EM Methods: Loop Methods, VLF, AFMAG and TEM
Inductive EM for CSIR NET geophysics: skin depth, response parameter, in-phase and quadrature, HLEM and tilt-angle loops, VLF, AFMAG, transient EM decay.
- 22 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Finding a Conductor Without Touching the Ground
- The Physics of Inductive EM
- Loop Methods (Frequency Domain)
- VLF: Very-Low-Frequency EM
- AFMAG: Audio-Frequency Magnetics
- TEM: Transient (Time-Domain) EM
- Comparing the EM Methods
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Magnetostatics and Electromagnetic Induction: Faraday’s law, mutual inductance and the L–R circuit, the whole of the response function on this page.
- EM Waves: Reflection, Refraction and Polarization: fields in conductors, attenuation and elliptical polarisation.
- Resistivity Profiling and Sounding: the conductivity contrasts EM is looking for, and the S (conductance) parameter that returns here.
The Hook: Finding a Conductor Without Touching the Ground
How CSIR NET asks it. Part C Geophysics: skin depth calculations, the meaning of in-phase and quadrature, the response parameter and phase of the secondary field, HLEM and tilt-angle profile shapes, VLF source geometry and the Fraser filter, the AFMAG source, and TEM decay laws and diffusion depth.
The Physics of Inductive EM
graph LR
A["Transmitter: alternating current
primary field Hp"] --> B["Faraday's law: emf in conductor
(90° behind Hp)"]
B --> C["Eddy currents (L-R circuit)
further lag φ = arctan(ωL/R)"]
C --> D["Secondary field Hs"]
A --> E["Receiver: Hp + Hs"]
D --> EThe circuit model and the response parameter
Treat a compact conductor as a loop of inductance \( L \) and resistance \( R \), coupled to the transmitter and receiver by mutual inductances. The emf induced in it lags the primary field by \( 90° \); the current lags that emf by \( \varphi = \tan^{-1}(\omega L/R) \). The secondary field at the receiver, as a fraction of the primary, is proportional to the response function
$$\boxed{G(\alpha) = \frac{\alpha^2 + i\alpha}{1 + \alpha^2}}, \qquad \boxed{\alpha = \frac{\omega L}{R}}\ \ (\text{response parameter or induction number}).$$| Part | Formula | Name |
|---|---|---|
| Real | \( \alpha^2/(1 + \alpha^2) \) | in-phase (real) component, opposed to the primary |
| Imaginary | \( \alpha/(1 + \alpha^2) \) | quadrature (out-of-phase, imaginary) component |
| Ratio | quadrature / in-phase \( = 1/\alpha \) | the basic conductor-quality indicator |
| Phase lag of secondary | \( 90° + \tan^{-1}\alpha \) | between \( 90° \) (poor conductor) and \( 180° \) (perfect conductor) |
- Poor conductor (\( \alpha \ll 1 \)): small response, mostly quadrature.
- Good conductor (\( \alpha \gg 1 \)): response saturates near its maximum, almost all in-phase; quadrature becomes small again.
- Quadrature peaks at \( \alpha = 1 \) with value 0.5.
For a thin sheet (the usual model for a steep tabular orebody), the response is controlled by its conductivity–thickness product \( \sigma t \) (conductance, in siemens), the frequency and the coil spacing together. Measuring at several frequencies, or measuring both components, lets you estimate \( \sigma t \) by comparing with model phasor diagrams.
Skin depth
A plane EM field entering a uniform conductor decays as \( e^{-z/\delta} \), with
$$\boxed{\delta = \sqrt{\frac{2}{\mu_0\sigma\omega}} \approx 503\sqrt{\frac{\rho}{f}}\ \text{m}}\qquad(\rho\ \text{in}\ \Omega\,\text{m},\ f\ \text{in Hz}).$$The phase also lags by one radian per skin depth. High frequency and low resistivity mean shallow penetration.
| \( \rho \) (\( \Omega\,\text{m} \)) | \( f \) | \( \delta \) |
|---|---|---|
| 100 | 1 kHz | 159 m |
| 100 | 10 kHz | 50 m |
| 100 | 20 kHz (VLF) | 36 m |
| 1,000 | 20 kHz (VLF) | 113 m |
Skin depth is an upper reference, not the depth of exploration. For loop systems the coil separation and geometry usually limit the useful depth to a fraction of the coil spacing or of \( \delta \), whichever is smaller.
Ground conductivity meters: the low induction number
For two coplanar coils of separation \( s \) over a uniform half-space, define the induction number \( B = s/\delta \). When \( B \ll 1 \) (low induction number), the quadrature part of the secondary-to-primary ratio is directly proportional to conductivity:
$$\boxed{\sigma_a = \frac{4}{\omega\mu_0 s^2}\left(\frac{H_s}{H_p}\right)_{\text{quad}}}$$The instrument reads apparent conductivity directly (in mS/m), with no electrodes. Example: \( s = 10 \) m, \( f = 10 \) kHz, quadrature ratio 0.005: \( \omega\mu_0 s^2 = 7.90 \), so \( \sigma_a = 0.02/7.90 = 2.53 \) mS/m (\( \rho_a \approx 395\ \Omega\,\text{m} \)). Check: \( \delta \approx 100 \) m \( \gg s \), so the condition holds. Changing coil orientation (vertical or horizontal dipoles) and separation changes the depth sampled. These meters are widely used for soil salinity, contaminant plumes and shallow mapping.
Loop Methods (Frequency Domain)
Moving-source systems: Slingram / horizontal-loop EM (HLEM)
Two horizontal coplanar coils, a fixed distance apart (often tens to a couple of hundred metres), joined by a reference cable, are moved together along a line. The receiver reports the in-phase and quadrature parts of the secondary field as percentages of the primary, with the primary itself cancelled using the known separation.
Profile over a thin vertical conductor (plotted at the midpoint):
- The response is zero when either coil is directly over the conductor (the coil’s field there is parallel to the sheet and induces no current that couples).
- Between those two positions, i.e. for a profile width equal to the coil separation, there is a negative anomaly centred over the conductor.
- Outside it, small positive shoulders.
- Dipping conductors make the profile asymmetric; the shoulder sizes are used to estimate dip, and the anomaly amplitude to estimate depth and \( \sigma t \).
Fixed-source systems
- Turam. A large fixed loop or long grounded cable carries the current; two receiver coils a fixed distance apart are moved across the area, measuring the ratio of field strengths and the phase difference between them. With no moving transmitter, it reaches deeper conductors and suits rugged terrain.
- Large fixed-loop systems in general give strong coupling to flat-lying and deep targets.
Tilt-angle (dip-angle) methods
A vertical transmitting coil is set up; the receiving coil is rotated to find the direction of the resultant field (the minimum signal, or null, gives the tilt of the major axis of the polarisation ellipse). Over a conductor the tilt changes sign: the crossover marks the conductor. Variants differ in how the transmitter and receiver are laid out and moved (fixed-transmitter, broadside and shoot-back layouts). Tilt-angle methods give location and rough depth but little about conductivity, unless an ellipticity is also measured.
Airborne EM
Helicopter systems tow a “bird” with coils at several frequencies (frequency-domain HEM) or a large loop (time-domain); fixed-wing systems carry a transmitter loop around the aircraft and tow the receiver. They give in-phase and quadrature (or decay) data along closely spaced lines, used for conductor detection, mapping of conductivity-depth sections and groundwater work. The principles are those of the ground methods; the extra difficulty is the variable height and geometry of the sensors.
VLF: Very-Low-Frequency EM
The VLF band is 3–30 kHz. Navies operate powerful VLF transmitters for communication with submarines, and their signals, roughly in the 15–30 kHz range, are used as free sources for geophysics.
Source geometry. At a site far from the transmitter, the field is a plane wave: a horizontal magnetic field perpendicular to the direction of the transmitter and a vertical electric field (plus a small horizontal electric field in the ground). The horizontal magnetic field induces currents in conductors that run toward the transmitter.
What is measured. Over a conductor the secondary field adds a vertical component, so the total field becomes elliptically polarised. VLF instruments measure:
- the tilt angle of the major axis of the ellipse (in-phase component, roughly the real part of \( H_z/H_x \)), and
- the ellipticity (ratio of minor to major axis, roughly the quadrature part of \( H_z/H_x \)).
Over a conductor the tilt angle passes through zero: a crossover, positive on one side, negative on the other.
The Fraser filter
Crossovers are hard to contour. Fraser’s filter converts them into peaks:
$$\boxed{F_{2,3} = (M_3 + M_4) - (M_1 + M_2)}$$for four consecutive readings \( M_1 \) to \( M_4 \) at equal spacing, plotted midway between \( M_2 \) and \( M_3 \). It is a first difference (turns a crossover into a peak) combined with a running average (suppresses noise), and it removes any constant bias. Whether a conductor appears as a positive or a negative extreme depends on the sign convention for tilt and the direction of travel along the line; processing usually fixes the convention so that conductors plot as positive peaks. Either way, the largest magnitude marks the crossover.
A related linear filter (the Karous–Hjelt filter) turns VLF profiles into pseudosections of equivalent current density at increasing depths.
VLF-R (resistivity mode)
Measuring the horizontal electric field \( E \) with two electrodes along with the horizontal magnetic field \( H \) gives a single-frequency magnetotelluric measurement:
$$\rho_a = \frac{1}{\omega\mu_0}\left\lvert\frac{E}{H}\right\rvert^2, \qquad \text{phase of } E/H\ (45°\ \text{over a uniform half-space}).$$This is exactly the MT formula of the next page at one frequency, and penetration is limited by the VLF skin depth (36 m in 100 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) ground at 20 kHz).
| VLF strengths | VLF limitations |
|---|---|
| no transmitter needed; light, fast, cheap | shallow (tens of metres in conductive ground) |
| good for steep conductors: fractures, shear zones, faults with water, graphitic zones | only conductors striking toward a usable station couple well |
| useful for groundwater in hard rock | sensitive to conductive overburden, topography and cultural conductors (fences, pipes, power lines) |
AFMAG: Audio-Frequency Magnetics
AFMAG uses a natural source: the electromagnetic energy of lightning discharges in thunderstorms around the world (sferics), which travels in the Earth–ionosphere waveguide. In the audio-frequency range used, the natural field is mainly horizontal over uniform ground, but its direction varies randomly with time as different storms dominate.
- Measurement: two orthogonal coils determine the azimuth and tilt (dip) of the plane of the natural field’s polarisation; over uniform ground the field is nearly horizontal, while over a conductor the field tilts and the tilt reverses sign across it, as in other tilt-angle methods.
- Advantages: no transmitter, low frequencies (so deeper penetration than VLF or high-frequency loops), and it works in any strike direction because the source azimuth varies.
- Limitations: the signal strength is variable and intermittent (it depends on storm activity, season and time of day), measurements need averaging, and interpretation is mostly qualitative.
- Legacy: the idea of measuring the tipper (vertical-to-horizontal magnetic field ratio) from natural fields has been revived in modern airborne natural-field systems, and it is the same transfer function used in geomagnetic depth sounding.
TEM: Transient (Time-Domain) EM
How TEM works
A steady current flows in a transmitter loop; it is switched off abruptly (in microseconds to milliseconds). By Faraday’s law the collapse of the primary field induces eddy currents in the ground that try to maintain the field. These currents start near the surface just below the loop and then diffuse downward and outward while decaying, like a smoke ring blown from the loop. A receiver coil measures the decaying secondary field (usually \( \partial B/\partial t \)) at a series of delay times (time gates) after switch-off.
graph TD
A["Current on in Tx loop
steady primary field"] --> B["Abrupt switch-off"]
B --> C["Eddy currents at surface
(image of the loop)"]
C --> D["Currents diffuse down and out,
decaying: 'smoke ring'"]
D --> E["Receiver samples dB/dt
at early to late gates"]
E --> F["Early time: shallow
Late time: deep"]The key advantage: measurements are made when the primary field is off, so the receiver sees only the secondary field. The tiny-signal-on-huge-primary problem of frequency-domain loops disappears, and coil geometry need not be known so precisely.
Diffusion depth
The depth to which the currents have diffused after time \( t \) scales as
$$\boxed{d \approx \sqrt{\frac{2t}{\mu_0\sigma}} \approx 1262\sqrt{\rho\,t}\ \text{m}}\qquad(\rho\ \text{in}\ \Omega\,\text{m},\ t\ \text{in s}).$$This is the time-domain counterpart of the skin depth. In 50 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) ground: 282 m at 1 ms, 892 m at 10 ms. Later gates see deeper; a TEM decay is therefore a depth sounding.
Decay laws
| Model | Late-time decay of \( \partial B/\partial t \) | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Uniform half-space (central loop) | power law, \( \propto \sigma^{3/2}t^{-5/2} \) | a straight line of slope \( -5/2 \) on log–log axes; gives late-time apparent resistivity |
| Layered ground | departs from the \( t^{-5/2} \) line | conductive layer: slower decay at the gates that “see” it; resistive basement: faster decay |
| Confined conductor (sphere, plate) | exponential, \( e^{-t/\tau} \) | a straight line on a semi-log plot; \( \tau \) measures conductor quality |
For a conducting sphere of radius \( a \), the late-time time constant is
$$\tau = \frac{\mu_0\sigma a^2}{\pi^2},$$so good, large conductors decay slowly. Better conductors have longer time constants and stand out at late times, while weak conductors and conductive overburden are gone by then.
Configurations and uses
| Configuration | Layout | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Central (in-loop) | receiver at the centre of a square loop | layered-earth soundings: groundwater, salinity, basin depth |
| Coincident loop | one loop transmits and receives (or two loops on top of each other) | strong coupling, simple; mineral exploration |
| Fixed loop, moving receiver | large loop, receiver read along lines inside and outside it | deep conductors, plate modelling |
| Airborne (helicopter or fixed-wing) | towed loop or bird | regional conductor mapping and conductivity-depth imaging |
Limitations: very early times are distorted by the switch-off ramp and the system response, so very shallow layers are poorly resolved; late times are limited by noise, because the signal falls steeply.
Comparing the EM Methods
| Method | Source | Frequency / time | Measures | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HLEM (Slingram) | portable coil | hundreds of Hz to tens of kHz | in-phase, quadrature (% of primary) | conductor quality; depth and dip | needs exact geometry; shallow-moderate |
| Turam | fixed large loop or cable | low audio | field ratio, phase difference | deep, rugged terrain | heavy layout |
| Tilt-angle | vertical loop | audio | tilt of resultant field | quick location | little on conductivity |
| Ground conductivity meter | small coil pair | kHz, LIN | apparent conductivity | fast mapping | shallow |
| VLF | distant naval transmitter | 15–30 kHz | tilt, ellipticity (and \( \rho_a \)) | cheap, fast | shallow; strike-dependent |
| AFMAG | natural sferics | audio | azimuth and tilt of natural field | deeper; no transmitter | intermittent source |
| TEM | switched-off loop | µs to tens of ms | decay of \( \partial B/\partial t \) | depth sounding; primary off | early-time and noise limits |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| In-phase vs quadrature | in step with the primary (opposed); dominates for good conductors | 90° out of step; dominates for poor conductors |
| Skin depth vs depth of investigation | \( 503\sqrt{\rho/f} \): where the field is \( 1/e \) | practical depth, usually smaller, set also by geometry and noise |
| Frequency-domain vs time-domain EM | measures with primary on; separates components by phase | measures with primary off; separates by delay time |
| VLF vs AFMAG | man-made distant transmitter, fixed direction, ~15–30 kHz | natural lightning source, random direction, audio band |
| Exponential vs power-law decay | confined conductor (\( \tau \)) | half-space or layered ground (\( t^{-5/2} \) for half-space) |
| Tilt angle vs ellipticity (VLF) | in-phase information | quadrature information |
| HLEM vs Turam | moving source with receiver | fixed source, moving receivers |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- What natural phenomenon supplies the AFMAG signal?
- In TEM, is the secondary field measured with the transmitter current on or off?
- What is the skin depth in 100 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) ground at 10 kHz?
Answers
- Lightning (thunderstorm) discharges worldwide, whose signals (sferics) travel in the Earth–ionosphere waveguide.
- Off. That is the defining feature of time-domain EM.
- \( 503\sqrt{100/10^4} \approx 50 \) m.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A VLF survey in 1,000 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) granite uses a 20 kHz transmitter. The skin depth is closest to:
(a) 36 m (b) 113 m (c) 280 m (d) 503 m
Answer: (b) 113 m
\( \delta = 503\sqrt{1000/20000} = 503\times0.224 \approx 113 \) m. (a) is the value for 100 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \). (c) uses \( f \) in place of \( \omega \) in \( \sqrt{2/\mu_0\sigma\omega} \) (\( 113\times\sqrt{2\pi} \approx 282 \)). (d) drops \( \sqrt{\rho/f} \).
Practice Q2. A conductor has \( L/R = 0.1 \) ms. At 1 kHz the ratio of quadrature to in-phase response and the phase lag of its secondary field behind the primary are:
(a) 0.16 and 171° (b) 1.59 and 122° (c) 0.63 and 148° (d) 1.59 and 32°
Answer: (b)
\( \alpha = 2\pi\times10^3\times10^{-4} = 0.628 \). Q/I \( = 1/\alpha = 1.59 \). Lag \( = 90° + \tan^{-1}0.628 = 90° + 32.1° = 122.1° \). (a) is for \( L/R = 1 \) ms. (c) quotes \( \alpha \) as the ratio. (d) forgets the 90° lag of the induced emf.
Practice Q3. Four consecutive VLF tilt angles at 20 m spacing are +10°, +14°, +6°, −8°. The Fraser-filtered value, and where it is plotted, are:
(a) −26, between the 2nd and 3rd stations (b) +26, at the 2nd station (c) −2, between the 3rd and 4th stations (d) −26, at the 4th station
Answer: (a)
\( F = (M_3 + M_4) - (M_1 + M_2) = (6 - 8) - (10 + 14) = -26 \), plotted midway between \( M_2 \) and \( M_3 \). (b) reverses the subtraction and misplaces the point. (c) is \( M_3 + M_4 \) alone, without subtracting the first pair. (d) has the right value at the wrong place: the filter output belongs to the centre of the four-point window.
Practice Q4. A central-loop TEM sounding over a uniform half-space reads \( \partial B/\partial t = V_1 \) at 1 ms. At 4 ms the reading is expected to be:
(a) \( V_1/4 \) (b) \( V_1/8 \) (c) \( V_1/16 \) (d) \( V_1/32 \)
Answer: (d) V₁/32
Late-time half-space decay is \( \propto t^{-5/2} \): \( 4^{5/2} = 32 \). (a) assumes \( t^{-1} \); (b) \( t^{-3/2} \); (c) \( t^{-2} \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A ground conductivity meter with horizontal coplanar coils 10 m apart operates at 10 kHz and reads a quadrature secondary-to-primary ratio of 0.5%. Which statements are correct?
- The apparent conductivity is about 2.5 mS/m.
- The apparent resistivity is about 395 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \).
- The low-induction-number condition is satisfied.
- Doubling the coil spacing at the same ground conductivity would double the quadrature reading.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) all four
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
\( \sigma_a = 4(0.005)/(\omega\mu_0 s^2) \), with \( \omega\mu_0 s^2 = 2\pi\times10^4\times4\pi\times10^{-7}\times100 = 7.90 \). So \( \sigma_a = 0.02/7.90 = 2.53\times10^{-3} \) S/m.
- True. 2.53 mS/m.
- True. \( 1/0.00253 \approx 395\ \Omega\,\text{m} \).
- True. \( \delta = 503\sqrt{395/10^4} \approx 100 \) m, ten times the coil spacing.
- False. The quadrature ratio is \( \propto s^2 \) at fixed \( \sigma \): doubling \( s \) multiplies it by four (and samples deeper).
Practice Q6. A TEM survey over 50 \( \Omega\,\text{m} \) ground records gates from 0.1 ms to 10 ms. At one station the late gates fall on a straight line on a semi-log (log amplitude vs linear time) plot, reading 200 \( \mu\text{V} \) at 2 ms and 50 \( \mu\text{V} \) at 6 ms. Which statements are correct?
- The late-time behaviour indicates a confined conductor, not a uniform half-space.
- The time constant is about 2.9 ms.
- The current system in the host rock has diffused to roughly 890 m by 10 ms.
- A longer time constant would indicate a poorer conductor.
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) all four
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- True. Exponential decay (straight on semi-log) is the signature of a confined conductor; a half-space gives a \( t^{-5/2} \) power law (straight on log–log).
- True. \( \tau = 4/\ln 4 \approx 2.89 \) ms.
- True. \( d \approx 1262\sqrt{50\times0.01} \approx 892 \) m.
- False. \( \tau = \mu_0\sigma a^2/\pi^2 \) for a sphere: longer \( \tau \) means a better (or larger) conductor.
Practice Q7. A survey is planned to locate a steeply dipping, water-filled shear zone striking north–south in hard rock, at 10–30 m depth. A usable VLF station lies due east. Which plan is best?
(a) VLF with the eastern station, lines run north–south (b) VLF with the eastern station, lines run east–west (c) Find a station to the north or south and run VLF lines east–west, with a resistivity profile to confirm (d) TEM central-loop soundings only, at 500 m spacing
Answer: (c)
VLF couples best with conductors whose strike points toward the transmitter. The eastern station’s magnetic field is north–south, inducing current east–west, across the zone: poor coupling, so (a) and (b) are weak (and (a) also runs lines along strike, which can miss the zone). A station to the north or south induces current along the north–south zone; lines should cross strike (east–west). A resistivity or EM profile confirms. (d) is a 1-D sounding method at a spacing far too coarse for a narrow steep target.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Response function | \( (\alpha^2 + i\alpha)/(1 + \alpha^2) \), \( \alpha = \omega L/R \) |
| Q/I ratio | \( 1/\alpha \); quadrature max 0.5 at \( \alpha = 1 \) |
| Secondary phase lag | \( 90° + \tan^{-1}\alpha \) (90° to 180°) |
| Skin depth | \( \sqrt{2/\mu_0\sigma\omega} \approx 503\sqrt{\rho/f} \) m |
| LIN conductivity | \( \sigma_a = 4(H_s/H_p)_{quad}/(\omega\mu_0 s^2) \), valid for \( s \ll \delta \) |
| HLEM over thin vertical sheet | zero when either coil over sheet; negative anomaly of width = coil spacing |
| Primary vs spacing | \( H_p \propto 1/s^3 \): spacing errors amplified three times |
| VLF | 15–30 kHz naval transmitters; \( H \) perpendicular to station direction; couples with strike toward station |
| VLF outputs | tilt (in-phase), ellipticity (quadrature); crossover over conductor |
| Fraser filter | \( (M_3 + M_4) - (M_1 + M_2) \), plotted between \( M_2 \) and \( M_3 \) |
| VLF-R | \( \rho_a = \lvert E/H\rvert^2/\omega\mu_0 \) |
| AFMAG | natural sferics, audio band, azimuth and tilt of natural field |
| TEM depth | \( \sqrt{2t/\mu_0\sigma} \approx 1262\sqrt{\rho t} \) m |
| TEM decay | half-space \( t^{-5/2} \); confined conductor \( e^{-t/\tau} \) |
| Sphere time constant | \( \tau = \mu_0\sigma a^2/\pi^2 \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Magnetotellurics and Geomagnetic Depth Sounding: the same physics with natural sources at much lower frequencies, reaching the mantle.
- Maxwell’s Equations, Potentials and Gauge Invariance: the diffusion equation behind skin depth and TEM.
- Electrical and Electromagnetic Methods: back to the chapter overview.