Carbanions: Acidity, Enolates, Ylides and Anionic Rearrangements
CSIR NET organic chemistry: carbanion structure, C–H acidity, kinetic vs thermodynamic enolates, ylides, E1cB, Favorskii, Stevens and Wittig rearrangements.
- 16 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Deuterium Where You Did Not Put It
- Structure
- Stability and C–H Acidity
- Generation
- Enolates
- Ylides
- Elimination Through a Carbanion: E1cB
- Carbanion Rearrangements
- Evidence That a Carbanion Has Formed
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Carbocations: many arguments here are the mirror image of cation stability.
- Acid–Base Concepts and Acid–Base Strength: a carbanion is a conjugate base, so its stability is read from pKa.
- HSAB Concept: explains C- versus O-alkylation of enolates.
- Hückel Theory of Conjugated Systems: why the cyclopentadienide anion is aromatic.
The Hook: Deuterium Where You Did Not Put It
Structure
A carbanion has a carbon bearing an unshared electron pair and a negative charge, with eight valence electrons.
| Type | Geometry | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Simple alkyl carbanion (CH₃⁻, R₃C⁻) | pyramidal, roughly sp³, lone pair in an orbital with s character | inverts rapidly, like an amine; a chiral carbanion usually racemises |
| Resonance-stabilised (allyl, benzyl, enolate, nitronate) | planar, sp², lone pair in a p orbital | delocalised charge; reacts at more than one site (ambident) |
| Cyclopropyl carbanion | pyramidal, inversion strongly hindered by ring strain | can retain configuration |
| Vinyl carbanion | sp², lone pair in an sp² orbital | configurationally fairly stable; vinyllithiums keep E/Z geometry at low temperature |
| Acetylide | sp, lone pair in an sp orbital | linear; most stable of the hydrocarbon anions |
Real carbanions in solution are usually ion pairs or aggregates with Li⁺, Na⁺, K⁺ or MgX⁺. Organolithiums and Grignard reagents are best regarded as carbanion equivalents with polar C–metal bonds. Solvents and additives that bind the cation (THF, TMEDA, HMPA, crown ethers) make the carbanion more reactive.
Stability and C–H Acidity
Carbanion stability is measured by the pKa of the conjugate acid R–H: the lower the pKa, the more stable the carbanion.
What stabilises a carbanion
| Factor | Effect | Example |
|---|---|---|
| s character of the lone-pair orbital | sp > sp² > sp³ | HC≡CH (pKa about 25) far more acidic than CH₂=CH₂ or CH₃CH₃ |
| Resonance into C=O, C=N, NO₂, CN, SO₂R | charge moves onto electronegative atoms | acetone, nitromethane, malonates |
| Aromaticity | 6π anion formed | cyclopentadiene (pKa about 16) |
| Inductive (−I) groups | stabilise the charge through σ bonds | CF₃, R₃N⁺ |
| Second-row and heavier heteroatoms (S, P, Si) on the carbanion carbon | polarisability and negative hyperconjugation into σ*(C–S), σ*(C–P), σ*(C–Si) | 1,3-dithiane anion, phosphorus and sulfur ylides, α-silyl carbanions |
| Positive neighbour | ylides (adjacent onium centre) | Ph₃P⁺–CH₂⁻, Me₂S⁺–CH₂⁻ |
What destabilises:
| Factor | Example |
|---|---|
| Alkyl groups (electron releasing) | CH₃⁻ > RCH₂⁻ > R₂CH⁻ > R₃C⁻ in stability: the opposite of cations |
| Antiaromaticity | cycloheptatrienyl anion (8π) |
| Lone pairs directly on the carbanion carbon’s neighbour (α-O, α-N) | lone-pair repulsion offsets their −I effect |
An approximate C–H acidity ladder
Values are rounded and approximate; they differ between aqueous-extrapolated and DMSO scales, so use them only for ordering.
| Compound | Approx. pKa | Carbanion stabilised by |
|---|---|---|
| CH₄, CH₃CH₃ | about 50 | nothing |
| C₆H₆, CH₂=CH₂ | about 43–44 | sp² |
| PhCH₃ | about 41 | benzylic resonance |
| Ph₃CH | about 31–32 | three rings |
| HC≡CH | about 25 | sp |
| CH₃CO₂Et | about 25 | ester enolate |
| CH₃COCH₃ | about 19–20 | ketone enolate |
| Cyclopentadiene | about 16 | aromatic 6π anion |
| CH₂(CO₂Et)₂ | about 13 | two esters |
| CH₃NO₂ | about 10 | nitronate |
| CH₃COCH₂COCH₃ | about 9 | two ketones |
Generation
graph LR
A["C-H deprotonation
LDA, NaH, BuLi, NaNH2, RO-"] --> C["Carbanion or
carbanion equivalent"]
B["Metal-halogen exchange
ArBr + BuLi"] --> C
D["Metal insertion
RX + Mg or Li"] --> C
E["Conjugate addition
Nu- + enone"] --> C
F["Decarboxylation
Cl3C-CO2- loses CO2"] --> C
G["Shapiro
tosylhydrazone + 2 BuLi"] --> C| Method | Example | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Deprotonation | ketone + LDA, THF, −78 °C | strong, hindered, non-nucleophilic base |
| Metal–halogen exchange | ArBr + n-BuLi → ArLi + n-BuBr | fast, at low temperature |
| Direct metallation | RBr + Mg → RMgBr; RCl + 2 Li → RLi + LiCl | Grignard and organolithium reagents |
| Directed ortho-metallation | anisole or an aryl amide + BuLi | coordination of Li to the directing group guides deprotonation at the ortho position |
| Conjugate addition | R₂CuLi + enone → enolate | the enolate can be trapped by an electrophile |
| Decarboxylation | trichloroacetate → CCl₃⁻ + CO₂ | CCl₃⁻ can lose Cl⁻ to give dichlorocarbene |
| Shapiro reaction | ketone tosylhydrazone + 2 RLi → vinyllithium + N₂ + ArSO₂⁻ | dianion route to a vinyl carbanion |
Enolates
Kinetic versus thermodynamic enolates
An unsymmetrical ketone such as 2-methylcyclohexanone can give two enolates.
| Kinetic enolate | Thermodynamic enolate | |
|---|---|---|
| Which α-H is removed | the less hindered (more accessible, often more numerous) one | either; equilibration follows |
| Double bond | less substituted | more substituted |
| Conditions | strong, bulky base (LDA), aprotic solvent, low temperature (−78 °C), base in slight excess, short time | weaker base or a slight excess of ketone, protic solvent or higher temperature, longer time |
| Why | rate of deprotonation decides; no equilibration | stability (more substituted alkene) decides |
| 2-Methylcyclohexanone | deprotonation at C6 | double bond between C1 and C2 (toward the methyl-bearing carbon) |
Equilibration requires a proton source (excess ketone, or protic solvent) that can reprotonate the enolate.
Ambident reactivity: C versus O
An enolate has negative charge on both carbon and oxygen.
| Favours C-alkylation | Favours O-alkylation |
|---|---|
| soft electrophiles (CH₃I, allyl and benzyl bromides) | hard electrophiles (R₃SiCl, Me₂SO₄, alkyl triflates, acyl chlorides) |
| tight ion pairs, Li⁺ counterion, less polar solvents | free enolate: K⁺, crown ether, HMPA, DMSO |
| product C–C bond is thermodynamically favoured | charge-controlled attack at the more electronegative atom |
Silyl enol ethers (from O-silylation) are isolable, regiochemically defined enolate equivalents.
Reactions of enolates and other stabilised carbanions
| Reaction | Carbanion + electrophile | Product |
|---|---|---|
| Alkylation | enolate + RX (SN2) | α-alkyl carbonyl compound |
| Aldol | enolate + aldehyde/ketone | β-hydroxy carbonyl, then enone by E1cB dehydration |
| Claisen / Dieckmann | ester enolate + ester | β-keto ester (driven by deprotonation of the product) |
| Michael | stabilised carbanion + α,β-unsaturated acceptor | 1,5-dicarbonyl |
| Robinson annulation | Michael then intramolecular aldol | cyclohexenone |
| Knoevenagel | active methylene + aldehyde, weak amine base | alkylidene malonate or similar |
| Henry (nitroaldol) | nitronate + aldehyde | β-nitro alcohol |
| Darzens | α-halo ester enolate + ketone | glycidic ester (epoxide) |
| Haloform | methyl ketone + X₂/OH⁻ | carboxylate + CHX₃ |
| Corey–Seebach (umpolung) | 2-lithio-1,3-dithiane + RX, then hydrolysis | ketone: the dithiane anion is an acyl anion equivalent |
Ylides
An ylide has a carbanion directly bonded to a positively charged heteroatom.
| Ylide | Typical reaction with C=O | Product |
|---|---|---|
| Phosphorus ylide Ph₃P⁺–C⁻HR | Wittig: via oxaphosphetane; driving force is the strong P=O bond of Ph₃P=O | alkene |
| Dimethylsulfonium methylide, Me₂S⁺–CH₂⁻ | Corey–Chaykovsky: addition, then intramolecular displacement of Me₂S | epoxide |
| Dimethylsulfoxonium methylide, Me₂S⁺(O)–CH₂⁻ | with enones, conjugate (1,4) addition | cyclopropyl ketone |
| Ammonium ylide R₃N⁺–C⁻HR | Stevens or Sommelet–Hauser rearrangement | rearranged amine |
Wittig stereochemistry: non-stabilised ylides (R = alkyl) give mainly Z-alkenes under salt-free conditions; stabilised ylides (R = CO₂Et, COR) give mainly E-alkenes. The Horner–Wadsworth–Emmons reaction (phosphonate carbanion) gives mainly E-alkenes and a water-soluble phosphate by-product.
Elimination Through a Carbanion: E1cB
$$\text{H–C}_\beta\text{–C}_\alpha\text{–X} \xrightarrow{\ \text{B}^-\ } {}^{-}\text{C}_\beta\text{–C}_\alpha\text{–X} \longrightarrow \text{C}_\beta{=}\text{C}_\alpha + \text{X}^-$$The proton is removed first, forming a carbanion (the conjugate base of the substrate), which then expels the leaving group. Conditions that favour E1cB: an acidic β-H (next to C=O, NO₂, SO₂R, CN) and a poor leaving group (OH, OR, OAr).
| Variant | Slow step | Diagnostic |
|---|---|---|
| (E1cB)R, reversible | loss of X⁻ from the carbanion | substrate exchanges H for D from the solvent faster than it eliminates; no primary KIE on elimination |
| (E1cB)irr | deprotonation | primary kinetic isotope effect; no exchange |
| E2 (for comparison) | concerted | primary KIE and leaving-group effect together; no exchange |
Dehydration of aldol products under base is the commonest E1cB in synthesis.
Carbanion Rearrangements
| Rearrangement | Substrate + base | Key intermediate | Product |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favorskii | α-haloketone with an α′-H + RO⁻ or OH⁻ | cyclopropanone | ester or acid; cyclic ketones ring-contract (2-chlorocyclohexanone → methyl cyclopentanecarboxylate) |
| Quasi-Favorskii (semibenzilic) | α-haloketone with no α′-H | tetrahedral alkoxide; 1,2-shift with loss of X⁻ | ester or acid |
| Stevens [1,2] | quaternary ammonium (or sulfonium) salt + strong base | ylide; radical-pair recombination | tertiary amine with group moved from N to C |
| Sommelet–Hauser [2,3] | benzyltrialkylammonium + NaNH₂ | ylide; [2,3]-sigmatropic shift into the ring | ortho-alkylated benzylamine |
| [1,2]-Wittig | ether R–O–CH₂R′ + BuLi | α-alkoxy carbanion; radical pair | alcohol R′CH(R)–OH; migration order follows radical stability (3° > 2° > 1° > Me) |
| [2,3]-Wittig | allyl ether carbanion, low temperature | concerted [2,3]-sigmatropic shift | homoallylic alcohol |
| Brook | α-silyl alkoxide | silyl moves from C to O | silyl ether and carbanion (driven by the strong Si–O bond) |
| Benzilic acid | 1,2-diketone + OH⁻ | tetrahedral alkoxide | α-hydroxy acid (aryl migrates as an anion-driven 1,2-shift) |
Evidence That a Carbanion Has Formed
- H/D exchange at carbon in a deuterated protic solvent with base.
- Racemisation at a stereocentre bearing the acidic H, at a rate comparable with exchange.
- Trapping with electrophiles (D₂O, MeI, Me₃SiCl, CO₂).
- Kinetics consistent with pre-equilibrium deprotonation (E1cB)R.
- Spectroscopy of stabilised anions: NMR of enolates and organolithiums at low temperature; colour of highly conjugated anions (the trityl anion is deep red).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Kinetic enolate: less substituted, LDA, −78 °C | Thermodynamic enolate: more substituted, equilibrating conditions | |
| Sulfonium ylide Me₂S⁺CH₂⁻ + enone → epoxide (1,2) | Sulfoxonium ylide Me₂S(O)⁺CH₂⁻ + enone → cyclopropane (1,4) | |
| Stevens: [1,2]-shift, ammonium ylide | Sommelet–Hauser: [2,3]-shift into a benzyl ring, ortho product | |
| [1,2]-Wittig: radical pair | [2,3]-Wittig: concerted, allyl ethers | |
| Wittig rearrangement (ether → alcohol) | Wittig reaction (ylide + C=O → alkene) | |
| Cyclopentadienide: 6π, aromatic | Cycloheptatrienide: 8π, antiaromatic | |
| (E1cB)R: exchange faster than elimination | (E1cB)irr: deprotonation slow, primary KIE, no exchange |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which is more stable: the methyl anion or the tert-butyl anion?
- Why is cyclopentadiene much more acidic than cyclopentane?
- Name the intermediate of the Favorskii rearrangement.
Answers
- CH₃⁻: alkyl groups are electron-releasing and destabilise a negative charge.
- Its conjugate base, cyclopentadienide, is aromatic (6π, planar, cyclic).
- A cyclopropanone.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The correct order of C–H acidity is:
(a) CH₂(COCH₃)₂ > CH₃COCH₃ > HC≡CH > CH₂=CH₂ (b) CH₃COCH₃ > CH₂(COCH₃)₂ > HC≡CH > CH₂=CH₂ (c) HC≡CH > CH₂(COCH₃)₂ > CH₃COCH₃ > CH₂=CH₂ (d) CH₂(COCH₃)₂ > HC≡CH > CH₃COCH₃ > CH₂=CH₂
Answer: (a)
Two carbonyls (pKa about 9) > one carbonyl (about 19–20) > sp C–H (about 25) > sp² C–H (about 44).
Practice Q2. 2-Methylcyclohexanone is treated with LDA in THF at −78 °C, followed by CH₃I. The major product is:
(a) 2,2-dimethylcyclohexanone (b) 2,6-dimethylcyclohexanone (c) 3-methylcyclohexanone (d) 2-methoxy-1-methylcyclohexene
Answer: (b)
LDA at −78 °C forms the kinetic enolate by removing a proton from the less substituted α-carbon, C6. Methylation at C6 gives 2,6-dimethylcyclohexanone. Equilibrating conditions would favour the more substituted enolate and 2,2-dimethylcyclohexanone. CH₃I is a soft electrophile, so C-alkylation dominates over O-alkylation.
Practice Q3. Treatment of 2-chlorocyclohexanone with sodium methoxide in methanol gives mainly:
(a) 2-methoxycyclohexanone (b) cyclohex-2-en-1-one (c) methyl cyclopentanecarboxylate (d) methyl cyclohexanecarboxylate
Answer: (c)
Favorskii rearrangement. Methoxide removes the α′-H, the enolate displaces chloride intramolecularly to form a bicyclic cyclopropanone, methoxide adds to the carbonyl, and the three-membered ring opens to the carbanion, which is protonated. The ring contracts by one carbon.
Practice Q4. Benzyltrimethylammonium iodide is treated with NaNH₂ in liquid ammonia. The major product is:
(a) N,N-dimethylbenzylamine (b) N,N-dimethyl-1-phenylethan-1-amine (c) N,N-dimethyl-2-methylbenzylamine (d) toluene and trimethylamine
Answer: (c)
Sommelet–Hauser rearrangement. Under these conditions the methyl ylide Me₂N⁺(CH₂⁻)CH₂Ph (in equilibrium with the benzylic ylide) undergoes a [2,3]-sigmatropic shift into the ortho position of the ring; rearomatisation by a proton shift gives the ortho-methyl benzylamine, 2-CH₃C₆H₄CH₂NMe₂. Option (b) is the Stevens [1,2] product, which competes under other conditions (for example, at higher temperature).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Acetone (take pKa = 19) is mixed with an equimolar amount of sodium ethoxide in ethanol (take pKa of EtOH = 16). In a separate experiment, acetone is treated with 1.05 equivalents of LDA (take pKa of diisopropylamine = 36). Ignoring activity effects and side reactions, which statements are correct?
- With ethoxide, the equilibrium constant for enolate formation is 10⁻³.
- With ethoxide, about 3% of the acetone is present as enolate at equilibrium.
- With LDA, the equilibrium constant is about 10¹⁷, so enolate formation is essentially complete.
- Aldol condensation is impossible with ethoxide because so little enolate is present.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. \( K = 10^{16 - 19} = 10^{-3} \).
- Correct. Starting from equal amounts, let x be the fraction converted: \( x^2/(1 - x)^2 = 10^{-3} \), so \( x/(1 - x) = 0.0316 \) and \( x = 0.031 \): about 3%.
- Correct. \( K = 10^{36 - 19} = 10^{17} \).
- Wrong. A small equilibrium concentration of enolate is enough: it reacts with the abundant ketone, and the enolate is replenished. This is exactly how base-catalysed aldol reactions run.
Practice Q6. The compound PhSO₂CH₂CH₂OPh is treated with NaOD in D₂O/dioxane. Recovered starting material, taken after 10% conversion to phenyl vinyl sulfone, contains PhSO₂CD₂CH₂OPh in substantial amount. The elimination rate shows no primary kinetic isotope effect when the CH₂ next to sulfur is deuterated. Which statements are correct?
- The mechanism is E1cB with reversible carbanion formation.
- Loss of phenoxide from the carbanion is rate-determining.
- A concerted E2 mechanism fits the data equally well.
- The sulfonyl group makes the β-H acidic and stabilises the carbanion.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
1 and 2. Correct. Deuterium enters the starting material faster than it eliminates, so the α-sulfonyl carbanion forms and is reprotonated many times before phenoxide leaves: (E1cB)R. With deprotonation fast and reversible, the slow step is loss of PhO⁻, so there is no primary KIE. 3. Wrong. In E2 the C–H bond breaks in the rate-determining step (primary KIE expected) and no carbanion lives long enough to exchange with solvent. 4. Correct. The PhSO₂ group stabilises the adjacent negative charge; phenoxide is a poor enough leaving group to let the carbanion form first.
Practice Q7. A Favorskii experiment uses 1-chloro-3-phenylpropan-2-one, PhCH₂COCH₂Cl, with the carbonyl carbon enriched in ¹³C, and sodium methoxide. Which statements are correct?
- The cyclopropanone intermediate is 2-phenylcyclopropan-1-one with the label at its carbonyl carbon.
- Ring opening occurs mainly to give the benzylic carbanion.
- The major product is methyl 3-phenylpropanoate, PhCH₂CH₂CO₂Me, with the label in the ester carbonyl carbon.
- The major product is methyl 2-phenylpropanoate.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 3 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. Deprotonation at the benzylic CH₂ (more acidic) and intramolecular displacement of Cl⁻ give 2-phenylcyclopropanone; the old carbonyl carbon stays as the carbonyl of the three-membered ring.
- Correct. After methoxide adds to the C=O, the ring breaks to give the more stable carbanion: the one on the carbon bearing phenyl (benzylic).
- Correct. Cleaving the C(O)–CHPh bond leaves MeO₂C–CH₂–CH⁻Ph, which is protonated to PhCH₂CH₂CO₂Me. The labelled carbon becomes the ester carbonyl.
- Wrong. Methyl 2-phenylpropanoate would require cleavage to the primary carbanion, which is less stable.
Quick Revision Table
| Point | Fact |
|---|---|
| Structure | simple: pyramidal, inverts; delocalised: planar; cyclopropyl and vinyl hold configuration |
| Stability order | CH₃⁻ > 1° > 2° > 3°; sp > sp² > sp³; resonance, aromaticity, −I, α-S/P/Si stabilise |
| Acidity ladder | alkane ~50 > arene ~43 > toluene ~41 > Ph₃CH ~31 > alkyne ~25 > ketone ~19–20 > Cp-H ~16 > malonate ~13 > MeNO₂ ~10 > acac ~9 (pKa, approximate) |
| K for deprotonation | \( 10^{\text{p}K_a(\text{HB}) - \text{p}K_a(\text{HA})} \) |
| Kinetic enolate | LDA, −78 °C, less substituted |
| Thermodynamic enolate | equilibrating, more substituted |
| C vs O | soft → C; hard → O |
| Ylides | P: Wittig alkene; S: epoxide; S(O): cyclopropane with enones |
| E1cB | carbanion first; (E1cB)R shows exchange |
| Rearrangements | Favorskii (cyclopropanone), Stevens [1,2], Sommelet–Hauser [2,3], Wittig [1,2]/[2,3], Brook |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Free Radicals: the one-electron intermediates between carbocations and carbanions.
- Carbanions that lose a halide become carbenes: see Carbenes for dichlorocarbene from chloroform.
- Aryl carbanions that lose a halide give Benzynes.
- Back to the chapter overview.