Helmholtz Theorem and Seismic Wave Propagation
CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C: Helmholtz decomposition, Navier equation, P and S wave equations, elastic moduli, plane waves, reflection, surface waves, Q.
- 17 min
On this page · 15 sections
Prerequisites
- Seismology Basics and Earth’s Internal Structure: the Part B picture of P, S and surface waves, Snell’s law and Earth’s layers. This page derives that picture.
- Newtonian Potential, Laplace and Poisson Equations: scalar potentials and the \( 1/r \) kernel, which reappear in the Helmholtz theorem.
- Maxwell’s Equations in Geophysics: the scalar-plus-vector potential split for \( \mathbf{E} \) and \( \mathbf{B} \).
- Vector identities: \( \nabla\cdot(\nabla\times\mathbf{A}) = 0 \), \( \nabla\times\nabla f = 0 \), \( \nabla\times\nabla\times\mathbf{A} = \nabla(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{A}) - \nabla^2\mathbf{A} \).
The Hook: Why Two Body Waves?
The Helmholtz Theorem
Statement
The proof uses only \( \nabla^2\left(\frac{1}{4\pi\lvert\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'\rvert}\right) = -\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}') \), the same Green’s function as the Newtonian potential. Taking the divergence of the decomposition recovers \( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{F} \) from \( -\nabla^2\Phi \); taking the curl recovers \( \nabla\times\mathbf{F} \) (using \( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{A} = 0 \)).
| Part | Property | Source |
|---|---|---|
| \( -\nabla\Phi \) | curl-free (irrotational, longitudinal) | the divergence of \( \mathbf{F} \) |
| \( \nabla\times\mathbf{A} \) | divergence-free (solenoidal, transverse) | the curl of \( \mathbf{F} \) |
The theorem across geophysics
| Field | Divergence | Curl | Helmholtz result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gravity \( \mathbf{g} \) | \( -4\pi G\rho \) | 0 | \( \mathbf{g} = \nabla U \), \( U = G\int\rho/r\,dV \): the Newtonian potential |
| Static magnetic \( \mathbf{B} \) | 0 | \( \mu_0\mathbf{J} \) | \( \mathbf{B} = \nabla\times\mathbf{A} \), \( \mathbf{A} = \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\int\mathbf{J}/r\,dV \) (Biot–Savart) |
| Electrostatic \( \mathbf{E} \) | \( \rho_q/\varepsilon_0 \) | 0 | \( \mathbf{E} = -\nabla\phi \), Coulomb potential |
| Seismic displacement \( \mathbf{u} \) | dilatation \( \theta \) | rotation | P part plus S part (below) |
| Ocean or atmospheric velocity | horizontal divergence | vorticity | velocity potential plus stream function |
So gravity, magnetostatics and elastic waves are three applications of one theorem.
From Newton’s Law to the Wave Equations
Equation of motion and Hooke’s law
For an elastic solid of density \( \rho \), Newton’s second law per unit volume (ignoring gravity and body forces) is
$$\rho\,\frac{\partial^2 u_i}{\partial t^2} = \frac{\partial\tau_{ij}}{\partial x_j}$$For an isotropic, linearly elastic solid, Hooke’s law with the Lamé parameters \( \lambda \) and \( \mu \) (the shear modulus) is
$$\tau_{ij} = \lambda\,\theta\,\delta_{ij} + 2\mu\,e_{ij}, \qquad \theta = \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}, \qquad e_{ij} = \tfrac{1}{2}\left(\partial_i u_j + \partial_j u_i\right)$$Substituting, for a homogeneous medium:
$$\boxed{\rho\,\ddot{\mathbf{u}} = (\lambda + 2\mu)\,\nabla(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}) - \mu\,\nabla\times(\nabla\times\mathbf{u})}$$This is the Navier equation (equivalently \( \rho\ddot{\mathbf{u}} = (\lambda+\mu)\nabla(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}) + \mu\nabla^2\mathbf{u} \)).
Separating P and S
Write the displacement with Helmholtz potentials:
$$\boxed{\mathbf{u} = \nabla\phi + \nabla\times\boldsymbol{\psi}, \qquad \nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\psi} = 0}$$Then \( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} = \nabla^2\phi \) and \( \nabla\times\nabla\times\mathbf{u} = -\nabla\times\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\psi} \). The Navier equation becomes
$$\nabla\left[(\lambda+2\mu)\nabla^2\phi - \rho\ddot{\phi}\right] + \nabla\times\left[\mu\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\psi} - \rho\ddot{\boldsymbol{\psi}}\right] = 0$$which is satisfied when each bracket vanishes:
$$\boxed{\nabla^2\phi = \frac{1}{\alpha^2}\frac{\partial^2\phi}{\partial t^2}, \quad \alpha = \sqrt{\frac{\lambda+2\mu}{\rho}} = \sqrt{\frac{K + \frac{4}{3}\mu}{\rho}}}$$$$\boxed{\nabla^2\boldsymbol{\psi} = \frac{1}{\beta^2}\frac{\partial^2\boldsymbol{\psi}}{\partial t^2}, \quad \beta = \sqrt{\frac{\mu}{\rho}}}$$Equivalently, take the divergence and the curl of the Navier equation directly: the dilatation \( \theta = \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} \) travels at \( \alpha \), and the rotation \( \nabla\times\mathbf{u} \) travels at \( \beta \).
| P (primary, compressional) | S (secondary, shear) | |
|---|---|---|
| Potential | scalar \( \phi \) | vector \( \boldsymbol{\psi} \) |
| Divergence of \( \mathbf{u} \) | non-zero (volume change) | zero |
| Curl of \( \mathbf{u} \) | zero (no rotation) | non-zero |
| Particle motion | parallel to propagation | perpendicular to propagation (SV in the vertical plane, SH horizontal) |
| Speed | \( \alpha = \sqrt{(K + 4\mu/3)/\rho} \) | \( \beta = \sqrt{\mu/\rho} \) |
| In a fluid (\( \mu = 0 \)) | \( \alpha = \sqrt{K/\rho} \) | does not exist |
Consequences
- P is always faster than S. \( \alpha^2/\beta^2 = (K/\mu) + 4/3 > 4/3 \) for any material with positive bulk modulus.
- No S waves in fluids. The outer core, oceans and magma do not transmit S; this is the evidence for a liquid outer core.
- Poisson solid. With \( \lambda = \mu \) (a good first approximation for many crustal rocks), \( \alpha = \sqrt{3}\,\beta \).
- Moduli from velocities: \( \mu = \rho\beta^2 \), \( K = \rho\left(\alpha^2 - \frac{4}{3}\beta^2\right) \).
Poisson’s ratio from \( V_P/V_S \)
$$\boxed{\nu = \frac{\alpha^2 - 2\beta^2}{2\left(\alpha^2 - \beta^2\right)}}$$| \( V_P/V_S \) | \( \nu \) | Typical meaning |
|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | 0.10 | stiff, low-\( \nu \) material |
| \( \sqrt{3} \approx 1.73 \) | 0.25 | Poisson solid |
| 2.0 | 0.33 | high \( \nu \) |
| \( \to\infty \) | \( \to 0.5 \) | fluid (\( \beta = 0 \)) |
High \( V_P/V_S \) is often read as a sign of fluid or partial melt; the ratio is used in crustal and reservoir studies for that reason.
Plane and Spherical Waves
Plane waves
A harmonic plane wave has potentials \( \phi = \Phi_0\, e^{i(\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{x} - \omega t)} \) with \( \lvert\mathbf{k}\rvert = \omega/\alpha \). Then
$$\mathbf{u} = \nabla\phi = i\mathbf{k}\,\phi \quad\Rightarrow\quad \mathbf{u}\parallel\mathbf{k} \quad \text{(longitudinal)}$$For the S potential, \( \mathbf{u} = \nabla\times\boldsymbol{\psi} = i\mathbf{k}\times\boldsymbol{\psi} \), so \( \mathbf{u}\perp\mathbf{k} \) (transverse), with \( \lvert\mathbf{k}\rvert = \omega/\beta \).
Quick test of a displacement field. Compute \( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} \) and \( \nabla\times\mathbf{u} \):
| \( \mathbf{u} \) | \( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} \) | \( \nabla\times\mathbf{u} \) | Wave |
|---|---|---|---|
| \( (A\sin k(x - ct),\ 0,\ 0) \) | \( Ak\cos k(x-ct) \neq 0 \) | 0 | P travelling along \( x \) |
| \( (0,\ A\sin k(x - ct),\ 0) \) | 0 | \( (0,0,Ak\cos k(x-ct)) \neq 0 \) | S travelling along \( x \), polarised along \( y \) |
| \( (0,\ 0,\ A\sin k(x - ct)) \) | 0 | non-zero | S along \( x \), polarised along \( z \) |
With \( z \) vertical and propagation along horizontal \( x \), the \( y \)-polarised wave is SH and the \( z \)-polarised one is SV.
Spherical waves and geometrical spreading
From a point source, the P potential is \( \phi = \frac{1}{r}f\!\left(t - \frac{r}{\alpha}\right) \): the amplitude falls as \( 1/r \) because the energy spreads over a sphere of area \( 4\pi r^2 \).
| Wave | Spreads over | Amplitude falls as | Energy falls as |
|---|---|---|---|
| Body wave | sphere, \( \propto r^2 \) | \( 1/r \) | \( 1/r^2 \) |
| Surface wave | cylinder (ring), \( \propto r \) | \( 1/\sqrt{r} \) | \( 1/r \) |
That is why surface waves dominate seismograms of shallow earthquakes at large distances.
Waves at Interfaces
Snell’s law and the ray parameter
At a plane interface the horizontal slowness is conserved:
$$\boxed{p = \frac{\sin i_1}{v_1} = \frac{\sin i_2}{v_2}}$$for every reflected and transmitted wave, including converted waves (P to SV and SV to P). SH does not convert to P or SV at a horizontal interface; P–SV and SH are decoupled. When \( v_2 > v_1 \), the critical angle is \( \sin i_c = v_1/v_2 \), beyond which the head wave used in refraction surveys is generated.
Normal incidence
At normal incidence there is no mode conversion. With acoustic impedance \( Z = \rho v \), the usual reflection-seismology coefficients are for stress (pressure) amplitude:
$$\boxed{R = \frac{Z_2 - Z_1}{Z_2 + Z_1}}, \qquad T = \frac{2Z_2}{Z_1 + Z_2} \quad\text{(stress amplitudes)}$$For displacement (or particle velocity) the signs and transmission factor differ: \( R_u = (Z_1 - Z_2)/(Z_1 + Z_2) = -R \) and \( T_u = 2Z_1/(Z_1 + Z_2) \). Check which quantity a question means.
The fractions of incident energy reflected and transmitted are \( R^2 \) and \( \frac{Z_1}{Z_2}T^2 = 1 - R^2 \), the same in either convention. A negative \( R \) means the reflected stress wave has reversed polarity (going into lower impedance). The transmitted stress amplitude can exceed the incident one when \( Z_2 > Z_1 \), and the transmitted displacement amplitude can exceed the incident one when \( Z_2 < Z_1 \); energy is still conserved.
Surface Waves
A free surface (zero traction) or a layered medium allows waves trapped near the boundary.
| Rayleigh | Love | |
|---|---|---|
| Built from | interfering P and SV | trapped SH |
| Needs | a free surface (exists even on a uniform half-space) | a low-velocity layer over a faster half-space (\( \beta_1 < \beta_2 \)) |
| Particle motion | elliptical in the vertical plane; retrograde at the surface of a half-space, reversing with depth | horizontal, transverse to propagation |
| Speed | on a Poisson half-space, \( c_R = 0.919\,\beta \) | between \( \beta_1 \) and \( \beta_2 \) |
| Dispersion | none on a uniform half-space; dispersive in layered media | always dispersive |
| Recorded on | vertical and radial components | transverse component |
For a Poisson solid the Rayleigh equation gives \( c_R^2/\beta^2 = 2 - 2/\sqrt{3} \), so \( c_R = 0.9194\,\beta \). For Love waves, long wavelengths sample the faster half-space and travel near \( \beta_2 \); short wavelengths are confined to the layer and travel near \( \beta_1 \).
Phase and group velocity. In a dispersive wave train, crests move at the phase velocity \( c = \omega/k \), but energy moves at the group velocity
$$U = \frac{d\omega}{dk} = c + k\frac{dc}{dk}$$Dispersion curves of surface waves (velocity against period) are inverted for the shear-velocity structure of the crust and upper mantle: longer periods sample deeper.
Interface waves also exist at a solid–solid boundary (Stoneley waves) and at a solid–fluid boundary such as the sea floor (Scholte waves). In borehole logging, the guided “Stoneley” or tube wave travels along the wall of the fluid-filled hole.
Attenuation and Q
Real rocks lose energy to internal friction. The quality factor \( Q \) is defined by the fractional energy loss per cycle, \( \frac{2\pi}{Q} = \frac{\Delta E}{E} \). For a wave travelling for time \( t \):
$$\boxed{A = A_0\, e^{-\pi f t/Q}} = A_0\, e^{-\pi f r/(Qv)}$$- Higher frequencies are lost faster (more cycles in the same distance): the Earth is a low-pass filter, which is why distant events sound “dull” and why deep seismic reflection uses lower frequencies.
- Low Q means strong attenuation. Partially molten, hot or fluid-filled zones have low Q.
- Observed amplitude = source × geometrical spreading × intrinsic attenuation × scattering × site effects.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Irrotational part \( \nabla\phi \): P, volume change, no rotation | solenoidal part \( \nabla\times\boldsymbol{\psi} \): S, rotation, no volume change | |
| SV: polarised in the vertical plane, couples with P | SH: horizontal polarisation, decoupled, makes Love waves | |
| Rayleigh: P–SV, vertical-plane ellipse | Love: SH, horizontal transverse | |
| Phase velocity \( \omega/k \): crests | group velocity \( d\omega/dk \): energy | |
| Amplitude coefficient \( R \) (can be negative) | energy fraction \( R^2 \) | |
| Geometrical spreading (no energy lost) | intrinsic attenuation \( Q \) (energy turned into heat) | |
| Bulk modulus \( K \) (volume) | shear modulus \( \mu \) (shape); fluids have \( \mu = 0 \) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which part of the Helmholtz decomposition of seismic displacement carries the P wave?
- What is Poisson’s ratio for a Poisson solid?
- A wave goes from a layer with \( v_1 = 2000 \) m/s into one with \( v_2 = 4000 \) m/s. What is the critical angle?
Answers
- The irrotational (gradient) part \( \nabla\phi \).
- 0.25 (\( \lambda = \mu \), \( V_P/V_S = \sqrt{3} \)).
- 30°. \( \sin i_c = 2000/4000 = 0.5 \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A rock has \( \lambda = \mu = 30 \) GPa and density 2700 kg/m³. Its P-wave speed is about:
(a) 3.33 km/s (b) 4.71 km/s (c) 5.77 km/s (d) 6.67 km/s
Answer: (c) 5.77 km/s
\( \alpha = \sqrt{(30 + 60)\times 10^9/2700} = \sqrt{3.333\times 10^7} = 5774 \) m/s.
(a) is \( \beta = \sqrt{30\times 10^9/2700} = 3333 \) m/s. (b) uses \( \sqrt{(\lambda+\mu)/\rho} \).
Practice Q2. A sandstone has \( V_P/V_S = 2.0 \). Its Poisson’s ratio is:
(a) 0.25 (b) 0.30 (c) 0.33 (d) 0.40
Answer: (c) 0.33
\( \nu = \dfrac{4 - 2}{2(4 - 1)} = \dfrac{2}{6} = 0.333 \).
Practice Q3. The displacement field \( \mathbf{u} = (0,\ A\sin k(x - ct),\ 0) \), with \( z \) vertical, describes:
(a) a P wave travelling along \( y \) (b) an SH wave travelling along \( x \) (c) an SV wave travelling along \( x \) (d) a Rayleigh wave
Answer: (b)
It depends on \( x - ct \), so it travels along \( x \). \( \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} = \partial u_y/\partial y = 0 \), \( (\nabla\times\mathbf{u})_z = \partial u_y/\partial x \neq 0 \): transverse, with horizontal (\( y \)) polarisation: SH.
Practice Q4. Taking the stress-amplitude convention, a P wave travels at normal incidence from shale (2400 kg/m³, 3000 m/s) into sandstone (2200 kg/m³, 2500 m/s). The reflection coefficient is:
(a) +0.134 (b) −0.134 (c) −0.018 (d) −0.091
Answer: (b) −0.134
\( R = (5.5 - 7.2)/(5.5 + 7.2) = -0.134 \). (c) is \( -R^2 \), the energy fraction with a sign. (d) uses velocities only: \( (2500 - 3000)/(5500) \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A crustal rock has \( V_P = 6.0 \) km/s, \( V_S = 3.464 \) km/s and density 2700 kg/m³. Which statements are correct?
- Its shear modulus is about 32.4 GPa.
- Its bulk modulus is about 54 GPa.
- Its Poisson’s ratio is 0.25.
- Rayleigh waves on a half-space of this rock travel at about 3.18 km/s.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (d) all four
\( \beta^2 = (3464)^2 = 1.200\times 10^7 \) m²/s², \( \alpha^2 = 3.6\times 10^7 \) m²/s².
- \( \mu = \rho\beta^2 = 2700\times 1.2\times 10^7 = 3.24\times 10^{10} \) Pa. Correct.
- \( K = \rho(\alpha^2 - \tfrac{4}{3}\beta^2) = 2700(3.6 - 1.6)\times 10^7 = 5.4\times 10^{10} \) Pa. Correct.
- \( \alpha^2/\beta^2 = 3 \): \( \nu = (3 - 2)/(2\times 2) = 0.25 \). Correct.
- Poisson solid, so \( c_R = 0.9194\times 3.464 = 3.18 \) km/s. Correct.
Practice Q6. For the shale-to-sandstone interface of Q4 (normal incidence), which statements are correct?
- About 1.8% of the incident energy is reflected.
- The transmitted stress amplitude is about 0.87 times the incident amplitude.
- The transmitted displacement amplitude is about 1.13 times the incident amplitude, which violates energy conservation.
- The reflected stress wave has reversed polarity.
(a) 1 and 4 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 4 only
- \( R^2 = 0.134^2 = 0.018 \). Correct.
- \( T = 2Z_2/(Z_1 + Z_2) = 11.0/12.7 = 0.866 \). Correct.
- The displacement transmission factor \( T_u = 2Z_1/(Z_1 + Z_2) = 14.4/12.7 = 1.134 \) is indeed above 1, but the transmitted energy fraction \( = (Z_1/Z_2)T^2 = (7.2/5.5)(0.750) = 0.982 = 1 - R^2 \). Energy is conserved. Wrong.
- \( R < 0 \). Correct.
Practice Q7. A 10 Hz P wave travels for 2 s through rock with \( Q = 100 \). Which statements are correct?
- Intrinsic attenuation alone reduces its amplitude to about 53% of the initial value.
- A 20 Hz wave on the same path would retain about 28%.
- Between 100 km and 400 km from a shallow source, geometrical spreading reduces surface-wave amplitude by half and body-wave amplitude to a quarter.
- Raising Q to 200 would increase the loss.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- \( e^{-\pi(10)(2)/100} = e^{-0.628} = 0.534 \). Correct.
- \( e^{-\pi(20)(2)/100} = e^{-1.257} = 0.285 \). Correct.
- Distance ×4: surface waves \( 1/\sqrt{4} = 1/2 \); body waves \( 1/4 \). Correct.
- Higher Q means less attenuation. Wrong.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Formula or fact |
|---|---|
| Helmholtz | \( \mathbf{F} = -\nabla\Phi + \nabla\times\mathbf{A} \); fixed by div and curl |
| Navier | \( \rho\ddot{\mathbf{u}} = (\lambda+2\mu)\nabla(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}) - \mu\nabla\times\nabla\times\mathbf{u} \) |
| Potentials | \( \mathbf{u} = \nabla\phi + \nabla\times\boldsymbol{\psi} \), \( \nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\psi} = 0 \) |
| P speed | \( \alpha = \sqrt{(\lambda+2\mu)/\rho} = \sqrt{(K + 4\mu/3)/\rho} \) |
| S speed | \( \beta = \sqrt{\mu/\rho} \); zero in fluids |
| Poisson’s ratio | \( \nu = (\alpha^2 - 2\beta^2)/[2(\alpha^2 - \beta^2)] \); \( \sqrt{3} \to 0.25 \) |
| Snell | \( p = \sin i/v \) conserved; \( \sin i_c = v_1/v_2 \) |
| Normal incidence | \( R = (Z_2 - Z_1)/(Z_2 + Z_1) \) (stress amplitude); energy \( R^2 \) |
| Rayleigh | P–SV, retrograde at surface, \( 0.919\beta \) (Poisson half-space) |
| Love | SH, needs low-velocity layer, \( \beta_1 < c < \beta_2 \), dispersive |
| Spreading | body \( 1/r \), surface \( 1/\sqrt{r} \) |
| Attenuation | \( A = A_0 e^{-\pi f t/Q} \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Field Theory: Quick Revision: all four topics on one page.
- Back to the Field Theory overview.
- Revisit the observational side in Seismology Basics and Earth’s Internal Structure and Earthquakes: Causes, Measurement and Seismicity.
- The Earth Sciences overview lists the other geophysics units.