Aromatic Substitution: SEAr, SNAr, Benzyne and SRN1
CSIR NET organic mechanisms: arenium-ion SEAr, directing effects, partial rate factors, ipso attack, SNAr Meisenheimer complexes, benzyne and SRN1 pathways.
- 19 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Electrophiles, Nucleophiles and Radicals: the arene as a π nucleophile; leaving-group logic.
- Nucleophilic Substitution: why aryl halides resist SN1 and SN2.
- Aromaticity and resonance in benzene; Hückel π energies help with the arenium ion: see Hückel Theory for Conjugated Systems.
- Primary kinetic isotope effects: see Reaction Mechanisms and Chain Reactions.
The Hook: Why Benzene Substitutes Instead of Adding
Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution (SEAr)
The arenium-ion mechanism
$$\mathrm{ArH + E^+ \xrightarrow{\text{slow}} [ArHE]^+ \xrightarrow{\text{fast},\ -H^+} ArE}$$- Generation of the electrophile (usually with an acid or Lewis acid).
- Attack by the π system on E⁺ to give the arenium ion (σ-complex, Wheland intermediate): a cyclohexadienyl cation with the positive charge delocalised over the carbons ortho and para to the sp³ carbon. A loose π-complex may precede it.
- Loss of H⁺ from the sp³ carbon restores aromaticity.
Step 2 is usually rate-determining. The evidence: no primary kinetic isotope effect in most nitrations and many halogenations (C₆H₆ and C₆D₆ react at nearly the same rate), so C–H cleavage is not part of the slow step. Sulfonation (and some iodinations, and reactions at very hindered positions) shows a primary KIE because the arenium ion can revert to reactants nearly as fast as it loses H⁺, so deprotonation becomes partly rate-limiting. Stable arenium salts have been isolated with very weakly nucleophilic counter-ions at low temperature.
Electrophiles and conditions
| Reaction | Reagents | Electrophile | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nitration | conc. HNO₃ + conc. H₂SO₄ | NO₂⁺ (nitronium) | H₂SO₄ protonates HNO₃, which loses water |
| Halogenation | Br₂/FeBr₃, Cl₂/AlCl₃ or FeCl₃ | polarised X–X···MX₃ | activated rings (phenol, aniline) need no catalyst and polyhalogenate |
| Sulfonation | fuming H₂SO₄ (SO₃) | SO₃ (or HSO₃⁺) | reversible: hot dilute acid removes SO₃H (useful as a blocking group) |
| Friedel–Crafts alkylation | RX/AlCl₃, alkene/H⁺, ROH/H⁺ | carbocation or R–X···AlCl₃ complex | rearrangements; polyalkylation (product more reactive); reversible |
| Friedel–Crafts acylation | RCOCl or (RCO)₂O, AlCl₃ (≥ 1 equiv) | acylium RC≡O⁺ | no rearrangement; stops at monoacylation (product deactivated); AlCl₃ bound by the ketone product |
| Diazo coupling | ArN₂⁺ | aryldiazonium (weak) | needs strongly activated partner: phenoxide (mildly alkaline) or arylamine (mildly acidic) |
| Nitrosation | HNO₂/H⁺ | NO⁺ | only very activated rings (phenols, tertiary arylamines) |
Substituent effects: rate and orientation
A substituent already on the ring affects (i) how fast the ring reacts relative to benzene (activation or deactivation) and (ii) where the electrophile goes (ortho/para or meta). Both follow from how the substituent stabilises the arenium ion.
| Class | Substituents | Effect | Orientation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strongly activating | –O⁻, –NH₂, –NHR, –NR₂, –OH | strong +M (lone pair) | ortho, para |
| Moderately activating | –OR, –NHCOR, –OCOR | +M reduced by competing conjugation | ortho, para |
| Weakly activating | alkyl, aryl | +I and hyperconjugation | ortho, para |
| Weakly deactivating | –F, –Cl, –Br, –I | −I outweighs +M | ortho, para |
| Moderately deactivating | –CHO, –COR, –CO₂R, –CO₂H, –CONH₂ | −M, −I | meta |
| Strongly deactivating | –NO₂, –CN, –SO₃H, –CF₃, –NR₃⁺ | strong −M and/or −I | meta |
Ortho : para ratio. Statistically there are two ortho positions and one para. Steric bulk on either the substituent or the electrophile pushes the ratio toward para: tert-butylbenzene nitrates mostly para, toluene gives a large ortho fraction.
Anilines in strong acid. In concentrated HNO₃/H₂SO₄, aniline is largely protonated to the anilinium ion (–NH₃⁺, meta-directing and deactivating), so substantial meta-nitroaniline forms along with oxidation products. Acetylation first (–NHCOCH₃) gives a moderately activating, para-selective group, after which hydrolysis returns the amine.
Partial rate factors
The partial rate factor \( f_x \) compares the rate at one position x of a substituted benzene with the rate at one position of benzene:
$$f_x = \frac{k_{\text{ArH}}}{k_{\text{PhH}}}\times\frac{6}{n_x}\times(\text{fraction of product at } x)$$where \( n_x \) is the number of x positions in ArH (2 for ortho, 2 for meta, 1 for para) and 6 is the number of positions in benzene. \( f > 1 \) means that position is activated relative to a benzene position.
Partial rate factors for the para position correlate with the substituent constant \( \sigma_p^+ \) (Brown’s electrophilic substituent constants), not with ordinary \( \sigma_p \), because a positive charge develops in conjugation with the substituent. This is used on Determination of Reaction Pathways.
More than one substituent
- When directing effects reinforce each other, the product is predictable.
- When they conflict, the more strongly activating group controls orientation (–OH, –NR₂ beat alkyl, which beats halogen and all meta directors).
- A position flanked by two substituents (between two groups meta to each other) is attacked little, for steric reasons.
Ipso substitution
Attack at a ring carbon that already carries a substituent other than H is ipso attack. If that substituent is a better electrofuge than H⁺ (it leaves more easily as a cation), ipso substitution results.
| Group lost | Example |
|---|---|
| –SO₃H | desulfonation in hot dilute acid (reverse of sulfonation) |
| –SiR₃ | protodesilylation and halodesilylation: E⁺ replaces silicon (β-silicon effect stabilises the arenium ion) |
| –C(CH₃)₃ | de-tert-butylation (loses the stable tert-butyl cation) |
| –CO₂H | decarboxylation of activated (e.g. hydroxy) benzoic acids |
Kinetic versus thermodynamic control: naphthalene
Naphthalene reacts faster at C1 (α) because the arenium ion keeps one intact benzene ring in more resonance forms. Sulfonation at low temperature gives naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (kinetic product). At higher temperature, where sulfonation is reversible, the 2-sulfonic acid accumulates (thermodynamic product), because the 1-isomer suffers a steric clash between the SO₃H group and the peri hydrogen at C8. Nitration, which is effectively irreversible, gives 1-nitronaphthalene.
Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution
Simple aryl halides do not undergo SN1 (aryl cations are very unstable; the empty orbital is sp² and in the ring plane) or SN2 (backside blocked by the ring). Nucleophiles substitute arenes by three other routes.
graph TD
A["Aryl halide + nucleophile"] --> B{"Strong -M groups
(NO2, CN, C=O)
ortho/para to X?"}
B -- yes --> C["SNAr: addition-elimination
Meisenheimer complex
F > Cl > Br > I"]
B -- no --> D{"Very strong base
(NaNH2, LDA, KNH2)
and an ortho H?"}
D -- yes --> E["Elimination-addition
via benzyne:
cine substitution"]
D -- no --> F{"Light or electron donor,
suppressed by
radical scavengers?"}
F -- yes --> G["SRN1:
radical-anion chain"]
F -- no --> H["Use a metal catalyst
(Cu, Pd) or a
diazonium salt instead"]SNAr: addition–elimination
$$\mathrm{ArX + Nu^- \xrightarrow{\text{slow}} [Ar(X)(Nu)]^- \xrightarrow{\text{fast}} ArNu + X^-}$$- The nucleophile adds to the ipso carbon, giving a resonance-stabilised cyclohexadienyl anion, the Meisenheimer complex. Stable, coloured Meisenheimer salts have been isolated from polynitroaryl ethers and alkoxides.
- Activation: strongly electron-withdrawing groups ortho or para to the leaving group delocalise the negative charge onto themselves (onto the oxygens of NO₂). A meta-NO₂ helps only inductively. Each extra o/p NO₂ increases the rate dramatically: 2,4-dinitro and 2,4,6-trinitro substrates react under mild conditions.
- Kinetics: second order, \( v = k[\mathrm{ArX}][\mathrm{Nu}] \).
- Leaving-group order (element effect): F ≫ Cl ≈ Br > I. Addition is rate-determining; the very electronegative F makes the ipso carbon more electrophilic and stabilises the anionic transition state, while C–F cleavage comes later in a fast step. The reverse of the SN2 order is itself evidence that C–X is not broken in the rate-determining step.
- Example: Sanger’s reagent, 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene, reacts with the free N-terminal amino group of a peptide by SNAr, which is how the N-terminal residue was labelled for identification.
- Pyridines and other aza-arenes undergo SNAr at C2 and C4 without extra activation: ring nitrogen plays the role of the nitro group.
Elimination–addition: benzyne
Chlorobenzene with NaNH₂ (or KNH₂) in liquid ammonia gives aniline through benzyne (1,2-didehydrobenzene):
- NH₂⁻ removes the proton ortho to Cl (the most acidic ring proton, by the −I effect of Cl).
- The aryl anion loses Cl⁻ to give benzyne, which has a strained, weak “triple” bond formed by side-on overlap of two in-plane sp² orbitals; the aromatic π sextet is untouched.
- NH₂⁻ adds to either end of the benzyne; the new aryl anion takes a proton from NH₃.
Evidence:
| Observation | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Chlorobenzene-1-¹⁴C gives aniline with the label about half at C1 (ipso product) and half at C2 (cine product: NH₂ on the carbon next to where Cl was) | a symmetrical intermediate in which C1 and C2 have become equivalent |
| Aryl halides with no ortho hydrogen (both ortho positions substituted) do not react under these conditions | the ortho C–H must be broken |
| Benzyne generated in the presence of furan or anthracene is trapped as a Diels–Alder adduct | a reactive dienophile is formed |
| Ortho-deuterated halobenzenes react more slowly than the protio compounds or exchange D with the solvent, depending on the halogen | ortho deprotonation occurs (and can be reversible) |
Regiochemistry with substituted arynes. The incoming nucleophile adds so that the resulting aryl anion is better stabilised, usually placing the carbanion next to an inductively withdrawing group.
- 2-Bromoanisole + NaNH₂/NH₃ gives 3-methoxyaniline (m-anisidine): NH₂⁻ adds at C3 so that the anion at C2 sits next to the −I OCH₃ group.
- 4-Chlorotoluene gives a mixture of 4- and 3-methylaniline (p- and m-toluidine), because the methyl group barely distinguishes the two aryne carbons.
More on the structure and generation of arynes (from anthranilic acid diazonium salts, from 2-(trimethylsilyl)aryl triflates with fluoride) belongs to the reactive-intermediates unit.
SN1 at aryl carbon: diazonium salts
Aryldiazonium ions lose N₂, the best leaving group known, on warming. In water they give phenols; the tetrafluoroborate salts on heating give aryl fluorides (Balz–Schiemann). Whether a free aryl cation forms in every case is debated, but the reactions show first-order kinetics in ArN₂⁺ and are insensitive to the nucleophile, as expected for an SN1-like pathway. Copper(I)-mediated replacements (Sandmeyer: ArCl, ArBr, ArCN) go by single-electron transfer and aryl radicals instead.
SRN1: radical-nucleophilic substitution
Unactivated aryl halides with no nitro group react with enolates, amide ions or thiolates in liquid ammonia or DMSO when irradiated (or given a solvated-electron donor), by a radical chain:
- Initiation: ArX + e⁻ → [ArX]•⁻
- [ArX]•⁻ → Ar• + X⁻
- Ar• + Nu⁻ → [ArNu]•⁻
- [ArNu]•⁻ + ArX → ArNu + [ArX]•⁻ (chain carrier regenerated)
Diagnostics: light or alkali-metal stimulation, inhibition by radical scavengers (TEMPO, di-tert-butylnitroxide) or electron acceptors (p-dinitrobenzene), and no cine substitution (the nucleophile appears exactly where X was). These criteria separate SRN1 from benzyne routes on the same substrates.
Comparing the Four Aromatic Pathways
| Feature | SEAr | SNAr | Benzyne | SRN1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ring role | nucleophile | electrophile | electrophile (aryne) | radical acceptor |
| Intermediate | arenium cation | Meisenheimer anion | aryne | aryl radical, radical anions |
| Activating groups | electron donors | o/p electron acceptors | none needed | none needed |
| Leaving group | H⁺ (or ipso electrofuge) | F > Cl ≈ Br > I | Cl, Br, I; F reluctant (F⁻ loss from the aryl anion is slow) | I usually best |
| Substitution position | set by directing groups | ipso only | ipso + cine | ipso only |
| Typical KIE | none (most) | not used as a test | ortho H/D effects | not used as a test |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Arenium (Wheland) ion: cation, SEAr | Meisenheimer complex: anion, SNAr | |
| Halogen: deactivating but o/p-directing | Nitro: deactivating and meta-directing | |
| Ipso substitution: same carbon, group other than H leaves | Cine substitution: neighbouring carbon (benzyne) | |
| Kinetic product (naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid) | Thermodynamic product (naphthalene-2-sulfonic acid) | |
| Friedel–Crafts alkylation: rearranges, polyalkylates | Friedel–Crafts acylation: no rearrangement, monoacylates | |
| SNAr leaving group F > Cl ≈ Br > I | SN2 leaving group I > Br > Cl ≫ F | |
| SRN1: radical chain, no activating group, light | SNAr: polar, needs o/p electron-withdrawing groups |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name the electrophile in the nitration of benzene with mixed acid.
- Is –NHCOCH₃ activating or deactivating, and which positions does it direct to?
- What is the intermediate in the reaction of 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene with methoxide?
Answers
- The nitronium ion, NO₂⁺.
- Moderately activating (the N lone pair is partly drawn into the acetyl C=O), ortho/para directing, mainly para for steric reasons.
- A Meisenheimer complex (anionic σ-complex) with the negative charge delocalised onto the ortho and para nitro groups.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The major product of mononitration of methyl benzoate is:
(a) methyl 2-nitrobenzoate (b) methyl 3-nitrobenzoate (c) methyl 4-nitrobenzoate (d) a 2:1 mixture of 2- and 4-isomers
Answer: (b)
The ester group (–CO₂CH₃) is a −M, −I deactivating meta director: ortho and para attack would place positive charge on the carbon bearing the carbonyl group.
Practice Q2. For SNAr reaction of 1-X-2,4-dinitrobenzenes with piperidine, the order of reactivity is:
(a) X = I > Br > Cl > F (b) X = F > Cl ≈ Br > I (c) X = Cl > F > Br > I (d) all four react at the same rate
Answer: (b)
Addition to form the Meisenheimer complex is rate-determining. The most electronegative halogen makes the ipso carbon most electrophilic and stabilises the developing negative charge; C–F cleavage occurs in the fast second step.
Practice Q3. 2-Bromoanisole is treated with NaNH₂ in liquid ammonia. The major product is:
(a) 2-methoxyaniline (b) 3-methoxyaniline (c) 4-methoxyaniline (d) 2-bromo-3-methoxyaniline
Answer: (b)
Deprotonation at C3 (the only H ortho to Br) and loss of Br⁻ give 3-methoxybenzyne (the triple bond between C1 and C2, OMe on the adjacent carbon). NH₂⁻ adds at the carbon remote from OMe so that the aryl anion forms next to the inductively withdrawing OCH₃ group. Protonation gives 3-methoxyaniline: a cine product.
Practice Q4. A substituted benzene ArH is nitrated 0.033 times as fast as benzene and gives 30 % ortho, 1 % meta and 69 % para product (illustrative data). The para partial rate factor \( f_p \) is closest to:
(a) 0.023 (b) 0.14 (c) 0.69 (d) 1.4
Answer: (b)
\( f_p = 0.033 \times 6 \times 0.69 = 0.137 \approx 0.14 \). Less than 1, so the para position is deactivated relative to a benzene position, yet it is still the favoured site: the pattern of a halogen substituent. (a) ignores the factor 6; (c) is just the fraction.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Chlorobenzene labelled with ¹⁴C at C1 is treated with KNH₂ in liquid NH₃. Separately, 2,6-dimethylchlorobenzene is treated under the same conditions, and in a third experiment chlorobenzene and KNH₂ react in the presence of furan. Which statements are correct?
- The aniline formed from labelled chlorobenzene has the label distributed nearly equally between C1 and C2 (relative to NH₂ at C1).
- 2,6-Dimethylchlorobenzene is essentially unreactive because it has no hydrogen ortho to Cl.
- In the presence of furan, a Diels–Alder adduct of benzyne is isolated.
- The reaction of chlorobenzene is an addition–elimination via a Meisenheimer complex.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Benzyne makes C1 and C2 equivalent; amide adds to either end, giving ipso and cine products in about equal amounts. Correct.
- Without an ortho H there is no elimination to benzyne, and without activation there is no SNAr. Correct.
- Benzyne is a reactive dienophile and is trapped by furan to give 1,4-dihydro-1,4-epoxynaphthalene. Correct.
- There is no electron-withdrawing group to stabilise a Meisenheimer complex; this is elimination–addition. Wrong.
Practice Q6. In competitive nitration, toluene reacts 24 times as fast as benzene and gives 60 % ortho, 3 % meta and 37 % para product; tert-butylbenzene reacts 15 times as fast as benzene and gives 12 % ortho, 8 % meta and 80 % para product (all values illustrative). Which statements are correct?
- \( f_p \) for toluene is about 53.
- \( f_o \) for tert-butylbenzene is lower than \( f_o \) for toluene, consistent with steric hindrance by the larger alkyl group.
- For both compounds, \( f_m > 1 \), consistent with a weak activating effect even at the meta position.
- The \( f_p/f_m \) ratio is larger for tert-butylbenzene than for toluene.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
Toluene: \( f_o = 24 \times 3 \times 0.60 = 43.2 \); \( f_m = 24 \times 3 \times 0.03 = 2.16 \); \( f_p = 24 \times 6 \times 0.37 = 53.3 \). tert-Butylbenzene: \( f_o = 15 \times 3 \times 0.12 = 5.4 \); \( f_m = 15 \times 3 \times 0.08 = 3.6 \); \( f_p = 15 \times 6 \times 0.80 = 72 \).
- 53.3. Correct.
- 5.4 against 43.2: ortho attack is strongly suppressed by the bulky group. Correct.
- 2.16 and 3.6, both above 1. Correct.
- Toluene 53.3/2.16 = 24.7; tert-butylbenzene 72/3.6 = 20. The ratio is smaller for tert-butylbenzene. Wrong.
Practice Q7. Iodobenzene does not react with the potassium enolate of acetone in liquid ammonia in the dark. Under near-UV irradiation it gives phenylacetone in good yield; the reaction is suppressed by a small amount of di-tert-butylnitroxide, and 4-iodotoluene gives only 4-methylphenylacetone (no 3-isomer). The best mechanistic interpretation is:
(a) SNAr via a Meisenheimer complex (b) elimination–addition via benzyne (c) SRN1 radical-chain substitution through aryl radicals and radical anions (d) SN1 through a phenyl cation
Answer: (c)
Photostimulation, inhibition by a radical scavenger and the absence of any activating group point to a radical chain. The absence of the cine (3-) isomer rules out benzyne, which would give a mixture with 4-iodotoluene. SNAr needs strong o/p acceptors, and phenyl cations are not formed from iodobenzene under these conditions.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| SEAr steps | E⁺ generation → arenium ion (slow) → loss of H⁺ (fast) |
| KIE in SEAr | ≈ 1 for nitration; primary KIE in sulfonation |
| o/p directors | –O⁻, –NR₂, –OH, –OR, –NHCOR, alkyl, aryl, halogens |
| meta directors | –NO₂, –CN, –SO₃H, –CF₃, –NR₃⁺, –CHO, –COR, –CO₂R |
| Halogens | deactivate, but o/p |
| Partial rate factor | \( f_x = (k_{\text{ArH}}/k_{\text{PhH}})(6/n_x)(\text{fraction}_x) \) |
| Friedel–Crafts | alkylation: rearrangement, polyalkylation; acylation: neither; fails on deactivated rings and anilines |
| Ipso | –SO₃H, –SiR₃, –CMe₃, –CO₂H can be replaced |
| Naphthalene | α kinetic; 2-SO₃H thermodynamic |
| SNAr | o/p EWG; Meisenheimer complex; F > Cl ≈ Br > I; second order |
| Benzyne | NaNH₂/NH₃; ortho H required; ¹⁴C split C1/C2; furan trap; cine product |
| Aryne regiochemistry | carbanion forms next to −I group (2-bromoanisole → m-anisidine) |
| SRN1 | light, radical-anion chain, scavenger-inhibited, no cine |
| Diazonium | N₂ loss; phenols, ArF (Balz–Schiemann); Sandmeyer is radical (Cu) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Elimination Reactions: E1, E2, E1cB and syn eliminations.
- Determination of Reaction Pathways: σ⁺, Hammett plots and isotope labels in full.
- Ring heteroatoms change SEAr and SNAr rates sharply; the inorganic analogue of associative substitution is in Substitution and Electron-Transfer Mechanisms.
- Organic Reaction Mechanisms: Quick Revision.