Nucleophilic Substitution: SN1, SN2, SNi, NGP and Acyl Substitution
CSIR NET organic mechanisms: SN2 and SN1 kinetics and stereochemistry, ion pairs, solvent rules, SNi, SN2', neighbouring-group participation, acyl substitution.
- 18 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Walden’s Cycle
- SN2: Bimolecular Nucleophilic Substitution
- SN1: Unimolecular Nucleophilic Substitution
- SN1 versus SN2 at a Glance
- SNi: Internal Return with Retention
- Neighbouring-Group Participation (Anchimeric Assistance)
- Allylic Substitution: SN1′ and SN2′
- Nucleophilic Substitution at the Acyl Carbon
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Electrophiles, Nucleophiles and Radicals: nucleophilicity, solvent effects, leaving groups.
- R/S configuration and the meaning of inversion, retention and racemisation: see Stereogenicity, Chirality and Configuration.
- First- and second-order rate laws and the steady-state idea: see Complex Reactions and the Steady-State Approximation.
- The inorganic parallel (dissociative and associative substitution at metal centres): see Substitution and Electron-Transfer Mechanisms.
The Hook: Walden’s Cycle
SN2: Bimolecular Nucleophilic Substitution
$$\mathrm{Nu^- + R{-}X \longrightarrow [Nu\cdots R\cdots X]^{\ddagger -} \longrightarrow Nu{-}R + X^-}, \qquad v = k_2[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{Nu^-}]$$- One step, one transition state, no intermediate. Bond making and bond breaking are simultaneous.
- Backside attack: the nucleophile’s HOMO overlaps the large back lobe of the C–X σ* orbital, 180° from the leaving group.
- Transition state: carbon is trigonal bipyramidal, with Nu and X apical and the three other substituents planar.
- Stereochemistry: complete inversion of configuration (Walden inversion). Whether the CIP descriptor changes from R to S depends on priorities: if Nu and X have the same priority rank, R becomes S.
Substrate effects
| Substrate | Relative SN2 reactivity | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| CH₃–X | fastest | no steric hindrance |
| RCH₂–X (primary) | fast | one alkyl group |
| R₂CH–X (secondary) | slow | two groups crowd the backside |
| R₃C–X (tertiary) | negligible | backside blocked; elimination or SN1 instead |
| (CH₃)₃CCH₂–X (neopentyl) | extremely slow despite being primary | β-branching blocks the backside |
| Allylic, benzylic | faster than simple primary | π overlap with the p-type orbital in the transition state |
| α-Halo carbonyl (XCH₂COR) | much faster than simple primary | C=O π* lowers the energy of the transition state |
| Vinyl, aryl halides | inert | sp² C–X is stronger; backside path through the π system or ring |
| Bridgehead (e.g. 1-bromonorbornane) | inert | backside lies inside the cage; inversion impossible |
Solvent effects (Hughes–Ingold rules)
The effect of solvent polarity depends on how charge changes from reactants to transition state.
| Reaction type | Charge change on reaching the TS | Effect of a more polar solvent |
|---|---|---|
| SN1: R–X → R⁺ + X⁻ | charge created | large increase in rate |
| SN1: R–X⁺ → R⁺ + X | charge dispersed | small decrease |
| SN2: Nu⁻ + R–X | charge dispersed over Nu and X | small decrease (in protic solvents larger, because the anion is solvated) |
| SN2: Nu + R–X (Menshutkin, R₃N + RX) | charge created | large increase |
| SN2: Nu⁻ + R–X⁺ (e.g. HO⁻ + R–SMe₂⁺) | charge destroyed | large decrease |
| SN2: Nu + R–X⁺ | charge dispersed | small decrease |
Beyond polarity, protic versus aprotic matters for anionic nucleophiles: polar aprotic solvents (DMSO, DMF, acetone, HMPA) can raise SN2 rates by orders of magnitude because the anion is not hydrogen-bonded.
SN1: Unimolecular Nucleophilic Substitution
$$\mathrm{R{-}X \xrightarrow{\text{slow}} R^+ + X^-}, \qquad \mathrm{R^+ + Nu^- \xrightarrow{\text{fast}} R{-}Nu}, \qquad v = k_1[\mathrm{RX}]$$- Two steps, carbocation intermediate. Ionisation is rate-determining; the nucleophile does not appear in the rate law.
- Substrate: tertiary, benzylic, allylic, α-alkoxy (oxocarbenium) and other substrates that give stabilised cations: R₃C–X > R₂CH–X ≫ RCH₂–X. Methyl and simple primary substrates do not ionise.
- Solvolysis: in practice SN1 is usually observed when the solvent is the nucleophile (water, alcohols, formic acid, acetic acid) and is pseudo-first order.
- Stereochemistry: a planar cation can be attacked from either face, so the ideal outcome is racemisation. Real SN1 reactions usually give racemisation with some excess inversion, because the departing anion still shields the front face (ion pairs, below).
- Rearrangements: the cation can undergo 1,2-hydride or 1,2-alkyl shifts to a more stable cation before capture (neopentyl systems rearrange to tertiary products under SN1 conditions).
- Bridgehead substrates cannot become planar and ionise extremely slowly.
- Elimination (E1) competes from the same cation.
Winstein’s ion-pair scheme
$$\mathrm{R{-}X \rightleftharpoons R^+X^- \rightleftharpoons R^+\Vert X^- \rightleftharpoons R^+ + X^-}$$| Stage | Name | Capture by nucleophile gives |
|---|---|---|
| R⁺X⁻ | intimate (contact) ion pair | mainly inversion (front face blocked by X⁻); internal return to RX may racemise or scramble the substrate |
| R⁺‖X⁻ | solvent-separated ion pair | partial inversion |
| R⁺ + X⁻ | free (dissociated) ions | racemisation |
Supporting observations: the common-ion effect (added X⁻ slows solvolysis of substrates that form free, relatively stable cations, by returning R⁺ to RX), and the special salt effect of LiClO₄ (a small amount causes a disproportionate rate increase by intercepting solvent-separated ion pairs that would otherwise return).
Rate law with competing pathways
When both mechanisms operate,
$$v = k_1[\mathrm{RX}] + k_2[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{Nu}], \qquad k_{\text{obs}} = k_1 + k_2[\mathrm{Nu}]$$A plot of \( k_{\text{obs}} \) against [Nu] is a straight line: intercept \( k_1 \) (SN1 or solvolysis), slope \( k_2 \) (SN2). This is the standard way Part C presents “borderline” secondary substrates.
SN1 versus SN2 at a Glance
| Criterion | SN2 | SN1 |
|---|---|---|
| Rate law | \( k[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{Nu}] \) | \( k[\mathrm{RX}] \) |
| Intermediate | none | carbocation (and ion pairs) |
| Substrate order | CH₃ > 1° > 2° ≫ 3° | 3° > 2° ≫ 1° > CH₃ |
| Stereochemistry | inversion | racemisation, usually with excess inversion |
| Rearrangement | never | common |
| Nucleophile | strong, high concentration | weak (often solvent); concentration irrelevant to rate |
| Solvent | polar aprotic (for anionic Nu) | polar protic (ionising) |
| Leaving group | needed in both; I > Br > Cl ≫ F | needed in both; I > Br > Cl ≫ F |
| ΔS‡ | negative (two particles become one) | near zero or positive (one particle becomes two; solvation of the ions can offset this) |
| Effect of α-branching | strong decrease | strong increase |
SNi: Internal Return with Retention
An alcohol treated with thionyl chloride alone (no base) is converted into an alkyl chloride with retention of configuration.
- ROH + SOCl₂ → R–O–S(=O)Cl (alkyl chlorosulfite) + HCl
- The C–O bond ionises to a tight ion pair R⁺ ⁻OS(O)Cl; the chlorosulfite collapses, delivering Cl from the same face as the departing oxygen, with loss of SO₂.
| Conditions | Outcome | Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| SOCl₂ alone (or in a non-nucleophilic solvent) | retention | SNi via tight ion pair |
| SOCl₂ + pyridine | inversion | pyridine takes HCl; free Cl⁻ attacks the chlorosulfite (or the pyridinium salt) from the back: SN2 |
| SOCl₂ in dioxane | retention | dioxane attacks first (inversion), then Cl⁻ displaces dioxane (inversion again): net retention |
Neighbouring-Group Participation (Anchimeric Assistance)
A group within the substrate that has a lone pair or π electrons, placed so that it can reach the backside of the C–X bond, may displace the leaving group intramolecularly. The external nucleophile then opens the cyclic intermediate.
Signature features:
- Retention of configuration (two successive inversions).
- Rate enhancement relative to a model compound without the group, or relative to a stereoisomer that cannot participate.
- Rearranged or scrambled products when the cyclic intermediate can open at either carbon.
| Neighbouring group | Cyclic intermediate | Classic example |
|---|---|---|
| α-Carboxylate (–CO₂⁻) | α-lactone | (S)-2-bromopropanoate with Ag₂O or dilute HO⁻ gives (S)-lactic acid (retention); concentrated HO⁻ attacks directly (SN2, inversion) |
| β-Sulfur (–SR) | episulfonium ion | sulfur mustard (ClCH₂CH₂)₂S hydrolyses and alkylates far faster than an analogous chloride lacking S |
| β-Nitrogen (–NR₂) | aziridinium ion | nitrogen mustards (alkylating agents) |
| β-Oxygen (–O⁻, –OAc) | epoxide; acetoxonium (dioxolanylium) ion | trans-2-chlorocyclohexanol + base → cyclohexene oxide; trans-2-acetoxycyclohexyl tosylate solvolyses faster than the cis isomer and gives trans product |
| β-Aryl | phenonium (spiro-cyclopropyl) ion | Cram’s 3-phenyl-2-butyl tosylates (below) |
| C=C π bond, σ bond | non-classical cation | anti-7-norbornenyl and exo-2-norbornyl systems |
Allylic Substitution: SN1′ and SN2′
Allylic substrates can be attacked at the γ-carbon with migration of the double bond:
$$\mathrm{Nu^- + CH_2{=}CH{-}CHR{-}X \longrightarrow Nu{-}CH_2{-}CH{=}CHR + X^-}\quad (\text{SN2}')$$- SN2′ is favoured when the α-carbon is hindered and the γ-carbon is not, and with soft nucleophiles such as cuprates.
- Under SN1 conditions the allyl cation is delocalised and gives a mixture of the two regioisomers (the allylic rearrangement or SN1′ product).
Nucleophilic Substitution at the Acyl Carbon
Carboxylic acid derivatives RCOL react by addition–elimination through a tetrahedral intermediate, not by a one-step SN2 displacement.
$$\mathrm{RC({=}O)L + Nu^- \rightleftharpoons RC(O^-)(L)(Nu) \longrightarrow RC({=}O)Nu + L^-}$$Reactivity order (fastest first):
acyl chloride > acid anhydride > thioester > ester ≈ carboxylic acid > amide > carboxylate
The order follows two things together: how good L is as a leaving group, and how strongly L donates its lone pair into C=O (amide nitrogen donates most, so amides are least electrophilic). A derivative can be converted down the ladder directly (acid chloride → ester → amide) but not up it without activation.
Evidence for the tetrahedral intermediate: when an ester labelled with ¹⁸O in the carbonyl group is partly hydrolysed in ordinary water (base or acid), the recovered ester has lost some of its label. This exchange requires a symmetric-enough intermediate in which the two oxygens become equivalent by proton transfer, then the intermediate reverts to ester with either oxygen. A one-step displacement would not exchange the carbonyl oxygen.
Ingold’s classification of ester hydrolysis
The labels give: A (acid) or B (base) catalysed; AC (acyl–oxygen cleavage) or AL (alkyl–oxygen cleavage); 1 or 2 (molecularity of the rate-determining step).
| Label | Bond cleaved | Rate-determining step | Typical case |
|---|---|---|---|
| BAC2 | acyl–O | attack of HO⁻ on C=O | ordinary saponification (most common) |
| AAC2 | acyl–O | attack of H₂O on protonated ester | ordinary acid-catalysed hydrolysis |
| AAL1 | alkyl–O | ionisation to R⁺ (carbocation) | tert-butyl and other tertiary or benzhydryl esters in acid |
| AAC1 | acyl–O | ionisation to acylium RCO⁺ | hindered aryl esters (e.g. mesitoates) in concentrated H₂SO₄ |
| BAL2 | alkyl–O | SN2 on the alkyl carbon | rare; methyl esters cleaved by soft nucleophiles (I⁻, RS⁻) |
¹⁸O labelling settles the cleavage site. Saponify an ester R′C(=O)–¹⁸OR in ordinary water: in BAC2 the ¹⁸O stays in the alcohol R–¹⁸OH. If an optically active secondary alcohol is the alkyl part, its configuration is retained in BAC2 (C–O of the alcohol is never broken). In AAL1 the label ends up in the acid and the alcohol carbon racemises (or rearranges) through the carbocation.
graph TD
A["Ester RCO-OR' hydrolysis"] --> B{"Where does the
alkoxy 18O end up?"}
B -- "in R'OH" --> C["Acyl-oxygen cleavage:
BAC2 / AAC2 / AAC1"]
B -- "in RCOOH" --> D["Alkyl-oxygen cleavage:
AAL1 (tertiary, acid)
or BAL2 (methyl, soft Nu)"]
C --> E["Chiral R' retains
configuration"]
D --> F["AAL1: R' racemises
or rearranges;
BAL2: R' inverts"]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Inversion of configuration (geometric) | Change of R/S label (depends on priorities) | |
| SNi (retention via tight ion pair, SOCl₂ alone) | NGP (retention via a cyclic intermediate from a neighbouring group) | |
| Common-ion effect (rate slows on adding X⁻): free cation | Special salt effect (LiClO₄ speeds up): solvent-separated ion pairs | |
| Acyl substitution: tetrahedral intermediate | SN2 at sp³ carbon: no intermediate | |
| AAL1 (alkyl–O cleavage, carbocation) | AAC2 (acyl–O cleavage, tetrahedral intermediate) | |
| SN2′ (attack at γ-carbon, one step) | SN1′ (allyl cation captured at either end) | |
| Neopentyl SN2: very slow, no rearrangement | Neopentyl SN1: rearranges to tertiary products |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the rate law for the reaction of CH₃Br with NaOH in aqueous acetone?
- Arrange in order of SN1 reactivity in aqueous ethanol: (CH₃)₃CBr, CH₃CH₂Br, (CH₃)₂CHBr.
- What is the stereochemical outcome of converting (R)-2-octanol to its chloride with SOCl₂ in the presence of pyridine?
Answers
- \( v = k[\mathrm{CH_3Br}][\mathrm{HO^-}] \) (SN2).
- (CH₃)₃CBr > (CH₃)₂CHBr > CH₃CH₂Br, following cation stability.
- Inversion: pyridine scavenges HCl and free chloride attacks from the back side, giving (S)-2-chlorooctane.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which substrate reacts fastest with NaI in acetone (SN2)?
(a) 1-chloro-2,2-dimethylpropane (b) 2-chloro-2-methylpropane (c) chloroacetone (ClCH₂COCH₃) (d) chlorobenzene
Answer: (c)
α-Halo ketones are strongly activated toward SN2: the C=O π system stabilises the transition state. (a) is neopentyl (very slow); (b) is tertiary (no SN2); (d) is aryl (inert).
Practice Q2. Optically pure (R)-2-bromooctane is hydrolysed in aqueous acetone. The 2-octanol formed has 60 % enantiomeric excess of the inverted configuration. If the reaction is a mixture of SN2 (clean inversion) and SN1 through a free cation (complete racemisation), the fraction proceeding by SN2 is:
(a) 30 % (b) 40 % (c) 60 % (d) 80 %
Answer: (c)
The racemising path contributes equal amounts of both enantiomers, so the ee equals the fraction that went by clean inversion: 60 % SN2, 40 % SN1. Option (d) is the percentage of the inverted enantiomer in the product (80 % inverted, 20 % retained), not the fraction of SN2.
Practice Q3. Which change will increase the rate of the Menshutkin reaction Et₃N + CH₃I → Et₃NCH₃⁺ I⁻ the most?
(a) changing solvent from hexane to acetonitrile (b) changing solvent from acetonitrile to hexane (c) replacing CH₃I by CH₃F (d) adding tetrabutylammonium iodide as a common ion
Answer: (a)
Two neutral reactants form ions: charge is created in the transition state, so a more polar solvent accelerates it strongly (Hughes–Ingold). (c) F⁻ is a very poor leaving group; (d) no common-ion effect exists in an SN2 reaction of this type.
Practice Q4. Optically active 2-bromopropanoate ion (CH₃CHBrCO₂⁻) is converted into 2-hydroxypropanoate (lactate) under two conditions: (I) concentrated NaOH; (II) Ag₂O in water (low [HO⁻]). The stereochemical outcomes are:
(a) I inversion, II retention (b) I retention, II inversion (c) both inversion (d) both racemisation
Answer: (a)
(I) Concentrated hydroxide attacks the C–Br carbon directly: SN2, inversion. (II) With low [HO⁻] and Ag⁺ assisting loss of Br⁻, the neighbouring carboxylate displaces bromide first (inversion, α-lactone), and water opens the α-lactone (second inversion): net retention.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. The solvolysis of a secondary alkyl tosylate in 70 % aqueous acetone at 25 °C is studied with added sodium azide. The pseudo-first-order rate constant follows \( k_{\text{obs}} = 2.0\times10^{-5} + 4.0\times10^{-4}[\mathrm{N_3^-}] \) s⁻¹. Which statements are correct?
- At \( [\mathrm{N_3^-}] = 0.10 \) M, two-thirds of the substrate reacts through the bimolecular path.
- The intercept measures the rate constant of the solvolysis (unimolecular or solvent-assisted) path.
- If the substrate were optically active, the alkyl azide formed by the bimolecular path would be racemic.
- Doubling [N₃⁻] from 0.10 to 0.20 M increases \( k_{\text{obs}} \) by a factor of about 1.67.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Bimolecular part \( 4.0\times10^{-4}\times0.10 = 4.0\times10^{-5} \); total \( 6.0\times10^{-5} \); fraction 0.667. Correct.
- With no azide, only the first term remains: the solvolysis constant. Correct.
- The bimolecular path is SN2 and gives inverted azide, not racemic. Wrong.
- At 0.20 M: \( 2.0\times10^{-5} + 8.0\times10^{-5} = 1.0\times10^{-4} \); ratio \( 1.0\times10^{-4}/6.0\times10^{-5} = 1.67 \). Correct.
Practice Q6. Consider the following observations for two diastereomeric 2-substituted cyclohexyl substrates.
- trans-2-Chlorocyclohexanol with aqueous NaOH gives cyclohexene oxide rapidly.
- cis-2-Chlorocyclohexanol under the same conditions reacts much more slowly and gives no epoxide.
Which statements are correct?
- In the trans isomer, the alkoxide and the chloride can be diaxial and anti-periplanar, allowing intramolecular backside displacement.
- Epoxide formation from the trans isomer is an example of neighbouring-group participation by oxygen.
- In the cis isomer the alkoxide and the chloride are never anti-periplanar in either chair, so intramolecular displacement (epoxide formation) is not possible.
- Both isomers react by intermolecular SN2 attack of HO⁻ at C–Cl.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- In the trans-diaxial conformer O⁻ sits anti to Cl. Correct.
- The internal oxygen nucleophile displaces chloride: participation (it gives the isolable cyclic product). Correct.
- In the cis isomer O⁻ can never be anti to Cl (one is axial, the other equatorial in each chair), so it cannot reach the back of C–Cl and no epoxide forms. Correct.
- The trans isomer gives the epoxide by intramolecular attack, not by intermolecular HO⁻ attack (which would give the diol). Wrong.
Practice Q7. An optically active ester of a chiral tertiary alcohol, R′CO–OR* (R* = the tertiary alkyl group), labelled with ¹⁸O in the alkoxy oxygen, is hydrolysed (I) with aqueous NaOH, slowly, and (II) with dilute aqueous H₂SO₄. Which statements are correct?
- In (I), the ¹⁸O label is found in the alcohol R*–OH, whose configuration is retained.
- In (II), the ¹⁸O label is found in the carboxylic acid, and R*–OH is largely racemised.
- (II) proceeds by the AAL1 mechanism.
- (I) proceeds by the BAL2 mechanism.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Base hydrolysis attacks the acyl carbon (BAC2); the R*–O bond is untouched, so the label stays with the alcohol and configuration is retained. Correct.
- A tertiary alkyl group ionises easily in acid: R*–O bond breaks, the label stays with the acid, and the planar cation captures water from either face. Correct.
- Acid, alkyl–oxygen cleavage, unimolecular rate-determining ionisation: AAL1. Correct.
- BAL2 is SN2 at the alkyl carbon, impossible at a tertiary centre; (I) is BAC2. Wrong.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| SN2 | \( k[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{Nu}] \); one step; backside; inversion; CH₃ > 1° > 2° |
| SN2 accelerated | allylic, benzylic, α-carbonyl; polar aprotic solvent |
| SN2 dead | 3°, neopentyl, vinyl, aryl, bridgehead |
| SN1 | \( k[\mathrm{RX}] \); carbocation; racemisation + excess inversion; rearrangement; 3° > 2° |
| Ion pairs | contact → solvent-separated → free (Winstein) |
| Salt effects | common-ion (slows, free R⁺); LiClO₄ special salt effect (speeds) |
| Mixed kinetics | \( k_{\text{obs}} = k_1 + k_2[\mathrm{Nu}] \) |
| Hughes–Ingold | charge created → polar solvent accelerates; charge destroyed → slows |
| SNi | SOCl₂ alone: retention; + pyridine: inversion; dioxane: retention |
| NGP | retention + rate acceleration; anti-periplanar group; phenonium, episulfonium, α-lactone |
| SN2′ | γ-attack with allylic shift |
| Acyl substitution | tetrahedral intermediate; ¹⁸O exchange evidence |
| Acyl ladder | RCOCl > (RCO)₂O > RCOSR > RCOOR ≈ RCOOH > RCONR₂ > RCOO⁻ |
| Ester hydrolysis | BAC2 usual; AAC2 usual acid; AAL1 tertiary in acid; AAC1 hindered in conc. H₂SO₄; BAL2 rare |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Aromatic Substitution: SNAr, benzyne and electrophilic substitution of arenes.
- Elimination Reactions: the E1/E2 competitors of SN1/SN2.
- Determination of Reaction Pathways: Grunwald–Winstein and Swain–Scott equations for these reactions.
- Organic Reaction Mechanisms: Quick Revision.