Refraction and Reflection Interpretation
Refraction intercept and crossover, dipping refractors, hidden layers, plus-minus; reflection hyperbola, NMO, T2-X2, Dix and section interpretation.
- 16 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Snell’s Law, Ray Theory and the Zoeppritz Equations — critical angle, head waves, ray parameter.
- Seismic Sources, Detectors and Noise — spreads, offsets and what a shot record looks like.
- Comfort with square roots, small-angle approximations and inverse sines under time pressure: Numerical Ability.
The Hook: Depth to Bedrock Before Lunch
How CSIR NET asks it. This is the most numerical part of the unit. Part C (Geophysics) expects you to compute depth from intercept time or crossover distance, dip and true velocity from reversed profiles, velocity from NMO or a \(T^2\)–\(X^2\) plot, interval velocity from Dix, and to recognise hidden layers, blind zones, multiples and velocity pull-up.
Refraction: Travel-Time Equations
Direct wave
$$t_{direct} = \frac{x}{V_1}$$A straight line through the origin with slope \(1/V_1\).
Two horizontal layers
A layer of thickness \(h\) and velocity \(V_1\) over a half-space of velocity \(V_2 > V_1\). The head-wave ray goes down at \(i_c\), along the interface at \(V_2\), and up at \(i_c\):
$$t = \frac{x}{V_2} + \frac{2h\cos i_c}{V_1}, \qquad \sin i_c = \frac{V_1}{V_2}$$This is a straight line of slope \(1/V_2\) and intercept time
$$\boxed{t_i = \frac{2h\cos i_c}{V_1} = \frac{2h\sqrt{V_2^2 - V_1^2}}{V_1V_2}} \quad\Rightarrow\quad h = \frac{t_i\,V_1V_2}{2\sqrt{V_2^2 - V_1^2}}$$Critical distance (nearest offset where the head wave exists):
$$x_{crit} = 2h\tan i_c$$Crossover distance (where the head wave overtakes the direct wave):
$$\boxed{x_{cross} = 2h\sqrt{\frac{V_2 + V_1}{V_2 - V_1}}}$$Worked numbers: \(V_1 = 1000\) m/s, \(V_2 = 3000\) m/s, \(h = 20\) m. Then \(\sin i_c = 1/3\), \(\cos i_c = 0.943\), \(t_i = 40\times0.943/1000 = 37.7\) ms, \(x_{crit} = 40\times0.354 = 14.1\) m, \(x_{cross} = 40\sqrt2 = 56.6\) m. Check: at 56.6 m the direct wave takes 56.6 ms and the head wave \(18.9 + 37.7 = 56.6\) ms.
Note that \(x_{cross} > x_{crit}\) always: between them the head wave exists but is a second arrival.
Several horizontal layers
For \(n\) layers with velocities increasing downwards, the head wave on top of layer \(n\) has
$$t_n = \frac{x}{V_n} + \sum_{i=1}^{n-1}\frac{2h_i\cos\theta_{i}}{V_i}, \qquad \sin\theta_i = \frac{V_i}{V_n}$$Interpretation is layer stripping: get \(V_1, V_2, h_1\) from the first two segments, then use each new intercept to solve for the next thickness.
Dipping refractor
A refractor dipping at \(\alpha\), with shots at both ends of the line (a reversed profile). Shooting down-dip, the refractor gets deeper along the line, arrivals are delayed, and the apparent velocity is lower; shooting up-dip it is higher:
$$V_d = \frac{V_1}{\sin(i_c + \alpha)}, \qquad V_u = \frac{V_1}{\sin(i_c - \alpha)}$$Solving:
$$i_c = \frac12\left[\sin^{-1}\frac{V_1}{V_d} + \sin^{-1}\frac{V_1}{V_u}\right], \qquad \alpha = \frac12\left[\sin^{-1}\frac{V_1}{V_d} - \sin^{-1}\frac{V_1}{V_u}\right]$$then \(V_2 = V_1/\sin i_c\). For small dips, \(V_2 \approx 2V_uV_d\cos\alpha/(V_u + V_d)\). The perpendicular depth below each shot comes from that shot’s intercept: \(h = t_iV_1/(2\cos i_c)\).
Reciprocal time: the travel time from shot A to a geophone at B equals that from a shot at B to a geophone at A. Equal end-to-end times on a reversed profile are a quality check on picking.
Delay times, plus-minus and GRM
The delay time at a point is the extra time taken to go down to the refractor and back up, compared with travelling the same horizontal distance along the refractor. For a geophone G between two shots A and B with a reversed refraction profile:
$$T^+ = t_{AG} + t_{BG} - t_{AB}, \qquad T^- = t_{AG} - t_{BG}$$- \(T^+\) equals twice the delay time at G, so the depth under G is \(h_G = T^+V_1/(2\cos i_c)\) (Hagedoorn’s plus-minus method). It maps an irregular refractor geophone by geophone.
- \(T^-\) plotted against distance has slope \(2/V_2\), giving the refractor velocity, with irregularities in the overburden cancelling.
- The generalised reciprocal method (GRM) of Palmer improves on this by combining arrivals at two geophones a distance XY apart, chosen so that their rays leave the same refractor point. The time-term method solves the same delay-time problem by least squares over many shots and receivers (least squares in general: Ill-Posed Problems and Least Squares).
When refraction fails
| Problem | Cause | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Hidden layer (velocity inversion) | A layer slower than the one above it | No head wave from its top; its thickness is lumped into neighbours, so deeper depths are overestimated |
| Blind zone (thin layer) | Layer has \(V_2 > V_1\) but is too thin | Its head wave exists but is never a first arrival, so it is missed; deeper depths are underestimated |
| Strongly irregular refractor | Topography on the interface | Simple formulas fail; use plus-minus, GRM or tomography |
| Lateral velocity change | Facies or weathering change | Mistaken for dip unless the profile is reversed |
A step (fault) in the refractor shows as an offset between parallel segments of the travel-time curve, with a diffraction near the step.
Uses of refraction
- Depth to bedrock, the water table and rippability for engineering.
- Weathering (static) corrections for reflection data, from first breaks.
- Crustal and upper-mantle structure: head waves along the Moho (Pn) give upper-mantle velocity (see Seismology).
- Refraction tomography with diving waves in gradient media.
Reflection: Travel-Time Equations
One horizontal reflector
Source and receiver separated by offset \(x\), reflector at depth \(h\), velocity \(V\). By the image-source construction:
$$\boxed{t^2 = t_0^2 + \frac{x^2}{V^2}}, \qquad t_0 = \frac{2h}{V}$$A hyperbola with apex at \(x = 0\) and asymptote \(t = x/V\) (the direct wave). Reflections always arrive after the direct wave.
Normal moveout (NMO)
$$\Delta t_{NMO} = t_x - t_0 = \sqrt{t_0^2 + \frac{x^2}{V^2}} - t_0 \approx \frac{x^2}{2V^2t_0}$$- The approximation holds for \(x \ll Vt_0\) and overestimates at large offset.
- NMO decreases with depth (larger \(t_0\)) and with higher velocity: deep reflections are flatter.
- Rearranged: \(V \approx x/\sqrt{2t_0\Delta t}\).
Example: \(t_0 = 1.0\) s, \(V = 2000\) m/s, \(x = 1000\) m. Exact \(t_x = \sqrt{1.25} = 1.118\) s, so \(\Delta t = 118\) ms; the approximation gives 125 ms.
The \(T^2\)–\(X^2\) method
Plot \(t^2\) against \(x^2\): a straight line of slope \(1/V^2\) and intercept \(t_0^2\). Two clean points suffice:
$$\frac{1}{V^2} = \frac{t_2^2 - t_1^2}{x_2^2 - x_1^2}$$Example: \(t = 0.800\) s at \(x = 0\) and 1.000 s at \(x = 1500\) m. \(1/V^2 = 0.36/(2.25\times10^6)\) → \(V = 2500\) m/s, \(h = Vt_0/2 = 1000\) m.
Dipping reflector
For a reflector dipping at \(\theta\), with \(h\) the perpendicular distance from the shot and \(x\) measured positive down-dip:
$$t^2 = \frac{x^2 + 4h^2 + 4hx\sin\theta}{V^2}$$- Still a hyperbola, but its minimum is shifted up-dip to \(x = -2h\sin\theta\).
- On a split spread at offsets \(\pm x\), the dip moveout
- The stacking (NMO) velocity for a dipping reflector is \(V/\cos\theta\): higher than the medium velocity. Processing handles this with dip moveout (DMO) correction.
Many layers: RMS velocity and the Dix equation
For horizontal layers with interval velocities \(V_i\) and two-way interval times \(\Delta t_i\), the hyperbola is best fitted at short offsets by the root-mean-square velocity:
$$V_{rms,n}^2 = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n}V_i^2\,\Delta t_i}{\sum_{i=1}^{n}\Delta t_i}$$The Dix equation recovers the interval velocity between reflectors \(n-1\) and \(n\):
$$\boxed{V_{int}^2 = \frac{V_{rms,n}^2\,t_n - V_{rms,n-1}^2\,t_{n-1}}{t_n - t_{n-1}}}$$and the interval thickness is \(V_{int}(t_n - t_{n-1})/2\).
Velocities you must keep apart
| Velocity | Definition | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Interval \(V_{int}\) | Velocity of one layer | Lithology, pore pressure, Dix output |
| Average \(\bar V\) | Total depth ÷ one-way time | Depth conversion |
| RMS \(V_{rms}\) | Time-weighted RMS of interval velocities | Short-offset hyperbola; Dix input |
| Stacking / NMO | Velocity that best flattens a CMP gather | Stacking; approximately \(V_{rms}\) for flat layers |
| Migration | Velocity field used to image | Often derived from smoothed stacking velocities |
| Apparent | Inverse slope of an event across traces | f-k filtering, refraction dip |
Always \(V_{rms} \ge \bar V\), with equality only for a single uniform layer.
Multiples
| Type | Path | Recognition |
|---|---|---|
| Long-path (simple) multiple | Bounces twice between a strong reflector and the surface | At about twice the primary time; more NMO than a primary at the same time (lower velocity) |
| Peg-leg multiple | One extra short bounce between shallow interfaces | Just after the primary; adds a tail |
| Water-bottom reverberation | Repeated bounces in the water layer | Periodic ringing at the water two-way time |
| Interbed multiple | Between two subsurface interfaces | Hardest to predict |
| Ghost | Short path via the surface near source or receiver | Close behind every event; spectral notches |
Reading a Reflection Section
graph TD
S["Stacked or migrated
section"] --> W["Tie to wells:
synthetic seismogram,
check-shot or VSP"]
W --> H["Pick key horizons
and faults"]
H --> M["Time-structure
and isochron maps"]
M --> D["Depth conversion
with average velocity"]
D --> P["Prospect: closure,
trap, amplitude anomaly"]
H --> A["Check pitfalls:
multiples, pull-up,
sideswipe, bow-ties"]Structural interpretation.
- Faults: abrupt terminations and offsets of reflections, diffraction hyperbolae from cut-off edges (on unmigrated data), changes of dip, fault-plane reflections at steep dips.
- Folds and closures: time-structure maps show closures, but must be depth-converted before drilling.
- Salt and shale diapirs: reflection-free or chaotic bodies with upturned flanks.
- Unconformities: angular truncation of reflections below, onlap above (the starting point of seismic stratigraphy).
Pitfalls (time is not depth).
- Velocity pull-up: a fast body (salt, carbonate reef, high-velocity wedge) makes deeper reflectors look shallower beneath it.
- Velocity push-down (sag): a slow body (gas, shallow channel fill) makes deeper reflectors look deeper.
- Bow-ties: on unmigrated sections, a tight syncline whose radius of curvature is smaller than its depth (centre of curvature above the reflector, a buried focus) gives a crossing “bow-tie”.
- Sideswipe: reflections from out of the plane of a 2D line; only 3D removes them.
- Multiples that mimic deep structure; check moveout and periodicity.
Memory Tricks
Dimensional and limiting checks.
- \(h = 0\): \(t_i = 0\) and \(x_{cross} = 0\). Head wave from the start.
- \(V_2 \to V_1\): \(x_{cross} \to \infty\). No contrast, no overtaking.
- \(x \to \infty\) in the reflection hyperbola: \(t \to x/V\), the direct-wave line.
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Critical distance \(2h\tan i_c\): head wave first appears | vs | Crossover distance: head wave becomes the first arrival |
| Intercept time \(t_i\) (refraction) | vs | Zero-offset time \(t_0\) (reflection) |
| Hidden layer: slower layer, no head wave | vs | Blind zone: faster but thin layer, head wave never first |
| Average velocity: for depth conversion | vs | RMS velocity: for moveout; always ≥ average |
| NMO: offset-dependent, symmetric | vs | Dip moveout: asymmetric, from reflector dip |
| Perpendicular depth (from intercepts, dipping case) | vs | Vertical depth \(= h/\cos\alpha\) |
| Pull-up (fast overburden) | vs | Push-down (slow overburden, e.g. gas) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET Part C (Geophysics) style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- On a first-arrival plot, what does the slope of the segment through the origin give?
- On a \(t^2\)–\(x^2\) plot of a reflection, what is the slope?
- What is a “hidden layer” in refraction work?
Answers
- \(1/V_1\), the reciprocal of the top-layer velocity.
- \(1/V^2\) (and the intercept is \(t_0^2\)).
- A layer whose velocity is lower than that of the layer above, so it produces no head wave and cannot be seen on first arrivals.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). A two-layer refraction survey gives \(V_1 = 600\) m/s, \(V_2 = 1800\) m/s and intercept time 30 ms. The thickness of the top layer is about:
- (a) 9.0 m
- (b) 9.5 m
- (c) 19.1 m
- (d) 27.0 m
Answer and explanation
(b). \(h = t_iV_1V_2/(2\sqrt{V_2^2 - V_1^2}) = (0.030)(600)(1800)/(2\sqrt{2.88\times10^6}) = 32{,}400/3394 = 9.55\) m. Option (a) is \(V_1t_i/2\), ignoring the slant path.
Q2 (practice). A 20 m thick layer of velocity 1000 m/s overlies a half-space of 3000 m/s. The crossover distance is about:
- (a) 14 m
- (b) 40 m
- (c) 57 m
- (d) 80 m
Answer and explanation
(c). \(x_{cross} = 2h\sqrt{(V_2 + V_1)/(V_2 - V_1)} = 40\sqrt{4000/2000} = 40\sqrt2 = 56.6\) m. Option (a) is the critical distance \(2h\tan i_c = 14.1\) m.
Q3 (practice). A horizontal reflector gives \(t = 0.800\) s at zero offset and \(t = 1.000\) s at 1500 m offset. The velocity and reflector depth are:
- (a) 2500 m/s, 1000 m
- (b) 1875 m/s, 750 m
- (c) 2500 m/s, 2000 m
- (d) 3000 m/s, 1200 m
Answer and explanation
(a). \(1/V^2 = (1.000^2 - 0.800^2)/1500^2 = 0.36/2.25\times10^6\) → \(V = 1500/0.6 = 2500\) m/s. \(h = Vt_0/2 = 2500\times0.4 = 1000\) m. Option (b) uses \(1500/0.8\), a straight-line guess.
Q4 (practice). Stacking velocities are 2000 m/s at 1.0 s and 2500 m/s at 2.0 s (two-way). Assuming flat layers, the interval velocity and thickness between the two reflectors are about:
- (a) 2250 m/s and 1125 m
- (b) 2915 m/s and 1458 m
- (c) 2915 m/s and 2915 m
- (d) 3500 m/s and 1750 m
Answer and explanation
(b). Dix: \(V_{int}^2 = (2500^2\times2.0 - 2000^2\times1.0)/(2.0 - 1.0) = (12.5 - 4.0)\times10^6 = 8.5\times10^6\) → \(V_{int} = 2915\) m/s. Thickness \(= 2915\times(1.0/2) = 1458\) m (half the two-way interval time). Option (a) is the simple average, which Dix never gives.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). A reversed refraction profile over a dipping refractor gives a top-layer velocity of 1500 m/s and apparent refractor velocities of 2615 m/s (shooting down-dip) and 3549 m/s (shooting up-dip). The intercept time for the shot fired at the shallower (up-dip) end of the line, the one that gave the down-dip apparent velocity, is 40 ms.
(i) Find the critical angle and dip. (ii) Find the true refractor velocity, exactly and by the small-dip formula. (iii) Find the perpendicular depth to the refractor below that shot.
Answer and worked solution
- \(\sin^{-1}(1500/2615) = \sin^{-1}0.5736 = 35.0°\); \(\sin^{-1}(1500/3549) = \sin^{-1}0.4227 = 25.0°\). \(i_c = (35.0 + 25.0)/2 = \) 30.0°; \(\alpha = (35.0 - 25.0)/2 = \) 5.0°.
- Exact: \(V_2 = V_1/\sin i_c = 1500/0.5 = \) 3000 m/s. Small-dip formula: \(2V_uV_d\cos\alpha/(V_u + V_d) = 2(3549)(2615)(0.9962)/6164 = 3000\) m/s. The arithmetic mean, 3082 m/s, would be wrong by about 3%.
- \(h = t_iV_1/(2\cos i_c) = 0.040\times1500/(2\times0.866) = 60/1.732 = \) 34.6 m (perpendicular to the refractor).
Q2 (practice). A CMP gather over a flat reflector has \(t_0 = 1.000\) s, and the true velocity is 2000 m/s.
(i) Compute the exact NMO at 1000 m offset and compare with the small-offset formula. (ii) If an interpreter measures the exact NMO but uses the small-offset formula to get velocity, what velocity results? (iii) On a split spread over a different, dipping reflector (velocity 2000 m/s), the arrival at +1000 m (down-dip) is 87 ms later than at −1000 m. Estimate the dip.
Answer and worked solution
- Exact: \(t_x = \sqrt{1 + (1000/2000)^2} = \sqrt{1.25} = 1.1180\) s → \(\Delta t = 118.0\) ms. Approximate: \(x^2/(2V^2t_0) = 10^6/(8\times10^6) = 125\) ms, an overestimate of about 6%.
- \(V = x/\sqrt{2t_0\Delta t} = 1000/\sqrt{2\times1\times0.1180} = 1000/0.4859 = 2058\) m/s, about 3% too high. Use the hyperbolic form (or \(T^2\)–\(X^2\)) at large offsets.
- \(\sin\theta \approx V\Delta t_d/(2x) = 2000\times0.087/2000 = 0.087\) → \(\theta \approx\) 5.0°.
Q3 (practice). Two flat layers: layer 1 has \(V = 2000\) m/s and two-way thickness 1.0 s; layer 2 has \(V = 4000\) m/s and two-way thickness 1.0 s. Consider:
(A) At the base of layer 2 (\(t = 2.0\) s), the RMS velocity exceeds the average velocity. (B) Applying Dix to \(V_{rms}\) at 1.0 s and 2.0 s returns exactly 4000 m/s for layer 2. (C) The depth to the base of layer 2 is 3000 m. (D) Converting 2.0 s to depth with the RMS velocity gives the correct depth.
Which are correct?
- (a) A, B and C only
- (b) A and D only
- (c) B, C and D only
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(a) A, B and C.
- \(\bar V = (2000\times1 + 4000\times1)/2 = 3000\) m/s. \(V_{rms} = \sqrt{(2000^2 + 4000^2)/2} = \sqrt{10^7} = 3162\) m/s. (A) correct.
- (B) \(V_{int}^2 = (10^7\times2 - 4\times10^6\times1)/1 = 1.6\times10^7\) → 4000 m/s. Correct.
- (C) Depth \(= 2000(0.5) + 4000(0.5) = 1000 + 2000 = 3000\) m \(= \bar V\times t/2\). Correct.
- (D) \(3162\times1.0 = 3162\) m: about 5% too deep. Wrong.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Formula or fact |
|---|---|
| Direct wave | \(t = x/V_1\) |
| Head wave (2-layer) | \(t = x/V_2 + 2h\cos i_c/V_1\) |
| Depth from intercept | \(h = t_iV_1V_2/(2\sqrt{V_2^2 - V_1^2})\) |
| Critical distance | \(2h\tan i_c\) |
| Crossover distance | \(2h\sqrt{(V_2 + V_1)/(V_2 - V_1)}\) |
| Dipping refractor | \(V_d = V_1/\sin(i_c + \alpha)\); \(V_u = V_1/\sin(i_c - \alpha)\) |
| Plus-minus | \(T^+ = t_{AG} + t_{BG} - t_{AB}\) → depth; \(T^-\) slope \(2/V_2\) |
| Hidden layer / blind zone | Slow layer, depths too large / thin layer, depths too small |
| Reflection hyperbola | \(t^2 = t_0^2 + x^2/V^2\) |
| NMO | \(\approx x^2/(2V^2t_0)\), overestimates at far offset |
| \(T^2\)–\(X^2\) | Slope \(1/V^2\), intercept \(t_0^2\) |
| Dipping reflector | Apex up-dip at \(-2h\sin\theta\); \(\Delta t_d \approx 2x\sin\theta/V\); \(V_{NMO} = V/\cos\theta\) |
| RMS velocity | \(\sqrt{\sum V_i^2\Delta t_i/\sum\Delta t_i}\) ≥ average |
| Dix | \(V_{int}^2 = (V_n^2t_n - V_{n-1}^2t_{n-1})/(t_n - t_{n-1})\) |
| Depth conversion | Average velocity, not RMS |
| Pitfalls | Pull-up (fast body), push-down (gas), bow-tie, sideswipe, multiples |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Seismic Data Processing — CDP sorting, velocity analysis, NMO, stacking, deconvolution and migration put these equations into a production flow.
- Bright Spots, AVO, VSP, 3D and Seismic Stratigraphy — interpretation beyond structure.
- Snell’s Law, Ray Theory and the Zoeppritz Equations — the ray physics behind every formula here.
- Earth Sciences — other geophysics units in the Part C syllabus.