Skip to content

Basic Concepts: Potency, Specification, Induction and Stem Cells

Potency, commitment, specification vs determination, induction, competence, morphogens, fate maps, stem cells, genomic equivalence, imprinting, transgenics.

  • 24 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 19 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: One Nucleus, a Whole Frog
  3. Development in One Paragraph
  4. Potency: What a Cell Could Become
  5. Commitment: Specification and Determination
  6. Induction and Competence
  7. Morphogens and Positional Information
  8. Cell Fate, Fate Maps and Lineage
  9. Stem Cells
  10. Genomic Equivalence
  11. Genomic Imprinting
  12. Mutants and Transgenics: How Developmental Genes Are Found
  13. Memory Tricks
  14. Don’t Confuse
  15. Common Mistakes
  16. Practice
  17. Quick Revision Table
  18. Key Takeaways
  19. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: One Nucleus, a Whole Frog

How CSIR NET asks it. Part B: define potency classes, distinguish specification from determination, identify mosaic vs regulative development, match morphogens and inducers to systems, pick the imprinted gene or the syndrome. Part C: read transplant and isolation experiments (“the cells formed X when moved to Y; were they specified or determined?”), predict offspring phenotypes for imprinted alleles, and design or interpret knockout, rescue and reporter experiments.


Development in One Paragraph

Development turns one cell into an organism through five overlapping processes: cell proliferation, cell differentiation (cells acquire distinct structures and functions), pattern formation (differentiated cells are placed in an ordered spatial arrangement), morphogenesis (tissues change shape through cell movement, adhesion, growth and death) and growth. Behind all five lies differential gene expression: the same genome read differently in different cells.

Potency: What a Cell Could Become

Potency is the full range of cell types a cell can give rise to.

PotencyCan formExamples
TotipotentEvery cell type of the embryo and the extra-embryonic tissues (a whole organism)Zygote; early mammalian blastomeres; most living plant cells (a single carrot phloem cell regenerated a whole plant in Steward’s experiments)
PluripotentAll three germ layers and germ cells, but not trophoblastInner cell mass (ICM), embryonic stem (ES) cells, induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells, epiblast
MultipotentSeveral cell types within one lineage or tissueHaematopoietic stem cells (all blood cells), neural stem cells, mesenchymal stromal cells, neural crest
OligopotentA few closely related typesCommon myeloid progenitor, common lymphoid progenitor
UnipotentOne cell type (while still self-renewing)Spermatogonial stem cells (sperm only), epidermal basal cells in some models

Potency normally narrows as development proceeds (Waddington’s picture of a ball rolling down a branching “epigenetic landscape” into valleys). Experiments such as nuclear transfer and iPS reprogramming push the ball back up the hill.

Commitment: Specification and Determination

Commitment is the process by which a cell’s fate becomes restricted. It has two stages, and the difference between them is the most-tested idea in this topic.

StageDefinitionTestReversible?
SpecificationThe cell will follow its normal fate when isolated in a neutral environment (a dish, or a culture medium with no inducers)Isolate the cell or tissueYes: placed among other cells, it can be redirected
DeterminationThe cell follows its fate even when transplanted into a different region of the embryoTransplant it heterotopicallyNo (under normal conditions)
DifferentiationThe cell expresses the specialised proteins and structure of its type (haemoglobin, crystallins, myosin)Look for markersUsually terminal

The order is always specification → determination → differentiation. A determined cell need not look different yet; determination is a state of the cell, recognised only by experiment.

graph LR
    A["Uncommitted cell"] --> B["Specified
keeps fate in isolation
(neutral environment)"] B --> C["Determined
keeps fate after
heterotopic transplant"] C --> D["Differentiated
cell-type-specific
proteins made"] B -. "can be re-specified
by new neighbours" .-> A

Three ways to specify a cell

ModeMechanismHallmark experimentTypical organisms
Autonomous (“mosaic”)Cell inherits cytoplasmic determinants (mRNAs, proteins) partitioned at cleavageRemove a blastomere → the embryo lacks exactly what that blastomere would have madeTunicates (ascidians), molluscs, nematodes (largely)
Conditional (“regulative”)Fate depends on interactions with neighbours and positionRemove or move cells → others change fate and compensateVertebrates, sea urchins (most cells)
SyncytialNuclei in a common cytoplasm read gradients of transcription factors before cells formManipulate maternal gradients → nuclei change fateInsects (Drosophila)

Classic experiments.

  • Ascidian yellow crescent (Conklin): the yellow-pigmented cytoplasm of the tunicate egg segregates into the cells that form tail muscle. Blastomeres that inherit it make muscle even in isolation; the muscle determinant was later identified as the maternal mRNA macho-1.
  • Roux (frog): destroying one of two blastomeres with a hot needle gave a half-embryo. He read this as mosaic development, but the dead cell was still attached, so the remaining cell “did not know” it was alone.
  • Driesch (sea urchin): separating the blastomeres of a 2-cell or 4-cell embryo gave complete, smaller larvae from each cell: regulative development.
  • Twins and chimeras: separating early mammalian blastomeres gives identical twins; aggregating two morulae gives one normal-sized chimeric mouse. Both prove regulative development.

Induction and Competence

Induction is the interaction by which one group of cells (the inducer) changes the fate of another (the responder). Two ideas complete it:

  • Competence: the ability of a tissue to respond to an inductive signal. It requires the right receptors, signal transducers and transcription factors, and it is time-limited. Example: only head ectoderm expressing Pax6 is competent to form lens when contacted by the optic vesicle.
  • Instructive vs permissive induction: an instructive signal decides which fate is chosen (without it the responder would take another fate). A permissive signal only allows a fate already specified to be expressed (for example, an extracellular matrix or a survival factor).
TermMeaningExample
Primary embryonic inductionInduction of the main body axis and nervous systemSpemann–Mangold organiser (dorsal blastopore lip) inducing a secondary axis
Reciprocal inductionInducer and responder induce each otherUreteric bud and metanephric mesenchyme in the kidney; optic vesicle and lens
Sequential (cascade) inductionOne induced tissue becomes the inducer for the nextOptic vesicle → lens → cornea
Homeogenetic inductionInduced tissue induces the same fate in neighboursSpread of neural plate character
Lateral inhibitionA cell that adopts a fate inhibits neighbours from doing the sameNotch–Delta in Drosophila neuroblasts, C. elegans anchor cell choice

In 1924 Hans Spemann and Hilde Mangold grafted the dorsal blastopore lip of one newt gastrula onto the ventral side of another, using donor and host of different pigmentation. The host formed a second body axis, and the pigment showed that most of the secondary axis came from host cells that had been induced. The graft itself contributed mainly notochord. This is the defining organiser experiment; Spemann received the Nobel Prize in 1935.

How signals travel

ModeHowFamilies and examples
ParacrineDiffusible factors act over a few to tens of cell diametersFGF (receptor tyrosine kinases), Hedgehog (Patched/Smoothened), Wnt (Frizzled, β-catenin), TGF-β superfamily (BMPs, Nodal, activin, Dpp; Smad transcription factors)
JuxtacrineMembrane-bound ligand on one cell, receptor on the neighbourNotch–Delta/Serrate, ephrin–Eph, cadherins
MatrixExtracellular matrix molecules bind integrinsFibronectin, laminin
Gap junctionsSmall molecules move directly between cellsConnexins; left–right signalling in some embryos

The cell-signalling machinery behind these pathways (receptors, second messengers, kinase cascades) is the subject of the cell-communication unit; here we use them as tools.

Morphogens and Positional Information

A morphogen is a diffusible substance whose concentration gradient specifies different cell fates at different concentrations: cells read their position by the dose they receive, without needing direct contact with the source. Lewis Wolpert’s French flag model captures the logic: a source at one end of a row of cells creates a gradient; cells above a high threshold become “blue”, between thresholds “white”, below the lower threshold “red”. The same pattern then forms whatever the size of the field.

$$C(x) = C_0\,e^{-x/\lambda}\qquad\Rightarrow\qquad x_{\text{threshold}} = \lambda\,\ln\!\frac{C_0}{C_T}$$

For an exponential gradient with length constant λ, a cell switches fate where \(C(x)\) falls to its threshold \(C_T\). Doubling \(C_0\) moves every boundary away from the source by \(\lambda\ln 2\).

MorphogenSystemRead-out
Bicoid (transcription factor in a syncytium)Drosophila anterior–posterior axishunchback and head genes at high dose
Dorsal (nuclear gradient of an NF-κB-like factor)Drosophila dorsal–ventral axistwist, snail (mesoderm) at highest ventral levels
Dpp / BMPDrosophila wing disc, vertebrate dorsal–ventral axisspalt, optomotor-blind; ventral fates in vertebrates
Sonic hedgehogVertebrate neural tube (from notochord, floor plate), limb (ZPA)Ventral neuron types; posterior digit identity
Activin / NodalXenopus mesodermAnimal-cap cells express Xbra at low and goosecoid at high doses
Retinoic acidVertebrate hindbrain, limb, regenerationPosterior or proximal identity

Cell Fate, Fate Maps and Lineage

  • Fate: what a cell normally becomes in undisturbed development. It says nothing about what the cell could become (potency) or whether it is committed.
  • Fate map: a diagram of the embryo showing what each region will become. Vogt made the first amphibian fate maps with vital dyes (Nile blue sulphate, neutral red). Modern maps use injected fluorescent dextrans, DiI, or genetic labels.
  • Lineage tracing: following the descendants of a single cell. Genetic methods (Cre-mediated recombination of a reporter, “Brainbow”, barcoding) give permanent heritable labels.
  • Invariant lineage of C. elegans: Sulston and colleagues traced every division by microscopy. The adult hermaphrodite has 959 somatic nuclei; 131 additional cells generated during development die by programmed cell death (1,090 generated in all). Because the lineage is invariant, any cell can be named and ablated with a laser to test what it does.

Stem Cells

A stem cell can self-renew (make more of itself) and produce differentiated progeny. It usually divides asymmetrically (one stem cell + one committed daughter) or, across a population, through population asymmetry (some divisions give two stem cells, others two committed cells).

ClassSourcePotencyNotes
Embryonic stem (ES) cellsICM of the blastocystPluripotentMouse ES cells derived in 1981; human ES cells in 1998. Maintained by Oct4, Sox2, Nanog
Embryonic germ cellsPrimordial germ cellsPluripotent
Adult (somatic) stem cellsBone marrow, gut crypts, skin, brainMultipotent or unipotentLive in a niche
iPS cellsReprogrammed somatic cellsPluripotentTakahashi and Yamanaka (2006), mouse fibroblasts, with Oct3/4, Sox2, Klf4, c-Myc
Plant meristem cellsShoot and root apical meristemsPluripotentWUSCHEL/CLAVATA (shoot) and WOX5 (root) maintain them

The niche. A stem cell niche is the microenvironment that keeps stem cells undifferentiated: supporting cells, matrix and short-range signals. In the Drosophila ovary, germline stem cells sit next to cap cells that secrete Dpp; a daughter displaced one cell away from the cap cells loses Dpp and differentiates. In the gut, Wnt from Paneth cells and surrounding stroma maintains Lgr5⁺ crypt stem cells.

Genomic Equivalence

Genomic equivalence is the principle that every somatic cell nucleus contains the same complete genome as the zygote. Differentiation is therefore controlled by which genes are expressed, not by which genes are present.

Evidence for it:

  • Nuclear transfer (cloning): Briggs and King transplanted blastula nuclei into enucleated Rana pipiens eggs (1952) and obtained tadpoles; nuclei from later stages supported development less often. Gurdon obtained fertile Xenopus adults from tadpole intestinal nuclei. Dolly the sheep (Wilmut and colleagues, reported 1997) came from the nucleus of an adult mammary gland cell.
  • Plant regeneration: single differentiated cells form whole plants.
  • Polytene chromosomes: the same bands are present in different larval tissues, but different bands are “puffed” (transcribed) in different tissues and stages.
  • Molecular hybridisation: globin genes are present (but silent) in non-erythroid cells.

Known exceptions (important for “which is not an example” questions):

ExceptionWhat happens
Chromatin diminutionIn Parascaris (Ascaris), somatic cells discard parts of their chromosomes; only the germ line keeps the full genome (Boveri)
V(D)J recombinationB and T lymphocytes rearrange and delete parts of their immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor genes
Gene amplificationDrosophila follicle cells amplify chorion genes; amphibian oocytes amplify rRNA genes
Loss of nucleusMammalian erythrocytes, lens fibre cells, keratinocytes, sieve tube elements in plants
EndoreduplicationPolytene and polyploid cells (salivary glands, trophoblast giant cells, plant endosperm) change copy number, not content

Notice that the failure of most late nuclei to support development in early cloning experiments did not disprove genomic equivalence; it reflected how hard it is to reprogram chromatin (DNA methylation, histone marks) quickly.

Genomic Imprinting

Genomic imprinting is parent-of-origin-specific gene expression: for an imprinted gene only the allele from one parent is expressed, while the other is silenced epigenetically. It is a clear case where the genome is equivalent but the epigenome is not.

The key experiment. In mouse, McGrath and Solter and Surani’s group (mid-1980s) built zygotes with two maternal pronuclei (gynogenetic) or two paternal pronuclei (androgenetic) by pronuclear transplantation. Neither developed to term:

  • Gynogenetic / parthenogenetic embryos: relatively good embryo, poor extra-embryonic tissue (placenta, yolk sac).
  • Androgenetic embryos: poor embryo, extensive trophoblast.

Conclusion: the maternal and paternal genomes are not equivalent; mammals need one of each.

Mechanism.

  • DNA methylation of CpG-rich imprinting control regions (ICRs) is set in the germ line (by DNMT3A with DNMT3L), differently in sperm and eggs.
  • After fertilisation, imprints resist the genome-wide demethylation of the early embryo.
  • In primordial germ cells, imprints are erased and then re-established according to the sex of the embryo, so a male passes on paternal imprints at all loci regardless of which parent he got each allele from.
LocusExpressed alleleMechanism / effect
Igf2 (growth factor)PaternalOn the maternal chromosome, unmethylated ICR binds CTCF, an insulator that blocks downstream enhancers from reaching Igf2, so enhancers act on H19 instead
H19 (non-coding RNA)MaternalPaternal ICR is methylated: no CTCF, enhancers reach Igf2, H19 silenced
Igf2r (clearance receptor for IGF2)MaternalPaternal copy silenced by the Airn non-coding RNA
Human 15q11–q13MixedLoss of paternal expression → Prader–Willi syndrome; loss of maternal UBE3A expression → Angelman syndrome

The parental conflict (kinship) hypothesis explains the pattern: paternally expressed genes tend to promote fetal growth and maternal resource transfer (Igf2), while maternally expressed genes tend to restrain it (Igf2r, H19). Imprinting also exists in flowering plants, mainly in the endosperm (see Plant Reproduction, Double Fertilisation and Seed Development).

Mutants and Transgenics: How Developmental Genes Are Found

Forward genetics: phenotype first

Mutagenise (EMS, X-rays, transposons), screen for an abnormal phenotype, then find the gene.

  • Christiane Nüsslein-Volhard and Eric Wieschaus screened Drosophila for mutations that alter the larval cuticle pattern and found the gap, pair-rule and segment-polarity classes. With Edward Lewis (homeotic genes of the bithorax complex) they received the 1995 Nobel Prize.
  • Large screens followed in zebrafish, C. elegans and Arabidopsis (embryo-pattern mutants such as gnom and monopteros).
  • Maternal-effect screens need an extra generation: the mutant phenotype appears in the offspring of homozygous mutant mothers.
Mutation typeEffectDevelopmental example
Loss of function (amorph, hypomorph)Gene product absent or reduced; usually recessivebithorax-type Ubx loss → haltere-to-wing transformation
Gain of function (hypermorph, neomorph, ectopic)Product overactive or in the wrong place; often dominantAntennapedia dominant alleles → legs on the head
Dominant negativeMutant protein poisons the wild-type oneTruncated receptor lacking a kinase domain
HomeoticOne body part transformed into anotherAntp, Ubx; floral apetala, agamous
Conditional (temperature-sensitive)Defect only at restrictive temperatureUsed to find the time a gene is needed (temperature-shift experiments)

Reverse genetics: gene first

ToolWhat it doesOrganism
Knockout by homologous recombination in ES cellsReplace a gene with a disrupted copy; ES cells → chimera → germline transmissionMouse; Capecchi, Evans and Smithies, Nobel 2007
CRISPR–Cas9Guide RNA directs Cas9 to cut; repair by NHEJ (indels) or HDR (precise edit)Almost all organisms
RNA interferencedsRNA → siRNA → mRNA degradation (knockdown)C. elegans (feeding), Drosophila, plants
Morpholino oligonucleotidesBlock translation or splicing (knockdown)Xenopus, zebrafish
Cre–loxPCre recombinase excises DNA between loxP sites; tissue-specific or tamoxifen-inducible (CreER)Conditional knockouts in mouse
GAL4–UASGAL4 driver line expresses the yeast activator in chosen cells; UAS line carries the gene of interestDrosophila (misexpression, RNAi)
FLP–FRT mosaicsMitotic recombination makes homozygous mutant clones in a heterozygous animalDrosophila
P-element transformationTransposon-based germline transgenesisDrosophila
Agrobacterium T-DNAInsertional mutagenesis or transgene deliveryArabidopsis (floral dip), crop plants
Reporter genesGFP, lacZ (β-galactosidase), GUS (β-glucuronidase in plants), luciferase fused to an enhancer or a proteinAll

Three experiment types and what they prove: loss of function shows a gene is necessary; gain of function / ectopic expression shows it is sufficient; rescue (restoring the gene in a mutant) proves the phenotype is caused by that gene. Part C questions often give one of these and ask what can or cannot be concluded.


Memory Tricks

  • Imprinting tug-of-war: Paternal genes Pack the baby (Igf2); maternal genes moderate it (H19, Igf2r).
  • Necessary, sufficient, specific: loss of function, gain of function, rescue.

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Fate: what a cell normally becomesvsPotency: everything it could become
Specification: fate kept in a neutral environment, reversiblevsDetermination: fate kept after transplant, irreversible
Totipotent: embryo + extra-embryonic tissuesvsPluripotent: embryo only (no trophoblast)
Autonomous (mosaic): cytoplasmic determinantsvsConditional (regulative): neighbour interactions
Instructive induction: chooses the fatevsPermissive induction: allows a chosen fate to proceed
Inducer competence (not a term)vsResponder competence: ability of the responder to respond
Morphogen: dose-dependent fates, direct actionvsInducer: may give one fate only, often by contact
Genomic imprinting: parent-of-origin allele silencingvsMaternal effect: mother’s genotype decides phenotype
Knockout (gene destroyed)vsKnockdown (mRNA reduced: RNAi, morpholino)
Gynogenetic mouse embryo: poor placentavsAndrogenetic mouse embryo: poor embryo, much trophoblast

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which test distinguishes determination from specification?
  2. Name the four factors used by Takahashi and Yamanaka to make iPS cells.
  3. In mouse, which allele of Igf2 is normally expressed?
Answers
  1. Heterotopic transplantation. A determined cell keeps its fate in a new location; a specified cell may change.
  2. Oct3/4, Sox2, Klf4 and c-Myc.
  3. The paternal allele.

Level 2: Part B Style

Q1 (practice). Presumptive neural ectoderm from an early gastrula is grafted into the presumptive epidermis region of another early gastrula and forms epidermis. The same tissue taken from a late gastrula and grafted the same way forms neural tissue. The best conclusion is:

  • (a) The tissue was determined in the early gastrula.
  • (b) The tissue was not yet determined in the early gastrula but was determined by the late gastrula.
  • (c) The tissue was autonomously specified by cytoplasmic determinants at both stages.
  • (d) The host epidermis lacks competence at both stages.
Answer and explanation

(b). At the early stage the graft followed its new surroundings, so it was not determined. By the late gastrula it kept its original fate after heterotopic transplantation, which is the definition of determination. This is the classic Spemann newt transplant result. (c) is wrong because a fate that changes with position is conditional, not autonomous.

Q2 (practice). Which of the following is not consistent with genomic equivalence?

  • (a) Adult frogs obtained by transplanting tadpole intestinal nuclei into enucleated eggs
  • (b) Different chromosome puffs in salivary gland and other larval tissues of Drosophila
  • (c) Elimination of chromosome segments from somatic cells of Parascaris
  • (d) Regeneration of a whole plant from a single cultured carrot cell
Answer and explanation

(c). Chromatin diminution removes DNA from somatic cells, so those cells no longer carry the full genome. (a) and (d) show that differentiated nuclei or cells retain all needed genes; (b) shows the same genes being expressed differently, which is what genomic equivalence predicts.

Q3 (practice). In a mouse, the ICR between Igf2 and H19 on the maternal chromosome is:

  • (a) methylated, so CTCF binds and Igf2 is expressed
  • (b) unmethylated, so CTCF binds, blocking enhancer access to Igf2; H19 is expressed
  • (c) unmethylated, so CTCF cannot bind; both genes are expressed
  • (d) methylated, so H19 is expressed and Igf2 is silent
Answer and explanation

(b). CTCF binds only unmethylated ICR. On the maternal chromosome this insulator stops the shared downstream enhancers from reaching Igf2, so they activate H19. On the paternal chromosome the ICR is methylated, CTCF cannot bind, and the enhancers drive Igf2 while H19 is silenced.

Q4 (practice). A cell population that can produce all blood cell types and also self-renew, but cannot form neurons or trophoblast, is best described as:

  • (a) totipotent
  • (b) pluripotent
  • (c) multipotent
  • (d) unipotent
Answer and explanation

(c). Haematopoietic stem cells are multipotent: several cell types, one lineage. Pluripotent cells could form all three germ layers; totipotent cells could also form trophoblast.

Level 3: Part C Style

Q1 (practice). In a mouse line, a null allele of Igf2 (written Igf2⁻) produces small (dwarf) mice when it is the only allele that would otherwise be expressed. Consider these crosses (all mice otherwise wild type):

(i) Male Igf2⁺/⁻ (he received Igf2⁻ from his mother and is normal sized) × wild-type female. (ii) Wild-type male × female Igf2⁺/⁻ (she received Igf2⁻ from her father and is dwarf). (iii) Male Igf2⁻/⁻ × female Igf2⁻/⁻.

What fraction of offspring is dwarf in each cross?

Answer and worked solution

Only the paternal Igf2 allele is expressed. An offspring is dwarf if, and only if, the allele it receives from its father is Igf2⁻. Which grandparent the allele came from does not matter, because imprints are reset in the parent’s germ line.

  1. Cross (i): the father transmits Igf2⁻ to half his offspring, and in them it is now a paternal allele → 1/2 dwarf. (He himself was normal because in him the null allele was maternal.)
  2. Cross (ii): the father is wild type; every offspring gets a functional paternal allele → 0 dwarf, even though the mother is dwarf and transmits Igf2⁻ to half her pups.
  3. Cross (iii): every offspring gets Igf2⁻ from the father → all dwarf (1).

This is the pattern to recognise in Part C: a phenotype that appears or disappears depending on the sex of the transmitting parent, not on the genotype alone.

Q2 (practice). A morphogen forms an exponential gradient from a source at x = 0 with length constant λ = 100 µm. Gene A is switched on where the concentration exceeds 10% of the source concentration.

(i) How far from the source does the A expression boundary lie? (ii) If the source strength is doubled (for example, by doubling gene dosage of the morphogen), where does the boundary move? (iii) What does a measured shift that is much smaller than predicted suggest?

Answer and worked solution
  1. Boundary where \(C_0 e^{-x/\lambda} = 0.1\,C_0\) → \(x = \lambda\ln 10 = 100 \times 2.303 =\) ≈ 230 µm.
  2. With \(2C_0\): \(x = \lambda\ln 20 = 100 \times 2.996 =\) ≈ 300 µm, a shift of \(\lambda\ln 2 \approx\) 69 µm away from the source.
  3. If the boundary moves much less than \(\lambda\ln 2\), the read-out is buffered: other inputs (repressors from the opposite pole, cross-regulation among target genes, or a source-dependent change in λ) help set the boundary, so the morphogen is not the only positional cue. This is an argument used in work on the Bicoid gradient.

Q3 (practice). In an ascidian 8-cell embryo, the posterior-vegetal pair of blastomeres is isolated and cultured alone. It forms muscle cells. Injecting antisense morpholino against macho-1 mRNA into the egg abolishes most tail muscle in the intact embryo, and injecting macho-1 mRNA into an anterior blastomere causes it to form ectopic muscle. Which conclusions are justified?

(A) Muscle in these blastomeres is autonomously specified. (B) macho-1 is necessary for most primary tail muscle. (C) macho-1 is sufficient to promote muscle fate in some non-muscle lineages. (D) The posterior-vegetal blastomeres are determined, as shown by the isolation experiment.

  • (a) A, B and C
  • (b) A and D only
  • (c) B, C and D
  • (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution

(a) A, B and C.

  • (A) Correct: they form muscle in a neutral environment, so they are specified, and since this happens without neighbours the specification is autonomous.
  • (B) Correct: loss of function (morpholino) removes most tail muscle.
  • (C) Correct: gain of function (ectopic mRNA) induces muscle elsewhere.
  • (D) Not justified: isolation tests specification. Determination requires showing the cells keep their fate after transplantation to a different position.

Quick Revision Table

ItemFact
Potency orderToti (embryo + extra-embryonic) > pluri (germ layers, no trophoblast) > multi > oligo > uni
Specification vs determinationIsolation test vs heterotopic transplant test
Autonomous specificationCytoplasmic determinants; ascidian yellow crescent, macho-1
Conditional specificationNeighbour interactions; Driesch’s sea urchin halves; twins; chimeras
Syncytial specificationDrosophila nuclei read Bicoid and Dorsal gradients
CompetenceAbility to respond; lens competence needs Pax6
OrganiserSpemann and Mangold, 1924; graft forms mainly notochord, host forms the rest
Paracrine familiesFGF, Hedgehog, Wnt, TGF-β (BMP, Nodal, activin, Dpp)
JuxtacrineNotch–Delta, ephrins, cadherins
Morphogen boundary\(x = \lambda\ln(C_0/C_T)\); doubling source shifts by \(\lambda\ln 2\)
C. elegans lineage959 adult somatic nuclei; 131 cells die; 1,090 generated
iPSTakahashi and Yamanaka 2006; OSKM
Genomic equivalence evidenceNuclear transfer (Briggs–King, Gurdon, Dolly), plant regeneration, puffs
ExceptionsChromatin diminution, V(D)J, chorion/rDNA amplification, enucleation
ImprintingIgf2 paternal, H19 maternal (CTCF insulator), Igf2r maternal; PWS (paternal loss) vs AS (maternal UBE3A loss)
Pronuclear transferGynogenetic: poor placenta; androgenetic: poor embryo
Gene testsLoss of function = necessary; gain = sufficient; rescue = causal
ToolsKnockout (ES cells), CRISPR, RNAi, morpholinos, Cre–loxP, GAL4–UAS, FLP–FRT, T-DNA

Key Takeaways

What’s Next