Particle in a Box, Harmonic Oscillator and Tunnelling
CSIR NET chemistry: particle in 1D, 2D and 3D boxes, degeneracy, free-electron model, harmonic oscillator, isotope effects and barrier tunnelling.
- 22 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Postulates of Quantum Mechanics and Operator Algebra: acceptable wavefunctions, eigenvalue equations and expectation values.
- Solving \( y'' = -k^2y \) and \( y'' = +\kappa^2y \), and the integral \( \int_0^L \sin^2(n\pi x/L)\,dx = L/2 \).
- The physics-paper version, with the finite well, delta potential and ladder operators, is One-Dimensional Problems: Box, Oscillator and Tunnelling.
The Hook: Same Element, Different Colour
Particle in a One-Dimensional Box
A particle of mass \( m \) moves freely between infinitely high walls at \( x = 0 \) and \( x = L \): \( V = 0 \) inside, \( V = \infty \) outside.
Solving it. Outside, \( \psi = 0 \). Inside, \( -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\psi'' = E\psi \), so \( \psi = A\sin kx + B\cos kx \) with \( k = \sqrt{2mE}/\hbar \). Continuity at \( x = 0 \) gives \( B = 0 \); continuity at \( x = L \) gives \( \sin kL = 0 \), so \( kL = n\pi \). The boundary conditions, not any extra assumption, quantise the energy.
What to read off:
| Property | Result |
|---|---|
| Lowest energy | \( E_1 = h^2/8mL^2 > 0 \): zero-point energy. \( n = 0 \) gives \( \psi = 0 \) everywhere, not a state. |
| Level ratios | \( E_1 : E_2 : E_3 = 1 : 4 : 9 \) |
| Spacing | \( E_{n+1} - E_n = (2n + 1)h^2/8mL^2 \): grows with \( n \) |
| Relative spacing | \( \Delta E/E_n \approx 2/n \to 0 \): the classical continuum at large \( n \) (correspondence principle) |
| Nodes | \( n - 1 \) interior nodes |
| Parity about the centre | odd \( n \): symmetric; even \( n \): antisymmetric |
| Dependence on size and mass | \( E \propto 1/(mL^2) \): small boxes and light particles show quantisation |
| \( \langle x\rangle \) | \( L/2 \) for every \( n \) |
| \( \langle p_x\rangle \), \( \langle p_x^2\rangle \) | \( 0 \); \( n^2h^2/4L^2 = 2mE_n \) |
| \( \langle x^2\rangle \) | \( L^2\left(\dfrac{1}{3} - \dfrac{1}{2n^2\pi^2}\right) \) |
The box states are real, so \( \langle p_x\rangle = 0 \): each is an equal mixture of momenta \( +nh/2L \) and \( -nh/2L \). They are eigenfunctions of \( \hat{H} \) and of \( \hat{p}_x^2 \), but not of \( \hat{p}_x \).
Probability over part of the box
$$P(a \le x \le b) = \frac{2}{L}\int_a^b \sin^2\frac{n\pi x}{L}\,dx = \left[\frac{x}{L} - \frac{1}{2n\pi}\sin\frac{2n\pi x}{L}\right]_a^b$$| State | \( P(0 \le x \le L/4) \) | \( P(L/3 \le x \le 2L/3) \) |
|---|---|---|
| \( n = 1 \) | \( \tfrac{1}{4} - \tfrac{1}{2\pi} = 0.091 \) | \( \tfrac{1}{3} + \tfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2\pi} = 0.609 \) |
| \( n = 2 \) | \( 0.250 \) | \( 0.196 \) |
| \( n = 3 \) | \( 0.303 \) | \( 0.333 \) |
| Classical | \( 0.250 \) | \( 0.333 \) |
The ground state piles up in the middle; higher states approach the classical uniform distribution. For \( n = 2 \) the centre is a node, so the middle third is depleted.
The free-electron model of conjugated polyenes
Treat the \( N \) \( \pi \) electrons of a linear conjugated polyene as independent particles in a box of length \( L \) (roughly the chain length plus a bond length or so at each end). Two electrons go in each level, so the HOMO is \( n = N/2 \) and the LUMO \( n = N/2 + 1 \):
$$\Delta E = \frac{h^2}{8m_eL^2}\left[\left(\tfrac{N}{2} + 1\right)^2 - \left(\tfrac{N}{2}\right)^2\right] = \frac{(N + 1)h^2}{8m_eL^2}, \qquad \lambda = \frac{8m_ecL^2}{h(N + 1)}$$As the chain grows, \( L \) grows roughly in proportion to \( N \), so \( \lambda \) grows roughly as \( N \): longer conjugation absorbs further to the red. That is the trend from butadiene through the carotenoids. The model gets the trend right; its absolute wavelengths depend on the choice of \( L \).
Boxes in Two and Three Dimensions
For a rectangular box, \( V = 0 \) inside and \( \infty \) outside. The Hamiltonian is a sum of independent \( x, y, z \) parts, so the wavefunction is a product and the energy is a sum:
$$\psi = \psi_{n_x}(x)\,\psi_{n_y}(y)\,\psi_{n_z}(z), \qquad E = \frac{h^2}{8m}\left(\frac{n_x^2}{L_x^2} + \frac{n_y^2}{L_y^2} + \frac{n_z^2}{L_z^2}\right)$$Each quantum number starts at 1. The ground state of a cube is \( (1,1,1) \) with \( E = 3h^2/8mL^2 \).
Degeneracy in a cube
For \( L_x = L_y = L_z = L \), write \( E = (h^2/8mL^2)(n_x^2 + n_y^2 + n_z^2) \).
| \( n_x^2 + n_y^2 + n_z^2 \) | States | Degeneracy |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | (1,1,1) | 1 |
| 6 | (2,1,1) and permutations | 3 |
| 9 | (2,2,1) | 3 |
| 11 | (3,1,1) | 3 |
| 12 | (2,2,2) | 1 |
| 14 | (3,2,1): all 6 permutations | 6 |
| 17 | (3,2,2) | 3 |
| 18 | (4,1,1) | 3 |
| 27 | (3,3,3) and (5,1,1), (1,5,1), (1,1,5) | 4 |
Counting rule. Three equal quantum numbers: 1 state. Two equal: 3. All different: 6. Then check whether a different set gives the same sum: \( 27 = 9 + 9 + 9 = 25 + 1 + 1 \). That extra coincidence is accidental degeneracy; the 3- and 6-fold ones come from the symmetry of the cube.
Square and rectangular boxes in 2D
Square box (\( E \propto n_x^2 + n_y^2 \)): \( 2 \) (1), \( 5 \) (2), \( 8 \) (1), \( 10 \) (2), \( 13 \) (2). Accidental degeneracies appear at \( 50 = 1 + 49 = 25 + 25 \), which is 3-fold: (1,7), (7,1), (5,5); and at \( 65 = 1 + 64 = 16 + 49 \), 4-fold.
Lowering the symmetry removes degeneracy. Stretch one side and the symmetry-based degeneracy of the cube or square disappears. A rectangle with \( L_y = 2L_x \) has \( E \propto n_x^2 + n_y^2/4 \): levels at 1.25, 2, 3.25, 4.25 and then 5, which is 2-fold only because \( (1,4) \) and \( (2,2) \) happen to coincide.
The Harmonic Oscillator
Near the bottom of any potential well, \( V(x) \approx \tfrac{1}{2}kx^2 \), where \( k = d^2V/dx^2 \) at the minimum is the force constant. For a diatomic molecule, \( x \) is the displacement from the equilibrium bond length and \( m \) is replaced by the reduced mass \( \mu = m_1m_2/(m_1 + m_2) \).
In wavenumbers: \( \tilde{\nu} = \dfrac{1}{2\pi c}\sqrt{\dfrac{k}{\mu}} \).
Hermite polynomials (physicists’ convention): \( H_0 = 1 \), \( H_1 = 2y \), \( H_2 = 4y^2 - 2 \), \( H_3 = 8y^3 - 12y \). Recursion: \( H_{v+1} = 2yH_v - 2vH_{v-1} \).
| Property | Result |
|---|---|
| Zero-point energy | \( E_0 = \tfrac{1}{2}h\nu \); a molecule vibrates even at 0 K |
| Spacing | equal, \( h\nu \), at all \( v \) (unlike the box) |
| Nodes | \( v \) |
| Parity | \( (-1)^v \): even \( v \) symmetric, odd \( v \) antisymmetric |
| Ground state | Gaussian \( (\alpha/\pi)^{1/4}e^{-\alpha x^2/2} \); minimum uncertainty \( \Delta x\Delta p = \hbar/2 \) |
| \( \langle x\rangle \), \( \langle p\rangle \) | \( 0 \) for every \( v \) |
| \( \langle x^2\rangle \) | \( (v + \tfrac{1}{2})\hbar/(\mu\omega) \) |
| Virial theorem | \( \langle T\rangle = \langle V\rangle = \tfrac{1}{2}E_v \) |
| Classical turning points | \( x_{\text{tp}} = \pm\sqrt{2E_v/k} \); for \( v = 0 \), \( y = \pm 1 \) |
| Outside the turning points | for \( v = 0 \), probability \( \operatorname{erfc}(1) \approx 0.157 \): about 16% |
| Nodes of \( \psi_2 \) | \( 4y^2 - 2 = 0 \Rightarrow y = \pm 1/\sqrt{2} \) |
| Spectroscopic selection rule | \( \Delta v = \pm 1 \) (harmonic, with a changing dipole) |
The 16% of the ground-state probability beyond the classical turning points is itself a tunnelling effect: the particle is found where its total energy is less than the potential energy.
Isotope effects
Isotopic substitution changes \( \mu \) but not \( k \) (the electronic potential is the same), so
$$\frac{\tilde{\nu}_{\text{heavy}}}{\tilde{\nu}_{\text{light}}} = \sqrt{\frac{\mu_{\text{light}}}{\mu_{\text{heavy}}}}$$| Pair | \( \mu \) (amu, integer masses) | Frequency ratio light/heavy |
|---|---|---|
| H₂ / D₂ | 0.5 / 1 | \( \sqrt{2} = 1.414 \) |
| H³⁵Cl / D³⁵Cl | 0.972 / 1.892 | 1.395 |
| C–H / C–D (as a diatomic) | 0.923 / 1.714 | 1.363 |
So a C–H stretch near 3000 cm⁻¹ moves to about 2200 cm⁻¹ on deuteration.
Tunnelling
A rectangular barrier
A particle of energy \( E \) meets a barrier of height \( V_0 > E \) and width \( a \). Classically it is reflected. Quantum mechanically, inside the barrier the wavefunction is not zero but decays:
$$\psi(x) \sim e^{-\kappa x}, \qquad \kappa = \frac{\sqrt{2m(V_0 - E)}}{\hbar}$$If the barrier is finite in width, some amplitude reaches the far side, where the wave travels on. The transmission coefficient (the fraction of particles that pass) is, exactly,
$$T = \left[1 + \frac{V_0^2\sinh^2(\kappa a)}{4E(V_0 - E)}\right]^{-1}$$and, for a wide or high barrier (\( \kappa a \gg 1 \)),
$$\boxed{T \approx 16\,\frac{E}{V_0}\left(1 - \frac{E}{V_0}\right)e^{-2\kappa a}}$$The exponential dominates. \( T \) falls off steeply with
- barrier width \( a \) (linearly in the exponent),
- the square root of the mass \( m \), and
- the square root of the energy deficit \( V_0 - E \).
Light particles, thin barriers and energies close to the top tunnel most.
graph LR
A["Region I: E > V
incident + reflected
oscillating waves"] --> B["Region II: E < V0
exponential decay
exp(-kappa x)"]
B --> C["Region III: E > V
transmitted wave
smaller amplitude"]Where tunnelling matters in chemistry
| Phenomenon | What tunnels | The point |
|---|---|---|
| Scanning tunnelling microscope | electrons across a vacuum gap of a few ångströms | current \( \propto e^{-2\kappa d} \); with an effective barrier of about 4.5 eV, \( \kappa \approx 1.1 \) Å⁻¹, so the current changes by roughly a factor of 9 (about an order of magnitude) per ångström, giving atomic-scale height resolution |
| Ammonia inversion | the N atom through the planar barrier of the NH₃ umbrella | splits each vibrational level into a doublet; the ground-state splitting lies in the microwave region (about 24 GHz) and was the basis of the ammonia maser |
| H-atom and proton transfer | H, much less D | kinetic isotope effects far above the semiclassical value of about 7, and rates that level off at low temperature instead of following Arrhenius behaviour |
| Alpha decay | an alpha particle through the Coulomb barrier of the nucleus | the Gamow explanation of why half-lives vary enormously with small changes in decay energy |
| Field emission, tunnel diodes | electrons through a thin barrier | device physics |
| Electron transfer in proteins and between redox centres | electrons over 1–2 nm of protein | rates fall roughly exponentially with distance; see Biological Electron Transfer |
Related quantum effects without a barrier:
- A finite well has fewer bound states than an infinite one, and each has a lower energy than the corresponding infinite-well level, because the wavefunction leaks into the walls and has more room.
- At a potential step with \( E > V_0 \), a quantum particle is partly reflected, which never happens classically.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Box: \( n = 1, 2, \ldots \); \( n - 1 \) nodes | Oscillator: \( v = 0, 1, \ldots \); \( v \) nodes | |
| Box spacing grows as \( 2n + 1 \) | Harmonic spacing constant; real (anharmonic) spacing shrinks | |
| Box ZPE \( h^2/8mL^2 \) | Oscillator ZPE \( \tfrac{1}{2}h\nu \) | |
| Symmetry degeneracy (cube: (2,1,1) and permutations) | Accidental degeneracy (cube: (3,3,3) with (5,1,1)) | |
| Mass in the box formula: particle mass | Mass in the oscillator: reduced mass \( \mu \) | |
| Tunnelling through a barrier: \( E < V_0 \), \( T \) small but non-zero | Reflection above a step: \( E > V_0 \), \( R \) non-zero | |
| \( \langle x\rangle = L/2 \) (box from 0 to L) | \( \langle x\rangle = 0 \) (oscillator centred at 0) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Constants: \( h = 6.626 \times 10^{-34} \) J s, \( \hbar = 1.055 \times 10^{-34} \) J s, \( m_e = 9.109 \times 10^{-31} \) kg, \( c = 2.998 \times 10^8 \) m s⁻¹, 1 eV \( = 1.602 \times 10^{-19} \) J.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many nodes does \( \psi_4 \) of a particle in a 1D box have (excluding the walls)?
- What is the ratio \( E_3/E_1 \) for a harmonic oscillator?
- If the length of a 1D box is doubled, by what factor does \( E_1 \) change?
Answers
- 3 (\( n - 1 \)).
- \( E_3/E_0 \) would be 7, but the question asks \( E_3/E_1 = (3.5)/(1.5) = \mathbf{7/3} \). (Oscillator levels start at \( v = 0 \).)
- \( E \propto 1/L^2 \): it falls to one quarter.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. For a particle in a cubic box, the degeneracy of the level with energy \( 14h^2/8mL^2 \) is
(a) 1 (b) 3 (c) 6 (d) 4
Answer: (c) 6
\( n_x^2 + n_y^2 + n_z^2 = 14 \) only for \( \{1, 2, 3\} \): \( 1 + 4 + 9 \). All three numbers differ, so there are \( 3! = 6 \) arrangements. No other set gives 14.
Practice Q2. An electron is confined to a one-dimensional box of length 1.0 nm. The wavelength of the \( n = 1 \to 2 \) transition is closest to
(a) 330 nm (b) 550 nm (c) 1100 nm (d) 3300 nm
Answer: (c)
\( E_1 = h^2/8m_eL^2 = 6.02 \times 10^{-20} \) J (0.376 eV). \( \Delta E = 3E_1 = 1.81 \times 10^{-19} \) J. \( \lambda = hc/\Delta E = 1.99 \times 10^{-25}/1.81 \times 10^{-19} = 1.10 \times 10^{-6} \) m = 1100 nm. Option (d) uses \( E_1 \) instead of \( 3E_1 \).
Practice Q3. The fundamental vibrational wavenumber of ¹H³⁵Cl is \( \tilde{\nu} \). In the harmonic approximation, that of ²H³⁵Cl is about
(a) \( \tilde{\nu}/2 \) (b) \( \tilde{\nu}/1.40 \) (c) \( \tilde{\nu}/1.18 \) (d) \( 1.40\,\tilde{\nu} \)
Answer: (b)
\( \mu(\text{HCl}) = 35/36 = 0.972 \), \( \mu(\text{DCl}) = 70/37 = 1.892 \). Ratio \( \sqrt{1.892/0.972} = 1.395 \). The frequency falls by about 1.40. Option (c) is \( \sqrt{1.40} \) (square root taken twice).
Practice Q4. For the ground state of a 1D harmonic oscillator, which statement is false?
(a) The probability density is largest at the equilibrium position. (b) There is a non-zero probability of finding the particle beyond the classical turning points. (c) \( \langle T\rangle = \langle V\rangle \). (d) The energy is zero at 0 K.
Answer: (d)
The zero-point energy \( \tfrac{1}{2}h\nu \) remains at 0 K. (a), (b) and (c) are all true: the Gaussian peaks at \( x = 0 \), about 16% lies outside the turning points, and the virial theorem gives \( \langle T\rangle = \langle V\rangle = E/2 \). (Classically the particle would be most likely near the turning points, the opposite of (a).)
Practice Q5. The tunnelling probability of a particle through a rectangular barrier (\( \kappa a \gg 1 \)) increases when
(a) the particle mass increases (b) the barrier width increases (c) the particle energy approaches the barrier top (d) the barrier height increases at fixed particle energy
Answer: (c)
\( T \propto e^{-2\kappa a} \) with \( \kappa = \sqrt{2m(V_0 - E)}/\hbar \). Bringing \( E \) closer to \( V_0 \) reduces \( \kappa \) and raises \( T \). The other three all increase \( \kappa a \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q6. A linear conjugated polyene has 8 \( \pi \) electrons. Model them as free electrons in a 1D box of length 1.12 nm. Which statements are correct?
- The HOMO is \( n = 4 \) and the LUMO \( n = 5 \).
- The HOMO–LUMO gap is \( 9h^2/8m_eL^2 \).
- The predicted absorption wavelength is about 460 nm.
- Lengthening the chain (with \( L \) proportional to \( N \)) shifts the absorption to shorter wavelength.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. 8 electrons fill \( n = 1 \) to 4.
- Correct. \( 5^2 - 4^2 = 9 \).
- Correct. \( \Delta E = 9(6.626 \times 10^{-34})^2/[8(9.109 \times 10^{-31})(1.12 \times 10^{-9})^2] = 4.32 \times 10^{-19} \) J; \( \lambda = hc/\Delta E = 1.986 \times 10^{-25}/4.32 \times 10^{-19} = 4.60 \times 10^{-7} \) m, about 460 nm.
- Wrong. \( \lambda = 8m_ecL^2/[h(N + 1)] \); with \( L \propto N \), \( \lambda \) grows roughly as \( N \): a red shift.
Practice Q7. For a particle in a 1D box of length \( L \), the probability of finding it between \( x = 0 \) and \( x = L/4 \) in states \( n = 1 \) and \( n = 2 \) is, respectively,
(a) 0.091 and 0.25 (b) 0.25 and 0.25 (c) 0.091 and 0.50 (d) 0.159 and 0.25
Answer: (a)
\( P = \dfrac{x}{L} - \dfrac{1}{2n\pi}\sin\dfrac{2n\pi x}{L} \) evaluated from 0 to \( L/4 \).
\( n = 1 \): \( \tfrac{1}{4} - \tfrac{1}{2\pi}\sin\tfrac{\pi}{2} = 0.25 - 0.159 = 0.091 \).
\( n = 2 \): \( \tfrac{1}{4} - \tfrac{1}{4\pi}\sin\pi = 0.25 \).
(b) is the classical answer; (d) confuses the subtracted term with the answer.
Practice Q8. A hydrogen atom and a deuterium atom each tunnel through the same rectangular barrier, 0.050 nm wide and 0.20 eV above their energy. (\( m_\text{H} = 1.674 \times 10^{-27} \) kg, \( m_\text{D} = 3.344 \times 10^{-27} \) kg.) Taking \( T \propto e^{-2\kappa a} \) with the same prefactor for both, the ratio \( T_\text{H}/T_\text{D} \) is closest to
(a) 1.4 (b) 2 (c) 60 (d) \( 10^4 \)
Answer: (c)
For H: \( \kappa = \sqrt{2(1.674 \times 10^{-27})(0.20 \times 1.602 \times 10^{-19})}/1.055 \times 10^{-34} = 9.82 \times 10^{10} \) m⁻¹; \( 2\kappa a = 9.82 \).
For D: \( \kappa \) is larger by \( \sqrt{2} \); \( 2\kappa a = 13.88 \).
\( T_\text{H}/T_\text{D} = e^{13.88 - 9.82} = e^{4.06} \approx 58 \).
The ratio is far above the classical ZPE-based isotope effect, which is why very large \( k_\text{H}/k_\text{D} \) values point to tunnelling. (a) is the ratio of \( \kappa \) values; (b) is the mass ratio.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| 1D box | \( E_n = n^2h^2/8mL^2 \), \( n \ge 1 \); \( \psi_n = \sqrt{2/L}\sin(n\pi x/L) \) |
| Box nodes, ratios | \( n - 1 \); 1 : 4 : 9 |
| Box averages | \( \langle x\rangle = L/2 \), \( \langle p\rangle = 0 \), \( \langle p^2\rangle = n^2h^2/4L^2 \) |
| \( P(0 \to L/4) \) | 0.091 (\( n = 1 \)), 0.25 (\( n = 2 \)) |
| Free-electron model | \( \Delta E = (N + 1)h^2/8mL^2 \); longer chain, longer \( \lambda \) |
| 3D box | \( E = (h^2/8m)\sum n_i^2/L_i^2 \) |
| Cube degeneracies | 3:1, 6:3, 9:3, 11:3, 12:1, 14:6, 27:4 (accidental) |
| Oscillator | \( E_v = (v + \tfrac{1}{2})h\nu \), \( \nu = (1/2\pi)\sqrt{k/\mu} \) |
| Oscillator facts | equal spacing; \( v \) nodes; parity \( (-1)^v \); \( \langle T\rangle = \langle V\rangle \) |
| Outside turning points (\( v = 0 \)) | about 16% |
| Isotope ratio | \( \tilde{\nu} \propto \mu^{-1/2} \); H₂/D₂ \( \sqrt{2} \); HCl/DCl 1.40 |
| Semiclassical KIE | up to about 7 at 298 K for C–H/C–D |
| Tunnelling | \( T \approx 16\frac{E}{V_0}(1 - \frac{E}{V_0})e^{-2\kappa a} \), \( \kappa = \sqrt{2m(V_0 - E)}/\hbar \) |
| STM | current about ×9 per Å change in gap |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum: the particle on a ring, the rigid rotor and spin, which complete the model systems.
- The Hydrogen Atom and the Shapes of Atomic Orbitals.
- Revisit operators and expectation values in Postulates of Quantum Mechanics and Operator Algebra.
- Vibrational spectroscopy of real molecules: IR and Raman Spectroscopy.