Electron States, Spin, Helium and Alkali Spectra
CSIR NET Physical Sciences Part C: one-electron states, electron spin and magnetic moments, helium singlets and triplets, alkali quantum defects and series.
- 21 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Angular Momentum, Spin and the Hydrogen Atom: hydrogen energies, \( Y_l^m \), Pauli matrices and the addition of angular momenta are used on every line below.
- Identical Particles, Pauli Principle and Spin-Statistics: singlet and triplet spin states, and why the spatial part must have the opposite exchange symmetry.
- Perturbation Theory and the Variational Method: the helium ground-state estimates are first-order perturbation theory and a one-parameter variational calculation.
The Hook: Two Heliums That Never Talk
One-Electron States
Quantum numbers
An electron in a central potential is labelled by four quantum numbers:
| Symbol | Name | Values | Fixes |
|---|---|---|---|
| \( n \) | principal | 1, 2, 3, … | energy (exactly in hydrogen, mostly elsewhere) |
| \( l \) | orbital | 0, 1, …, \( n - 1 \) | \( L^2 = l(l+1)\hbar^2 \); letters s, p, d, f |
| \( m_l \) | magnetic | \( -l, \ldots, +l \) | \( L_z = m_l\hbar \) |
| \( m_s \) | spin projection | \( \pm\frac{1}{2} \) | \( S_z = m_s\hbar \) |
Each \( (n, l) \) subshell holds \( 2(2l + 1) \) electrons, and each shell \( n \) holds \( 2n^2 \). When spin–orbit coupling is switched on, \( m_l \) and \( m_s \) are no longer good quantum numbers; the right set becomes \( (n, l, j, m_j) \) with \( j = l \pm \frac{1}{2} \). The number of states is unchanged: \( 2(2l + 1) = (2l) + (2l + 2) \) for \( l \geq 1 \).
Electron spin and the magnetic moments
Spin was proposed by Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit in 1925 to explain the doublet structure of alkali lines and the anomalous Zeeman effect. It is an intrinsic angular momentum with \( s = \frac{1}{2} \), so \( S^2 = \frac{3}{4}\hbar^2 \) and \( S_z = \pm\frac{\hbar}{2} \). Both orbital and spin angular momentum carry a magnetic moment:
$$\boxed{\boldsymbol\mu_L = -g_L\mu_B\frac{\mathbf L}{\hbar}, \quad g_L = 1 \qquad \boldsymbol\mu_S = -g_s\mu_B\frac{\mathbf S}{\hbar}, \quad g_s \approx 2.0023}$$with the Bohr magneton
$$\mu_B = \frac{e\hbar}{2m_e} = 9.274\times10^{-24}\ \text{J T}^{-1} = 5.788\times10^{-5}\ \text{eV T}^{-1}$$Useful conversions: \( \mu_B B/h = 14.0 \) GHz per tesla and \( \mu_B B/hc = 0.467 \) cm\( ^{-1} \) per tesla.
The factor \( g_s \approx 2 \) is the key fact. It comes out of the Dirac equation (exactly 2), and quantum electrodynamics adds the small anomaly \( (g_s - 2)/2 \approx \alpha/2\pi \approx 0.00116 \). Because \( g_s \neq g_L \), the total magnetic moment of an atom is not parallel to its total angular momentum \( \mathbf J = \mathbf L + \mathbf S \). That single fact is the origin of the Landé \( g_J \) factor and the anomalous Zeeman effect on the Zeeman, Stark and Magnetic Resonance page.
The nuclear magneton \( \mu_N = e\hbar/2m_p \) is smaller by \( m_e/m_p \approx 1/1836 \). That ratio sets the size of hyperfine structure relative to fine structure.
Evidence for spin
| Observation | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Stern–Gerlach: silver beam splits into 2 | an angular momentum with 2 components, so \( s = \frac{1}{2} \) (orbital \( l \) always gives an odd number) |
| Alkali doublets (Na D lines) | every \( l \geq 1 \) level splits in two: \( j = l \pm \frac{1}{2} \) |
| Anomalous Zeeman effect | more than three components; needs \( g_s \approx 2 \) |
| Periodic table | shells close at 2, 8, 18 electrons: two spin states per orbital |
Many-Electron Atoms: the Central-Field Picture
The exact Hamiltonian of an \( N \)-electron atom contains \( e^2/4\pi\epsilon_0r_{ij} \) repulsions that couple every electron to every other. The central-field approximation replaces them by an average spherically symmetric potential \( V(r) \) felt by each electron:
- Near the nucleus an electron sees the full charge, \( V \to -Ze^2/4\pi\epsilon_0r \).
- Far outside, the other \( N - 1 \) electrons screen the nucleus, \( V \to -(Z - N + 1)e^2/4\pi\epsilon_0r \). For a neutral atom the outer electron sees net charge \( +e \).
Each electron then occupies a hydrogen-like orbital \( (n, l) \), but the energy now depends on \( l \) as well as \( n \). A low-\( l \) orbital (s, then p) penetrates the inner core, sees more of the nuclear charge and is more tightly bound. This is why 4s fills before 3d in potassium and calcium. The configuration (for example \( 1s^22s^22p^63s \) for sodium) is the first label of an atomic state; the residual electrostatic repulsion and spin–orbit coupling then split each configuration into terms and levels, which is the subject of Fine Structure, Hyperfine Structure and LS/jj Coupling.
Alkali Spectra
The quantum defect
An alkali atom (Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs) is a closed-shell core plus one valence electron. Its levels are hydrogen-like, written with an effective principal quantum number \( n^* = n - \delta_l \):
$$\boxed{E_{nl} = -\frac{hcR}{(n - \delta_l)^2} = -\frac{13.6\ \text{eV}}{(n^*)^2}}$$The quantum defect \( \delta_l \) measures how much the orbital penetrates the core. It depends strongly on \( l \) and only weakly on \( n \):
| \( l \) | Penetration | Quantum defect (Na, approximate) |
|---|---|---|
| s | strong | about 1.35 |
| p | moderate | about 0.86 |
| d | slight | about 0.01 |
| f | negligible | about 0 |
High-\( l \) orbitals stay outside the core, see a net charge \( +e \), and are almost exactly hydrogenic. The \( l \)-degeneracy of hydrogen is gone: \( 3s \), \( 3p \) and \( 3d \) of sodium are at very different energies.
Selection rules and the four series
For one active electron the electric dipole rules are
$$\Delta l = \pm1, \qquad \Delta j = 0, \pm1, \qquad \text{parity changes}$$(the parity of a one-electron state is \( (-1)^l \), so \( \Delta l = \pm1 \) already guarantees the parity change). The historical series names survive in the letters s, p, d, f:
| Series | Transition (Na) | Pattern of each member |
|---|---|---|
| Principal | \( np \to 3s \) | doublet; splitting shrinks as \( n \) rises (upper \( np \) fine structure falls like \( 1/n^{*3} \)) |
| Sharp | \( ns \to 3p \) | doublet with constant separation (the splitting of the common lower 3p level) |
| Diffuse | \( nd \to 3p \) | compound doublet: three lines, since \( ^2D_{5/2} \to {}^2P_{1/2} \) has \( \Delta j = 2 \) and is forbidden |
| Fundamental (Bergmann) | \( nf \to 3d \) | close doublets, nearly hydrogenic |
The first member of the principal series is the sodium D doublet: \( 3p\ ^2P_{3/2} \to 3s\ ^2S_{1/2} \) (D2, 589.0 nm) and \( 3p\ ^2P_{1/2} \to 3s\ ^2S_{1/2} \) (D1, 589.6 nm). The separation is \( \Delta\tilde\nu = 1/589.0\ \text{nm} - 1/589.6\ \text{nm} \approx 17.2 \) cm\( ^{-1} \), about 2.1 meV. The intensity ratio D2 : D1 is close to 2 : 1, the ratio of the upper-level degeneracies \( 2j + 1 = 4 \) and 2.
The series limit of the principal series is the ionisation energy; the sharp and diffuse series converge to a common limit lying one 3p excitation below it.
graph TD
L[Ionisation limit] --- P[np levels]
P -->|principal series| S3[3s ground]
NS[ns levels, n at least 4] -->|sharp series| P3[3p]
ND[nd levels] -->|diffuse series| P3
NF[nf levels] -->|fundamental series| D3[3d]
P3 -->|D lines| S3Why alkali levels are doublets
Every \( l \geq 1 \) level of the valence electron splits into \( j = l + \frac{1}{2} \) and \( j = l - \frac{1}{2} \) through spin–orbit coupling \( \xi(r)\,\mathbf L\cdot\mathbf S \). The \( j = l + \frac{1}{2} \) level lies higher for one electron outside a closed shell. The splitting grows rapidly down the group (Li tiny, Cs large), because the valence electron penetrates closer to a larger nuclear charge. The derivation of the spin–orbit operator and its size is on Spin-Orbit Coupling and Fine Structure.
The Helium Atom
The ground state: three estimates
Helium has \( Z = 2 \) and two electrons:
$$\hat H = \underbrace{-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}(\nabla_1^2 + \nabla_2^2) - \frac{2e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\left(\frac{1}{r_1} + \frac{1}{r_2}\right)}_{\hat H_0:\ \text{two hydrogen-like ions}} + \underbrace{\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0r_{12}}}_{\hat H'}$$The measured ground-state energy is about \( -79.0 \) eV, which is the sum of the two ionisation energies (24.6 eV and 54.4 eV).
| Method | Energy | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Ignore repulsion | \( 2\times(-13.6\times4) = -108.8 \) eV | far too low |
| First-order perturbation | \( -108.8 + \frac{5}{4}Z(13.6) = -108.8 + 34.0 = -74.8 \) eV | \( \langle 1/r_{12}\rangle = \frac{5Z}{8a_0} \) |
| Variational, \( Z_{\text{eff}} \) free | \( Z_{\text{eff}} = Z - \frac{5}{16} = \frac{27}{16} \); \( E = -2Z_{\text{eff}}^2(13.6) = -77.5 \) eV | upper bound, as it must be |
| Experiment | \( -79.0 \) eV |
The variational value is above the true energy, as the variational principle guarantees. \( Z_{\text{eff}} = 1.69 \) says each electron screens about \( 5/16 \) of a proton charge from the other.
Ionisation energy: removing one electron leaves He\( ^+ \) at \( -54.4 \) eV, so \( IE_1 = 79.0 - 54.4 = 24.6 \) eV, the largest of any neutral atom.
Excited states: singlets and triplets
Promote one electron: configuration \( 1s\,nl \). The total wavefunction must be antisymmetric. With spin, there are two options:
$$\Psi_{\text{singlet}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt2}\left[\phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{nl}(2) + \phi_{nl}(1)\phi_{1s}(2)\right]\chi_{0,0}, \qquad \Psi_{\text{triplet}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt2}\left[\phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{nl}(2) - \phi_{nl}(1)\phi_{1s}(2)\right]\chi_{1,m_S}$$The first-order repulsion energy is
$$\boxed{E^{(1)} = J \pm K, \qquad + \text{ for singlet } (S = 0), \quad - \text{ for triplet } (S = 1)}$$where the direct (Coulomb) integral \( J = \left\langle \phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{nl}(2)\right\rvert\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0r_{12}}\left\lvert\phi_{1s}(1)\phi_{nl}(2)\right\rangle \) is the classical repulsion of two charge clouds, and the exchange integral \( K \) has no classical analogue. \( K > 0 \) here, so the triplet lies below the singlet of the same configuration by \( 2K \).
The physics: the spatially antisymmetric triplet vanishes when \( \mathbf r_1 = \mathbf r_2 \). The electrons keep apart, repel less, and the energy is lower. Spin enters the energy only through the symmetry it forces on the spatial part. This is the atomic root of Hund’s first rule (maximum \( S \) lies lowest).
Features of the helium spectrum
- No \( 1s^2\ ^3S \) state. Both electrons in 1s means a symmetric spatial function; the spin part must be the singlet. The ground state is \( 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) only.
- Two systems. The dipole rule \( \Delta S = 0 \) separates the singlet (parahelium) and triplet (orthohelium) systems. Intercombination lines (\( \Delta S = \pm1 \)) appear only weakly, made possible by spin–orbit mixing, which is tiny in helium.
- Metastable \( 2\,^3S_1 \). It cannot decay to \( 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) by an allowed dipole transition: \( \Delta S = 1 \), and both states have \( L = 0 \) with even parity. It is very long-lived and is the energy store in the helium–neon laser.
- \( 2\,^1S_0 \) is also metastable (\( J = 0 \to J = 0 \) and no parity change).
- Resonance line. \( 1s2p\ ^1P_1 \to 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) at 58.4 nm (21.2 eV), deep in the vacuum ultraviolet.
- Doubly excited states such as \( 2s^2 \) lie above the first ionisation limit (\( 2\times(-13.6) = -27.2 \) eV in the independent-electron estimate, versus \( -54.4 \) eV for the He\( ^+ \) + e threshold). They decay by ejecting an electron: autoionisation.
Helium versus alkali: the comparison table
| Feature | Alkali (one valence electron) | Helium (two electrons) |
|---|---|---|
| Ground state | \( ^2S_{1/2} \) | \( ^1S_0 \) |
| Multiplicities | all doublets | singlets and triplets |
| Fine structure | \( j = l \pm \frac{1}{2} \) doublets | triplet levels split into \( J = L - 1, L, L + 1 \); singlets unsplit |
| Main splitting mechanism | penetration (\( \delta_l \)) | exchange (\( \pm K \)) and penetration |
| Lines between systems | not applicable | forbidden (\( \Delta S = 0 \)) |
| Metastable levels | none low-lying in the valence series | \( 2\,^3S_1 \), \( 2\,^1S_0 \) |
Memory Tricks
Short anchors for the results on this page. Say each one aloud before a mock test; if one does not trigger the formula, reread its section.
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Quantum defect \( \delta_l \): shift of \( n \) from penetration | Fine structure: \( j \)-splitting from spin–orbit coupling | |
| Direct integral \( J \): classical repulsion | Exchange integral \( K \): from antisymmetry, no classical analogue | |
| Parahelium = singlet (\( S = 0 \)) | Orthohelium = triplet (\( S = 1 \)) | |
| Sharp series \( ns \to 3p \): constant doublet spacing | Principal series \( np \to 3s \): shrinking spacing | |
| \( \mu_B = e\hbar/2m_e \) | \( \mu_N = e\hbar/2m_p \), smaller by 1836 | |
| Variational energy: an upper bound | Perturbation (first order) energy: no bound guaranteed |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Take \( 13.6 \) eV for the hydrogen ground-state binding energy.
Level 1: Foundation
- How many states (including spin) belong to the \( n = 3 \) shell of hydrogen?
- Why are there no strong lines between the singlet and triplet systems of helium?
- For which value of \( l \) is the quantum defect of an alkali atom largest?
Answers
- 18. \( 2n^2 \): \( 2 + 6 + 10 \).
- The dipole operator does not act on spin, so \( \Delta S = 0 \). Intercombination lines need spin–orbit mixing, which is weak in helium.
- \( l = 0 \) (s). The s orbital penetrates the core most.
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The ionisation energy of sodium from its \( 3s \) ground state is 5.14 eV. The quantum defect of the \( 3s \) level is closest to:
(a) 0.37 (b) 1.37 (c) 1.63 (d) 2.63
Answer: (b) 1.37
\( n^* = \sqrt{13.6/5.14} = 1.627 \), so \( \delta_s = 3 - 1.627 = 1.37 \). Option (c) is \( n^* \) itself; option (a) forgets that the defect is measured from \( n = 3 \) and subtracts from 2.
Practice Q2. For the \( 1s2s \) configuration of helium, which statement is correct?
(a) The \( ^1S_0 \) level lies below \( ^3S_1 \) because paired spins are more stable (b) The \( ^3S_1 \) level lies below \( ^1S_0 \); the gap is twice the exchange integral (c) The two levels are degenerate; only spin–orbit coupling separates them (d) The \( ^3S_1 \) level lies below \( ^1S_0 \); the gap is twice the direct integral
Answer: (b)
\( E = J + K \) for the singlet and \( J - K \) for the triplet, so the gap is \( 2K \) with the triplet lower. The direct integral \( J \) shifts both levels equally (option d). Option (c) ignores the electrostatic exchange effect, which is much larger than spin–orbit coupling in helium.
Practice Q3. The first ionisation energy of lithium is 5.39 eV. Treating the \( 2s \) electron as hydrogen-like with an effective charge, \( Z_{\text{eff}} \) is about:
(a) 1.00 (b) 1.26 (c) 1.59 (d) 2.52
Answer: (b) 1.26
\( 5.39 = 13.6\,Z_{\text{eff}}^2/2^2 \) gives \( Z_{\text{eff}} = 2\sqrt{5.39/13.6} = 1.259 \). Option (a) is no screening or penetration at all; option (d) multiplies by \( n^2 = 4 \) instead of dividing (\( Z_{\text{eff}} = 4\sqrt{5.39/13.6} = 2.52 \)); option (c) is \( \sqrt{2.52} \), an arbitrary mishandling of that factor.
Practice Q4. Which of these helium transitions is an allowed electric dipole transition?
(a) \( 1s2s\ ^3S_1 \to 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) (b) \( 1s2s\ ^1S_0 \to 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) (c) \( 1s2p\ ^1P_1 \to 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \) (d) \( 1s2p\ ^3P_1 \to 1s2s\ ^1S_0 \)
Answer: (c)
(c) has \( \Delta S = 0 \), \( \Delta L = -1 \), \( \Delta J = -1 \) and a parity change (odd to even): allowed; it is the 58.4 nm resonance line. (a) and (d) change \( S \). (b) is \( J = 0 \to 0 \) with no parity change.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. For the ground state of helium (measured total energy \( -79.0 \) eV), consider:
- Treating the electron–electron repulsion in first-order perturbation theory gives \( -74.8 \) eV.
- A variational trial function with both electrons in hydrogen-like 1s orbitals of charge \( Z_{\text{eff}} \) gives \( Z_{\text{eff}} = 27/16 \) and \( E \approx -77.5 \) eV.
- The first ionisation energy of helium is about 24.6 eV.
- The variational estimate lies below the true ground-state energy.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- \( E^{(0)} = -2Z^2(13.6) = -108.8 \) eV; \( \langle e^2/4\pi\epsilon_0r_{12}\rangle = \frac{5}{8}Z(27.2\ \text{eV}) = 34.0 \) eV; total \( -74.8 \) eV. True.
- \( E(Z_{\text{eff}}) = 27.2\left[Z_{\text{eff}}^2 - 2ZZ_{\text{eff}} + \frac{5}{8}Z_{\text{eff}}\right] \) eV; minimising gives \( Z_{\text{eff}} = Z - \frac{5}{16} = \frac{27}{16} \) and \( E = -27.2(27/16)^2 = -77.5 \) eV. True.
- He\( ^+ \) has \( -13.6\times4 = -54.4 \) eV, so \( IE_1 = 79.0 - 54.4 = 24.6 \) eV. True.
- False: the variational principle makes \( -77.5 \) eV an upper bound, above \( -79.0 \) eV.
Practice Q6. In sodium, the ground \( 3s \) level is bound by 5.14 eV and the D lines (mean wavelength 589.3 nm) connect \( 3p \) to \( 3s \). Consider:
- The \( 3p \) level is bound by about 3.04 eV.
- The quantum defect of \( 3p \) is about 0.88.
- The quantum defect of \( 3p \) is larger than that of \( 3s \) because p orbitals are more diffuse.
- A \( 3d \) level of sodium, with negligible quantum defect, would be bound by about 1.51 eV.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 4 only
- Photon energy \( 1239.8/589.3 = 2.104 \) eV; \( 5.14 - 2.10 = 3.04 \) eV. True.
- \( n^* = \sqrt{13.6/3.035} = 2.117 \); \( \delta_p = 3 - 2.117 = 0.88 \). True.
- False on both counts: \( \delta_p \) (0.88) is smaller than \( \delta_s \) (1.37), because the p electron penetrates the core less.
- With \( \delta_d \approx 0 \), \( E = 13.6/9 = 1.51 \) eV. True.
Practice Q7. The \( 1s2s \) levels of helium are measured at 19.82 eV (\( ^3S_1 \)) and 20.62 eV (\( ^1S_0 \)) above the ground state. Consider:
- The exchange integral for \( 1s2s \) is about 0.40 eV.
- The \( ^3S_1 \) level is metastable because its decay to the ground state needs \( \Delta S = 1 \) and has no parity change.
- The \( ^3S_1 \) level has three times the statistical weight of \( ^1S_0 \).
- A photon of 19.82 eV absorbed by ground-state helium populates \( ^3S_1 \) efficiently.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 1 and 4 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Gap \( = 2K = 0.80 \) eV, so \( K = 0.40 \) eV. True.
- \( 1s^2\ ^1S_0 \leftrightarrow 1s2s\ ^3S_1 \) violates \( \Delta S = 0 \) and both states are even: no allowed dipole route. True.
- \( 2J + 1 = 3 \) versus 1. True.
- False: the same selection rules forbid absorption. The \( ^3S_1 \) level is populated in practice by electron impact (as in a discharge), where exchange collisions can flip the total spin.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Formula or fact |
|---|---|
| Shell capacity | \( 2(2l + 1) \) per subshell, \( 2n^2 \) per shell |
| Magnetic moments | \( \mu = -g\mu_B J/\hbar \); \( g_L = 1 \), \( g_s \approx 2.0023 \) |
| Bohr magneton | \( 5.788\times10^{-5} \) eV/T; 14.0 GHz/T; 0.467 cm\( ^{-1} \)/T |
| Alkali levels | \( E = -13.6/(n - \delta_l)^2 \) eV; \( \delta_s > \delta_p > \delta_d \approx 0 \) |
| One-electron dipole rules | \( \Delta l = \pm1 \), \( \Delta j = 0, \pm1 \) |
| Na D lines | 589.0 nm (\( ^2P_{3/2} \)), 589.6 nm (\( ^2P_{1/2} \)); 17.2 cm\( ^{-1} \); intensity 2 : 1 |
| Series | principal \( np\to3s \); sharp \( ns\to3p \) (constant spacing); diffuse \( nd\to3p \) (three lines) |
| Helium ground | \( -79.0 \) eV; IEs 24.6 and 54.4 eV |
| Helium estimates | \( -108.8 \) (no repulsion), \( -74.8 \) (first order), \( -77.5 \) (\( Z_{\text{eff}} = 27/16 \)) eV |
| Helium excited | \( E = J \pm K \): singlet \( +K \), triplet \( -K \) |
| Metastables | \( 2\,^3S_1 \) and \( 2\,^1S_0 \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Fine Structure, Hyperfine Structure and LS/jj Coupling: what splits each configuration into terms and levels, plus isotope shifts and line widths.
- Zeeman, Paschen–Back and Stark Effects; ESR and NMR: the same states in external fields.
- Chemists meet the same physics as term symbols and many-electron atoms in Atomic Structure and Spectroscopy.
- Atomic and Molecular Physics: Quick Revision.