Origin of Life, Early Evolution and the Mechanisms of Evolution
Prebiotic chemistry, RNA world, LUCA, endosymbiosis, multicellularity, and the population genetics of selection, drift, gene flow and mutation for CSIR NET.
- 23 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Carbohydrates, Lipids, Nucleic Acids and Vitamins — RNA chemistry (the 2’-OH, base pairing, catalytic folds) is the basis of the RNA-world argument.
- DNA Replication, Repair and Recombination — where mutations come from, and why mutation rates are as low as they are.
- Mendelian and Extrachromosomal Inheritance — Mendelian ratios and probability, which population genetics extends from families to whole populations.
- Organelles and Protein Sorting — mitochondrial and plastid genomes, the living evidence for endosymbiosis.
The Hook: A Flask, Two Electrodes and a Week
How CSIR NET asks it. Part B: the Oparin–Haldane hypothesis, what Miller–Urey showed, the evidence for an RNA world and for endosymbiosis, the order of early events, modes of selection, founder effect versus bottleneck, assumptions of Hardy–Weinberg. Part C: allele and genotype frequencies, carrier frequencies, change under selection, equilibrium under heterozygote advantage or mutation–selection balance, loss of heterozygosity by drift, effective population size, migration, and molecular-clock dates.
Part 1: Origin and Early Evolution of Life
The timeline in one table
All dates are approximate and are revised as new rocks and fossils are dated. Learn the order first; the numbers are the commonly quoted ones.
| Approximate age | Event | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| ~4.54 billion years (Ga) | Formation of Earth | Radiometric dating of meteorites and lunar rocks |
| ~4.4 Ga | Liquid water on the surface | Oxygen isotopes in the oldest zircon crystals |
| ~3.5 Ga (older claims debated) | Earliest widely accepted traces of life | Stromatolites (layered microbial mats) and microfossils; carbon isotope signatures in older rocks are contested |
| ~2.4 Ga | Great Oxidation Event: free O₂ accumulates in the atmosphere | Disappearance of detrital pyrite and uraninite; red beds; banded iron formations decline afterwards |
| ~1.8–1.6 Ga (debated) | Eukaryotic microfossils | Large, ornamented cells (acritarchs) |
| ~1 Ga | Multicellular red algae with differentiated cells | Bangiomorpha fossils |
| ~575–540 million years (Ma) | Ediacaran biota: soft-bodied macroscopic organisms | Impressions in sandstone (for example Dickinsonia) |
| ~540 Ma onward | Cambrian explosion: most animal phyla with hard parts appear | Burgess Shale, Chengjiang fossils |
| ~470 Ma | Land plants | Cryptospores |
Prebiotic chemistry
The Oparin–Haldane hypothesis (Alexander Oparin, 1924; J. B. S. Haldane, 1929): the early atmosphere was reducing (little or no free O₂), energy from lightning, UV light and heat drove the synthesis of organic molecules, these accumulated in the oceans as a “primordial soup”, and they assembled into larger aggregates that eventually became self-maintaining.
Miller–Urey (1953) tested the first step. Gases: CH₄, NH₃, H₂ and H₂O; energy: electric discharge; products: amino acids, hydroxy acids, urea and other organics. Reanalysis of Miller’s archived samples decades later found many more amino acids than were reported in 1953.
Other abiotic syntheses that are standard textbook material:
- Adenine from hydrogen cyanide (HCN) in concentrated ammonia (Joan Oró, around 1960). Adenine is formally a pentamer of HCN.
- Sugars by the formose reaction: formaldehyde polymerises under alkaline conditions with mineral catalysts to a mixture of sugars, including ribose in small amounts.
- Polymerisation on mineral surfaces: clays such as montmorillonite adsorb activated nucleotides and catalyse the formation of short RNA chains; they also speed the formation of fatty-acid vesicles.
Where did it happen? Two main settings are argued:
| Setting | Argument for | Argument against |
|---|---|---|
| Shallow pools and the “warm little pond” | Wet–dry cycles concentrate molecules and drive condensation; UV light for photochemistry | UV also destroys molecules |
| Deep-sea hydrothermal vents (especially alkaline vents) | Natural pH and redox gradients across mineral walls resemble chemiosmosis; FeS and NiS minerals resemble the metal clusters of ancient enzymes (“iron–sulfur world”, Günter Wächtershäuser) | High temperature hydrolyses RNA; dilution in the ocean |
The modern view of the early atmosphere is that it was neutral or only weakly reducing (CO₂, N₂, H₂O, with some H₂), which gives lower yields in Miller-type experiments. This is why vents and local reducing environments are taken seriously.
The RNA world
DNA stores information, proteins catalyse, and each needs the other to be made. This “chicken-and-egg” problem is solved if an earlier stage used RNA for both jobs. Walter Gilbert named it the RNA world in 1986.
Evidence:
- Ribozymes exist: self-splicing group I introns of Tetrahymena (Thomas Cech) and RNase P RNA (Sidney Altman); Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1989.
- The ribosome is a ribozyme: the peptidyl transferase centre, where peptide bonds form, is built of rRNA, and the catalysis is carried out by RNA rather than by ribosomal proteins.
- Nucleotide cofactors (NAD⁺, FAD, coenzyme A, ATP, S-adenosylmethionine) carry nucleotide “handles” that do no chemistry, read as molecular fossils of RNA-based metabolism.
- DNA is made from RNA: deoxyribonucleotides are synthesised by reducing ribonucleotides (ribonucleotide reductase), and thymine is made by methylating uracil (as dUMP), as if DNA were a later, more stable upgrade.
- In vitro evolution has produced RNA ligases and RNA polymerase ribozymes that can copy short templates.
Why DNA took over storage: the 2’-OH makes RNA prone to alkaline hydrolysis, and thymine in place of uracil lets repair enzymes recognise cytosine deamination (which produces uracil).
From molecules to cells
- Protocells: Oparin’s coacervates (droplets of polymers that separate from water) and Sidney Fox’s proteinoid microspheres (from heated amino acids) showed that compartments form spontaneously. Fatty-acid vesicles are the favoured modern model because they grow by taking up micelles and divide under mild shear.
- Metabolism-first versus replicator-first: whether self-sustaining reaction networks came before self-copying molecules is unresolved. CSIR NET expects you to know both positions, not to pick a winner.
- LUCA, the last universal common ancestor: the population from which Bacteria and Archaea descend. Shared features of all life imply LUCA had DNA genes, ribosomes and a universal (near-universal) genetic code, ATP synthase and a membrane. Whether LUCA was thermophilic, and what its membrane was made of, are debated.
Three domains and the origin of eukaryotes
Carl Woese compared 16S/18S small-subunit rRNA sequences and found that prokaryotes are two deeply separate groups. In 1990 Woese, Kandler and Wheelis proposed three domains: Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya. The details of each domain are on the microbial life page.
Eukaryotes are chimeras:
- Their information-processing machinery (RNA polymerase, histones in some archaea, translation factors) resembles that of Archaea. Metagenomes from deep-sea sediments revealed the Asgard archaea, which carry genes for proteins previously thought to be eukaryote-specific; in many phylogenies eukaryotes branch from within or next to this group. This supports a two-domain view in which Eukarya arose from an archaeal lineage.
- Their mitochondria came from an α-proteobacterium, and plastids from a cyanobacterium.
Endosymbiotic theory (championed by Lynn Margulis from 1967):
| Evidence that mitochondria and plastids were once bacteria |
|---|
| Their own circular genomes, without histones |
| 70S-type ribosomes, sensitive to chloramphenicol and streptomycin, not to cycloheximide |
| Translation starts with N-formylmethionine |
| Double membrane; the inner membrane is bacterial in composition (mitochondria: cardiolipin) and the outer has porins like Gram-negative outer membranes |
| Division by binary fission, using FtsZ in plastids and in some protist mitochondria |
| Phylogeny: their rRNA and protein genes cluster with α-proteobacteria and cyanobacteria |
| Most of their original genes have moved to the nucleus (endosymbiotic gene transfer), so their proteins are imported |
Primary endosymbiosis of a cyanobacterium gave the two-membrane plastids of Archaeplastida (glaucophytes, red algae, green algae and land plants). Secondary endosymbiosis, in which a eukaryote engulfed a red or green alga, gave plastids with three or four membranes in euglenoids, dinoflagellates, diatoms, brown algae and apicomplexans (the apicoplast of Plasmodium). In cryptophytes and chlorarachniophytes a remnant nucleus of the engulfed alga, the nucleomorph, survives between the membranes.
Oxygen changes everything
Oxygenic photosynthesis by cyanobacteria released O₂. At first it was consumed by dissolved Fe²⁺ (precipitating as banded iron formations) and other reduced compounds. Once these sinks were saturated, O₂ rose in the atmosphere: the Great Oxidation Event about 2.4 Ga. Consequences: an ozone layer that screens UV, aerobic respiration (far more ATP per glucose), and the extinction or retreat of many anaerobes to anoxic habitats. A second large rise in O₂ in the late Neoproterozoic preceded the appearance of large animals.
Multicellularity
Multicellularity evolved many times independently. Simple forms (filaments, colonies, clusters) are widespread among bacteria and eukaryotes. Complex multicellularity, with many cell types, tissues and programmed development, arose independently in a few lineages: animals, land plants (from green algae), red algae, brown algae and fungi.
Steps that every lineage had to take:
- Adhesion: cells stay together after division (incomplete separation) or aggregate. Animals use cadherins and integrins; plants have cell walls that already hold daughters together.
- Communication: signalling between cells. Many animal signalling and adhesion gene families are already present in choanoflagellates, the closest living relatives of animals.
- Differentiation and division of labour: above all a germ–soma split, in which some cells give up reproduction.
- Control of cheaters: cells that over-proliferate at the group’s expense (cancer is the animal version). Development from a single-celled bottleneck (zygote or spore) keeps the cells of a body genetically identical, so selection acts on the group.
Two classic model systems:
- Volvocine algae: a size series of related green algae, from unicellular Chlamydomonas through Gonium and Pandorina to Eudorina and Volvox, which has thousands of somatic cells and a few germ cells. It shows how a germ–soma division can arise step by step.
- Dictyostelium: an aggregative route (cells come together when starved), described on the protists page. In such aggregates cheating is a real problem, unlike in clonal bodies.
In laboratory evolution, yeast selected for rapid settling evolved “snowflake” clusters that stay attached after division, showing that the first step can be fast.
graph LR
A["Prebiotic synthesis
amino acids, nucleobases,
sugars"] --> B["RNA world
ribozymes copy
and catalyse"]
B --> C["Protocells
vesicles with
replicators"]
C --> D["LUCA
DNA, ribosomes,
genetic code"]
D --> E["Bacteria"]
D --> F["Archaea"]
F --> G["Eukaryotes
+ α-proteobacterium
= mitochondria"]
E -.-> G
G --> H["+ cyanobacterium
= plastids"]
G --> I["Multicellular
lineages (several
independent origins)"]Part 2: Mechanisms of Evolution
Charles Darwin (On the Origin of Species, 1859) and Alfred Russel Wallace (joint papers read in 1858) proposed natural selection. Without a theory of inheritance, they could not explain how variation is kept. The Modern Synthesis (1930s–1940s: R. A. Fisher, J. B. S. Haldane and Sewall Wright in theory; Theodosius Dobzhansky, Ernst Mayr, G. G. Simpson and others in the field) united Mendelian genetics with selection. Its core statement: evolution is a change in allele frequencies in populations over generations, driven by four forces: mutation, natural selection, genetic drift and gene flow.
The null model: Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium
For one locus with two alleles A (frequency p) and a (frequency q), \(p + q = 1\). With random mating and no evolutionary forces, after one generation
$$\boxed{p^2 + 2pq + q^2 = 1}$$and allele and genotype frequencies stay constant (G. H. Hardy and Wilhelm Weinberg, 1908).
Assumptions: large (effectively infinite) population, random mating, no mutation, no migration, no selection, diploid sexual organism, non-overlapping generations, equal allele frequencies in the two sexes (for autosomal loci).
Uses:
- Carrier frequency of a recessive disease: if \(q^2\) is known, \(2pq \approx 2q\) when q is small.
- Testing for departures with a χ² test (1 degree of freedom for two alleles: 3 genotype classes minus 1 minus 1 estimated parameter).
- For X-linked loci, male frequencies equal allele frequencies: if q = 0.08 for colour blindness, 8% of males but only \(q^2\) = 0.64% of females are affected.
- For multiple alleles (p, q, r): \((p+q+r)^2\); for the ABO system, \(I^O\) frequency \(r = \sqrt{\text{frequency of O}}\).
Non-random mating changes genotype frequencies but not allele frequencies. Inbreeding (coefficient F) reduces heterozygosity: \(H = 2pq(1-F)\), and increases the frequency of recessive homozygotes, which is why rare recessive diseases are more frequent in offspring of consanguineous marriages.
Natural selection
Selection acts when genotypes differ in fitness: survival and reproduction. Relative fitness (w) scales the best genotype to 1; the selection coefficient \(s = 1 - w\).
| Mode | What is favoured | Effect on mean and variance | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Directional | One extreme | Mean shifts; variance may fall | Industrial melanism in the peppered moth Biston betularia (dark form rose in polluted woods, fell after clean-air laws); antibiotic and pesticide resistance |
| Stabilising | The intermediate | Mean unchanged; variance falls | Human birth weight (historically higher mortality at both extremes) |
| Disruptive (diversifying) | Both extremes | Variance rises; can become bimodal | Large- and small-billed African seedcrackers (Pyrenestes) that specialise on hard and soft seeds |
| Balancing | Maintains several alleles | Polymorphism kept | Heterozygote advantage (HbS and malaria); negative frequency-dependent selection (rare morph favoured) |
| Sexual selection | Traits that improve mating success | Can oppose survival | Peacock train; intrasexual competition (antlers) and intersexual choice |
Selection against a recessive homozygote. Fitnesses AA = 1, Aa = 1, aa = 1 − s:
$$\Delta q = \frac{-spq^2}{1 - sq^2}$$When q is small, \(q^2\) is tiny, so selection becomes very slow: rare recessive alleles hide in heterozygotes. For a recessive lethal (s = 1),
$$q_t = \frac{q_0}{1 + t q_0} \qquad\Longleftrightarrow\qquad t = \frac{1}{q_t} - \frac{1}{q_0}$$This is why eugenic sterilisation of affected individuals is ineffective against rare recessive traits: halving q from 0.01 to 0.005 takes 100 generations.
Selection against a dominant allele is fast, because every carrier is exposed.
Heterozygote advantage (overdominance). Fitnesses AA = 1 − s, Aa = 1, aa = 1 − t. A stable equilibrium exists at
$$\boxed{\hat{q} = \frac{s}{s + t}}, \qquad \hat{p} = \frac{t}{s + t}$$(q is the frequency of a; the equilibrium frequency of each allele is proportional to the selection coefficient against the other homozygote). Sickle-cell haemoglobin (HbS) in malarial regions is the classic case: HbA/HbS heterozygotes resist Plasmodium falciparum malaria better than HbA/HbA, while HbS/HbS has sickle-cell disease.
Quantitative traits: the breeder’s equation. For a continuously varying trait, the response to selection R (change in the mean from parents’ generation to offspring) is
$$\boxed{R = h^2 S}$$where S, the selection differential, is the mean of selected parents minus the population mean, and \(h^2\) is narrow-sense heritability (the fraction of phenotypic variance due to additive genetic variance, \(V_A/V_P\)).
Mutation
Mutation is the ultimate source of new alleles, but as a force changing allele frequencies it is weak. Per-locus rates are of the order of 10⁻⁵ to 10⁻⁶ per generation. With mutation A → a at rate µ and no back mutation, \(p_t = p_0 e^{-\mu t}\): halving p would take about 0.69/µ generations, roughly 70,000 generations for µ = 10⁻⁵.
Mutation matters through its interaction with selection and drift:
- Mutation–selection balance: harmful alleles persist at low frequency because new mutations replace those removed. For a recessive harmful allele, \(\hat{q} \approx \sqrt{\mu/s}\). For a dominant one, \(\hat{q} \approx \mu/s\) (more precisely µ/(hs) for a partially dominant allele with dominance h).
- Mutations are random with respect to need: they arise before selection, not because of it (Luria–Delbrück fluctuation test, 1943; Lederbergs’ replica plating, 1952; covered with resistance in Microbial Physiology and AMR).
Genetic drift
Drift is the random change in allele frequency caused by sampling a finite number of gametes each generation. It is strongest in small populations and it is non-directional: it does not favour adaptive alleles.
Key results (Wright–Fisher model, diploid population of effective size \(N_e\)):
| Quantity | Formula | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Variance of change per generation | \(\mathrm{Var}(\Delta p) = \dfrac{pq}{2N_e}\) | Smaller population, larger random jumps |
| Loss of heterozygosity | \(H_t = H_0\left(1 - \dfrac{1}{2N_e}\right)^t \approx H_0 e^{-t/2N_e}\) | Variation is lost steadily |
| Probability of eventual fixation of an allele | Its current frequency p | A new neutral mutation fixes with probability \(1/2N\) |
| Mean time to fixation of a new neutral mutation | About \(4N_e\) generations | Long in large populations |
| Rate of neutral substitution | Equal to the neutral mutation rate µ | Independent of population size (Kimura) |
Effective population size \(N_e\) is the size of an ideal population that would drift at the same rate. It is usually smaller than the census size:
- Unequal sex ratio: \(N_e = \dfrac{4N_m N_f}{N_m + N_f}\).
- Fluctuating size: \(N_e\) is the harmonic mean over generations, dominated by the smallest generation.
- Variance in family size also lowers \(N_e\).
Two drift scenarios that Part B always separates:
- Bottleneck: an existing population crashes and recovers. Northern elephant seals and cheetahs show very low genetic variation after past crashes.
- Founder effect: a few individuals start a new population. High frequencies of otherwise rare alleles in isolated communities (for example Ellis–van Creveld syndrome among the Old Order Amish of Pennsylvania).
Neutral theory (Motoo Kimura, 1968; Jack King and Thomas Jukes, 1969): most variation and most substitutions at the molecular level are selectively neutral and fixed by drift. Its predictions:
- Functionally less constrained sites evolve faster: synonymous sites, introns and pseudogenes evolve faster than non-synonymous sites; fibrinopeptides faster than histone H4.
- A roughly constant substitution rate per lineage, the molecular clock (Emile Zuckerkandl and Linus Pauling, 1960s).
Molecular clock arithmetic. If two species differ by K substitutions per site and each lineage accumulates r substitutions per site per year, the divergence time is
$$\boxed{T = \frac{K}{2r}}$$(the factor 2 because both lineages have been changing since the split). For selection on protein-coding genes, the ratio \(\omega = d_N/d_S\) of non-synonymous to synonymous substitution rates is the standard test: ω < 1 purifying selection, ω ≈ 1 neutral, ω > 1 positive (diversifying) selection.
Gene flow
Gene flow (migration) moves alleles between populations. It homogenises populations and opposes divergence by drift or local selection.
- Continent–island model: a fraction m of the island’s genes each generation comes from a mainland with fixed frequency \(q_m\):
The island frequency approaches the mainland frequency geometrically.
- Wright’s rule of thumb: about one migrant per generation (\(N_e m \approx 1\)) is enough to prevent populations from drifting to fixation for different neutral alleles.
- F_ST measures differentiation: 0 when populations have the same allele frequencies, 1 when they are fixed for different alleles. In the island model at equilibrium, \(F_{ST} \approx 1/(1 + 4N_e m)\).
- Gene flow can introduce new alleles (including adaptive ones by introgression) and can swamp local adaptation.
How the four forces compare
| Force | Changes allele frequency? | Direction | Effect on variation within a population | Effect on differences between populations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mutation | Yes, very slowly | Random with respect to fitness | Increases | Increases (slowly) |
| Selection | Yes | Adaptive (towards higher fitness) | Directional and stabilising decrease; balancing maintains | Increases if environments differ; decreases if same |
| Genetic drift | Yes | Random | Decreases | Increases |
| Gene flow | Yes | Towards the source population | Increases | Decreases |
| Non-random mating | No (genotype frequencies only) | — | Inbreeding lowers heterozygosity | — |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Bottleneck: existing population shrinks | vs | Founder effect: small group starts a new population |
| Genetic drift: random, size-dependent | vs | Gene flow: movement of alleles between populations |
| Inbreeding: changes genotype frequencies | vs | Selection: changes allele frequencies |
| Coacervate (Oparin): polymer-rich droplets | vs | Proteinoid microsphere (Fox): heated amino-acid polymers |
| Primary endosymbiosis: two-membrane plastids (Archaeplastida) | vs | Secondary endosymbiosis: three or four membranes (diatoms, dinoflagellates, euglenoids, apicomplexans) |
| Neutral rate of substitution = µ | vs | Fixation probability of one new neutral mutation = 1/2N |
| Narrow-sense \(h^2 = V_A/V_P\): predicts response | vs | Broad-sense \(H^2 = V_G/V_P\): includes dominance and epistasis |
| Stabilising selection: removes extremes | vs | Balancing selection: keeps two or more alleles |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CSIR NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name the four gases used in the 1953 Miller–Urey experiment.
- A new neutral mutation arises in a diploid population of 500 individuals. What is its probability of eventual fixation?
- Which bacterial group gave rise to mitochondria?
Answers
- Methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour.
- 1/(2N) = 1/1000 = 0.001.
- α-proteobacteria.
Level 2: Part B Style
Q1 (practice). An autosomal recessive disorder affects 1 in 10,000 newborns in a population in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium. The frequency of heterozygous carriers is closest to:
- (a) 1 in 100
- (b) 1 in 50
- (c) 1 in 200
- (d) 1 in 5,000
Answer and explanation
(b). \(q^2 = 10^{-4}\), so q = 0.01 and p = 0.99. Carriers = 2pq = 2 × 0.99 × 0.01 = 0.0198, about 1 in 50.5. Option (a) confuses q with 2pq.
Q2 (practice). A population is maintained at an effective size of 50 diploid individuals. Its heterozygosity at a neutral locus is now 0.50. Ignoring mutation and migration, the expected heterozygosity after 10 generations is about:
- (a) 0.25
- (b) 0.40
- (c) 0.45
- (d) 0.50
Answer and explanation
(c). \(H_{10} = 0.50 \times (1 - 1/100)^{10} = 0.50 \times 0.904 = 0.452\). Drift removes about 1/(2N) = 1% of heterozygosity per generation.
Q3 (practice). At a locus with heterozygote advantage, relative fitnesses are AA = 0.9, Aa = 1.0 and aa = 0.6. The equilibrium frequency of allele a is:
- (a) 0.10
- (b) 0.20
- (c) 0.40
- (d) 0.80
Answer and explanation
(b). s (against AA) = 0.1 and t (against aa) = 0.4. \(\hat{q} = s/(s+t) = 0.1/0.5 = 0.20\). Option (d) is \(\hat{p}\), the frequency of A.
Q4 (practice). Which of the following is NOT evidence for the endosymbiotic origin of mitochondria?
- (a) Mitochondrial ribosomes are sensitive to chloramphenicol.
- (b) Mitochondrial genes cluster with α-proteobacteria in phylogenies.
- (c) In most animals mitochondrial DNA is inherited only through the mother.
- (d) The mitochondrial inner membrane contains cardiolipin.
Answer and explanation
(c). Maternal (uniparental) inheritance is true for most animals, but it is a feature of how eggs and sperm contribute cytoplasm, not a bacterial trait, so it says nothing about where mitochondria came from. (a) 70S-type ribosomes, (b) α-proteobacterial phylogeny and (d) a bacterial-type inner membrane are bacterial features the organelle kept.
Level 3: Part C Style
Q1 (practice). A recessive allele is lethal in the homozygote. In a large randomly mating population its frequency is 0.1.
(i) How many generations of selection are needed to reduce it to 0.01? (ii) What will the frequency of affected newborns be at that point? (iii) A student argues that preventing the reproduction of all affected individuals would “eliminate the disease in a few generations”. Comment.
Answer and worked solution
- For a recessive lethal, \(t = 1/q_t - 1/q_0 = 1/0.01 - 1/0.1 = 100 - 10 = \mathbf{90}\) generations.
- \(q^2 = (0.01)^2 = 10^{-4}\): 1 affected newborn in 10,000 (down from 1 in 100 at the start).
- The argument is wrong. Selection here already removes every affected individual (s = 1), yet the next tenfold fall would take 900 more generations (1/0.001 − 1/0.01). At low q almost all copies of the allele are in heterozygotes, which selection cannot see. New mutations also replenish the allele, holding it near \(\sqrt{\mu/s}\).
Q2 (practice). An island population of a lizard has frequency 0.2 for allele b; the large mainland population has frequency 0.6. Each generation, 5% of the island’s breeding adults are mainland immigrants. A separate island population has 10 breeding males and 40 breeding females.
Which statements are correct?
(A) After 10 generations of migration, the island frequency of b is about 0.36. (B) The island frequency will eventually reach 0.6 if migration continues and no other force acts. (C) The effective size of the second population is 32. (D) Drift will be stronger in the second population than in an ideal population of 50 with equal sex ratio.
- (a) A and B only
- (b) A, B and C only
- (c) C and D only
- (d) A, B, C and D
Answer and worked solution
(d) A, B, C and D.
- (A) \(q_{10} = 0.6 + (0.2 - 0.6)(0.95)^{10} = 0.6 - 0.4 \times 0.599 = 0.360\). Correct.
- (B) As \(t \to \infty\), \((1-m)^t \to 0\), so \(q \to q_m = 0.6\). Correct.
- (C) \(N_e = 4 \times 10 \times 40/(10 + 40) = 1600/50 = 32\). Correct.
- (D) \(N_e\) = 32 < 50, so drift (variance pq/2Ne) is stronger. Correct.
Q3 (practice). The table gives the number of nucleotide differences per site between a gene in species X and Y, separately for synonymous and non-synonymous sites. Fossils show that X and Y diverged 30 million years ago.
| Site class | Differences per site (X vs Y) |
|---|---|
| Synonymous (dS) | 0.15 |
| Non-synonymous (dN) | 0.03 |
(i) Estimate the synonymous substitution rate per site per year. (ii) What does dN/dS indicate? (iii) If species Z differs from X by 0.06 synonymous substitutions per site at the same gene, when did Z and X diverge, assuming a constant clock?
Answer and worked solution
- \(r = K/(2T) = 0.15/(2 \times 30\times10^6) = 2.5 \times 10^{-9}\) per site per year.
- dN/dS = 0.03/0.15 = 0.2 < 1: purifying selection; most amino-acid changes are removed because they are harmful.
- \(T = K/(2r) = 0.06/(2 \times 2.5\times10^{-9}) = 1.2 \times 10^7\) years = 12 million years.
The clock is calibrated with synonymous sites because they are closest to neutral, so their rate approximates the mutation rate.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Earth | ~4.54 Ga; earliest widely accepted life ~3.5 Ga (stromatolites) |
| Oparin–Haldane | Reducing atmosphere, primordial soup (1924, 1929) |
| Miller–Urey 1953 | CH₄, NH₃, H₂, H₂O + spark → amino acids |
| Abiotic syntheses | Adenine from HCN (Oró); sugars by formose reaction; clay-catalysed RNA |
| RNA world | Ribozymes (Cech, Altman), ribosomal peptidyl transferase, nucleotide cofactors |
| Protocells | Coacervates (Oparin), microspheres (Fox), fatty-acid vesicles |
| Three domains | Woese 16S rRNA; Bacteria, Archaea, Eukarya (1990) |
| Eukaryote origin | Archaeal (Asgard-related) host + α-proteobacterium |
| Plastids | Primary (cyanobacterium) → Archaeplastida; secondary → 3–4 membranes |
| Great Oxidation Event | ~2.4 Ga; cyanobacteria; banded iron formations |
| Multicellularity | Many independent origins; complex in animals, plants, red, brown algae, fungi |
| Hardy–Weinberg | p² + 2pq + q² = 1; no mutation, selection, drift, migration; random mating |
| Recessive lethal | t = 1/qₜ − 1/q₀ |
| Heterozygote advantage | q̂ = s/(s + t) |
| Mutation–selection | Recessive q̂ ≈ √(µ/s); dominant ≈ µ/s |
| Breeder’s equation | R = h²S |
| Drift | Var Δp = pq/2Nₑ; Hₜ = H₀(1 − 1/2Nₑ)ᵗ; fixation of new mutation 1/2N; time ~4Nₑ |
| Nₑ | 4·Nm·Nf/(Nm + Nf); harmonic mean over time |
| Neutral theory | Kimura 1968; substitution rate = µ |
| Clock | T = K/2r; dN/dS < 1 purifying, > 1 positive |
| Island model | qₜ = qₘ + (q₀ − qₘ)(1 − m)ᵗ; Nₑm ≈ 1 prevents divergence |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Speciation, Extinction, Macroevolution and Human Evolution — how populations split into species, and the large-scale patterns that result.
- Principles and Methods of Taxonomy — how evolutionary relationships are turned into classifications and trees.
- Microbes, Protists and Fungi — the three domains in detail.
- Chapter overview and Quick Revision.