Nutrient and Trace-Metal Cycling in the Ocean
CSIR NET Ocean Sciences: Redfield ratios, N, P and Si cycles, AOU and preformed nutrients, N*, trace-metal profile types, scavenging and Th-234 export.
- 17 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Composition of Seawater and Residence Times — the conservative, nutrient-type and scavenged classification this page develops.
- Estuaries, Hydrothermal Vents, Anoxic Basins and HNLC Waters — OMZs, iron limitation and vent sources, which feed into these cycles.
- Stable Isotopes and Geochemical Cycles — the global N, P and S cycles in outline.
The Hook: Cadmium That Behaves Like Phosphate
How CSIR NET asks it. Part C questions on Redfield stoichiometry, AOU and preformed nutrients, N\(^*\) and denitrification, f-ratio and new production, matching metals to profile types, and short numericals on \(^{234}\)Th export.
The Nutrients and Their Forms
| Nutrient | Main dissolved forms | Used by | Sink at the surface | Regeneration |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nitrogen | NO\(_3^-\) (dominant at depth), NO\(_2^-\), NH\(_4^+\), urea, DON, N\(_2\) gas | All phytoplankton; N\(_2\) only by diazotrophs | Assimilation into protein and nucleic acids | Ammonification, then nitrification to NO\(_3^-\) |
| Phosphorus | HPO\(_4^{2-}\) (dominant at pH 8), DOP | All | Nucleic acids, ATP, phospholipids | Fast, shallow |
| Silicon | Si(OH)\(_4\) (silicic acid, uncharged) | Diatoms, radiolarians, silicoflagellates, sponges | Opal (SiO\(_2\)·nH\(_2\)O) | Slow chemical dissolution, deeper |
Redfield stoichiometry
Alfred Redfield noticed that the ratio of nitrate to phosphate in deep water (about 16:1) matches the N:P of plankton. With carbon and oxygen added (the Redfield–Ketchum–Richards formulation):
$$(\text{CH}_2\text{O})_{106}(\text{NH}_3)_{16}(\text{H}_3\text{PO}_4) + 138\,\text{O}_2 \;\rightarrow\; 106\,\text{CO}_2 + 16\,\text{HNO}_3 + \text{H}_3\text{PO}_4 + 122\,\text{H}_2\text{O}$$$$\boxed{\text{C : N : P} = 106 : 16 : 1, \qquad -\text{O}_2 : \text{P} = 138}$$Check the oxygen demand: 106 O\(_2\) to oxidise carbon plus \( 16\times2 = 32 \) O\(_2\) to oxidise NH\(_3\) to HNO\(_3\) gives 138. Later estimates of \( -\text{O}_2 : \text{P} \) are somewhat higher (around 150–170), because real organic matter is more reduced (lipids, proteins) than CH\(_2\)O. For diatoms add Si:N ≈ 1 under nutrient-replete conditions.
The ratio is an average: it varies with taxa, growth rate and nutrient status (high N:P in nutrient-poor gyres, lower in productive upwelling regions). Part C may ask you to accept that variation while still using 106:16:1 for calculations.
Vertical profiles
graph LR
A["Surface:
uptake → NO3, PO4, Si
near zero (except HNLC)"] --> B["Nutricline:
steep rise below
euphotic zone"]
B --> C["NO3 and PO4 maximum
~500–1500 m
(coincides with O2 minimum)"]
C --> D["Deep water:
NO3, PO4 slightly lower;
Si keeps rising to
2–3 km or bottom"]- N and P are released from soft tissue quickly; their maxima sit at intermediate depth with the oxygen minimum.
- Si dissolves slowly from opal, which sinks fast in large particles; its maximum is deeper.
- Inter-basin contrast: deep North Pacific water has roughly twice the nitrate and phosphate of deep North Atlantic water (about 40 versus 20 µmol kg\(^{-1}\) nitrate) and several times the silicate (above 150 versus a few tens of µmol kg\(^{-1}\)). Deep water ages along the conveyor and accumulates regenerated nutrients.
The Marine Nitrogen Cycle
graph TD
N2["N2 gas"] -->|"N2 fixation
(Trichodesmium,
unicellular cyanobacteria)"| ORG["Organic N"]
NO3["NO3-"] -->|"Assimilation"| ORG
NH4["NH4+"] -->|"Assimilation"| ORG
ORG -->|"Ammonification"| NH4
NH4 -->|"Ammonia oxidation
(archaea, bacteria)"| NO2["NO2-"]
NO2 -->|"Nitrite oxidation"| NO3
NO3 -->|"Denitrification
(low O2)"| N2
NH4 -->|"Anammox
NH4+ + NO2- → N2"| N2
NO2 -->|"Anammox"| N2| Process | Conditions | Effect on fixed N |
|---|---|---|
| N\(_2\) fixation | Warm, stratified, N-poor, Fe- and P-available surface water | Adds |
| Nitrification (NH\(_4^+\) → NO\(_2^-\) → NO\(_3^-\)) | Oxic; inhibited by light | Recycles; source of N\(_2\)O |
| Denitrification (NO\(_3^-\) → N\(_2\)) | O\(_2\) below a few µmol kg\(^{-1}\): OMZs, sediments | Removes; source and sink of N\(_2\)O |
| Anammox (NH\(_4^+\) + NO\(_2^-\) → N\(_2\) + 2H\(_2\)O) | Anoxic; OMZs and sediments | Removes |
| DNRA (nitrate → ammonium) | Anoxic, sulfidic sediments | Retains fixed N |
Primary nitrite maximum: at the base of the euphotic zone, where nitrification (inhibited by light above) and incomplete nitrate reduction by phytoplankton release nitrite. Secondary nitrite maximum: in the core of an OMZ, from denitrification. Seeing a secondary nitrite maximum in a profile is the signal of active N loss.
Denitrification in simplified form:
$$5\,\text{CH}_2\text{O} + 4\,\text{NO}_3^- + 4\,\text{H}^+ \;\rightarrow\; 2\,\text{N}_2 + 5\,\text{CO}_2 + 7\,\text{H}_2\text{O}$$N\(^*\): tracking fixation and denitrification
Since denitrification removes N but not P, and fixation adds N but not P, the departure of nitrate from the Redfield line traces both:
$$N^{*} = [\text{NO}_3^-] - 16\,[\text{PO}_4^{3-}]\ (+\ \text{a constant in the published version})$$Gruber and Sarmiento’s published definition adds a small constant so that the global mean is near zero. The sign is what matters:
- Negative N\(^*\): nitrate deficit: denitrification or anammox (Arabian Sea, eastern tropical Pacific OMZs).
- Positive N\(^*\): nitrate excess: N\(_2\) fixation (subtropical North Atlantic, where dust supplies the Fe that diazotrophs need).
New and regenerated production
Dugdale and Goering divided primary production by the N source:
| Nitrogen source | Meaning | |
|---|---|---|
| New production | NO\(_3^-\) mixed or upwelled from below, N\(_2\) fixation, atmospheric deposition | Supplied from outside the euphotic zone |
| Regenerated production | NH\(_4^+\), urea recycled within the euphotic zone | Recycled locally |
At steady state, new production equals export production (the organic matter that leaves the euphotic zone), because what comes in must go out. The f-ratio is low (around 0.1) in oligotrophic gyres and high (0.4 or more) in upwelling and spring-bloom regions. It links nutrient supply to the biological pump.
Which nutrient limits?
- On short time scales, nitrogen usually limits in the open ocean (surface nitrate runs out before phosphate; N\(^*\) is mostly negative globally).
- On geological time scales, phosphorus is the “ultimate” limiting nutrient: there is no biological way to fix P, while N deficits can be made up by fixation (Tyrrell’s argument: N proximate, P ultimate).
- Iron limits in HNLC regions and constrains N\(_2\) fixation; silicate limits diatoms in some regions.
Phosphorus and Silicon Cycles
Phosphorus: input mainly from rivers (dissolved and particulate, much of it trapped in estuaries and on shelves) and dust. Removal by burial as organic P, P adsorbed to Fe-oxyhydroxides, authigenic carbonate fluorapatite (phosphorites; see CaCO\(_3\), Silica, Nodules and Phosphorites) and P scavenged by hydrothermal plume particles. Residence time of order \( 10^{4} \)–\( 10^{5} \) yr.
Silicon: input from rivers (weathering of silicates), hydrothermal fluids, and dissolution of aeolian and sedimentary silicates. Removal almost entirely as biogenic opal burial, plus reverse weathering. Seawater is undersaturated with respect to opal everywhere, so only a small fraction of the opal produced is buried.
AOU and Preformed Nutrients
Deep-water nutrients have two origins:
- Preformed: already present when the water left the surface (unused nutrient carried down).
- Regenerated (remineralised): released by respiration of sinking organic matter since then.
Respiration consumes O\(_2\) in Redfield proportion. Define the apparent oxygen utilisation:
$$\text{AOU} = [\text{O}_2]_{sat}(T, S) - [\text{O}_2]_{obs}$$assuming the water was saturated when it last left the surface. Then
$$\text{PO}_4^{regen} = \frac{\text{AOU}}{138}, \qquad \text{PO}_4^{pref} = \text{PO}_4^{obs} - \frac{\text{AOU}}{138}$$and similarly for nitrate with 16/138.
Caveat: AOU overestimates true utilisation where water left the surface undersaturated (common in rapidly formed high-latitude deep water under sea ice), so regenerated nutrients from AOU are upper estimates there.
Trace Metals
Why they matter
Phytoplankton need trace metals as enzyme cofactors:
| Metal | Key biochemical role |
|---|---|
| Fe | Photosynthetic and respiratory electron transport (cytochromes, ferredoxin), nitrate reductase, nitrogenase |
| Mn | Water-oxidising complex of photosystem II; superoxide dismutase |
| Zn | Carbonic anhydrase, alkaline phosphatase |
| Cd | Can substitute for Zn in carbonic anhydrase in some diatoms |
| Co | Vitamin B\(_{12}\); can substitute for Zn |
| Ni | Urease; Ni superoxide dismutase |
| Cu | Plastocyanin, cytochrome oxidase; toxic as free Cu\(^{2+}\) |
| Mo | Nitrogenase, nitrate reductase |
Toxicity and availability depend on the free-ion concentration, not the total: more than 99% of dissolved Fe and Cu is bound to organic ligands, which lowers both bioavailability (Fe) and toxicity (Cu).
Profile types, extended
| Type | Mechanism | Shape | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conservative | No significant reaction | Flat with salinity | Mo, U, Rb, Cs, W |
| Nutrient-type, shallow regeneration | Taken up in soft tissue, released fast | Like phosphate | Cd (Cd ∝ PO\(_4\)) |
| Nutrient-type, deep regeneration | Associated with hard parts or refractory phases | Like silicate | Zn, Ba (Ba also tracks alkalinity), Ge |
| Mixed nutrient | Both pools | Between P and Si | Ni |
| Scavenged | Adsorbed onto particles, removed | Maximum at the source; decrease with depth and along deep flow | Al (dust), Pb (anthropogenic), Th, Mn (also photoreduction at surface) |
| Hybrid nutrient–scavenged | Uptake and regeneration plus continuous scavenging | Surface depletion, mid-depth rise, no steady deep increase | Fe, Cu, Co |
| Redox-sensitive | Different oxidation states with different behaviour | Changes across oxyclines | Cr (VI/III), As (V/III), Se (VI/IV), I (iodate/iodide), Mn, Fe, Ce |
Specific signatures worth recognising in a Part C plot:
- Cd versus PO\(_4\): straight line (with a slight kink at low P). Benthic foraminiferal Cd/Ca therefore records past bottom-water phosphate, a palaeo-nutrient proxy (see Paleoceanographic Proxies).
- Zn versus Si: nearly linear, although Zn is not part of opal in significant amounts. Why Zn is regenerated like silicate rather than like phosphate is still debated; it is a well-known puzzle.
- Mn: surface maximum (dust input plus photoreduction of Mn oxides to soluble Mn\(^{2+}\)), a mid-depth maximum in OMZs (reductive dissolution), and maxima in hydrothermal plumes; low in the deep ocean.
- Al: high in surface Atlantic and Mediterranean (Saharan dust), very low in the remote Pacific. A dust tracer.
- Pb: a surface maximum dominated by anthropogenic lead (leaded petrol, smelting), which has fallen since leaded petrol was phased out. A classic example of a transient anthropogenic signal in a short-residence-time element.
- Cu: increases roughly linearly with depth, the result of uptake and regeneration combined with scavenging, plus sediment input at the bottom.
Scavenging and thorium isotopes
Scavenging is the adsorption of dissolved metals onto sinking particles, followed by removal to the sea floor. Thorium is the type example: it is produced in solution at a known, constant rate by decay of dissolved uranium (which is conservative), and it is very particle-reactive.
- \(^{234}\)Th (half-life 24.1 days) is produced from \(^{238}\)U. In the deep ocean the two are in secular equilibrium (equal activities). In the surface ocean, sinking particles carry \(^{234}\)Th down, creating a \(^{234}\)Th deficit relative to \(^{238}\)U. The size of the deficit measures the particle export flux on time scales of weeks.
- At steady state, the downward \(^{234}\)Th flux from a surface layer of thickness \( h \) is
Multiply by the POC/\(^{234}\)Th ratio of sinking particles to get carbon export.
- \(^{230}\)Th (from \(^{234}\)U) and \(^{231}\)Pa (from \(^{235}\)U) are long-lived. Th is removed more efficiently than Pa, so their ratio in sediments is used to reconstruct past circulation and particle flux.
Sources of trace metals to the ocean
| Source | Delivers |
|---|---|
| Aeolian dust | Fe, Al, Mn, Co; strongest near deserts (Sahara, Arabia, Thar for the Arabian Sea) |
| Rivers (after estuarine removal) | Ba, Cu, Ni, Zn; little Fe |
| Continental shelf sediments | Fe and Mn released under reducing conditions |
| Hydrothermal vents | Fe, Mn, Zn (much precipitated near the vent) |
| Anthropogenic | Pb, Cd, Zn, Cu via aerosols |
| Sea ice and glaciers | Fe in polar oceans |
The international GEOTRACES programme has mapped many of these elements and their isotopes along ocean sections; its data underpin most current statements about trace-metal distributions.
Memory Tricks
- Redfield “106-16-1-138”: “One hundred and six carbons, sixteen nitrogens, one phosphorus, breathe 138 oxygens.”
- Profile types by partner: “Cd follows P, Zn follows Si, Ni sits between.”
- N\(^*\) sign: “Negative = Nitrogen Gone (denitrification); Positive = Plenty fixed.”
- f-ratio: “f for from outside”: new production over total.
- Nitrite maxima: “Primary at the Photic base, secondary in the Suboxic core.”
Don’t Confuse
| This | Is not this |
|---|---|
| New production (NO\(_3^-\), N\(_2\) fixation; equals export at steady state) | Regenerated production (NH\(_4^+\), urea recycled in the euphotic zone) |
| Denitrification (NO\(_3^-\) → N\(_2\), heterotrophic) | Anammox (NH\(_4^+\) + NO\(_2^-\) → N\(_2\), autotrophic) |
| Nitrification (oxidation; needs O\(_2\)) | Nitrogen fixation (reduction of N\(_2\); needs Fe, energy) |
| Preformed nutrients (carried from the surface) | Regenerated nutrients (from AOU) |
| Nutrient-type metal (Cd, Zn, Ni) | Scavenged metal (Al, Pb, Th) |
| \(^{234}\)Th (24.1 d; weekly export flux) | \(^{230}\)Th (long-lived; sediment flux, Pa/Th circulation) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Write the Redfield C:N:P ratio.
- Which process produces the secondary nitrite maximum?
- Which trace metal correlates linearly with phosphate in the open ocean?
Answers
- 106 : 16 : 1.
- Denitrification in an oxygen minimum zone.
- Cadmium.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Deep water has NO\(_3^-\) = 25.0 and PO\(_4^{3-}\) = 2.20 µmol kg\(^{-1}\). Its N\(^*\) (taken as NO\(_3^-\) − 16 PO\(_4^{3-}\)) and the likely process are:
(a) +10.2, N\(_2\) fixation (b) −10.2, denitrification (c) −10.2, N\(_2\) fixation (d) +10.2, denitrification
Answer: (b)
\( 25.0 - 16\times2.20 = 25.0 - 35.2 = -10.2 \) µmol kg\(^{-1}\). A nitrate deficit relative to phosphate indicates fixed-N loss by denitrification (or anammox).
Practice Q2. In a region where total primary production is 120 mmol N m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\) and nitrate uptake is 30 mmol N m\(^{-2}\) d\(^{-1}\) (no N\(_2\) fixation), the f-ratio is:
(a) 0.20 (b) 0.25 (c) 0.33 (d) 4.0
Answer: (b) 0.25
\( f = 30/120 = 0.25 \). (d) inverts the ratio; (c) divides new by regenerated production (30/90).
Practice Q3. Which element has a scavenged-type profile with a surface maximum supplied mainly by aeolian dust?
(a) Cd (b) Zn (c) Al (d) Mo
Answer: (c) Al
Cd and Zn are nutrient-type; Mo is conservative.
Practice Q4. The \(^{234}\)Th deficit in the upper ocean is used to estimate:
(a) the age of deep water (b) the export flux of particles over weeks (c) the rate of N\(_2\) fixation (d) air–sea gas exchange
Answer: (b)
\(^{234}\)Th (24.1 d) produced from conservative \(^{238}\)U is removed by sinking particles; the deficit relative to U gives particle (and, with POC/Th, carbon) export.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A water sample at 1,500 m has O\(_2\) = 120 µmol kg\(^{-1}\), O\(_2\) saturation at its potential temperature and salinity = 320 µmol kg\(^{-1}\), NO\(_3^-\) = 34.0 and PO\(_4^{3-}\) = 2.60 µmol kg\(^{-1}\). Use −O\(_2\):P = 138 and N:P = 16. Which statements are correct?
- AOU is 200 µmol kg\(^{-1}\).
- Regenerated phosphate is about 1.45 µmol kg\(^{-1}\).
- Preformed nitrate is about 10.8 µmol kg\(^{-1}\).
- If the water was undersaturated in O\(_2\) when it formed, the true regenerated phosphate is larger than calculated.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1: \( 320 - 120 = 200 \). True.
- 2: \( 200/138 = 1.449 \). True.
- 3: regenerated N \( = 16\times1.449 = 23.2 \); preformed \( = 34.0 - 23.2 = 10.8 \). True.
- 4: false. Initial undersaturation makes AOU too large, so the true regenerated phosphate is smaller than calculated.
Practice Q6. A benthic foraminifer from a glacial-age sediment has Cd/Ca = 0.12 µmol mol\(^{-1}\). Take a partition coefficient \( D = (\text{Cd/Ca})_{foram}/(\text{Cd/Ca})_{sw} = 2.0 \) (illustrative) and seawater Ca = 10.3 mmol kg\(^{-1}\). Which statements are correct?
- Seawater Cd/Ca was 0.06 µmol mol\(^{-1}\).
- Bottom-water Cd was about 0.62 nmol kg\(^{-1}\).
- Because Cd tracks phosphate, a higher glacial Cd at this site implies more nutrient-rich (older or more southern-sourced) bottom water.
- Cd/Ca is a proxy for bottom-water temperature.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1: \( 0.12/2.0 = 0.06 \) µmol mol\(^{-1}\). True.
- 2: \( 0.06\times10^{-6}\times10.3\times10^{-3} = 6.2\times10^{-10} \) mol kg\(^{-1}\) = 0.62 nmol kg\(^{-1}\). True.
- 3: the logic of Cd as a palaeo-nutrient proxy. True.
- 4: false. Mg/Ca is the temperature proxy; Cd/Ca records nutrients.
Practice Q7. Profiles from a station in the eastern Arabian Sea show: O\(_2\) below 2 µmol kg\(^{-1}\) between 150 and 1,000 m; a nitrite maximum of 4 µmol kg\(^{-1}\) at 250 m; N\(^*\) of −12 µmol kg\(^{-1}\) at the same depth; no H\(_2\)S detected. Which statements are correct?
- Denitrification and/or anammox are active.
- The water column is euxinic.
- N\(_2\)O production is likely at the OMZ boundaries.
- The secondary nitrite maximum lies within the OMZ core, not at the base of the euphotic zone.
(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
- 1: negative N\(^*\) and a deep nitrite maximum. True.
- 2: false. No sulfide: functionally anoxic but not euxinic.
- 3: incomplete nitrification and denitrification at the oxic–suboxic boundaries are major N\(_2\)O sources. True.
- 4: 250 m inside the low-O\(_2\) layer is a secondary nitrite maximum. True.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Redfield | C:N:P = 106:16:1; −O\(_2\):P = 138 (later estimates 150–170); Si:N ≈ 1 for diatoms |
| Profiles | N, P max at 500–1500 m with O\(_2\) minimum; Si deeper |
| Pacific vs Atlantic | deep nitrate about 40 vs 20; silicate above 150 vs tens (µmol kg\(^{-1}\)) |
| N removal | denitrification, anammox; OMZs (Arabian Sea, ETNP, ETSP) and sediments |
| N addition | N\(_2\) fixation (Trichodesmium, unicellular cyanobacteria); needs Fe and P |
| N\(^*\) | NO\(_3^-\) − 16 PO\(_4^{3-}\) (+ constant); negative = denitrification |
| Nitrite maxima | primary: base of euphotic zone; secondary: OMZ core |
| f-ratio | new / total production; new = export at steady state |
| AOU | O\(_2\),sat − O\(_2\),obs; regenerated P = AOU/138 |
| Limitation | N proximate, P ultimate, Fe in HNLC, Si for diatoms |
| Cd | follows PO\(_4\); Cd/Ca palaeo-nutrient proxy |
| Zn, Ba | follow Si (deep regeneration) |
| Scavenged | Al (dust), Pb (anthropogenic), Th, Mn |
| Hybrid | Fe, Cu, Co |
| \(^{234}\)Th | half-life 24.1 d; deficit vs \(^{238}\)U gives export |
| Metal roles | Fe: nitrogenase, cytochromes; Zn/Cd: carbonic anhydrase; Co: B\(_{12}\); Mn: PSII; Ni: urease |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Air–Sea Gas Exchange, the Carbonate System and the Biological Pump — what export production does to CO\(_2\).
- CaCO\(_3\), Silica, Manganese Nodules and Phosphorites — where nutrients and metals are finally buried.
- Paleoceanographic Proxies and Paleo-SST Methods — Cd/Ca and other nutrient proxies in use.
- Chemical Oceanography: Quick Revision