Skip to content

Objective Analysis, Initialization, Data Assimilation and Satellite Data

CSIR NET meteorology: Cressman and optimal interpolation, normal-mode and digital-filter initialization, 3D-Var, 4D-Var, Kalman filters and satellite data.

  • 21 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 14 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Richardson’s Real Problem
  3. The Analysis Problem
  4. Objective Analysis: From Hand Analysis to Interpolation
  5. Initialization
  6. Variational Data Assimilation
  7. Satellite Data
  8. Memory Tricks
  9. Don’t Confuse
  10. Common Mistakes
  11. Practice
  12. Quick Revision Table
  13. Key Takeaways
  14. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Richardson’s Real Problem

The Analysis Problem

An analysis is an estimate of the true state of the atmosphere on the model grid at a given time. Its ingredients:

IngredientSymbolError statistics
Background (first guess): a short forecast from the previous analysis\( \mathbf{x}_b \)covariance \( \mathbf{B} \)
Observations\( \mathbf{y} \)covariance \( \mathbf{R} \) (instrument + representativeness error)
Observation operator: maps a model state to what the instrument would see (interpolation, or a radiative-transfer model for radiances)\( H \)
Analysis\( \mathbf{x}_a \)covariance \( \mathbf{A} \)

The innovation (observation-minus-background, O − B) is \( \mathbf{y} - H(\mathbf{x}_b) \); the analysis increment is \( \mathbf{x}_a - \mathbf{x}_b \).

Representativeness error is part of \( \mathbf{R} \): a point measurement samples scales the model grid cannot represent (a station in a valley, a single cloud), so even a perfect instrument disagrees with a perfect model value.

The cycle repeats:

graph LR
    A["Background
(short forecast)"] --> B["Analysis
(background + observations)"] O["Observations
quality controlled"] --> B B --> C["Initialization
(remove imbalance)"] C --> D["Forecast model"] D -->|"6 h forecast"| A D --> E["Forecast products"]

This loop of background, analysis and forecast is data assimilation. The background carries information from all earlier observations forward in time, so data-sparse regions (oceans, the southern hemisphere) still get a reasonable analysis.

Objective Analysis: From Hand Analysis to Interpolation

Before NWP, analyses were drawn by hand. Objective analysis replaces the analyst by a reproducible algorithm. The main historical steps:

MethodIdeaWeakness
Polynomial fitting (earliest)fit a local polynomial (often a quadratic) to observations around each grid point by least squaresunstable in data-sparse areas; ignores a first guess
Successive correction (Bergthorsson–Döös, Cressman)start from a first guess; add weighted averages of the innovations within a radius of influence; repeat with smaller radiiweights are empirical; ignores observation error and data clustering
Optimal interpolation (OI), statistical interpolation (Gandin)choose weights that minimise the expected analysis error variance, from the error covariances of background and observationsneeds covariance models; local data selection; usually treats \( H \) as linear
Variational (3D-Var, 4D-Var)minimise a cost function measuring misfit to background and observationsneeds \( \mathbf{B} \) and, for 4D-Var, an adjoint model
Kalman filter and ensemble methodspropagate the error covariances with the modelvery costly in full form; ensembles approximate it

Cressman successive correction

At a grid point \( g \), with background \( x_b \) and observations \( k \) at distance \( r_k \) from \( g \):

$$x_a = x_b + \frac{\sum_k w_k\,(y_k - x_{b,k})}{\sum_k w_k}, \qquad w_k = \begin{cases} \dfrac{R^2 - r_k^2}{R^2 + r_k^2}, & r_k < R \\[4pt] 0, & r_k \ge R \end{cases}$$

where \( x_{b,k} \) is the background interpolated to observation \( k \), and \( R \) is the radius of influence. A weight of 1 applies at the grid point itself, falling to 0 at \( R \). Several passes are made with decreasing \( R \) (for example from several hundred to about a hundred kilometres), so large scales are fitted first and smaller scales later. The Barnes scheme is a variant with Gaussian weights \( w = e^{-r^2/\kappa} \).

Optimal interpolation

For one grid value, one observation at the same point, and uncorrelated errors with variances \( \sigma_b^2 \) and \( \sigma_o^2 \), minimising the expected squared analysis error gives

$$\boxed{x_a = x_b + \frac{\sigma_b^2}{\sigma_b^2 + \sigma_o^2}(y - x_b), \qquad \sigma_a^2 = \frac{\sigma_b^2\,\sigma_o^2}{\sigma_b^2 + \sigma_o^2}}$$

Equivalently \( \frac{1}{\sigma_a^2} = \frac{1}{\sigma_b^2} + \frac{1}{\sigma_o^2} \): precisions add, so the analysis is always more accurate than either source alone. The weight given to the observation rises as the background becomes less reliable.

In matrix form, for many observations and grid points,

$$\mathbf{x}_a = \mathbf{x}_b + \mathbf{K}\left[\mathbf{y} - H\mathbf{x}_b\right], \qquad \mathbf{K} = \mathbf{B}H^{\mathsf T}\left(H\mathbf{B}H^{\mathsf T} + \mathbf{R}\right)^{-1},$$

the best linear unbiased estimate (BLUE). \( \mathbf{K} \) is the gain. The background-error covariance \( \mathbf{B} \) does the essential work: it spreads the information from an observation to nearby points and to other variables (a height observation updates the wind through geostrophically balanced covariances), and it builds balance into the increments. That is why multivariate OI reduced, but did not eliminate, the need for separate initialization.

Initialization

Why it is needed

Any analysis contains small imbalances between the wind and mass fields. In a primitive-equation model they project onto inertia–gravity waves with large amplitudes and high frequencies. The symptoms are spurious oscillations of surface pressure in the first hours of the forecast, corrupted rainfall and vertical velocity during the “spin-up” period, and noisy short-range forecasts that then serve as the next background. Initialization removes the unbalanced part while keeping the slow, meteorological (Rossby) part.

Methods

MethodHow it worksNotes
Static initializationDerive the wind from the mass field with a balance relation (geostrophic wind, or the nonlinear balance equation), or the reverseSimple; geostrophy is poor in the tropics; discards observed wind information
Dynamic initializationIntegrate the model forward and backward about the initial time with a scheme that damps high frequencies (for example Matsuno, Euler-backward)Uses the model’s own dynamics; costly; also damps some meteorological signal
Linear normal-mode initializationExpand the analysis in the model’s linear normal modes (slow Rossby modes and fast gravity modes); set the gravity-mode amplitudes to zeroRemoves gravity waves at time zero, but nonlinear terms regenerate them
Nonlinear normal-mode initialization (NNMI)Set the initial tendencies of the gravity modes to zero (Machenhauer’s condition), iterativelyKeeps the gravity modes that the slow flow forces; the operational standard of the 1980s
Digital filter initialization (DFI)Integrate the model a few hours forward and backward around the initial time and apply a low-pass time filter to the sequence of statesSimple, uses the full model and physics; widely used in regional models
Implicit (in the assimilation)Balance constraints in \( \mathbf{B} \), a penalty term in the cost function (\( J_c \)), or 4D-Var fitting observations over a windowModern variational systems need little or no separate initialization

Variational Data Assimilation

3D-Var

3D-Var finds the state \( \mathbf{x} \) that minimises

$$\boxed{J(\mathbf{x}) = \tfrac{1}{2}(\mathbf{x} - \mathbf{x}_b)^{\mathsf T}\mathbf{B}^{-1}(\mathbf{x} - \mathbf{x}_b) + \tfrac{1}{2}\left[\mathbf{y} - H(\mathbf{x})\right]^{\mathsf T}\mathbf{R}^{-1}\left[\mathbf{y} - H(\mathbf{x})\right]}$$

The first term \( J_b \) penalises departure from the background, the second \( J_o \) misfit to observations, each weighted by the inverse of its error covariance. For linear \( H \) and Gaussian errors the minimum is the same as the OI / BLUE solution. The advantages of 3D-Var over OI are practical:

  • all observations are used together in one global minimisation (no local data selection);
  • nonlinear observation operators are allowed, so satellite radiances can be assimilated directly through a radiative-transfer model rather than through retrieved temperature profiles;
  • constraints (balance, smoothness) can be added as extra terms.

The minimum is found iteratively with the gradient \( \nabla J = \mathbf{B}^{-1}(\mathbf{x} - \mathbf{x}_b) - H^{\mathsf T}\mathbf{R}^{-1}[\mathbf{y} - H(\mathbf{x})] \), using conjugate-gradient or quasi-Newton methods.

4D-Var

4D-Var extends the cost function over an assimilation window (commonly 6 or 12 hours). It seeks the initial state \( \mathbf{x}_0 \) whose model trajectory best fits all observations at their correct times:

$$J(\mathbf{x}_0) = \tfrac{1}{2}(\mathbf{x}_0 - \mathbf{x}_b)^{\mathsf T}\mathbf{B}^{-1}(\mathbf{x}_0 - \mathbf{x}_b) + \tfrac{1}{2}\sum_{i=0}^{n}\left[\mathbf{y}_i - H_i(\mathbf{x}_i)\right]^{\mathsf T}\mathbf{R}_i^{-1}\left[\mathbf{y}_i - H_i(\mathbf{x}_i)\right], \quad \mathbf{x}_i = M_{0\to i}(\mathbf{x}_0).$$
  • The model \( M \) is a strong constraint: the analysis is a model solution, so it is dynamically consistent and balanced.
  • The gradient is computed with the adjoint of the (linearised) model, run backward in time over the window.
  • Observations are used at their actual times, which suits asynoptic data (satellites, aircraft).
  • The background-error covariance evolves implicitly through the window (“flow-dependent” structure functions).
  • It is expensive; operational systems use an incremental formulation with a simplified, lower-resolution linear model for the inner loops.

Kalman filters and ensembles

The Kalman filter is the sequential form of BLUE that also forecasts the error covariance:

$$\mathbf{x}_f^{\,t+1} = M\mathbf{x}_a^{\,t}, \qquad \mathbf{P}_f^{\,t+1} = \mathbf{M}\mathbf{P}_a^{\,t}\mathbf{M}^{\mathsf T} + \mathbf{Q},$$

followed by the analysis step with \( \mathbf{K} = \mathbf{P}_f H^{\mathsf T}(H\mathbf{P}_f H^{\mathsf T} + \mathbf{R})^{-1} \) and \( \mathbf{P}_a = (\mathbf{I} - \mathbf{K}H)\mathbf{P}_f \). For a model with \( 10^8 \) or more variables, \( \mathbf{P} \) cannot even be stored. The ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) estimates \( \mathbf{P}_f \) from an ensemble of forecasts, with localization (cutting off spurious long-distance correlations from a small ensemble) and inflation (counteracting the ensemble’s tendency to become over-confident). Hybrid systems blend a static \( \mathbf{B} \) with ensemble covariances in a variational analysis, and an ensemble of data assimilations also provides initial perturbations for ensemble forecasts.

Comparison

OI3D-Var4D-VarEnKF
Time dimensionsingle timesingle time (observations binned to analysis time)window; observations at their own timessequential
Background covariancestatic, modelledstaticstatic at start, evolves implicitly over windowflow-dependent, from ensemble
Nonlinear \( H \) (radiances)awkwardyesyesyes
Needs adjoint modelnonoyesno
Data selectionlocalglobalgloballocal (localization)

Quality control and bias correction

Before any analysis, observations go through:

  • gross error checks (physically impossible values), hydrostatic and consistency checks on radiosondes;
  • background check: reject observations whose O − B departure is too large relative to expected error;
  • buddy check: compare with neighbouring observations;
  • thinning of dense data (satellites) to reduce correlated errors;
  • bias correction, especially for satellite radiances, whose systematic biases (instrument calibration, radiative-transfer errors) can be larger than the signal. Modern systems estimate the bias coefficients inside the variational analysis (variational bias correction).

Satellite Data

Satellites now supply most of the observations used in global NWP, and are the only routine source over the oceans and the southern hemisphere.

Orbits

Polar-orbiting (sun-synchronous)Geostationary
Altitudelow Earth orbit, typically about 800 kmabout 35 800 km above the equator
Coveragewhole globe, each place about twice a day per satellitefixed disc, up to about 60–70° latitude; no polar view
Repeat timeabout 12 h per satellite at a placeminutes (rapid scans)
Strengthhigh-resolution sounders (IR and microwave), global coveragecontinuous imaging: cloud motion, convection, rapid change
NWP usetemperature and humidity sounding radiances, scatterometer winds, radio occultationatmospheric motion vectors, clear-sky radiances, nowcasting

What satellites measure and how it is used

ObservationPhysicsInformation
Infrared sounder radiances (hyperspectral sounders such as AIRS, IASI, CrIS; earlier HIRS)emission in the CO₂ absorption band near 15 μm (temperature) and water-vapour bandstemperature and humidity profiles, mainly in clear sky
Microwave sounder radiances (AMSU-A, ATMS; humidity: AMSU-B, MHS)emission by O₂ in the 50–60 GHz band (temperature) and H₂O near 183 GHz (humidity)temperature and humidity profiles through most clouds
Microwave imagersemission at window frequenciestotal column water vapour, cloud liquid water, rain rate, surface wind speed over sea
Atmospheric motion vectors (AMVs)tracking clouds and water-vapour features in successive geostationary imageswind at the height assigned to the feature (height assignment is the main error source)
Scatterometer winds (for example ASCAT; the Indian Oceansat-2 scatterometer and SCATSAT-1)radar backscatter from wind-roughened sea surfaceocean surface wind vectors
GNSS radio occultationbending of GPS signals passing through the atmosphere’s limbrefractivity, hence temperature in the upper troposphere and stratosphere; no calibration drift, so it anchors radiance bias correction
Ocean altimetry, SSTradar altimeter, IR and microwave SSTocean initial states for coupled models

Weighting functions and the retrieval problem

A sounder channel at frequency \( \nu \) measures radiance emitted from a layer of the atmosphere described by its weighting function \( W(p) = d\tau_\nu/d\ln p \), where \( \tau_\nu \) is the transmittance from level \( p \) to space. Channels near the centre of an absorption band peak high in the atmosphere (opaque, emission escapes only from near the top); channels in the wings peak lower. Each channel sees a broad layer, and neighbouring channels overlap, so recovering a temperature profile from radiances (retrieval) is an ill-posed inverse problem: many profiles give the same radiances.

Two ways to use them:

Retrieval assimilationDirect radiance assimilation
What enters the analysisretrieved temperature/humidity profilesthe radiances themselves
Observation operatorsimple interpolationa fast radiative-transfer model (and its adjoint)
Prior informationfrom the retrieval’s own first guess (often climatology or a different model), with complicated errorsfrom the NWP background, used consistently with \( \mathbf{B} \)
Statusolder approachstandard in variational systems

Direct assimilation is preferred because the errors of radiances are simpler and better known than those of retrievals, and because the background used is the same as in the rest of the analysis. Its difficulties are clouds and precipitation (IR channels see cloud tops; microwave channels are affected by rain), surface emissivity over land and snow, and bias correction.

Impact

Observing-system experiments (forecasts run with and without one type of data) show that satellite data, especially microwave and hyperspectral IR sounder radiances, are among the largest contributors to global forecast skill, with the largest impact in the southern hemisphere and over the oceans. The narrowing of the gap between northern and southern hemisphere skill is attributed largely to better use of satellite radiances. Over India and the surrounding seas, geostationary imagery and soundings from the INSAT-3D series, together with scatterometer and microwave data, fill the gaps between the sparse radiosonde network and the open ocean.

Conventional data for comparison

PlatformVariablesRemarks
Radiosondes\( T \), humidity, wind, pressure profilesmain synoptic hours 00 and 12 UTC; backbone of upper-air data over land
Surface (SYNOP), ships, buoyspressure, temperature, humidity, windsurface pressure is especially valuable
Aircraft (AMDAR)temperature, wind; some humiditydense along flight routes and near airports
Wind profilers, Doppler weather radarwind profiles; reflectivity and radial windradar is central to convective-scale assimilation and nowcasting

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Objective analysis (spatial interpolation at one time)Data assimilation (analysis + forecast cycling in time)
Innovation \( \mathbf{y} - H\mathbf{x}_b \)Analysis increment \( \mathbf{x}_a - \mathbf{x}_b \)
Linear NMI: gravity-mode amplitudes set to zeroNonlinear NMI: gravity-mode tendencies set to zero
Static initialization (balance relation)Dynamic initialization (damping time integration)
3D-Var: one time, no adjoint model4D-Var: window, model as constraint, adjoint
\( \mathbf{B} \): background-error covariance\( \mathbf{R} \): observation-error covariance (includes representativeness)
Retrieved profileRadiance assimilated directly through a radiative-transfer operator
Polar-orbiting, about 800 km, globalGeostationary, about 35 800 km, fixed disc, frequent images

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. What is the Cressman weight of an observation located exactly at the radius of influence?
  2. Which data assimilation method requires the adjoint of the forecast model?
  3. Which spectral band is used by microwave sounders to measure temperature profiles?
Answers
  1. Zero. \( w = (R^2 - R^2)/(R^2 + R^2) = 0 \).
  2. 4D-Var, to compute the gradient of the cost function with respect to the initial state.
  3. The oxygen absorption band at 50–60 GHz.

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. With a radius of influence \( R = 200 \) km, the Cressman weight of an observation 100 km from a grid point is:

(a) 0.25 (b) 0.50 (c) 0.60 (d) 0.75

Answer: (c) 0.60

\( w = (200^2 - 100^2)/(200^2 + 100^2) = 30\,000/50\,000 = 0.6 \). Option (d) would be the linear weight \( 1 - (r/R)^2 \); option (b) is \( 1 - r/R \).

Practice Q2. A background temperature of 20.0 °C has error standard deviation 1.0 °C. An observation at the same point reads 22.0 °C with error standard deviation 0.5 °C. Errors are unbiased and uncorrelated. The optimal analysis and its error standard deviation are:

(a) 21.0 °C, 0.75 °C (b) 21.6 °C, 0.45 °C (c) 22.0 °C, 0.50 °C (d) 21.6 °C, 0.20 °C

Answer: (b) 21.6 °C, about 0.45 °C

Weight \( = \sigma_b^2/(\sigma_b^2 + \sigma_o^2) = 1/(1 + 0.25) = 0.8 \). \( x_a = 20 + 0.8(2) = 21.6 \) °C.

\( \sigma_a^2 = (1)(0.25)/1.25 = 0.2 \), so \( \sigma_a = 0.447 \) °C. Option (d) quotes the variance as the standard deviation. The analysis error is smaller than both input errors.

Practice Q3. In nonlinear normal-mode initialization:

(a) The amplitudes of the Rossby modes are set to zero (b) The initial time tendencies of the gravity modes are set to zero (c) The model is integrated forward with the forward (Euler) scheme to amplify gravity waves (d) The wind is replaced by the geostrophic wind everywhere

Answer: (b)

NNMI (Machenhauer’s condition) sets the gravity-mode tendencies to zero, keeping the slowly varying gravity-mode component forced by the Rossby flow. (d) is static initialization; (a) would remove the weather itself.

Practice Q4. A geostationary satellite differs from a sun-synchronous polar-orbiting satellite in that it:

(a) Orbits at about 800 km and sees the whole globe twice a day (b) Orbits at about 35 800 km above the equator and images the same disc every few minutes, but cannot see the poles (c) Measures only microwave radiances (d) Provides GNSS radio-occultation profiles

Answer: (b)

Geostationary orbit is about 35 800 km above the equator, period one sidereal day; it gives frequent images of a fixed disc (hence atmospheric motion vectors) but poor views poleward of about 60–70°. (a) describes a polar orbiter.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. A grid point has background value 10.0 (units of the field). Two observations lie within a Cressman radius of influence of 200 km: observation A at 50 km with innovation (O − B) of +4.0, and observation B at 150 km with innovation +2.0. The Cressman analysis at the grid point (single pass) is closest to:

(a) 12.0 (b) 13.0 (c) 13.5 (d) 14.0

Answer: (c) about 13.5

\( w_A = (40\,000 - 2\,500)/(40\,000 + 2\,500) = 37\,500/42\,500 = 0.882 \).

\( w_B = (40\,000 - 22\,500)/(40\,000 + 22\,500) = 17\,500/62\,500 = 0.280 \).

Correction \( = (0.882 \times 4 + 0.280 \times 2)/(0.882 + 0.280) = (3.529 + 0.560)/1.162 = 3.52 \).

\( x_a = 10 + 3.52 = 13.52 \). Option (b) is the simple mean of the innovations (3.0) added to 10; Cressman favours the nearer observation.

Practice Q6. At one grid point, a 3D-Var analysis combines a background temperature of 280 K (\( \sigma_b = 2 \) K) with two independent observations: 282 K (\( \sigma = 1 \) K) and 283 K (\( \sigma = 2 \) K), both at the grid point. Consider:

  1. The analysis is about 281.8 K.
  2. The analysis error variance is about 0.67 K².
  3. The analysis lies closer to the first observation than to the background because the first observation has the smallest error.
  4. Removing the background term from the cost function would leave the analysis unchanged.

Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only

Minimising \( J = \frac{(x - 280)^2}{2 \cdot 4} + \frac{(x - 282)^2}{2 \cdot 1} + \frac{(x - 283)^2}{2 \cdot 4} \) gives the precision-weighted mean:

\( x_a = \dfrac{280/4 + 282/1 + 283/4}{1/4 + 1 + 1/4} = \dfrac{70 + 282 + 70.75}{1.5} = 281.83 \) K. (1 true)

\( \sigma_a^2 = 1/1.5 = 0.667 \) K², \( \sigma_a = 0.82 \) K. (2 true)

281.83 is 0.17 K from 282 and 1.83 K from 280. (3 true)

Without \( J_b \): \( x = (282/1 + 283/4)/(1 + 1/4) = 352.75/1.25 = 282.2 \) K, a different answer. (4 false)

Practice Q7. Consider these statements about initialization and satellite data:

  1. Digital filter initialization applies a low-pass filter in time to a short model integration around the initial time.
  2. 4D-Var reduces the need for separate initialization because its analysis is a model trajectory fitted over a window.
  3. Direct radiance assimilation needs a fast radiative-transfer model as the observation operator.
  4. Retrieving a temperature profile from sounder radiances is a well-posed problem because each channel senses a thin layer.

Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only

1, 2 and 3 are true as described on this page. 4 is false: weighting functions are broad and overlapping, so the inverse problem is ill-posed; prior information (a background) is needed to choose among profiles that fit the radiances.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFormula or fact
Analysis ingredientsbackground \( \mathbf{x}_b \) (\( \mathbf{B} \)), observations \( \mathbf{y} \) (\( \mathbf{R} \)), operator \( H \)
Cressman weight\( (R^2 - r^2)/(R^2 + r^2) \), 0 beyond \( R \); successive passes, shrinking \( R \)
Barnes weight\( e^{-r^2/\kappa} \)
OI (scalar)\( x_a = x_b + \frac{\sigma_b^2}{\sigma_b^2 + \sigma_o^2}(y - x_b) \); \( 1/\sigma_a^2 = 1/\sigma_b^2 + 1/\sigma_o^2 \)
BLUE gain\( \mathbf{K} = \mathbf{B}H^{\mathsf T}(H\mathbf{B}H^{\mathsf T} + \mathbf{R})^{-1} \)
3D-Var\( J = J_b + J_o \); same minimum as OI for linear \( H \); allows radiances
4D-Varwindow, model as strong constraint, adjoint for the gradient, incremental form
Kalman / EnKFforecasts \( \mathbf{P} \); EnKF uses ensemble with localization and inflation
Static / dynamic initializationbalance relation / damping forward-backward integration
Linear vs nonlinear NMIgravity amplitudes = 0 / gravity tendencies = 0 (Machenhauer)
DFIlow-pass time filter on a short integration
Polar vs geostationaryabout 800 km, global / about 35 800 km, fixed disc, frequent
Temperature soundingCO₂ 15 μm (IR), O₂ 50–60 GHz (microwave, through cloud)
Humidity soundingH₂O 6.3 μm (IR), 183 GHz (microwave)
Other satellite dataAMVs, scatterometer winds, GNSS RO, microwave imager TPW and rain
Weighting function\( d\tau/d\ln p \); broad, overlapping ⇒ retrieval ill-posed

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement