Determination of Reaction Pathways
CSIR NET organic mechanisms: product, trapping, crossover and labelling evidence, kinetic isotope effects, Hammett and Grunwald-Winstein plots, Curtin-Hammett.
- 21 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: A Mechanism Is a Hypothesis
- The Evidence Toolkit
- Products, Intermediates and Trapping
- Crossover and Labelling Experiments
- Stereochemical Evidence
- Kinetic Evidence
- Kinetic Isotope Effects
- Linear Free-Energy Relationships
- Interpreting Selectivity: Curtin–Hammett and Control
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- The four mechanism pages of this chapter, especially Nucleophilic Substitution and Elimination Reactions, which supply the examples.
- Rate laws, the Eyring equation and activation parameters: see Collision Theory, Transition-State Theory and Unimolecular Reactions.
- Kinetic isotope effects from zero-point energies: see Reaction Mechanisms and Chain Reactions.
- General and specific acid–base catalysis and the Brønsted catalysis law: see Enzyme Kinetics, Salt Effects and Homogeneous Catalysis.
- Least-squares straight lines (for Hammett and Eyring plots): see Linear Regression, Covariance and Correlation.
The Hook: A Mechanism Is a Hypothesis
The Evidence Toolkit
| Method | What it can show | Typical decisive use |
|---|---|---|
| Product identification (including minor and by-products) | what bonds are formed and broken; rearrangements | dimers (R–R) point to radicals; rearranged skeletons implicate cations |
| Isolation or detection of intermediates | an energy minimum on the path | Meisenheimer salts; carbocations in superacid by NMR; radicals by EPR |
| Trapping of intermediates | a short-lived species exists | benzyne + furan; carbene + alkene; radicals + TEMPO |
| Crossover experiments | intra- versus intermolecular transfer | doubly labelled substrates mixed together |
| Isotopic labelling | which atom ends up where | ¹⁸O in ester hydrolysis; ¹⁴C in benzyne amination; D in exchange |
| Stereochemistry | geometry of attack or departure | inversion (SN2), racemisation (SN1), retention (NGP); syn vs anti |
| Kinetics (rate law) | composition of the rate-determining transition state | SN1 vs SN2; E2 vs E1; pre-equilibria |
| Activation parameters (ΔH‡, ΔS‡, ΔV‡) | molecularity and order of the transition state | negative ΔS‡ for bimolecular and cyclic TSs |
| Kinetic isotope effects | whether a bond to H is broken in or before the rate-determining step; hybridisation changes | E2 vs (E1cB)ᵣ; SEAr; hydride transfer |
| Substituent effects (Hammett, Taft) | charge development at the reaction centre in the TS | ρ sign and size |
| Solvent effects (Grunwald–Winstein) | degree of ionisation in the TS | m ≈ 1 SN1-like; small m SN2-like |
| Catalysis studies | role of acids, bases, metal ions | general vs specific acid–base catalysis; Brønsted α, β |
graph TD
O["Observation set"] --> K["Rate law and
activation parameters"]
O --> S["Stereochemistry and
labelling"]
O --> I["Intermediates:
detect, trap, scramble"]
O --> L["Perturbations:
isotope, substituent,
solvent, catalyst"]
K --> M["Candidate mechanisms"]
S --> M
I --> M
L --> M
M --> T{"Consistent with
every observation?"}
T -- no --> X["Discard or modify"]
T -- yes --> P["Provisional mechanism
(never proven, only
not yet disproved)"]Products, Intermediates and Trapping
Products tell you what changed
Product analysis is the first test: a skeleton rearrangement implies a cation (or radical) intermediate with time to rearrange; an allylic shift implies an allyl cation or an SN2′ path; cine substitution implies an aryne. Minor products are often the most informative: dimeric products (R–R) point to radicals; products containing solvent or an added nucleophile point to a cationic intermediate (the bromine-in-methanol experiment on Addition Reactions).
Detecting intermediates directly
| Intermediate | Typical detection |
|---|---|
| Carbocations | ¹H and ¹³C NMR in superacid (SbF₅/SO₂ClF) at low temperature |
| Radicals | EPR (directly, or after spin trapping with nitrones or nitroso compounds) |
| Radical anions, radical pairs | EPR; CIDNP (chemically induced dynamic nuclear polarisation: enhanced absorption or emission signals in NMR of products formed from radical pairs) |
| Meisenheimer complexes | isolation; UV-vis (coloured) and NMR |
| Tetrahedral intermediates | indirect: ¹⁸O exchange; occasionally observed in stabilised cases |
| Arynes, carbenes, nitrenes | matrix isolation at very low temperature; otherwise trapping |
Trapping
A trap is a reagent that reacts with the suspected intermediate faster than its normal fate, giving a characteristic product. Good practice: show that the trap does not react with the starting material or the product, and that the trapped product accounts for a fraction of material that otherwise gives the normal product.
- Benzyne → Diels–Alder adduct with furan or anthracene.
- Carbenes → cyclopropanes with alkenes (stereospecific for singlets).
- Carbon radicals → TEMPO adducts; inhibition by scavengers.
- Carbocations → capture by azide or by an added alcohol.
Radical clocks
A radical clock is a radical that undergoes a unimolecular rearrangement with a known rate constant. If a reaction is suspected to generate the radical R•, run it with a substrate that would give a clock radical:
- cyclopropylmethyl radical ring-opens to the but-3-enyl radical extremely fast (of the order of 10⁸ s⁻¹ at room temperature);
- 5-hexenyl radical cyclises to the cyclopentylmethyl radical more slowly (of the order of 10⁵ s⁻¹).
Rearranged products prove a radical; the ratio of rearranged to unrearranged product, with the known clock rate, gives the rate of the competing bimolecular step (for example H-atom transfer from Bu₃SnH). Absence of rearranged product with a fast clock argues against a free radical of significant lifetime.
Crossover and Labelling Experiments
Crossover
To decide whether a group migrates within one molecule or is released and picked up by another, mix two substrates that differ in two independent labels (for example, one carries substituent A in the migrating group and substituent B in the skeleton, the other carries A′ and B′).
| Result | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Only the original combinations (A–B, A′–B′) appear | intramolecular (the migrating group never leaves the solvent cage or the molecule) |
| Mixed products (A–B′ and A′–B) appear | intermolecular: free fragments formed |
Controls: the products must not exchange labels with each other under the reaction conditions, and both substrates should react at comparable rates.
Isotopic labelling
| Experiment | Result | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| ¹⁸O-carbonyl ester partly hydrolysed in H₂¹⁶O | recovered ester has lost ¹⁸O | tetrahedral intermediate formed reversibly |
| Ester with ¹⁸O-alkoxy saponified | ¹⁸O in the alcohol | acyl–oxygen cleavage (BAC2) |
| Chlorobenzene-1-¹⁴C + KNH₂ | label split ≈ 50:50 between C1 and C2 of aniline | symmetrical intermediate (benzyne) |
| Substrate run in D₂O or EtOD | D incorporated into recovered substrate | reversible carbanion formation ((E1cB)ᵣ, enolisation) |
| Label scrambling in an alkyl group | label found at several positions | carbocation with shifts or a symmetrical bridged ion |
Stereochemical Evidence
| Outcome at a stereocentre | Implies |
|---|---|
| Complete inversion | backside, concerted displacement (SN2) |
| Racemisation (often with slight inversion) | planar intermediate (carbocation, often via ion pairs) |
| Retention | double inversion (NGP), front-side internal delivery (SNi), or a mechanism that never breaks the bond to the stereocentre |
| Stereospecific syn or anti addition/elimination | concerted or bridged pathway (E2 anti; Ei syn; Br₂ anti; hydroboration syn) |
| Loss of stereospecificity | open intermediate with free rotation (open cation, radical) |
Optical rotation, ee, and diastereomer ratios turn this into numbers. When two paths operate together, the ee of the product often measures their ratio directly (see Practice Q2 on Nucleophilic Substitution).
Kinetic Evidence
Rate law
The rate law gives the composition of the rate-determining transition state relative to reactants: SN2 [RX][Nu]; SN1 [RX]; E2 [RX][B]; SNAr [ArX][Nu]; specific-acid-catalysed reactions [S][H⁺]. It cannot show what happens after the rate-determining step.
Activation parameters
From rate constants at several temperatures, the Eyring equation
$$k = \frac{k_BT}{h}\,e^{\Delta S^\ddagger/R}\,e^{-\Delta H^\ddagger/RT}, \qquad \Delta H^\ddagger = E_a - RT \ \ (\text{solution})$$gives ΔH‡ and ΔS‡ (for a first-order or pseudo-first-order k; for second-order k the standard state must be stated).
| ΔS‡ | Typical meaning |
|---|---|
| Large and negative (about −80 to −150 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ or more negative) | bimolecular association; highly ordered cyclic TS (Diels–Alder, Claisen, Cope and other Ei eliminations); strong solvent ordering around developing charge |
| Near zero or positive | unimolecular dissociation with loosening (SN1 ionisation in the gas phase; homolysis) |
In solution, SN1 ionisation often shows modestly negative ΔS‡ because the developing ions order the solvent, so ΔS‡ is read alongside other evidence. A negative volume of activation (rate increases with pressure) points the same way as a negative ΔS‡: bond formation or charge creation in the transition state.
Kinetic Isotope Effects
| Type | Where the isotope is | Typical size (H/D, room temperature) | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary | on the bond broken in the rate-determining step | about 2–7 | C–H (or O–H, N–H) cleavage is rate-determining |
| Very large primary | same | well above 7 | tunnelling contributes |
| Secondary α | on the reacting carbon, bond not broken | slightly above 1 for sp³ → sp² (SN1, ionisation); slightly below 1 (inverse) for sp² → sp³ (addition to C=O) or crowded SN2 TS | hybridisation change at the carbon |
| Secondary β | on the adjacent carbon | slightly above 1 for carbocation formation | hyperconjugation with the developing cation |
| Solvent (H₂O vs D₂O) | exchangeable H in solvent | \( k_{\mathrm{D_2O}} > k_{\mathrm{H_2O}} \) for specific acid catalysis (pre-equilibrium protonation); \( k_{\mathrm{H_2O}}/k_{\mathrm{D_2O}} \) about 2–3 or more for general acid catalysis with proton transfer in the slow step | timing of proton transfer |
| Heavy-atom (¹²C/¹³C, ¹⁴N/¹⁵N, ³⁵Cl/³⁷Cl) | heavy atom on the reacting bond | a few per cent | bond to that atom changes in the rate-determining step |
Applications on this chapter’s pages: E2 (primary KIE) versus E1 or (E1cB)ᵣ (no primary KIE); nitration (no KIE) versus sulfonation (KIE) in SEAr; SN1 (α-secondary KIE above 1) versus SN2 (near 1 or inverse).
Linear Free-Energy Relationships
A linear free-energy relationship (LFER) is a linear correlation between log k (or log K) for one reaction series and log k (or log K) for a reference series. Because \( \log k \propto -\Delta G^\ddagger \), it means that a structural change affects two free energies in proportion.
The Hammett equation
For meta- and para-substituted benzene derivatives:
$$\log\frac{k_X}{k_H} = \rho\,\sigma_X \qquad \left(\text{or } \log\frac{K_X}{K_H} = \rho\,\sigma_X\right)$$- σ (substituent constant) is defined from the ionisation of substituted benzoic acids in water at 25 °C, for which ρ = 1 by definition: \( \sigma_X = \log(K_X/K_H) \). Positive σ: electron-withdrawing; negative σ: electron-donating.
- ρ (reaction constant) measures how sensitive the reaction is to substituents, and its sign shows the direction of charge change between reactant and TS at the reaction centre.
| Substituent | \( \sigma_m \) | \( \sigma_p \) | \( \sigma_p^+ \) |
|---|---|---|---|
| p-OCH₃ / m-OCH₃ | +0.12 | −0.27 | −0.78 |
| CH₃ | −0.07 | −0.17 | −0.31 |
| H | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Cl | +0.37 | +0.23 | +0.11 |
| NO₂ | +0.71 | +0.78 | +0.79 |
(Commonly tabulated values; small differences exist between compilations.)
| ρ | Reading |
|---|---|
| ρ > 0 | negative charge builds up (or positive charge is lost) near the ring in the TS; electron-withdrawing groups accelerate (ester saponification, nucleophilic addition to ArCHO, ionisation of ArCOOH) |
| ρ < 0 | positive charge builds up (or negative charge is lost); electron-donating groups accelerate (SN1 solvolysis of ArCMe₂Cl, SEAr, electrophilic addition to styrenes) |
| |ρ| large (about 3 or more) | substantial charge, close to or conjugated with the ring |
| |ρ| small (below about 1) | little charge development, or the charge is insulated from the ring |
σ⁺ and σ⁻. When positive charge develops in direct conjugation with a para donor (benzylic cations, SEAr), the correlation is better with \( \sigma^+ \) (Brown–Okamoto). When negative charge develops in direct conjugation with a para acceptor (phenoxide or anilide ionisation, SNAr), \( \sigma^- \) is used (for p-NO₂, \( \sigma^- \) is much larger than \( \sigma_p \)). A better fit with σ⁺ than with σ is itself evidence for a cationic, conjugated TS.
Non-linear Hammett plots.
| Shape | Usual meaning |
|---|---|
| Concave upward (V-shaped: slope changes from negative to positive) | change of mechanism across the series: each substituent uses whichever path is faster |
| Concave downward (slope changes from positive to negative or levels off) | change of rate-determining step within one mechanism |
Taft, Grunwald–Winstein, Swain–Scott and Brønsted
| Equation | Form | Reference (by definition) | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taft (aliphatic) | \( \log(k/k_0) = \rho^*\sigma^* + \delta E_s \) | σ* from acid- vs base-catalysed ester hydrolysis; Eₛ steric constants | separates polar (σ*) from steric (Eₛ) effects |
| Grunwald–Winstein (solvent ionising power) | \( \log(k/k_0) = mY \) | tert-butyl chloride solvolysis: m = 1; 80 % aqueous ethanol: Y = 0 | m ≈ 1: SN1-like ionisation; m small (about 0.3 or less): SN2-like, nucleophilic solvent assistance |
| Swain–Scott (nucleophilicity) | \( \log(k/k_0) = sn \) | CH₃Br in water: s = 1; water: n = 0 | s ≈ 1 or above: substrate very sensitive to nucleophile (SN2); s small: SN1-like |
| Brønsted catalysis | \( \log k_{\text{HA}} = \alpha\log K_{\text{HA}} + c \); \( \log k_B = \beta\log K_B + c \) | — | α or β between 0 and 1 measures how far the proton has been transferred in the TS |
Interpreting Selectivity: Curtin–Hammett and Control
The Curtin–Hammett principle
If two conformers (or rapidly interconverting isomers) A and B each give a different product, and A ⇌ B is much faster than either reaction, then the product ratio depends only on the difference in free energy of the two transition states, not on the populations of A and B:
$$\frac{[\mathrm{P_A}]}{[\mathrm{P_B}]} = \exp\!\left(\frac{G^\ddagger_{\mathrm{B}} - G^\ddagger_{\mathrm{A}}}{RT}\right)$$The less populated conformer can give the major product if its transition state is lower in absolute free energy. Conversely, if interconversion is slow (conformationally locked rings, atropisomers), the product ratio reflects the conformer populations.
Kinetic versus thermodynamic control
| Kinetic control | Thermodynamic control |
|---|---|
| irreversible conditions, low temperature, short time | reversible conditions, higher temperature, long time |
| ratio = ratio of rates, \( \exp(\Delta\Delta G^\ddagger/RT) \) | ratio = equilibrium constant, \( \exp(\Delta\Delta G^\circ/RT) \) |
| examples: 1,2-addition to butadiene, naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid, kinetic (less substituted) enolate with LDA at low temperature | 1,4-addition, naphthalene-2-sulfonic acid, thermodynamic (more substituted) enolate |
Other guiding principles
- Hammond postulate: the TS resembles the nearer stable species in energy; explains selectivity in radical halogenation and the effect of cation stability on SN1 rates.
- Microscopic reversibility: forward and reverse reactions follow the same path. If acid-catalysed dehydration goes through a carbocation, so does acid-catalysed hydration under the same conditions.
- Reactivity–selectivity principle: more reactive species are often less selective (Cl• vs Br•), though there are well-known exceptions.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Crossover products: intermolecular | No crossover: intramolecular (or caged) | |
| Primary KIE: bond to H broken in the rate-determining step | Secondary KIE: hybridisation change, bond not broken | |
| ρ (reaction constant: property of the reaction) | σ (substituent constant: property of the group) | |
| m (Grunwald–Winstein: sensitivity to solvent ionising power) | s (Swain–Scott: sensitivity to nucleophile) | |
| Curtin–Hammett: fast interconversion, ratio from TS energies | Slow interconversion: ratio from ground-state populations | |
| Detecting an intermediate (it exists) | Showing it lies on the main pathway (it is kinetically competent) | |
| Rate law (before and at the slow step) | Product analysis (after the slow step) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- In the Hammett equation, for which reaction is ρ defined as exactly 1?
- What does a crossover experiment test?
- What is the typical range of a primary deuterium KIE at room temperature?
Answers
- Ionisation of substituted benzoic acids in water at 25 °C.
- Whether a fragment is transferred within one molecule (intramolecular, no crossover) or between molecules (intermolecular, mixed products).
- About 2–7 for \( k_\mathrm{H}/k_\mathrm{D} \); larger values suggest tunnelling.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. An elimination gives \( k = 3.6\times10^{-3}\ \text{s}^{-1} \) for the protio substrate and \( 5.2\times10^{-4}\ \text{s}^{-1} \) for the substrate deuterated at the β-carbon. The data are most consistent with:
(a) E1 with rate-determining ionisation (b) E2 (c) (E1cB)ᵣ (d) a secondary isotope effect only
Answer: (b)
\( k_\mathrm{H}/k_\mathrm{D} = 3.6\times10^{-3}/5.2\times10^{-4} = 6.9 \): a primary isotope effect, so the β C–H bond is broken in the rate-determining step. That excludes E1 and (E1cB)ᵣ (no C–H cleavage in the slow step) and is far too large for a secondary effect.
Practice Q2. For a reaction with ρ = +2.5 and \( k_H = 2.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{L mol}^{-1}\text{s}^{-1} \), the rate constant for the p-nitro compound (σ = 0.78) is closest to:
(a) \( 3.9\times10^{-3} \) (b) \( 2.2\times10^{-2} \) (c) \( 1.8\times10^{-1} \) (d) \( 2.2\times10^{-5} \) L mol⁻¹ s⁻¹
Answer: (c)
\( k = k_H\times10^{\rho\sigma} = 2.0\times10^{-3}\times10^{1.95} = 0.178 \) L mol⁻¹ s⁻¹. Option (d) uses −ρσ (the wrong sign); option (a) multiplies k by ρσ instead of raising 10 to it.
Practice Q3. Two chair conformers of a cyclohexane derivative interconvert rapidly. Conformer A (90 % of the population) reacts to give P_A; conformer B (10 %) reacts to give P_B. The transition state from B is 5.0 kJ mol⁻¹ lower in free energy than that from A. At 298 K the ratio P_B : P_A is closest to:
(a) 1 : 9 (b) 1 : 1 (c) 7.5 : 1 (d) 68 : 1
Answer: (c)
Curtin–Hammett: the ratio depends only on the transition-state free energies. \( \exp(5000/(8.314\times298)) = 7.5 \). The ground-state population (9:1 in favour of A) does not enter. Option (a) wrongly uses the population ratio; (d) multiplies 7.5 by the population ratio 9 instead of ignoring it.
Practice Q4. For the solvolysis of a substrate RX, the Grunwald–Winstein m value is 0.30. On moving from 80 % aqueous ethanol (Y = 0) to a solvent with Y = 2.0, the rate increases by a factor of about:
(a) 1.6 (b) 4 (c) 80 (d) 100
Answer: (b)
\( \log(k/k_0) = mY = 0.30\times2.0 = 0.60 \), so \( k/k_0 = 10^{0.60} = 3.98 \approx 4 \). A substrate with m ≈ 0.95 would speed up by \( 10^{1.9} \approx 79 \). The small m indicates little charge separation in the TS and nucleophilic solvent participation: SN2-like character.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Rate constants (L mol⁻¹ s⁻¹) for the reaction of a series of ring-substituted aryl esters with hydroxide in aqueous dioxane at 25 °C are (illustrative data):
| X | p-OCH₃ | p-CH₃ | H | p-Cl | m-NO₂ | p-NO₂ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| σ | −0.27 | −0.17 | 0 | 0.23 | 0.71 | 0.78 |
| k | 2.5 × 10⁻⁵ | 4.5 × 10⁻⁵ | 1.2 × 10⁻⁴ | 4.5 × 10⁻⁴ | 7.2 × 10⁻³ | 1.1 × 10⁻² |
Which statements are correct?
- A plot of log k against σ is linear with slope about +2.5.
- Negative charge develops near the aromatic ring in the rate-determining transition state.
- The data favour rate-determining addition of hydroxide to the carbonyl group over rate-determining formation of an acylium ion.
- Electron-donating substituents accelerate the reaction.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Least-squares fit of log k against σ gives slope 2.51 and intercept −3.92 (log of \( k_H \)), with r > 0.999. Quick check from the end points: \( [\log(1.1\times10^{-2}) - \log(2.5\times10^{-5})]/(0.78 + 0.27) = 2.64/1.05 = 2.5 \). Correct.
- ρ > 0: negative charge builds up in the TS. Correct.
- Hydroxide addition creates an anionic tetrahedral TS (ρ > 0); acylium formation would create a cation (ρ < 0). Correct.
- With ρ > 0, donors (σ < 0) slow the reaction: p-OCH₃ is the slowest. Wrong.
Practice Q6. A first-order rearrangement has \( k = 1.0\times10^{-4}\ \text{s}^{-1} \) at 298 K and \( 4.0\times10^{-4}\ \text{s}^{-1} \) at 318 K. No crossover products form when two differently labelled substrates are rearranged together, and the rate is independent of solvent polarity. Which statements are correct?
- \( E_a \approx 55\ \text{kJ mol}^{-1} \) and \( \Delta H^\ddagger \approx 52\ \text{kJ mol}^{-1} \).
- \( \Delta S^\ddagger \approx -147\ \text{J K}^{-1}\text{mol}^{-1} \), indicating a highly ordered transition state.
- The absence of crossover shows that the migrating group never becomes free in solution.
- The data are best explained by dissociation into an ion pair that diffuses apart and recombines.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- \( E_a = 8.314\ln4/(1/298 - 1/318) = 54.6 \) kJ mol⁻¹; \( \Delta H^\ddagger = 54.6 - 2.48 = 52.1 \) kJ mol⁻¹. Correct.
- Eyring: \( \Delta S^\ddagger = R[\ln(kh/k_BT) + \Delta H^\ddagger/RT] = 8.314\times(-38.67 + 21.04) = -147 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹. Correct. A unimolecular reaction with such a negative ΔS‡ points to a cyclic, concerted TS.
- No crossover: intramolecular. Correct.
- Diffusing ions would give crossover and a strong solvent-polarity effect, and dissociation would give a less negative ΔS‡. Wrong.
Practice Q7. A secondary benzylic chloride ArCH(CH₃)Cl is solvolysed in aqueous ethanol. Observations: (i) first-order kinetics, unaffected by added azide up to 0.05 M, although alkyl azide forms; (ii) \( \alpha \)-deuterium KIE \( k_\mathrm{H}/k_\mathrm{D} = 1.15 \) (D on the carbon bearing Cl); (iii) a Hammett plot for ring substituents correlates better with σ⁺ than with σ, with ρ⁺ = −5; (iv) optically active substrate gives largely racemised product. Which statements are correct?
- The α-secondary KIE above 1 indicates sp³ → sp² rehybridisation at the reacting carbon in the TS.
- Formation of alkyl azide without a rate increase shows that azide captures an intermediate formed after the rate-determining step.
- The large negative ρ⁺ indicates substantial positive charge delocalised into the ring.
- The data together support an SN1 mechanism.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- Ionisation changes the carbon from sp³ to sp²; the C–D bending modes loosen, giving a normal secondary effect of about 1.1–1.2. Correct.
- Azide changes the product but not the rate: product-determining step after the rate-determining ionisation. Correct.
- σ⁺ correlation and a large negative ρ⁺ mean a benzylic cation in direct conjugation with the ring. Correct.
- First order, nucleophile-independent rate, cationic TS, racemisation: SN1. Correct.
Quick Revision Table
| Tool | Key reading |
|---|---|
| Products, by-products | rearrangement → cation/radical; dimer → radical; solvent incorporation → cation |
| Trapping | benzyne + furan; carbene + alkene; radical + TEMPO; cation + N₃⁻ |
| Radical clocks | cyclopropylmethyl ring opening (very fast); 5-hexenyl cyclisation (slower) |
| Crossover | mixed products = intermolecular |
| ¹⁸O, ¹⁴C, D labels | ester cleavage site; benzyne; reversible carbanion |
| Stereochemistry | inversion SN2; racemisation SN1; retention NGP/SNi |
| ΔS‡ | strongly negative: bimolecular or cyclic TS |
| Primary KIE | 2–7; C–H broken in or before the slow step |
| Secondary α KIE | > 1 for sp³ → sp²; < 1 for sp² → sp³ |
| Hammett | \( \log(k/k_H) = \rho\sigma \); ρ = 1 for ArCOOH ionisation |
| ρ sign | + : negative charge builds; − : positive charge builds |
| σ⁺ / σ⁻ | through-conjugation with cation / anion |
| Non-linear Hammett | concave up: mechanism change; concave down: RDS change |
| Grunwald–Winstein | \( \log(k/k_0) = mY \); t-BuCl m = 1 |
| Swain–Scott | \( \log(k/k_0) = sn \); CH₃Br s = 1 |
| Curtin–Hammett | fast interconversion → ratio from TS free energies |
| Kinetic vs thermodynamic | \( \exp(\Delta\Delta G^\ddagger/RT) \) vs \( \exp(\Delta\Delta G^\circ/RT) \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Revise the whole chapter: Organic Reaction Mechanisms: Quick Revision.
- Revisit the mechanisms these tools were applied to: Nucleophilic Substitution, Aromatic Substitution, Elimination Reactions.
- Kinetics underpinning every table here: Chemical Kinetics.