Cyclic Systems: Configuration and Conformation
CSIR NET: ring strain, cyclohexane chair and boat, A-values, disubstituted cyclohexanes, anomeric effect, decalins and conformation-controlled reactions.
- 17 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Conformational Isomerism in Acyclic Systems: gauche-butane increments, Boltzmann populations and the Curtin–Hammett principle, all reused here.
- Stereogenicity, Chirality and Configurational Isomerism: meso compounds and counting stereoisomers.
- Point Groups: chair cyclohexane is \( D_{3d} \), twist-boat \( D_2 \), boat \( C_{2v} \); symmetry decides which ring isomers are chiral.
The Hook: One Methyl, Nineteen to One
Ring Strain
Baeyer assumed planar rings and predicted strain from the deviation of the internal angle from 109.5°. The idea is right for three- and four-membered rings and wrong beyond, because larger rings pucker. Experimental strain comes from heats of combustion per CH₂ compared with an unstrained chain.
| Ring | Strain energy (kJ mol⁻¹, textbook values) | Shape and main strain |
|---|---|---|
| Cyclopropane | ≈ 115 | planar; C–C–C 60°; bent (“banana”) bonds; all C–H eclipsed |
| Cyclobutane | ≈ 110 | puckered (“butterfly”), which relieves some eclipsing at a small cost in angle strain |
| Cyclopentane | ≈ 26 | envelope and half-chair, interconverting by pseudorotation; little angle strain, some eclipsing |
| Cyclohexane | ≈ 0 | chair: ideal angles, all bonds staggered |
| Medium rings (8 to 11) | larger again | transannular strain: H atoms across the ring crowd each other |
Large rings (about 14 and above) can adopt nearly strain-free, chain-like conformations.
Cyclohexane
Chair, boat and twist-boat
graph LR
C1["Chair 1
0 kJ/mol"] --> HC["Half-chair (TS)
about 45"]
HC --> TB["Twist-boat
about 23"]
TB --> B["Boat (TS between
twist-boats) about 29"]
B --> TB2["Twist-boat"]
TB2 --> HC2["Half-chair (TS)"]
HC2 --> C2["Chair 2
0 kJ/mol"]| Conformation | Point group | Energy above chair (kJ mol⁻¹) | Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chair | \( D_{3d} \) | 0 | all C–C–C ≈ 111°; all bonds staggered; 6 axial + 6 equatorial H |
| Twist-boat | \( D_2 \) | ≈ 23 | a true minimum; partly relieves the boat’s strain; chiral |
| Boat | \( C_{2v} \) | ≈ 29 | flagpole H/H contact; four eclipsed C–C bonds; a transition state between twist-boats |
| Half-chair | \( C_2 \) | ≈ 45 | highest point on the chair–chair path |
- The ring flip (chair → chair) converts every axial position into an equatorial one and vice versa; “up” stays “up”. Its barrier is about 45 kJ mol⁻¹, giving roughly \( 10^5 \) flips per second at 298 K. Room-temperature NMR shows averaged axial/equatorial signals; at low temperature the two sets separate.
- Axial bonds are parallel to the \( C_3 \) axis, alternating up and down. Equatorial bonds point outward, roughly in the “plane” of the ring, each parallel to two ring C–C bonds.
- On adjacent carbons, an axial–equatorial pair is cis, an axial–axial pair is trans (anti-periplanar, θ = 180°), and an equatorial–equatorial pair is trans (gauche, θ ≈ 60°).
Monosubstituted cyclohexanes and A-values
An axial substituent at C1 has 1,3-diaxial contacts with the axial H atoms on C3 and C5. Viewed along C1–C2 (and C1–C6), it is gauche to C3 (and C5): two gauche-butane interactions, 2 × 3.8 = 7.6 kJ mol⁻¹ for methyl. An equatorial substituent is anti to both.
\( A = -\Delta G^\circ \) for the equilibrium axial ⇌ equatorial of a monosubstituted cyclohexane: the free-energy preference for the equatorial position.
$$K = \frac{[\text{eq}]}{[\text{ax}]} = e^{A/RT}$$| Substituent | A (kJ mol⁻¹, approximate) | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| –CH₃ | 7.3 | K ≈ 19 at 298 K: 95% equatorial |
| –CH₂CH₃ | 7.5 | ethyl turns its CH₃ away from the ring |
| –CH(CH₃)₂ | 9.2 | isopropyl can still turn its C–H toward the ring |
| –C(CH₃)₃ | ≈ 20 or more | no C–H to turn inward; effectively locks the ring |
| –C₆H₅ | ≈ 12 | the ring plane can rotate to reduce contacts |
| –OH | ≈ 2.5 to 4 | depends on solvent (hydrogen bonding enlarges the effective size) |
| –Cl, –Br | ≈ 2 | long C–X bond places the halogen farther from the axial H atoms |
| –CN | ≈ 1 | small, linear |
Two rules of thumb follow:
- Size is not volume. A-values measure contact with the axial hydrogens, so long bonds (C–Br, C–I) and linear groups (C≡N) give small A-values despite large atoms.
- The isopropyl/tert-butyl jump. Isopropyl can rotate its single C–H toward the ring; tert-butyl cannot, so its A-value is more than twice as large. A tert-butyl group holds the chair with it equatorial: conformational locking.
Disubstituted cyclohexanes: stability
Draw both chairs, put each substituent axial or equatorial, and add costs: each axial group costs its A-value, and two groups on adjacent carbons that are gauche (e,e or a,e) cost an extra gauche interaction.
| Isomer | Chair 1 | Chair 2 | More stable isomer (R = R′ = CH₃) |
|---|---|---|---|
| cis-1,2 | a,e | e,a (same energy) | trans-1,2 (e,e) |
| trans-1,2 | e,e | a,a | |
| cis-1,3 | e,e | a,a | cis-1,3 (e,e) |
| trans-1,3 | a,e | e,a (same energy) | |
| cis-1,4 | a,e | e,a (same energy) | trans-1,4 (e,e) |
| trans-1,4 | e,e | a,a |
Worked estimates for the dimethylcyclohexanes (gauche Me/Me = 3.8, axial Me = 7.6 as two gauche interactions):
- trans-1,2 (e,e): one Me/Me gauche = 3.8. cis-1,2 (a,e): axial Me 7.6 + Me/Me gauche 3.8 = 11.4. Difference ≈ 7.6 kJ mol⁻¹ in favour of trans.
- cis-1,3 (e,e): 0. trans-1,3 (a,e): 7.6. cis favoured by ≈ 7.6. The diaxial chair of cis-1,3 adds a severe Me/Me 1,3-diaxial (syn-pentane) contact and is negligible.
- trans-1,4 (e,e): 0. cis-1,4 (a,e): 7.6. trans favoured by ≈ 7.6.
- trans-1,2 diaxial chair: four Me/H 1,3-diaxial contacts (2 × 7.6 = 15.2) and no Me/Me gauche, so it lies about 11.4 kJ mol⁻¹ above the diequatorial chair.
Disubstituted cyclohexanes: configuration and chirality
Treat the ring as planar to decide chirality and count stereoisomers (the conclusions match the real, rapidly flipping chairs).
| Compound (two identical groups) | Isomers | Chirality |
|---|---|---|
| 1,1-dimethyl | 1 | achiral |
| cis-1,2 | 1 | meso-like: each chair is chiral, but the ring flip converts it into its mirror image, so it is not resolvable; the planar average has a mirror plane |
| trans-1,2 | 2 (pair of enantiomers) | chiral, \( C_2 \) |
| cis-1,3 | 1 | meso (mirror plane through C2 and C5) |
| trans-1,3 | 2 (pair of enantiomers) | chiral |
| cis-1,4 and trans-1,4 | 1 each | achiral (plane through C1 and C4); C1 and C4 are stereogenic but not chirality centres |
So 1,2- and 1,3-dimethylcyclohexane have three stereoisomers each, and 1,4-dimethylcyclohexane has two. With two different substituents (1-X-2-Y or 1-X-3-Y), every isomer is chiral and the count is four (two pairs). The 1,4 case still gives two achiral diastereomers.
The same rules apply to small rings: cis-1,2-dimethylcyclopropane is meso; the trans isomer is a pair of enantiomers.
Heteroatoms and the anomeric effect
- Anomeric effect. In a tetrahydropyran (and in pyranose sugars), an electronegative substituent at C2 (next to the ring oxygen) is more stable axial than steric arguments predict. Two explanations are used: overlap of a ring-oxygen lone pair with the anti-periplanar \( \sigma^*_{\text{C–X}} \) orbital, possible only when X is axial; and a smaller dipole–dipole repulsion in the axial arrangement. The effect decreases in polar solvents.
- Glucose. In water at equilibrium (after mutarotation), D-glucopyranose is about 36% α (anomeric OH axial) and 64% β (all substituents equatorial). The β preference is smaller than steric arguments alone would give because the anomeric effect favours α. From these figures, \( \Delta G^\circ(\alpha \rightarrow \beta) = -RT\ln(64/36) \approx -1.4 \) kJ mol⁻¹.
- Nitrogen and oxygen in the ring shorten C–X bonds, so 1,3-diaxial contacts across a heteroatom are tighter; lone pairs are “smaller” than C–H.
Cyclohexanones and cyclohexenes
- In cyclohexanone, C1 is trigonal. A 3-axial substituent has no axial H at C1 to collide with, so its preference for equatorial is reduced (the 3-alkylketone effect).
- 2-Halocyclohexanones show a larger axial population than the A-value predicts, especially in non-polar solvents: equatorial C–X is nearly eclipsed with C=O and the two dipoles repel. The axial population falls as solvent polarity rises.
- Cyclohexene adopts a half-chair; the allylic positions carry pseudo-axial and pseudo-equatorial bonds.
Fused rings: decalins and steroids
| Property | trans-Decalin | cis-Decalin |
|---|---|---|
| Ring fusion | both bridgehead H axial to the other ring; the rings joined e,e | one ring attached a,e |
| Ring flip | impossible (an e,e fusion would have to become a,a, which cannot span the ring) | possible; the two conformers are mirror images and interconvert |
| Chirality | achiral (\( C_{2h} \)) | each conformer \( C_2 \) (chiral), but rapid interconversion makes it non-resolvable |
| Stability | more stable by ≈ 11 kJ mol⁻¹: cis has three extra gauche-butane interactions (3 × 3.8) |
- Steroids with all-trans ring fusions (5α series) are rigid, flat molecules; a cis A/B fusion (5β series) bends the A ring out of plane. Conformational analysis of steroid substituents (axial versus equatorial OH, rates of oxidation, acetylation and elimination) was one of the first great successes of the method.
- Bredt’s rule: a double bond cannot be placed at a bridgehead of a small bicyclic system (norbornane, bicyclo[2.2.2]octane), because the p orbitals cannot overlap.
Conformation Controls Reactivity in Rings
E2: the trans-diaxial requirement
In a cyclohexane, H and the leaving group can only be anti-periplanar if both are axial.
- Neomenthyl chloride (Cl axial in the preferred chair, with methyl and isopropyl equatorial) has two anti-periplanar axial H atoms. It eliminates rapidly to a mixture in which the more substituted alkene, 3-menthene (Zaitsev), dominates.
- Menthyl chloride (Cl, CH₃ and iPr all equatorial) must first flip to the chair with all three groups axial, which is a high-energy minor conformer. In that chair, the only axial H anti to Cl is on the CH₂ side (the H on the isopropyl-bearing carbon is now equatorial). Elimination is slow and gives only 2-menthene, the less substituted (non-Zaitsev) alkene.
- The rates and products together are a Curtin–Hammett result: the reacting conformer of menthyl chloride is minor, and its transition state is high.
Other conformation-dependent reactions
| Reaction | Faster or favoured | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Epoxide opening (Fürst–Plattner rule) | trans-diaxial product first, via a chair-like TS | nucleophile and leaving O anti-periplanar |
| Br₂ addition to cyclohexene | trans-1,2-dibromide, initially formed diaxial (the conformers then equilibrate) | anti, trans-diaxial opening of the bromonium ion |
| Chromic acid oxidation of a secondary alcohol | axial OH oxidises faster | relief of 1,3-diaxial strain in the rate-limiting step (steric acceleration) |
| Esterification/acetylation of an OH; hydrolysis of esters | equatorial group reacts faster | less hindered approach |
| SN1 ionisation of a cyclohexyl leaving group | axial leaving group ionises faster | strain relief |
Nucleophilic addition to cyclohexanones
4-tert-Butylcyclohexanone (locked chair) can be attacked from the axial or the equatorial face.
- Small nucleophiles (LiAlH₄, NaBH₄) attack mainly axially, giving the equatorial alcohol (trans-4-tert-butylcyclohexanol) as the major product. Axial attack avoids torsional strain with the adjacent axial C–H bonds that equatorial attack develops.
- Bulky nucleophiles (L-Selectride, LiBH(sec-Bu)₃) attack equatorially, because axial approach is blocked by the 3,5-diaxial hydrogens; the product is the axial alcohol (cis isomer).
This competition of torsional versus steric control is the ring version of the face selectivity treated in Stereospecific and Stereoselective Reactions.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | Is not this |
|---|---|
| cis/trans (configuration): same or opposite face of the ring | axial/equatorial (conformation): changes on ring flip |
| cis-1,2-dimethylcyclohexane: achiral overall (chairs interconvert as mirror images) | trans-1,2-dimethylcyclohexane: chiral, resolvable pair |
| 1,4-disubstituted cis and trans: both achiral | 1,3-disubstituted trans: chiral |
| Twist-boat (\( D_2 \)): a minimum, ≈ 23 kJ mol⁻¹ | Boat (\( C_{2v} \)): a transition state, ≈ 29 kJ mol⁻¹ |
| trans-Decalin: rigid, more stable | cis-Decalin: flips, ≈ 11 kJ mol⁻¹ higher |
| Anomeric effect: electronegative group at C2 of a pyran prefers axial | A-value: steric preference for equatorial |
| Axial OH: faster oxidation | Equatorial OH: faster esterification |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not taken from any CSIR NET paper. Use R = 8.314 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ and T = 298 K.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which isomer of 1,3-dimethylcyclohexane is more stable?
- How many stereoisomers does 1,2-dimethylcyclohexane have?
- Can trans-decalin undergo a ring flip?
Answers
- cis: it can adopt the (e,e) chair; the trans isomer is always (a,e).
- Three: the cis (meso-like, achiral) isomer and the two enantiomers of the trans isomer.
- No. Its two rings are joined through two equatorial bonds; flipping would need both to become axial, which cannot bridge the second ring.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A substituent X has an A-value of 2.2 kJ mol⁻¹. The percentage of equatorial conformer of cyclohexyl–X at 298 K is closest to
(a) 50% (b) 59% (c) 71% (d) 95%
Answer: (c)
\( K = e^{2200/(8.314\times298)} = e^{0.888} = 2.43 \). Equatorial fraction = 2.43/3.43 = 0.71.
Practice Q2. Which of the following is chiral and resolvable at room temperature?
(a) cis-1,2-dimethylcyclohexane (b) cis-1,3-dimethylcyclohexane (c) trans-1,3-dimethylcyclohexane (d) trans-1,4-dimethylcyclohexane
Answer: (c)
trans-1,3-Dimethylcyclohexane has no mirror plane in either chair or in the planar average; its mirror image is a different molecule, and a ring flip gives the same molecule back (a,e ↔ e,a). (a) interconverts with its mirror image on ring flip; (b) has a mirror plane; (d) has a mirror plane through C1 and C4.
Practice Q3. On treatment with sodium ethoxide, menthyl chloride (all three substituents equatorial in the preferred chair) gives
(a) mainly 3-menthene, rapidly (b) only 2-menthene, slowly (c) a 1:1 mixture of 2- and 3-menthene (d) no alkene; only substitution
Answer: (b)
E2 needs Cl axial. That requires the minor chair with Cl, CH₃ and iPr all axial. In it the H on the isopropyl-bearing carbon is equatorial, so only the axial H on the other neighbouring CH₂ is anti-periplanar: only 2-menthene, and slowly. Option (a) describes neomenthyl chloride.
Practice Q4. Reduction of 4-tert-butylcyclohexanone with LiAlH₄ gives as the major product
(a) cis-4-tert-butylcyclohexanol (axial OH) (b) trans-4-tert-butylcyclohexanol (equatorial OH) (c) a 1:1 mixture (d) 4-tert-butylcyclohexene
Answer: (b)
Small hydride donors attack the locked ketone mainly from the axial face, pushing the oxygen equatorial. With tert-butyl equatorial at C4 and OH equatorial at C1, the two groups are trans. A bulky hydride such as L-Selectride would give the cis (axial OH) alcohol.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Use A(CH₃) = 7.3 kJ mol⁻¹, treat tert-butyl as fully locking the ring, and take T = 298 K. Consider cis- and trans-1-tert-butyl-4-methylcyclohexane equilibrated through a catalyst that epimerises C4 only.
Which statements are correct?
- In the cis isomer the methyl group is axial.
- The trans isomer is more stable by about 7.3 kJ mol⁻¹.
- The equilibrium trans:cis ratio is about 19:1.
- The cis isomer undergoes a ring flip to place both groups equatorial.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. tert-Butyl is equatorial; a cis-1,4 partner must then be axial (1,4-cis is always a,e).
- Correct. The only difference between the isomers is axial versus equatorial methyl, i.e. the A-value.
- Correct. \( K = e^{7300/(8.314\times298)} = 19.0 \).
- Wrong. A ring flip cannot change cis to trans; it would only put tert-butyl axial and methyl equatorial, which is far worse.
Practice Q6. In water at equilibrium, D-glucopyranose is 36% α and 64% β (ignore the open-chain form). Which statements are correct?
- In the β anomer, all ring substituents can be equatorial in the ⁴C₁ chair.
- \( \Delta G^\circ \) for α → β is about −1.4 kJ mol⁻¹ at 298 K.
- The α anomer has its anomeric OH axial.
- The anomeric effect favours the β anomer.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Correct. β-D-Glucopyranose is the all-equatorial hexose in the usual chair.
- Correct. \( \Delta G^\circ = -RT\ln(64/36) = -8.314 \times 298 \times 0.575 = -1.43 \) kJ mol⁻¹.
- Correct. In the ⁴C₁ chair of α-D-glucopyranose the C1–OH is axial.
- Wrong. The anomeric effect favours an axial electronegative group, i.e. the α anomer. It reduces the β preference rather than causing it; the β anomer still wins on steric grounds.
Practice Q7. Two diastereomeric secondary alcohols, cis- and trans-4-tert-butylcyclohexanol, are compared.
Which statements are correct?
- The cis isomer has an axial OH.
- The cis isomer is oxidised faster by chromic acid.
- The trans isomer is acetylated faster.
- Both isomers give the same ketone on oxidation.
(a) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3 and 4
- Correct. tert-Butyl equatorial; cis-1,4 places OH axial.
- Correct. Oxidation of an axial alcohol relieves 1,3-diaxial strain as C1 becomes trigonal (steric acceleration).
- Correct. Equatorial OH is less hindered toward an acylating agent.
- Correct. Both give 4-tert-butylcyclohexanone; C1 loses its stereocentre.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Strain (kJ mol⁻¹) | cyclopropane ≈ 115; cyclobutane ≈ 110; cyclopentane ≈ 26; cyclohexane ≈ 0 |
| Cyclohexane energies | chair 0; twist-boat ≈ 23; boat ≈ 29; half-chair ≈ 45 (flip barrier) |
| Point groups | chair \( D_{3d} \); twist-boat \( D_2 \); boat \( C_{2v} \) |
| Axial Me | ≈ 7.3 kJ mol⁻¹ (two gauche-butane contacts); 95% equatorial at 298 K |
| A-values | Me 7.3, Et 7.5, iPr 9.2, tBu ≥ 20, Ph ≈ 12, OH 2.5–4, Cl/Br ≈ 2 |
| Diequatorial isomers | trans-1,2, cis-1,3, trans-1,4 |
| Chirality | trans-1,2 and trans-1,3 chiral; cis-1,2, cis-1,3 and both 1,4 achiral |
| Stereoisomer counts | dimethyl: 1,2 → 3; 1,3 → 3; 1,4 → 2 |
| Anomeric effect | C2 electronegative group axial; glucose 36% α, 64% β in water |
| Decalins | trans rigid, \( C_{2h} \), more stable by ≈ 11 kJ mol⁻¹ |
| E2 in rings | trans-diaxial; neomenthyl fast (3-menthene), menthyl slow (2-menthene) |
| Ketone reduction | small hydride → equatorial OH; bulky → axial OH |
| Oxidation vs esterification | axial OH oxidised faster; equatorial OH esterified faster |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Stereospecific and Stereoselective Reactions: definitions of stereo-, enantio- and diastereoselectivity, with ee, dr and their energy equivalents.
- Asymmetric Induction: how an existing stereocentre or a chiral catalyst biases a new one.
- Carbohydrate chemistry in Life Sciences: anomers and pyranose conformations from the biochemical side.
- Stereochemistry: Quick Revision.