Meteorites, Earth's Composition and Differentiation
CSIR NET Earth Sciences: meteorite classes, chondrites and CAIs, bulk Earth, crust, mantle and core composition, Goldschmidt classes and core formation.
- 17 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- How the solar nebula condensed and built planetesimals: Milky Way, Solar System and Earth’s Orbit.
- Pb–Pb and short-lived isotope ages (\( ^{26}\text{Al} \), \( ^{182}\text{Hf} \)): Geological Time Scale and Radiometric Dating.
- Basic mineralogy (olivine, pyroxene, plagioclase, Fe–Ni metal, troilite) and the idea of element affinity from Chemical Sciences inorganic chemistry.
The Hook: A Planet You Cannot Sample
Meteorites: Definitions
- Meteoroid: a small body in space. Meteor: the luminous streak as it passes through the atmosphere. Meteorite: the part that reaches the ground.
- Fall: a meteorite seen to fall and then recovered. Find: one discovered later with no observed fall. Falls give an unbiased sample of what arrives; finds are biased towards iron meteorites, which look unusual and resist weathering. Antarctica and hot deserts are rich hunting grounds for finds.
- Most meteorites come from the asteroid belt. A small number come from the Moon and from Mars, blasted off by impacts.
Classification of Meteorites
graph TD
M[Meteorites] --> S[Stony]
M --> SI[Stony-iron]
M --> I[Iron]
S --> C[Chondrites: undifferentiated]
S --> A[Achondrites: differentiated, igneous]
C --> OC[Ordinary: H, L, LL]
C --> CC[Carbonaceous: CI, CM, CV, ...]
C --> EC[Enstatite: EH, EL]
A --> HED[HED: from asteroid Vesta]
A --> SNC[Martian: shergottites, nakhlites, chassignites]
A --> LUN[Lunar]
SI --> P[Pallasites: olivine in metal]
SI --> MS[Mesosiderites: basalt breccia plus metal]
I --> OCT[Octahedrites, hexahedrites, ataxites]| Group | Share of observed falls (approx.) | Made of | Parent body |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chondrites | about 86% | silicates, metal, sulphide, chondrules | undifferentiated asteroids |
| Achondrites | about 8% | igneous silicate rocks | differentiated bodies (asteroids, Moon, Mars) |
| Irons | about 4–5% | Fe–Ni metal | cores of differentiated asteroids |
| Stony-irons | about 1% | silicate plus metal | core–mantle boundary or mixed debris |
Ordinary chondrites alone make up about 80% of falls.
Chondrites: primitive samples
Chondrites have never melted as a whole. They are sedimentary rocks of the solar nebula, made of three components:
- Chondrules: millimetre-sized spheres of olivine and pyroxene, once molten droplets that cooled in minutes to hours in the nebula. Their name gives the class its name.
- Calcium–aluminium-rich inclusions (CAIs): refractory, white inclusions of Ca–Al–Ti oxides and silicates, the first solids to condense. Pb–Pb ages of about 4,567 Ma define the age of the solar system. Many contain excess \( ^{26}\text{Mg} \) from the decay of extinct \( ^{26}\text{Al} \).
- Matrix: fine-grained dust between them, with Fe–Ni metal and troilite (FeS) grains.
Chemical groups
| Group | Feature |
|---|---|
| Ordinary (H, L, LL) | the commonest; H = high total iron, L = low iron, LL = low iron and low metal |
| Carbonaceous (C) | contain water-bearing clays, carbon and organic compounds (including amino acids); CI chondrites are the most primitive |
| Enstatite (E) | very reduced (Fe as metal and sulphide, little FeO in silicates); oxygen isotopes very close to Earth’s |
Petrologic types (Van Schmus–Wood scale) describe secondary processing on the parent body: type 3 is the least altered; types 1 and 2 show increasing aqueous alteration (water); types 4 to 6 show increasing thermal metamorphism (chondrules blur, minerals equilibrate). A label like “L6” means an L-group chondrite that was strongly heated.
Achondrites: igneous rocks from other worlds
Achondrites lack chondrules because their parent bodies melted and differentiated.
- HED meteorites (howardites, eucrites, diogenites): basalts, pyroxene cumulates and their breccias. Their spectra match the asteroid 4 Vesta, a small differentiated body with crust, mantle and core.
- Martian meteorites (shergottites, nakhlites, chassignites, collectively “SNC”): young igneous ages and trapped gas matching the Martian atmosphere measured by the Viking landers.
- Lunar meteorites: anorthosites and mare basalts that match Apollo samples.
- Aubrites, ureilites, angrites and others: smaller groups.
Iron meteorites: cores of asteroids
Iron meteorites are Fe–Ni alloys, mostly about 5–20% Ni (a few ataxites much more), with troilite and graphite inclusions. Slow cooling inside a metallic core separates two alloys: kamacite (low-Ni, body-centred cubic) and taenite (high-Ni, face-centred cubic). Etched and polished, they show the Widmanstätten pattern of interlocking plates.
| Structural class | Ni content | Texture |
|---|---|---|
| Hexahedrites | low (about 5–6%) | kamacite only; Neumann lines |
| Octahedrites | intermediate | Widmanstätten pattern; band width shrinks as Ni rises |
| Ataxites | high | no visible structure |
The Widmanstätten texture needs cooling rates of only degrees per million years, possible only deep inside bodies tens to hundreds of kilometres across. Iron meteorites are therefore direct evidence that small planets formed metallic cores, and a model for Earth’s core.
Stony-irons
- Pallasites: olivine crystals set in Fe–Ni metal. The classic interpretation is a sample of the core–mantle boundary of a differentiated asteroid.
- Mesosiderites: brecciated basalt and pyroxenite mixed with metal, a product of impact mixing.
Earth’s Composition
Physical constraints
| Quantity | Value | What it tells us |
|---|---|---|
| Mean density | 5.51 g cm\(^{-3}\) | much denser than surface rocks (about 2.7–3.0), so the interior must be denser |
| Moment of inertia factor \( C/MR^2 \) | 0.3307 | less than 0.4 (uniform sphere): mass is concentrated towards the centre |
| Core radius | about 3,480 km (core–mantle boundary at 2,890 km depth) | from seismic P and S waves; S waves do not cross the outer core, so it is liquid |
| Inner core radius | about 1,220 km | solid; discovered by Inge Lehmann (1936) |
| Core mass fraction | about 32.5% of Earth’s mass, about 16% of its volume | |
| Pressure at the centre | about 364 GPa |
Seismic density profiles (the PREM model): crust about 2.7–2.9; upper mantle about 3.3 rising to about 4.4 at 660 km; lower mantle about 4.4 to 5.6; outer core about 9.9 to 12.2; inner core about 12.8 to 13.1 g cm\(^{-3}\).
Bulk Earth
Approximate mass percentages for the whole Earth (chondrite-based models):
| Element | Mass % (approx.) |
|---|---|
| Fe | 32 |
| O | 30 |
| Si | 15 |
| Mg | 14 |
| S | 3 |
| Ni | 1.8 |
| Ca | 1.5 |
| Al | 1.4 |
These four elements, Fe, O, Si, Mg, make up over 90% of Earth. Compared with CI chondrites, Earth is depleted in volatile elements (for example K, Na, Pb, S and especially water and noble gases), roughly in order of their volatility.
Crust
The eight most abundant elements in the continental crust (mass %, classic estimates):
| O | Si | Al | Fe | Ca | Na | K | Mg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 46.6 | 27.7 | 8.1 | 5.0 | 3.6 | 2.8 | 2.6 | 2.1 |
Mnemonic below. Oxygen is nearly half the crust’s mass and over 90% of its volume, because the crust is essentially oxygen anions packed around small cations. The continental crust is broadly andesitic to granodioritic (about 60% SiO\(_2\)); oceanic crust is basaltic (about 50% SiO\(_2\)), about 7 km thick against an average of about 35–40 km for continents.
Mantle
The mantle is peridotite: olivine-rich, with orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene and an aluminous phase (plagioclase at shallow depth, spinel deeper, garnet deeper still). Ringwood’s pyrolite model (about 3 parts peridotite to 1 part basalt) is a standard composition. Primitive mantle in oxide wt%: SiO\(_2\) about 45, MgO about 38, FeO about 8, Al\(_2\)O\(_3\) about 4.5, CaO about 3.5.
With depth, olivine transforms to wadsleyite (about 410 km) and ringwoodite, and at about 660 km to bridgmanite (Mg-silicate perovskite) plus ferropericlase. Bridgmanite is the most abundant mineral in Earth.
Core
- Mainly Fe with about 5% Ni (by analogy with iron meteorites and cosmic Fe/Ni ratios).
- The outer core is about 10% less dense than pure Fe–Ni at core pressure and temperature, so it must contain light elements: candidates are S, O, Si, C and H. The inner core has a smaller density deficit.
- The outer core is liquid and convects, generating the geomagnetic field; the inner core is solid and grows as Earth cools, releasing latent heat and light elements that help drive convection.
Primary Differentiation
Differentiation is the separation of a planet into chemically distinct layers. Earth’s primary differentiation, mostly within its first ~100 Myr, made the core and the primitive mantle; later melting extracted the crust, ocean and atmosphere.
Goldschmidt’s geochemical classification
| Class | Affinity | Typical elements | Where they went |
|---|---|---|---|
| Siderophile | metallic iron | Fe, Ni, Co, Au, Pt-group elements (Pt, Ir, Os, …), Re, Mo | core |
| Chalcophile | sulphur | Cu, Zn, Pb, Ag, Cd, As, S, Se | sulphides; partly core |
| Lithophile | silicate and oxygen | Si, Al, Ca, Mg, Na, K, rare-earth elements, U, Th, Rb, Sr, Hf | mantle and crust |
| Atmophile | gas | H, N, noble gases (and C as CO\(_2\)) | atmosphere and oceans |
The scheme was built from the phases in meteorites and smelter products (metal, sulphide matte, silicate slag, gas). Some elements straddle classes; Fe itself is siderophile, chalcophile and lithophile depending on oxygen and sulphur availability.
Core formation
graph TD
A[Accretion: planetesimals and embryos collide] --> B[Heating: impacts, Al-26 decay, gravitational energy]
B --> C[Melting: magma ocean]
C --> D[Fe-Ni metal droplets segregate through silicate melt]
D --> E[Metal diapirs sink to form the core]
E --> F[Siderophiles stripped from mantle into core]
F --> G[Moon-forming giant impact remelts outer Earth]
G --> H[Late veneer adds a little chondritic material]Heat sources for melting: kinetic energy of impacts, the decay of short-lived \( ^{26}\text{Al} \) and \( ^{60}\text{Fe} \) in early planetesimals, and the gravitational energy released as dense metal sinks (enough on its own to raise Earth’s average temperature by of order a thousand kelvin).
Evidence for timing. The \( ^{182}\text{Hf}\to{}^{182}\text{W} \) system (half-life about 8.9 Myr) is the key clock. Hf is lithophile and stays in the mantle; W is siderophile and goes with metal. If the core formed while \( ^{182}\text{Hf} \) was still alive, the mantle would later develop excess \( ^{182}\text{W} \) relative to chondrites. It does, which shows that core formation was largely complete within the first few tens of Myr of solar-system history.
The excess-siderophile problem. If the mantle equilibrated with core metal at low pressure, highly siderophile elements (Pt-group elements, Au, Re) should have been almost entirely removed. Instead the mantle has them in roughly chondritic relative proportions, at roughly 1% or less of chondritic concentrations. The common explanation is a late veneer: less than 1% of Earth’s mass of chondritic material added after core formation ended. High-pressure, high-temperature metal–silicate equilibrium in a deep magma ocean also explains the moderately siderophile elements (Ni, Co).
Crust, ocean and atmosphere
Crusts are often grouped in three kinds (after Taylor and McLennan):
| Crust type | How it forms | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Primary | crystallises directly from a magma ocean, often by flotation | lunar highland anorthosite |
| Secondary | partial melting of the mantle | oceanic crust (mid-ocean ridge basalt); Martian and Venusian basalts |
| Tertiary | remelting and reworking of secondary crust, with water, at subduction zones | Earth’s continental crust; unique among the terrestrial planets |
Partial melting of the mantle concentrates incompatible elements (those that do not fit easily into mantle mineral lattices: K, Rb, U, Th, light REE, Ba) into the melt, so the continental crust is strongly enriched in them. Earth’s crust holds a large fraction of the planet’s heat-producing U, Th and K despite being less than 1% of its mass. The residual mantle is depleted, and mid-ocean ridge basalts sample this depleted mantle.
The atmosphere and oceans came from degassing of the interior and from volatile-rich material (carbonaceous-chondrite-like bodies; comets probably contributed less, judging from their D/H ratios). Much of Earth’s \( ^{40}\text{Ar} \), made by \( ^{40}\text{K} \) decay inside the planet, is now in the atmosphere, which shows that the interior has degassed substantially.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Chondrite: never melted; has chondrules | Achondrite: igneous; from a differentiated body | |
| Chondrule: once-molten silicate droplet | CAI: refractory first condensate; dates solar system | |
| Fall: observed, unbiased sample | Find: biased towards irons | |
| Kamacite: low Ni, bcc | Taenite: high Ni, fcc | |
| Pallasite: olivine in metal (core–mantle boundary) | Mesosiderite: basalt breccia plus metal (impact mix) | |
| Siderophile: goes to the core (Ni, Pt, Au) | Chalcophile: goes to sulphide (Cu, Zn, Pb) | |
| Compatible elements (Ni, Cr, Mg) stay in mantle | Incompatible elements (K, U, Th, Rb) go to melt and crust |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the Widmanstätten pattern made of?
- Name the asteroid from which HED meteorites are thought to come.
- Which element is most abundant by mass in the continental crust?
Answers
- Interlocking plates of kamacite (low-Ni) and taenite (high-Ni) Fe–Ni alloys, produced by very slow cooling.
- 4 Vesta.
- Oxygen (about 46.6%).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The oldest dated solids in the solar system are:
(a) chondrules in ordinary chondrites (b) calcium–aluminium-rich inclusions in carbonaceous chondrites (c) Jack Hills detrital zircons (d) eucrites from Vesta
Answer: (b)
CAIs give Pb–Pb ages of about 4,567 Ma, defining “time zero”. Chondrules formed within a few Myr after them. Jack Hills zircons (about 4.4 Ga) are the oldest terrestrial minerals; eucrites are igneous rocks from an already-differentiated body.
Practice Q2. Which group of elements is most strongly concentrated in Earth’s core?
(a) K, Rb, U (b) Ni, Ir, Au (c) Cu, Zn, Pb (d) Ar, Ne, N
Answer: (b) Ni, Ir, Au
These are siderophile. (a) are lithophile and incompatible (crust); (c) are chalcophile (sulphides); (d) are atmophile.
Practice Q3. Pallasites are best interpreted as samples of:
(a) the regolith of the Moon (b) the core–mantle boundary region of a differentiated asteroid (c) primitive nebular condensates (d) Martian volcanic rocks
Answer: (b)
Pallasites are olivine (mantle mineral) in Fe–Ni metal (core material), the classic picture of a core–mantle boundary. Primitive condensates are chondrites; Martian igneous rocks are the SNC group.
Practice Q4. Earth’s moment of inertia factor is 0.33 rather than 0.40 because:
(a) Earth is oblate (b) Earth rotates (c) Earth’s density increases towards the centre (d) Earth’s crust is less dense than its mantle only beneath oceans
Answer: (c)
A uniform sphere has \( C/MR^2 = 0.4 \). Concentrating mass towards the centre lowers the factor; 0.33 requires a dense core. Oblateness and rotation affect \( C - A \) (and \( J_2 \)), not the main reduction.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. Consider the statements about the \( ^{182}\text{Hf}\to{}^{182}\text{W} \) system:
- Hf is lithophile and W is siderophile.
- Core formation while \( ^{182}\text{Hf} \) was still alive leaves the silicate mantle with a high Hf/W ratio.
- Earth’s mantle has a \( ^{182}\text{W} \) excess relative to chondrites, indicating early core formation.
- If the core had formed after all \( ^{182}\text{Hf} \) had decayed, the mantle would still show a \( ^{182}\text{W} \) excess.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 true: that difference is the whole basis of the method.
- 2 true: W leaves with the metal, Hf stays, so mantle Hf/W rises.
- 3 true: the high-Hf/W mantle then grew extra radiogenic \( ^{182}\text{W} \) while \( ^{182}\text{Hf} \) was still decaying.
- 4 false: once \( ^{182}\text{Hf} \) is extinct (after about 50–60 Myr, six to seven half-lives), separating Hf from W cannot change \( ^{182}\text{W} \) any further, so a late core would leave no anomaly.
Practice Q6. A two-layer Earth model has a core of radius 3,480 km and a mantle-plus-crust shell extending to 6,371 km. If the mean density of the whole Earth is 5.51 g cm\(^{-3}\) and the shell’s mean density is 4.5 g cm\(^{-3}\), the mean density of the core is closest to:
(a) 7.9 g cm\(^{-3}\) (b) 9.5 g cm\(^{-3}\) (c) 11.0 g cm\(^{-3}\) (d) 12.8 g cm\(^{-3}\)
Answer: (c) 11.0 g cm^-3
Volume fraction of the core: \( (3480/6371)^3 = (0.5462)^3 \approx 0.163 \).
Mass balance: \( 5.51 = 0.163\,\rho_c + 0.837 \times 4.5 = 0.163\,\rho_c + 3.767 \).
So \( \rho_c = (5.51 - 3.767)/0.163 \approx 10.7 \) g cm\(^{-3}\), closest to 11.0. This matches the PREM range for the core (about 9.9–13.1), and is far above any rock, confirming a metallic core.
Practice Q7. The continental crust makes up well under 1% of Earth’s mass but contains a large fraction of its K, U and Th. The best explanation is:
(a) these elements are siderophile and were stripped from the core (b) these elements are incompatible and partition into partial melts of the mantle, which build the crust (c) these elements were added by the late veneer of carbonaceous chondrites (d) these elements are atmophile and condensed from the early atmosphere
Answer: (b)
K, U and Th are large or highly charged ions that do not fit olivine and pyroxene sites. During partial melting they enter the melt, and repeated melting and recycling concentrate them in the continental crust. (a) gets the affinity wrong (they are lithophile); (c) the late veneer was less than 1% of Earth’s mass and chondritic, not specially enriched in these elements.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact |
|---|---|
| Meteorite falls | chondrites about 86%, achondrites 8%, irons 4–5%, stony-irons about 1% |
| Chondrite parts | chondrules, CAIs (about 4,567 Ma), matrix |
| CI chondrites | match solar photosphere (except H, C, N, O, noble gases, Li) |
| Enstatite chondrites | reduced; isotopes closest to Earth |
| HED / SNC | Vesta / Mars |
| Iron meteorites | kamacite + taenite → Widmanstätten pattern; asteroid cores |
| Pallasites | olivine in metal; core–mantle boundary |
| Bulk Earth | Fe 32, O 30, Si 15, Mg 14% |
| Crust | O 46.6, Si 27.7, Al 8.1, Fe 5.0, Ca 3.6, Na 2.8, K 2.6, Mg 2.1% |
| Core | Fe + about 5% Ni + about 10% light elements (outer core) |
| \( C/MR^2 \) | 0.3307 (uniform sphere 0.4) |
| Goldschmidt | siderophile, chalcophile, lithophile, atmophile |
| Core timing | Hf–W: within first few tens of Myr |
| Late veneer | under 1% of Earth’s mass of chondritic material |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Stratigraphy, Origin of Life and the Fossil Record: from the differentiated planet to the layered rock record and life.
- Gravity, Geomagnetism, Heat Flow and Isostasy: how geophysics sees the layered interior described here.
- The Earth and the Solar System: Quick Revision.