Defects, Dislocations, Liquid Crystals and Quasicrystals
CSIR NET Part C: point defects and their concentration, edge and screw dislocations, Burgers vector, liquid crystal phases and order parameter, quasicrystals.
- 18 min
On this page · 14 sections
Prerequisites
- Bravais and Reciprocal Lattices, Diffraction and the Structure Factor: lattice vectors (Burgers vectors are lattice vectors) and diffraction patterns (the evidence for quasicrystals).
- Bonding, Elastic Properties, Phonons and Lattice Specific Heat: shear modulus and elastic energy, which set dislocation energies.
- Canonical and Grand Canonical Ensembles: Boltzmann factors and free-energy minimisation, which fix defect concentrations.
- First- and Second-Order Phase Transitions: order parameters, used for the nematic–isotropic transition.
The Hook: Perfection Is Expensive, and Not Always Periodic
Classifying Defects
| Dimension | Defect | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| 0 (point) | vacancy, interstitial, substitutional impurity, Schottky pair, Frenkel pair, colour centre | missing ion pair in NaCl; Ag\( ^+ \) interstitials in AgCl |
| 1 (line) | dislocations | edge, screw, mixed |
| 2 (planar) | grain boundaries, twin boundaries, stacking faults, surfaces, antiphase boundaries | low-angle tilt boundary; …ABCABABC… in fcc |
| 3 (volume) | voids, precipitates, inclusions |
Only point defects exist in thermal equilibrium; dislocations and grain boundaries cost too much energy per unit length or area to be stabilised by entropy, and are present because of growth and deformation history.
Point Defects in Equilibrium
Vacancies in a monatomic crystal
Creating \( n \) vacancies among \( N \) sites costs energy \( nE_v \) and gains configurational entropy \( k_B\ln\binom{N}{n} \). Minimising \( F = nE_v - k_BT\ln\dfrac{N!}{n!(N - n)!} \) with Stirling’s formula (\( n \ll N \)):
$$\boxed{\frac{n}{N} = e^{-E_v/k_BT}}$$For \( E_v = 1.0 \) eV, \( n/N \approx 9\times10^{-6} \) at 1000 K and \( 1.6\times10^{-17} \) at 300 K. Any crystal at \( T > 0 \) has vacancies: the free energy always decreases on adding the first few. (A vibrational entropy factor \( e^{S_v/k_B} \) multiplies this in reality; it is usually omitted in exam problems.)
Schottky and Frenkel defects in ionic crystals
| Defect | What it is | Concentration | Density change | Typical host |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schottky | a cation vacancy plus an anion vacancy (charge neutral) | \( n = Ne^{-E_s/2k_BT} \) | density falls | NaCl, KCl |
| Frenkel | an ion moved from its site to an interstitial site | \( n = \sqrt{NN_i}\,e^{-E_f/2k_BT} \) | unchanged | AgCl, AgBr (cation Frenkel) |
The factor 2 in the exponent comes from creating two independent defects (two vacancies, or a vacancy and an interstitial) each with its own configurational entropy: \( n^2 \approx N^2e^{-E_s/k_BT} \). \( N_i \) is the number of interstitial sites.
Consequences
- Ionic conductivity and diffusion proceed by vacancy or interstitial hopping: \( D = D_0e^{-Q/k_BT} \), where \( Q \) includes formation and migration energies. A plot of \( \ln D \) or \( \ln(\sigma T) \) against \( 1/T \) gives \( Q \).
- Doping with aliovalent ions creates vacancies to keep neutrality: adding Ca\( ^{2+} \) to NaCl creates one cation vacancy per Ca ion, raising the low-temperature ionic conductivity (extrinsic region).
- Colour centres. An F-centre is an anion vacancy that has trapped an electron; it absorbs visible light and colours an otherwise transparent alkali halide. They form, for example, when the crystal is heated in alkali-metal vapour or irradiated.
- Non-stoichiometry: Fe\( _{1-x} \)O with Fe vacancies balanced by Fe\( ^{3+} \).
Dislocations
Why they are needed
Slipping a perfect plane rigidly requires a shear stress of order \( G/2\pi \) (Frenkel’s sinusoidal estimate; more realistic force laws give about \( G/30 \)). For \( G = 40 \) GPa that is several GPa; observed critical resolved shear stresses of pure, annealed metal crystals are of order 1 MPa or less. Dislocations let the slip happen by breaking only one row of bonds at a time.
Edge and screw
The Burgers vector \( \mathbf{b} \) is found by drawing a closed circuit of lattice steps around the line (a Burgers circuit) and the same circuit in a perfect crystal: the closure failure is \( \mathbf{b} \). For a perfect (unit) dislocation \( \mathbf{b} \) is a lattice translation vector.
| Property | Edge dislocation | Screw dislocation |
|---|---|---|
| Picture | extra half-plane of atoms ending at the line | planes form a helical ramp around the line |
| \( \mathbf{b} \) vs line direction \( \boldsymbol\xi \) | perpendicular | parallel |
| Direction of motion under shear | parallel to \( \mathbf{b} \) | perpendicular to \( \mathbf{b} \) |
| Slip plane | unique (contains \( \mathbf{b} \) and \( \boldsymbol\xi \)) | any plane containing the line: can cross-slip |
| Climb (out of slip plane) | yes, by absorbing or emitting vacancies; needs diffusion, so high \( T \) | no climb |
| Stress field | hydrostatic + shear; compression above the half-plane, tension below | pure shear |
A general (mixed) dislocation curves through edge and screw orientations with a single \( \mathbf{b} \). A dislocation line cannot end inside a crystal: it ends on a surface, a grain boundary, a node with other dislocations, or forms a loop. At a node \( \sum\mathbf{b} = 0 \) (like Kirchhoff’s current law).
Energy, force and multiplication
- Line energy (tension): \( E \approx \alpha Gb^2 \) per unit length with \( \alpha \approx 0.5 \)–1 (the elastic field energy, with a logarithmic factor \( \ln(R/r_0)/4\pi \) for a screw). For \( G = 40 \) GPa and \( b = 0.25 \) nm, \( Gb^2/2 \approx 1.3\times10^{-9} \) J m\( ^{-1} \), about 8 eV per nm of line: far too much for thermal equilibrium.
- Frank’s rule: since \( E \propto b^2 \), a dislocation splits if \( b_1^2 > b_2^2 + b_3^2 \). In fcc, \( \tfrac{a}{2}[110] \to \tfrac{a}{6}[211] + \tfrac{a}{6}[12\bar1] \) lowers \( b^2 \) from \( a^2/2 \) to \( a^2/3 \); the two Shockley partials are separated by a ribbon of stacking fault, whose energy fixes their spacing.
- Peach–Koehler force: a resolved shear stress \( \tau \) exerts a force \( \tau b \) per unit length on the line.
- Frank–Read source: a segment pinned at both ends bows out under stress and generates loop after loop, so plastic deformation multiplies dislocations. Interactions and tangles then impede motion: work hardening. Solute atoms and precipitates pin dislocations (solid-solution and precipitation hardening); grain boundaries block them (Hall–Petch strengthening, \( \sigma_y = \sigma_0 + k/\sqrt d \)).
- Slip systems: slip occurs on close-packed planes along close-packed directions. fcc: \( \{111\}\langle110\rangle \), 4 planes × 3 directions = 12 systems, hence ductile. bcc: \( \langle111\rangle \) directions on several plane families. hcp: basal slip only at room temperature in many metals, hence less ductile.
Grain boundaries
A low-angle tilt boundary is a wall of edge dislocations spaced \( D \) apart; the misorientation is \( \theta \approx b/D \). For \( b = 0.25 \) nm and \( \theta = 1^\circ \), \( D \approx 14 \) nm. A twist boundary is a grid of screw dislocations. High-angle boundaries cannot be described as separate dislocations.
Liquid Crystals
Mesophases
A liquid crystal is a phase of anisotropic molecules (rod-like calamitic or disc-like discotic) with orientational order and at most partial positional order.
| Phase | Positional order | Orientational order | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Isotropic liquid | none | none | |
| Nematic | none | molecules aligned along a director \( \hat n \), with \( \hat n \equiv -\hat n \) | most fluid; used in displays |
| Cholesteric (chiral nematic) | none | director rotates helically about an axis | pitch \( p \); selectively reflects \( \lambda \approx \bar n_{\text{ref}}p \) at normal incidence, colour changes with \( T \) |
| Smectic A | 1D density wave (layers), liquid within layers | director normal to layers | |
| Smectic C | layers | director tilted in the layers | chiral smectic C can be ferroelectric |
| Columnar | 2D lattice of columns | discs stacked in columns | discotic molecules |
Thermotropic liquid crystals change phase with temperature (typical sequence on heating: crystal → smectic → nematic → isotropic). Lyotropic ones (soaps, lipids, surfactants in water) change phase with concentration; cell membranes are lyotropic lamellar phases.
The nematic order parameter
The director gives the average direction; the degree of alignment is
$$\boxed{S = \left\langle P_2(\cos\theta)\right\rangle = \left\langle\frac{3\cos^2\theta - 1}{2}\right\rangle}$$with \( \theta \) the angle between a molecule’s axis and \( \hat n \). \( S = 1 \) for perfect alignment, \( S = 0 \) for the isotropic liquid (\( \langle\cos^2\theta\rangle = 1/3 \)), \( S = -1/2 \) if all molecules lie perpendicular to \( \hat n \). A first-rank average \( \langle\cos\theta\rangle \) would vanish by the \( \hat n \to -\hat n \) symmetry, which is why the second Legendre polynomial is used. The full order parameter is the traceless tensor \( Q_{ij} = S(n_in_j - \delta_{ij}/3) \).
The nematic–isotropic transition is weakly first order: \( S \) jumps from zero to a finite value (mean-field Maier–Saupe theory gives about 0.43 at the transition) and there is a small latent heat. In Landau–de Gennes theory the free energy contains a cubic term in \( S \), allowed because \( S \) and \( -S \) are physically different states; a cubic term always makes the transition first order.
Elasticity and the Fréedericksz transition
Distorting a nematic costs Frank elastic energy with three constants: splay \( K_1 \), twist \( K_2 \), bend \( K_3 \), each of order \( 10^{-11} \) N. Molecules with positive dielectric anisotropy \( \Delta\varepsilon = \varepsilon_\parallel - \varepsilon_\perp \) tend to align with an electric field. In a cell with the director anchored parallel to the plates and a field across it, nothing happens until
$$\boxed{V_c = \pi\sqrt{\frac{K_1}{\varepsilon_0\Delta\varepsilon}}}$$the Fréedericksz threshold, independent of cell thickness (the field threshold \( E_c = (\pi/d)\sqrt{K/\varepsilon_0\Delta\varepsilon} \) scales as \( 1/d \)). For \( K_1 = 10^{-11} \) N and \( \Delta\varepsilon = 10 \), \( V_c \approx 1.06 \) V. In a twisted-nematic display, a 90° twisted cell between crossed polarisers guides the light’s polarisation and transmits; above threshold the twist is destroyed and the pixel goes dark.
Quasicrystals
The crystallographic restriction
A rotation that maps a lattice onto itself has an integer matrix in the lattice basis, so its trace is an integer. The trace of a rotation by \( \phi \) is \( 2\cos\phi \) in 2D and \( 1 + 2\cos\phi \) in 3D. Integer values of \( 2\cos\phi \) are \( -2, -1, 0, 1, 2 \), giving
$$\boxed{\phi = \frac{2\pi}{n}, \quad n = 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 \text{ only}}$$For \( n = 5 \), \( 2\cos72^\circ = 0.618... \), not an integer: no periodic lattice has five-fold symmetry (nor 7, 8, 10, 12-fold).
Order without periodicity
A quasicrystal has long-range order and a diffraction pattern of sharp (Bragg-like) spots, but a rotational symmetry forbidden to crystals: icosahedral (five-fold axes in 3D), or eight-, ten- or twelve-fold in planar (axial) quasicrystals. The first was found by Shechtman in a rapidly cooled Al–Mn alloy showing icosahedral electron diffraction; the work received the 2011 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. The International Union of Crystallography later redefined a crystal as any solid with an essentially discrete diffraction pattern, so quasicrystals are crystals in the modern sense, just not periodic ones.
- Quasiperiodicity. Density can be written as a Fourier sum over wavevectors that are integer combinations of more basis vectors than the dimension (six for icosahedral in 3D). Equivalently, the structure is a slice of a periodic lattice in higher dimension, projected at an irrational angle (the cut-and-project method).
- Penrose tiling: two rhombi (36° and 72°) tile the plane without periodicity but with five-fold local symmetry and long-range order. The ratio of the numbers of the two tiles tends to the golden ratio \( \tau = (1 + \sqrt5)/2 \approx 1.618 \).
- Fibonacci chain (1D model): long (L) and short (S) segments generated by \( L \to LS \), \( S \to L \). The counts of L and S after successive steps are consecutive Fibonacci numbers (1,1), (2,1), (3,2), (5,3), (8,5)…, so \( N_L/N_S \to \tau \). Its Fourier transform is a dense set of sharp peaks indexed by two integers.
- Diffraction spots fill reciprocal space densely, but only a discrete set is strong; scaling the pattern by a power of \( \tau \) maps it onto itself (self-similarity).
- Properties: many are hard, brittle, with low friction and surprisingly low electrical and thermal conductivity for metallic alloys. Phonons and electrons cannot be described by Bloch’s theorem, since there is no periodicity.
Memory Tricks
- “Pairs halve the exponent.” Schottky and Frenkel: \( e^{-E/2k_BT} \); single vacancies: \( e^{-E/k_BT} \).
- “Edge is perpendicular, screw is parallel.” \( \mathbf{b}\perp \) line for edge, \( \mathbf{b}\parallel \) line for screw. Screws cross-slip, edges climb.
- Allowed rotations “1, 2, 3, 4, 6”: “no five, nothing above six.”
- Frank constants “Splay, Twist, Bend = \( K_1, K_2, K_3 \)”.
- Fréedericksz: “pi root K over epsilon-zero delta-epsilon”, thickness-free.
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Schottky: vacancy pair, density decreases | Frenkel: ion to interstitial, density unchanged | |
| Edge: \( \mathbf{b}\perp\boldsymbol\xi \), moves along \( \mathbf{b} \), can climb | Screw: \( \mathbf{b}\parallel\boldsymbol\xi \), moves perpendicular to \( \mathbf{b} \), can cross-slip | |
| Glide: in slip plane, conservative | Climb: out of slip plane, needs vacancy diffusion | |
| Nematic: orientational order only | Smectic: orientational order + layers | |
| Thermotropic: phase set by \( T \) | Lyotropic: phase set by concentration in a solvent | |
| Quasicrystal: sharp spots, forbidden symmetry, no periodicity | Amorphous solid (glass): diffuse rings, no long-range order | |
| Fréedericksz voltage: thickness-independent | Fréedericksz field: \( \propto 1/d \) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written for this page. They are not from any CSIR NET paper. Use \( k_B = 8.617\times10^{-5} \) eV K\( ^{-1} \), \( \varepsilon_0 = 8.854\times10^{-12} \) F m\( ^{-1} \).
Level 1: Foundation
- What is the angle between the Burgers vector and the line direction for a screw dislocation?
- Which rotational symmetries are compatible with a periodic lattice?
- What is the nematic order parameter of an isotropic liquid?
Answers
- 0° (parallel).
- 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6-fold.
- \( S = 0 \).
Level 2: Part B Style
Practice Q1. The vacancy formation energy in a metal is 1.0 eV. The ratio of equilibrium vacancy concentrations at 1000 K and 800 K is closest to:
(a) 1.25 (b) 4.3 (c) 18 (d) 330
Answer: (c) 18
\( \exp\left[\dfrac{1.0}{8.617\times10^{-5}}\left(\dfrac{1}{800} - \dfrac{1}{1000}\right)\right] = \exp(2.90) = 18.2 \). (a) is the temperature ratio; (b) is \( \sqrt{18.2} \), the Schottky-style factor 2 applied wrongly.
Practice Q2. A low-angle symmetric tilt boundary in a crystal with \( b = 0.25 \) nm has a misorientation of \( 1.0^\circ \). The spacing of the edge dislocations in the boundary is closest to:
(a) 0.25 nm (b) 1.4 nm (c) 14 nm (d) 140 nm
Answer: (c) 14 nm
\( D = b/\theta = 0.25/(1.745\times10^{-2}) = 14.3 \) nm.
Practice Q3. A nematic with \( K_1 = 6.0\times10^{-12} \) N and \( \Delta\varepsilon = 15 \) is in a planar cell 10 μm thick. The Fréedericksz threshold voltage is closest to:
(a) 0.067 V (b) 0.67 V (c) 2.1 V (d) 6.7 V
Answer: (b) 0.67 V
\( V_c = \pi\sqrt{6.0\times10^{-12}/(8.854\times10^{-12}\times15)} = \pi\times0.2125 = 0.668 \) V. The thickness does not enter.
Practice Q4. If every molecule in a nematic makes an angle of \( 30^\circ \) with the director, the order parameter \( S \) is:
(a) 0.25 (b) 0.50 (c) 0.625 (d) 0.866
Answer: (c) 0.625
\( \cos^230^\circ = 0.75 \); \( S = (3\times0.75 - 1)/2 = 0.625 \). (d) is \( \cos30^\circ \), the first-rank average.
Level 3: Part C Style
Practice Q5. The equilibrium vacancy fraction of a metal is measured as \( 1.9\times10^{-7} \) at 900 K and \( 9.1\times10^{-6} \) at 1200 K. Consider:
- The vacancy formation energy is about 1.2 eV.
- At 600 K the vacancy fraction is about \( 8\times10^{-11} \).
- If the same data described Schottky pairs in an ionic crystal, the pair formation energy would be about 2.4 eV.
- Quenching the crystal rapidly from 1200 K to room temperature leaves a vacancy fraction close to the room-temperature equilibrium value.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- \( E_v = k_B\ln(9.1\times10^{-6}/1.9\times10^{-7})/(1/900 - 1/1200) = 8.617\times10^{-5}\times3.87/2.78\times10^{-4} = 1.20 \) eV. True.
- \( e^{-1.2/(8.617\times10^{-5}\times600)} = e^{-23.2} = 8.2\times10^{-11} \). True.
- The slope gives \( E_s/2 = 1.2 \) eV, so \( E_s = 2.4 \) eV. True.
- Quenching freezes in the high-temperature vacancies (removing them needs diffusion); that is how excess vacancies are studied. False.
Practice Q6. Consider dislocations in an fcc metal with cube edge \( a \). Consider:
- The Burgers vector of a perfect dislocation is \( \tfrac{a}{2}\langle110\rangle \).
- The dissociation \( \tfrac{a}{2}[110] \to \tfrac{a}{6}[211] + \tfrac{a}{6}[12\bar1] \) is favoured by Frank’s rule, because the sum of \( b^2 \) falls from \( a^2/2 \) to \( a^2/3 \).
- The fcc lattice has 12 slip systems of the type \( \{111\}\langle110\rangle \).
- A pure edge dislocation can cross-slip onto another {111} plane.
Which are correct?
(a) 1 and 3 only (b) 1, 2 and 3 only (c) 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- The shortest fcc lattice vector is \( \tfrac{a}{2}\langle110\rangle \), length \( a/\sqrt2 \). True.
- \( b^2 \): \( a^2/4\times2 = a^2/2 \) before; \( 2\times a^2/36\times6 = a^2/3 \) after; the vectors add correctly (\( [211] + [12\bar1] = [330] \), and \( \tfrac{a}{6}[330] = \tfrac{a}{2}[110] \)). True.
- Four {111} planes, three \( \langle110\rangle \) directions in each. True.
- Cross-slip needs \( \mathbf{b} \) to lie in both planes, which is possible only for a screw dislocation. False.
Practice Q7. Consider the following statements about quasicrystals and the Fibonacci chain generated by \( L \to LS \), \( S \to L \) from a single L:
- After five substitution steps the chain contains 8 L and 5 S segments.
- The ratio \( N_L/N_S \) tends to \( (1 + \sqrt5)/2 \).
- Five-fold rotational symmetry is forbidden for a periodic 2D lattice because \( 2\cos72^\circ \) is not an integer.
- The diffraction pattern of an icosahedral quasicrystal consists of broad diffuse rings, like that of a glass.
Which are correct?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: (a) 1, 2 and 3 only
- Starting from L: LS (1,1), LSL (2,1), LSLLS (3,2), LSLLSLSL (5,3), then (8,5). True.
- The counts are consecutive Fibonacci numbers, whose ratio tends to the golden ratio 1.618. True.
- \( 2\cos72^\circ = 0.618 \). True.
- Quasicrystals give sharp spots. False.
Quick Revision Table
| Idea | Formula or fact |
|---|---|
| Vacancies | \( n/N = e^{-E_v/k_BT} \) |
| Schottky | \( n = Ne^{-E_s/2k_BT} \); density falls |
| Frenkel | \( n = \sqrt{NN_i}e^{-E_f/2k_BT} \); density unchanged |
| Diffusion | \( D = D_0e^{-Q/k_BT} \) |
| Edge / screw | \( \mathbf{b}\perp \) / \( \parallel \) line; climb / cross-slip |
| Line energy | \( \sim Gb^2/2 \) per length; Frank: split if \( b_1^2 > b_2^2 + b_3^2 \) |
| Force on line | \( \tau b \) per length (Peach–Koehler) |
| fcc slip | \( \{111\}\langle110\rangle \), 12 systems; partials \( \tfrac{a}{6}\langle112\rangle \) |
| Tilt boundary | \( \theta = b/D \) |
| Nematic order | \( S = \langle(3\cos^2\theta - 1)/2\rangle \); N–I weakly first order |
| Fréedericksz | \( V_c = \pi\sqrt{K_1/\varepsilon_0\Delta\varepsilon} \) |
| Restriction | rotations 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 only |
| Quasicrystals | sharp spots, forbidden symmetry; golden ratio \( 1.618 \) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Condensed Matter Physics: Quick Revision: every formula and trap from the unit on one page.
- Close Packing and Ionic Structures in Chemical Sciences, for Schottky and Frenkel defects in specific ionic solids.
- First- and Second-Order Phase Transitions, to place the nematic–isotropic transition in Landau theory.
- Condensed Matter Physics chapter overview.