Renewable and Non-Renewable Resources
CSIR NET Physical Geography: resource classes, sustainable yield and MSY, McKelvey box, reserve lifetimes, Hubbert peak, Hotelling rule, conservation.
- 17 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Fifty Years of Oil, for Fifty Years
- What Is a Resource?
- Classifying Resources
- Using Renewable Resources: Sustainable Yield
- Using Non-Renewable Resources: How Long Will They Last?
- Resources and India: The Geographic Picture
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Carrying capacity and logistic growth from Man–Land Relationship.
- Ore, grade and the resource–reserve distinction from Mineral Resource Exploitation and Conservation.
- Fossil fuels and renewable energy from Energy Resources and the Environmental Impact of Energy and Land Use.
- Exponential growth and logarithms from Speed, Time, Work and Growth.
The Hook: Fifty Years of Oil, for Fifty Years
What Is a Resource?
Erich Zimmermann, in World Resources and Industries (1933), argued that “resources are not, they become.” A substance is only neutral stuff until human wants, knowledge and technology give it a use. This is the functional theory of resources.
- Bauxite was not a resource before an economic method of smelting aluminium existed.
- Uranium became an energy resource only with nuclear fission.
- A resource can also stop being one: a mineral replaced by a cheaper substitute, or a fishing ground polluted beyond use.
So a resource depends on three things together: nature (the material exists), people (a want for it) and technology and economics (a feasible way to use it). This is the possibilist view of the Man–Land Relationship applied to materials.
Classifying Resources
| Basis | Classes | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | biotic; abiotic | forests, fish, livestock; minerals, water, land |
| Exhaustibility | renewable; non-renewable | solar, forests, groundwater; coal, petroleum, metal ores |
| Ownership | individual; community; national; international | farmland; village grazing commons; minerals under the state; the high seas |
| Status of development | potential; developed (actual); stock; reserve | see below |
| Distribution | ubiquitous; localised | air, sunlight; ores, petroleum |
Development status (the scheme used in Indian school geography):
- Potential resources: found in a region but not yet used (for example wind or solar potential in an area with no installations).
- Developed (actual) resources: surveyed, quantity and quality known, and being used.
- Stock: materials that could meet human needs but for which suitable technology is lacking (hydrogen in water as a large-scale fuel is the textbook example).
- Reserves: a subset of stock that can be used with existing technology but has not yet been used (water in a dam reservoir kept for future supply).
Renewable resources
Renewable resources are replenished by natural processes on a human time scale. Two kinds behave very differently:
| Kind | Also called | Renewal | Can it be exhausted? | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flow (perpetual) | non-critical | continuous, independent of use | no, though it can be wasted if not captured | solar radiation, wind, tides, river flow at a point |
| Stock-renewable | critical-zone, conditionally renewable | depends on the stock remaining | yes, if use exceeds regeneration | forests, fish, soils, groundwater, wildlife |
Soil is the key geographical case: it is renewable in principle, but forms so slowly that soil lost by erosion is, on human time scales, effectively non-renewable.
Non-renewable resources
Non-renewable resources form over geological time and are used much faster than they form.
- Consumed in use: fossil fuels; the energy cannot be recovered.
- Recyclable: most metals; the atoms remain and can be recovered from scrap.
- Even nuclear fuel is non-renewable: uranium and thorium are finite (though breeding can stretch them).
graph TD
R[Natural resources] --> RE[Renewable]
R --> NR[Non-renewable]
RE --> F[Flow: solar, wind, tides]
RE --> S[Stock-renewable: forest, fish, soil, groundwater]
NR --> C[Consumed: coal, oil, gas]
NR --> RC[Recyclable: metals]
S -->|use above regeneration| D[Depletion]
C -->|use above discovery| DUsing Renewable Resources: Sustainable Yield
The rule for a stock-renewable resource is simple to state: harvest no more than the regeneration rate. The sustainable yield is the harvest that can be taken year after year without reducing the stock.
Surplus production and maximum sustainable yield
If a stock (fish, timber, a herd) grows logistically, its annual surplus production is
$$G(N) = rN\left(1 - \frac{N}{K}\right)$$A harvest \( H = G(N) \) keeps the stock steady at \( N \). The largest such harvest is the maximum sustainable yield:
$$\boxed{\text{MSY} = \frac{rK}{4} \quad \text{at} \quad N = \frac{K}{2}}$$For a constant harvest \( H < \text{MSY} \), there are two equilibrium stocks:
$$N^{*} = \frac{K}{2}\left(1 \pm \sqrt{1 - \frac{4H}{rK}}\right)$$The upper one is stable (a small fall in stock raises growth above the harvest and the stock recovers); the lower one is unstable (a small fall pushes the stock to collapse). If \( H > \text{MSY} \), there is no equilibrium and the stock collapses.
MSY is a guide, not a safe target: \( r \) and \( K \) are uncertain, vary with climate, and a stock fished at \( K/2 \) has little buffer. Managers therefore aim below MSY.
Other sustainable-yield rules
| Resource | Rule |
|---|---|
| Forest | annual cut ≤ annual increment (volume growth); a forest of 10,000 ha growing 4 m\(^3\) ha\(^{-1}\) yr\(^{-1}\) supports about 40,000 m\(^3\) yr\(^{-1}\) |
| Groundwater | long-term abstraction ≤ recharge (the “safe yield”); see Hydrological Cycle, Water Resources and Management |
| Soil | erosion ≤ the rate of soil formation |
| Pollution sinks | emissions ≤ assimilative capacity of air, water and soil |
These are often summarised as Daly’s rules for sustainability: harvest renewables no faster than they regenerate, emit wastes no faster than they can be assimilated, and deplete non-renewables no faster than renewable substitutes are developed.
The tragedy of the commons
Garrett Hardin (Science, 1968) argued that when a resource is open to all, each user gains the full benefit of extra use but bears only a share of the damage, so the commons is overused. His example was a pasture shared by herders.
Elinor Ostrom (Governing the Commons, 1990; Nobel economics prize 2009) showed that many communities manage commons sustainably through local rules, monitoring and sanctions. Hardin’s tragedy applies to open-access resources more than to community-managed ones. India’s Joint Forest Management (from 1990) and village water-user groups are attempts at such management.
Using Non-Renewable Resources: How Long Will They Last?
Resource versus reserve: the McKelvey box
The McKelvey diagram (V. E. McKelvey, US Geological Survey) classifies a deposit on two axes:
| Identified (demonstrated: measured and indicated; inferred) | Undiscovered (hypothetical, speculative) | |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Reserves | undiscovered resources (not classed by economics until found) |
| Marginally economic | marginal reserves | (as above) |
| Subeconomic | subeconomic resources | (as above) |
- Horizontal axis: increasing geological certainty (from speculative to measured).
- Vertical axis: increasing economic feasibility.
- Reserves are the identified and economically extractable part: the top-left box. Resources are the whole box.
Reserves are therefore dynamic: a rise in price or a better extraction method moves material up into the reserve box; exploration moves it left. The ultimately recoverable resource (URR) is the total that will ever be produced.
Static and exponential lifetimes
Static reserve life (R/P ratio):
$$\boxed{T_s = \frac{R}{C}}$$with \( R \) the reserve and \( C \) the present annual consumption.
If consumption grows exponentially at rate \( r \) (per year, as a fraction), cumulative use after \( T \) years is \( C(e^{rT} - 1)/r \). Setting this equal to \( R \):
$$\boxed{T_e = \frac{1}{r}\ln\left(1 + \frac{rR}{C}\right)}$$This is the exponential reserve index used in The Limits to Growth.
The Hubbert curve
M. King Hubbert, a Shell geophysicist, predicted in 1956 that oil production from the US lower 48 states would peak around 1965–1970. Production did peak in 1970 (it later rose again with shale oil). His model treats cumulative production \( Q \) as logistic, approaching the URR:
$$Q(t) = \frac{\text{URR}}{1 + e^{-b(t - t_m)}} \qquad P = \frac{dQ}{dt} = bQ\left(1 - \frac{Q}{\text{URR}}\right)$$- Production traces a bell-shaped curve.
- The peak comes when half the URR has been produced, at time \( t_m \).
- Peak production: \( \boxed{P_{\max} = b\,\text{URR}/4} \).
The same form as MSY is no accident: both are the maximum of \( xN(1 - N/K) \).
Hubbert linearisation. Plotting \( P/Q \) against \( Q \) gives a straight line, \( P/Q = b - (b/\text{URR})Q \): the intercept is \( b \) and the \( Q \)-intercept is the URR. This is a quick way to estimate URR from production data.
Economics of depletion
- Hotelling rule (Harold Hotelling, 1931): in a competitive market, the net price (scarcity rent: price minus extraction cost) of an exhaustible resource rises at the rate of interest. Owners are then indifferent between extracting now and later. A rent of 20 units rising at 5% a year reaches \( 20 \times 1.05^{10} = 32.6 \) units after 10 years.
- Hartwick rule (1977): consumption can be kept constant if the rents from exhaustible resources are invested in reproducible capital. This is the weak-sustainability rule.
- Energy return on investment (EROI) = energy delivered / energy used to obtain it. The net-energy fraction is \( 1 - 1/\text{EROI} \): at EROI 10 it is 90%, at EROI 2 only 50%. Depleting high-grade deposits lowers EROI before the resource “runs out”.
Stretching non-renewables
| Strategy | Effect |
|---|---|
| Exploration and better technology | moves material into reserves |
| Efficiency | lowers \( C \) for the same service |
| Substitution | replaces a scarce material (optical fibre for copper in communications) |
| Recycling | if a fraction \( \rho \) of demand is met from scrap, primary demand falls to \( C(1 - \rho) \); 40% recycling stretches a 30-year static life to 50 years |
| Circular economy | design for reuse, repair and recovery (reduce, reuse, recycle) |
Resources and India: The Geographic Picture
| Resource | Geographic pattern |
|---|---|
| Coal | mostly Gondwana basins of the Damodar, Son, Mahanadi and Godavari valleys; Tertiary coal in the North-East; lignite at Neyveli |
| Iron ore | Odisha, Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Karnataka, Goa |
| Bauxite | east-coast Khondalite belt (Odisha, Andhra Pradesh), laterite plateaus |
| Thorium | monazite in beach sands of Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Odisha |
| Forests | goal of one-third of land area under forest or tree cover (National Forest Policy, 1988) |
| Solar and wind | high solar potential in Rajasthan and Gujarat; wind along the Gujarat and Tamil Nadu coasts and plateau edges |
Details of the deposits are in Mineral Concentration Processes and Rocks and Minerals of India; soils, water and other resources region by region are in Drainage, Soils and Natural Resources of India, and forest policy and protected areas in Forest Conservation, Sanctuaries and Parks.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | Difference |
|---|---|
| Resource vs reserve (McKelvey) | all that exists (known or not, paying or not) vs identified and economic |
| Stock vs reserve (school scheme) | usable only with future technology vs usable now but held back |
| Flow vs stock-renewable | renewal independent of use vs renewal depends on remaining stock |
| Renewable vs sustainable | can regenerate vs actually used no faster than it regenerates |
| Static vs exponential lifetime | \( R/C \) vs \( \ln(1 + rR/C)/r \) |
| MSY stock vs carrying capacity | \( K/2 \) vs \( K \) |
| Open access vs common property | no rules (tragedy likely) vs community rules (Ostrom) |
| Hotelling vs Hartwick | price path of a depleting resource vs reinvesting its rents |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote that “resources are not, they become”?
- In the McKelvey diagram, what do the two axes represent?
- For a logistic stock, at what population size is the maximum sustainable yield obtained?
Answers
- Erich Zimmermann (World Resources and Industries, 1933).
- Geological certainty (horizontal) and economic feasibility (vertical).
- At \( K/2 \), giving MSY \( = rK/4 \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. Which of the following is a stock-renewable (critical-zone) resource rather than a flow resource?
(a) Solar radiation (b) Tidal energy (c) Groundwater in an alluvial aquifer (d) Wind
Answer and explanation
(c). Groundwater regenerates by recharge, but abstraction above recharge depletes it. Solar, tidal and wind energy are flows whose supply does not depend on how much we used last year.
Practice Q2. A country has 4.5 billion tonnes of a mineral in reserves and produces 90 million tonnes a year. Its static reserve life is:
(a) 5 years (b) 20 years (c) 50 years (d) 500 years
Answer and explanation
(c). \( 4.5\times 10^9 / 9\times 10^7 = 50 \) years. (d) mixes up the powers of ten.
Practice Q3. According to the Hotelling rule, the net price of an exhaustible resource in a competitive market:
(a) stays constant until the resource is exhausted (b) rises at the rate of interest (c) falls as extraction technology improves (d) rises at the rate of growth of demand
Answer and explanation
(b). The scarcity rent must rise at the interest rate so that owners are indifferent between extracting now and later. Real price paths also reflect costs, discoveries and technology, which is why observed prices often do not follow the rule.
Practice Q4. A fish stock follows logistic growth with \( K = 80{,}000 \) t and \( r = 0.5 \) yr\(^{-1}\). Its maximum sustainable yield is:
(a) 10,000 t yr\(^{-1}\) (b) 20,000 t yr\(^{-1}\) (c) 40,000 t yr\(^{-1}\) (d) 80,000 t yr\(^{-1}\)
Answer and explanation
(a). \( rK/4 = 0.5\times 80{,}000/4 = 10{,}000 \) t yr\(^{-1}\). (b) is \( rK/2 \); (c) is the stock at MSY, not the yield.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. For an oil province, the ratio of annual production \( P \) to cumulative production \( Q \) is 0.048 yr\(^{-1}\) when \( Q = 40 \) billion barrels (Gb) and 0.036 yr\(^{-1}\) when \( Q = 80 \) Gb. Assuming Hubbert (logistic) behaviour, which set is correct?
(a) URR = 200 Gb; peak production 3 Gb yr\(^{-1}\) at \( Q = 100 \) Gb; peak about 23 years after \( Q = 40 \) Gb (b) URR = 160 Gb; peak production 4 Gb yr\(^{-1}\) at \( Q = 80 \) Gb (c) URR = 200 Gb; peak production 6 Gb yr\(^{-1}\) at \( Q = 200 \) Gb (d) URR = 120 Gb; peak already passed at \( Q = 80 \) Gb
Answer and worked solution
(a).
Linearise: \( P/Q = b - (b/\text{URR})Q \). Slope \( = (0.036 - 0.048)/(80 - 40) = -0.0003 \) Gb\(^{-1}\) yr\(^{-1}\). Intercept \( b = 0.048 + 0.0003\times 40 = 0.06 \) yr\(^{-1}\).
URR \( = b/0.0003 = 200 \) Gb. Peak at \( Q = \text{URR}/2 = 100 \) Gb, with \( P_{\max} = b\,\text{URR}/4 = 3 \) Gb yr\(^{-1}\).
Timing: \( Q/\text{URR} \) goes from 0.2 to 0.5; in the logistic \( e^{-b(t - t_m)} = 4 \) at 0.2, so \( t_m - t = \ln 4/0.06 = 23.1 \) years.
Checks: at \( Q = 40 \), \( P = 1.92 \) Gb yr\(^{-1}\); at \( Q = 80 \), \( P = 2.88 \) Gb yr\(^{-1}\), still rising, so the peak has not passed. (d) is wrong; (b) and (c) misplace the peak.
Practice Q6. A metal has reserves equal to 50 years of present consumption. Demand grows at 2% a year. A planner proposes to double the reserves by exploration. Which statement is correct?
(a) Life with growth is about 35 years; after doubling it is about 55 years, so the extra 50 years of static life buys only about 20 years (b) Life with growth is 50 years; after doubling it is 100 years (c) Life with growth is about 25 years; doubling makes it 50 years (d) Growth does not affect the life of a reserve, only its price
Answer and worked solution
(a).
\( T_e = \ln(1 + 0.02\times 50)/0.02 = \ln 2/0.02 = 34.7 \) years.
Doubled: \( \ln(1 + 0.02\times 100)/0.02 = \ln 3/0.02 = 54.9 \) years: a gain of about 20 years.
(b) ignores growth; (c) halves the static life arbitrarily; (d) is false because cumulative use rises faster under growth.
Practice Q7. A fishery with \( K = 80{,}000 \) t and \( r = 0.5 \) yr\(^{-1}\) is harvested at a constant 7,500 t yr\(^{-1}\). Consider these statements:
- There are two equilibrium stock sizes, 20,000 t and 60,000 t.
- The 20,000 t equilibrium is stable.
- If a bad recruitment year pushes the stock from 60,000 t to 50,000 t, it tends to return towards 60,000 t.
- Raising the constant harvest to 11,000 t yr\(^{-1}\) gives a new, lower stable equilibrium.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 3 and 4 only (d) 2 and 4 only
Answer and worked solution
(a).
- 1 true: \( N^{*} = 40{,}000(1 \pm \sqrt{1 - 0.75}) = 20{,}000 \) or 60,000 t.
- 2 false: below 20,000 t growth is less than the catch, and above it growth exceeds the catch, so the stock moves away: unstable.
- 3 true: at 50,000 t, growth \( = 0.5\times 50{,}000\times(1 - 0.625) = 9{,}375 \) t > 7,500 t, so the stock rises.
- 4 false: 11,000 t exceeds MSY (10,000 t); there is no equilibrium and the stock collapses.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Functional theory | Zimmermann 1933: “resources are not, they become” |
| Classes | origin, exhaustibility, ownership, development status, distribution |
| Development status | potential, developed, stock, reserve |
| Renewable kinds | flow (solar, wind, tides) vs stock-renewable (forest, fish, soil, groundwater) |
| Sustainable yield | harvest ≤ regeneration; Daly’s rules |
| MSY | \( rK/4 \) at \( K/2 \); \( N^{*} = \tfrac{K}{2}(1 \pm \sqrt{1 - 4H/rK}) \), upper stable |
| Commons | Hardin 1968 (open access); Ostrom 1990 (community rules) |
| McKelvey | certainty × feasibility; reserves = identified and economic |
| Lifetimes | \( R/C \); \( \ln(1 + rR/C)/r \) |
| Hubbert | logistic \( Q \); peak at URR/2; \( P_{\max} = b\,\text{URR}/4 \); \( P/Q \) vs \( Q \) linear |
| Hotelling | net price rises at the interest rate |
| Hartwick | invest resource rents to keep consumption constant |
| EROI | net fraction \( 1 - 1/\text{EROI} \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
Using resources, settling flood plains and building industries exposes people to hazards, some natural and some of our own making.
→ Natural and Man-Made Hazards
Related: Biodiversity, Conservation and Policy · Ecological Balance and Pollution