Skip to content

Electrophiles, Nucleophiles and Radicals

CSIR NET organic mechanisms: electrophiles, nucleophiles and radicals, curly arrows, nucleophilicity vs basicity, leaving groups and radical chain selectivity.

  • 21 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 16 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: One Alkene, Three Partners
  3. Bond Breaking: Heterolysis and Homolysis
  4. Electrophiles
  5. Nucleophiles
  6. Leaving Groups
  7. Radicals
  8. Matching Species to Reaction Types
  9. Reaction Energy Profiles
  10. Memory Tricks
  11. Don’t Confuse
  12. Common Mistakes
  13. Practice
  14. Quick Revision Table
  15. Key Takeaways
  16. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: One Alkene, Three Partners

Bond Breaking: Heterolysis and Homolysis

Every reaction breaks and makes bonds. A two-electron bond can break in two ways.

CleavageElectron bookkeepingArrowGivesFavoured by
Heterolysisboth electrons go to one fragmentfull (double-barbed) curly arrowions: carbocation + anion, or carbanion + cationpolar solvents, polar bonds, good leaving groups, acids and bases
Homolysisone electron to each fragmenttwo half (fish-hook) arrowstwo radicalsheat or light, weak bonds (O–O, N–N, Br–Br, C–I), non-polar solvents, gas phase

A reaction in which the bond-forming and bond-breaking steps use electron pairs is a polar (ionic) reaction. One that uses single electrons is a radical reaction. A third class, pericyclic reactions, reorganises electrons in a cyclic array through one transition state with no intermediate; those belong to the pericyclic and photochemical reactions unit and are not treated here.

Electrophiles

An electrophile (“electron-loving”) is a species that accepts an electron pair from a nucleophile to form a new bond. Every electrophile is a Lewis acid; the term “electrophile” is used when the new bond is usually to carbon and when we talk about rates rather than equilibria.

TypeExamplesElectron-accepting orbital
Cations with a vacant orbitalH⁺, carbocations R₃C⁺, acylium RC≡O⁺, NO₂⁺, NO⁺, ArN₂⁺, “Br⁺” (as Br₂–FeBr₃)empty p orbital or π*
Neutral Lewis acidsBF₃, AlCl₃, FeBr₃, SO₃, BH₃, carbenes (singlet, empty p)empty p or d orbital
Polarised σ bondsCH₃–I, R–OTs, Br–Br near a π system, H–Clσ* of the bond to the leaving group
Polarised π bondsC=O of aldehydes, ketones, acid derivatives; C≡N; β-carbon of α,β-unsaturated carbonylsπ* (largest coefficient on carbon)
Epoxides, aziridines, onium ionsring C–O, C–N, bromonium, episulfoniumσ* of the strained ring bond

Electrophilicity rises when:

  • the electrophilic atom carries more positive charge (acylium > protonated carbonyl > aldehyde > ketone > ester > amide);
  • the LUMO is lower in energy (a Lewis acid that coordinates to O lowers the C=O π*);
  • the leaving group is better (for σ electrophiles);
  • steric access is easier (CH₃–X > RCH₂–X > R₂CH–X for backside attack).

A Lewis acid often turns a weak electrophile into a strong one: Br₂ + FeBr₃ polarises Br–Br for aromatic bromination; AlCl₃ generates acylium ions from acid chlorides; protonation of a carbonyl makes it attack-ready for weak nucleophiles such as water or an alcohol.

Nucleophiles

A nucleophile (“nucleus-loving”) donates an electron pair to an electrophile. Every nucleophile is a Lewis base.

TypeExamplesElectron-donating orbital
AnionsHO⁻, RO⁻, RS⁻, CN⁻, N₃⁻, halides, H⁻ (from LiAlH₄, NaBH₄), carbanions (RLi, RMgX, enolates)non-bonding lone pair or C–M σ bond
Neutral lone-pair donorsH₂O, ROH, NH₃, RNH₂, R₃P, R₂S, pyridinelone pair (n orbital)
π nucleophilesalkenes, alkynes, arenes, enols, enol ethers, enamines, allylsilanesπ (HOMO)
σ nucleophilesC–H of R₃SiH, B–H of boranes, C–M bondsσ bond

Nucleophilicity versus basicity

Basicity is a thermodynamic property: the position of an equilibrium with a proton (pKₐ of the conjugate acid). Nucleophilicity is a kinetic property: the rate constant for attack on a reference electrophile, usually carbon. The two often run together but they diverge in four predictable ways.

FactorEffect on nucleophilicity (toward sp³ carbon)Example
Same attacking atom, different groupsparallels basicityRO⁻ > HO⁻ > RCO₂⁻ > ROH
Across a periodparallels basicityH₂N⁻ > HO⁻ > F⁻; R₃C⁻ > R₂N⁻ > RO⁻
Down a group (protic solvent)opposite to basicity: larger, more polarisable atoms are betterI⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > F⁻; RS⁻ > RO⁻; R₃P > R₃N
Down a group (polar aprotic solvent)order moves toward basicity, because small anions are no longer caged by hydrogen bondsin DMSO or DMF, F⁻ and Cl⁻ become far more reactive than in water or methanol
Steric bulkreduces nucleophilicity much more than basicity(CH₃)₃CO⁻ and LDA are strong bases but poor nucleophiles
α-effecta lone pair on the atom next to the nucleophilic atom raises nucleophilicity above what basicity predictsHOO⁻, NH₂NH₂, NH₂OH, HONH⁻, ClO⁻

Hard and soft nucleophiles and electrophiles

The HSAB principle (see The HSAB Concept) is a qualitative guide to which site a reagent attacks:

Hard (small, high charge density, charge-controlled)Soft (large, polarisable, orbital-controlled)
NucleophilesF⁻, HO⁻, RO⁻, H₂O, NH₃, RLi, RMgXI⁻, RS⁻, R₃P, CN⁻ (through C), R₂CuLi, enolate carbon
ElectrophilesH⁺, carbonyl carbon (1,2-addition), acyl carbon, Sisp³ C–X carbon (SN2), β-carbon of an enone (1,4-addition), Br₂, Pd(II)

Typical consequences: organolithium and Grignard reagents add 1,2 to enones while cuprates add 1,4 (see Addition Reactions); RS⁻ attacks carbon (substitution) where RO⁻ of similar basicity eliminates.

Ambident nucleophiles

An ambident nucleophile has two nucleophilic atoms connected by resonance.

NucleophileSitesTypical outcome
Cyanide, ⁻C≡N ↔ C=N⁻C (soft) or N (harder)NaCN or KCN with RX: nitrile R–CN; AgCN: isocyanide R–NC (Ag⁺ pulls the halide, the reaction gains SN1 character and the more electronegative N attacks)
Enolate, C=C–O⁻ ↔ ⁻C–C=OC or OC-alkylation with soft alkyl halides (RI); O-attack with hard electrophiles (R₃SiCl, acyl chlorides, alkyl sulfates) and in polar aprotic solvents with free anions
PhenoxideO or ring C (ortho, para)O-alkylation in DMF or DMSO; more C-alkylation in protic solvents that hydrogen-bond the oxygen

The general rule (associated with Kornblum): the more SN1-like (cationic, harder) the electrophile, the more attack occurs through the more electronegative atom of the ambident nucleophile.

Leaving Groups

In substitution and elimination, the group that departs with the bonding pair is the leaving group (nucleofuge). Its ability tracks the weakness of the conjugate base it becomes: good leaving groups are weak bases.

AbilityLeaving groupsConjugate acid
ExcellentCF₃SO₃⁻ (triflate), N₂ (from diazonium), p-TolSO₃⁻ (tosylate), CH₃SO₃⁻ (mesylate), I⁻strong acids (or N₂, which is neutral and stable)
GoodBr⁻, H₂O (from ROH₂⁺), ROH (from protonated ether)HBr, H₃O⁺
ModerateCl⁻, RCO₂⁻HCl, carboxylic acids
PoorF⁻, HO⁻, RO⁻, NH₂⁻, H⁻, R⁻weak acids

In SN1, SN2, E1 and E2 the C–leaving group bond breaks in (or before) the rate-determining step, so the leaving group order above matters. In SNAr the leaving group departs after the rate-determining step (nucleophilic attack), and the order can invert: fluoride is the best halide leaving group in SNAr. See Nucleophilic Substitution and Aromatic Substitution.

Radicals

A radical is a species with an unpaired electron. Most carbon radicals are neutral, short-lived and planar or shallowly pyramidal; they are electron-deficient (seven electrons round carbon) and so behave as mild electrophiles, but they react through single-electron steps, not electron pairs. Structures and stabilities of radicals are treated in detail in the reactive-intermediates chapter; here the focus is on how radicals take part in mechanisms.

Stability order

Benzyl ≈ allyl > tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl > vinyl ≈ aryl.

Stability rises with delocalisation (allyl, benzyl), hyperconjugation (more alkyl groups) and captodative substitution (one donor and one acceptor on the radical carbon). Steric shielding gives persistent radicals that survive for long periods: triphenylmethyl (trityl) and nitroxides such as TEMPO.

Generating radicals

MethodExample
Thermal homolysis of weak bondsperoxides (RO–OR, benzoyl peroxide) and azo compounds (AIBN, which loses N₂)
PhotolysisBr₂, Cl₂ with light; ketones (Norrish type I)
One-electron redoxFe²⁺ + H₂O₂ (Fenton, gives HO•); Bu₃Sn• from Bu₃SnH + initiator abstracting halogen from R–X
Radical chain transferan existing radical abstracts an atom to make a new one

Elementary radical steps

StepExamplePolar analogue (if any)
Atom abstraction (S_H2)Cl• + CH₄ → HCl + CH₃•substitution
Addition to π bondBr• + CH₂=CHCH₃ → BrCH₂–ĊHCH₃electrophilic addition
Fragmentation (β-scission)RCO₂• → R• + CO₂elimination
Combination2 CH₃• → C₂H₆—
Disproportionation2 CH₃CH₂• → CH₂=CH₂ + CH₃CH₃—
Electron transferArX + e⁻ → ArX•⁻—

Combination and disproportionation terminate a chain; abstraction, addition and fragmentation propagate it.

Radical substitution: halogenation of alkanes

$$\mathrm{R{-}H + X_2 \xrightarrow{h\nu\ \text{or}\ \Delta} R{-}X + HX}$$
  1. Initiation: X₂ → 2X•
  2. Propagation: X• + R–H → H–X + R•; then R• + X₂ → R–X + X•
  3. Termination: 2X•, X• + R•, 2R• combine

Selectivity. For each type of hydrogen,

$$\frac{\text{product from type } i}{\text{product from type } j} = \frac{n_i\,r_i}{n_j\,r_j}$$

where \( n \) is the number of equivalent hydrogens and \( r \) the relative reactivity per hydrogen. Chlorination is fast and only modestly selective (tertiary > secondary > primary by single-digit factors at room temperature). Bromination is slow and very selective (tertiary hydrogens react hundreds to over a thousand times faster than primary). The exact factors depend on temperature and phase; use the values a question gives.

Allylic and benzylic bromination with NBS

N-Bromosuccinimide (NBS) in CCl₄ (or a modern replacement solvent) with light or a radical initiator brominates the allylic or benzylic position, not the C=C. NBS reacts with the HBr formed in each propagation cycle to release Br₂ at a very low, steady concentration. At low [Br₂], addition of Br• to the C=C is reversible and the ionic addition of Br₂ is too slow, while abstraction of the weak allylic C–H (giving a resonance-stabilised allyl radical) wins. Unsymmetrical allyl radicals can give mixtures of allylic bromides with the double bond shifted.

Radical addition: the peroxide effect

With peroxides present, HBr adds to alkenes anti-Markovnikov: Br• adds to the less substituted carbon to give the more stable carbon radical, which then abstracts H from HBr. HCl and HI do not show the effect in practice: for HCl the H-abstraction step R• + H–Cl is too slow (strong H–Cl bond), and for HI the addition of I• to the alkene is unfavourable. Details are on Addition Reactions.

Inhibitors and evidence for radicals

Radical chains are slowed or stopped by inhibitors (scavengers) that trap chain carriers: O₂ (itself a diradical), phenols such as BHT and hydroquinone, nitroxides (TEMPO), and nitroso or nitrone spin traps used with EPR. A reaction that is accelerated by light or peroxides and suppressed by a scavenger is very likely a radical chain. More on this evidence on Determination of Reaction Pathways.

Matching Species to Reaction Types

The three official syllabus words “addition, elimination, substitution” combine with the three kinds of attacking species to give the standard mechanistic labels:

SubstitutionAdditionElimination
NucleophilicSN1, SN2, SNi, SNAr, acyl substitutionnucleophilic addition to C=O, conjugate (Michael) additionE1cB (carbanion route)
ElectrophilicSEAr (aromatic), SE1/SE2 (aliphatic, e.g. organometallics)AdE to alkenes and alkynes (HX, X₂, H₂O/H⁺, hydroboration)E1 (cation route), E2 is concerted
RadicalSH2 / radical halogenation, SRN1radical addition (peroxide HBr, polymerisation)β-scission, radical fragmentation

The label refers to the reagent that attacks the substrate. In SN2 the reagent is a nucleophile and the substrate is an electrophile; in SEAr the reagent is an electrophile and the aromatic ring is the nucleophile.

graph TD
    A["Identify substrate
and reagent"] --> B{"Light, peroxide,
AIBN, weak X-X bond,
non-polar solvent?"} B -- yes --> R["Radical pathway:
abstraction, addition,
chain kinetics"] B -- no --> C{"Reagent electron-rich
(lone pair, anion,
C-M bond)?"} C -- yes --> N["Nucleophilic attack
on substrate LUMO:
sigma* C-X, pi* C=O,
beta-C of enone"] C -- no --> D{"Reagent electron-poor
(H+, cation, Lewis acid,
polarised X2)?"} D -- yes --> E["Electrophilic attack
on substrate HOMO:
C=C, arene, enol"] D -- no --> P["Consider pericyclic
or concerted pathway"]

Reaction Energy Profiles

TermMeaning
Transition state (‡)energy maximum along the reaction coordinate; a saddle point, lifetime about one vibration, cannot be isolated
Intermediatelocal energy minimum between two transition states; may be detected or trapped
Rate-determining stepthe step whose transition state is highest in free energy relative to the starting materials (for a simple sequence)
Hammond postulatea transition state resembles the species (reactant, intermediate or product) nearest to it in energy
Kinetic controlproduct ratio set by relative rates (relative barrier heights); irreversible conditions, low temperature
Thermodynamic controlproduct ratio set by relative stabilities; reversible conditions, higher temperature, long times
Microscopic reversibilitythe forward and reverse reactions under the same conditions pass through the same transition state

An SN2 reaction has one transition state and no intermediate; SN1, E1, SEAr, SNAr and E1cB each have at least one intermediate. Profile shapes and how they are proved experimentally are developed on Determination of Reaction Pathways.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Nucleophilicity: rate constant toward carbonBasicity: equilibrium toward H⁺
Heterolysis: ions, full arrowsHomolysis: radicals, fish-hook arrows
Electrophilic addition (reagent is E⁺; alkene is the nucleophile)Nucleophilic addition (reagent is Nu⁻; C=O carbon is the electrophile)
Persistent radical (kinetically protected: TEMPO, trityl)Stabilised radical (thermodynamically delocalised: allyl, benzyl)
Intermediate (energy minimum)Transition state (energy maximum)
Inhibitor (traps chain carriers)Initiator (creates chain carriers)
Leaving-group order I > Br > Cl > F (SN1, SN2, E2)F > Cl ≈ Br > I (SNAr, where C–X breaks after the slow step)

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Classify each as electrophile, nucleophile or radical: (i) NO₂⁺, (ii) Ph₃P, (iii) Br•, (iv) BF₃, (v) CH₃S⁻.
  2. Which is the better nucleophile toward CH₃I in methanol: Cl⁻ or I⁻?
  3. Why does AIBN serve as a radical initiator?
Answers
  1. (i) electrophile; (ii) nucleophile; (iii) radical; (iv) electrophile (Lewis acid); (v) nucleophile.
  2. I⁻. It is larger, more polarisable and less tightly hydrogen-bonded by methanol than Cl⁻.
  3. On heating (or irradiation) it loses N₂, a very stable molecule, giving two carbon-centred radicals (stabilised by the nitrile group) that start chains.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. The correct order of nucleophilicity toward methyl iodide in DMSO is best represented by:

(a) I⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > F⁻ (b) F⁻ > Cl⁻ > Br⁻ > I⁻ (c) Br⁻ > I⁻ > F⁻ > Cl⁻ (d) all four halides are equally nucleophilic

Answer: (b)

In a polar aprotic solvent the halide anions are poorly solvated, and their intrinsic reactivity follows charge density (and basicity): F⁻ > Cl⁻ > Br⁻ > I⁻. Option (a) is the order in protic solvents, where hydrogen bonding holds back the small anions.

Practice Q2. Propane is monochlorinated photochemically. Take the relative reactivity per hydrogen as primary : secondary = 1 : 3.8 (illustrative value). The percentage of 2-chloropropane in the monochloride product is closest to:

(a) 25 % (b) 44 % (c) 56 % (d) 79 %

Answer: (c)

Propane has 6 primary and 2 secondary hydrogens. Relative amounts: primary \( 6 \times 1 = 6 \); secondary \( 2 \times 3.8 = 7.6 \). Fraction of 2-chloropropane \( = 7.6/13.6 = 0.559 \), i.e. about 56 %. Option (d) is \( 3.8/4.8 \), which ignores the number of hydrogens; option (a) is \( 2/8 \), which ignores reactivity.

Practice Q3. Which reagent combination brominates cyclohexene mainly at the allylic position?

(a) Br₂ in CH₂Cl₂ in the dark (b) NBS with a radical initiator and light (c) HBr with peroxides (d) Br₂ in water

Answer: (b)

NBS keeps Br₂ at a low steady concentration, so allylic hydrogen abstraction (giving a resonance-stabilised allyl radical) outcompetes addition to C=C. (a) gives trans-1,2-dibromocyclohexane by ionic addition; (c) gives bromocyclohexane by radical addition; (d) gives the bromohydrin.

Practice Q4. Which of the following is an example of the α-effect?

(a) I⁻ reacts faster than Cl⁻ with CH₃Br in water (b) HOO⁻ reacts with an ester faster than HO⁻, although H₂O₂ is a stronger acid than water (c) tert-butoxide reacts more slowly than methoxide with CH₃I (d) F⁻ reacts faster in DMSO than in methanol

Answer: (b)

HOO⁻ is a weaker base than HO⁻ (its conjugate acid H₂O₂ is more acidic than water) yet a better nucleophile. The adjacent lone-pair-bearing oxygen raises nucleophilicity above the basicity trend: the α-effect. (a) is polarisability and solvation; (c) is steric hindrance; (d) is a solvent effect.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. 2-Methylpropane (isobutane) is monohalogenated in two separate experiments. Use the illustrative per-hydrogen relative reactivities primary : tertiary = 1 : 5.0 for chlorination and 1 : 1600 for bromination. Which statements are correct?

  1. Chlorination gives tert-butyl chloride as about 36 % of the monochloride product.
  2. Bromination gives tert-butyl bromide as more than 99 % of the monobromide product.
  3. The higher selectivity of bromination is explained by a later, more product-like transition state for hydrogen abstraction.
  4. Raising the temperature would make chlorination more selective.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only

Isobutane has 9 primary and 1 tertiary hydrogen.

  1. Chlorination: tertiary \( 1 \times 5.0 = 5 \); primary \( 9 \times 1 = 9 \). Fraction tertiary \( = 5/14 = 0.357 \), about 36 %. Correct.
  2. Bromination: tertiary \( 1600 \); primary \( 9 \). Fraction \( = 1600/1609 = 0.994 \), above 99 %. Correct.
  3. Hammond postulate: abstraction by Br• is endothermic, the transition state is late and radical-like, so radical stability is strongly expressed. Correct.
  4. Higher temperature lets more molecules surmount the higher barriers, so relative rates move toward 1: selectivity falls. Wrong.

Practice Q6. An alkyl bromide RBr (R = a secondary alkyl group) is treated with NaCN in DMSO in one experiment and with AgCN in ethanol in another. A third experiment uses sodium thiophenoxide (PhS⁻Na⁺) in ethanol, and a fourth uses potassium tert-butoxide in tert-butanol. Which statements are correct?

  1. NaCN in DMSO gives mainly the nitrile R–CN through attack by carbon.
  2. AgCN gives a significant amount of isocyanide R–NC because Ag⁺ assists ionisation and the more electronegative N attacks the more cation-like carbon.
  3. PhS⁻ gives mainly substitution, while tert-butoxide gives mainly elimination.
  4. PhS⁻ is a stronger base than tert-butoxide, which is why it substitutes.

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. Free cyanide in a polar aprotic solvent reacts SN2 through its softer, more nucleophilic carbon. Correct.
  2. Ag⁺ coordinates the leaving bromide, the transition state becomes SN1-like, and attack shifts to nitrogen (Kornblum’s generalisation). Correct.
  3. PhS⁻ is a soft, polarisable, weakly basic nucleophile, so SN2 wins; tert-butoxide is a hindered strong base, so E2 wins. Correct.
  4. Thiophenol is far more acidic than tert-butanol, so PhS⁻ is a much weaker base than tert-butoxide. It substitutes because it is a good nucleophile, not a strong base. Wrong.

Practice Q7. A student treats 1-methylcyclohexene with HBr in two flasks: flask A in pentane in the dark with a radical scavenger, flask B in pentane with benzoyl peroxide. Which pairing of major product and mechanism is correct?

(a) A: 1-bromo-1-methylcyclohexane, electrophilic addition via a tertiary cation; B: 1-bromo-2-methylcyclohexane, radical chain via a tertiary radical (b) A: 1-bromo-2-methylcyclohexane, radical; B: 1-bromo-1-methylcyclohexane, ionic (c) Both flasks give 1-bromo-1-methylcyclohexane (d) Both flasks give 1-bromo-2-methylcyclohexane

Answer: (a)

Flask A: H⁺ adds to C2 to give the tertiary cation at C1; Br⁻ captures it (Markovnikov). Flask B: Br• adds to C2, the less substituted alkene carbon, giving the tertiary radical at C1, which abstracts H from HBr, so Br ends up on C2 (anti-Markovnikov). In both cases the more stable intermediate (tertiary) is formed; what differs is whether H or Br adds first.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
Electrophileelectron-pair acceptor (Lewis acid); attacked through its LUMO
Nucleophileelectron-pair donor (Lewis base); attacks with its HOMO
Radicalodd electron; reacts by single-electron steps; fish-hook arrows
Protic solventI⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > F⁻; RS⁻ > RO⁻
Polar aprotic solventanions “naked”; order moves toward basicity; SN2 accelerated
α-effectHOO⁻, NH₂NH₂, NH₂OH more nucleophilic than basicity predicts
Bulky basest-BuO⁻, LDA: strong base, poor nucleophile
Leaving groupweak conjugate base; TfO⁻, TsO⁻, I⁻, Br⁻ good; HO⁻, RO⁻, F⁻ poor
AmbidentAgCN → isocyanide; NaCN → nitrile; harder (SN1-like) centre attacked by the more electronegative atom
Radical stabilitybenzyl ≈ allyl > 3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃ > vinyl, aryl
Halogenation ratioproduct ∝ (number of H) × (reactivity per H)
SelectivityBr₂ ≫ Cl₂ (late vs early transition state)
NBSallylic/benzylic bromination by low steady [Br₂]
Peroxide effectHBr only; anti-Markovnikov
InhibitorsO₂, BHT, hydroquinone, TEMPO

Key Takeaways

What’s Next