Energy Flow, Food Webs and the Microbial Loop
CSIR NET Ocean Sciences: trophic levels and transfer efficiency, marine pyramids, cascades, the microbial loop and viral shunt, and the biological carbon pump.
- 17 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Primary and secondary production, growth efficiencies and new production: Primary and Secondary Production and Plankton.
- Fish production and fisheries: Nekton, Benthos and Fisheries.
- General ecosystem ecology, pyramids and nutrient cycles: Ecosystem Ecology and Human Impacts.
- Carbon and nitrogen in sea water and isotopes: Stable Isotopes and Geochemical Cycles.
The Hook: The Missing Half
Energy Flow
Principles
- Energy flows one way: from sunlight (or chemical energy at vents) through producers to consumers and is lost as heat at every step (second law of thermodynamics). Nutrients cycle.
- Lindeman’s (1942) trophic-dynamic view treats each trophic level as a compartment receiving energy from the one below.
- Trophic transfer efficiency (TE) is production at level \( n+1 \) divided by production at level \( n \). It is the product of how much is eaten (exploitation efficiency), how much of that is assimilated, and how much of that becomes growth. In marine food webs the average is about 10%, with a range of roughly 5–20%.
The production at trophic level \( n \) is
$$P_n = P_1 \times \text{TE}^{\,n-1}$$Fractional trophic levels
Most marine consumers eat at more than one level. Their trophic level is
$$\text{TL}_i = 1 + \sum_j \text{DC}_{ij}\,\text{TL}_j$$where \( \text{DC}_{ij} \) is the fraction of prey \( j \) in the diet of \( i \). Primary producers and detritus have TL = 1; herbivorous copepods about 2; sardines about 2.5–3; tunas and sharks 4 or more.
Ecological pyramids in the sea
| Pyramid | Shape in the open ocean | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Numbers | often inverted at the base (one diatom, many bacteria; one whale, many lice) | depends on body size |
| Biomass (standing stock) | can be inverted: zooplankton biomass may exceed phytoplankton | phytoplankton turn over in days and are grazed as fast as they grow |
| Energy (production per unit time) | never inverted | thermodynamics: each level produces less than the one below |
Food-chain length and fish yield
The number of steps between producers and fish depends on the size of the producers:
| System | Dominant producers | Typical steps to harvested fish | Consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coastal upwelling | large diatoms, chains | about 1–2 (diatoms → anchovy) | most of production reaches fish |
| Shelves | mixed | about 3 | moderate |
| Oligotrophic open ocean | pico-cyanobacteria (Prochlorococcus) | about 4–5 (pico → flagellates → ciliates → copepods → small fish → tuna) | very little reaches fish |
Ryther’s classic 1969 analysis used exactly this reasoning: although the open ocean makes most of the world’s primary production, its long food chains and lower efficiencies mean that upwelling zones and shelves, covering a small fraction of the area, produce most of the fish. Because \( \text{TE}^n \) is a power, a few extra steps change fish production by orders of magnitude.
Size spectra
Marine food webs are strongly size-structured: predators are usually much larger than their prey, so trophic level rises with body size. When biomass is grouped into logarithmic size classes, it is roughly constant from bacteria to whales in many ocean samples (the “Sheldon spectrum”), because the loss of energy at each step is balanced by the slower metabolism of larger organisms.
Food Webs: Structure and Control
Grazing and detrital pathways
| Pathway | Start | Importance |
|---|---|---|
| Grazing food chain | living phytoplankton eaten by zooplankton | dominates upwelling and blooms |
| Detrital food chain | dead organic matter (marine snow, faecal pellets, plant litter) consumed by bacteria and detritivores | dominates estuaries, mangroves, salt marshes and the deep-sea floor |
| Microbial food web | dissolved organic matter used by bacteria, which are eaten by protists | dominates oligotrophic open ocean |
Top-down and bottom-up control
- Bottom-up control: nutrient supply and primary production set the abundance of every level above (upwelling strength controls sardines).
- Top-down control: predators set the abundance of the levels below.
- Trophic cascade: a change at the top propagates down, alternating in sign. The classic marine case: sea otters eat sea urchins; where otters were hunted out, urchins multiplied and grazed kelp forests into “urchin barrens”; where otters returned, kelp recovered.
- Keystone species: a species whose effect is far larger than its abundance suggests. Paine’s experiments on a rocky shore in Washington State, USA, in the 1960s showed that removing the predatory sea star Pisaster let mussels monopolise the space and cut the number of species sharply.
- Wasp-waist control: in upwelling systems a few species of small pelagic fish (sardines, anchovies) sit at a narrow middle level; they control their zooplankton prey from above and their predators from below.
graph TD
A[Sea otters] -->|eat| B[Sea urchins]
B -->|graze| C[Kelp forest]
C -->|shelter and food| D[Fishes and invertebrates]
A -. otters removed so urchins boom and kelp is lost .-> CThe Microbial Loop
The idea
In 1974 Pomeroy argued that microbes, not copepods, handle much of the ocean’s energy flow. Azam and colleagues in 1983 named and described the microbial loop: phytoplankton release dissolved organic matter (DOM); heterotrophic bacteria take it up; bacteria are eaten by heterotrophic nanoflagellates; these are eaten by ciliates; and ciliates are eaten by copepods, returning some of the carbon to the classic food chain.
graph LR
P[Phytoplankton] -->|exudation, sloppy feeding, lysis| D[Dissolved organic matter]
P -->|grazing| Z[Copepods]
D -->|uptake| B[Heterotrophic bacteria]
B -->|grazing| F[Heterotrophic nanoflagellates]
F -->|grazing| C[Ciliates]
C -->|grazing| Z
Z --> FI[Fish]
B -->|respiration| CO2[CO2 and regenerated NH4+ and PO4]
V[Viruses] -->|lysis| D
B -.infected by.-> VSources of DOM
- Exudation (leakage) of photosynthate by healthy phytoplankton.
- Sloppy feeding by zooplankton that break cells while eating.
- Excretion by zooplankton.
- Viral lysis of bacteria and phytoplankton.
- Dissolution of sinking particles.
Key numbers and terms
| Quantity | Typical value |
|---|---|
| Heterotrophic bacteria in surface water | about \( 10^5 \)–\( 10^6 \) cells mL\(^{-1}\) |
| Viruses | about \( 10^6 \)–\( 10^7 \) mL\(^{-1}\), roughly 10 per bacterium |
| Share of NPP passing through bacteria as DOM | large; often quoted as up to about half |
| Bacterial growth efficiency | \( \text{BGE} = \dfrac{\text{BP}}{\text{BP} + \text{BR}} \), commonly about 10–30% in the open ocean |
| Bacterial carbon demand | \( \text{BCD} = \text{BP} + \text{BR} = \text{BP}/\text{BGE} \) |
BP is bacterial production and BR bacterial respiration.
Link or sink?
Is the microbial loop a link that passes energy to larger animals, or a sink that respires it away?
- Each step (bacteria → flagellates → ciliates → copepods) has low efficiency, so after three or four steps only a small fraction of the DOM carbon reaches copepods. In energy terms, the loop is mostly a sink.
- But it regenerates nutrients (ammonium, phosphate) in the euphotic zone, sustaining regenerated production. In nutrient-poor gyres this recycling keeps the whole system running.
- It also feeds small cells to protists whose own grazers are larger, so in oligotrophic water it is the main route by which any energy reaches metazoans.
The viral shunt
Viruses lyse bacteria and phytoplankton, turning living particulate matter back into DOM that is used by other bacteria. This viral shunt:
- keeps carbon and nutrients inside the microbial loop and away from grazers;
- raises community respiration and nutrient regeneration;
- may make cells more prone to aggregation and sinking when lysis products are sticky;
- sustains diversity by “killing the winner”: the most abundant strain is most likely to meet its virus, so no strain dominates for long;
- moves genes between hosts (transduction); cyanophages carry photosynthesis genes.
Mixotrophy
Many protists are both photosynthetic and phagotrophic (many dinoflagellates and haptophytes, some ciliates). Mixotrophs blur the line between producer and consumer and can increase the transfer of energy to larger organisms in nutrient-poor water, because they gain nutrients from prey and energy from light.
The Biological Carbon Pump
The ocean moves carbon from the surface to depth by three pumps:
| Pump | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Solubility pump | cold, dense high-latitude water absorbs more CO\(_2\) and sinks |
| Organic (soft-tissue) biological pump | phytoplankton fix CO\(_2\); organic matter sinks as aggregates (marine snow), faecal pellets and dead organisms, or is carried down by vertical migrators and by mixing of DOC |
| Carbonate (hard-tissue) pump | calcifiers (coccolithophores, foraminifera, pteropods) make CaCO\(_3\) that sinks; calcification itself releases CO\(_2\) at the surface (the carbonate counter-pump) |
How much sinks, and how deep
- Export production leaves the euphotic zone; the e-ratio = export / NPP, typically about 0.1–0.3 and higher in blooms.
- Most exported carbon is remineralised in the upper few hundred metres by bacteria and zooplankton. The flux decreases with depth according to the empirical Martin curve (Martin and colleagues, 1987):
With \( b = 0.858 \), only about 14% of the flux at 100 m reaches 1,000 m. Carbon remineralised below the deepest winter mixed layer is stored for centuries.
- Ballast: dense minerals (calcite, opal, dust) make particles sink faster and may protect organic carbon, so export is linked to the kind of plankton present.
- Microbial carbon pump: microbes convert labile DOM into refractory DOM that resists further breakdown and persists for thousands of years in the deep ocean, a further route of carbon storage.
Linked cycles
| Process | Organisms | Where |
|---|---|---|
| N\(_2\) fixation | Trichodesmium, unicellular cyanobacteria, symbionts of diatoms | warm, stratified, nitrate-poor water |
| Nitrification (NH\(_4^+\) → NO\(_2^-\) → NO\(_3^-\)) | ammonia-oxidising archaea and bacteria, nitrite oxidisers | below the euphotic zone |
| Denitrification (NO\(_3^-\) → N\(_2\)) | heterotrophic bacteria using nitrate | oxygen minimum zones (Arabian Sea, eastern tropical Pacific) and sediments |
| Anammox (NH\(_4^+\) + NO\(_2^-\) → N\(_2\)) | anammox bacteria | OMZs and sediments |
| DMS production | DMSP from coccolithophores, Phaeocystis, dinoflagellates, cleaved to dimethyl sulfide | surface ocean; DMS forms sulfate aerosol and cloud nuclei (the CLAW hypothesis, 1987, proposed a climate feedback through cloud albedo) |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Pyramid of biomass: can invert in the sea | vs | Pyramid of energy: never inverts |
| Transfer efficiency: production ratio between levels | vs | Gross growth efficiency: one population’s growth ÷ ingestion |
| Microbial loop: DOM → bacteria → protists → copepods | vs | Viral shunt: lysis returns cells to DOM, bypassing grazers |
| BGE = BP/(BP + BR) | vs | BCD = BP + BR |
| Bottom-up: resources control | vs | Top-down: predators control |
| Keystone species: large effect relative to abundance | vs | Dominant species: large effect because abundant |
| Soft-tissue pump: organic carbon | vs | Carbonate pump: CaCO\(_3\) (releases CO\(_2\) at the surface when formed) |
| Export production (leaves euphotic zone) | vs | Sequestration (below the deepest winter mixed layer) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who named and described the microbial loop in 1983?
- Which pyramid can never be inverted?
- What is the approximate value of the exponent \( b \) in the Martin curve?
Answers
- Azam and colleagues (building on Pomeroy, 1974).
- The pyramid of energy (production).
- About 0.86 (0.858).
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A fish’s diet is 60% copepods (TL 2.2) and 40% small fish (TL 3.1). Its trophic level is:
- (a) 2.56
- (b) 2.65
- (c) 3.56
- (d) 4.30
Answer and explanation
(c). \( \text{TL} = 1 + 0.6(2.2) + 0.4(3.1) = 1 + 1.32 + 1.24 = 3.56 \). (a) forgets the “1 +”.
Q2 (practice). Bacterial production is 2 and bacterial respiration 6 µg C L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\). The bacterial growth efficiency and the bacterial carbon demand are:
- (a) 33% and 6
- (b) 25% and 8
- (c) 25% and 6
- (d) 75% and 8
Answer and explanation
(b). BGE = 2/(2 + 6) = 25%; BCD = 2 + 6 = 8 µg C L\(^{-1}\) d\(^{-1}\). (a) divides BP by BR.
Q3 (practice). The particulate organic carbon flux at 100 m is 5.0 mmol C m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\). Using the Martin curve with \( b = 0.858 \), the flux at 1,000 m is about:
- (a) 0.50
- (b) 0.69
- (c) 1.25
- (d) 4.3
Answer and explanation
(b). \( F = 5.0 \times 10^{-0.858} = 5.0 \times 0.139 = 0.69 \) mmol C m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\): about 14% survives. (a) assumes the flux falls in proportion to depth (\( b = 1 \)).
Q4 (practice). Removal of sea otters from a coast is followed by an increase in sea urchins and loss of kelp. This is best described as:
- (a) bottom-up control
- (b) a trophic cascade from a keystone predator
- (c) competitive exclusion between urchins and kelp
- (d) the microbial loop
Answer and explanation
(b). The effect alternates down the chain (predator down, herbivore up, plant down): a top-down trophic cascade. Otters act as a keystone species.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Compare two regions (practice values):
| Region | NPP (g C m\(^{-2}\) yr\(^{-1}\)) | Transfers from producers to harvested fish | Transfer efficiency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oligotrophic open ocean | 50 | 4 | 10% |
| Coastal upwelling | 300 | 2 | 20% |
(i) Calculate fish production per m\(^2\) in each. (ii) By what factor does the upwelling region exceed the open ocean? (iii) If the upwelling region covers 0.1% of the ocean area and the open ocean 90%, which produces more fish in total?
Answer and worked solution
- Open ocean: \( 50 \times 0.1^4 = 0.005 \) g C m\(^{-2}\) yr\(^{-1}\). Upwelling: \( 300 \times 0.2^2 = 12 \) g C m\(^{-2}\) yr\(^{-1}\).
- \( 12/0.005 = \) 2,400 times, although primary production differs only sixfold.
- Totals scale with area: open ocean \( 0.005 \times 0.90 = 0.0045 \); upwelling \( 12 \times 0.001 = 0.012 \) (in the same arbitrary area units). Upwelling produces about 2.7 times more fish from 0.1% of the area. This is the logic of Ryther’s argument.
Q2 (practice). In an oligotrophic gyre, 30 units of carbon per day are released as DOM and taken up by bacteria. Assume a growth efficiency of 30% at each step: bacteria, heterotrophic nanoflagellates, ciliates, and copepods eating ciliates. Compare with 30 units of phytoplankton eaten directly by copepods (copepod growth efficiency 30%).
(i) How much copepod production results from each route? (ii) How much carbon is respired in the microbial route before reaching copepods? (iii) Which statements are correct?
(A) The microbial route delivers about 2.7% as much copepod production as the direct route. (B) Viral lysis of 50% of the bacterial production would further reduce what reaches copepods. (C) The microbial route has no ecological value because it is mostly a sink. (D) The microbial route regenerates ammonium that can support regenerated production.
- (a) A, B and D
- (b) A and C only
- (c) B, C and D
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
- Direct: \( 30 \times 0.3 = 9 \) units of copepod production. Microbial: bacteria \( 30 \times 0.3 = 9 \); flagellates \( 9 \times 0.3 = 2.7 \); ciliates \( 2.7 \times 0.3 = 0.81 \); copepods \( 0.81 \times 0.3 = 0.243 \) units.
- Carbon reaching ciliate biomass is 0.81, so before reaching copepods \( 30 - 0.81 = 29.19 \) units have been respired, egested or excreted (most of it respired to CO\(_2\)).
- (a) A, B and D.
- (A) \( 0.243/9 = 0.027 \), i.e. 2.7%. Correct.
- (B) Correct: the viral shunt returns half the bacterial production to DOM, so flagellates get 4.5 instead of 9.
- (C) Wrong: the loop recycles nutrients and is the main route to metazoans when cells are too small for copepods.
- (D) Correct.
Q3 (practice). At a station, NPP is 600 mg C m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\) and sediment traps catch 90 mg C m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\) at 100 m. Assume the Martin curve with \( b = 0.858 \). Which statements are correct?
(A) The e-ratio is 0.15. (B) The flux at 500 m is about 23 mg C m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\). (C) About 2% of NPP reaches 1,000 m. (D) If the community shifted to heavily ballasted coccolithophore aggregates, \( b \) would likely become smaller.
- (a) A, B, C and D
- (b) A and B only
- (c) A, B and C only
- (d) C and D only
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B, C and D.
- (A) \( 90/600 = 0.15 \). Correct.
- (B) \( 90 \times 5^{-0.858} = 90 \times 0.251 = 22.6 \). Correct.
- (C) \( 90 \times 10^{-0.858} = 12.5 \) mg C m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\); \( 12.5/600 = 2.1\% \). Correct.
- (D) Correct: faster-sinking, ballasted particles spend less time in the twilight zone, so attenuation is weaker and \( b \) smaller.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Energy vs nutrients | energy flows one way; nutrients cycle |
| Lindeman | trophic-dynamic concept, 1942 |
| Transfer efficiency | about 10% (5–20%); \( P_n = P_1 \text{TE}^{n-1} \) |
| Fractional TL | \( 1 + \sum \text{DC}_{ij}\text{TL}_j \) |
| Pyramids | biomass may invert; energy never |
| Chain length | upwelling 1–2 steps; open ocean 4–5 |
| Control | bottom-up, top-down, cascades (otter–urchin–kelp), keystone (Pisaster, Paine), wasp-waist |
| Microbial loop | Pomeroy 1974; Azam et al. 1983; DOM → bacteria → HNF → ciliates → copepods |
| Abundances | bacteria about \( 10^6 \) mL\(^{-1}\); viruses about 10× more |
| BGE, BCD | BP/(BP + BR); BP + BR |
| Viral shunt | lysis to DOM, keeps C in loop, “kill the winner” |
| Pumps | solubility, soft-tissue, carbonate (counter-pump) |
| e-ratio | export/NPP, about 0.1–0.3 |
| Martin curve | \( F = F_{100}(z/100)^{-0.858} \); 14% from 100 to 1,000 m |
| N cycle | N\(_2\) fixation (Trichodesmium); denitrification and anammox in OMZs |
| DMS | from DMSP; CLAW hypothesis (1987) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Human, Climate and Pollution Impacts on Marine Life: what warming, acidification, deoxygenation and fishing do to these webs and pumps.
- Primary and Secondary Production and Plankton: revise new production and the f-ratio, which link to export.
- Paleoceanographic Proxies and Paleo-SST Methods: how productivity and the pump are reconstructed from sediments.
- Biological Oceanography: chapter overview.