Skip to content

Origin of Life, Tempo of Evolution and Mass Extinctions

CSIR NET Earth Sciences Part C geology: early life evidence, punctuated equilibrium vs gradualism, evolutionary rates, the Big Five extinctions and causes.

  • 23 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 12 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Centimetre of Clay at Gubbio
  3. Part 1: Origin and Early History of Life
  4. Part 2: The Tempo of Evolution
  5. Part 3: Mass Extinctions
  6. Memory Tricks
  7. Don’t Confuse
  8. Common Mistakes
  9. Practice
  10. Quick Revision Table
  11. Key Takeaways
  12. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: A Centimetre of Clay at Gubbio

Part 1: Origin and Early History of Life

The geological evidence, oldest first

The Part B page gives the outline. For Part C you need to know what kind of evidence each claim rests on and why it is disputed, because questions often ask which evidence is strongest.

EvidenceApproximate ageLocality (examples)Strength
Detrital zirconsup to about 4.4 GaJack Hills, Western Australianot life itself; oxygen isotopes suggest crust and liquid water existed by then
\( ^{13}\text{C} \)-depleted graphiteabout 3.7–3.8 GaIsua, south-west Greenlandisotopic only; metamorphism and abiotic processes can also make light carbon
Stromatolite-like structuresabout 3.7 Ga (claimed)Isuacontested; may be deformation structures
Stromatolitesabout 3.48 Ga and 3.43 GaDresser and Strelley Pool formations, Pilbarawidely accepted biogenic structures
Filamentous microfossilsabout 3.46 GaApex Chert, Pilbarafirst described as cyanobacteria-like; later challenged as mineral artefacts
Well-preserved microbial microfossilsabout 1.9 GaGunflint Chert, Ontarioaccepted; classic Proterozoic assemblage in chert
Eukaryotic microfossils (acritarchs) and red algaePaleo- to MesoproterozoicChina, India (Vindhyan claims), Canadasize, wall structure and ornament point to eukaryotes; exact first age debated
Ediacaran macrofossilsabout 575–539 MaNewfoundland, South Australia, White Sea, Namibialarge multicellular organisms; some (e.g. Dickinsonia) carry animal biomarkers
Cambrian body fossils with hard partsfrom 538.8 Maworldwideunquestioned animals

Three kinds of biosignature are in use:

  1. Morphological: microfossils, stromatolites, microbially induced sedimentary structures. The problem is that some abiotic processes make similar shapes.
  2. Isotopic: biological carbon fixation by RuBisCO prefers \( ^{12}\text{C} \), so organic carbon is about 20–30‰ lighter in \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) than coexisting carbonate. Sulphate reducers leave light sulphide. The problem is metamorphic resetting and abiotic organic synthesis. The isotope tools are developed on Oxygen and Carbon Isotopes in Paleoclimate.
  3. Molecular (biomarkers): hopanes (bacteria), steranes (eukaryotes), 2-methylhopanes. The problem is contamination by younger hydrocarbons, which discredited several Archean sterane reports.

From chemistry to cells: the hypotheses in one table

StageKey ideaSetting proposed
MonomersOparin–Haldane “primordial soup”; Miller–Urey (1953) made amino acids with sparks in CH\(_4\), NH\(_3\), H\(_2\), H\(_2\)Oreducing atmosphere; shallow water
Monomers from spaceamino acids and nucleobases in carbonaceous chondrites (e.g. Murchison)delivery by meteorites and comets
Polymersclay mineral surfaces (montmorillonite) catalyse RNA oligomer formation; wet–dry cyclestidal pools, hot springs
Metabolism firstiron–sulphur world: surface reactions on FeS and pyrite drive carbon fixationhydrothermal settings
Compartments and gradientsalkaline hydrothermal vents give natural pH and redox gradients across mineral membranesserpentinite-hosted vents (Lost City type)
ReplicatorsRNA world: RNA stores information and catalyses reactions (ribozymes) before DNA and proteinsany of the above
Cellsfatty-acid vesicles self-assemble and growlow-salt water

None of these is settled. For the exam, know what each proposes and the strongest objection to it. Miller–Urey yields fall in a weakly reducing CO\(_2\)–N\(_2\) atmosphere. RNA is unstable and hard to make abiotically. Meteoritic delivery supplies building blocks, not life.

The Precambrian biosphere in four steps

graph LR
    A["Archean
prokaryotes, stromatolites,
anoxygenic then oxygenic
photosynthesis"] --> B["Paleoproterozoic
Great Oxidation Event,
eukaryote origin"] B --> C["Meso- to Neoproterozoic
acritarchs, red and green algae,
snowball glaciations"] C --> D["Ediacaran
large soft-bodied biota,
first biomineralisers"] D --> E["Cambrian
skeletal animals,
deep burrows"]
  • Eukaryotes arose by endosymbiosis: mitochondria from an alpha-proteobacterium, plastids from a cyanobacterium. In the fossil record they are recognised by large size (tens of micrometres or more), complex wall ornament (spines, processes), and later by multicellular algae.
  • Ediacaran biota (about 575–539 Ma) is often divided into three assemblages: Avalon (deep water, frond-like rangeomorphs such as Charnia), White Sea (shallow marine, most diverse; Dickinsonia, Kimberella, Spriggina) and Nama (latest; the earliest calcified tubes such as Cloudina). Preservation is mostly as moulds and casts on the base of sandstone beds, sealed by microbial mats (“death-mask” preservation).
  • Cambrian explosion: the base of the Cambrian is defined at Fortune Head, Newfoundland, by the first appearance of the trace fossil Treptichnus pedum, a branching burrow. Small shelly fossils come first, then trilobites and most phyla. The Burgess Shale (Canada) and Chengjiang (China) preserve the soft-bodied side of this diversification.

Part 2: The Tempo of Evolution

Two models

Phyletic gradualismPunctuated equilibrium
Associated withDarwin’s view of slow, continuous changeNiles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould (1972)
Where change happensthroughout the lineage (anagenesis)mostly at speciation events (cladogenesis)
Rateslow and roughly steadylong stasis interrupted by geologically brief change
Speciation mode assumedwhole populations transformsmall peripheral isolates (Mayr’s peripatric speciation)
Expected fossil patternintermediates through the section; a smooth morphological trendabrupt replacement; ancestor may survive alongside descendant
Predicts ancestor and descendant overlap?no (one turns into the other)yes (the daughter branches off)
Macroevolutionary trends explained byaccumulation of change within lineagesspecies sorting or species selection: differential origination and extinction of species

What kind of data decides between them

A test needs (a) a densely sampled, (b) stratigraphically complete section with (c) morphometric data on (d) many specimens per level, ideally from (e) more than one lineage. Classic studies:

  • Gradual change: Sheldon’s work on Ordovician trilobites in central Wales (1987) recorded slow, net change in the number of pygidial ribs in several lineages over about 3 Myr.
  • Punctuation: Williamson’s work on molluscs from the Turkana basin of Kenya (1981) recorded long stasis broken by short episodes of change, linked to lake-level fluctuations.
  • Mixed patterns: studies of the planktonic foraminifer Globorotalia in Neogene deep-sea cores found stasis interrupted by intervals of fairly rapid but continuous change (“punctuated gradualism”).

Deep-sea microfossils are the best material for such tests because cores give continuous sections, thousands of specimens per sample and good age control. Today most palaeontologists accept that both patterns occur, and that stasis is common.

Measuring evolutionary rates

Two units are standard.

The darwin (d) measures proportional change per million years:

$$r_{\text{d}} = \frac{\ln x_2 - \ln x_1}{\Delta t}\quad (\Delta t \text{ in Myr})$$

One darwin is a change by a factor of \( e \) per million years. Using logarithms makes the rate independent of the units of \( x \).

The haldane (h) measures change in standard deviations per generation:

$$r_{\text{h}} = \frac{(\ln x_2 - \ln x_1)/s_{\ln x}}{\text{number of generations}}$$

where \( s_{\ln x} \) is the pooled standard deviation of \( \ln x \) within samples. It is the better unit for comparing with selection experiments.

The time-scaling problem. Measured rates fall as the time interval over which they are measured grows (Gingerich, 1983). Over long intervals, change in one direction is cancelled by later reversals and stasis, so the net change divided by a long time looks slow. Sedimentation rates show the same artefact (Sadler, 1981). Never compare rates measured over very different intervals without allowing for this.

Empirical “laws” of palaeontology

RuleStatementCaution
Cope’s rulebody size tends to increase within lineages over timea statistical tendency, with many exceptions; partly explained by small founders
Dollo’s lawa complex structure, once lost, is not regained in the same formirreversibility; some genetic re-evolution is now documented
Williston’s lawserially repeated parts (limbs, teeth, segments) tend to become fewer and more specialisede.g. fewer, specialised teeth in mammals than in early tetrapods
Simpson’s quantum evolutionrapid shifts between adaptive zonesproposed in Tempo and Mode in Evolution (1944)

Part 3: Mass Extinctions

Background vs mass extinction

Species go extinct all the time: this background extinction removes perhaps a few per cent of genera per million years. A mass extinction is a geologically brief event in which a large fraction of species in many unrelated groups, in many environments and across the globe, disappear. Raup and Sepkoski (1982), using a global compilation of marine animal families, picked out five events that stood clear of the background: the Big Five.

The Big Five

EventAge (Ma, approx.)Marine species lost (one widely used estimate)Main victimsLeading cause
End-Ordovician (Hirnantian)about 445–443about 86%graptolites, trilobites, brachiopods, conodonts, acritarchsGondwana glaciation: cooling and sea-level fall; two pulses
Late Devonian (Frasnian–Famennian, plus end-Devonian)about 372 and 359about 75%reef builders (stromatoporoids, tabulate and rugose corals), placoderms (end-Devonian), many brachiopodsrepeated ocean anoxia (Kellwasser and Hangenberg black shales), cooling; possibly nutrient runoff from spreading land plants
End-Permian252about 96% (the largest; other estimates are lower)last trilobites, tabulate and rugose corals, fusulinid forams, blastoids; most brachiopods, crinoids, bryozoans; the Glossopteris flora declinedSiberian Traps volcanism: CO\(_2\) warming, ocean acidification, anoxia and euxinia (H\(_2\)S)
End-Triassic201about 80%last conodonts; most ammonoids; many bivalves, brachiopods; non-dinosaur archosaurs on landCentral Atlantic Magmatic Province (CAMP) volcanism
End-Cretaceous (K–Pg)66about 76%non-avian dinosaurs, pterosaurs, ammonites, belemnites, rudist bivalves, mosasaurs, plesiosaurs, most planktonic forams and calcareous nannoplanktonChicxulub impact, with Deccan Traps volcanism as a contributor

The percentages are the species-level estimates compiled by Barnosky and colleagues (2011). Other compilations differ by 5–15 points, and genus-level losses are always smaller. Questions ask which is largest (end-Permian), the order, or the cause, not the decimals.

Evidence for the K–Pg impact

ObservationWhy it points to an impact
Iridium (and other platinum-group element) anomaly in the boundary clayPGEs are depleted in the crust but enriched in chondritic meteorites
Shocked quartz with multiple sets of planar deformation featuresrequires shock pressures that only impacts reach (volcanoes do not)
Glassy spherules and microtektites, Ni-rich spinelsmelt droplets ejected and cooled in the atmosphere
A buried crater about 180 km across at Chicxulub, Yucatán, of matching agethe source
Tsunami deposits around the Gulf of Mexicoproximity to the crater
Soot and a “fern spike” in pollen recordswildfires, then pioneer ferns recolonising devastated land

The Deccan Traps in western India erupted most of their volume within roughly a million years around the boundary. Debate continues over how much they contributed (warming, acidification) relative to the impact. A balanced answer cites both. India’s intertrappean beds, which hold fossils between lava flows, are discussed on Important Fossils in Indian Stratigraphy.

Kill mechanisms

graph TD
    LIP["Large igneous province
(Siberian, CAMP, Deccan)"] --> CO2["CO2 and SO2 release;
heating of organic-rich and
evaporite country rock"] CO2 --> W["Warming"] CO2 --> AC["Ocean acidification"] W --> AN["Reduced O2 solubility,
stratification: anoxia,
euxinia (H2S)"] IMP["Bolide impact"] --> D["Dust and sulphate aerosols:
darkness, cooling,
photosynthesis collapse"] IMP --> F["Wildfires, acid rain"] GL["Glaciation"] --> SL["Sea-level fall:
loss of shelf habitat"] GL --> CO["Cooling"]

Geochemical fingerprints that Part C uses in data questions:

  • Negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) excursions in carbonate: injection of isotopically light carbon (volcanic or methane-derived) and collapse of biological productivity. Large at the end-Permian and end-Triassic.
  • Mercury (Hg) spikes in sediments: a proxy for large-scale volcanic degassing.
  • Iridium and other PGE anomalies: impact (the K–Pg signal).
  • Black shales, pyrite framboids, biomarkers for green sulphur bacteria: anoxia and photic-zone euxinia (end-Permian, Late Devonian).
  • Oxygen-isotope shifts in conodont apatite: rapid warming across the end-Permian.

Selectivity, survival and recovery

Extinctions are not random. Survivors tend to be:

  • Generalists with wide geographic ranges (range size at the genus level is the best single predictor of survival in many events).
  • Detritus and deposit feeders rather than suspension feeders and photosynthesis-dependent food chains (at the K–Pg, food webs based on dead organic matter fared better).
  • Groups with resting stages or cysts (diatoms, dinoflagellates). By contrast, heavily calcified, weakly buffered, low-metabolism organisms (many corals, brachiopods, crinoids) suffered most in the end-Permian acidification.
  • Deep-sea benthos, partly insulated from surface collapses (benthic forams were little affected at the K–Pg).

Post-extinction vocabulary:

TermMeaningExample
Disaster taxonopportunist that becomes abundant right after the crisisLystrosaurus on land and the bivalve Claraia in the sea after the end-Permian; microbialites return in Early Triassic seas
Lazarus taxondisappears from the record and reappears later: it survived somewhere unsampledmany Early Triassic gaps in molluscs and brachiopods
Elvis taxona later look-alike mistaken for a survivor; convergence, not survivala younger form whose shell converges on an extinct genus
Dead clade walkingsurvives the event but never recovers and dwindles to extinctionseveral Paleozoic groups after the end-Permian
Lilliput effectsmall body size in survivors and early recovery faunasEarly Triassic gastropods

Recovery is slow: reef ecosystems did not return for millions of years after the end-Permian and end-Devonian events. Sepkoski grouped marine diversity into three evolutionary faunas: Cambrian (trilobites, inarticulate brachiopods), Paleozoic (articulate brachiopods, crinoids, corals) and Modern (molluscs, echinoids, bony fish). The end-Permian extinction marks the handover from the Paleozoic to the Modern fauna.

Sampling effects that create false patterns

Signor–Lipps effect (1982). Even if all species die out at one instant, their last observed occurrences will be scattered below the boundary, because the chance of finding the very last individual of a species is small, and rare species are found less often. A sudden extinction therefore looks gradual or stepwise in the rocks. The reverse (originations smeared upwards) is sometimes called the Sppil–Rongis effect.

How to test whether an extinction was really sudden:

  1. Sample densely near the boundary.
  2. Compute confidence intervals on the range end of each taxon from the number and spacing of its finds (if a species occurs often, its true last occurrence is probably close to its last find).
  3. Compare abundant and rare taxa: if abundant species end at the boundary and only rare ones end below it, the pattern fits an abrupt event smeared by sampling.

Pull of the Recent. Living groups are much better sampled than fossil ones, so a living group’s range is “pulled” up to the present even if it has no fossils in the youngest rocks. This inflates apparent Cenozoic diversity.

Taxonomic level matters. Losing 50% of families can mean losing 90% or more of species, because a family survives if any one of its species survives. Raup used this “reverse rarefaction” logic to estimate species-level loss at the end-Permian from family-level data.

Periodicity

Raup and Sepkoski (1984) argued that marine extinctions over the last 250 Myr peaked roughly every 26 Myr, and astronomical causes were proposed (a companion star, passage through the galactic plane). The statistical signal is weak and depends on the time scale used. Treat it as a hypothesis, not a fact.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Punctuated equilibrium: change concentrated at speciationSaltation: change in a single generational jump (not what Eldredge and Gould proposed)
Anagenesis: one lineage transformsCladogenesis: lineage splits
Darwin: proportional change per MyrHaldane: standard deviations per generation
Lazarus taxon: real survivor, gap in recordElvis taxon: look-alike, not a survivor
Signor–Lipps: abrupt extinction looks gradualPull of the Recent: living groups’ ranges extended to the present
K–Pg (66 Ma): impact plus Deccan; dinosaurs, ammonitesP–T (252 Ma): Siberian Traps; largest; trilobites’ last stand
Stromatolite: microbial biosedimentary structureThrombolite: clotted, non-laminated microbial structure

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which trace fossil defines the base of the Cambrian System?
  2. Who proposed punctuated equilibrium, and in what year?
  3. Which of the Big Five extinctions was the largest?
Answers
  1. Treptichnus pedum, at the GSSP at Fortune Head, Newfoundland.
  2. Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould, 1972.
  3. The end-Permian (about 252 Ma).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. Which observation is most diagnostic of a bolide impact rather than volcanism at an extinction boundary?

(a) A negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) excursion (b) A mercury enrichment in boundary shales (c) Quartz grains with multiple sets of planar deformation features (d) A rise in black shale deposition

Answer: (c)

Multiple sets of planar deformation features in quartz form only at shock pressures produced by hypervelocity impact. Negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) excursions and black shales occur with volcanism or anoxia, and Hg spikes are used as a volcanic proxy.

Practice Q2. A lineage shows long intervals with no net morphological change, separated by short intervals in which a descendant species appears and coexists with its ancestor. This pattern best fits:

(a) phyletic gradualism (b) punctuated equilibrium (c) Dollo’s law (d) Cope’s rule

Answer: (b)

Stasis plus branching (ancestor survives alongside descendant) is the punctuated-equilibrium signature. Gradualism predicts transformation of the whole lineage with no overlap. Dollo’s law concerns irreversibility; Cope’s rule concerns size increase.

Practice Q3. Which group’s final extinction coincides with the end-Triassic event?

(a) Trilobites (b) Graptolites (c) Conodonts (d) Ammonites

Answer: (c) Conodonts

Trilobites ended at the end-Permian. Graptoloids (planktonic graptolites) had disappeared by the Early Devonian, though some benthic dendroids lingered into the Carboniferous. Ammonites ended at the K–Pg. Conodonts are not found above the Triassic.

Practice Q4. A palaeontologist finds that the last occurrences of 40 ammonite species are spread through the 15 m below an iridium-rich clay, with the commoner species ending closest to the clay. The most likely interpretation is:

(a) gradual extinction over the 15 m interval, unrelated to the clay (b) an abrupt extinction at the clay, with ranges truncated below it by sampling (Signor–Lipps effect) (c) reworking of ammonites upward into younger beds (d) a Lazarus effect

Answer: (b)

If abundant species end nearest the boundary and rare species end further below, the scatter is explained by the lower chance of finding the last representatives of rare species. Reworking would extend ranges above the boundary, not truncate them below.

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. In a well-dated lineage of planktonic foraminifera, mean test diameter increases from 200 µm to 260 µm over 0.5 Myr. The pooled standard deviation of ln(diameter) is 0.08, and one generation is taken as one year. Which pair of values is closest to the rate?

(a) 0.52 darwins; \( 6.6\times 10^{-6} \) haldanes (b) 0.26 darwins; \( 3.3\times 10^{-6} \) haldanes (c) 0.13 darwins; \( 6.6\times 10^{-6} \) haldanes (d) 0.52 darwins; \( 3.3\times 10^{-6} \) haldanes

Answer: (a)

\( \ln(260/200) = \ln 1.3 = 0.262 \).

Darwins: \( 0.262 / 0.5 = 0.52 \) d.

Haldanes: change in standard deviations \( = 0.262 / 0.08 = 3.28 \); generations \( = 0.5\times 10^{6} \); rate \( = 3.28 / 5\times10^{5} = 6.6\times 10^{-6} \) h.

Option (b) forgets to divide by 0.5 Myr (it uses 1 Myr) and halves the haldanes; (d) mixes the two.

Practice Q6. Assume each species in an extinction event independently has probability 0.85 of extinction. A family contains 3 genera with 4 species each. What is the probability that the family becomes extinct?

(a) 0.15 (b) 0.52 (c) 0.14 (d) 0.85

Answer: (c) 0.14

A genus dies only if all 4 of its species die: \( 0.85^4 = 0.522 \).

The family dies only if all 3 genera die: \( 0.522^3 = 0.142 \).

Option (b), 0.52, is the genus extinction probability: the trap for anyone who stops one step early. The result shows how an 85% species loss can leave about 86% of such families alive.

Practice Q7. Consider the following statements about the end-Permian extinction.

  1. It coincided with the eruption of the Siberian Traps.
  2. A negative carbon-isotope excursion is recorded across the boundary in many sections.
  3. Rugose and tabulate corals survived it and gave rise to modern scleractinian corals.
  4. Early Triassic faunas include abundant opportunists such as the bivalve Claraia.

Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 4 only
  • 1 true: Siberian Traps volcanism is the leading cause.
  • 2 true: a negative \( \delta^{13}\text{C} \) excursion of several per mil marks the event.
  • 3 false: rugose and tabulate corals died out at the end of the Permian. Scleractinians appear in the Middle Triassic and are not their direct descendants.
  • 4 true: Claraia is a classic disaster taxon.

Practice Q8. A section shows (from bottom to top): a diverse benthic assemblage; a sharp horizon with phosphatised and glauconitised shells and a hardground; then a new assemblage with a descendant species morphologically distinct from its ancestor. A student argues this proves punctuated equilibrium. What is the strongest objection?

(a) Benthic organisms cannot be used to study evolution (b) The hardground and condensed horizon indicate a hiatus, so the abrupt change may record missing time rather than rapid evolution (c) Phosphatised shells are always reworked from older rocks (d) Punctuated equilibrium applies only to planktonic organisms

Answer: (b)

Hardgrounds, phosphatisation and glauconite mark very slow or no sedimentation. Gradual change during the missing interval would appear as a jump. The test of punctuation requires showing that the section is complete across the change.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFact
Oldest zirconsabout 4.4 Ga, Jack Hills
Isua light carbonabout 3.7–3.8 Ga; debated
Accepted stromatolitesabout 3.48 and 3.43 Ga, Pilbara
Gunflint Chertabout 1.9 Ga microbial microfossils
Ediacaran assemblagesAvalon, White Sea, Nama; Cloudina earliest calcified tubes
Base of CambrianTreptichnus pedum, Fortune Head, 538.8 Ma
Punctuated equilibriumEldredge and Gould 1972; stasis, peripatric speciation, cladogenesis
Gradualismanagenesis; intermediates through section
Darwin\( \Delta \ln x / \Delta t \) (Myr)
Haldane\( (\Delta \ln x / s) \) per generation
Big Five444, 372 (and 359), 252, 201, 66 Ma
Largestend-Permian (Siberian Traps)
K–Pg evidenceIr, shocked quartz, spherules, Chicxulub (about 180 km)
Last trilobites / conodonts / ammonitesend-Permian / end-Triassic / end-Cretaceous
Signor–Lippssudden extinction looks gradual
Survivorsgeneralists, wide ranges, deposit feeders, cyst formers

Key Takeaways

What’s Next