (the (Z,Z)-diene, which would need both methyls rotating inward, is not formed).
The 6π examples
| Triene | Termini | Thermal (dis) | hν (con) |
|---|---|---|---|
| (2E,4Z,6E)-octa-2,4,6-triene | out, out | cis-5,6-dimethylcyclohexa-1,3-diene | trans |
| (2E,4Z,6Z)-octa-2,4,6-triene | out, in | trans-5,6-dimethylcyclohexa-1,3-diene | cis |
The central double bond must be Z for the ends to meet. Here the cyclohexadiene is usually more stable than the triene (a σ bond replaces a π bond with little strain), so thermal 6π reactions run in the ring-closing direction.
8π and cascades
(2E,4Z,6Z,8E)-Deca-2,4,6,8-tetraene undergoes thermal 8π conrotatory closure to trans-7,8-dimethylcycloocta-1,3,5-triene, which then undergoes 6π disrotatory closure to a cis-fused bicyclo[4.2.0]octadiene. The same 8π-con / 6π-dis sequence underlies the endiandric acid cascade (proposed by Black, realised in the laboratory by Nicolaou): a whole family of polycyclic natural products formed from linear polyenes with no enzyme needed.
Ring constraints decide what is possible
| Compound | What orbital symmetry demands | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Dewar benzene (bicyclo[2.2.0]hexa-2,5-diene) | thermal opening of the cyclobutene unit must be conrotatory, which would put a trans double bond in a six-membered ring | kinetically persistent despite a large driving force to benzene |
| cis-Bicyclo[3.2.0]hept-6-ene | conrotatory opening would give a trans,cis-cycloheptadiene | survives to much higher temperatures than a simple cyclobutene |
| Cycloheptatriene ⇌ norcaradiene | 6π disrotatory; allowed and fast | valence tautomers in equilibrium; electron-withdrawing groups at C7 favour norcaradiene |
| Cyclooctatetraene ⇌ bicyclo[4.2.0]octatriene | 6π disrotatory | small equilibrium amount of the bicycle, which can be trapped by dienophiles |
Ionic Electrocyclic Reactions
Nazarov cyclisation
A divinyl ketone treated with a Lewis or Brønsted acid gives a cyclopent-2-enone.
graph TD
A["Divinyl ketone"] -->|"Lewis acid on O"| B["Pentadienyl cation
(oxyallyl-type, 4 pi electrons)"]
B -->|"4pi conrotatory closure
(thermal)"| C["Cyclic oxyallyl cation"]
C -->|"loss of H+ (beta to cation)"| D["Dienol / enolate"]
D -->|"tautomerisation"| E["Cyclopent-2-enone"]- The key step is a 4π conrotatory closure, so substituents at the two termini end up trans in the oxyallyl cation.
- The double-bond position in the product is set by which proton is lost; normally the more substituted alkene forms. A β-silyl group directs it (the silicon-directed Nazarov, Denmark): loss of the silyl group instead of H⁺ fixes the alkene where the silicon was.
Cyclopropyl cations and the outward-rotation rule
A cyclopropyl cation (2π when it opens) opens disrotatorily to an allyl cation. In practice ionisation and ring opening are concerted during solvolysis of cyclopropyl halides or tosylates, and the direction of disrotation is fixed: substituents trans to the leaving group rotate outward (the Woodward–Hoffmann–DePuy rule), because the C2–C3 bond electrons flow into the back lobe of the breaking C–X bond.
| cis-2,3-Dimethylcyclopropyl tosylate | Methyls rotate | Allyl cation | Solvolysis |
|---|---|---|---|
| methyls trans to OTs | both outward | W-shaped, no strain | fast |
| methyls cis to OTs | both inward | U-shaped, methyls clash | slow |
Anionic examples
The cyclopropyl anion → allyl anion (4π) is conrotatory; pentadienyl anions (6π) close disrotatorily. These are less common in exam questions but follow the same count.
Torquoselectivity
A conrotatory opening of a 3-substituted cyclobutene can rotate the substituent outward (giving the 1E-diene) or inward (1Z). Both are allowed, so orbital symmetry alone cannot choose. Houk called the preference torquoselectivity:
- Donors (OR, NR₂, halogen, alkyl) rotate outward: in the inward rotation their filled orbital would mix destructively with the breaking σ bond.
- Strong π-acceptors (CHO, for example) can rotate inward, because their empty orbital accepts electron density from the breaking σ bond.
Steric effects add to this: a large group also prefers to rotate outward. In a Part C question, a 3,3-disubstituted cyclobutene with a donor and an acceptor gives the diene in which the donor is outside (E) and the acceptor inside.
Photochemical Electrocyclic Reactions
| Reaction | Electrons | Mode | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7-Dehydrocholesterol → previtamin D₃ | 6π ring opening | conrotatory (hν) | UV-B in skin; previtamin D₃ then gives vitamin D₃ by a thermal [1,7]-H shift |
| cis-Stilbene → 4a,4b-dihydrophenanthrene | 6π | conrotatory (hν) → trans-dihydro | oxidant (I₂/air) aromatises to phenanthrene (Mallory) |
| cis,cis-Cycloocta-1,3-diene → bicyclo[4.2.0]oct-7-ene | 4π | disrotatory (hν) | cis-fused product |
| Cyclohexa-1,3-diene → (Z)-hexa-1,3,5-triene | 6π | conrotatory (hν) | the model for the vitamin D step |
The vitamin D story is a favourite Part C sequence: photochemical 6π conrotatory opening of the B ring, then an antarafacial [1,7]-H shift, which is thermally allowed for 8 electrons (see sigmatropic rearrangements). Overirradiation diverts previtamin D to lumisterol and tachysterol by further photochemical steps. The excited states involved are discussed on the organic photochemistry page.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Conrotatory: both termini rotate the same way; C₂ axis conserved | Disrotatory: opposite senses; mirror plane conserved | |
| Electron count of the open polyene (butadiene, 4) | Number of atoms in the ring (cyclobutene, 4) or of the closed π system (cyclobutene has 2 π electrons) | |
| “Forbidden”: high symmetry-imposed barrier; may go stepwise under forcing conditions | “Impossible” | |
| Torquoselectivity: choice between two allowed conrotations | Selection rule: choice between allowed and forbidden modes | |
| Nazarov: 4π cation, conrotatory | Pentadienyl anion: 6π, disrotatory | |
| Photochemical 6π ring opening of provitamin D: conrotatory | Thermal [1,7]-H shift that follows: antarafacial |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many nodes does the HOMO of hexa-1,3,5-triene have, and are its terminal lobes in phase?
- Which symmetry element is conserved along a disrotatory pathway?
- A heptatrienyl anion closes thermally. Con or dis?
Answers
- The HOMO is ψ₃: two nodes; the terminal coefficients are 0.521 and 0.521 (same sign), so the termini are in phase.
- A mirror plane perpendicular to the plane of the polyene, bisecting it.
- Seven atoms but 8 π electrons (\( 4n \)): conrotatory.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. trans-3,4-Diethylcyclobutene is heated. The major product is:
(a) (3E,5E)-octa-3,5-diene (b) (3E,5Z)-octa-3,5-diene (c) (3Z,5Z)-octa-3,5-diene (d) cis-3,4-diethylcyclobutene
Answer: (a)
Thermal 4π opening is conrotatory. Trans substituents on the ring both rotate outward (one up, one down in the same sense), giving both termini E. Running the other way, a trans-cyclobutene with con could also give Z,Z by rotating both inward, but that is sterically blocked.
Practice Q2. (2E,4Z,6Z)-Octa-2,4,6-triene is irradiated. The cyclohexadiene formed is:
(a) cis-5,6-dimethylcyclohexa-1,3-diene by disrotation (b) trans-5,6-dimethylcyclohexa-1,3-diene by disrotation (c) cis-5,6-dimethylcyclohexa-1,3-diene by conrotation (d) trans-5,6-dimethylcyclohexa-1,3-diene by conrotation
Answer: (c)
6π photochemical = conrotatory. The termini are E (outside) and Z (inside). Conrotation moves an outside group and an inside group to the same face, so the product is cis. Check: the thermal (dis) product of this triene would be trans.
Practice Q3. In the Nazarov cyclisation, the key ring-forming step is best described as:
(a) a 6π disrotatory closure of a pentadienyl anion (b) a 4π conrotatory closure of a pentadienyl cation (c) a [3,3]-sigmatropic shift (d) a 4π disrotatory closure under thermal conditions
Answer: (b)
Acid activation of the divinyl ketone gives a pentadienyl cation with 4 π electrons; thermal 4π closure is conrotatory.
Practice Q4. Of the two isomers of cis-2,3-dimethylcyclopropyl tosylate, the one that solvolyses faster has:
(a) methyls cis to OTs, because they rotate outward (b) methyls trans to OTs, because they rotate outward (c) methyls cis to OTs, because conrotation is allowed (d) both react at the same rate, since disrotation is allowed for both
Answer: (b)
Groups trans to the leaving group rotate outward during the disrotatory opening. With both methyls trans to OTs, both go outward to a W-shaped allyl cation without steric strain; the other isomer must turn both methyls inward.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. (2E,4Z,6Z,8E)-Deca-2,4,6,8-tetraene is heated gently. It first gives compound X (C₁₀H₁₄, monocyclic), which then gives Y (bicyclic). Which statements are correct?
- X is formed by an 8π conrotatory closure and its two methyl groups are trans.
- Y is formed from X by a 6π disrotatory closure.
- The ring fusion in Y is trans.
- Irradiation of the tetraene would give, by an 8π process, the cis-dimethyl cyclooctatriene.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
1: the termini are both E (outside); thermal 8π (\( 4n \)) is conrotatory, so the outside groups become trans. Correct. 2: X is a cycloocta-1,3,5-triene, a 6π unit; thermally it closes disrotatorily. Correct. 3: disrotatory closure of a 6π unit inside an eight-membered ring forms the new bond with both new ring-fusion hydrogens on the same face: cis-fused bicyclo[4.2.0]octadiene. Incorrect. 4: hν reverses the mode for 8π: disrotatory, so two outside groups end up cis. Correct.
Practice Q6. A 3-substituted cyclobutene bearing a donor group D undergoes thermal ring opening at 298 K. (Illustrative data.) The outward rotation of D is favoured over inward rotation by \( \Delta\Delta G^{\ddagger} = 8.0 \) kJ mol⁻¹. What is the approximate ratio of (1E)-diene to (1Z)-diene, and what is the origin of the preference?
(a) about 25 : 1; torquoselectivity, donors rotate outward (b) about 3 : 1; steric only (c) about 25 : 1; the inward path is symmetry-forbidden (d) about 1 : 25; donors rotate inward
Answer: (a)
Ratio \( = \exp(\Delta\Delta G^{\ddagger}/RT) = \exp\left(\frac{8000}{8.314 \times 298}\right) = \exp(3.23) \approx 25 \). Both rotations are conrotatory and so both are allowed; the choice is torquoselectivity, which for a donor favours outward rotation (E product). (c) is wrong because neither path is forbidden.
Practice Q7. Consider the correlation diagram for butadiene ⇌ cyclobutene. Which statements are correct?
- Along the conrotatory path, ψ₂ of butadiene (symmetric under C₂) correlates with the σ orbital of cyclobutene.
- Along the disrotatory path, the ground state of butadiene correlates with a doubly excited state of cyclobutene.
- The disrotatory path is allowed photochemically because the first excited states correlate.
- Along the conrotatory path, ψ₁ correlates with σ*.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a)
Under C₂: ψ₁ is A, ψ₂ is S; cyclobutene σ is S, π is A. So ψ₁ → π and ψ₂ → σ (1 correct, 4 wrong). Under the mirror: ψ₂ (A) correlates with π* (A), so ψ₁²ψ₂² → σ²π² (2 correct), while ψ₁²ψ₂ψ₃ → σ²ππ (3 correct).
Quick Revision Table
| Topic | Key facts |
|---|---|
| Pericyclic | concerted, cyclic TS, no intermediate, stereospecific, small solvent effect |
| Families | electrocyclic, cycloaddition, sigmatropic, cheletropic, group transfer, ene |
| Terminal phases | HOMO of \( 4n \) polyene: out of phase; of \( 4n + 2 \): in phase |
| Rules | \( 4n \): Δ con, hν dis; \( 4n + 2 \): Δ dis, hν con |
| Correlation diagram | con keeps C₂; dis keeps mirror; ground → ground = allowed |
| Dewar–Zimmerman | Hückel (even inversions) aromatic for \( 4n + 2 \); Möbius (odd) for \( 4n \) |
| Stereo routine | E = outside; con: outside groups trans; dis: outside groups cis |
| Ions | allyl⁺ 2 (dis), allyl⁻ 4 (con), pentadienyl⁺ 4 (con), pentadienyl⁻ 6 (dis) |
| Nazarov | divinyl ketone + acid → cyclopentenone, 4π con |
| DePuy | cyclopropyl solvolysis: groups trans to leaving group rotate out |
| Torquoselectivity | donors out; strong π-acceptors (CHO) can go in |
| Photochemical | provitamin D 6π con opening → [1,7]-H antarafacial; stilbene → dihydrophenanthrene |
| Constraints | Dewar benzene persists: con opening would give trans-cyclohexene |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Next topic: Cycloaddition Reactions: the same orbital logic applied to two components.
- Back to the chapter overview.
- Revise the orbitals themselves: Hückel Theory for Conjugated π Systems.
- Light-driven versions in depth: Organic Photochemistry.