Skip to content

Ore Microscopy, Fluid Inclusions and Isotopes

CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C: reflected-light ore microscopy, paragenesis, fluid inclusion microthermometry, and stable and radiogenic isotopes in ores.

  • 22 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Sorby’s Bubbles
  3. Ore Microscopy
  4. Fluid Inclusions
  5. Stable Isotopes
  6. Radiogenic Isotopes in Ore Deposits
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Sorby’s Bubbles

Ore Microscopy

Ore minerals (sulfides, oxides, native metals) are mostly opaque, so they are studied in reflected light on polished sections or polished thin sections. Light from a vertical illuminator falls on the polished surface and the reflected part is viewed through the objective.

Properties used for identification

PropertyConditionsWhat it tells you
Colourplane-polarised light, in air or oilpyrite pale brass-yellow; chalcopyrite brass-yellow (deeper than pyrite); gold rich yellow; covellite deep blue; bornite pinkish brown (tarnishes purple)
Reflectance (R%)percentage of incident light reflected, measured against a standardranks minerals by brightness
Bireflectance / reflection pleochroismrotate the stage in plane-polarised lightchange in brightness or colour in non-cubic minerals (strong in covellite, molybdenite, graphite)
Anisotropycrossed polars, rotate stagecubic minerals stay dark (isotropic); others show colour or brightness changes
Internal reflectionscrossed polars, best in oillight entering a transparent or translucent grain and returning: sphalerite (yellow-brown), cinnabar (red), cassiterite, rutile, hematite (rare, deep red)
Polishing hardnessrelative relief and the Kalb light line at a grain boundarythe harder mineral stands higher
Microindentation hardnessVickers hardness number (VHN)quantitative hardness
Form, cleavage, twinningplane lightgalena shows triangular cleavage pits; pyrite cubes; arsenopyrite rhombs; marcasite and arsenopyrite twins

Reflectance and optical constants. At normal incidence, the Fresnel relation gives reflectance in terms of the refractive index \( n \), the absorption coefficient \( k \) and the refractive index of the immersion medium \( N \) (1.00 for air, about 1.52 for oil):

$$\boxed{R = \frac{(n - N)^2 + k^2}{(n + N)^2 + k^2}}$$

For a transparent mineral (\( k = 0 \)) such as sphalerite (\( n \approx 2.37 \)), \( R = (1.37/3.37)^2 \approx 16.5\% \) in air. Opaque minerals have large \( k \) and therefore high \( R \). Reflectance always falls when you change from air to oil, because \( N \) rises.

A working identification table

Approximate reflectances in air at about 546 nm, rounded:

MineralColour in airR% (about)AnisotropyOther clues
Pyrite \( \text{FeS}_2 \)pale yellow-white54isotropic (some weak anomalous)very hard, high relief, cubes
Chalcopyrite \( \text{CuFeS}_2 \)brass-yellow46weaksofter than pyrite; twinning
Galena PbSwhite43isotropictriangular pits; soft
Pyrrhotite \( \text{Fe}_{1-x}\text{S} \)creamy pinkish brown39strongmagnetic; pentlandite flames
Pentlandite \( (\text{Fe,Ni})_9\text{S}_8 \)light creamabout 50isotropicflames and rims in pyrrhotite
Arsenopyrite FeAsSwhiteabout 51moderate to strongrhombic sections, hard
Hematite \( \text{Fe}_2\text{O}_3 \)grey-white with bluish tintabout 25–30distinctred internal reflections rare
Magnetite \( \text{Fe}_3\text{O}_4 \)grey with brownish tintabout 20isotropicmagnetic; martite (hematite) along {111}
Ilmenite \( \text{FeTiO}_3 \)brownish greyabout 18–20stronglamellae in magnetite
Sphalerite ZnSgreyabout 17isotropicyellow-brown internal reflections; chalcopyrite blebs
Chromite \( \text{FeCr}_2\text{O}_4 \)grey, brownishabout 12isotropicin ultramafics
Covellite CuSdeep blue to bluish white7–24 (strongly bireflectant)extreme, fiery orangesupergene
Native goldrich yellowhighisotropicsoft; does not tarnish

Exact values vary with composition and wavelength (see the accuracy note at the end of the chapter). For Part C the order matters more than the number: pyrite > chalcopyrite > galena > pyrrhotite > hematite > magnetite > sphalerite.

Ore textures

Texture groupExamplesInterpretation
Open-space fillingcomb quartz, crustiform and colloform banding, cockade around breccia fragments, vugsdeposition in open fractures at shallow depth (epithermal veins, MVT)
Replacementcaries texture (concave bites), rims along grain boundaries and fractures, pseudomorphs, relict islandsa later mineral replacing an earlier one; the replacing mineral is younger
Exsolutionilmenite lamellae in magnetite; pentlandite flames in pyrrhotite; chalcopyrite lamellae in bornite or cubanitea high-T solid solution unmixed on cooling; host and lamellae formed together
Colloform / framboidalframboidal pyrite, colloform sphalerite (schalenblende)rapid precipitation, low T, sometimes biogenic (framboids in black shale)
Deformationbent twin lamellae, curved galena cleavage pits, cataclasis of pyritepost-ore deformation
Annealing (metamorphic)equant grains with 120° triple junctions; pyrite porphyroblastsrecrystallisation during metamorphism

Building a paragenetic sequence

A paragenetic sequence is the order in which minerals were deposited. Rules:

  1. A mineral in veinlets that cut another mineral is younger.
  2. A replacing mineral (filling caries, forming rims, pseudomorphing) is younger than the one it replaces.
  3. Crystals that grew into open space are younger than the wall they grew on; crusts are younger from the wall inward.
  4. Exsolution pairs are contemporaneous (one phase at the time of formation).
  5. Mutual boundaries with no replacement suggest co-precipitation.

The result is usually drawn as a bar chart of minerals against stages (early, main, late, supergene).

Fluid Inclusions

A fluid inclusion is a small volume of fluid (usually 1–50 µm) trapped in a crystal as it grows or as a fracture heals.

Origin

TypeWhen trappedRecognition
Primaryduring growth of the host crystalalong growth zones, isolated in the crystal core, in random 3D distribution
Secondaryafter growth, in healed fracturestrails that cross grain boundaries
Pseudosecondaryduring growth, in fractures that healed before the crystal finished growingtrails that end inside the crystal at a growth zone

Only primary and pseudosecondary inclusions record the fluid that grew the mineral. A fluid inclusion assemblage (FIA) is a group of inclusions trapped at the same time (along one growth zone or one healed fracture); measurements should be reported by assemblage.

Roedder’s rules

Interpretations assume three conditions:

  1. The fluid was trapped as a single homogeneous phase.
  2. The cavity has kept a constant volume since trapping (the inclusion is isochoric).
  3. Nothing has been added or lost since trapping.

Violations: heterogeneous trapping (mixtures of liquid and vapour from a boiling fluid), necking down (one inclusion splits into several with different phase ratios), stretching and decrepitation (overheating), and leakage. Inconsistent phase ratios within one assemblage warn that the rules have failed.

Phase types at room temperature

TypePhasesCommon in
Liquid-rich two-phase (L + V)aqueous liquid with a small bubblemost hydrothermal systems
Vapour-rich (V + L)large bubble, thin liquid filmboiling systems, porphyry
Multiphase (L + V + daughter salt)a halite (cubic) or sylvite daughter crystalhypersaline porphyry fluids
\( \text{CO}_2 \)-bearingaqueous liquid + liquid \( \text{CO}_2 \) + \( \text{CO}_2 \) vapour (“double bubble”)orogenic gold, metamorphic fluids
Monophase liquidliquid onlylow-T fluids (below about 50–70 °C) or metastable

Microthermometry

On a heating–freezing stage, the inclusion is frozen and then warmed, and phase changes are recorded.

MeasurementSymbolMeaning
First (eutectic) melting\( T_e \)identifies dissolved salts: about −21.2 °C for \( \text{NaCl–H}_2\text{O} \); much lower (about −50 °C or below) when \( \text{CaCl}_2 \) is present
Final ice melting\( T_{m,\text{ice}} \)gives salinity from freezing-point depression
\( \text{CO}_2 \) melting\( T_{m,\text{CO}_2} \)−56.6 °C for pure \( \text{CO}_2 \); lower means \( \text{CH}_4 \) or \( \text{N}_2 \) is present
Clathrate melting\( T_{m,\text{cla}} \)salinity in \( \text{CO}_2 \)-bearing inclusions (clathrate excludes salt; ice melting is unreliable)
Halite dissolution\( T_s \)salinity of hypersaline inclusions (above about 26 wt% NaCl)
Homogenisation\( T_h \)temperature at which the bubble disappears (to liquid) or the liquid disappears (to vapour)

Salinity from ice melting. For the \( \text{NaCl–H}_2\text{O} \) system, with \( \theta \) the freezing-point depression in °C (\( \theta = -T_{m,\text{ice}} \)), the Bodnar (1993) equation gives salinity in wt% NaCl equivalent:

$$\boxed{\text{wt\% NaCl eq} = 1.78\,\theta - 0.0442\,\theta^2 + 0.000557\,\theta^3}$$

It is valid from 0 to the eutectic (−21.2 °C, 23.2 wt%). Salinity is reported as “NaCl equivalent” because other salts (KCl, \( \text{CaCl}_2 \)) also depress the freezing point.

From homogenisation to trapping conditions

Because the inclusion is isochoric, it follows a line of constant density (an isochore) in P–T space after trapping. The homogenisation temperature is where that isochore meets the liquid–vapour curve.

graph TD
    A[Trapping at Tt, Pt
single phase] --> B[Cooling along isochore
constant density] B --> C[Meets L-V curve at Th
bubble nucleates] C --> D[Room temperature
L + V] D --> E[Lab heating:
bubble vanishes at Th]
  • \( T_h \) is a minimum trapping temperature. To get the true trapping temperature \( T_t \), add a pressure correction along the isochore, using an independent pressure (depth) or temperature estimate.
  • If the fluid was boiling when trapped, it was on the liquid–vapour curve, so \( T_t = T_h \) and no correction is needed.
  • The intersection of isochores from two immiscible fluids, or of an isochore with an independent geothermometer, gives both P and T.

Evidence for boiling: coexisting liquid-rich and vapour-rich inclusions in one assemblage that homogenise at about the same temperature, the liquid-rich ones to liquid and the vapour-rich ones to vapour. Supporting textures: bladed calcite, adularia, colloform silica.

Fluid fingerprints of deposit types

Typical ranges from the literature, rounded:

Deposit\( T_h \) (°C, about)Salinity (wt% NaCl eq)Other
Porphyry Cu300 to over 600hypersaline (30–70, halite-bearing) coexisting with low-salinity vapourboiling, magmatic
Epithermal (low-sulfidation)150–300low (under about 5)boiling, meteoric-dominated
VMSabout 200–350close to seawater (about 3.5)
MVTabout 75–200high (about 10–30), Ca-richno boiling, basinal brine
Orogenic goldabout 250–400low (under about 10)\( \text{H}_2\text{O–CO}_2 \pm \text{CH}_4 \), metamorphic
Greisen Sn–Wabout 250–450variableF-rich

Beyond microthermometry: laser Raman spectroscopy identifies \( \text{CO}_2 \), \( \text{CH}_4 \), \( \text{N}_2 \), \( \text{H}_2\text{S} \) and daughter minerals without opening the inclusion; LA-ICP-MS measures metal contents (Cu, Zn, Pb, Au) of single inclusions; crush–leach analysis gives halogen ratios (Cl/Br) of bulk fluids.

Stable Isotopes

Notation and standards

Isotope ratios are reported as per-mil deviations from a standard:

$$\boxed{\delta = \left(\frac{R_{\text{sample}}}{R_{\text{standard}}} - 1\right)\times 1000\ \text{‰}}$$
SystemRatioStandard
Oxygen\( ^{18}\text{O}/^{16}\text{O} \)VSMOW (waters, silicates); VPDB (carbonates)
HydrogenD/HVSMOW
Carbon\( ^{13}\text{C}/^{12}\text{C} \)VPDB
Sulfur\( ^{34}\text{S}/^{32}\text{S} \)VCDT (Cañon Diablo troilite)

Fractionation and geothermometry

Between two phases A and B in equilibrium:

$$\alpha_{A\text{-}B} = \frac{R_A}{R_B}, \qquad \Delta_{A\text{-}B} = \delta_A - \delta_B \approx 1000\ln\alpha_{A\text{-}B}$$

At high temperature, \( 1000\ln\alpha \) varies as \( 1/T^2 \) (T in kelvin):

$$\boxed{1000\ln\alpha \approx \frac{A\times 10^{6}}{T^{2}} + B}$$

Fractionation falls as temperature rises, so a measured \( \Delta \) between two coexisting minerals is a geothermometer, independent of pressure. Common pairs: quartz–magnetite and quartz–water (oxygen); pyrite–galena and sphalerite–galena (sulfur). Requirements: the two minerals formed together in equilibrium and did not re-equilibrate later.

Order of \( ^{34}\text{S} \) enrichment among coexisting sulfides at equilibrium: pyrite > sphalerite ≈ pyrrhotite > chalcopyrite > galena. A pair that breaks this order (galena heavier than sphalerite) is not in equilibrium, and no temperature should be calculated from it.

Oxygen and hydrogen: where did the water come from?

Reservoir\( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) (‰ VSMOW)\( \delta\text{D} \) (‰ VSMOW)
Seawaterabout 0about 0
Meteoric waternegative, along the meteoric water line\( \delta\text{D} = 8\,\delta^{18}\text{O} + 10 \) (Craig)
Magmatic waterabout +5.5 to +10about −40 to −80
Metamorphic waterabout +3 to +25about −20 to −65

Two steps:

  1. Measure \( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) of a mineral (quartz, for example) and calculate the fluid value using the fractionation at the fluid inclusion temperature.
  2. Measure \( \delta\text{D} \) of the fluid directly from inclusions (or from hydrous minerals), and plot the fluid on the \( \delta\text{D} \)–\( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) diagram.

Oxygen shift. Meteoric water that exchanges with hot rock gains \( ^{18}\text{O} \) (rocks hold far more oxygen than water has hydrogen to exchange), so it moves to the right at almost constant \( \delta\text{D} \). Hydrogen is a better tracer of the original water source.

Sulfur: where did the sulfur come from?

Source\( \delta^{34}\text{S} \) (‰ VCDT)
Mantle and magmatic sulfurclose to 0 (about −3 to +3)
Modern seawater sulfateabout +21; it varied through the Phanerozoic (roughly +10 to +35)
Bacterial sulfate reduction (BSR), low T (below about 100 °C)sulfide strongly depleted, often tens of ‰ lighter than the sulfate; wide spread of values
Thermochemical sulfate reduction (TSR), higher Tsulfide a little lighter than the sulfate (small fractionation)

Reading the data:

  • Narrow range near 0‰ → magmatic sulfur (porphyry, magmatic Ni–Cu, many orogenic gold deposits).
  • Wide range of very negative values → BSR in sediments (framboidal pyrite in black shale; some SEDEX).
  • Values a few ‰ to 15–20‰ below coeval seawater sulfate → TSR (many MVT and VMS deposits, where seawater sulfate is reduced by hot rock or organic matter).

Carbon

Mantle carbon has \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) of about −5 to −7‰; marine carbonate about 0‰; organic matter about −25‰ (C3 plants). Hydrothermal carbonates plotting between these reservoirs show mixing of sources. Gold-related carbonates in orogenic deposits often lie between mantle and marine carbonate values.

Radiogenic Isotopes in Ore Deposits

Lead isotopes

Lead has one non-radiogenic isotope, \( ^{204}\text{Pb} \), and three radiogenic ones: \( ^{206}\text{Pb} \) (from \( ^{238}\text{U} \)), \( ^{207}\text{Pb} \) (from \( ^{235}\text{U} \)) and \( ^{208}\text{Pb} \) (from \( ^{232}\text{Th} \)).

Galena contains almost no U or Th. Once it crystallises, its Pb isotopic composition is frozen. That has two uses:

  1. Model ages. If the source evolved as a single closed U–Pb reservoir from primordial Pb (Holmes–Houtermans model) or in two stages (Stacey–Kramers model), the galena’s \( ^{206}\text{Pb}/^{204}\text{Pb} \) and \( ^{207}\text{Pb}/^{204}\text{Pb} \) give the time at which the Pb was separated from its source.
  2. Source tracing. Upper continental crust has high U/Pb (high \( \mu = {}^{238}\text{U}/{}^{204}\text{Pb} \)) and yields “radiogenic” Pb; mantle-derived Pb is less radiogenic. Pb from old crust gives high \( ^{207}\text{Pb}/^{204}\text{Pb} \).

Anomalous lead. Lead that has picked up radiogenic Pb from several sources does not fit a single-stage model. The classic case is the J-type (Joplin) lead of the Mississippi Valley district, so radiogenic that it gives a model age in the future (negative). Model ages are therefore trustworthy only for “conformable” lead from large, homogeneous sources such as VMS and SEDEX deposits.

Strontium and neodymium

\( ^{87}\text{Sr}/^{86}\text{Sr} \) of gangue minerals (calcite, fluorite, barite) records the source of the fluid: about 0.703–0.704 for mantle-derived fluids, about 0.709 for modern seawater, and higher for fluids that leached old continental crust. Barite in VMS deposits typically shows seawater-like values.

Dating mineralisation directly

MethodMineralNotes
Re–OsmolybdeniteRe-rich, essentially no initial Os; a robust direct age for porphyry and greisen ores
Re–Ospyrite, arsenopyrite (isochron)ages for gold and sulfide ores
\( ^{40}\text{Ar}/^{39}\text{Ar} \)sericite, adularia, alunite, biotiteages of alteration; reset by later heating
U–Pbhydrothermal zircon, monazite, xenotime, cassiterite, rutilehigh closure temperatures
Sm–Ndscheelite, fluorite, tourmaline
Rb–Srsphalerite, sericite

The age of the host rock is only a maximum for epigenetic ore; the age of a mineral grown with the ore is what dates the mineralising event.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisNot this
Bireflectance: brightness change on rotation in plane-polarised lightAnisotropy: colour or brightness change on rotation under crossed polars
Primary inclusion: trapped during growthSecondary inclusion: trapped later in healed fractures
\( T_h \): bubble disappears; minimum trapping T\( T_t \): true trapping T = \( T_h \) + pressure correction
\( T_e \): first melting; which salts\( T_{m,\text{ice}} \): last ice melts; how much salt
Exsolution: contemporaneous host and lamellaeReplacement: replacing phase is younger
BSR: low T, bacteria, large and variable \( ^{34}\text{S} \) depletionTSR: higher T, abiotic, small fractionation
\( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) shift: water–rock exchange moves meteoric water right\( \delta\text{D} \): changes little; keeps the meteoric signature

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which isotope of lead is not produced by radioactive decay?
  2. What is the melting temperature of pure solid \( \text{CO}_2 \) in a fluid inclusion?
  3. Under crossed polars a mineral stays dark on full rotation of the stage. What does this suggest about its crystal system?
Answers
  1. \( ^{204}\text{Pb} \).
  2. −56.6 °C (the \( \text{CO}_2 \) triple point).
  3. It is optically isotropic: usually cubic (galena, sphalerite, magnetite) or amorphous. It could also be a non-cubic grain cut perpendicular to an optic axis, so check several grains.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. A fluid inclusion in quartz shows final ice melting at −3.5 °C. Its salinity is closest to:

(a) 3.5 wt% NaCl eq (b) 5.7 wt% NaCl eq (c) 6.2 wt% NaCl eq (d) 10.0 wt% NaCl eq

Answer: (b) 5.7 wt% NaCl eq

\( \theta = 3.5 \): \( 1.78(3.5) - 0.0442(12.25) + 0.000557(42.875) = 6.230 - 0.541 + 0.024 = 5.71 \) wt%. Option (c) uses only the linear term; option (a) equates the temperature with the salinity.

Practice Q2. In a polished section, a mineral is grey, weakly reflecting, isotropic and shows yellow-brown internal reflections under crossed polars. It is most likely:

(a) galena (b) sphalerite (c) magnetite (d) pyrrhotite

Answer: (b) sphalerite

Low reflectance (about 17%), isotropic, and transparent enough to show internal reflections. Galena is white and bright; magnetite has no internal reflections; pyrrhotite is creamy brown and strongly anisotropic.

Practice Q3. Fluid inclusions in one growth zone of a quartz crystal include both liquid-rich and vapour-rich types. Both homogenise at 285 ± 5 °C, the first to liquid and the second to vapour. The best interpretation is:

(a) necking down after trapping (b) trapping from a boiling fluid at about 285 °C (c) two separate fluids trapped at different times (d) the quartz grew at much more than 285 °C and needs a large pressure correction

Answer: (b)

Coexisting liquid-rich and vapour-rich inclusions in one assemblage, homogenising at the same temperature by opposite modes, is the textbook evidence for boiling. A boiling fluid lies on the liquid–vapour curve, so \( T_h \) is the trapping temperature and no pressure correction is needed: (d) is wrong. Necking would give scattered \( T_h \).

Practice Q4. \( \delta^{34}\text{S} \) values of coexisting sulfides in a vein are: pyrite +4.1‰, sphalerite +2.9‰, galena +0.1‰. Which statement is correct?

(a) The order shows disequilibrium. (b) The order is consistent with equilibrium, and the narrow range near 0‰ suggests magmatic sulfur. (c) The values indicate bacterial sulfate reduction. (d) The sulfur came from seawater sulfate with no fractionation.

Answer: (b)

Equilibrium order is pyrite > sphalerite > galena: satisfied. Values within a few per mil of 0 point to magmatic (or igneous-rock-derived) sulfur. BSR would give strongly negative, scattered values; unfractionated seawater sulfate would be near +20‰.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. Coexisting pyrite and galena in a vein have \( \delta^{34}\text{S} \) of +3.4‰ and +0.4‰. Use the calibration \( \Delta_{\text{py-gn}} = 1.01\times 10^{6}/T^{2} \) (T in K). Fluid inclusions in associated quartz have \( T_h = 250 \) °C and show no evidence of boiling. Which conclusion is best supported?

(a) Sulfide deposition at about 307 °C; the pressure correction to the inclusion data is about 57 °C. (b) Sulfide deposition at about 250 °C; no pressure correction needed. (c) Sulfide deposition at about 580 °C; the inclusions leaked. (d) The pair is out of equilibrium, so no temperature can be obtained.

Answer: (a)

\( \Delta = 3.4 - 0.4 = 3.0 \)‰. \( T^2 = 1.01\times 10^{6}/3.0 = 3.37\times 10^{5} \), so \( T = 580 \) K = 307 °C.

The order (pyrite heavier than galena) is consistent with equilibrium, so (d) is wrong. Option (c) forgets to convert kelvin to celsius.

With no boiling, \( T_h \) is a minimum. If the sulfides and quartz formed together, the isotope temperature gives the trapping temperature, and the difference (about 57 °C) is the pressure correction. The pressure can then be read from where the isochore reaches 307 °C.

Practice Q6. Vein quartz has \( \delta^{18}\text{O} = +9.0 \)‰ and fluid inclusion data give a trapping temperature of 250 °C. Fluid \( \delta\text{D} \) from the inclusions is −70‰. Using \( 1000\ln\alpha_{\text{qtz-water}} = 3.38\times 10^{6}/T^{2} - 3.40 \), the fluid was most likely:

(a) magmatic water (b) seawater (c) meteoric water that had exchanged oxygen with rocks (d) metamorphic water with \( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) of +15‰

Answer: (c)

\( T = 523.15 \) K; \( 3.38\times 10^{6}/523.15^2 = 12.35 \); \( \Delta = 12.35 - 3.40 = 8.95 \)‰. So \( \delta^{18}\text{O}_{\text{water}} \approx 9.0 - 8.95 = +0.05 \)‰, about 0‰.

On the meteoric water line, \( \delta\text{D} = -70 \)‰ corresponds to \( \delta^{18}\text{O} = (-70 - 10)/8 = -10 \)‰. The fluid has the \( \delta\text{D} \) of a meteoric water but is shifted about 10‰ to the right in oxygen: an oxygen-shifted meteoric water. Seawater would have \( \delta\text{D} \) near 0; magmatic water would have \( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) of +5.5 to +10.

Practice Q7. Consider these statements:

  1. Molybdenite is well suited to Re–Os dating because it contains Re but almost no initial Os.
  2. A galena with J-type lead gives a model age older than the age of its host rock.
  3. Secondary fluid inclusions can be recognised as trails that cross grain boundaries.
  4. Reflectance of a mineral increases when it is observed in oil instead of air.

Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only

Answer: (a) 1 and 3 only
  • 1 true: almost all Os in molybdenite is radiogenic \( ^{187}\text{Os} \) from \( ^{187}\text{Re} \).
  • 2 false: J-type lead is anomalously radiogenic and gives model ages that are too young, even in the future.
  • 3 true: healed fractures that cut across several grains post-date their growth.
  • 4 false: in the Fresnel equation, raising the medium index \( N \) lowers \( R \).

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact or formula
Reflected lightcolour, R%, bireflectance (plane light); anisotropy, internal reflections (crossed polars); polishing hardness
Fresnel\( R = [(n-N)^2 + k^2]/[(n+N)^2 + k^2] \); R lower in oil
Brightness orderpyrite > chalcopyrite > galena > pyrrhotite > hematite > magnetite > sphalerite
Paragenesiscrosscutting and replacing phases are younger; exsolution pairs are contemporaneous
Inclusion originprimary (growth zones), pseudosecondary (fractures ending in crystal), secondary (cross grains)
Roedder’s rulessingle phase; constant volume; closed system
Key temperatures\( T_e \) NaCl–H₂O −21.2 °C; \( \text{CO}_2 \) melting −56.6 °C; \( T_h \) minimum trapping T
Salinity\( 1.78\theta - 0.0442\theta^2 + 0.000557\theta^3 \) wt% NaCl eq
BoilingL-rich and V-rich together, same \( T_h \), opposite modes; no pressure correction
\( \delta \) notation\( (R_s/R_{std} - 1)\times 1000 \); VSMOW, VPDB, VCDT
Geothermometry\( \Delta \approx 1000\ln\alpha \propto 1/T^2 \); larger \( \Delta \) = lower T
Water sourcesseawater 0/0; magmatic \( \delta^{18}\text{O} \) +5.5 to +10; MWL \( \delta\text{D} = 8\delta^{18}\text{O} + 10 \)
Sulfur sourcesmagmatic about 0‰; seawater sulfate about +21‰ today; BSR strongly negative; TSR small shift
Pb isotopesgalena freezes Pb; model ages; J-type gives future ages
Direct datingRe–Os molybdenite; Ar–Ar sericite, adularia; U–Pb hydrothermal zircon, monazite

Key Takeaways

What’s Next