Central Forces, Scattering and Collisions
CSIR NET classical mechanics: reduced mass, effective potential, Kepler orbits, orbit stability, Rutherford scattering, and collisions in lab and CM frames.
- 18 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Rutherford’s Backward-Bouncing Alphas
- Reducing Two Bodies to One
- Conserved Quantities and the Effective Potential
- The Kepler Problem
- Stability of Circular Orbits and Closed Orbits
- Scattering by a Central Force
- Two-Body Collisions: Laboratory and Centre-of-Mass Frames
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Newton’s Laws, Phase Space and Stability: the 1D energy method and small oscillations, applied here to the radial coordinate.
- Lagrangian and Hamiltonian Mechanics, Conservation Laws: the polar-coordinate Lagrangian, in which the angle is cyclic. You can read this page first and come back.
- Conic sections in polar form, \( r = p/(1 + e\cos\theta) \).
The Hook: Rutherford’s Backward-Bouncing Alphas
Reducing Two Bodies to One
Two particles interacting through \( V(\lvert\mathbf{r}_1 - \mathbf{r}_2\rvert) \) with no external force: put \( \mathbf{R} \) for the centre of mass and \( \mathbf{r} = \mathbf{r}_1 - \mathbf{r}_2 \). Then
$$L = \tfrac{1}{2}M\dot{\mathbf{R}}^2 + \tfrac{1}{2}\mu\dot{\mathbf{r}}^2 - V(r), \qquad M = m_1 + m_2, \qquad \boxed{\mu = \frac{m_1m_2}{m_1 + m_2}}$$The centre of mass moves uniformly; the relative coordinate behaves as a single particle of reduced mass \( \mu \) in the fixed potential \( V(r) \). Limits: \( \mu \to m_1 \) when \( m_2 \gg m_1 \) (planet and Sun), \( \mu = m/2 \) for equal masses.
Conserved Quantities and the Effective Potential
A central force exerts no torque about the centre, so \( \mathbf{L} = \mu\mathbf{r}\times\dot{\mathbf{r}} \) is conserved. Its direction fixes the plane of motion; its magnitude gives
$$L = \mu r^2\dot\theta, \qquad \frac{dA}{dt} = \frac{L}{2\mu} = \text{constant}$$This is Kepler’s second law, and it holds for every central force, not only gravity.
Energy conservation in polar coordinates, with \( \dot\theta \) eliminated:
$$E = \tfrac{1}{2}\mu\dot r^2 + \underbrace{V(r) + \frac{L^2}{2\mu r^2}}_{V_{\text{eff}}(r)}$$The radial motion is a 1D problem in \( V_{\text{eff}} \); the term \( L^2/2\mu r^2 \) is the centrifugal barrier. Read the orbit type straight off the graph of \( V_{\text{eff}} \):
| Energy | Radial motion | Orbit |
|---|---|---|
| \( E = V_{\text{eff,min}} \) | \( r \) fixed | circular |
| \( V_{\text{eff,min}} < E < 0 \) (attractive \( V \to 0 \) at infinity) | between \( r_{\min} \) and \( r_{\max} \) | bounded rosette (closed only for special forces) |
| \( E \geq 0 \) | \( r \) from \( r_{\min} \) to infinity | unbounded |
The orbit equation (Binet)
With \( u = 1/r \) and \( F(r) \) the radial force (positive outward),
$$\boxed{\frac{d^2u}{d\theta^2} + u = -\frac{\mu}{L^2u^2}F\!\left(\frac{1}{u}\right)}$$Use it in either direction: given \( F \), solve for the orbit; given the orbit, read off the force.
| Orbit | Force law |
|---|---|
| Conic with focus at the centre, \( r = p/(1 + e\cos\theta) \) | \( F \propto -1/r^2 \) |
| Circle through the centre, \( r = 2R\cos\theta \) | \( F \propto -1/r^5 \) |
| Logarithmic spiral, \( r = r_0e^{a\theta} \) | \( F \propto -1/r^3 \) |
| Ellipse centred on the force centre | \( F \propto -r \) (isotropic oscillator) |
For the spiral: \( u = e^{-a\theta}/r_0 \) gives \( u'' + u = (1 + a^2)u \), so \( F = -(1 + a^2)L^2u^3/\mu \), an attractive inverse cube.
The Kepler Problem
For \( V = -k/r \) (gravity: \( k = Gm_1m_2 \); attractive Coulomb: \( k = \lvert q_1q_2\rvert/4\pi\varepsilon_0 \)), the orbit equation gives
$$\boxed{r = \frac{p}{1 + e\cos\theta}, \qquad p = \frac{L^2}{\mu k}, \qquad e = \sqrt{1 + \frac{2EL^2}{\mu k^2}}}$$| \( E \) | \( e \) | Orbit |
|---|---|---|
| \( -\mu k^2/2L^2 \) (minimum of \( V_{\text{eff}} \)) | 0 | circle |
| negative | \( 0 < e < 1 \) | ellipse |
| zero | 1 | parabola |
| positive | \( e > 1 \) | hyperbola |
For an ellipse the energy depends only on the semi-major axis, and the period follows from the area law:
$$\boxed{E = -\frac{k}{2a}, \qquad T^2 = \frac{4\pi^2\mu}{k}a^3 = \frac{4\pi^2}{G(m_1 + m_2)}a^3}$$The second form is Kepler’s third law. Also \( r_{\min} = a(1 - e) \), \( r_{\max} = a(1 + e) \), and the vis-viva relation \( v^2 = (k/\mu)(2/r - 1/a) \).
Circular orbits obey the virial relation for \( 1/r \) potentials: \( \langle T\rangle = -\tfrac{1}{2}\langle V\rangle \), so \( E = -T = V/2 \). The escape speed from radius \( r \) is \( \sqrt{2} \) times the circular speed there.
The Kepler problem has an extra conserved vector, the Laplace–Runge–Lenz vector \( \mathbf{A} = \mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{L} - \mu k\hat{\mathbf{r}} \), which points to perihelion with \( \lvert\mathbf{A}\rvert = \mu ke \). Its conservation is why Kepler ellipses do not precess; any perturbation to \( 1/r \) (another planet, general-relativistic corrections, a \( 1/r^2 \) term) makes the perihelion advance.
Stability of Circular Orbits and Closed Orbits
For a power-law force \( F = -kr^n \) (\( k > 0 \)), a circular orbit exists at every radius, with \( L^2 = \mu kr_0^{n+3} \). It is a minimum of \( V_{\text{eff}} \), and so stable, only if
$$\boxed{n > -3}$$Small radial oscillations about it have frequency \( \omega_r \), while the orbital angular frequency is \( \omega_\theta = \dot\theta \). Expanding \( V_{\text{eff}} \) to second order:
$$\boxed{\frac{\omega_r}{\omega_\theta} = \sqrt{n + 3}}, \qquad \text{apsidal angle } \Delta\theta = \frac{\pi}{\sqrt{n + 3}}$$The apsidal angle is the angle swept between \( r_{\min} \) and the next \( r_{\max} \). A nearly circular orbit closes only if \( \sqrt{n + 3} \) is rational.
| Force | \( n \) | \( \omega_r/\omega_\theta \) | Apsidal angle | Near-circular orbit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gravity, Coulomb | \( -2 \) | 1 | \( \pi \) | closed ellipse, focus at centre |
| Isotropic oscillator | 1 | 2 | \( \pi/2 \) | closed ellipse, centre at centre |
| Inverse cube | \( -3 \) | 0 | infinite | neutral: spirals in or out |
| Inverse fourth power | \( -4 \) | imaginary | none | unstable |
Bertrand’s theorem: the only central forces for which all bounded orbits are closed are the inverse square and the linear (Hooke) force.
Scattering by a Central Force
A beam of particles with impact parameter \( b \) (perpendicular distance of the incoming line from the centre) is deflected through angle \( \Theta \). Particles in the ring \( b \) to \( b + db \) go into the solid angle \( d\Omega = 2\pi\sin\Theta\,d\Theta \). The differential cross section is
$$\boxed{\frac{d\sigma}{d\Omega} = \frac{b}{\sin\Theta}\left\lvert\frac{db}{d\Theta}\right\rvert}$$and the number scattered into \( d\Omega \) per unit time is (incident flux) \( \times\,(d\sigma/d\Omega)\,d\Omega \) per scatterer.
Hard sphere of radius \( a \): \( b = a\cos(\Theta/2) \), giving \( d\sigma/d\Omega = a^2/4 \) (isotropic) and total \( \sigma = \pi a^2 \), the geometric cross-section.
Rutherford scattering, \( V = k/r \) with \( k = Z_1Z_2e^2/4\pi\varepsilon_0 \) and energy \( E \):
$$b = \frac{k}{2E}\cot\frac{\Theta}{2}, \qquad \boxed{\frac{d\sigma}{d\Omega} = \left(\frac{k}{4E}\right)^2\frac{1}{\sin^4(\Theta/2)}}$$- Head-on (\( b = 0 \)) the particle stops at the distance of closest approach \( d = k/E \) and comes straight back.
- The total cross-section diverges, because the Coulomb force has infinite range and every particle is deflected a little.
- Doubling the energy cuts \( d\sigma/d\Omega \) by 4; doubling \( Z_2 \) raises it by 4.
- For the two-body problem, \( E \) and \( \Theta \) are the centre-of-mass values.
Two-Body Collisions: Laboratory and Centre-of-Mass Frames
Particle 1 (mass \( m_1 \), speed \( u \)) hits particle 2 (mass \( m_2 \)) at rest in the lab frame.
Centre-of-mass velocity: \( V = \dfrac{m_1u}{m_1 + m_2} \). In the CM frame the particles approach with speeds \( u - V = \dfrac{m_2u}{m_1 + m_2} \) and \( V \), momenta equal and opposite. In an elastic collision they leave with the same speeds, simply rotated through the CM angle \( \theta_C \).
Kinetic energy splits as
$$T_{\text{lab}} = \tfrac{1}{2}m_1u^2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(m_1 + m_2)V^2 + \underbrace{\tfrac{1}{2}\mu u^2}_{T_{\text{CM}}}$$Only \( T_{\text{CM}} = \frac{m_2}{m_1 + m_2}T_{\text{lab}} \) is available to excite or break the particles; the rest must remain as motion of the centre of mass. A perfectly inelastic collision (bodies stick) loses exactly \( \tfrac{1}{2}\mu u^2 \).
Angle conversion (elastic)
$$\boxed{\tan\theta_L = \frac{\sin\theta_C}{\cos\theta_C + m_1/m_2}}, \qquad \text{recoil angle of target } \phi_L = \frac{\pi - \theta_C}{2}$$| Case | Consequence |
|---|---|
| \( m_1 = m_2 \) | \( \theta_L = \theta_C/2 \); \( \theta_L + \phi_L = 90° \): outgoing particles move at right angles; projectile keeps fraction \( \cos^2\theta_L \) of its energy; \( \theta_L \leq 90° \) |
| \( m_1 > m_2 \) | maximum lab angle \( \sin\theta_{L,\max} = m_2/m_1 \): a heavy projectile cannot be turned back |
| \( m_1 < m_2 \) | every lab angle up to 180° possible |
| \( m_2 \to \infty \) | \( \theta_L = \theta_C \): the frames coincide |
Head-on (one-dimensional) elastic collision
$$v_1 = \frac{m_1 - m_2}{m_1 + m_2}u, \qquad v_2 = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}u, \qquad \frac{\Delta T}{T} = \frac{4m_1m_2}{(m_1 + m_2)^2}$$The fractional energy transfer is 1 for equal masses (why hydrogen-rich materials moderate neutrons well) and about 0.28 for a neutron on carbon-12 (\( 4\times12/13^2 \)).
Inelastic collisions with coefficient of restitution \( e \) (relative speed of separation over approach): \( v_2 - v_1 = e\,u \) in 1D, and the energy lost is \( \tfrac{1}{2}\mu u^2(1 - e^2) \).
Cross-sections in the two frames differ by the Jacobian of the angle map: \( \frac{d\sigma}{d\Omega_L} = \frac{d\sigma}{d\Omega_C}\frac{d\Omega_C}{d\Omega_L} \). For equal masses \( d\Omega_C/d\Omega_L = 4\cos\theta_L \), so isotropic CM scattering becomes \( \propto\cos\theta_L \) in the lab, confined to the forward hemisphere.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Kepler’s 2nd law: any central force | Kepler’s 1st and 3rd laws: inverse square only | |
| Inverse-square ellipse: force at a focus | Hooke ellipse: force at the centre | |
| Circular orbit stable for \( F \propto -r^n \), \( n > -3 \) | Potential \( V \propto r^{n+1} \) (one power higher) | |
| Lab angle \( \theta_L \) | CM angle \( \theta_C \) (equal: only for infinitely heavy target) | |
| Total Rutherford cross-section infinite | Hard sphere: finite, \( \pi a^2 \) | |
| \( T_{\text{CM}} = \frac{m_2}{m_1 + m_2}T_{\text{lab}} \) | \( T_{\text{lab}} \) (overestimates available energy) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper.
Level 1: Foundation
- Two equal masses \( m \) interact through a central force. What is the reduced mass?
- Planet B’s orbit has twice the semi-major axis of planet A’s (same star). Ratio of periods \( T_B/T_A \)?
- Ratio of escape speed to circular orbital speed at the same radius?
Answers
- \( m/2 \).
- \( 2^{3/2} \approx 2.83 \). \( T \propto a^{3/2} \).
- \( \sqrt{2} \). \( v_{\text{circ}}^2 = k/\mu r \), \( v_{\text{esc}}^2 = 2k/\mu r \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. A particle moves under a central force on the circle \( r = 2R\cos\theta \), which passes through the force centre. The force varies as:
(a) \( r^{-2} \) (b) \( r^{-3} \) (c) \( r^{-4} \) (d) \( r^{-5} \)
Answer: (d)
\( u = \sec\theta/2R \). Then \( u' = \sec\theta\tan\theta/2R \) and \( u'' = (\sec\theta\tan^2\theta + \sec^3\theta)/2R \), so \( u'' + u = (\sec\theta\tan^2\theta + \sec^3\theta + \sec\theta)/2R = 2\sec^3\theta/2R = 8R^2u^3 \). Binet gives \( F = -\frac{L^2u^2}{\mu}(u'' + u) = -\frac{8R^2L^2}{\mu}u^5 \propto -r^{-5} \).
Practice Q2. In an elastic collision between equal masses with the target at rest, the projectile is deflected through 30° in the lab frame. The fraction of its kinetic energy it keeps is:
(a) 1/4 (b) 1/2 (c) 3/4 (d) \( \sqrt{3}/2 \)
Answer: (c) 3/4
For equal masses the outgoing velocities are perpendicular, and the projectile’s speed is \( u\cos\theta_L \). Energy fraction \( \cos^2 30° = 3/4 \). Option (d) is the speed fraction, not the energy fraction.
Practice Q3. For a central force \( F = -kr \) (isotropic oscillator), a slightly perturbed circular orbit completes how many radial oscillations per revolution?
(a) 1 (b) \( \sqrt{2} \) (c) 2 (d) 3
Answer: (c) 2
\( n = 1 \), so \( \omega_r/\omega_\theta = \sqrt{n + 3} = 2 \). Geometrically, the orbit is an ellipse centred on the force centre: \( r \) passes through two minima and two maxima per revolution.
Practice Q4. In a Rutherford scattering experiment the count rate at 90° is 400 per minute. With the same beam, foil and detector, the expected rate at 60° is closest to:
(a) 800 per minute (b) 1200 per minute (c) 1600 per minute (d) 3200 per minute
Answer: (c) 1600 per minute
\( N \propto \sin^{-4}(\Theta/2) \): ratio \( \sin^4 45°/\sin^4 30° = 0.25/0.0625 = 4 \). Option (a) uses \( \sin^2 \).
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. A satellite is in a circular orbit of radius \( R_0 \) about a planet (planet mass much greater than satellite mass). A brief tangential burn raises its speed by a factor \( \sqrt{1.2} \). Consider:
- The new orbit has eccentricity 0.2.
- The new apoapsis distance is \( 1.5R_0 \).
- The new period is about 1.40 times the old.
- The point of the burn becomes the apoapsis of the new orbit.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
Let \( v_0^2 = k/\mu R_0 \). After the burn \( v^2 = 1.2v_0^2 \), and \( E = \tfrac{1}{2}\mu v^2 - k/R_0 = (k/R_0)(0.6 - 1) = -0.4k/R_0 \). So \( a = -k/2E = 1.25R_0 \).
The velocity is perpendicular to the radius and greater than circular speed, so the burn point is the periapsis: \( r_p = R_0 \) (statement 4 false). Then \( r_a = 2a - r_p = 1.5R_0 \) (statement 2 true) and \( e = (r_a - r_p)/(r_a + r_p) = 0.5/2.5 = 0.2 \) (statement 1 true).
\( T/T_0 = (a/R_0)^{3/2} = 1.25^{1.5} \approx 1.40 \) (statement 3 true).
Practice Q6. An alpha particle (4 u) moving with speed \( u \) collides elastically with a proton (1 u) at rest. Consider:
- The alpha particle can be deflected by at most about 14.5° in the lab frame.
- The maximum speed the proton can acquire is \( 1.6u \).
- The maximum fraction of the alpha’s kinetic energy transferred is 0.64.
- In the CM frame, the alpha particle’s speed is \( 0.2u \) both before and after the collision.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) 3 and 4 only
Answer: (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4
1: \( \sin\theta_{\max} = 1/4 \), \( \theta_{\max} = 14.48° \). True. 2: head-on, \( v_p = 2\times4u/5 = 1.6u \). True. 3: \( 4m_1m_2/(m_1 + m_2)^2 = 16/25 = 0.64 \). True. 4: \( V = 4u/5 = 0.8u \), so the alpha’s CM speed is \( u - 0.8u = 0.2u \), unchanged in magnitude by an elastic collision. True. (The proton’s CM speed is \( 0.8u \); the CM momenta \( 4\times0.2u \) and \( 1\times0.8u \) are equal, as they must be.)
Practice Q7. In units with \( \mu = k = L = 1 \), a particle moves in \( V = -1/r \) with energy \( E = -3/8 \). Which one of the following is correct?
(a) \( r_{\min} = 1/2 \), \( r_{\max} = 2 \), \( e = 3/5 \) (b) \( r_{\min} = 2/3 \), \( r_{\max} = 2 \), \( e = 1/2 \) (c) \( r_{\min} = 2/3 \), \( r_{\max} = 2 \), \( e = 1/3 \) (d) \( r_{\min} = 1 \), \( r_{\max} = 2 \), \( e = 1/3 \)
Answer: (b)
\( -1/r + 1/2r^2 = -3/8 \) gives \( 3r^2 - 8r + 4 = 0 \), roots \( 2/3 \) and \( 2 \). \( e = \sqrt{1 + 2EL^2/\mu k^2} = \sqrt{1/4} = 1/2 \), and indeed \( (2 - 2/3)/(2 + 2/3) = 1/2 \). The period is \( 2\pi(4/3)^{3/2} \approx 9.67 \). Option (d) uses \( r = 1 \), the circular radius \( L^2/\mu k \), which is the semi-latus rectum \( p \), not a turning point.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Result |
|---|---|
| Reduced mass | \( \mu = m_1m_2/(m_1 + m_2) \) |
| Areal velocity | \( dA/dt = L/2\mu \) (any central force) |
| Effective potential | \( V + L^2/2\mu r^2 \) |
| Binet | \( u'' + u = -\mu F/(L^2u^2) \) |
| Kepler orbit | \( r = p/(1 + e\cos\theta) \), \( p = L^2/\mu k \), \( e^2 = 1 + 2EL^2/\mu k^2 \) |
| Energy, period | \( E = -k/2a \), \( T^2 = 4\pi^2a^3/G(m_1 + m_2) \) |
| Circular stability | \( F \propto -r^n \): \( n > -3 \); \( \omega_r/\omega_\theta = \sqrt{n + 3} \) |
| Bertrand | all bounded orbits closed only for \( 1/r^2 \) and \( r \) |
| Cross section | \( d\sigma/d\Omega = (b/\sin\Theta)\lvert db/d\Theta\rvert \) |
| Rutherford | \( (k/4E)^2\sin^{-4}(\Theta/2) \); \( b = (k/2E)\cot(\Theta/2) \) |
| Hard sphere | \( a^2/4 \); \( \sigma = \pi a^2 \) |
| Lab–CM angle | \( \tan\theta_L = \sin\theta_C/(\cos\theta_C + m_1/m_2) \) |
| Max lab angle | \( \sin\theta_{\max} = m_2/m_1 \) for \( m_1 > m_2 \) |
| Head-on transfer | \( 4m_1m_2/(m_1 + m_2)^2 \) |
| Available energy | \( T_{\text{CM}} = \tfrac{1}{2}\mu u^2 \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Rigid Bodies and Non-Inertial Frames: angular momentum for extended bodies and the forces seen from a rotating Earth.
- Special Relativity: collisions and thresholds when speeds approach \( c \), where the CM-frame idea becomes the invariant mass.
- Angular Momentum, Spin and the Hydrogen Atom: the same effective potential with \( L^2 \to l(l+1)\hbar^2 \).
- Classical Mechanics: Quick Revision.