Model-System Calculations
CSIR NET chemistry: two-level systems and the Schottky anomaly, spin paramagnets, Einstein solids, ortho- and para-hydrogen, residual entropy and defects.
- 21 min
On this page · 17 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: A Heat Capacity with a Bump
- The Recipe
- The Two-Level System
- Spins in a Magnetic Field: Paramagnetism
- The Einstein Solid
- Rotation with Nuclear-Spin Statistics: Ortho- and Para-Hydrogen
- Residual Entropy: Counting Frozen Disorder
- Point Defects: Energy versus Configurational Entropy
- The Heat Capacity of a Diatomic Gas across Temperature
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Partition Functions and Thermodynamic Quantities: \( q \), \( Q = q^N \) for localised units, and the master relations for \( U \), \( S \), \( A \), \( C_V \).
- The Boltzmann Distribution: population ratios and \( S = k\ln W \).
- Nuclear spin and the symmetry of wavefunctions under exchange: Antisymmetry Principle and Slater Determinants and Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum.
- The third law and calorimetric entropies: Laws of Thermodynamics, State and Path Functions.
The Hook: A Heat Capacity with a Bump
The Recipe
Every calculation on this page follows the same steps.
graph LR
A["List levels
ε_j and g_j"] --> B["Write q
Σ g exp(−ε/kT)"]
B --> C["Populations
g exp(−ε/kT)/q"]
B --> D["U = N⟨ε⟩
= NkT² dlnq/dT"]
D --> E["C_V = dU/dT"]
B --> F["S = U/T + Nk ln q
(localised)"]For localised units (spins in a crystal, oscillators on lattice sites), \( Q = q^N \) and there is no \( N! \).
The Two-Level System
Two non-degenerate levels, \( 0 \) and \( \varepsilon \). Write \( x = \varepsilon/kT \).
| Quantity | \( T \to 0 \) (\( x \to \infty \)) | \( T \to \infty \) (\( x \to 0 \)) |
|---|---|---|
| Upper fraction | 0 | \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) (never more) |
| \( U - U(0) \) | 0 | \( \tfrac{1}{2}N_A\varepsilon \) (saturates) |
| \( C_{V,m} \) | 0 (exponentially) | 0 (as \( 1/T^2 \)) |
| \( S_m \) | 0 | \( R\ln 2 = 5.76 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ |
The Schottky anomaly
Because \( U \) saturates, the heat capacity must return to zero at high temperature. In between it passes through a maximum, the Schottky anomaly. Setting \( dC_V/dx = 0 \) gives
$$x = \frac{\varepsilon}{kT} \approx 2.40 \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad \boxed{T_{\max} \approx 0.417\,\frac{\varepsilon}{k}}, \qquad C_{V,m}^{\max} \approx 0.44R = 3.65\ \text{J K}^{-1}\text{mol}^{-1}$$The peak lies well below \( \varepsilon/k \): the system absorbs heat most readily when it starts to populate the upper level appreciably. Measuring \( T_{\max} \) gives the gap: for \( \varepsilon/hc = 100 \) cm⁻¹, \( T_{\max} = 0.417 \times 143.9 \) K = 60 K.
With degeneracies \( g_0 \) and \( g_1 \), the position and height of the peak change and the high-temperature entropy becomes \( R\ln(g_0 + g_1) \), but the qualitative behaviour is the same.
Spins in a Magnetic Field: Paramagnetism
An electron spin (\( S = \tfrac{1}{2} \), \( g \approx 2 \)) in a field \( B \) has two levels, \( m_s = \pm\tfrac{1}{2} \), with energies \( \pm\tfrac{1}{2}g\mu_BB \approx \pm\mu_BB \). This is a two-level system with gap \( 2\mu_BB \). The mean magnetic moment along the field is
$$\langle\mu_z\rangle = \mu_B\tanh\frac{\mu_BB}{kT} \;\xrightarrow{\;\mu_BB \ll kT\;}\; \frac{\mu_B^2B}{kT}$$So the magnetisation \( M = N\langle\mu_z\rangle \) is linear in \( B \) and inversely proportional to \( T \) at ordinary fields and temperatures: Curie’s law, \( \chi \propto 1/T \). At high field and low temperature it saturates at \( N\mu_B \).
| Conditions | \( \mu_BB/kT \) | Net polarisation \( \tanh(\mu_BB/kT) \) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 T, 298 K | 0.0023 | 0.23% |
| 1 T, 2 K | 0.34 | 32% |
The same arithmetic, with a nuclear moment several hundred times smaller (about 660 times for the proton), gives the tiny NMR polarisation computed on the Boltzmann page. A reported magnetic moment such as the spin-only value \( \sqrt{n(n + 2)}\,\mu_B \) is extracted from the Curie-law slope; see Orbital and Spin Angular Momentum.
The Einstein Solid
Einstein modelled a monatomic crystal of \( N \) atoms as \( 3N \) independent harmonic oscillators, all of the same frequency \( \nu_E \) (\( \theta_E = h\nu_E/k \)). Each oscillator is a uniform ladder:
$$q = \frac{1}{1 - e^{-\theta_E/T}}, \qquad Q = q^{3N}$$| \( \theta_E/T \) | \( E(x) \) | \( C_{V,m} \) / J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ |
|---|---|---|
| 0.5 | 0.979 | 24.4 |
| 1 | 0.921 | 23.0 |
| 2 | 0.724 | 18.1 |
| 3 | 0.496 | 12.4 |
| 5 | 0.171 | 4.3 |
- High temperature: \( E \to 1 \), \( C_{V,m} \to 3R = 24.9 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹, the law of Dulong and Petit. It is equipartition: each oscillator has two quadratic terms, \( 3N \times kT \).
- Low temperature: \( C_V \to 3R x^2e^{-x} \), falling exponentially to zero, as the third law requires.
- Hard, light solids (high \( \theta_E \)) are far below \( 3R \) at room temperature. With \( \theta_E = 1320 \) K, \( C_{V,m}(298\ \text{K}) = 6.0 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹; with \( \theta_E = 240 \) K, 23.6 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹. Diamond is the classic example of a solid far below the Dulong–Petit value at room temperature.
- The flaw: real solids fall as \( T^3 \) at low temperature, not exponentially. A real crystal has a spread of vibrational frequencies, and the lowest (long-wavelength) ones are always excited. The Debye model includes this spread and gives \( C_V \propto T^3 \) as \( T \to 0 \).
Rotation with Nuclear-Spin Statistics: Ortho- and Para-Hydrogen
For a homonuclear diatomic, the total wavefunction must be symmetric (bosonic nuclei) or antisymmetric (fermionic nuclei) under exchange of the two nuclei. Exchanging the nuclei multiplies the rotational wavefunction by \( (-1)^J \). The nuclear-spin wavefunction must therefore have the right symmetry to match each \( J \).
For H₂ (protons, \( I = \tfrac{1}{2} \), fermions; ground electronic state \( ^1\Sigma_g^+ \)):
| Form | Nuclear spin states | Number | Allowed \( J \) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Para-H₂ | antisymmetric (singlet, \( I_{\text{tot}} = 0 \)) | 1 | even: 0, 2, 4, … |
| Ortho-H₂ | symmetric (triplet, \( I_{\text{tot}} = 1 \)) | 3 | odd: 1, 3, 5, … |
With \( \theta_R = 87.6 \) K for H₂, the equilibrium para fraction is:
| \( T \) / K | 20 | 50 | 77 | 150 | 298 | high \( T \) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Para fraction | 0.998 | 0.79 | 0.52 | 0.29 | 0.25 | 0.25 |
| Ortho:para | 0.002:1 | 0.27:1 | 0.92:1 | 2.45:1 | 2.99:1 | 3:1 |
- At high temperature the even and odd sums are equal, so ortho:para \( \to \) 3:1, the ratio of spin weights.
- At low temperature only \( J = 0 \) is significantly populated, and it is para: equilibrium hydrogen becomes pure para-H₂.
- Interconversion requires flipping a nuclear spin and is very slow without a catalyst (paramagnetic surfaces or species speed it up). Hydrogen cooled without a catalyst keeps its room-temperature 3:1 mixture, which is why its heat capacity must be computed as a fixed mixture of two separate gases, not with the equilibrium partition function.
- The \( J = 1 \to J = 0 \) conversion releases \( 2hcB \), about 1.46 kJ mol⁻¹. In liquid hydrogen this exceeds the enthalpy of vaporisation, so unconverted liquid boils off slowly; commercial liquid hydrogen is catalytically converted to para before storage.
- In spectra: rotational Raman lines from odd-\( J \) levels of H₂ are enhanced 3:1 relative to the even ones (intensity alternation).
General rule. For a homonuclear diatomic with nuclear spin \( I \), there are \( (2I + 1)^2 \) spin states: \( (I + 1)(2I + 1) \) symmetric and \( I(2I + 1) \) antisymmetric, so the weight ratio is \( (I + 1)/I \).
| Molecule | \( I \) | Nuclei | Higher weight goes to | High-\( T \) ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H₂ | ½ | fermions | odd \( J \) (ortho) | 3:1 |
| D₂ | 1 | bosons | even \( J \) (ortho) | 6:3 = 2:1 |
| ¹⁶O₂, ¹⁶O–C–¹⁶O | 0 | bosons | only half of the \( J \) levels exist | — |
For nuclei with \( I = 0 \), the antisymmetric spin combination does not exist, so half the rotational levels are missing altogether: in ground-state CO₂ only even \( J \) levels occur, in ground-state ¹⁶O₂ only odd rotational levels. At high temperature the effect averages to the factor \( 1/\sigma \) in \( q_R \).
Residual Entropy: Counting Frozen Disorder
The third law says \( S \to 0 \) for a perfect crystal. If a crystal freezes in orientational disorder, the disorder stays as a residual entropy \( S = k\ln W \), and calorimetry (which integrates \( C_p/T \) up from near 0 K) misses it. The calorimetric entropy is then lower than the statistical (spectroscopic) entropy by \( S_{\text{res}} \).
| Crystal | Disorder | \( W \) per molecule | \( S_{\text{res}} \) (model) |
|---|---|---|---|
| CO, N₂O | head-to-tail: CO or OC | 2 | \( R\ln 2 = 5.76 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ |
| CH₃D | which of 4 positions holds D | 4 | \( R\ln 4 = 11.5 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ |
| Ice (Pauling) | hydrogen positions on O···O bonds | 3/2 | \( R\ln\tfrac{3}{2} = 3.37 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ |
Pauling’s count for ice. Each O has four O···O neighbours and must carry two near hydrogens (two covalent O–H) and two far ones. A water molecule can be oriented in \( \binom{4}{2} = 6 \) ways. But each orientation must also be compatible with its neighbours: each H-bond must have exactly one H, and each of a molecule’s two hydrogens has a probability of \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) of finding its bond free. So \( W = 6 \times (\tfrac{1}{2})^2 = \tfrac{3}{2} \) per molecule and \( S_{\text{res}} = R\ln\tfrac{3}{2} \), which agrees closely with the measured residual entropy of ice.
For CO, the observed residual entropy is smaller than \( R\ln 2 \), indicating partial ordering before the disorder froze. The model value is an upper limit.
Point Defects: Energy versus Configurational Entropy
Removing an atom from a lattice site to make a vacancy costs energy \( \varepsilon_v \), but the vacancies can be placed in \( \binom{N}{n} \) ways. The Helmholtz energy for \( n \) vacancies among \( N \) sites is
$$A = n\varepsilon_v - kT\ln\frac{N!}{n!(N - n)!}$$Minimising with respect to \( n \) (Stirling; \( n \ll N \)):
$$\boxed{\frac{n}{N} \approx e^{-\varepsilon_v/kT}}$$For an ionic crystal MX, a Schottky defect is a pair of vacancies (one cation, one anion) created together with energy \( \varepsilon_S \). Each kind can be placed independently, so \( n^2 \approx N^2e^{-\varepsilon_S/kT} \) and \( n/N \approx e^{-\varepsilon_S/2kT} \): note the factor of 2.
The Heat Capacity of a Diatomic Gas across Temperature
Putting the modes together for a diatomic gas such as H₂ (taking an equilibrium or fixed ortho:para mixture as appropriate):
| Temperature range | Active modes | \( C_{V,m} \) |
|---|---|---|
| \( T \ll \theta_R \) | translation only | \( \tfrac{3}{2}R \) |
| \( \theta_R \ll T \ll \theta_V \) | translation + rotation | \( \tfrac{5}{2}R \) |
| \( T \gg \theta_V \) | translation + rotation + vibration | \( \tfrac{7}{2}R \) |
For most diatomics \( \theta_R \) is a few kelvin (the gas has condensed long before rotation freezes), so the first step is seen only for H₂, HD and D₂. Each step is smooth: the vibrational one follows the Einstein function. The rotational step for normal H₂ depends on whether the ortho:para ratio is held fixed at 3:1 or allowed to equilibrate.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Two-level \( C_V \): peaks then falls to 0 | Oscillator \( C_V \): rises monotonically to \( R \) | |
| Schottky anomaly (finite level set) | Lattice heat capacity (Einstein / Debye) | |
| Einstein low-\( T \): exponential | Debye (and experiment): \( T^3 \) | |
| H₂: ortho = odd \( J \), weight 3 | D₂: ortho = even \( J \), weight 6 | |
| Equilibrium ortho:para (temperature-dependent) | Normal H₂ (frozen at 3:1 without catalyst) | |
| Residual entropy: frozen disorder, missed by calorimetry | Third-law entropy of a perfect crystal: 0 at 0 K | |
| Vacancy fraction \( e^{-\varepsilon/kT} \) | Schottky pair fraction \( e^{-\varepsilon/2kT} \) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Use \( hc/k = 1.4388 \) cm K, \( R = 8.314 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹, \( hcN_A = 11.96 \) J mol⁻¹ per cm⁻¹, \( k = 8.617 \times 10^{-5} \) eV K⁻¹.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the maximum molar entropy of a system of independent units each with two non-degenerate levels?
- What is the Dulong–Petit value of \( C_{V,m} \)?
- What is the ortho:para ratio of H₂ at high temperature?
Answers
- \( R\ln 2 = \mathbf{5.76} \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.
- \( 3R = \mathbf{24.9} \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.
- 3:1.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A crystal contains ions with two non-degenerate levels separated by 100 cm⁻¹. The Schottky maximum in the heat capacity occurs near
(a) 30 K (b) 60 K (c) 144 K (d) 240 K
Answer: (b)
\( \varepsilon/k = 100 \times 1.4388 = 143.9 \) K. The peak is at \( \varepsilon/kT \approx 2.40 \), so \( T_{\max} = 143.9/2.40 = 60 \) K. (c) is \( \varepsilon/k \) itself.
Practice Q2. Using Pauling’s model, the residual molar entropy of ice is
(a) \( R\ln 2 \) (b) \( R\ln\tfrac{3}{2} \) (c) \( R\ln 6 \) (d) \( R\ln 4 \)
Answer: (b)
\( W = 6 \times (\tfrac{1}{2})^2 = \tfrac{3}{2} \) per molecule; \( S = R\ln 1.5 = 3.37 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹. (c) ignores the bond constraint; (a) is the CO value.
Practice Q3. For an Einstein solid at \( T = \theta_E \), \( C_{V,m} \) is closest to
(a) 12.5 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ (b) 18.1 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ (c) 23.0 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ (d) 24.9 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹
Answer: (c)
\( E(1) = e/(e - 1)^2 = 2.718/2.952 = 0.921 \); \( C_{V,m} = 3R \times 0.921 = 23.0 \). (d) is the classical limit; (b) is the value at \( T = \theta_E/2 \).
Practice Q4. If crystalline CH₃D froze with complete randomness in the position of the D atom, its residual molar entropy would be
(a) \( R\ln 2 \) (b) \( R\ln 3 \) (c) \( R\ln 4 \) (d) \( R\ln 12 \)
Answer: (c)
A tetrahedral CH₃D can point its C–D bond along any of 4 directions in a fixed site, so \( W = 4 \) per molecule and \( S = R\ln 4 = 11.5 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹. (d) confuses this with the symmetry number of CH₄.
Practice Q5. For D₂ (deuterons have \( I = 1 \)), which combination is correct at high temperature?
(a) ortho on odd \( J \), ortho:para = 3:1 (b) ortho on even \( J \), ortho:para = 2:1 (c) ortho on even \( J \), ortho:para = 3:1 (d) ortho on odd \( J \), ortho:para = 2:1
Answer: (b)
Deuterons are bosons: the total wavefunction must be symmetric. \( (2I + 1)^2 = 9 \) spin states: 6 symmetric (with even \( J \)) and 3 antisymmetric (with odd \( J \)). Ortho (the larger set) goes with even \( J \): 6:3 = 2:1.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q6. A crystal contains independent units with non-degenerate levels at 0 and 300 cm⁻¹. At 298 K, which statements are correct?
- About 19% of the units are in the upper level.
- The molar internal energy above the ground state is about 0.68 kJ mol⁻¹.
- The molar heat capacity from these units is about 2.7 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹, and it would be larger at 1000 K.
- The molar entropy from these units is about 4.0 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
\( x = 300 \times 1.4388/298 = 1.448 \), \( e^{-x} = 0.235 \), \( q = 1.235 \).
- Correct. \( 0.235/1.235 = 0.190 \).
- Correct. \( 0.190 \times 300 \times 11.96 = 683 \) J mol⁻¹.
- Wrong in its second half. \( C_{V,m} = Rx^2e^x/(e^x + 1)^2 = 0.323R = 2.69 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ is right, but the Schottky peak lies at \( T_{\max} = 0.417 \times 431.6 = 180 \) K. At 298 K the system is already past the peak, and at 1000 K (\( x = 0.43 \)) \( C_{V,m} = 0.045R \approx 0.37 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹: smaller, not larger.
- Correct. \( S = U/T + R\ln q = 683/298 + 8.314 \times 0.211 = 2.29 + 1.76 = 4.05 \) J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹.
Practice Q7. Hydrogen (\( \theta_R = 87.6 \) K) is studied with and without an ortho–para conversion catalyst. Which statements are correct?
- At equilibrium at 20 K, almost all molecules are para-H₂.
- At equilibrium at 77 K, the ortho:para ratio is close to 1:1.
- Normal hydrogen cooled rapidly from 298 K to 20 K without a catalyst is almost pure para-H₂.
- The ortho:para ratio approaches 3:1 at high temperature because the spin triplet has three states and the singlet one.
(a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Correct. Para fraction 0.998 at 20 K: only \( J = 0 \) is significantly populated.
- Correct. The equilibrium para fraction at 77 K is about 0.52 (ortho:para 0.92:1).
- Wrong. Without a catalyst conversion is very slow; the gas keeps its room-temperature composition, about 3:1 ortho:para.
- Correct. At high \( T \) the even- and odd-\( J \) sums become equal, leaving the spin weights 3 and 1.
Practice Q8. The energy to form a vacancy in a metal is 1.0 eV. Which statements are correct?
- At 1000 K the equilibrium vacancy fraction is about \( 9 \times 10^{-6} \).
- Raising the temperature to 1200 K increases the vacancy fraction about sevenfold.
- At equilibrium above 0 K a crystal has a non-zero vacancy concentration because the configurational entropy outweighs the energy cost for the first vacancies.
- For Schottky pairs in an ionic crystal with a pair-formation energy of 1.0 eV, the fraction of each kind of vacancy at 1000 K would also be about \( 9 \times 10^{-6} \).
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. \( \varepsilon/kT = 1.0/(8.617 \times 10^{-5} \times 1000) = 11.60 \); \( e^{-11.60} = 9.1 \times 10^{-6} \).
- Correct. At 1200 K, \( e^{-9.67} = 6.3 \times 10^{-5} \), a ratio of 6.9.
- Correct. \( dA/dn = \varepsilon_v - kT\ln[(N - n)/n] \) is negative at small \( n \), so adding vacancies lowers \( A \) until \( n/N \approx e^{-\varepsilon_v/kT} \).
- Wrong. Cation and anion vacancies are placed independently, so for pairs \( n/N = e^{-\varepsilon_S/2kT} \). With \( \varepsilon_S = 1.0 \) eV at 1000 K this is \( e^{-5.80} = 3.0 \times 10^{-3} \), more than 300 times the single-vacancy value. The factor of 2 in the exponent is the whole point.
Quick Revision Table
| Model | Key results |
|---|---|
| Two-level | \( q = 1 + e^{-x} \); upper fraction \( 1/(e^x + 1) \le \tfrac{1}{2} \); \( S \to R\ln 2 \) |
| Schottky anomaly | \( C_V \) peak at \( kT \approx 0.417\varepsilon \), height \( 0.44R \); \( C_V \to 0 \) at both ends |
| Spin paramagnet | \( \langle\mu_z\rangle = \mu_B\tanh(\mu_BB/kT) \); Curie \( \chi \propto 1/T \); 1 T, 298 K: 0.23% |
| Einstein solid | \( C_{V,m} = 3RE(\theta_E/T) \); \( E(1) = 0.921 \); high \( T \): \( 3R = 24.9 \) |
| Low-\( T \) solids | Einstein exponential; Debye and experiment \( T^3 \) |
| H₂ nuclear statistics | para: even \( J \), weight 1; ortho: odd \( J \), weight 3; high \( T \) 3:1 |
| Equilibrium para-H₂ | 99.8% (20 K), 52% (77 K), 25% (298 K) |
| D₂ | ortho even \( J \), 2:1 |
| \( I = 0 \) nuclei | half the \( J \) levels missing (CO₂: even only) |
| Residual entropy | CO \( R\ln 2 \) (upper limit); CH₃D \( R\ln 4 \); ice \( R\ln\tfrac{3}{2} = 3.37 \) |
| Vacancies | \( n/N = e^{-\varepsilon_v/kT} \); Schottky pairs \( e^{-\varepsilon_S/2kT} \) |
| Diatomic \( C_{V,m} \) | \( \tfrac{3}{2}R \to \tfrac{5}{2}R \to \tfrac{7}{2}R \) across \( \theta_R \) and \( \theta_V \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
You have now covered all four official lines of this unit. Consolidate with the one-page sheet:
→ Statistical Thermodynamics: Quick Revision
The thermodynamic relations used here (\( A = U - TS \), \( C_V \), the third law) are developed in Laws of Thermodynamics, State and Path Functions. Intensity alternation from nuclear-spin statistics in rotational Raman spectra is covered in IR and Raman Activity: Selection Rules. Back to the chapter overview.