Köppen and Thornthwaite Classifications
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C: Köppen groups, letters and thresholds, Köppen types of India, Thornthwaite 1931 and 1948 schemes, worked classifications.
- 19 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Temperature controls and the seasonal shift of pressure belts, from Temperature, Pressure and Wind Belts: the belts explain where each climate type falls.
- Potential evapotranspiration, the water balance and the moisture index, from Humidity, Precipitation and Water Balance. Thornthwaite’s 1948 scheme is built directly on them.
- Monsoon and air-mass climatology, from Air Masses, Monsoon, Jet Streams, Tropical Cyclones and ENSO.
The Hook: The Botanist’s Map
Why Classify Climate?
A classification compresses twelve months of temperature and precipitation into a symbol that says how a place behaves. Two approaches exist:
| Approach | Basis | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Empirical (effective) | observed effects, especially on vegetation; thresholds of temperature and rainfall | Köppen, Thornthwaite, Trewartha |
| Genetic | causes: air masses, fronts, pressure belts | Strahler’s classification (low-, mid- and high-latitude climates controlled by air masses) |
Köppen’s scheme was first published in full in 1900 and revised several times, with Rudolf Geiger, which is why it is often called the Köppen–Geiger classification. Thornthwaite published his first scheme in 1931 and his “rational” water-balance scheme in 1948.
The Köppen Classification
The five main groups
| Group | Name | Defining criterion (thermal or moisture) | Vegetation it tracks |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | tropical humid | coldest month mean 18 °C or above | megatherm vegetation; no cold season |
| B | dry | annual precipitation below a dryness threshold that rises with temperature | steppe and desert |
| C | warm temperate (mesothermal) | coldest month between 0 °C (or −3 °C in Köppen’s original) and 18 °C; warmest month above 10 °C | mixed forests, evergreen broadleaf, Mediterranean scrub |
| D | snow / cold (microthermal) | coldest month 0 °C or below (−3 °C original); warmest above 10 °C | boreal forest (taiga) |
| E | polar | warmest month below 10 °C | no trees (10 °C warmest month approximates the treeline) |
Many maps add H for highland climates, where altitude dominates. Group B is tested first: a hot place that is too dry is B, whatever its temperature.
The dryness threshold
With mean annual temperature \( T \) (°C) and annual precipitation \( P \) (mm), a widely used form (as in Peel and colleagues, 2007) is:
| Seasonal rainfall regime | Threshold \( P_{th} \) (mm) |
|---|---|
| at least 70% of precipitation in the winter half-year | \( 20T \) |
| at least 70% in the summer half-year | \( 20T + 280 \) |
| neither | \( 20T + 140 \) |
Summer rain raises the threshold because it falls when evaporation is highest and is less effective.
Second and third letters
| Letter | Applies to | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| f | A, C, D | no dry season (in A: driest month at least 60 mm) |
| m | A | monsoon: short dry season compensated by heavy rain; driest month below 60 mm but at least \( 100 - P/25 \) mm |
| w | A, C, D | dry winter (in C and D: driest winter month below one-tenth of the wettest summer month) |
| s | A, C, D | dry summer (in C and D: driest summer month below 40 mm and below one-third of the wettest winter month) |
| W / S | B | desert / steppe |
| h / k | B | hot (mean annual temperature 18 °C or above) / cold (below 18 °C) |
| a | C, D | hot summer: warmest month 22 °C or above |
| b | C, D | warm summer: warmest below 22 °C, at least four months at 10 °C or above |
| c | C, D | cool summer: one to three months at 10 °C or above |
| d | D | very cold winter: coldest month below −38 °C |
| T / F | E | tundra (warmest month 0 °C or above but below 10 °C) / ice cap (warmest month below 0 °C) |
| g | (Indian usage) | Ganges type: hottest month comes before the summer solstice and the rainy season |
graph TD
S["Station data"] --> B{"P below dryness threshold?"}
B -->|yes| BW{"P below half the threshold?"}
BW -->|yes| W["BW desert"]
BW -->|no| BS["BS steppe"]
B -->|no| E{"Warmest month below 10 C?"}
E -->|yes| EE["E: ET or EF"]
E -->|no| A{"Coldest month 18 C or above?"}
A -->|yes| AA["A: Af, Am, Aw or As"]
A -->|no| C{"Coldest month above 0 C?"}
C -->|yes| CC["C: then f/s/w and a/b/c"]
C -->|no| DD["D: then f/s/w and a/b/c/d"]World distribution of the main types
| Type | Name | Typical regions | Controlling belt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Af | tropical rainforest | Amazon, Congo basin, Indonesia | ITCZ all year |
| Am | tropical monsoon | west coast of India, Myanmar coast | monsoon |
| Aw | tropical savanna | much of peninsular India, East Africa, Brazilian campos | ITCZ in summer only |
| BWh | hot desert | Sahara, Arabia, Thar, central Australia | subtropical high |
| BWk / BSk | cold desert / steppe | Gobi, Central Asia, Ladakh, interior plateaus | continentality, rain shadow |
| Csa / Csb | Mediterranean | Mediterranean basin, California, central Chile, southwestern Australia, the Cape | high in summer, westerlies in winter |
| Cfa | humid subtropical | southeastern United States, eastern China | east-coast warm currents, summer monsoon-like flow |
| Cfb | marine west coast | northwest Europe, New Zealand | westerlies all year |
| Cwa | monsoon-influenced warm temperate | north India, southern China | monsoon |
| Dfb / Dfc | humid continental / subarctic | eastern Europe, southern Canada / Siberian and Canadian taiga | continentality |
| Dwd | extreme subarctic | northeastern Siberia | Siberian High |
| ET / EF | tundra / ice cap | Arctic coasts / Greenland interior, Antarctica | polar high |
Note that D climates are essentially confined to the Northern Hemisphere: the Southern Hemisphere has no large land mass at 40–70°.
Köppen climate types of India
The standard Köppen map of India (as given in NCERT’s India: Physical Environment) recognises:
| Type | Description | Region |
|---|---|---|
| Amw | monsoon with a short dry season | west coast south of Goa |
| As | monsoon with a dry summer | Coromandel coast of Tamil Nadu (rain mostly October–December) |
| Aw | tropical savanna | most of the peninsular plateau south of the Tropic of Cancer |
| BShw | semi-arid steppe | northwest Gujarat, parts of western Rajasthan and Punjab |
| BWhw | hot desert | extreme western Rajasthan |
| Cwg | monsoon with a dry winter (Ganges type) | Ganga plain, eastern Rajasthan, northern Madhya Pradesh, most of the northeast |
| Dfc | cold humid winter with a short summer | Arunachal Pradesh |
| E | polar (tundra and ice) | high Himalaya of Jammu and Kashmir, Ladakh, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand |
Strengths and weaknesses
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|
| uses only monthly temperature and precipitation, available almost everywhere | thresholds are empirical, chosen from vegetation, not physics |
| boundaries match vegetation zones well | ignores evaporation directly (only through \( T \) in the B threshold) |
| simple, global, easy to map from gridded data | says nothing about causes (air masses, winds) |
| widely used to map climate shifts under warming | sharp boundaries for gradual transitions; does not capture rainfall variability |
Trewartha (1966, revised 1980) modified Köppen, redefining group C by the number of months at 10 °C or above, to make middle-latitude boundaries fit vegetation better.
The Thornthwaite Classifications
The 1931 scheme: precipitation and temperature efficiency
Thornthwaite’s first scheme used two indices computed from monthly precipitation \( P \) (inches) and temperature \( T \) (°F).
Precipitation-effectiveness (P-E) index:
$$\boxed{\text{P-E index} = \sum_{12} 115\left(\frac{P}{T - 10}\right)^{10/9}}$$Temperature-efficiency (T-E) index:
$$\boxed{\text{T-E index} = \sum_{12} \frac{T - 32}{4}}$$| Humidity province | P-E index | Vegetation |
|---|---|---|
| A wet | 128 and above | rainforest |
| B humid | 64–127 | forest |
| C subhumid | 32–63 | grassland |
| D semi-arid | 16–31 | steppe |
| E arid | below 16 | desert |
| Temperature province | T-E index |
|---|---|
| A’ tropical | 128 and above |
| B’ mesothermal | 64–127 |
| C’ microthermal | 32–63 |
| D’ taiga | 16–31 |
| E’ tundra | 1–15 |
| F’ frost | 0 |
A third letter described the seasonal distribution of rainfall: r (rainfall adequate in all seasons), s (deficient in summer), w (deficient in winter), d (deficient in all seasons). The scheme still keyed classes to vegetation, which Thornthwaite himself later regarded as a weakness.
The 1948 “rational” scheme: the water balance
In 1948 Thornthwaite based the classification on potential evapotranspiration (PE), computed from temperature and day length (the formula is on the water-balance page), and on the monthly water balance giving the annual water surplus \( S \) and deficit \( D \).
| Index | Formula |
|---|---|
| Humidity index | \( I_h = 100\,S/PE \) |
| Aridity index | \( I_a = 100\,D/PE \) |
| Moisture index | \( I_m = I_h - 0.6\,I_a \) (1948); \( I_m = I_h - I_a = 100(S - D)/PE \) (Thornthwaite and Mather, 1955) |
The factor 0.6 weights the deficit less heavily than the surplus in the 1948 index; the 1955 revision gave the two equal weight.
Moisture regions (1955 boundaries):
| Symbol | Moisture region | \( I_m \) |
|---|---|---|
| A | perhumid | 100 and above |
| B4 | humid | 80 to 100 |
| B3 | humid | 60 to 80 |
| B2 | humid | 40 to 60 |
| B1 | humid | 20 to 40 |
| C2 | moist subhumid | 0 to 20 |
| C1 | dry subhumid | −33.3 to 0 |
| D | semi-arid | −66.7 to −33.3 |
| E | arid | −100 to −66.7 |
With the 1948 index the dry boundaries are −20 (C1/D), −40 (D/E) and −60.
Thermal efficiency is measured by annual PE itself, in cm:
| Symbol | Thermal province | Annual PE (cm) |
|---|---|---|
| A' | megathermal | 114 and above |
| B'4 to B'1 | mesothermal | 57 to 114 (four subdivisions of about 14.25 cm) |
| C'2, C'1 | microthermal | 28.5 to 57 |
| D' | tundra | 14.2 to 28.5 |
| E' | frost | below 14.2 |
Two further letters complete the symbol: one for the seasonal variation of moisture (r, s, w, s2, w2 for moist climates, by the size and season of the deficit; d, s, w, s2, w2 for dry climates, by the size and season of the surplus), and one for the summer concentration of thermal efficiency (the share of annual PE falling in the three summer months: below 48% is a’, rising toward d’ above 88% in polar climates).
Köppen and Thornthwaite compared
| Köppen | Thornthwaite (1948) | |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | vegetation boundaries matched to T and P thresholds | water balance: P compared with PE |
| Moisture | dryness threshold from \( T \) and rainfall season | moisture index from surplus and deficit |
| Thermal | monthly temperature limits (18, 10, 0 or −3, −38 °C) | annual PE |
| Data needed | monthly T and P | monthly T, P, latitude (day length), soil storage |
| Best for | world maps, vegetation, teaching | agriculture, irrigation, hydrology, drought |
| Weakness | empirical thresholds, no evaporation | PE from temperature only (poor in hot, dry, windy climates); more computation |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | Distinction |
|---|---|
| Köppen w vs s | dry winter vs dry summer |
| Köppen m vs w (group A) | short dry season offset by heavy rain vs pronounced dry season; the test is \( 100 - P/25 \) |
| BW vs BS | below half the dryness threshold vs between half and the full threshold |
| h vs k (group B) | mean annual temperature 18 °C or above vs below |
| C vs D boundary | coldest month 0 °C (modern) vs −3 °C (Köppen’s original) |
| Thornthwaite A (moisture) vs A’ (thermal) | perhumid, \( I_m \ge 100 \) vs megathermal, \( PE \ge 114 \) cm |
| 1931 vs 1948 Thornthwaite | P-E and T-E indices from P and T vs PE and the water balance |
| \( I_m \) 1948 vs 1955 | \( I_h - 0.6I_a \) vs \( I_h - I_a \) |
| Empirical vs genetic classification | effects (vegetation, water balance) vs causes (air masses, fronts) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What temperature criterion defines Köppen’s group E?
- What is the Köppen type of extreme western Rajasthan on the standard map of India?
- What quantity did Thornthwaite use in 1948 to measure thermal efficiency?
Answers
- Warmest month mean below 10 °C.
- BWhw, hot desert.
- Annual potential evapotranspiration (cm).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A coastal station has all months above 25 °C, annual rainfall 3,000 mm, and a driest month of 1 mm. Its Köppen type is:
(a) Af (b) Am (c) Aw (d) BSh
Answer: (b) Am
Not B: threshold \( 20\times 27 + 280 \approx 820 \) mm (taking a mean near 27 °C), far below 3,000. Coldest month above 18 °C: A. Driest month 1 mm < 60, so not Af. Am limit: \( 100 - 3000/25 = -20 \) mm; 1 mm ≥ −20, so Am. Heavy monsoon rain compensates for the dry season, the situation of India’s west coast.
Practice Q2. A station has a mean annual temperature of 26 °C and 600 mm of rain, 85% of it in the summer half-year. Its Köppen type is:
(a) BWh (b) BSh (c) Aw (d) BSk
Answer: (b) BSh
Summer rain: \( P_{th} = 20\times 26 + 280 = 800 \) mm. \( 600 < 800 \): group B. Half the threshold is 400; \( 600 > 400 \): BS. Mean temperature 26 °C ≥ 18: h. BSh. Using \( 20T + 140 = 660 \) would also give BS, but with \( 20T = 520 \) mm the rainfall exceeds the threshold and the station would wrongly fall outside group B.
Practice Q3. Match the Köppen type with its region in India.
| Type | Region | |
|---|---|---|
| P. As | 1. Ganga plain | |
| Q. Cwg | 2. Arunachal Pradesh | |
| R. Dfc | 3. Coromandel coast | |
| S. Amw | 4. West coast south of Goa |
(a) P-3, Q-1, R-2, S-4 (b) P-4, Q-1, R-2, S-3 (c) P-3, Q-2, R-1, S-4 (d) P-1, Q-3, R-2, S-4
Answer: (a)
As: Tamil Nadu coast (dry high-Sun season). Cwg: Ganga plain. Dfc: Arunachal Pradesh. Amw: Konkan–Malabar coast.
Practice Q4. A station has \( PE = 900 \) mm, surplus 500 mm and deficit 50 mm. Using \( I_m = 100(S - D)/PE \), its moisture region is:
(a) B4 humid (b) B2 humid (c) C2 moist subhumid (d) A perhumid
Answer: (b) B2 humid
\( I_m = 100\times(500 - 50)/900 = 50 \), which lies in 40–60: B2. Using the surplus alone (\( I_h = 55.6 \)) would still give B2 here, but ignoring the deficit is a common slip that changes the class in drier stations.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Monthly data for three stations (all far from mountains):
| Station | Coldest month (°C) | Warmest month (°C) | Mean annual T (°C) | Annual P (mm) | Rain season | Driest month (mm) | Wettest month (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| X | 14 | 33 | 25 | 1,000 | 90% in summer | 5 (winter) | 300 (summer) |
| Y | 8 | 24 | 16 | 600 | 75% in winter | 5 (summer) | 110 (winter) |
| Z | −32 | 15 | −8 | 350 | 60% in summer | 10 (winter) | 70 (summer) |
Which statements are correct?
- X is Cwa.
- Y is Csa.
- Z, which has two months at or above 10 °C, is Dfc, not E.
- Y would be BSk if its rain fell mainly in summer.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 2, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- X: threshold \( 20\times 25 + 280 = 780 < 1000 \): not B. Coldest 14 °C: between 0 and 18, warmest above 10: C. Driest winter month 5 < 300/10 = 30: w. Warmest 33 ≥ 22: a. Cwa. Statement 1 true.
- Y: winter rain (75% ≥ 70%): \( P_{th} = 20\times 16 = 320 < 600 \): not B. Coldest 8 °C: C. Driest summer month 5 < 40 and < 110/3: s. Warmest 24 ≥ 22: a. Csa. Statement 2 true.
- Z: neither half has 70%: \( P_{th} = 20\times(-8) + 140 = -20 \); 350 mm exceeds it, so not B. Warmest 15 °C > 10: not E. Coldest −32 ≤ 0 but above −38: D. Two months at or above 10 °C: c. Driest winter month 10 mm is not below one-tenth of the wettest summer month (7 mm), so not w; it the data show no dry summer (the driest month falls in winter): f. Dfc. Statement 3 true.
- Statement 4 false: with summer rain \( P_{th} = 20\times 16 + 280 = 600 \); \( P = 600 \) is not below 600, so Y would still not be B (it would sit exactly on the boundary).
Practice Q6. In Thornthwaite’s 1931 scheme a station has six months with \( P = 4 \) in and \( T = 75 \) °F and six months with \( P = 0.5 \) in and \( T = 60 \) °F. Which classification is correct?
(a) P-E index about 35 (C, subhumid); T-E index about 107 (B’, mesothermal) (b) P-E index about 65 (B, humid); T-E index about 107 (B’) (c) P-E index about 35 (C); T-E index about 135 (A’, tropical) (d) P-E index about 18 (D, semi-arid); T-E index about 64 (B')
Answer: (a)
Wet months: \( 115\times(4/65)^{10/9} = 115\times 0.0451 = 5.19 \); six of them: 31.1. Dry months: \( 115\times(0.5/50)^{10/9} = 115\times 0.0060 = 0.69 \); six: 4.1. P-E index ≈ 35.3: C, subhumid (32–63).
T-E: wet months \( (75 - 32)/4 = 10.75 \), ×6 = 64.5; dry months \( (60 - 32)/4 = 7 \), ×6 = 42. T-E ≈ 106.5: B’, mesothermal (64–127).
Note how the dry months contribute almost nothing to the P-E index: the exponent and the temperature in the denominator penalise small rains.
Practice Q7. Two stations have the following annual water-balance values (mm):
| Station | PE | AE | S | D |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| M | 1,600 | 700 | 50 | 900 |
| N | 600 | 590 | 700 | 10 |
Which statements are correct?
- M has \( I_m(1955) \approx -53 \): semi-arid (D), and is megathermal (A’).
- N has \( I_m(1955) \approx 115 \): perhumid (A).
- N’s annual precipitation is about 1,290 mm.
- Using the 1948 index, M would be classed arid (E).
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 true: \( 100\times(50 - 900)/1600 = -53.1 \): between −66.7 and −33.3, D. PE 160 cm ≥ 114: A’. Check: \( AE + D = 1600 = PE \).
- 2 true: \( 100\times(700 - 10)/600 = 115 \): A. (\( AE + D = 600 = PE \).)
- 3 true: \( P = AE + S = 590 + 700 = 1{,}290 \) mm.
- 4 false: \( I_h = 3.1 \), \( I_a = 56.3 \); \( I_m(1948) = 3.1 - 33.8 = -30.6 \): between −40 and −20, which is D (semi-arid), not E.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Köppen groups | A (coldest ≥ 18 °C), B (dry), C (coldest 0/−3 to 18 °C), D (coldest ≤ 0/−3 °C), E (warmest < 10 °C) |
| Dryness threshold | \( 20T \) (winter rain), \( 20T + 140 \), \( 20T + 280 \) (summer rain), mm |
| BW / BS | \( P < P_{th}/2 \) / \( P_{th}/2 \le P < P_{th} \) |
| A subtypes | Af driest ≥ 60 mm; Am driest ≥ \( 100 - P/25 \); Aw otherwise |
| s / w | driest summer < 40 mm and < 1/3 wettest winter / driest winter < 1/10 wettest summer |
| a / b / c / d | warmest ≥ 22; ≥ 4 months ≥ 10; 1–3 months ≥ 10; coldest < −38 °C |
| ET / EF | warmest 0–10 °C / below 0 °C |
| India | Amw west coast, As Coromandel, Aw plateau, BShw, BWhw Thar, Cwg Ganga plain, Dfc Arunachal, E Himalaya |
| Thornthwaite 1931 | P-E \( = \sum 115[P/(T-10)]^{10/9} \); T-E \( = \sum (T-32)/4 \); classes 128, 64, 32, 16 |
| Thornthwaite 1948 | PE-based; \( I_m = I_h - 0.6I_a \) (1948), \( 100(S-D)/PE \) (1955) |
| Moisture regions (1955) | A ≥ 100; B4–B1 80/60/40/20; C2 0–20; C1 −33.3–0; D −66.7 to −33.3; E below |
| Thermal (PE, cm) | A’ ≥ 114; B’ 57–114; C’ 28.5–57; D’ 14.2–28.5; E’ < 14.2 |
| Other schemes | Trewartha (modified Köppen), Strahler (genetic, air masses) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Climate Change: why the boundaries on these maps are moving.
- The palaeoclimate behind past climate zones: Oxygen and Carbon Isotopes and Paleoclimate.
- Soils and weathering under each climate type: Soils, Sediments and Sedimentary Rocks.
- Back to the chapter overview.