Axis Formation in Animals: Dictyostelium, Drosophila, Amphibians, Chick and the C. elegans Vulva
Dictyostelium aggregation, Drosophila maternal and segmentation genes, amphibian organiser, chick primitive streak and C. elegans vulval induction.
- 24 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: A Fly With Two Rear Ends
- Dictyostelium discoideum: Development Without an Embryo
- Drosophila: A Hierarchy of Gene Expression
- Amphibians: Cortical Rotation and the Organiser
- Chick: Gravity, the Streak and the Node
- C. elegans Vulva: Induction and Lateral Signalling
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Basic Concepts of Development — morphogens, induction, competence, lateral inhibition and the logic of loss- and gain-of-function experiments.
- Gametogenesis, Fertilisation and Early Animal Development — the egg, cleavage patterns and gastrulation movements that the axes are built on.
- Regulation of Gene Expression and Epigenetics — enhancers, repressors and translational control carry the Drosophila hierarchy.
- Transcription and RNA Processing — alternative splicing and 3′ UTR elements reappear in mRNA localisation.
The Hook: A Fly With Two Rear Ends
How CSIR NET asks it. Part B: match a gene to its class (maternal, gap, pair-rule, segment polarity, homeotic), predict the phenotype of a maternal mutant, name the organiser and its secreted proteins, match signals to vulval fates. Part C: read stripe-expression data from mutants and deduce regulatory interactions, interpret grafts and UV or LiCl treatments in amphibians, order genes in a pathway from double-mutant (epistasis) phenotypes, and count vulval cells.
Dictyostelium discoideum: Development Without an Embryo
Dictyostelium is a social amoeba. While food lasts, cells live alone and divide by mitosis. When starved, up to about a hundred thousand cells come together to form a multicellular organism. It shows, in a simple system, aggregation by chemotaxis, cell adhesion, cell sorting, proportion regulation and programmed cell death.
graph LR
A["Free-living amoebae
feed on bacteria"] -->|starvation| B["Aggregation
cAMP waves"]
B --> C["Mound
cell sorting"]
C --> D["Tipped mound"]
D --> E["Slug (grex)
migrates, phototaxis"]
E --> F["Culmination
stalk cells die,
spores form"]
F --> G["Fruiting body
spores germinate"]
G --> AAggregation by a relayed cAMP signal
- Starving cells begin to secrete cyclic AMP (cAMP) in pulses. Cells sense it with the G-protein-coupled receptor cAR1.
- Each cell that receives cAMP (1) moves toward the source (chemotaxis) and (2) makes and releases its own pulse through the adenylyl cyclase ACA, relaying the signal outward. Then it becomes briefly refractory (receptor adaptation), so the signal travels outward as a wave rather than back.
- Secreted and membrane-bound phosphodiesterase destroys cAMP between pulses, so gradients are sharp.
- The result is spiral or concentric waves and streams of cells flowing to an aggregation centre.
Adhesion
| Molecule | When | Property |
|---|---|---|
| gp24 (DdCAD-1) | Early aggregation | Ca²⁺-dependent |
| gp80 (contact site A, csA) | Later aggregation (streams) | Ca²⁺-independent, homophilic |
The slug and cell types
- The slug (grex) is polarised: the anterior tip, about a fifth of the cells, is made of prestalk cells; the posterior four-fifths are prespore cells. The tip acts as an organiser: it continues to emit cAMP pulses and leads migration toward light and warmth.
- cAMP promotes prespore gene expression. DIF-1 (differentiation-inducing factor, a chlorinated small molecule made by prespore cells) induces prestalk subtypes.
- Cells are biased toward a fate before they meet: cells starved at a particular phase of the cell cycle or with different nutritional history tend to become stalk or spore. They then sort out to the right position by differential chemotaxis and adhesion. Fate is therefore decided by a mix of bias and position, and proportions are regulated: cut a slug into pieces and each piece re-forms a correctly proportioned fruiting body.
- At culmination, prestalk cells form the stalk: they vacuolate, lay down cellulose walls and die (an autophagic form of cell death). The prespore cells are lifted on top and encapsulate as spores.
Drosophila: A Hierarchy of Gene Expression
The fly embryo specifies its axes in a syncytium, so transcription factors can diffuse between nuclei and act as morphogens directly. The whole pattern is laid down by a cascade that starts with maternal mRNAs in the egg.
Oogenesis sets up both axes
The oocyte sits in an egg chamber with 15 nurse cells (which supply mRNAs and proteins through ring canals) and a surrounding layer of follicle cells.
- Anterior–posterior. The oocyte nucleus sits at the posterior and secretes Gurken (a TGF-α-like ligand). It acts on Torpedo (the fly EGF receptor) in the posterior follicle cells, which signal back. The oocyte’s microtubules reorganise: minus ends toward the anterior, plus ends toward the posterior.
- Dorsal–ventral. The nucleus then moves to an anterior-dorsal position, and gurken mRNA stays with it. Gurken now signals to the dorsal follicle cells only, telling them they are dorsal.
The anterior–posterior maternal systems
| System | Key mRNA | Localisation | Function |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anterior | bicoid | Anterior pole (3′ UTR; Exuperantia, Swallow, Staufen, dynein on minus-end microtubules) | Bicoid protein forms an anterior-to-posterior gradient; activates hunchback, represses caudal translation |
| Posterior | oskar → nanos | Posterior pole (kinesin on plus-end microtubules; Oskar anchors nanos mRNA and organises pole plasm) | Nanos (with Pumilio) represses translation of maternal hunchback in the posterior, allowing abdomen formation |
| Terminal | torso (receptor, uniform) | Activated only at the poles, by a ligand processed with Torso-like from polar follicle cells | Activates tailless and huckebein; acropod and telson |
| Uniform maternal mRNAs | hunchback, caudal | Throughout the egg | Their proteins become graded by translational repression: Hunchback high anterior, Caudal high posterior |
Bicoid is the textbook morphogen: high concentrations activate head genes such as orthodenticle; lower concentrations activate hunchback. Adding extra copies of bicoid moves the head–thorax boundary (the cephalic furrow) posteriorly.
| Maternal mutant (mother homozygous) | Embryo phenotype |
|---|---|
| bicoid | No head or thorax; anterior replaced by posterior terminal structures |
| nanos | No abdomen (head and thorax normal) |
| oskar | No abdomen and no pole cells (no germ line) |
| torso (loss) | No acron and no telson (both ends) |
The zygotic segmentation hierarchy
graph TD
A["Maternal effect genes
bicoid, nanos, hunchback, caudal, torso"] --> B["Gap genes
hunchback, Kruppel, knirps, giant, tailless"]
B --> C["Pair-rule genes
even-skipped, hairy, runt, fushi tarazu, odd-paired..."]
C --> D["Segment polarity genes
engrailed, wingless, hedgehog, patched"]
A --> E["Homeotic selector genes
Antennapedia and bithorax complexes"]
B --> E
C --> E
D --> F["14 parasegments with
distinct identities"]
E --> F| Class | Expressed as | Mutant phenotype | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gap | Broad domains | Loss of a block of several contiguous segments | hunchback, Krüppel, knirps, giant, tailless |
| Pair-rule | 7 stripes | Loss of alternate segment-width regions (half the number of segments) | Primary: even-skipped, hairy, runt; secondary: fushi tarazu, odd-paired, paired |
| Segment polarity | 14 stripes | Part of each segment deleted and replaced by a mirror image of the rest | engrailed, wingless, hedgehog, patched |
| Homeotic (Hox) | Specific parasegments | One segment transformed into the identity of another | Ubx, Antp, Scr, Abd-B |
Segment polarity: making the boundary stable
- Cells expressing engrailed (a transcription factor) form the posterior compartment of each segment and secrete Hedgehog.
- Their anterior neighbours, receiving Hedgehog through Patched/Smoothened, keep making Wingless (a Wnt).
- Wingless signals back to keep engrailed on. This Wg–Hh positive feedback loop fixes the parasegment boundary between them.
- The parasegment (the unit of gene expression) is out of register with the visible segment by half a segment.
Homeotic selector genes
The fly Hox genes lie in two clusters on chromosome 3, together called the homeotic complex (HOM-C):
| Complex | Genes (3′ → 5′) | Region |
|---|---|---|
| Antennapedia complex | labial, proboscipedia, Deformed, Sex combs reduced, Antennapedia | Head and anterior thorax |
| Bithorax complex | Ultrabithorax, abdominal-A, Abdominal-B | Posterior thorax and abdomen |
- Colinearity: genes are arranged on the chromosome in the same order as the body regions they specify. In vertebrates (four clusters, Hoxa–d) 3′ genes are also expressed earlier and more anteriorly.
- Posterior prevalence: where several Hox genes are expressed, the more posterior gene usually dominates.
- Classic mutants: Antennapedia gain of function puts legs in place of antennae; Ultrabithorax loss of function turns the third thoracic segment into a copy of the second, giving a four-winged fly (halteres become wings).
- Hox proteins share a 60-amino-acid homeodomain (encoded by the 180-bp homeobox), a helix-turn-helix DNA-binding domain.
Dorsal–ventral axis: Toll and Dorsal
graph LR
A["Gurken from oocyte
to dorsal follicle cells"] --> B["Torpedo (EGFR) active
pipe repressed dorsally"]
B --> C["Pipe active only in
ventral follicle cells"]
C --> D["Protease cascade
Nudel, Gastrulation defective,
Snake, Easter"]
D --> E["Cleaved Spatzle
activates Toll ventrally"]
E --> F["Cactus degraded"]
F --> G["Dorsal protein enters
ventral nuclei"]- Dorsal (an NF-κB-family transcription factor) is made uniformly but enters nuclei in a ventral-to-dorsal gradient: highest in ventral nuclei, absent from dorsal nuclei. Cactus (an IκB homologue) holds Dorsal in the cytoplasm until Toll signalling degrades it.
- Targets read the gradient: highest Dorsal activates twist and snail (mesoderm); intermediate levels activate rhomboid (neuroectoderm); Dorsal represses decapentaplegic (dpp), zerknüllt and tolloid, which are therefore expressed dorsally.
- Dorsally, a Dpp (BMP) activity gradient, shaped by its antagonist Short gastrulation (Sog), specifies amnioserosa and dorsal ectoderm.
| Maternal mutant | Phenotype |
|---|---|
| Loss of dorsal, Toll, pipe or spätzle | Dorsalised: all nuclei behave as dorsal |
| Loss of cactus | Ventralised: Dorsal enters all nuclei |
| Loss of gurken or torpedo | Ventralised eggshell and embryo: dorsal follicle cells are not told they are dorsal, so pipe is expressed all round |
Amphibians: Cortical Rotation and the Organiser
Setting the dorsal–ventral axis
- The animal–vegetal axis is set during oogenesis: pigment and nucleus in the animal half, yolk and maternal mRNAs such as VegT and Vg1 in the vegetal half.
- Sperm entry (in the animal hemisphere) fixes the ventral side. Within the first cell cycle the cortex rotates about 30° relative to the inner cytoplasm, moving toward the sperm entry point, along parallel microtubules in the vegetal cortex. In some species this exposes a lighter grey crescent opposite the sperm entry point.
- Cortical rotation carries Dishevelled, GBP and Wnt11 mRNA from the vegetal pole toward the future dorsal side, opposite the sperm.
- On the dorsal side, β-catenin is protected from GSK3-dependent degradation and accumulates in the nuclei of dorsal cells.
The Nieuwkoop centre and the organiser
graph TD
A["Vegetal VegT and Vg1
Nodal-related proteins
(mesoderm and endoderm)"] --> C["Dorsal vegetal cells
Nieuwkoop centre
beta-catenin + Nodal high"]
B["Dorsal beta-catenin
(cortical rotation)"] --> C
C --> D["Siamois, Twin
with Smad2"]
D --> E["Spemann organiser
dorsal blastopore lip
goosecoid"]
E --> F["Secretes BMP antagonists
chordin, noggin, follistatin
and Wnt antagonists
cerberus, Dkk, Frzb"]
F --> G["Neural induction,
dorsalised mesoderm,
head formation"]- Mesoderm induction: Pieter Nieuwkoop showed that the animal cap (presumptive ectoderm) alone forms only epidermis; the vegetal cells alone form only yolky endoderm; placed together, the animal cells next to the vegetal ones form mesoderm. The inducers are Nodal-related TGF-β proteins (with Vg1 and activin-like activity), made under maternal VegT control.
- Nieuwkoop centre: the dorsal-most vegetal cells, where β-catenin and high Nodal signalling overlap. They do not form the organiser themselves; they induce the overlying dorsal marginal zone to become it, through the homeobox genes siamois and twin.
- The organiser (dorsal lip of the blastopore) expresses goosecoid, involutes first, becomes pharyngeal endoderm, head mesoderm, notochord (prechordal plate and chordamesoderm), and induces the neural tube and dorsalises neighbouring mesoderm into somites.
Neural induction: the default model
Ectoderm left alone wants to be neural. Dissociated animal-cap cells become neural tissue; intact caps become epidermis because they make BMP4, which instructs epidermis. The organiser induces the nervous system by blocking BMP:
| Organiser protein | Action |
|---|---|
| Noggin | Binds BMP4, BMP2 |
| Chordin | Binds BMPs (homologue of fly Sog) |
| Follistatin | Binds activin and BMPs |
| Cerberus | Binds Nodal, BMP and Wnt; induces head |
| Dickkopf (Dkk), Frzb | Block Wnt; needed for head formation |
| Nodal-related 3 (Xnr3) | Required for convergent extension |
Head formation needs both BMP and Wnt to be blocked; trunk needs BMP blocked but tolerates Wnt. Posteriorising signals (Wnt, FGF, retinoic acid) then pattern the neural plate from head to tail.
| Treatment | Result | Why |
|---|---|---|
| UV to the vegetal pole before first cleavage | Ventralised embryos (no dorsal axis; “belly piece”) | Microtubule array destroyed, no cortical rotation, no dorsal β-catenin |
| Tipping the UV-treated egg 90° | Axis rescued | Gravity-driven rotation moves the determinants |
| Lithium chloride at the 32-cell stage | Dorsalised embryos (large head, radial dorsal structures) | Li⁺ inhibits GSK3, so β-catenin is stabilised everywhere |
| Inject β-catenin or Wnt8 mRNA into ventral vegetal cells | Secondary axis | Ectopic Nieuwkoop centre |
| Deplete maternal β-catenin (antisense) | No dorsal axis | Loss of function |
Left–right asymmetry
Across vertebrates, Nodal is expressed in the left lateral plate mesoderm and activates the transcription factor Pitx2, which directs asymmetric heart looping and gut coiling. In mouse (and Xenopus, zebrafish), leftward fluid flow made by rotating motile cilia in the node (or its equivalent) breaks the symmetry. Mutations in ciliary dynein (left–right dynein, iv) randomise situs, which is why primary ciliary dyskinesia in humans can come with situs inversus (Kartagener syndrome).
Chick: Gravity, the Streak and the Node
| Axis | How it is set |
|---|---|
| Anterior–posterior | As the egg rotates in the shell gland, the blastoderm is tipped; the side that is higher becomes the posterior, marking the posterior marginal zone (PMZ). The PMZ, with Koller’s sickle, expresses Vg1 and Wnt8c and induces the primitive streak |
| Dorsal–ventral | The epiblast faces the albumen and becomes the dorsal side; the hypoblast faces the yolk and the ventral side |
| Left–right | Asymmetric gene expression around Hensen’s node: Shh on the left side of the node, then Nodal and Pitx2 in left lateral plate mesoderm. In chick the asymmetry arises from cell rearrangements around the node, not from ciliary flow |
- The hypoblast secretes Cerberus, which blocks Nodal and prevents the streak from forming early or forming more than one. As the hypoblast is displaced by the endoblast, Nodal signalling is freed and the streak forms at the posterior edge.
- Hensen’s node is the organiser: grafted to another embryo, it induces a second axis. It expresses chordin, goosecoid and other organiser genes.
- Neural induction in chick needs FGF signalling in addition to BMP inhibition; BMP block alone is not enough in the epiblast. This is a point where frog and chick differ.
C. elegans Vulva: Induction and Lateral Signalling
The hermaphrodite vulva, through which eggs are laid, forms from 6 vulval precursor cells (VPCs), P3.p to P8.p, lying in a row in the ventral epidermis. All six are competent and form an equivalence group: each can adopt any of three fates.
| Fate | Division products | Who adopts it normally |
|---|---|---|
| 1° (primary) | 8 cells, inner vulva | P6.p (nearest the anchor cell) |
| 2° (secondary) | 7 cells each, outer vulva | P5.p and P7.p |
| 3° (tertiary) | 2 cells each, which fuse with the large epidermal syncytium hyp7 | P3.p, P4.p, P8.p |
The vulva is therefore built from 8 + 7 + 7 = 22 cells.
graph TD
AC["Anchor cell (gonad)
secretes LIN-3 (EGF-like)"] -->|highest dose| P6["P6.p: LET-23 (EGFR)
LET-60 Ras, MAP kinase
1 degree fate"]
AC -->|lower dose| P57["P5.p, P7.p"]
P6 -->|"lateral signal: Delta-like
ligands (LAG-2, APX-1, DSL-1)"| P57
P57 --> S["LIN-12 (Notch) active
2 degree fate;
1 degree fate inhibited"]
O["P3.p, P4.p, P8.p
no signal"] --> T["3 degree fate
fuse with hyp7"]- Inductive signal. The anchor cell of the gonad secretes LIN-3, an EGF-like ligand. It binds the receptor tyrosine kinase LET-23 (EGFR) on VPCs and activates SEM-5 (Grb2) → LET-60 (Ras) → LIN-45 (Raf) → MEK-2 → MPK-1 (ERK), which acts on transcription factors such as LIN-1 and LIN-31.
- Graded induction plus lateral signalling. P6.p receives the most LIN-3 and becomes 1°. It then makes Delta-like ligands that activate LIN-12 (Notch) in P5.p and P7.p, which become 2° and are prevented from becoming 1° (lateral inhibition). This ensures that two adjacent 1° cells do not form.
- Inhibitory signal from hyp7. The synthetic multivulva (synMuv) genes, such as lin-15, keep hyp7 from expressing LIN-3. Loss of both synMuv classes lets hyp7 make LIN-3 everywhere.
Classic results
| Manipulation | Result | Lesson |
|---|---|---|
| Laser ablation of the anchor cell | Vulvaless: all six VPCs become 3° | The anchor cell is the inducer |
| Ablate P5.p–P7.p | P3.p, P4.p or P8.p, normally 3°, can now adopt vulval (1° or 2°) fates | VPCs are equivalent; fate depends on signal received, not lineage |
| lin-3 or let-23 loss of function | Vulvaless (Vul) | Ligand and receptor needed |
| let-60(gf) (activated Ras) | Multivulva (Muv): extra ventral protrusions | Ras activity is sufficient for induced fates |
| lin-15 (synMuv) loss | Multivulva | hyp7 makes LIN-3 ectopically |
| lin-12(lf) | No 2° fates; adjacent cells can both become 1° | Notch is needed for 2° fate |
| lin-12(gf) | All VPCs tend to 2° fate | Notch activation is sufficient for 2° |
Anchor cell choice: lateral inhibition first
Two equivalent gonadal cells (Z1.ppp and Z4.aaa) both can become the anchor cell (AC) or a ventral uterine (VU) cell. Small random differences are amplified by LIN-12/Notch signalling (ligand LAG-2): the cell that ends with more LIN-12 activity becomes VU; the other becomes the AC. In lin-12(lf) both become ACs; in lin-12(gf) both become VU and no AC forms, so the animal is vulvaless.
Reading epistasis
For a linear pathway of positive regulators, the double mutant shows the phenotype of the downstream mutation. For example, lin-3(lf) (Vul) combined with let-60(gf) (Muv) is Muv: Ras acts downstream of the ligand and, if constitutively active, does not need it. This logic, applied to many vulval mutants, ordered the RTK–Ras–MAPK pathway before the biochemistry was known.
Memory Tricks
- UV = Underdorsal (ventralised); LiCl = Lots of dorsal (dorsalised).
- Vulva = 8 + 7 + 7 = 22. P6.p is 1°; P5.p and P7.p are 2°; the rest 3°.
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Bicoid: transcription factor (activates hunchback) and translational repressor of caudal | vs | Nanos: translational repressor of maternal hunchback (with Pumilio) |
| bicoid mother: embryo lacks head and thorax | vs | nanos mother: embryo lacks abdomen |
| Segment (visible unit) | vs | Parasegment (unit of gene expression; out of register by half a segment) |
| Dorsal protein gradient (ventral nuclei high) | vs | Dpp activity (dorsal high) |
| Toll/ dorsal loss: dorsalised | vs | cactus/ gurken loss: ventralised |
| Nieuwkoop centre (dorsal vegetal; induces organiser) | vs | Spemann organiser (dorsal marginal zone; induces neural tube) |
| UV: ventralised frog | vs | LiCl: dorsalised frog |
| Hensen’s node (chick organiser) | vs | Koller’s sickle (initiates the streak) |
| 1° vulval fate (EGF/Ras, 8 cells) | vs | 2° vulval fate (Notch/LIN-12, 7 cells) |
| cAMP (prespore, aggregation) in Dictyostelium | vs | DIF-1 (prestalk) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which molecule do starving Dictyostelium cells use as a chemoattractant?
- How many stripes does a Drosophila pair-rule gene show?
- Which vulval precursor cell normally adopts the 1° fate?
Answers
- Cyclic AMP, relayed from cell to cell.
- Seven stripes.
- P6.p, the VPC closest to the anchor cell.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). In a Drosophila embryo from a mother homozygous for a null cactus allele, the Dorsal protein will be:
- (a) absent from all nuclei
- (b) in all nuclei around the circumference
- (c) only in dorsal nuclei
- (d) in a normal ventral-to-dorsal gradient
Answer and explanation
(b). Cactus retains Dorsal in the cytoplasm. Without Cactus, Dorsal enters every nucleus, and the embryo is ventralised (mesoderm and neuroectoderm fates expanded, dorsal fates lost).
Q2 (practice). In a Xenopus experiment, animal-cap explants are dissociated into single cells and kept dispersed for several hours before reaggregation. They form neural tissue. Which statement best explains this?
- (a) Dissociation activates Wnt signalling, which induces neural fate.
- (b) Dispersal dilutes BMP signalling between cells, and ectoderm adopts its default neural fate.
- (c) Dissociation induces Nodal expression and mesoderm.
- (d) Single cells are not competent to respond to any signal.
Answer and explanation
(b). In intact caps, cells exchange BMP4, which instructs epidermal fate. Dispersing the cells dilutes the secreted BMPs, so cells follow the default neural pathway. The organiser achieves the same result in the embryo by secreting BMP antagonists.
Q3 (practice). In the Drosophila blastoderm, an eve stripe 2 enhancer–lacZ reporter is examined in different mutant backgrounds. In which mutant would the reporter domain extend further posteriorly?
- (a) giant
- (b) Krüppel
- (c) bicoid
- (d) hunchback
Answer and explanation
(b). Krüppel, expressed posterior to stripe 2, represses the stripe 2 enhancer and sets its posterior border. Without Krüppel, the stripe expands posteriorly. Loss of giant would expand it anteriorly; loss of the activators bicoid or hunchback would weaken or abolish it.
Q4 (practice). In C. elegans, a lin-12 loss-of-function hermaphrodite has two anchor cells. The most likely reason is:
- (a) LIN-3 is overexpressed
- (b) Lateral inhibition between Z1.ppp and Z4.aaa fails, so both adopt the default AC fate
- (c) The VPCs have become 2°
- (d) Both cells receive EGF signal from hyp7
Answer and explanation
(b). The AC/VU choice depends on LIN-12/Notch: the cell with more LIN-12 activity becomes VU. Without LIN-12 neither can become VU, so both become ACs. Notch signalling is a juxtacrine lateral-inhibition mechanism.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). Consider these vulval mutants of C. elegans:
| Genotype | Phenotype |
|---|---|
| lin-3(lf) | Vulvaless |
| let-23(lf) | Vulvaless |
| let-60(gf) | Multivulva |
| lin-15(lf) | Multivulva |
| let-23(lf); lin-15(lf) | Vulvaless |
| let-60(gf); let-23(lf) | Multivulva |
Which order of action is consistent with these data?
- (a) lin-15 → let-60 → let-23
- (b) lin-15 ⊣ (LIN-3 production) → let-23 → let-60
- (c) let-60 → let-23 → lin-15
- (d) let-23 and lin-15 act in independent parallel pathways with no epistasis
Answer and worked solution
(b).
- let-23(lf); lin-15(lf) is Vulvaless, the phenotype of let-23. So the receptor acts downstream of the process controlled by lin-15: removing the hyp7 brake on LIN-3 cannot cause induction without the receptor. lin-15 therefore acts upstream, as a negative regulator of ligand production.
- let-60(gf); let-23(lf) is Multivulva, the phenotype of activated Ras. So Ras acts downstream of LET-23: once Ras is on, the receptor is dispensable.
- Combining: lin-15 ⊣ LIN-3 → LET-23 → LET-60. Option (b).
Q2 (practice). Three manipulations on early Xenopus embryos:
(i) The vegetal hemisphere of a fertilised egg is UV-irradiated before first cleavage. (ii) Embryos from (i) are injected at the 4-cell stage with β-catenin mRNA into one vegetal blastomere. (iii) A normal embryo is injected with β-catenin mRNA into a ventral vegetal blastomere at the 32-cell stage.
Which set of outcomes is expected?
- (a) (i) ventralised; (ii) one dorsal axis restored; (iii) two dorsal axes
- (b) (i) dorsalised; (ii) no axis; (iii) one axis
- (c) (i) ventralised; (ii) no axis; (iii) one axis
- (d) (i) normal; (ii) two axes; (iii) ventralised
Answer and worked solution
(a).
- (i) UV destroys the vegetal microtubule array, so no cortical rotation, no dorsal β-catenin, no Nieuwkoop centre: ventralised embryo with no axis.
- (ii) β-catenin is downstream of cortical rotation. Supplying it in one vegetal cell creates a Nieuwkoop centre there, so one axis is restored (wherever it was injected).
- (iii) The normal embryo already has its own dorsal side; ectopic ventral β-catenin creates a second Nieuwkoop centre and a secondary axis: two axes (twinning).
Q3 (practice). Drosophila females carrying different numbers of functional bicoid copies (1, 2, 4 and 6) were crossed, and the position of the cephalic furrow in their embryos was measured as % egg length from the anterior pole (0% = anterior tip). Results: 1 copy → 25%; 2 copies → 33%; 4 copies → 40%; 6 copies → 45%. Assume an exponential Bicoid gradient \(C(x) = C_0 e^{-x/\lambda}\) with \(C_0\) proportional to gene copy number, and a fixed threshold for the furrow.
(i) From the 2-copy and 4-copy data, estimate λ in % egg length. (ii) Predict the furrow position for 6 copies using this λ and compare with the observed value. (iii) What conclusion is justified?
Answer and worked solution
- With a fixed threshold, doubling \(C_0\) shifts the boundary by \(\lambda\ln 2\). Shift from 2 to 4 copies = 40 − 33 = 7% → \(\lambda = 7/\ln 2 = 7/0.693 \approx\) 10.1% egg length.
- From 2 to 6 copies, \(C_0\) triples: predicted shift = \(\lambda\ln 3 = 10.1 \times 1.099 \approx 11.1\%\), so predicted position ≈ 33 + 11.1 = 44.1%. Observed 45%: close agreement.
- Check 1 copy: predicted shift = \(\lambda\ln 0.5 = -7\%\) → 26%; observed 25%. All four points fit a single exponential gradient read at a fixed threshold. Conclusion: the position of the head–thorax boundary is set in a dose-dependent manner by Bicoid, consistent with Bicoid acting as a morphogen. (The data are hypothetical, chosen to illustrate the calculation; real measurements also show some buffering.)
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Dictyostelium aggregation | cAMP pulses via cAR1, relayed by adenylyl cyclase ACA; phosphodiesterase sharpens waves |
| Dictyostelium fates | Anterior prestalk (DIF-1) about one-fifth; posterior prespore (cAMP); stalk cells die |
| Fly A-P maternal | bicoid anterior (head, thorax), oskar/nanos posterior (abdomen, germ cells), torso termini |
| Fly D-V maternal | Gurken → Torpedo dorsally ⊣ Pipe; ventral Spätzle → Toll → Cactus degraded → Dorsal nuclear |
| Dorsal targets | twist, snail (mesoderm); rhomboid (neuroectoderm); represses dpp, zen, tolloid |
| Gap genes | hunchback, Krüppel, knirps, giant, tailless |
| Pair-rule | 7 stripes; eve, hairy, runt, ftz |
| eve stripe 2 | On: Bicoid, Hunchback; off: Giant (anterior), Krüppel (posterior) |
| Segment polarity | 14 stripes; engrailed + Hh ↔ Wingless loop at parasegment boundary |
| Hox (fly) | lab, pb, Dfd, Scr, Antp | Ubx, abd-A, Abd-B; colinear |
| Frog dorsal axis | Cortical rotation 30°, Dishevelled/Wnt11 → β-catenin dorsal |
| Nieuwkoop centre | Dorsal vegetal; β-catenin + Nodal → siamois, twin |
| Organiser products | goosecoid; chordin, noggin, follistatin (BMP); cerberus, Dkk, Frzb (Wnt) |
| UV vs LiCl | Ventralised vs dorsalised |
| Chick | Higher side = posterior; Koller’s sickle, Vg1/Wnt8c; hypoblast Cerberus blocks streak; Hensen’s node |
| Left–right | Nodal → Pitx2 on left; nodal cilia flow in mouse |
| Vulva | Anchor cell LIN-3 → LET-23 → Ras → MAPK; 1° P6.p (8 cells), 2° P5.p, P7.p (7 each), 3° fuse with hyp7 |
| Vulva mutants | AC ablated, lin-3, let-23: Vul; let-60(gf), lin-15: Muv |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Organogenesis in Animals — lens induction, limb development and regeneration, neurons, metamorphosis and sex determination.
- Basic Concepts of Development — morphogen thresholds and the French flag model behind Bicoid.
- Regulation of Gene Expression and Epigenetics — how enhancers integrate activators and repressors.
- Developmental Biology chapter overview