Skip to content

Carbocations: Structure, Stability and Rearrangements

CSIR NET organic chemistry: carbocation structure, stability, non-classical ions, neighbouring-group participation, 1,2-shifts and pinacol-type rearrangements.

  • 19 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Neopentyl Halide That Will Not Stay Put
  3. What a Carbocation Is
  4. Generation
  5. Stability
  6. Fates of a Carbocation
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: A Neopentyl Halide That Will Not Stay Put

What a Carbocation Is

A carbocation is a species with a positively charged carbon. Olah’s nomenclature, now standard, separates two kinds:

TermCarbonBondingExample
Carbenium ion (classical)tricoordinate, six valence electronsthree 2c–2e bonds and an empty p orbital(CH₃)₃C⁺
Carbonium ion (non-classical)penta- or tetracoordinateincludes a three-centre two-electron (3c–2e) bondCH₅⁺, the 2-norbornyl cation

Most textbook “carbocations” are carbenium ions.

Shape

  • The cationic carbon is sp² hybridised and trigonal planar; the empty orbital is an unhybridised p orbital perpendicular to the plane.
  • Planarity maximises s character in the three σ bonds and keeps the empty orbital as high in energy as possible (so it does not “waste” s character).
  • Consequence: a nucleophile can attack either face. A carbocation formed at a stereocentre gives a racemic or partly racemised product. Partial inversion is common in practice because the leaving group still shields one face (an ion pair).

Bridgehead cations

A cation that cannot flatten is strongly destabilised. 1-Bromo- and 1-chloronorbornanes (bridgehead of bicyclo[2.2.1]heptane) are almost inert in SN1 reactions. The larger, more flexible 1-adamantyl system ionises readily, which is why 1-adamantyl derivatives are standard SN1 substrates.

Generation

graph LR
    A["R-X, R-OTs
ionisation (SN1, E1)"] --> C["R+"] B["R-OH + H+
loss of H2O"] --> C D["alkene + H+
or E+"] --> C E["R-NH2 + HNO2
R-N2+ loses N2"] --> C F["R-Cl + AlCl3
Lewis acid"] --> C G["alkane + superacid
or Ph3C+ hydride abstraction"] --> C
RouteExampleComment
Heterolysis of R–Xt-BuBr in aqueous ethanolneeds a good leaving group and an ionising solvent
Protonated alcohols, etherst-BuOH + H₂SO₄the leaving group is water
Protonation of alkenes(CH₃)₂C=CH₂ + H⁺ → (CH₃)₃C⁺Markovnikov orientation: the more stable cation forms
Diazotisation of primary aliphatic aminesRCH₂NH₂ + HNO₂ → RCH₂N₂⁺ → RCH₂⁺ + N₂N₂ is an excellent leaving group; “hot”, poorly solvated cations rearrange extensively
Lewis acidsRCl + AlCl₃ → R⁺ [AlCl₄]⁻; RCOCl + AlCl₃ → RC≡O⁺Friedel–Crafts alkylation and acylation
Superacids(CH₃)₃CH in FSO₃H–SbF₅ → (CH₃)₃C⁺ + H₂stable, long-lived cations at low temperature
Hydride abstractioncycloheptatriene + Ph₃C⁺BF₄⁻ → C₇H₇⁺BF₄⁻ + Ph₃CHtropylium salts

Stable carbocations in superacid

George Olah showed that alkyl cations become long-lived in superacids (for example “magic acid”, FSO₃H–SbF₅, in SO₂ or SO₂ClF at low temperature) and recorded their NMR spectra. He received the 1994 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for this work. In the ¹³C NMR spectrum, the cationic carbon of the tert-butyl cation lies far downfield (beyond δ 300), much further than any neutral sp² carbon, which is direct evidence of a large positive charge on carbon.

Stability

Every stabilising effect does one thing: it puts electron density into the empty p orbital or spreads the positive charge.

The order to remember

$$\text{CH}_3^+ < 1^\circ < 2^\circ < 3^\circ$$

Vinyl and aryl cations are less stable than even primary alkyl cations. Primary allyl and benzyl cations are roughly comparable with secondary alkyl cations, and tertiary allyl or benzyl cations are better than simple tertiary ones.

The effects, one by one

EffectHow it worksExamples
Hyperconjugationadjacent C–H or C–C σ bonds aligned with the empty p orbital donate into it3° > 2° > 1°: more α C–H bonds; explains the β-silicon effect too
Inductive (+I)alkyl groups are weak σ donors relative to Hminor next to hyperconjugation
Resonance with π systemsallyl, benzyl: charge delocalised over 2 or more carbonsPh₃C⁺ (trityl) is so stabilised that its salts are isolable
Lone-pair donation (+M) from α-heteroatomsO, N, S donate a lone pair into the empty p orbitalCH₃OCH₂⁺ ↔ CH₃O⁺=CH₂ (oxocarbenium); iminium; acylium RC≡O⁺
Aromaticitycyclic, planar, \( 4n + 2 \) π electronscyclopropenium (2π), tropylium (6π)
Cyclopropyl conjugationthe bent (Walsh) C–C bonds of cyclopropane overlap with the p orbital in the bisected conformationcyclopropylmethyl cations are unusually stable
β-silicon effecta C–Si σ bond anti-periplanar to the empty orbital is a strong hyperconjugative donorallylsilane and vinylsilane chemistry

Destabilising groups:

GroupWhy
α-C=O, α-CN, α-CF₃, α-NO₂−I (and for C=O, the carbonyl carbon is itself δ⁺)
sp-hybridised or sp² positive carbonvinyl (linear, sp) and phenyl cations (empty sp² orbital in the ring plane, orthogonal to the π system, so no resonance)
antiaromatic arrangementcyclopentadienyl cation (4π) is extremely unstable
enforced non-planaritybridgehead cations in small bicycles

Aromatic and antiaromatic ring cations

Cationπ electronsStatus
Cyclopropenium, C₃H₃⁺2aromatic; triphenylcyclopropenium salts are isolable
Cyclopentadienyl, C₅H₅⁺4antiaromatic; extremely unstable
Tropylium (cycloheptatrienyl), C₇H₇⁺6aromatic; tropylium bromide is an ionic, water-soluble solid
Homotropylium, C₈H₉⁺6homoaromatic: one sp³ CH₂ interrupts the ring, but the π system still closes over it

Measuring cation stability: pKR⁺

For aryl-stabilised cations, stability in solution is expressed by pKR⁺, defined from the equilibrium

$$\text{R}^+ + 2\,\text{H}_2\text{O} \rightleftharpoons \text{ROH} + \text{H}_3\text{O}^+ \qquad K_{R^+} = \frac{a_{\text{ROH}}\,a_{\text{H}_3\text{O}^+}}{a_{\text{R}^+}}$$

A higher pKR⁺ means a more stable cation (it survives to higher pH). The tropylium ion has a positive pKR⁺ (it exists in neutral water), while the trityl cation has a negative pKR⁺ (it needs strongly acidic solution). Tri(p-methoxyphenyl)methyl cation is much more stable than trityl: each p-OMe donates by resonance.

Hammett σ⁺: a Part C favourite

For reactions in which positive charge develops in conjugation with a ring (benzylic or cumyl solvolysis, electrophilic aromatic substitution), Brown and Okamoto defined σ⁺ constants:

$$\log\frac{k_X}{k_H} = \rho\,\sigma^+$$
  • A large negative ρ means positive charge builds up in the transition state: evidence for a carbocation-like rate-determining step.
  • p-OMe and p-NMe₂ have large negative σ⁺ (strong resonance donors); p-NO₂ and p-CF₃ have positive σ⁺.
  • For SN2 or radical reactions |ρ| is usually small.

Fates of a Carbocation

graph TD
    R["Carbocation R+"] --> N["Capture by nucleophile
(SN1, alkene addition)"] R --> E["Loss of beta-H+
(E1; Zaitsev alkene)"] R --> S["1,2-shift of H, alkyl or aryl
(more stable cation)"] R --> A["Addition to a pi bond
(cationic polymerisation,
Friedel-Crafts, Prins, cyclisation)"] R --> H["Hydride abstraction
from another molecule"] R --> F["Fragmentation
(Grob)"] S --> N S --> E

1,2-Shifts (Wagner–Meerwein rearrangements)

A group on the carbon next to the cationic centre migrates with its bonding electron pair to the cationic carbon. The new cation sits where the group came from.

$$\text{R}_2\overset{\text{R'}}{\text{C}}{-}\overset{+}{\text{C}}\text{R}_2 \longrightarrow \text{R}_2\overset{+}{\text{C}}{-}\text{C}\text{R}_2\text{R'}$$

Rules for predicting shifts:

  1. A shift happens when it gives a more stable cation (1° → 3°, 2° → 3°, 2° → resonance-stabilised or α-oxygen stabilised), or relieves ring strain (cyclobutylmethyl → cyclopentyl).
  2. The migrating group moves suprafacially, staying on the same face; the migration terminus is attacked from the side opposite to the departing group when the shift is concerted with ionisation.
  3. The best-aligned group (anti-periplanar to the leaving group) migrates in rigid systems; stereoelectronics can override intrinsic migratory aptitude.
  4. Typical migratory aptitude in cationic 1,2-shifts: aryl (electron-rich first) > alkyl, and among alkyls tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl. Hydride shifts are fast and frequent; the H position in the series depends on the system.

Classic examples:

Substrate and conditionsWhat movesProduct
Neopentyl bromide, solvolysisCH₃ (1° → 3°)2-methylbutan-2-ol, 2-methylbut-2-ene
3,3-Dimethylbutan-2-ol + HBrCH₃ (2° → 3°)2-bromo-2,3-dimethylbutane
3-Methylbutan-2-ol + HBrH (2° → 3°)2-bromo-2-methylbutane
Isoborneol + acidring C–C bond (Wagner–Meerwein)camphene
Cyclobutylmethanol + acidring bond (ring expansion)cyclopentyl products

Pinacol and semipinacol rearrangements

Pinacol rearrangement: a 1,2-diol in acid gives a ketone or aldehyde.

$$(\text{CH}_3)_2\text{C(OH)}{-}\text{C(OH)}(\text{CH}_3)_2 \xrightarrow{\text{H}_2\text{SO}_4} (\text{CH}_3)_3\text{C}{-}\text{CO}{-}\text{CH}_3 + \text{H}_2\text{O}$$

Pinacol gives pinacolone (3,3-dimethylbutan-2-one). Steps: protonate one OH, lose water to form the cation, shift a group from the neighbouring carbon, and lose H⁺ from the resulting oxocarbenium ion. The driving force is the conversion of a tertiary carbocation into a much more stable protonated carbonyl (oxocarbenium) ion.

For an unsymmetrical diol, do two things in order:

  1. Which OH leaves? The one that leaves behind the more stable cation.
  2. Which group moves? From the other carbon, the group of higher migratory aptitude (aryl, especially p-anisyl, ahead of alkyl), subject to stereoelectronic alignment in rings.

Worked example: Ph₂C(OH)–C(OH)(CH₃)₂. The diphenylmethyl cation (benzylic twice) forms rather than the tertiary alkyl cation; a methyl then migrates from the other carbon to give Ph₂C(CH₃)–CO–CH₃ (3,3-diphenylbutan-2-one).

Semipinacol-type relatives:

ReactionSubstrateCation formed byProduct
Tiffeneau–Demjanov1-(aminomethyl)cycloalkanol + HNO₂loss of N₂ from the diazoniumring-expanded cycloalkanone (cyclohexane → cycloheptanone)
Demjanov(aminomethyl)cycloalkane + HNO₂loss of N₂ring-expanded alcohols, with mixtures
Epoxide rearrangement (Meinwald)epoxide + Lewis acidC–O ionisationaldehyde or ketone
Dienone–phenolcross-conjugated cyclohexadienone + acidprotonation of C=Ophenol after 1,2-shift

Neighbouring-group participation (anchimeric assistance)

A group within the molecule that has electrons to share (lone pair, π bond, aryl ring, or a σ bond) can push out the leaving group intramolecularly. Signatures:

  1. Rate acceleration compared with a model compound that lacks the group.
  2. Retention of configuration (two inversions: the internal displacement and then external attack on the bridged ion).
  3. Rearranged or scrambled products when the bridged ion can open at two carbons.
Participating groupBridged intermediateExample
S lone pairepisulfonium (thiiranium)ClCH₂CH₂SR hydrolyses far faster than a simple primary chloride (sulfur mustards)
O⁻, OR, OAcepoxide, oxonium, acetoxoniumtrans-2-acetoxycyclohexyl tosylate solvolyses faster than the cis isomer and gives trans product
Arylphenonium ion (spiro-cyclopropane arenium)Cram’s 3-phenyl-2-butyl tosylates
C=C π bondnon-classical cationanti-7-norbornenyl tosylate reacts very much faster than 7-norbornyl tosylate, with retention
C–C σ bondnon-classical cationexo-2-norbornyl sulfonates

The 2-norbornyl cation: non-classical ions

Solvolysis of exo-2-norbornyl sulfonates is several hundred times faster than that of the endo isomers; both give only exo products; and optically active exo substrate gives racemic exo product. Winstein explained this with a σ-bridged, non-classical cation: the C1–C6 bond, anti-periplanar to the exo leaving group, participates, and the resulting ion (with a 3c–2e bond over C1, C2 and C6) has a mirror plane. H. C. Brown argued for a rapidly equilibrating pair of classical ions instead. Low-temperature NMR in superacid (Olah and others) and, later, a crystal structure of a 2-norbornyl cation salt supported the symmetrical bridged structure.

The cyclopropylmethyl / cyclobutyl / homoallyl cation system is another non-classical family: these three cations interconvert so easily that solvolysis of any one gives a mixture of cyclopropylmethyl, cyclobutyl and homoallyl products.

Other carbocation reactions you should recognise

ReactionCationOutcome
E1anyZaitsev alkene (more substituted), with rearranged alkenes possible
Friedel–Crafts alkylationfrom RX + AlCl₃rearranged alkyl groups (n-propyl chloride gives mainly isopropylbenzene)
Ritter reactionR⁺ from alkene or alcohol + H₂SO₄, captured by R’C≡NN-alkyl amide after hydrolysis of the nitrilium ion
Prins reactionprotonated aldehyde adds to an alkene1,3-diols, dioxanes or allylic alcohols
Cationic polymerisationisobutylene + Lewis acid/H₂Opolyisobutylene
Cation–olefin cyclisationpolyene + acidpolycyclic terpenoid skeletons (as in steroid biosynthesis)
Grob fragmentationγ-amino or γ-hydroxy cation precursor with anti-periplanar alignmentalkene + iminium or carbonyl
Hydride transferR⁺ + R’H → RH + R’⁺equilibrates cations; used in superacid chemistry

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Carbenium ion: tricoordinate, 6 e⁻, classicalCarbonium ion: penta/tetracoordinate, 3c–2e bond, non-classical
Benzyl cation: empty p orbital conjugated with ringPhenyl cation: empty sp² orbital orthogonal to ring π
Tropylium C₇H₇⁺: 6π, aromatic, stableCyclopentadienyl C₅H₅⁺: 4π, antiaromatic
Cyclopentadienyl anion: aromaticCyclopentadienyl cation: antiaromatic
Pinacol: diol → ketone, cation firstBenzilic acid rearrangement: 1,2-diketone + OH⁻ → α-hydroxy acid, anionic
Wagner–Meerwein: shift in a carbocationWittig or Stevens rearrangement: shift in a carbanion or ylide
SN1 at a stereocentre: racemisation (+ some inversion)NGP: retention

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. What is the hybridisation and geometry of the cationic carbon in the tert-butyl cation?
  2. How many π electrons does the tropylium ion have, and is it aromatic?
  3. Name the product of acid-catalysed rearrangement of pinacol.
Answers
  1. sp², trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital perpendicular to the plane.
  2. 6 π electrons over seven carbons in a planar ring: aromatic (\( 4n + 2 \), n = 1).
  3. Pinacolone, 3,3-dimethylbutan-2-one.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. The correct order of stability of the following cations is:

P: CH₃OCH₂⁺ Q: CH₃CH₂⁺ R: CF₃CH₂⁺ S: (CH₃)₃C⁺

(a) P > S > Q > R (b) S > P > Q > R (c) S > Q > P > R (d) P > Q > S > R

Answer: (a)

The α-methoxymethyl cation is an oxocarbenium ion: the oxygen lone pair fills the empty p orbital (CH₃O⁺=CH₂), giving every atom an octet. It is more stable than the tert-butyl cation, which relies on hyperconjugation. Ethyl cation (one alkyl group) is next, and the CF₃ group’s strong −I effect makes CF₃CH₂⁺ the least stable. Order P > S > Q > R.

Practice Q2. 3,3-Dimethylbutan-2-ol is heated with concentrated HBr. The major product is:

(a) 2-bromo-3,3-dimethylbutane (b) 2-bromo-2,3-dimethylbutane (c) 1-bromo-2,3-dimethylbutane (d) 3,3-dimethylbut-1-ene

Answer: (b)

Protonation and loss of water give the secondary cation (CH₃)₃C–CH⁺–CH₃. A methyl group shifts from the adjacent quaternary carbon to give the tertiary cation (CH₃)₂C⁺–CH(CH₃)₂, which is captured by Br⁻: 2-bromo-2,3-dimethylbutane.

Practice Q3. Which compound undergoes SN1 solvolysis most slowly?

(a) tert-butyl bromide (b) 1-bromoadamantane (c) 1-bromobicyclo[2.2.1]heptane (d) 2-bromo-2-methylbutane

Answer: (c)

The bridgehead of norbornane cannot become planar, so the 1-norbornyl cation is very high in energy. 1-Bromoadamantane is also a bridgehead, but the larger cage allows enough flattening for ionisation to be easy.

Practice Q4. 1-(Aminomethyl)cyclopentan-1-ol is treated with NaNO₂ and aqueous HCl at 0 °C. The main product is:

(a) cyclopentanecarbaldehyde (b) cyclohexanone (c) cyclopentylmethanol (d) 1-methylcyclopentan-1-ol

Answer: (b) cyclohexanone

Tiffeneau–Demjanov ring expansion. Diazotisation gives R–CH₂–N₂⁺; as N₂ leaves, a ring C–C bond on the carbinol carbon migrates to the CH₂, enlarging the ring by one carbon. The positive charge ends on the carbinol carbon, which is an oxocarbenium ion; loss of H⁺ gives the ketone. Five-membered ring becomes cyclohexanone.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. The rates of solvolysis of para-substituted cumyl chlorides (2-aryl-2-chloropropanes) in aqueous acetone follow \( \log(k_X/k_H) = \rho\sigma^+ \) with ρ = −4.5. Take σ⁺(p-OMe) = −0.78 and σ⁺(p-NO₂) = +0.79. Which statements are correct?

  1. The p-methoxy compound reacts about 3.2 × 10³ times faster than the parent.
  2. The p-nitro compound reacts about 3.6 × 10³ times more slowly than the parent.
  3. The ratio k(p-OMe)/k(p-NO₂) is about 1.2 × 10⁷.
  4. The negative ρ shows that negative charge builds up at the benzylic carbon in the transition state.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. Correct. \( \log(k/k_H) = (-4.5)(-0.78) = 3.51 \); \( 10^{3.51} \approx 3.2 \times 10^3 \).
  2. Correct. \( \log(k/k_H) = (-4.5)(0.79) = -3.555 \); \( k/k_H \approx 2.8 \times 10^{-4} \), i.e. about \( 1/(2.8 \times 10^{-4}) \approx 3.6 \times 10^3 \) times slower.
  3. Correct. \( \log \) ratio \( = 4.5 \times (0.78 + 0.79) = 7.065 \); \( 10^{7.065} \approx 1.2 \times 10^7 \).
  4. Wrong. A negative ρ means electron-donating groups accelerate the reaction, so positive charge develops at the benzylic carbon: the cumyl cation.

Practice Q6. The diol Ph₂C(OH)–C(OH)(CH₃)₂ is treated with cold concentrated H₂SO₄. A single ketone C₁₆H₁₆O is isolated. Its ¹H NMR spectrum shows a 3H singlet near δ 2.1, a 3H singlet near δ 1.9 and 10 aromatic H. Which statements are correct?

  1. The first-formed cation is the diphenylmethyl-type cation Ph₂C⁺–C(OH)(CH₃)₂.
  2. A methyl group migrates.
  3. The product is 3,3-diphenylbutan-2-one.
  4. The product is 2-methyl-1,2-diphenylpropan-1-one, formed by phenyl migration.

(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 3 only

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. Correct. Loss of water from the Ph₂C(OH) end gives a doubly benzylic cation, more stable than the tertiary alkyl alternative.
  2. Correct. The other carbon carries only CH₃ groups and OH; a methyl shifts to the cationic carbon, leaving an oxocarbenium ion at the C–OH carbon.
  3. Correct. Loss of H⁺ gives Ph₂C(CH₃)–CO–CH₃ = 3,3-diphenylbutan-2-one, C₁₆H₁₆O. Its NMR fits: CH₃ on the quaternary carbon (singlet) and the acetyl CH₃ (singlet, near δ 2.1).
  4. Wrong. That ketone, PhCO–C(CH₃)₂Ph (also C₁₆H₁₆O), would need the less stable tertiary alkyl cation to form first and a phenyl to migrate to it. Its two methyl groups are equivalent, so it would show one 6H singlet, not two different 3H singlets.

Practice Q7. Optically active threo-3-(4-methoxyphenyl)butan-2-yl tosylate undergoes acetolysis much faster than the corresponding 3-cyclohexylbutan-2-yl tosylate, and gives acetate with the threo relative configuration but zero optical rotation. Which conclusions are consistent?

  1. The aryl group provides anchimeric assistance.
  2. The intermediate is a bridged ion with a mirror plane.
  3. An open classical cation that is captured from either face would also give only threo acetate.
  4. The erythro tosylate would be expected to give optically active erythro acetate.

(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
  1. Correct. The rate enhancement over the cyclohexyl analogue (similar size, no π electrons) indicates participation; p-OMe makes the ring a better participant.
  2. Correct. Only an achiral (meso-like) bridged phenonium ion explains a racemic product that has kept the threo relative configuration.
  3. Wrong. An open cation can rotate about the C2–C3 bond before capture, so it would scramble the relative configuration and give erythro as well as threo acetate.
  4. Correct. The bridged ion from the erythro isomer is chiral; opening at either carbon gives the same enantiomer of the erythro product (overall retention).

Quick Revision Table

PointFact
Structuresp², planar, empty p; carbenium (3-coordinate) vs carbonium (3c–2e)
Stability3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃⁺; vinyl, aryl worst; α-OR, α-NR₂ strongly stabilise; α-C=O, α-CF₃ destabilise
Aromatic cationscyclopropenium (2π), tropylium (6π); cyclopentadienyl cation antiaromatic
GenerationR–X ionisation, ROH + H⁺, alkene + H⁺, RNH₂ + HNO₂, RX + AlCl₃, superacid
SuperacidFSO₃H–SbF₅; t-Bu⁺ observed by NMR (Olah, Nobel 1994)
σ⁺ / ρlarge negative ρ → cationic TS
1,2-Shiftgroup moves with its electron pair to a more stable cation; suprafacial
Migratory aptitudeelectron-rich aryl > alkyl (3° > 2° > 1° > Me); H variable
Pinacolwhich cation forms first, then which group migrates
Tiffeneau–Demjanovaminomethyl carbinol + HNO₂ → ring-expanded ketone
NGPrate up, retention, scrambling; phenonium (Cram), norbornyl (Winstein)
Bridgehead1-norbornyl cation very hard; 1-adamantyl easy

Key Takeaways

What’s Next