Elimination Reactions: E1, E2, E1cB and Syn Eliminations
CSIR NET organic mechanisms: E2 anti-periplanar geometry, Zaitsev vs Hofmann, E1 and E1cB, Cope, Chugaev, ester and selenoxide syn eliminations, SN vs E.
- 15 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Two Chlorides from Menthol
- The Three Polar Mechanisms
- E2: Bimolecular Elimination
- E1: Unimolecular Elimination
- E1cB: Elimination through the Conjugate Base
- Syn Eliminations: Pyrolytic (Ei) Reactions
- Other Eliminations Worth Knowing
- Substitution or Elimination?
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Nucleophilic Substitution: SN1 and SN2 are the constant competitors of E1 and E2.
- Electrophiles, Nucleophiles and Radicals: base strength versus nucleophilicity; bulky bases.
- Chair conformations of cyclohexane, axial and equatorial positions, Newman projections: see Stereogenicity, Chirality and Configuration.
- Primary kinetic isotope effects: see Reaction Mechanisms and Chain Reactions.
The Hook: Two Chlorides from Menthol
The Three Polar Mechanisms
A β-elimination removes a leaving group X from Cα and a proton from the adjacent Cβ to form a π bond. The timing of the two bond cleavages defines the mechanism.
graph LR
A["C-X breaks first
carbocation"] --> E1["E1
v = k[RX]"]
B["C-H and C-X
break together"] --> E2["E2
v = k[RX][B]"]
C["C-H breaks first
carbanion"] --> E1cB["E1cB
v depends on
which step is slow"]
E1 --- S["Spectrum of E2
transition states:
E1-like, central, E1cB-like"]
E2 --- S
E1cB --- SE2: Bimolecular Elimination
$$\mathrm{B^- + H{-}C_\beta{-}C_\alpha{-}X \longrightarrow BH + C_\beta{=}C_\alpha + X^-}, \qquad v = k[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{B^-}]$$- Concerted, one transition state. The base removes Hβ as the C–X bond breaks and the π bond forms.
- Primary deuterium KIE (\( k_\mathrm{H}/k_\mathrm{D} \) clearly above 1) because C–H is broken in the rate-determining step.
- Element effect: the leaving group matters (I > Br > Cl > F) because C–X is also breaking.
- Stereoelectronic requirement: the C–H σ bond must overlap with the C–X σ* orbital. This is best when H and X are anti-periplanar (dihedral angle 180°). Syn-periplanar (0°) elimination is possible but much slower and seen only when the anti arrangement is unavailable (some rigid bicyclic systems).
Stereospecificity
Because the geometry is fixed, a given diastereomer gives a specific alkene isomer.
E2 in cyclohexanes
Anti-periplanar in a chair means both H and X axial (trans-diaxial).
| Substrate | Conformation needed | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Neomenthyl chloride (Cl axial in the more stable chair, both neighbouring carbons carry an axial H) | already reactive | fast; both directions possible; Zaitsev (more substituted, toward the isopropyl carbon) alkene predominates |
| Menthyl chloride (Cl equatorial in the more stable chair) | ring flip puts Cl, isopropyl and methyl all axial; only the CH₂ side has an axial H anti to Cl | slow (small population of the reactive chair); only the less substituted alkene (anti-Zaitsev) |
| trans-1-Bromo-2-methylcyclohexane | needs the diaxial conformer; the only anti H is on C6 | 3-methylcyclohexene, not the Zaitsev product 1-methylcyclohexene |
The hidden lesson: conformation controls regiochemistry. Zaitsev’s rule applies only among the hydrogens that can be anti to X.
Regiochemistry: Zaitsev versus Hofmann
| Rule | Product | Favoured by |
|---|---|---|
| Zaitsev | more substituted (more stable) alkene | small strong bases (EtO⁻, HO⁻, MeO⁻), good leaving groups (Br, I, OTs), E1 conditions |
| Hofmann | less substituted alkene | bulky bases (t-BuO⁻, LDA), poor or charged leaving groups (–NR₃⁺, –SR₂⁺, F), steric crowding near the more substituted β-H |
Why Hofmann: with a poor leaving group the transition state shifts toward the E1cB-like end (C–H breaking is ahead of C–X breaking), so carbanion stability (primary > secondary > tertiary) rather than alkene stability controls which proton goes. A bulky base simply reaches the less hindered CH₃ hydrogens more easily. Hofmann elimination of quaternary ammonium hydroxides (R–NMe₃⁺ HO⁻, heated) is the classic case.
E/Z selectivity. When the β-carbon carries two hydrogens, E2 usually prefers the (E)-alkene, because the anti-periplanar conformer leading to it has the large groups anti rather than gauche.
The variable E2 transition state
| End of the spectrum | Character | Favoured by | Regiochemistry |
|---|---|---|---|
| E1-like | C–X well broken, little C–H breaking; positive charge at Cα | good leaving group, cation-stabilising Cα substituents, weak base | Zaitsev |
| Central (synchronous) | balanced | typical alkyl halide + alkoxide | Zaitsev |
| E1cB-like | C–H well broken, C–X little broken; negative charge at Cβ | poor leaving group, acidifying Cβ substituents, strong base | Hofmann |
Hammett \( \rho \) values for 2-arylethyl substrates (aryl on Cβ) are positive for E2 with alkoxide, and become larger as the leaving group becomes poorer: more carbanion character at Cβ.
E1: Unimolecular Elimination
$$\mathrm{R{-}X \xrightarrow{\text{slow}} R^+ + X^-}, \qquad \mathrm{R^+ \xrightarrow{\text{fast},\ -H^+} \text{alkene}}, \qquad v = k[\mathrm{RX}]$$- Same rate-determining step as SN1, so E1 and SN1 always compete; the ratio is set by the cation’s partitioning, not by the leaving group.
- Substrates: tertiary, secondary, benzylic, allylic; acid-catalysed dehydration of alcohols (ROH₂⁺ loses water): tertiary > secondary > primary.
- Zaitsev product dominates (thermodynamic alkene), with (E) over (Z).
- Rearrangements via hydride or alkyl shifts are common; acid-catalysed dehydration of 3,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol gives mainly 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene after a methyl shift.
- No stereochemical requirement (the cation is planar); no primary KIE in the slow step.
- Higher temperature favours E1 over SN1 (elimination makes more particles: positive ΔS).
E1cB: Elimination through the Conjugate Base
$$\mathrm{B^- + H{-}C_\beta{-}C_\alpha{-}X \rightleftharpoons BH + {}^-C_\beta{-}C_\alpha{-}X \longrightarrow C_\beta{=}C_\alpha + X^-}$$E1cB requires (i) an acidic β-hydrogen, made so by an adjacent C=O, NO₂, CN, SO₂R or aryl group, and (ii) a relatively poor leaving group (HO⁻, RO⁻, PhO⁻, F⁻) that does not leave in concert.
| Variant | Slow step | Diagnostic |
|---|---|---|
| (E1cB)ᵣ, reversible | loss of X⁻ from the carbanion; deprotonation is fast and reversible | in D₂O or EtOD, substrate exchanges H for D faster than it eliminates; no primary KIE on elimination; specific base catalysis |
| (E1cB)ᵢᵣᵣ, irreversible | deprotonation; X⁻ leaves faster than reprotonation | primary KIE; no H/D exchange in recovered substrate; general base catalysis |
| (E1cB)anion | substrate fully deprotonated first; loss of X⁻ from the anion | rate independent of [base] once the substrate is fully converted |
Classic example: base-catalysed dehydration of an aldol (β-hydroxy carbonyl compound) to an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl. The enolate forms first; hydroxide, a poor leaving group, departs from the enolate. This is why the aldol condensation drives itself to the conjugated enone.
Syn Eliminations: Pyrolytic (Ei) Reactions
Several eliminations proceed by an intramolecular, cyclic transition state in which the leaving group itself removes the β-hydrogen. The H and the leaving group must be syn-periplanar, and no external base is needed.
| Reaction | Substrate | Ring size of TS | Typical conditions | Products |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cope elimination | tertiary amine N-oxide R–NMe₂⁺–O⁻ | 5-membered | heating | alkene + Me₂NOH |
| Selenoxide elimination | R–Se(=O)Ph (from oxidation of the selenide) | 5-membered | often at or near room temperature | alkene + PhSeOH |
| Chugaev reaction | xanthate R–O–C(=S)SMe | 6-membered | heating | alkene + COS + MeSH |
| Ester (acetate) pyrolysis | R–OC(=O)CH₃ | 6-membered | high temperature (gas phase) | alkene + CH₃CO₂H |
Characteristics:
- Syn stereospecificity: a single diastereomer gives a single alkene geometry, the opposite of what anti-E2 would give from the same diastereomer.
- Regiochemistry is governed largely by the number of syn β-hydrogens available (statistical) and by steric factors, so the less substituted (Hofmann-type) alkene is often significant or major. In cyclohexyl systems the syn H must be cis to the leaving group; an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl is formed preferentially when a β-H is α to a carbonyl (selenoxide route to enones).
- First-order kinetics, a negative entropy of activation (ordered cyclic TS) and a primary KIE support the concerted cyclic mechanism.
Other Eliminations Worth Knowing
- Dehalogenation of vicinal dihalides with I⁻ or Zn: anti, stereospecific (worked example above).
- Double dehydrohalogenation of vicinal or geminal dihalides with NaNH₂ gives alkynes.
- α-Elimination: loss of H and X from the same carbon gives a carbene (CHCl₃ + base → :CCl₂). See the reactive-intermediates unit.
- Bredt’s rule: a double bond cannot form at the bridgehead of a small bicyclic ring system, so eliminations toward a bridgehead in such systems fail.
Substitution or Elimination?
| Substrate | Strong, unhindered base / good Nu (HO⁻, EtO⁻) | Bulky strong base (t-BuO⁻, LDA) | Good Nu, weak base (I⁻, RS⁻, N₃⁻, CN⁻) | Weak Nu / weak base (H₂O, ROH), heat |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Methyl | SN2 | SN2 | SN2 | no reaction |
| Primary | SN2 (major) | E2 | SN2 | no reaction (slow) |
| Secondary | E2 (major) + SN2 | E2 | SN2 | SN1 + E1 (slow) |
| Tertiary | E2 | E2 | SN1/E1 or E2 | SN1 + E1 |
Further levers:
- Higher temperature favours elimination (more particles formed: larger \( \Delta S \), and the \( -T\Delta S \) term grows).
- Polar aprotic solvent with an anionic base favours SN2 for primary and E2 for secondary substrates.
- β-Branching and α-branching both shift toward elimination.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| E2: anti-periplanar, external base, bimolecular | Ei: syn-periplanar, internal base, unimolecular | |
| (E1cB)ᵣ: H/D exchange faster than elimination, no primary KIE | (E1cB)ᵢᵣᵣ: no exchange, primary KIE | |
| E1: carbocation, Zaitsev, rearrangement | E1cB: carbanion, often Hofmann-like or conjugated product | |
| Zaitsev: product stability | Hofmann: acidity/accessibility of the proton | |
| Stereospecific (diastereomer → defined alkene) | Stereoselective (preference among possible alkenes) | |
| β-elimination (alkene) | α-elimination (carbene) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What dihedral angle between H and X is preferred in E2?
- Which alkene is the major product when 2-bromo-2-methylbutane reacts with potassium tert-butoxide?
- Name the syn elimination of tertiary amine N-oxides.
Answers
- 180° (anti-periplanar).
- 2-Methylbut-1-ene (Hofmann product): the bulky base removes a more accessible CH₃ hydrogen.
- The Cope elimination.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. meso-2,3-Dibromobutane is heated with NaI in acetone. The product is:
(a) (Z)-but-2-ene (b) (E)-but-2-ene (c) a 1:1 mixture of (E)- and (Z)-but-2-ene (d) but-1-ene
Answer: (b)
Anti-periplanar debromination: in the meso isomer, the conformation with Br anti to Br also has CH₃ anti to CH₃, so the methyls end up trans. The racemic isomer gives (Z)-but-2-ene.
Practice Q2. trans-1-Bromo-2-methylcyclohexane is treated with NaOEt in ethanol. The major alkene is:
(a) 1-methylcyclohexene (b) 3-methylcyclohexene (c) methylenecyclohexane (d) equal amounts of (a) and (b)
Answer: (b)
In the reactive chair Br must be axial; in the trans isomer the C2 methyl is then also axial, so H on C2 is equatorial and cannot be anti to Br. Only an axial H on C6 is available, giving 3-methylcyclohexene (anti-Zaitsev).
Practice Q3. In base-catalysed elimination of PhCH₂CH₂OPh (illustrative system) in EtOD/EtO⁻, recovered starting material after partial reaction contains deuterium at the benzylic carbon, and the rate shows no primary isotope effect when the substrate is PhCD₂CH₂OPh. The mechanism is best described as:
(a) E1 (b) E2 (c) (E1cB)ᵣ (d) (E1cB)ᵢᵣᵣ
Answer: (c)
Exchange of H for D faster than elimination shows that the carbanion forms reversibly; the absence of a primary KIE shows that C–H cleavage is not rate-determining. Loss of the poor leaving group PhO⁻ from the carbanion is the slow step: reversible E1cB.
Practice Q4. The difference in free energies of activation for E2 formation of (Z)- and (E)-pent-2-ene from 2-bromopentane is 4.0 kJ mol⁻¹, favouring the (E)-isomer (illustrative value). Under kinetic control at 298 K, the E : Z ratio is closest to:
(a) 1.6 (b) 2.5 (c) 5.0 (d) 50
Answer: (c)
\( \text{E/Z} = \exp(\Delta\Delta G^\ddagger/RT) = \exp\!\left(\dfrac{4000}{8.314\times298}\right) = e^{1.61} = 5.0 \). Product ratios under kinetic control depend only on the difference in transition-state free energies.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Consider the following four reactions:
- (I) 2-bromo-2-methylbutane + EtO⁻ in EtOH
- (II) 2-methylbutan-2-yl trimethylammonium hydroxide, heated
- (III) 2-bromo-2-methylbutane + t-BuO⁻ in t-BuOH
- (IV) 2-methylbutan-2-ol + conc. H₂SO₄, heated
Which statements are correct?
- (I) and (IV) give 2-methylbut-2-ene as the major alkene.
- (II) and (III) give 2-methylbut-1-ene as the major alkene.
- (IV) proceeds through a carbocation and could give rearranged products in a less symmetrical substrate.
- In (II), the major alkene is controlled by the stability of the alkene formed.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Small base with a good leaving group (I) and E1 dehydration (IV) both give the Zaitsev (trisubstituted) alkene. Correct.
- Charged poor leaving group (II, Hofmann elimination) and bulky base (III) give the less substituted alkene. Correct.
- Acid dehydration of a tertiary alcohol is E1 through a tertiary cation; with other skeletons, hydride or alkyl shifts can occur. Correct.
- In Hofmann elimination the E1cB-like transition state and proton accessibility, not alkene stability, decide the regiochemistry. Wrong.
Practice Q6. A single diastereomer of PhCH(CH₃)–CH(Ph)–X is converted into 1,2-diphenylpropene by two routes: (I) X = Br with EtO⁻ in EtOH; (II) X = N(CH₃)₂ oxidised to the N-oxide with H₂O₂ and heated. Which statements are correct?
- Route (I) removes the β-H anti-periplanar to Br; route (II) removes the β-H syn-periplanar to the N-oxide.
- Routes (I) and (II) give alkenes of opposite configuration (one E, one Z) from the same relative configuration of the substrate.
- Route (II) shows second-order kinetics, first order in an external base.
- Route (I) should show a primary deuterium isotope effect if the benzylic CH(CH₃) hydrogen is replaced by D.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- E2 is anti; the Cope elimination is syn through a five-membered cyclic transition state. Correct.
- With only one β-H available on that carbon, anti and syn removal from the same diastereomer place the substituents on opposite sides of the new π bond. Correct.
- The Cope elimination is intramolecular and first order; the N-oxide oxygen is the base. Wrong.
- E2 breaks C–H in the rate-determining step. Correct.
Practice Q7. A secondary alkyl bromide reacts with sodium ethoxide in ethanol at two temperatures. The E2 : SN2 product ratio is 3.0 at 298 K and 6.0 at 328 K. Treating the ratio as \( k_E/k_S \) with Arrhenius behaviour, which statements are correct?
- The activation energy for elimination exceeds that for substitution by about 18.8 kJ mol⁻¹.
- Raising the temperature favours elimination, in line with the larger entropy change of elimination.
- The ratio would be 3.0 at all temperatures if both pathways had the same activation energy.
- At 298 K, 75 % of the product is alkene.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- \( \ln(6.0/3.0) = \dfrac{\Delta E}{R}\left(\dfrac{1}{298} - \dfrac{1}{328}\right) \Rightarrow \Delta E = \dfrac{8.314\times0.6931}{3.069\times10^{-4}} = 18.8 \) kJ mol⁻¹. Correct.
- Elimination makes three particles from two; higher temperature favours it. Correct.
- Equal activation energies make the ratio equal to the ratio of pre-exponential factors, independent of temperature. Correct.
- Ratio 3:1 means 3/4 = 75 % alkene. Correct.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| E2 | \( k[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{B}] \); concerted; anti-periplanar; primary KIE; I > Br > Cl > F |
| Cyclohexane E2 | H and X trans-diaxial |
| Menthyl / neomenthyl chloride | menthyl: slow, only anti-Zaitsev; neomenthyl: fast, mainly Zaitsev |
| Stereospecific E2 | meso-2,3-dibromobutane → E; (±) → Z |
| Zaitsev | small base, good leaving group, E1 |
| Hofmann | bulky base, –NR₃⁺ / F leaving group; E1cB-like TS |
| E1 | \( k[\mathrm{RX}] \); carbocation; Zaitsev; rearrangement; competes with SN1 |
| E1cB | acidic β-H + poor leaving group; (E1cB)ᵣ = H/D exchange, no KIE; (E1cB)ᵢᵣᵣ = KIE, no exchange |
| Aldol dehydration | E1cB via enolate |
| Ei (syn) | Cope (N-oxide), selenoxide, Chugaev (xanthate), acetate pyrolysis |
| Cyclic TS | 5-membered (N-oxide, selenoxide); 6-membered (xanthate, ester) |
| SN vs E | 3° + base → E2; 2° + strong base → E2; 1° + t-BuO⁻ → E2; heat → E |
| Kinetic ratio | \( \exp(\Delta\Delta G^\ddagger/RT) \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Addition Reactions: the reverse direction, adding across C=C and C=O.
- Determination of Reaction Pathways: isotope effects, Hammett ρ and activation parameters used to place an E2 on the spectrum.
- Activation entropy and the Eyring analysis behind “heat favours elimination”: Collision Theory, Transition-State Theory and Unimolecular Reactions.
- Organic Reaction Mechanisms: Quick Revision.