Thunderstorm Electrification
CSIR NET Earth Sciences: thunderstorm charge structure, tripole, graupel-ice non-inductive and inductive charging, convective theory, fields under storms.
- 21 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Field Mill That Changes Its Mind
- The Thunderstorm as a Charge Separator
- What a Cloud Needs to Electrify Strongly
- Charging Mechanisms
- Point Discharge, Precipitation Current and Corona
- How Lightning Starts
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- The fair-weather field, conductivity and relaxation time, from Fair-Weather Electric Field and Atmospheric Ionization.
- Supercooled water, graupel, ice crystals and the Bergeron process, from Clouds, Precipitation and General Circulation.
- Conditional instability and CAPE, from Atmospheric Structure, Stability and Radiation Balance.
- Image charges above a conducting plane, from Electrostatics: Gauss’s Law, Laplace and Poisson.
The Hook: The Field Mill That Changes Its Mind
How CSIR NET asks it. Part C (meteorology): the tripole charge structure and its temperature levels; the field reversal under a storm; comparisons of the precipitation and convection hypotheses; the inductive and non-inductive (graupel–ice) mechanisms, the reversal temperature and why the main negative charge sits near −15 °C; conditions a cloud needs to electrify; point discharge and the mirror-image effect; image-charge numericals.
The Thunderstorm as a Charge Separator
Life cycle
A single-cell thunderstorm passes through three stages (from the Thunderstorm Project analysis of the late 1940s):
| Stage | Dynamics | Electrical state |
|---|---|---|
| Cumulus (towering) | Updraft throughout; cloud grows through the 0 °C level | Weak electrification until a mixed-phase region with graupel develops |
| Mature | Updraft and precipitation-laden downdraft side by side; heavy rain at the ground; anvil spreads at the tropopause | Strong charge separation; most lightning; field reversed at the ground |
| Dissipating | Downdraft throughout; updraft cut off | Charging stops; lightning rate falls; field at the ground often oscillates in sign (the end-of-storm oscillation) as charge regions descend and decay |
A mature cell typically lasts tens of minutes. Multicell and supercell storms and mesoscale convective systems last hours and have more complex charge.
The tripole
Balloon soundings, ground field-change networks and lightning mapping give a basic structure that is remarkably similar from storm to storm:
| Region | Sign | Typical location | Main carriers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upper screening layer | Negative (thin) | Cloud top boundary | Fair-weather negative ions attracted to the upper positive charge |
| Upper positive charge | + | Upper cloud and anvil | Small ice crystals carried up by the updraft |
| Main negative charge | − | A layer near the −10 to −25 °C levels, roughly −15 °C | Graupel and the region where graupel and crystals separate |
| Lower positive charge | + (smaller) | Near and below the 0 °C level, often in the precipitation core | Graupel and precipitation charged positive at warmer temperatures |
The charges are each tens of coulombs for the main regions; the lower positive region is usually smaller. Two observations are central:
- The main negative charge sits at roughly the same temperature level (not the same height) in storms of very different size and climate, including summer storms at mid-latitudes and in the subtropics and low-topped winter storms. Temperature, not height, controls the charging. This is the strongest single argument for an ice-phase microphysical mechanism.
- Electrification grows with the mixed phase. Strong electrification and lightning appear after radar shows precipitation-sized ice (graupel) in the region between about −10 and −20 °C, together with supercooled water and strong updrafts.
The tripole is a simplification. Soundings through convective updrafts often show four or more charge layers, and the stratiform regions of large convective systems carry their own extensive layers. For the exam, know the tripole and the temperature argument.
graph TD
T["Cloud top: thin negative screening layer"] --> U["Upper positive charge
small ice crystals carried up"]
U --> M["Main negative charge
near -10 to -25 C (about -15 C)
graupel"]
M --> L["Lower positive charge
near the 0 C level
graupel and rain"]
L --> G["Ground below: field reversed
(points up, PG negative)
corona from points"]The field at the ground
Treat the ground as a flat conductor. A point charge Q at height h has an image −Q at depth h. Directly below it, the vertical field at the surface is
$$\boxed{E_z = -\frac{2kQ}{h^2} = -\frac{Q}{2\pi\varepsilon_0 h^2}}\qquad (k = 1/4\pi\varepsilon_0 = 8.99\times10^9\ \mathrm{N\,m^2C^{-2}})$$and at horizontal distance d,
$$E_z = -\frac{2kQh}{(h^2 + d^2)^{3/2}}$$with \(z\) upward. A positive charge aloft gives a downward field (\(E_z < 0\), the fair-weather sense); a negative charge aloft gives an upward field (\(E_z > 0\), PG negative). Fields from several charges add.
Worked example. Main negative charge −30 C at 6 km, directly overhead: \(E_z = +2(8.99\times10^9)(30)/(6000)^2 = +1.5\times10^4\) V/m. The field reverses from fair-weather (about −100 V/m) to about +15 kV/m.
In practice the field measured at the ground under a storm rarely exceeds about 10 kV/m in magnitude, because sharp objects go into corona (point discharge) once the ground-level field reaches a few kV/m. The corona releases ions of the opposite sign to the charge overhead (positive under the main negative charge), building a space-charge layer that shields the ground. Aloft, where nothing shields it, the field is much larger.
Distance matters: field reversal. Because the upper positive charge is higher, its field falls off more slowly with distance than that of the main negative charge. Beneath the storm the negative charge dominates (reversed field); some kilometres away the positive charge dominates and the field returns to fair-weather polarity. This is why the field at a station often rises above fair-weather values as an anvil approaches, then reverses as the storm core arrives.
What a Cloud Needs to Electrify Strongly
| Requirement | Why |
|---|---|
| Mixed-phase region with graupel, small ice crystals and supercooled liquid water together, roughly between 0 and −40 °C | The leading charging mechanism needs riming graupel colliding with ice crystals in the presence of supercooled droplets |
| Strong updraft (several to tens of m/s) | Supplies supercooled water and crystals to the charging zone; carries the light positive crystals upward |
| Deep cloud, top well above the freezing level (lightning-producing storms usually reach −20 °C or colder) | Space for the charging zone and for gravitational separation |
| Gravity | Falling graupel and rising crystals separate the two signs over kilometres |
These requirements explain the geography of lightning: tropical continents, with deep, vigorous updrafts, produce far more lightning than oceans, where updrafts are generally weaker even when clouds are tall. Warm (ice-free) tropical clouds can rain heavily but rarely produce lightning. More on this on Lightning and the Global Electric Circuit.
Charging Mechanisms
Two big ideas: precipitation versus convection
| Hypothesis | Charge separation by | Charge generated by | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Precipitation (gravitational) hypothesis | Gravity: heavy particles (graupel, hail, rain) fall relative to light particles (crystals, cloud droplets) | Collisions between particles that transfer charge of a definite sign (inductive or non-inductive) | Widely accepted as dominant, through non-inductive graupel–ice charging |
| Convective hypothesis (Grenet; Vonnegut) | Updrafts and downdrafts move space charge | Pre-existing fair-weather ions, corona ions from the ground and ions captured at cloud boundaries | Can contribute, especially early; not believed sufficient by itself for strong electrification |
1. Non-inductive graupel–ice charging (the leading mechanism)
When a riming graupel particle (or small hail) collides with a small ice crystal in the presence of supercooled droplets and the two separate, a small charge (of order femtocoulombs to tens of femtocoulombs per collision in laboratory experiments) is transferred without needing an external field. That is why it is called non-inductive.
Laboratory work (from Takahashi’s experiments in the late 1970s onwards, and by Saunders and co-workers) shows that the sign of the charge on the graupel depends on:
- temperature, and
- the liquid water content (or, more precisely, the rate of rime accretion on the graupel).
For the moderate liquid water contents typical of thunderstorm updrafts:
| Temperature | Graupel acquires | Ice crystal acquires |
|---|---|---|
| Colder than the reversal temperature (roughly −10 to −20 °C, depending on liquid water content) | Negative | Positive |
| Warmer than the reversal temperature | Positive | Negative |
At high rime-accretion rates graupel tends to charge positive over a wider range of temperatures.
Building the tripole from this table.
- In the main charging zone (colder than the reversal temperature) graupel charges negative and crystals positive.
- The updraft carries the light positive crystals up to form the upper positive charge; the heavier negative graupel stays or falls, forming the main negative charge near the reversal level, around −15 °C.
- Graupel falling below the reversal level into warmer air charges positive, forming the lower positive charge near 0 °C.
A favoured physical explanation is the relative growth rate idea: the ice surface growing faster by vapour deposition acquires positive charge in a collision. Riming changes the graupel’s surface temperature and vapour growth, so liquid water content and temperature together decide which surface grows faster. The details are still researched; the sign table is what Part C uses.
An older explanation is the thermoelectric effect (Latham and Mason): in ice, H⁺ ions are more mobile than OH⁻ ions. Across a temperature gradient the excess H⁺ diffuses to the colder end, which becomes positive, leaving the warmer end negative. Graupel warmed by freezing rime (latent heat) is warmer than the crystals it touches, so on separation the crystal (colder) takes positive charge and the graupel negative. The measured charges are larger than this effect predicts, which is why it is now considered a partial explanation at most.
2. Inductive (polarization) charging
In a downward-pointing field (the fair-weather sense, which is also the sense of the field inside the cloud between the upper positive and the main negative charge), a conducting precipitation particle is polarized: positive charge is induced on its lower half and negative on its upper half. For a conducting sphere of radius r in a uniform field E, the induced surface charge density is \(3\varepsilon_0E\cos\theta\), and the charge on each hemisphere is
$$q_{hemisphere} = 3\pi\varepsilon_0 r^2 E$$A small cloud particle carried up by the updraft strikes the underside of a falling graupel particle, touches it briefly and bounces away carrying some of the induced positive charge. The graupel is left negative, falls; the small particle, positive, rises. The resulting charge separation strengthens the field, which polarizes particles more strongly: positive feedback.
Limits: it needs a pre-existing field, enough contact time for charge to flow (difficult for ice-ice contacts, which conduct poorly), and rebounding (drop–drop collisions mostly coalesce). It is now thought to help amplify fields once they are strong, not to start electrification.
Worked example. A graupel particle of radius 1 mm in a field of 100 kV/m: \(q = 3\pi(8.854\times10^{-12})(10^{-3})^2(10^{5}) \approx 8.3\times10^{-12}\) C, about 8 pC available on each hemisphere. In the fair-weather field of 100 V/m it would be a thousand times smaller, about 8 fC: inductive charging is weak until a field already exists.
3. Convective charging
Fair-weather positive space charge near the ground (and positive corona ions under a developing cloud) is drawn into the cloud base by the updraft and carried aloft. The positive charge at the top attracts negative fair-weather ions from the clear air above, which attach to cloud particles at the cloud’s upper boundary (the screening layer). Downdrafts at the cloud edges carry this negative charge down. Once started, the redistribution increases corona at the ground and so feeds itself. The mechanism is elegant and explains the screening layers, but by itself it does not account for the observed charge, its fixed temperature level or the link with graupel.
4. Other classical mechanisms
| Mechanism | What happens | Sign |
|---|---|---|
| Wilson’s selective ion capture | A falling drop polarized in the fair-weather field captures negative ions on its positive lower face and repels positive ions | Drop becomes negative; requires a pre-existing field |
| Lenard (balloelectric) effect | Breakup or splashing of water drops | Large drops positive, fine spray and air negative (seen near waterfalls) |
| Workman–Reynolds (freezing potential) effect | Freezing of dilute solutions separates charge across the ice–water interface | Sign depends on the solute |
| Thermoelectric effect | H⁺ diffusion in ice down a temperature gradient | Colder part positive |
These are real effects but are now considered secondary to graupel–ice collisions.
Point Discharge, Precipitation Current and Corona
- Point discharge (corona). Under a storm, the enhanced field at tips of trees, grass and masts ionizes the air and emits ions of the sign opposite to the charge overhead. Under the main negative charge, positive ions flow upward: a positive current from ground to cloud. Visible corona on masts and aircraft is St Elmo’s fire.
- Precipitation current. Rain falling from a thunderstorm carries charge to the ground. The charge on raindrops is frequently of the opposite sign to that expected from the overhead charge and tends to mirror the field: this is the mirror-image effect, explained by drops capturing corona ions of the opposite sign as they fall through the space-charge layer near the ground.
- Lightning neutralises charge directly (next page).
Over land, these three processes together transfer net negative charge to the Earth under thunderstorms, which is the generator side of the global circuit.
How Lightning Starts
Laboratory breakdown of dry air at sea-level pressure requires about 3 MV/m, and the breakdown field scales with air density. At 6 km (density about 0.54 of sea level) that is about 1.6 MV/m. Balloon soundings inside thunderstorms rarely find fields larger than a few hundred kV/m, an order of magnitude less. Two ideas bridge the gap:
- Hydrometeor-initiated corona. The field at the tips of elongated ice particles or deformed drops is enhanced enough to start streamers, which can grow in a field far below the conventional breakdown value.
- Runaway electron breakdown. Energetic secondary electrons from cosmic rays can be accelerated into avalanches of relativistic electrons at fields well below conventional breakdown. This is linked to the X-ray and gamma-ray bursts observed from thunderstorms.
Either way, lightning starts in the high-field region between charge layers, most often between the main negative and upper positive charge (intracloud) or between the main negative and lower positive charge (often the starting point of cloud-to-ground flashes).
Charging rate and flash rate. A vigorous storm separates charge at a rate of order 1 A. If each flash neutralises about 20 C, the storm can sustain about one flash every 20 s. Strong updrafts raise the charging current and so the flash rate.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Non-inductive charging: no field needed; sign depends on temperature and liquid water | vs | Inductive charging: needs an existing field; sign set by field direction |
| Precipitation hypothesis: gravity separates charged particles | vs | Convective hypothesis: air motions carry space charge |
| Reversal temperature (graupel charge sign changes) | vs | 0 °C level (lower positive charge sits near it, but the sign reversal is colder) |
| Main negative charge: same temperature level in different storms | vs | Same height: it is not; storm tops and freezing levels differ |
| Point discharge current: ions from the ground, upward positive under a negative cloud | vs | Precipitation current: charge carried by rain, often the mirror image of the field |
| Lenard effect: drop breakup, drops positive, air negative | vs | Thermoelectric effect: ice in a temperature gradient, colder end positive |
| Field under the storm core: reversed (PG negative) | vs | Field a few tens of km away: fair-weather polarity, often enhanced |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- At roughly what temperature level is the main negative charge of a thunderstorm found?
- Which particles carry the upper positive charge?
- What is the sign of the potential gradient at the ground directly beneath the main negative charge?
Answers
- About −15 °C (the −10 to −25 °C layer).
- Small ice crystals lifted by the updraft after charging positively in collisions with graupel.
- Negative (the field points upward), the reverse of fair weather.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A charge of −30 C sits 6 km directly above flat, conducting ground. The vertical electric field at the ground directly below is about:
- (a) 7.5 kV/m, pointing up
- (b) 15 kV/m, pointing up
- (c) 15 kV/m, pointing down
- (d) 30 kV/m, pointing up
Answer and explanation
(b). With the image charge, \(E = 2kQ/h^2 = 2(8.99\times10^9)(30)/(3.6\times10^7) = 1.50\times10^4\) V/m. The charge is negative, so the field points toward it: up. Option (a) forgets the image.
Q2 (practice). In laboratory experiments on riming graupel colliding with ice crystals at moderate liquid water content, the graupel charges negatively at −20 °C and positively at −5 °C. This result best explains:
- (a) the negative screening layer at cloud top
- (b) the main negative charge near −15 °C together with the lower positive charge near 0 °C
- (c) the mirror-image effect in precipitation currents
- (d) positive point-discharge currents under storms
Answer and explanation
(b). Colder than the reversal temperature graupel is negative (main negative region, crystals carry positive charge aloft); warmer, graupel is positive (lower positive region). The screening layer comes from fair-weather ions; the mirror-image effect and point discharge involve corona ions near the ground.
Q3 (practice). Which observation argues most strongly that thunderstorm charging is an ice-phase microphysical process rather than a purely convective one?
- (a) Storms produce corona at the ground.
- (b) The main negative charge occurs at a similar temperature level in storms of very different heights and climates.
- (c) The field at the ground reverses under storms.
- (d) Rain carries charge to the ground.
Answer and explanation
(b). A charging zone tied to temperature, not height or cloud size, points to a temperature-dependent microphysical process. (a), (c) and (d) occur whatever the charging mechanism.
Q4 (practice). A thunderstorm cell charges at 1.5 A and each lightning flash neutralises 25 C. If the cell is in a steady state in which all separated charge is removed by lightning, the flash rate is about:
- (a) 0.6 per minute
- (b) 3.6 per minute
- (c) 16.7 per minute
- (d) 37.5 per minute
Answer and explanation
(b). Time between flashes \(= Q/I = 25/1.5 = 16.7\) s, so \(60/16.7 = 3.6\) flashes per minute.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Model a storm as point charges directly above a station on flat, conducting ground: upper positive +40 C at 12 km, main negative −40 C at 7 km and lower positive +10 C at 4 km. Take \(k = 8.99\times10^9\) SI units.
(i) Find the vertical field at the station with all three charges. (ii) Repeat without the lower positive charge. (iii) What does the comparison tell you about interpreting a single field-mill reading under a storm?
Answer and worked solution
Each charge gives \(|E| = 2kQ/h^2\); positive charge → field down (\(E_z < 0\)), negative → field up (\(E_z > 0\)). \(2k = 1.798\times10^{10}\).
- −40 C at 7 km: \(1.798\times10^{10}\times40/4.9\times10^7 = 1.467\times10^4\) V/m, up.
- +40 C at 12 km: \(1.798\times10^{10}\times40/1.44\times10^8 = 4.99\times10^3\) V/m, down.
- +10 C at 4 km: \(1.798\times10^{10}\times10/1.6\times10^7 = 1.124\times10^4\) V/m, down.
(i) \(E_z = 14{,}670 - 4{,}990 - 11{,}240 \approx -1{,}550\) V/m: the field points down, fair-weather polarity, about 1.6 kV/m.
(ii) \(E_z = 14{,}670 - 4{,}990 \approx +9{,}680\) V/m: reversed, about 9.7 kV/m upward.
(iii) A modest lower positive charge, being close to the ground, can mask the main negative charge directly beneath it (the \(1/h^2\) dependence weights low charges heavily). A ground reading of fair-weather polarity under a storm does not mean the storm is uncharged. To locate charges, use a network of field mills at different distances, or field changes from lightning.
Q2 (practice). A storm is modelled as a vertical dipole: +40 C at 10 km and −40 C at 6 km, above flat conducting ground. A station moves away from the point beneath the storm.
(i) Find the vertical field directly beneath the storm. (ii) At what horizontal distance does the field change sign? (iii) Which statements are correct?
(A) Beneath the storm the potential gradient is negative. (B) Beyond the reversal distance the field has fair-weather polarity. (C) The reversal distance would increase if the positive charge were higher. (D) At large distances the field from the dipole and its image falls off as \(1/d^2\).
- (a) A and B only
- (b) A, B and C only
- (c) A, B and D only
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(i) −40 C at 6 km: \(1.798\times10^{10}\times40/3.6\times10^7 = 1.998\times10^4\) V/m up; +40 C at 10 km: \(7.19\times10^3\) V/m down. Net \(\approx +12.8\) kV/m (up, PG negative).
(ii) Off-axis, \(|E_z| = 2kQh/(h^2+d^2)^{3/2}\). Setting the two equal (h in km, Q cancels):
\[\frac{10}{(100+d^2)^{3/2}} = \frac{6}{(36+d^2)^{3/2}} \;\Rightarrow\; \frac{100+d^2}{36+d^2} = \left(\frac{10}{6}\right)^{2/3} = 1.406\]\(100 + d^2 = 1.406(36 + d^2) \Rightarrow 0.406\,d^2 = 49.4 \Rightarrow d \approx 11.0\) km.
(iii) (b) A, B and C.
- (A) correct (part i).
- (B) correct: beyond about 11 km the higher positive charge dominates and the field points down.
- (C) correct: in general the condition is \(\dfrac{h_+^2+d^2}{h_-^2+d^2} = (h_+/h_-)^{2/3}\). With the positive charge at 12 km, \((12/6)^{2/3} = 1.587\); \(144 + d^2 = 1.587(36 + d^2) \Rightarrow 0.587\,d^2 = 86.9 \Rightarrow d \approx 12.2\) km. The reversal distance increases.
- (D) wrong: each charge and its image form a vertical dipole, giving \(E_z \approx 2kQh/d^3\) at large d. The net field is \(2k(Q_+h_+ + Q_-h_-)/d^3 = 2k(400 - 240)\ \mathrm{C\,km}/d^3\), which is non-zero and falls off as \(1/d^3\), not \(1/d^2\).
Q3 (practice). Consider these statements about thunderstorm charging.
(A) Inductive charging is most effective when a small particle strikes the lower surface of a falling graupel particle in a downward-directed field and rebounds. (B) The non-inductive graupel–ice mechanism requires supercooled liquid water to be present. (C) The convective hypothesis explains why the main negative charge occurs near −15 °C in storms of different heights. (D) The thermoelectric effect predicts that the colder particle in a graupel–crystal collision acquires positive charge.
Which are correct?
- (a) A, B and D only
- (b) A and C only
- (c) B and C only
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B and D.
- (A) correct: the lower face is positive in a downward field; the rebounding particle takes positive charge, the graupel is left negative, and the field is reinforced.
- (B) correct: charge transfer in laboratory graupel–crystal collisions is significant only when the graupel is riming, that is, in supercooled cloud.
- (C) wrong: the convective mechanism moves pre-existing ions and has no reason to fix charge at a temperature level; the fixed temperature is the argument against it.
- (D) correct: H⁺ ions diffuse towards the colder side, making it positive.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Value or rule |
|---|---|
| Tripole | Upper +, main − (about −15 °C), lower + (near 0 °C); thin − screening layer at the top |
| Charge magnitudes | Tens of coulombs in the main regions; lower positive smaller |
| Requirements | Mixed phase (graupel + crystals + supercooled water), strong updraft, top colder than about −20 °C |
| Non-inductive charging | No field needed; colder than reversal temperature (roughly −10 to −20 °C) graupel −, crystal +; warmer graupel + |
| Inductive charging | Needs field; \(q = 3\pi\varepsilon_0r^2E\) per hemisphere; positive feedback |
| Convective hypothesis | Updrafts lift positive space charge; screening layer negative ions carried down |
| Other effects | Wilson ion capture (drop −), Lenard (drops +, air −), Workman–Reynolds, thermoelectric (cold end +) |
| Ground field below Q at h | \(2kQ/h^2\); off-axis \(2kQh/(h^2+d^2)^{3/2}\) |
| Field at ground under storm | Reversed, up to about 10 kV/m (limited by corona) |
| Field reversal distance | Some km to over 10 km from the core; upper positive dominates further out |
| Breakdown field | About 3 MV/m at sea level, scales with density; in-cloud fields much lower |
| Charging current | Of order 1 A per storm; flash every few tens of seconds |
| Mirror-image effect | Rain charge opposite to the field-implied sign; corona ion capture |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
The charge has been separated; next it is neutralised. Lightning flashes, their phases and the way storms worldwide keep the fair-weather field alive are on Lightning and the Global Electric Circuit. Revise the fair-weather side on Fair-Weather Electric Field and Atmospheric Ionization, or return to the chapter overview.