Skip to content

Bonding, Elastic Properties, Phonons and Lattice Specific Heat

CSIR NET Part C: crystal bonding and cohesive energy, elastic constants, phonon dispersion of monatomic and diatomic chains, Einstein and Debye heat capacity.

  • 19 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Why Diamond Is Cold to the Touch of Heat
  3. Bonding in Crystals
  4. Elastic Properties
  5. Phonons
  6. Lattice Specific Heat
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Why Diamond Is Cold to the Touch of Heat

Bonding in Crystals

Five kinds of bond

BondOriginTypical crystalsCharacter
Van der Waals (molecular)fluctuating dipole–induced dipole attraction, \( \propto -1/r^6 \)solid Ne, Ar, Kr; molecular solidsweakest; low melting points; insulating
IonicCoulomb attraction of closed-shell ionsNaCl, KCl, MgOstrong; high melting; ionic conductors when hot; IR absorption
Covalentshared electron pairs, directionaldiamond, Si, Gestrong and directional; low coordination (4)
Metallicion cores in a sea of delocalised electronsNa, Cu, Alnon-directional; high coordination; ductile, conducting
HydrogenH between two electronegative atomsice, KH\( _2 \)PO\( _4 \)intermediate strength; directional

All bonding has the same skeleton: a long-range attraction plus a short-range repulsion that comes from the Pauli principle when closed shells overlap. The equilibrium spacing \( r_0 \) is where the total energy is a minimum.

Van der Waals crystals: the Lennard-Jones potential

$$U(r) = 4\varepsilon\left[\left(\frac{\sigma}{r}\right)^{12} - \left(\frac{\sigma}{r}\right)^6\right]$$
  • For an isolated pair: minimum at \( r_0 = 2^{1/6}\sigma \approx 1.12\sigma \), depth \( -\varepsilon \); \( U = 0 \) at \( r = \sigma \).
  • In an fcc crystal, summing over all neighbours replaces the coefficients by lattice sums (12.13 and 14.45 for fcc). The result: \( r_0 \approx 1.09\sigma \), cohesive energy about \( -8.6\varepsilon \) per atom, and bulk modulus about \( 75\varepsilon/\sigma^3 \).

The crystal value of \( r_0 \) is slightly smaller than the pair value because more distant neighbours add attraction.

Ionic crystals: Madelung energy

The total energy of \( 2N \) ions (\( N \) pairs) at nearest-neighbour distance \( r \) is

$$U(r) = N\left[-\frac{\alpha e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0r} + \frac{C}{r^n}\right]$$

with the Madelung constant \( \alpha \) carrying the whole Coulomb lattice sum. Setting \( dU/dr = 0 \) at \( r_0 \):

$$\boxed{U_0 = -\frac{N\alpha e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0r_0}\left(1 - \frac{1}{n}\right)} \qquad \text{(Born–Landé)}$$

The Born–Mayer form uses \( \lambda e^{-r/\rho} \) for the repulsion and gives \( (1 - \rho/r_0) \) instead of \( (1 - 1/n) \).

Structure\( \alpha \) (referred to nearest-neighbour distance)
1D chain of alternating \( \pm \) charges\( 2\ln2 \approx 1.386 \)
NaCl1.748
CsCl1.763
Zinc blende1.638

Bulk modulus from the potential. \( B = V\,d^2U/dV^2 \) at \( V_0 \). For NaCl (\( V = 2Nr^3 \)) and the Born–Landé form this gives

$$B = \frac{\alpha e^2(n - 1)}{72\pi\varepsilon_0r_0^4}$$

so measured \( B \) and \( r_0 \) fix the repulsive exponent \( n \). With \( r_0 = 0.282 \) nm and \( n = 9 \), \( B \approx 28 \) GPa and \( |U_0| \approx 765 \) kJ mol\( ^{-1} \).

Elastic Properties

Stress, strain and the elastic constants

For small deformations, stress is linear in strain (Hooke’s law): \( \sigma_{ij} = C_{ijkl}\varepsilon_{kl} \). In Voigt notation (\( xx \to 1, yy \to 2, zz \to 3, yz \to 4, zx \to 5, xy \to 6 \)) this becomes \( \sigma_i = \sum_jC_{ij}\varepsilon_j \) with a symmetric \( 6\times6 \) matrix. Symmetry cuts down the independent constants:

SymmetryIndependent elastic constants
Triclinic (no symmetry)21
Hexagonal5
Cubic3 (\( C_{11}, C_{12}, C_{44} \))
Isotropic solid2 (e.g. Lamé \( \lambda, \mu \))

For a cubic crystal:

  • Bulk modulus \( B = (C_{11} + 2C_{12})/3 \).
  • Shear constants \( C_{44} \) and \( C' = (C_{11} - C_{12})/2 \); isotropy requires \( C_{44} = C' \). The ratio \( 2C_{44}/(C_{11} - C_{12}) \) measures elastic anisotropy (1 for an isotropic solid).
  • Stability: \( C_{44} > 0 \), \( C_{11} > |C_{12}| \), \( C_{11} + 2C_{12} > 0 \).
  • Cauchy relation \( C_{12} = C_{44} \): holds when all forces are central pairwise forces and every atom is a centre of inversion. Deviations measure non-central (many-body, metallic or covalent) bonding.

Isotropic moduli

Young’s modulus \( E \), shear modulus \( G \), bulk modulus \( B \) and Poisson’s ratio \( \nu \) are related by

$$E = 2G(1 + \nu) = 3B(1 - 2\nu)$$

with \( -1 < \nu < 1/2 \); \( \nu = 1/2 \) means incompressible.

Elastic waves

The wave equation in a cubic crystal along [100] gives one longitudinal and two (degenerate) transverse waves:

$$v_L = \sqrt{C_{11}/\rho}, \qquad v_T = \sqrt{C_{44}/\rho}$$

Along [110] the longitudinal speed involves \( (C_{11} + C_{12} + 2C_{44})/2 \), and the two transverse waves split. In an isotropic solid \( v_L = \sqrt{(B + \tfrac43G)/\rho} \) and \( v_T = \sqrt{G/\rho} \), so \( v_L > v_T \) always.

Phonons

The monatomic chain

Atoms of mass \( M \), spacing \( a \), nearest-neighbour springs of constant \( K \): \( M\ddot u_n = K(u_{n+1} + u_{n-1} - 2u_n) \). Trying \( u_n = Ae^{i(kna - \omega t)} \):

$$\boxed{\omega(k) = 2\sqrt{\frac{K}{M}}\left|\sin\frac{ka}{2}\right|}$$
  • Long wavelength (\( ka \ll 1 \)): \( \omega \approx a\sqrt{K/M}\,k \), sound waves with \( v_s = a\sqrt{K/M} \).
  • Zone boundary \( k = \pi/a \): maximum frequency \( \omega_{\max} = 2\sqrt{K/M} \), group velocity \( d\omega/dk = 0 \): a standing wave, adjacent atoms moving oppositely (Bragg reflection at the zone face).
  • \( k \) and \( k + 2\pi/a \) describe the same atomic motion, so all physically distinct modes lie in the first Brillouin zone \( -\pi/a < k \leq \pi/a \). With \( N \) atoms and periodic boundary conditions there are exactly \( N \) allowed \( k \), spaced \( 2\pi/Na \).

The diatomic chain

Two masses \( M_1 \) and \( M_2 \) alternate (\( M_1 < M_2 \)), springs \( K \), lattice constant \( a \) (one pair per cell). The dispersion relation is

$$\omega^2 = K\left(\frac{1}{M_1} + \frac{1}{M_2}\right) \pm K\sqrt{\left(\frac{1}{M_1} + \frac{1}{M_2}\right)^2 - \frac{4\sin^2(ka/2)}{M_1M_2}}$$
PointAcoustic branch (−)Optical branch (+)
\( k = 0 \)\( \omega = 0 \); both atoms move together\( \omega = \sqrt{2K(1/M_1 + 1/M_2)} \); atoms move oppositely, centre of mass fixed
\( k = \pm\pi/a \)\( \omega = \sqrt{2K/M_2} \): only the heavy atoms move\( \omega = \sqrt{2K/M_1} \): only the light atoms move

Between \( \sqrt{2K/M_2} \) and \( \sqrt{2K/M_1} \) lies a frequency gap: waves in that range are evanescent. As \( M_1 \to M_2 \) the gap closes, and the diagram folds back into the monatomic one with lattice constant \( a/2 \). In an ionic crystal the optical mode moves positive and negative ions in opposite directions, creating an oscillating dipole that couples to infrared light: hence “optical”.

Counting branches in 3D

A crystal with \( p \) atoms in its primitive cell and \( N \) cells has \( 3pN \) normal modes:

$$3 \text{ acoustic branches} + (3p - 3) \text{ optical branches}, \quad \text{each with } N \text{ modes}$$

So a monatomic Bravais lattice (Cu, Na) has only acoustic branches (1 longitudinal + 2 transverse); diamond, Si, NaCl and hcp metals (\( p = 2 \)) have 3 acoustic and 3 optical.

Phonons as quanta

Each normal mode is a quantum harmonic oscillator with energies \( (n + \tfrac12)\hbar\omega \). The quantum \( \hbar\omega \) is a phonon. At temperature \( T \) its mean occupation is the Bose–Einstein value with zero chemical potential, \( \bar n = 1/(e^{\hbar\omega/k_BT} - 1) \). A phonon carries crystal momentum \( \hbar\mathbf{k} \), conserved only up to a reciprocal lattice vector: in a three-phonon collision \( \mathbf{k}_1 + \mathbf{k}_2 = \mathbf{k}_3 + \mathbf{G} \). Processes with \( \mathbf{G} = 0 \) are normal; those with \( \mathbf{G} \neq 0 \) are umklapp, and only umklapp processes give a finite thermal resistance in a perfect crystal. Inelastic neutron scattering measures \( \omega(\mathbf{k}) \) directly.

Lattice Specific Heat

Classical: Dulong–Petit

Each atom is a 3D oscillator with six quadratic terms: mean energy \( 3k_BT \), so

$$C_V = 3Nk_B = 3R \approx 24.9 \text{ J mol}^{-1}\text{ K}^{-1}$$

Correct at high temperature; wrong at low temperature, where \( C_V \to 0 \) (third law).

Einstein model

All \( 3N \) modes at one frequency \( \omega_E \) (Einstein temperature \( \theta_E = \hbar\omega_E/k_B \)). Using the oscillator’s mean energy:

$$\boxed{C_V = 3Nk_B\left(\frac{\theta_E}{T}\right)^2\frac{e^{\theta_E/T}}{(e^{\theta_E/T} - 1)^2}}$$
  • \( T \gg \theta_E \): \( C_V \to 3Nk_B \).
  • \( T \ll \theta_E \): \( C_V \approx 3Nk_B(\theta_E/T)^2e^{-\theta_E/T} \), an exponential fall, too fast compared with experiment.
  • At \( T = \theta_E \), \( C_V = 0.921\times3Nk_B \).

The Einstein model fails at low \( T \) because real crystals have low-frequency acoustic modes that remain excited however cold it gets. It is still a good description of optical branches, which are fairly flat.

Debye model

Treat the crystal as an elastic continuum with linear dispersion \( \omega = vk \) up to a cut-off chosen to give exactly \( 3N \) modes. Using one average speed for all three polarisations, the density of states is

$$g(\omega) = \frac{3V\omega^2}{2\pi^2v^3}, \qquad 0 \leq \omega \leq \omega_D$$

and \( \int_0^{\omega_D}g\,d\omega = 3N \) gives

$$\boxed{k_D = (6\pi^2n)^{1/3}, \qquad \omega_D = vk_D, \qquad \theta_D = \frac{\hbar\omega_D}{k_B}}$$

(\( n = N/V \) is the atom density; with separate speeds, \( 3/v^3 \to 1/v_L^3 + 2/v_T^3 \).) Then

$$C_V = 9Nk_B\left(\frac{T}{\theta_D}\right)^3\int_0^{\theta_D/T}\frac{x^4e^x}{(e^x - 1)^2}dx$$
  • \( T \gg \theta_D \): \( C_V \to 3Nk_B \). At \( T = \theta_D \), already \( 0.952\times3Nk_B \).
  • \( T \ll \theta_D \): extend the integral to infinity (it equals \( 4\pi^4/15 \)):
$$\boxed{C_V = \frac{12\pi^4}{5}Nk_B\left(\frac{T}{\theta_D}\right)^3 \approx 1944\left(\frac{T}{\theta_D}\right)^3 \text{ J mol}^{-1}\text{ K}^{-1}}$$

The \( T^3 \) law follows from counting: only modes with \( \hbar\omega \lesssim k_BT \) are active, their number grows as \( T^3 \) (volume of a sphere in \( k \)-space), and each holds about \( k_BT \). The same argument in \( d \) dimensions with linear acoustic modes gives \( C \propto T^d \); for a dispersion \( \omega \propto k^s \) it gives \( C \propto T^{d/s} \). The low-\( T \) limit is exact for real crystals (only long-wavelength acoustic modes matter there); the intermediate region depends on the true density of states.

Metals: electrons plus phonons

In a metal at low \( T \), \( C = \gamma T + AT^3 \): a linear electronic term (page 3) and the Debye term. A plot of \( C/T \) against \( T^2 \) is a straight line, intercept \( \gamma \), slope \( A = 1944/\theta_D^3 \) J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-4} \). The two terms are equal at \( T^* = \sqrt{\gamma/A} \), typically a few kelvin.

Anharmonic effects

A purely harmonic crystal has no thermal expansion (the mean position does not move with amplitude) and infinite thermal conductivity (phonons never scatter). Both need cubic and higher terms in the potential. The Grüneisen parameter \( \gamma_G = -d\ln\omega/d\ln V \) links the two: \( \alpha = \gamma_GC_V/(3BV) \). Kinetic theory gives the phonon thermal conductivity \( \kappa = \tfrac13Cv\ell \).

Memory Tricks

  • “1944 over theta cubed.” Debye low-\( T \) heat capacity in J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \): \( 1944(T/\theta_D)^3 \).
  • “Heavy sits at the top of acoustic, light at the bottom of optical.” Zone-boundary frequencies \( \sqrt{2K/M_{\text{heavy}}} \) and \( \sqrt{2K/M_{\text{light}}} \).
  • “3 acoustic, \( 3p - 3 \) optical.” Count atoms in the primitive cell, not the conventional cell.
  • “Cubic three, hexagonal five, triclinic twenty-one.” Independent elastic constants.
  • Einstein falls exponentially, Debye as \( T^3 \). If a curve vanishes exponentially, there is a gap (optical mode, or superconductor).

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Acoustic branch: \( \omega \to 0 \) as \( k \to 0 \), atoms in phaseOptical branch: finite \( \omega \) at \( k = 0 \), atoms in a cell out of phase
Einstein: one frequency, \( C \sim e^{-\theta_E/T} \)Debye: \( \omega = vk \) up to \( \omega_D \), \( C \propto T^3 \)
\( k_D = (6\pi^2n)^{1/3} \): phonons, no spin factor\( k_F = (3\pi^2n)^{1/3} \): electrons, spin 2 included
Normal phonon collision: crystal momentum conserved exactlyUmklapp: changed by \( \mathbf{G} \); gives thermal resistance
Born–Landé \( 1 - 1/n \)Born–Mayer \( 1 - \rho/r_0 \)
LJ pair minimum \( 2^{1/6}\sigma = 1.12\sigma \)LJ fcc crystal \( r_0 = 1.09\sigma \)

Common Mistakes

Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Use \( R = 8.314 \) J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \).

Level 1: Foundation

  1. How many acoustic and optical phonon branches does silicon (two atoms per primitive cell) have?
  2. What is the group velocity of a monatomic-chain phonon at the zone boundary?
  3. How many independent elastic constants does a cubic crystal have?
Answers
  1. 3 acoustic, 3 optical (\( 3p = 6 \) branches in all).
  2. Zero: \( d\omega/dk \propto \cos(ka/2) = 0 \) at \( k = \pi/a \); the mode is a standing wave.
  3. Three: \( C_{11}, C_{12}, C_{44} \).

Level 2: Part B Style

Practice Q1. An insulating solid has Debye temperature 300 K. Its molar heat capacity at 10 K is closest to:

(a) 0.0072 J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \) (b) 0.072 J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \) (c) 0.72 J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \) (d) 0.83 J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \)

Answer: (b) 0.072

\( C = 1944\times(10/300)^3 = 1944/27000 = 0.072 \) J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \). (d) is \( 3R/30 \), a linear scaling that has no basis in an insulator.

Practice Q2. In a diatomic linear chain with masses \( m \) and \( 2m \) and spring constant \( K \), the ratio of the maximum optical frequency to the maximum acoustic frequency is:

(a) \( \sqrt2 \) (b) \( \sqrt3 \) (c) 2 (d) \( \sqrt6 \)

Answer: (b) √3

Optical maximum at \( k = 0 \): \( \sqrt{2K(1/m + 1/2m)} = \sqrt{3K/m} \). Acoustic maximum at \( k = \pi/a \): \( \sqrt{2K/2m} = \sqrt{K/m} \). Ratio \( \sqrt3 \). (a) compares the two zone-boundary frequencies, the edges of the gap.

Practice Q3. For a cubic crystal with \( C_{11} = 170 \) GPa and \( C_{44} = 75 \) GPa and density 8900 kg m\( ^{-3} \), the transverse sound speed along [100] is closest to:

(a) 2.9 km s\( ^{-1} \) (b) 4.4 km s\( ^{-1} \) (c) 8.4 km s\( ^{-1} \) (d) 0.92 km s\( ^{-1} \)

Answer: (a) 2.9 km/s

\( v_T = \sqrt{C_{44}/\rho} = \sqrt{75\times10^9/8900} = 2.90\times10^3 \) m s\( ^{-1} \). (b) is the longitudinal speed \( \sqrt{C_{11}/\rho} = 4.37 \) km s\( ^{-1} \).

Practice Q4. For a one-dimensional crystal with linear acoustic phonons, the lattice heat capacity at low temperature varies as:

(a) \( T \) (b) \( T^2 \) (c) \( T^3 \) (d) \( e^{-\theta/T} \)

Answer: (a) T

Number of thermally active modes \( \propto k_{\text{th}} \propto T \) in 1D, each with energy about \( k_BT \): \( U \propto T^2 \), \( C \propto T \). In \( d \) dimensions \( C \propto T^d \).

Level 3: Part C Style

Practice Q5. Low-temperature heat-capacity data of a metal fit \( C/T = 0.70 + 0.050\,T^2 \), with \( C \) in mJ mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \) and \( T \) in K. Consider:

  1. The electronic coefficient is \( \gamma = 0.70 \) mJ mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-2} \).
  2. The Debye temperature is about 340 K.
  3. The electronic and lattice contributions are equal at about 3.7 K.
  4. At 10 K the lattice contribution is smaller than the electronic one.

Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 1, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. The intercept of \( C/T \) against \( T^2 \) is \( \gamma \). True.
  2. \( A = 0.050 \) mJ mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-4} = 5.0\times10^{-5} \) J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-4} \); \( \theta_D = (1944/5.0\times10^{-5})^{1/3} = 339 \) K. True.
  3. \( \gamma T = AT^3 \Rightarrow T = \sqrt{0.70/0.050} = 3.74 \) K. True.
  4. At 10 K: electronic 7.0 mJ mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \), lattice 50 mJ mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \). Lattice is larger. False.

Practice Q6. A linear chain has alternating masses \( M_1 < M_2 \), spring constant \( K \) and lattice constant \( a \). Consider:

  1. At \( k = 0 \) in the optical branch the centre of mass of each cell stays at rest.
  2. At \( k = \pi/a \) in the acoustic branch only the lighter atoms move.
  3. Frequencies between \( \sqrt{2K/M_2} \) and \( \sqrt{2K/M_1} \) cannot propagate.
  4. If \( M_1 = M_2 \), the gap closes and the spectrum is that of a monatomic chain of spacing \( a/2 \).

Which are correct?

(a) 1, 3 and 4 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1, 3 and 4 only
  1. Optical \( k = 0 \): \( M_1u_1 + M_2u_2 = 0 \). True.
  2. At \( k = \pi/a \) the acoustic mode \( \sqrt{2K/M_2} \) has only the heavier atoms moving. False.
  3. That is the gap; waves there decay. True.
  4. Equal masses: the edges \( \sqrt{2K/M} \) coincide, and the two branches are the folded monatomic dispersion with spacing \( a/2 \). True.

Practice Q7. Compare the Einstein model (temperature \( \theta_E \)) and the Debye model (temperature \( \theta_D \)) of a monatomic solid. Consider:

  1. At \( T = \theta_E \) the Einstein heat capacity is about 92 % of \( 3R \).
  2. At \( T = \theta_D \) the Debye heat capacity is about 95 % of \( 3R \).
  3. As \( T \to 0 \), the Einstein heat capacity falls faster than any power of \( T \).
  4. The Debye cut-off wavevector depends on the sound speed.

Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
  1. \( x = 1 \): \( x^2e^x/(e^x - 1)^2 = 2.718/2.952 = 0.921 \). True.
  2. Numerical integration of the Debye function at \( \theta_D/T = 1 \) gives 0.952. True.
  3. \( (\theta_E/T)^2e^{-\theta_E/T} \) vanishes faster than any power. True.
  4. \( k_D = (6\pi^2n)^{1/3} \) depends only on atom density; the sound speed enters \( \omega_D = vk_D \) and \( \theta_D \). False.

Quick Revision Table

IdeaFormula or fact
Lennard-Jonespair \( r_0 = 2^{1/6}\sigma \); fcc \( r_0 = 1.09\sigma \), \( U = -8.6\varepsilon \), \( B \approx 75\varepsilon/\sigma^3 \)
Ionic (Born–Landé)\( U_0 = -N\alpha e^2(1 - 1/n)/(4\pi\varepsilon_0r_0) \); \( \alpha_{\text{NaCl}} = 1.748 \), 1D \( 2\ln2 \)
Elastic constantscubic 3; \( B = (C_{11} + 2C_{12})/3 \); \( v_L = \sqrt{C_{11}/\rho} \), \( v_T = \sqrt{C_{44}/\rho} \) along [100]
Monatomic chain\( \omega = 2\sqrt{K/M}\vert \sin(ka/2)\vert \); \( v_s = a\sqrt{K/M} \)
Diatomic chaingap between \( \sqrt{2K/M_2} \) and \( \sqrt{2K/M_1} \); optical top \( \sqrt{2K(1/M_1 + 1/M_2)} \)
Branches3 acoustic + \( (3p - 3) \) optical
Dulong–Petit\( 3R = 24.9 \) J mol\( ^{-1} \) K\( ^{-1} \)
Einstein\( 3R x^2e^x/(e^x - 1)^2 \), \( x = \theta_E/T \); exponential at low \( T \)
Debye\( k_D = (6\pi^2n)^{1/3} \); \( C = 1944(T/\theta_D)^3 \) at low \( T \)
Metals\( C = \gamma T + AT^3 \); plot \( C/T \) vs \( T^2 \)

Key Takeaways

What’s Next