Mass Spectrometry and Combined Structure Problems
CSIR NET organic spectroscopy: ionisation, nitrogen rule, isotope patterns, HRMS, α-cleavage, McLafferty, RDA, and solving structures from IR, UV, NMR and MS.
- 18 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- IR Spectroscopy of Organic Compounds, ¹H NMR and ¹³C NMR: the combined problems at the end of this page use all three.
- Carbocations: Structure, Stability and Rearrangements: fragment ions are cations, and their stability decides which bonds break.
- Mass Spectrometry, Electron Spectroscopy and Microscopy: instrument basics and metal isotope patterns from the inorganic side.
The Hook: Weighing a Molecule, Then Breaking It
How a Mass Spectrum Is Made
graph LR
A["Sample
(gas, solution, solid)"] --> B["Ion source
EI, CI, ESI, MALDI, FAB"]
B --> C["Mass analyser
sector, quadrupole, TOF,
ion trap, FT-ICR, Orbitrap"]
C --> D["Detector
(electron multiplier)"]
D --> E["Spectrum:
relative abundance vs m/z"]Ionisation methods
| Method | How | Main ion | Fragmentation | Typical sample |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Electron ionisation (EI) | 70 eV electron beam knocks out an electron | M⁺• (radical cation) | extensive; molecular ion may be weak or absent | volatile, thermally stable organics |
| Chemical ionisation (CI) | reagent gas (CH₄, isobutane, NH₃) ionised first; reagent ions protonate the analyte | [M+H]⁺ (also adducts such as [M+NH₄]⁺) | little (“soft”) | to see the molecular mass when EI M⁺• is missing |
| Electrospray (ESI) | charged droplets from solution; solvent evaporates | [M+H]⁺, [M+Na]⁺, [M−H]⁻; multiply charged [M+nH]ⁿ⁺ | very soft | polar molecules, peptides, proteins, salts |
| MALDI | laser on analyte in a UV-absorbing matrix | mostly singly charged [M+H]⁺ | soft | proteins, polymers, large biomolecules |
| FAB | fast atoms (Xe, Ar) on a liquid matrix | [M+H]⁺ | soft | older method for polar, non-volatile compounds |
70 eV is far above typical organic ionisation energies (about 8–11 eV); the excess energy drives fragmentation.
Mass analysers in one table
| Analyser | Principle | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Magnetic sector | ions of the same kinetic energy follow radius \( r \) in field \( B \): \( m/z = B^2 r^2 e/2V \) | double focusing (electric + magnetic) for high resolution |
| Quadrupole | only ions of one m/z have stable paths through oscillating RF/DC fields | compact, common in GC-MS |
| Time-of-flight (TOF) | all ions get the same kinetic energy; flight time \( t \propto \sqrt{m/z} \) | wide mass range; pairs with MALDI |
| Ion trap, FT-ICR, Orbitrap | ions trapped and their oscillation frequencies measured | very high resolution (FT-ICR, Orbitrap) |
Resolution \( R = m/\Delta m \), where \( \Delta m \) is the smallest separable mass difference at mass \( m \).
Vocabulary
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Molecular ion M⁺• | the intact molecule minus one electron; an odd-electron radical cation |
| Base peak | most intense peak, set to 100 % relative abundance; not necessarily M⁺• |
| M+1, M+2 | isotope peaks one and two mass units above M |
| Fragment ion | product of bond cleavage; even-electron cation (with a radical lost) or odd-electron (with a neutral molecule lost) |
| Metastable ion | an ion that fragments in flight between source and analyser; appears as a broad peak at \( m^* = m_2^2/m_1 \) in a sector instrument |
The metastable peak links a parent and daughter: for 134 → 119, \( m^* = 119^2/134 = 105.7 \). Its presence proves that 119 is formed directly from 134.
Molecular Formula from the Mass Spectrum
The nitrogen rule
The reason: nitrogen is the only common element with an even mass (14) and an odd valence (3). As a corollary, in EI an even-electron fragment of a nitrogen-free compound has an odd m/z (CH₃CO⁺ 43, C₇H₇⁺ 91), while a fragment formed by loss of a neutral molecule (an odd-electron ion) has an even m/z (McLafferty ion 58 from 2-hexanone).
Degree of unsaturation (DBE)
$$\text{DBE} = C - \frac{H}{2} - \frac{X}{2} + \frac{N}{2} + 1$$with \( X \) the number of halogens; O and S are ignored. Each ring or π bond counts 1; a triple bond counts 2; a benzene ring counts 4. A DBE of 4 or more in a small molecule strongly suggests an aromatic ring.
The rule of 13
For a hydrocarbon of nominal mass \( M \): divide by 13, \( M = 13n + r \). The base formula is \( \text{C}_n\text{H}_{n+r} \) with DBE \( = (n - r + 2)/2 \). Then trade atoms: adding O means removing CH₄ (16); adding N means removing CH₂ (14). Example: \( M = 128 = 13 \times 9 + 11 \) gives C₉H₂₀ (DBE 0, a nonane). Because one C (12 u) has the same nominal mass as H₁₂, the same mass also fits C₁₀H₈ (DBE 7, naphthalene); chemical sense or HRMS decides between such alternatives.
Isotope patterns
| Element | Isotopes (approximate natural abundance) | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| C | ¹²C 98.9 %, ¹³C 1.1 % | M+1 about 1.1 % per carbon |
| H | ²H about 0.012 % | negligible |
| N | ¹⁵N 0.37 % | small M+1 contribution |
| O | ¹⁸O 0.20 % | small M+2 |
| S | ³⁴S about 4.2 % | M+2 about 4.4 % of M per S |
| Cl | ³⁵Cl 75.8 %, ³⁷Cl 24.2 % | M : M+2 about 3 : 1 |
| Br | ⁷⁹Br 50.7 %, ⁸¹Br 49.3 % | M : M+2 about 1 : 1 |
- Carbons: \( n_C \approx \dfrac{I(M+1)}{I(M)} \times \dfrac{100}{1.1} \) (when N is absent or few).
- \( n \) halogen atoms: the M, M+2, M+4 … intensities follow the binomial expansion \( (a + b)^n \).
| Halogens | Pattern M : M+2 : M+4 (: M+6) |
|---|---|
| Cl | 3 : 1 |
| Cl₂ | 9 : 6 : 1 (exactly 100 : 64 : 10) |
| Cl₃ | 27 : 27 : 9 : 1 |
| Br | 1 : 1 |
| Br₂ | 1 : 2 : 1 |
| ClBr | 3 : 4 : 1 |
High-resolution MS: exact mass
Atomic masses are not whole numbers (¹²C = 12.0000 by definition; ¹H 1.00783; ¹⁴N 14.00307; ¹⁶O 15.99491). Ions of the same nominal mass therefore have different exact masses:
| Formula (nominal 28) | Exact mass |
|---|---|
| CO | 27.9949 |
| N₂ | 28.0061 |
| C₂H₄ | 28.0313 |
Separating CO from C₂H₄ needs \( R \approx 28/0.0364 \approx 770 \); separating CO from N₂ needs \( R \approx 28/0.0112 \approx 2500 \). Modern HRMS measures masses to a few ppm, enough to assign a unique formula to most small organic ions.
Fragmentation of Organic Ions
Fragmentation follows the stability of the products: the cation formed and the radical or neutral lost. Three guiding ideas:
- Stevenson’s rule: when a radical cation breaks into a cation and a radical, the positive charge stays preferentially on the fragment with the lower ionisation energy.
- Even-electron rule: even-electron ions tend to fragment to other even-electron ions plus neutral molecules, not to radicals.
- Weakest bond, most stable product: branch points, benzylic and allylic bonds, and bonds α to heteroatoms break first.
Main fragmentation types
| Process | What breaks | Characteristic ions |
|---|---|---|
| σ-Cleavage at branching (alkanes) | C–C bond at the branch point, giving the more substituted carbocation | straight-chain alkanes: clusters 14 apart, m/z 29, 43, 57, 71, 85 …; branched alkanes: weak M⁺•, strong ion from cleavage at the branch |
| α-Cleavage (amines, ethers, alcohols, carbonyls) | bond next to the carbon bearing the heteroatom; the lone pair stabilises the cation (iminium, oxonium, acylium) | primary amines R–CH₂NH₂: m/z 30 (CH₂=NH₂⁺); primary alcohols: m/z 31 (CH₂=OH⁺); methyl ketones: m/z 43 (CH₃C≡O⁺) |
| Benzylic cleavage | bond β to the ring | m/z 91 (C₇H₇⁺, usually drawn as tropylium); then 91 → 65 (loss of C₂H₂) |
| Acylium formation from aryl ketones | C(=O)–R bond | ArC≡O⁺: benzoyl m/z 105 → phenyl 77 (−CO) → 51 (−C₂H₂) |
| McLafferty rearrangement | γ-H transferred to C=O oxygen through a six-membered transition state; Cα–Cβ bond breaks; an alkene is lost | odd-electron enol radical cation, even m/z (see below) |
| Retro-Diels–Alder (RDA) | cyclohexene ring splits into a diene and an alkene | cyclohexene (M 82) → butadiene radical cation m/z 54 + ethylene |
| Loss of small neutral molecules | elimination | alcohols M−18 (H₂O); acetates M−60 (AcOH); alkyl halides M−HX; aldehydes M−1 (H•) and M−29 (CHO•) |
| Loss of halogen | C–X | iodides and bromides lose X• readily |
The McLafferty rearrangement
graph LR
A["Carbonyl with γ-H
R-C(=O)-CH₂(α)-CH₂(β)-CH₂(γ)-H"] --> B["Six-membered TS:
γ-H moves to O"]
B --> C["Cα-Cβ bond breaks"]
C --> D["Enol radical cation
(odd-electron, even m/z)"]
C --> E["Neutral alkene lost"]Requirements: a C=O (or C=N, C=C, aryl) group and a hydrogen on the γ carbon. The characteristic ions:
| Compound class | McLafferty ion m/z (unsubstituted α carbon) |
|---|---|
| Aldehydes RCH₂CH₂CH₂CHO | 44 |
| Methyl ketones | 58 |
| Carboxylic acids | 60 |
| Methyl esters | 74 |
| Ethyl esters | 88 |
| Primary amides | 59 |
Example: hexan-2-one, CH₃COCH₂CH₂CH₂CH₃ (M = 100). The γ-H on C5 transfers to O; C3–C4 breaks; propene (42) is lost; the ion CH₂=C(OH)CH₃⁺• appears at m/z 58. α-Cleavage of the same ketone gives m/z 43 (CH₃CO⁺) and m/z 85 (C₄H₉CO⁺).
Fragmentation fingerprints by class
| Class | Look for |
|---|---|
| Alkanes | M⁺• weak; 14-unit clusters; base 43 or 57 |
| Alkenes | allylic cleavage (m/z 41, C₃H₅⁺); RDA for cyclohexenes |
| Alkylbenzenes | m/z 91 base peak (toluene, ethylbenzene), 65; m/z 92 by McLafferty for propylbenzene and longer chains |
| Alcohols | M⁺• weak or absent; M−18; α-cleavage (31 for RCH₂OH, 45 for RCH(OH)CH₃, 59 for R C(OH)(CH₃)₂) |
| Phenols | strong M⁺•; M−28 (CO), M−29 (CHO) |
| Ethers | α-cleavage to oxonium ions; C–O cleavage |
| Aldehydes | M−1, M−29; McLafferty 44 |
| Ketones | α-cleavage to acylium ions; McLafferty 58 (methyl ketones) |
| Esters | acylium RCO⁺, alkoxy loss (M−OR); McLafferty 74 (methyl esters) |
| Acids | M−17 (OH), M−45 (CO₂H); McLafferty 60 |
| Amines | odd M (one N); α-cleavage, base 30 for RCH₂NH₂ |
| Halides | M+2 pattern; loss of X•, loss of HX |
| Aromatic carbonyls | 105 (PhCO⁺) → 77 → 51 |
Combined Structure Determination
Real problems, and nearly all Part C spectroscopy questions, give more than one spectrum. Each technique answers a different question; use them in a fixed order.
graph TD
A["MS: M⁺•, isotope pattern,
nitrogen rule, HRMS → formula"] --> B["DBE"]
B --> C["IR: functional groups
(C=O type, OH, NH, C≡N, NO₂)"]
C --> D["UV: conjugated chromophore?
(Woodward-Fieser)"]
D --> E["¹³C + DEPT: number and type of carbons,
symmetry, carbonyl class"]
E --> F["¹H: fragments from δ, integration, J"]
F --> G["Assemble; check against
MS fragments and every datum"]| Technique | Main question it answers |
|---|---|
| MS | How heavy? Which formula? Which halogens? Which fragments? |
| IR | Which functional groups are present or absent? |
| UV-Vis | Is there conjugation, and how extended? |
| ¹³C/DEPT | How many distinct carbons, of which type? |
| ¹H | How are the protons arranged and connected? |
| 2D NMR | Which fragments connect to which? |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Base peak: most intense | Molecular ion: intact molecule minus e⁻ (may be weak) | |
| EI: M⁺•, hard, many fragments | CI/ESI/MALDI: [M+H]⁺, soft, few fragments | |
| Simple cleavage: radical lost, odd m/z ion (no N) | Rearrangement (McLafferty, RDA): molecule lost, even m/z ion | |
| Nominal mass (integers) | Exact mass (HRMS, 4 decimals) | |
| M+2 of Cl (one-third of M) | M+2 of Br (equal to M) | |
| Benzylic cleavage → m/z 91 | Benzoyl α-cleavage → m/z 105 | |
| Metastable \( m^* = m_2^2/m_1 \) | Doubly charged ion at m/z = M/2 |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Spectral data are illustrative, rounded values.
Level 1: Foundation
- A compound containing C, H, N and O has M⁺• at m/z 135. What can you say about the number of N atoms?
- A molecular ion cluster shows two peaks of almost equal height, two mass units apart. Which element is indicated?
- Which ionisation method most often gives multiply charged ions of proteins?
Answers
- Odd mass → an odd number of nitrogen atoms (1, 3, …).
- One bromine atom (⁷⁹Br : ⁸¹Br ≈ 1 : 1).
- Electrospray ionisation (ESI).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. In the EI mass spectrum of hexan-2-one (M = 100), the McLafferty rearrangement gives an ion at m/z:
(a) 43 (b) 57 (c) 58 (d) 85
Answer: (c)
γ-H transfer from C5 to O and cleavage of C3–C4 expel propene (42): \( 100 - 42 = 58 \), the enol radical cation CH₂=C(OH)CH₃⁺•. m/z 43 (CH₃CO⁺) and 85 (C₄H₉CO⁺) are α-cleavage ions; 57 is C₄H₉⁺.
Practice Q2. A compound shows M⁺• peaks at m/z 156 and 158 of almost equal intensity and a strong peak at m/z 77. It is most likely:
(a) chlorobenzene (b) bromobenzene (c) 4-chlorotoluene (d) benzyl bromide
Answer: (b)
1 : 1 at M and M+2 means one Br. C₆H₅⁷⁹Br = 72 + 5 + 79 = 156. m/z 77 is C₆H₅⁺ from loss of Br•. Benzyl bromide would have M = 170/172 and a base peak at 91.
Practice Q3. For a hydrocarbon with M = 128, the rule of 13 gives a base formula and, after exchanging H₁₂ for one C, a second formula of the same nominal mass. These are:
(a) C₉H₂₀ and C₁₀H₈ (b) C₁₀H₈ and C₁₁H₁₀ (c) C₈H₁₆O and C₉H₂₀ (d) C₉H₁₈ and C₁₀H₈
Answer: (a)
\( 128 = 13 \times 9 + 11 \): C₉H₉₊₁₁ = C₉H₂₀ (DBE \( = (9 - 11 + 2)/2 = 0 \), nonane). Replacing H₁₂ by one C (both 12 u) gives C₁₀H₈ (DBE 7, naphthalene).
Practice Q4. The minimum resolution \( R = m/\Delta m \) needed to separate CO⁺• (27.9949) from C₂H₄⁺• (28.0313) is about:
(a) 77 (b) 770 (c) 2500 (d) 28 000
Answer: (b)
\( \Delta m = 28.0313 - 27.9949 = 0.0364 \); \( R = 28/0.0364 \approx 770 \). (c) is the value for CO versus N₂ (\( \Delta m = 0.0112 \)).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. An unknown gives: MS m/z 134 (M⁺•, 35 %), 119 (100 %), 91 (40 %), 65; a metastable peak near m/z 105.7. IR 1683 cm⁻¹. ¹H NMR: δ 7.86 (2H, d, J = 8 Hz), 7.25 (2H, d, J = 8 Hz), 2.57 (3H, s), 2.41 (3H, s). Which structure and interpretation are correct?
(a) 4-methylacetophenone; 119 = M − CH₃ (acylium), 91 = 119 − CO; the metastable peak confirms 134 → 119. (b) 4-methylacetophenone; 119 = M − OH; the metastable peak confirms 119 → 91. (c) 2-phenylpropanal; 119 = M − CH₃; 91 = tropylium from the side chain. (d) 4-ethylbenzaldehyde; 119 = M − CH₃ by benzylic cleavage.
Answer: (a)
- M = 134, even, no N: C₉H₁₀O (DBE 5: ring + C=O).
- IR 1683: aryl ketone (no 2720/2820 aldehyde C–H).
- ¹H: para-disubstituted ring (two 2H doublets, J 8 Hz), CH₃CO (δ 2.57) and Ar–CH₃ (δ 2.41).
- MS: α-cleavage loses CH₃• to give CH₃C₆H₄C≡O⁺ (m/z 119, base peak); loss of CO gives C₇H₇⁺ (91), then 65.
- Metastable: \( 119^2/134 = 105.7 \), proving 134 → 119 in one step. For 119 → 91 it would be \( 91^2/119 = 69.6 \). 2-Phenylpropanal and 4-ethylbenzaldehyde are aldehydes (CHO near δ 9.7–10, IR 2720) and do not give two methyl singlets.
Practice Q6. A protein’s ESI spectrum shows adjacent peaks at m/z 1001.0 and 858.1 (proton mass 1.007). The charge on the m/z 1001.0 ion and the molecular mass are:
(a) 6+ and about 6000 Da (b) 7+ and about 7000 Da (c) 6+ and about 5000 Da (d) 5+ and about 5000 Da
Answer: (a)
For adjacent peaks \( m_1 > m_2 \) carrying \( n \) and \( n + 1 \) protons: \( n = \dfrac{m_2 - 1.007}{m_1 - m_2} = \dfrac{857.09}{142.9} \approx 6.0 \). \( M = n(m_1 - 1.007) = 6 \times 999.99 \approx 6000 \) Da. Check with the other peak: \( 7 \times (858.1 - 1.007) = 6000 \) Da.
Practice Q7. A colourless compound gives M⁺• at m/z 146 with M : M+2 : M+4 ≈ 100 : 64 : 10 and M+1 about 6.6 % of M. Its proton-decoupled ¹³C spectrum shows four lines, and its ¹H spectrum shows only aromatic protons. Which conclusions are correct?
- The compound contains two chlorine atoms.
- It contains about six carbon atoms.
- Its DBE is 4.
- It is 1,3-dichlorobenzene.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (c)
- Correct. 100 : 64 : 10 is \( (0.758 + 0.242)^2 \) scaled: two Cl (9 : 6 : 1).
- Correct. \( n_C \approx 6.6/1.1 = 6 \).
- Correct. \( 146 - 2(35) = 76 \) = C₆H₄, so C₆H₄Cl₂: DBE \( = 6 - 4/2 - 2/2 + 1 = 4 \) (a benzene ring).
- Correct. Of the three dichlorobenzenes, ortho gives 3 lines, meta 4, para 2.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| EI | 70 eV, M⁺•, many fragments |
| Soft methods | CI, ESI, MALDI, FAB: [M+H]⁺; ESI multiply charged |
| Analysers | sector \( m/z = B^2r^2e/2V \); quadrupole; TOF \( t \propto \sqrt{m/z} \); FT-ICR/Orbitrap high resolution |
| Nitrogen rule | odd M ⇔ odd number of N |
| DBE | \( C - H/2 - X/2 + N/2 + 1 \) |
| Rule of 13 | \( M = 13n + r \): \( \text{C}_n\text{H}_{n+r} \) |
| Isotopes | M+1 ≈ 1.1 % per C; Cl 3 : 1; Br 1 : 1; Cl₂ 9 : 6 : 1; Br₂ 1 : 2 : 1; S M+2 about 4.4 % |
| HRMS | CO 27.9949, N₂ 28.0061, C₂H₄ 28.0313 |
| Metastable | \( m^* = m_2^2/m_1 \) |
| α-Cleavage | amine 30, alcohol 31, acetyl 43, benzoyl 105 |
| Benzylic | 91 (tropylium) → 65 |
| McLafferty | needs γ-H; 44 (aldehyde), 58 (methyl ketone), 60 (acid), 74 (methyl ester) |
| RDA | cyclohexene 82 → 54 + C₂H₄ |
| Solving order | formula → DBE → IR → UV → ¹³C/DEPT → ¹H → check fragments |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Review the whole unit on one page: Structure Determination by Spectroscopy: Quick Revision.
- Carbocation stability, which controls which fragments form: Carbocations.
- The inorganic side of MS (metal isotope envelopes, carbonyl losses): Mass Spectrometry, Electron Spectroscopy and Microscopy.
- Back to the chapter overview.