Extensional, Compressional and Strike-Slip Terrains; Mantle Plumes
CSIR NET Geology Part C: rifts and stretching, thrust systems, duplexes, critical taper, Riedel shears, flower structures, inversion, mantle plumes and LIPs.
- 19 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Anderson’s theory, fault terms and throw/heave from Stress, Strain, Folds, Joints and Faults.
- Reactivation and fluid pressure from Stress, Mohr Circle, Failure Criteria and Fault Reactivation.
- Isostasy and heat flow from Gravity, Geomagnetism, Heat Flow and Isostasy: rift subsidence and plume uplift are isostatic responses to density changes.
- Shear zones and kinematic indicators from Deformation Mechanisms and Shear Zones.
The Hook: Three Ways to Break a Plate
The Three Regimes at a Glance
| Extensional | Compressional (contractional) | Strike-slip (wrench) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vertical principal stress | \( \sigma_1 \) | \( \sigma_3 \) | \( \sigma_2 \) |
| Main faults | normal, dipping about 60° (steepening or flattening with depth) | thrusts, dipping about 30° or less, ramp–flat | vertical, nearly straight in map view |
| Crust | thinned | thickened | little change (except at bends) |
| Typical structures | grabens, half-grabens, tilted blocks, rollover anticlines, detachments, core complexes | fold–thrust belts, duplexes, nappes, klippen, windows | en echelon folds and faults, Riedel shears, flower structures, pull-apart basins |
| Plate setting | rifts, passive margins, back-arc basins, orogenic collapse | convergent margins, collisions | transform boundaries, oblique convergence |
Extensional Terrains
Normal-fault geometry
- Planar rotational faults (domino style): parallel faults and rigid blocks rotate together; beds tilt in the sense opposite to the fault dip as the faults flatten.
- Listric faults: concave upward, flattening into a detachment. The hanging wall collapses onto the curved fault, forming a rollover anticline with antithetic and synthetic secondary faults (and a crestal collapse graben).
- Grabens (down-dropped blocks between inward-dipping faults) and horsts (upstanding blocks).
- Half-grabens: tilted blocks bounded on one side by a major fault. Polarity often switches along the rift across accommodation (transfer) zones.
- Growth faults: faults active during sedimentation, with thicker hanging-wall strata. Common on passive margins with thick sediment and in deltas.
- Detachments and metamorphic core complexes: low-angle normal faults that bring mid-crustal mylonitic rocks up beneath brittle upper-plate rocks, with large extension. The Basin and Range province of western North America is the type region.
Measuring extension
For rigid domino blocks whose faults rotate from initial dip \( \theta_0 \) to final dip \( \theta \):
$$\boxed{\beta = \frac{\sin\theta_0}{\sin\theta}}$$\( \beta \) is the stretching factor: final length over initial length. Crust of initial thickness \( t_0 \) thinned uniformly becomes \( t_0/\beta \).
Models of lithospheric extension
| Model | Idea | Predictions |
|---|---|---|
| Pure shear (uniform stretching), D. McKenzie (1978) | crust and mantle lithosphere thin by the same factor \( \beta \), instantaneously | initial fault-controlled subsidence, then slower thermal subsidence decaying over tens of Myr as the lithosphere cools; symmetric margins |
| Simple shear, B. Wernicke (1985) | a lithosphere-scale low-angle detachment | asymmetric margins: upper-plate and lower-plate margins; thinning of crust and mantle offset laterally |
| Depth-dependent stretching | crust and mantle stretch by different amounts | explains margins with more subsidence than upper-crustal faults suggest |
Rifting to drifting
- Continental rift: graben systems, alkaline volcanism, shallow earthquakes (East African Rift).
- Narrow ocean: first oceanic crust (Red Sea, Gulf of Aden).
- Passive margin and ocean basin: thermal subsidence, wedge of sediment (Atlantic margins; India’s western and eastern margins).
Volcanic (magma-rich) margins have thick igneous crust and seaward-dipping reflectors (stacked lava flows) on seismic sections. Magma-poor margins (the Iberia margin is the classic example) can expose serpentinised mantle at the sea floor between continental and oceanic crust.
Active versus passive rifting. In active rifting, a mantle upwelling (often a plume) domes and heats the lithosphere, with volcanism preceding rifting. In passive rifting, far-field tensile stress stretches the plate and upwelling follows. The Indian Gondwana basins (Damodar, Son–Mahanadi, Pranhita–Godavari) are intracontinental rifts, and the Cambay basin is a Mesozoic–Cenozoic rift on the western margin.
Compressional Terrains
Thrust-system rules
The geometric rules of thrust belts (Dahlstrom; Boyer and Elliott, 1982) hold remarkably widely:
- Thrusts cut up-section in the transport direction and follow weak layers as flats, linked by ramps across stronger units.
- Hanging-wall flats over footwall ramps and vice versa produce folds in the thrust sheets.
- Thrusts generally propagate towards the foreland (piggy-back or in-sequence order): each new thrust forms beneath and in front of the previous one, which is carried on its back. Out-of-sequence thrusts break this rule.
- Thin-skinned deformation stays above a basal décollement (often in salt, shale or evaporite), leaving the basement undeformed. Thick-skinned deformation involves the basement, often by inverting old normal faults.
Thrust-related folds
| Fold | Formation | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Fault-bend fold (J. Suppe, 1983) | hanging wall bends over a ramp | flat-topped anticline with fixed geometric links between ramp angle and fold shape |
| Fault-propagation fold | fold forms at the tip of a propagating thrust | tight, forelimb steep to overturned |
| Detachment fold | fold over a décollement with no ramp | ductile core of weak rock (salt, shale) |
Duplexes and imbricate fans
A duplex is a set of thrust slices (horses) bounded by a floor thrust below and a roof thrust above.
| Duplex | Geometry |
|---|---|
| Hinterland-dipping | horses dip towards the hinterland; displacement on each slice less than slice length |
| Antiformal stack | horses stacked on top of each other; displacement about equal to slice length |
| Foreland-dipping | horses dip towards the foreland; displacement more than slice length |
An imbricate fan has many thrusts that splay from one sole thrust without a roof thrust, with displacement concentrated at the front (leading imbricate fan) or the back (trailing). Triangle zones form where a backthrust and forethrust meet at the front of a thrust belt.
Nappe, klippe and window: a nappe is a large allochthonous sheet moved far from its root. A klippe is an erosional remnant of the nappe resting on the autochthon; a window (fenster) is a hole eroded through the nappe exposing the rocks beneath.
Balanced sections
A cross-section is balanced if it can be restored to an undeformed state without gaps or overlaps. Two checks:
- Line-length balance: bed lengths are the same in deformed and restored sections (for parallel folds and thrusts).
- Area balance: cross-sectional area is conserved. With \( A \) the excess (uplifted) area above a reference level and \( S \) the shortening, the depth to detachment is
Shortening is \( e = (l - l_0)/l_0 \), negative for shortening.
The critical taper wedge
Davis, Suppe and Dahlen (1983), with later work by Dahlen, compared a fold–thrust belt to a wedge of soil pushed by a bulldozer. The wedge deforms internally until it reaches a critical taper: the sum of surface slope \( \alpha \) and décollement dip \( \beta \),
$$\boxed{\alpha + \beta = \text{critical taper}}$$which depends on the strength of the wedge material and the friction (and pore pressure) on the décollement.
- Subcritical wedge (taper too small): deforms internally, thickens (out-of-sequence thrusting, backthrusts) until the taper is restored.
- Critical wedge: slides along its base and grows forward by adding new thrusts at the front.
- Supercritical wedge (taper too large, for example when the base becomes weaker): slides stably and may extend at the top rather than shorten internally.
A weak base (salt, high pore pressure) gives a narrow taper; a strong base gives a steep wedge. Erosion at the surface keeps the wedge subcritical and promotes internal thrusting, linking climate to tectonics.
Strike-Slip Terrains
Riedel shears
In clay-cake experiments of a shear zone above a strike-slip fault, fractures develop in a regular order. With \( \phi \) the angle of internal friction (about 30°):
| Structure | Angle to the main fault | Sense |
|---|---|---|
| R (Riedel) shear | about \( \phi/2 \approx 15° \) | synthetic (same as main fault) |
| R′ (conjugate Riedel) | about \( 90° - \phi/2 \approx 75° \) | antithetic |
| P shear | about \( -\phi/2 \) (mirror of R) | synthetic, forms later, links R shears |
| T (tension) fractures | about 45° | opening, normal to the instantaneous extension |
| Y shears | parallel to the main fault | synthetic, form at large displacement |
| En echelon folds | axes at about 45° initially, rotating towards the fault | form in the shortening direction |
R and T fractures form an en echelon pattern whose orientation gives the shear sense. R shears lie between the fault trend and \( \sigma_1 \): in a dextral zone they are rotated clockwise from the fault trend, in a sinistral zone anticlockwise. When in doubt, sketch the zone, draw \( \sigma_1 \) at 45° to it in the shortening quadrant, and place R at about 30° to \( \sigma_1 \).
Bends and step-overs
| Fault sense | Step or bend | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Dextral | right-stepping | releasing: transtension, pull-apart basin, negative flower structure |
| Dextral | left-stepping | restraining: transpression, pop-up, push-up range, positive flower structure |
| Sinistral | left-stepping | releasing |
| Sinistral | right-stepping | restraining |
Flower structures (in seismic profiles across strike-slip faults): faults that converge downward into one steep strand. In a positive flower they have reverse separation and form an antiformal pop-up (transpression); in a negative flower they have normal separation and form a synformal sag (transtension).
Transform versus transcurrent faults
J. T. Wilson (1965) introduced transform faults: plate-boundary strike-slip faults that end at other plate boundaries (ridges, trenches) and transform one type of motion into another.
- In a ridge–ridge transform, the sense of slip is opposite to the apparent offset of the ridge. The transform is active only between the ridge segments; beyond them, the fracture zones are inactive scars.
- A transcurrent fault is a strike-slip fault within a plate or continental crust. Its displacement can die out at its tips, and the offset of markers gives its sense.
Examples of large continental strike-slip faults include the San Andreas (dextral, a transform), the North Anatolian (dextral), the Dead Sea Transform (sinistral), the Karakoram Fault (dextral) and the Chaman Fault (sinistral).
Inversion tectonics
- Positive inversion: a basin bounded by normal faults is shortened; the faults reactivate as reverse faults and basin fill is pushed up, giving harpoon structures (the hanging-wall syn-rift wedge uplifted into an anticline), with footwall shortcuts where new thrusts cut across the old footwall.
- Negative inversion: thrusts reactivated as normal faults, for example during orogenic collapse.
- The null point on an inverted fault separates net extension below from net contraction above.
Mantle Plumes
The hypothesis
J. T. Wilson (1963) explained the age-progressive Hawaiian chain as a plate moving over a fixed source of melt, a hotspot. W. J. Morgan (1971) proposed that hotspots are the surface expressions of mantle plumes: narrow columns of hot, buoyant material rising from deep in the mantle, possibly from the core–mantle boundary layer (D″).
The plume head–tail model (I. H. Campbell and R. W. Griffiths, 1990): a new plume has a large, roughly spherical head, followed by a narrow tail. When the head reaches the base of the lithosphere it flattens and melts on a large scale, producing a large igneous province (LIP) in a geologically short time. The tail then feeds a narrow, long-lived hotspot track.
Signatures of a plume
| Signature | Description |
|---|---|
| Age-progressive volcanic chain | ages increase away from the active hotspot, in the direction of plate motion |
| Topographic swell | broad dome of the order of 1,000 km across and about a kilometre high, supported by hot, buoyant mantle |
| Geoid high and gravity | swell is isostatically compensated by hot mantle |
| LIP at the start of the track | flood basalts erupted in a few Myr or less |
| Excess mantle temperature | estimates of about 100–300 °C above ambient |
| Geochemistry | ocean island basalts (OIB) enriched in incompatible elements; high \( ^3\text{He}/^4\text{He} \) in some hotspots, suggesting a less degassed source |
| Seismic tomography | low-velocity columns beneath some hotspots, imaged into the lower mantle in some models |
| Pre-volcanic uplift | predicted by the head model; tested in sediment records |
Hotspot track rate:
$$\boxed{v = \frac{\text{distance between two volcanoes}}{\text{age difference}}}$$1 km Myr\(^{-1}\) = 1 mm yr\(^{-1}\); so 100 km per Myr = 10 cm yr\(^{-1}\). The Hawaiian–Emperor bend (about 47 Ma) records a change in the direction of the Pacific plate’s motion relative to the hotspot, and possibly some motion of the hotspot itself.
Large igneous provinces linked to plumes (examples)
| LIP | Approximate age | Proposed plume / hotspot |
|---|---|---|
| Deccan Traps (India) | about 66 Ma (around the Cretaceous–Paleogene boundary) | Réunion; track through Chagos–Laccadive Ridge and Mascarene Plateau |
| Rajmahal Traps (eastern India) | about 118 Ma | Kerguelen; Ninetyeast Ridge as a later track |
| Siberian Traps | about 252 Ma (end-Permian) | Siberian |
| Central Atlantic Magmatic Province (CAMP) | about 201 Ma (end-Triassic) | linked to Pangea breakup |
| Paraná–Etendeka | early Cretaceous | Tristan da Cunha |
| Columbia River Basalts | mid-Miocene | Yellowstone |
| Ontong Java Plateau (oceanic) | early Cretaceous | debated |
Several LIPs coincide with mass extinctions (end-Permian with the Siberian Traps, end-Triassic with CAMP, end-Cretaceous with the Deccan Traps alongside the Chicxulub impact) and with continental breakup (CAMP and the central Atlantic; Paraná–Etendeka and the South Atlantic; Deccan and the separation of the Seychelles from India).
Plumes and continental breakup
Plume heads weaken the lithosphere and often produce domes with three rifts at about 120° (an RRR triple junction); two arms open into an ocean and the third fails, becoming an aulacogen. Afar, where the Red Sea, Gulf of Aden and East African Rift meet, is the modern example.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | With this | Difference |
|---|---|---|
| Listric fault | Planar rotational fault | curved, flattening with depth, rollover in hanging wall versus straight, rigid domino blocks |
| Thin-skinned | Thick-skinned | basement uninvolved, décollement versus basement involved, often inverted rift faults |
| Klippe | Window | isolated remnant of a nappe versus hole through a nappe |
| Transform fault | Transcurrent fault | plate boundary ending at other boundaries, slip opposite to ridge offset versus intraplate strike-slip |
| Fracture zone | Transform fault | inactive scar versus active segment between ridge offsets |
| Positive flower | Negative flower | transpression, reverse separation, antiform versus transtension, normal separation, synform |
| Pure-shear rifting | Simple-shear rifting | symmetric uniform thinning (McKenzie) versus asymmetric detachment (Wernicke) |
| Hotspot | Plume | the surface volcanic expression versus the proposed deep mantle upwelling |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for these notes.
Level 1: Foundation
- Practice. Which principal stress is vertical in a strike-slip regime?
- Practice. On a dextral fault, does a left step create a pull-apart basin or a push-up?
- Practice. What do you call an erosional remnant of a thrust sheet surrounded by the rocks it overlies?
Answers
- \( \sigma_2 \).
- A push-up (restraining bend, transpression). A right step would make a pull-apart.
- A klippe.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q4. In a domino-style rift, faults that initially dipped 60° now dip 40°. The stretching factor \( \beta \) is about:
(a) 1.17 (b) 1.35 (c) 1.50 (d) 1.73
Answer: (b)
\( \beta = \sin 60°/\sin 40° = 0.866/0.643 = 1.35 \). Option (d) is the value for a final dip of 30°.
Practice Q5. A marker bed in a balanced section is 40 km long when restored and spans 28 km today. The shortening is:
(a) −12% (b) −30% (c) −43% (d) −70%
Answer: (b)
\( e = (28 - 40)/40 = -0.30 \), that is 30% shortening. Option (c) divides by the deformed length.
Practice Q6. In a dextral strike-slip zone in rocks with \( \phi = 30° \), Riedel (R) shears form at about:
(a) 15° to the fault, synthetic (b) 45° to the fault, opening (c) 75° to the fault, antithetic (d) parallel to the fault
Answer: (a)
R shears lie at \( \phi/2 \approx 15° \) and are synthetic. 75° and antithetic describes R′; 45° opening describes T fractures; parallel describes Y shears.
Practice Q7. Two volcanoes on an oceanic hotspot track are 600 km apart, with ages 2 Ma and 8 Ma. The plate speed over the hotspot is:
(a) 1 cm yr\(^{-1}\) (b) 3 cm yr\(^{-1}\) (c) 7.5 cm yr\(^{-1}\) (d) 10 cm yr\(^{-1}\)
Answer: (d)
\( 600 \) km / 6 Myr = 100 km Myr\(^{-1}\) = 100 mm yr\(^{-1}\) = 10 cm yr\(^{-1}\). Option (c) divides by 8 Myr instead of the difference.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q8. A restored section across a thin-skinned fold–thrust belt shows 8 km of shortening above a single décollement. The area of rock uplifted above the regional level of a key bed is 24 km\(^2\). Which statements are correct?
- The depth from the key bed to the décollement is about 3 km.
- If the décollement is in evaporites, the critical taper will be smaller than over a strong basal shale, other things equal.
- Erosion of the wedge top, all else equal, tends to keep it subcritical and promote internal thrusting.
- In a piggy-back sequence, the frontal thrust is the oldest.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 true: \( d = A/S = 24/8 = 3 \) km (area balance).
- 2 true: a weak base gives a narrow (low-taper) wedge.
- 3 true: erosion lowers the surface slope, reducing taper, so the wedge thickens internally.
- 4 false: in-sequence thrusts propagate towards the foreland, so the frontal thrust is the youngest.
Practice Q9. A rift basin has continental crust thinned from 35 km to 25 km. Assuming uniform pure-shear stretching (McKenzie model), which statements are correct?
- \( \beta = 1.4 \).
- The mantle lithosphere was thinned by the same factor.
- Subsidence ends as soon as faulting stops.
- Upwelling asthenosphere under the rift causes the thermal subsidence that follows rifting, as it cools.
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 4 only
- 1 true: \( \beta = 35/25 = 1.4 \).
- 2 true: uniform stretching thins crust and mantle lithosphere equally.
- 3 false: after the initial fault-controlled subsidence, thermal subsidence continues for tens of Myr.
- 4 true: hot asthenosphere replaces thinned lithosphere; as it cools and contracts, the basin subsides further.
Practice Q10. A flood basalt province is studied. Which observations would support a plume-head origin?
- Most of the lava volume erupted within about 1–2 Myr.
- An age-progressive volcanic ridge extends from the province, ages increasing towards the province.
- Sediments below the basalts show evidence of regional uplift before eruption.
- The basalts were erupted at a subduction zone above a sinking slab.
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- 1 supports: rapid, voluminous eruption is the head signature.
- 2 supports: a tail track gets older towards the LIP (the LIP was the start of the track); the youngest end is the present hotspot. Deccan to Réunion is the Indian example.
- 3 supports: plume heads are predicted to cause uplift before volcanism.
- 4 does not: arc magmatism over a slab is a different setting.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Fact or formula |
|---|---|
| Anderson | \( \sigma_1 \) vertical normal; \( \sigma_3 \) vertical thrust; \( \sigma_2 \) vertical strike-slip |
| Extensional structures | grabens, half-grabens, domino blocks, listric faults, rollover, detachments, core complexes |
| Domino extension | \( \beta = \sin\theta_0/\sin\theta \); crust \( t_0/\beta \) |
| Rift models | McKenzie pure shear (symmetric, thermal subsidence); Wernicke simple shear (asymmetric) |
| Margins | volcanic (SDRs) versus magma-poor (exhumed mantle) |
| Thrust rules | cut up-section towards foreland; ramps and flats; piggy-back sequence; thin- versus thick-skinned |
| Thrust folds | fault-bend, fault-propagation, detachment |
| Duplexes | hinterland-dipping, antiformal stack, foreland-dipping; imbricate fans; triangle zones |
| Balancing | line length; area; depth to detachment \( d = A/S \) |
| Critical taper | \( \alpha + \beta \) set by wedge and base strength; weak base = narrow taper |
| Riedel | R about 15° synthetic; R′ about 75° antithetic; P mirror of R; T 45°; Y parallel |
| Step-overs | dextral + right step = releasing; dextral + left step = restraining |
| Flowers | positive = transpression; negative = transtension |
| Transform | slip opposite to ridge offset; fracture zones inactive |
| Inversion | positive (normal → reverse), harpoon structures; negative (reverse → normal) |
| Plumes | Wilson 1963, Morgan 1971; head → LIP, tail → track; swell, OIB, high \( ^3\text{He}/^4\text{He} \) |
| Indian LIPs | Deccan about 66 Ma (Réunion); Rajmahal about 118 Ma (Kerguelen) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Himalayan Orogeny and Supercontinents: compressional tectonics on the largest scale, and the cycles that assemble and break continents.
- Seismology Basics and Earth’s Internal Structure: the seismic evidence for the mantle in which plumes rise.
- Back to the Structural Geology and Geotectonics overview.